Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel on the tenth anniversary of the National Regulatory Control Council on September 21, 2016, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

23 September 2016 · Tenth anniversary of the National Regulatory Control Council · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the National Regulatory Control Council in Berlin on its tenth anniversary, celebrating a decade of systematic bureaucracy reduction and regulatory reform in Germany.
Main themes
Bureaucracy reduction, better regulation, National Regulatory Control Council anniversary, standard cost model, regulatory burden on businesses, economic competitiveness, legislative reform, legal certainty, cost-benefit analysis of regulations, German domestic policy
Duration
~22 min
70th percentile
Words
2,646
70th percentile
Sentences
166
84th percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
10.8
30th percentile
Syntax
2.80
22nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 67%67%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Economic 11%11%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

166 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Ludewig,

dear members of the National Regulatory Control Council,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag,

Mr. State Minister Braun,

ladies and gentlemen,

In 2006, the then grand coalition had been in office for less than a year when it took on a truly significant task. Previous governments had attempted to reduce bureaucracy, but these were mostly just attempts. It was therefore time to give a starting signal – for a new, far-reaching, and both systematic and comprehensive approach.

First,

it was necessary to determine what bureaucratic burdens actually exist and what they cost. For answers to these questions, an objective basis had previously been lacking. To create this basis, we introduced the standard cost model in Germany. It provided us with the measurement results we needed to set concrete, verifiable, and binding reduction targets. In fact, we were also inspired by other countries: the Netherlands and the United Kingdom.

To accompany and advance the overall process, we secondly established the National Regulatory Control Council. Its role was not only to examine existing laws for bureaucratic effort, but it was also given a guardian role. It was to ensure that unnecessary bureaucracy is avoided from the outset in new legislative projects. A challenging task. But ten years of the National Regulatory Control Council speak for themselves. The Council has proven its worth.

However, ten years ago, there were doubts. These were also fueled by the fact that such a comprehensive, systematic approach, as we had chosen, naturally takes time to show any effect. I still remember well the chorus of critical voices: We would create bureaucracy by law in order to reduce bureaucracy. But the discussion only underscored how important it was to bring in external expertise.

I believe it can be said that the blanket criticism has since quieted down. When we today debate bureaucracy reduction and better regulation, we do so on the substance and in detail, but not on principle. This is a result of the convincing work of the Regulatory Control Council. There is now a stronger awareness of the impact of bureaucracy. The benefits and costs of regulations are weighed much better than before.

Of course, it is not possible to do without bureaucracy altogether. Without regulations and rules, no state can function. They create order and prevent arbitrariness. Thus, we have achieved a high level of legal certainty in Germany. Where indeterminate legal terms arise, judicial questions of legal certainty are not always unbureaucratic, so to speak. Our proven standards and their reliable application are – one can also say – quality features of the location Germany. But the question always arises: How much bureaucracy do we really need? What is necessary and what goes beyond that?

Bureaucracy always costs strength, time, and thus money that companies lack for other investments. When bureaucracy becomes excessive, it hinders entrepreneurial and ultimately overall economic dynamism. Therefore, the legislator is obliged and responsible to create or secure leeway, and certainly not to diminish it. Because companies should be able to focus on their actual tasks. This is also a question of competitiveness, which of course also affects employees.

In this respect, bureaucracy reduction and better regulation act like a kind of economic stimulus program that does not burden public budgets. We often talk in Europe about economic stimulus programs that are supposedly only good when they generate as high state expenditures as possible. I always remind that there are also economic stimulus programs that cost nothing and have similar effects.

It has already proven beneficial that we have seized the opportunities of this independent economic stimulus program. This has helped us, alongside many other measures, to get through the difficult years of the global financial and economic crisis relatively well. This means that for us, bureaucracy reduction and better regulation remain high priorities. They are independent policy goals.

With the help of the Regulatory Control Council, we have succeeded in simplifying existing regulations and reducing a quarter of all costs from information obligations for companies. This saves around twelve billion euros each year. After we reached the 25 percent target, the perspective was broadened. Mr. Ludewig spoke of not always easy discussions, but the perspective has been broadened today. It concerns the entire measurable fulfillment effort of statutory rules. This was also associated with the decision to expand the Regulatory Control Council to ten members. This means we are no longer only looking at the tip of the bureaucratic iceberg, the information obligations, but have a much broader approach. We are also looking at what lies beneath the surface.

This means in practice that the federal government carefully examines laws and regulations before their adoption – always with the aim of reducing burdens to the necessary minimum and lowering costs. If we do not do it, then you do it, sometimes in conjunction with Bundestag members who particularly scrutinize laws that do not immediately meet with one hundred percent approval, to see if perhaps the content could be somewhat absurd by referring to the bureaucratic costs. These are moments when both aspects sometimes blur a bit.

The quantification of costs and the disclosure of results are carried out by the Federal Statistical Office. This way, everyone can trace in which direction the cost pendulum is currently swinging. More transparency about bureaucratic follow-up costs – we have repeatedly experienced – can indeed have a corrective effect in the legislative process. In any case, the work in the federal ministries in preparing new laws has changed significantly. A new sensitivity has been established, so to speak, to estimate costs as accurately as possible when considering how to regulate something. Today, it is also considered whether there is an even simpler way; and that was indeed one of the goals of the exercise.

We have a partner in the Regulatory Control Council who can certainly be uncomfortable. It watches with eagle eyes that the follow-up costs of laws and regulations remain truly limited to what is necessary. Cost transparency creates cost awareness; and cost awareness leads to cost avoidance. I believe this is how the success formula of the Regulatory Control Council can be simplified and put succinctly.

Regardless of how independent it is, the Regulatory Control Council insists on taking unconventional paths – especially with bureaucratic perennial issues. For many years, the burden that companies face when social security contributions are due has been a thorn in the side of the Regulatory Control Council. The discussion began in 2006 with the new rule on contributions. The Federal Statistical Office investigated on behalf of the Regulatory Control Council and quantified the cost burden of possible alternative solutions. This provided us as the federal government with a solid basis to decide on a new regulation. Accordingly, companies will in the future be able to use a simplified procedure for the due date of social security contributions. This eliminates cumbersome monthly estimates. This saves the economy around 64 million euros per year. I am curious to see if a psychological effect will also occur now that this issue is largely resolved; we will have to wait and see.

But this is just one measure that we have initiated with our second Bureaucracy Relief Act. The complete package we have put together is worth around 360 million euros, which companies can save in the future. I therefore believe it is worthwhile to continue on the path we have taken.

Whether we are on the right track is also shown by the bureaucracy cost index. It is the measure of the burdens that arise for the economy from information and documentation obligations. In 2015, it fell below its starting value of 100 for the first time since its introduction, and in June 2016 even below 99 – there is still a bit of room; but we will see. This means that the savings in bureaucracy costs are overall higher than the additional effort associated with newly enacted regulations. When I see what I sign off on cabinet proposals week after week, I must say: It is quite remarkable that despite many new regulations, we have still ended up with a value below 100. This means that the principle of "one in, one out" works. Our bureaucracy brake is effective, although I believe that it will still require a lot of work to ensure that it remains so.

All of this is little noticed in everyday life, but that is also quite natural. Because not every relief affects everyone. Of course, burdens that are avoided from the outset do not weigh in either – much better consideration is already given in new legislation. And of course, this is an ongoing, continuous process.

The fact that the work is worthwhile, but the results are not yet really noticeable in everyday life, could also be due to the fact that we have so far approached the topic primarily from the legislative side. Therefore, it is certainly important to adopt more of the perspective of citizens. They can provide us with very valuable advice with their experiences. Bureaucracy reduction and regulation should ultimately serve to enhance the quality of life for all of us. That is why we have also introduced the life situation survey conducted by the Federal Statistical Office. Like the bureaucracy brake, it is part of a multitude of new instruments that we are now using.

Overall, it can therefore be said that in ten years, a well-equipped toolbox for bureaucracy reduction and better regulation has emerged from which we can draw. The craft has already been learned to some extent. The OECD also certifies that we in Germany implement international standards exemplary. This is a gratifying recognition for all those who advocate for this issue.

Of course, we know that a significant part of bureaucracy arises from European requirements. This is also part of the inventory. Therefore, it is good that bureaucracy reduction and better regulation have now also found their firm place on the agenda in Brussels. They are joint tasks of the European institutions and the member states. Therefore, it would make no sense to shift responsibility back and forth – especially when one knows how many Commission proposals in the past were based on interesting suggestions from the member states. Germany supports the EU programs to simplify existing European law. We also review our own procedures for participation in EU legislation to make them more efficient if necessary.

The European Commission, under President Jean-Claude Juncker, attaches great importance to this topic. He has changed the responsibilities. The First Vice-President Frans Timmermans is now responsible for bureaucracy reduction and better regulation. This is an institutional upgrade that the Commission has undertaken. The Commission has also acted substantively and presented a package of measures to improve the quality of legislation and also the quality of the law itself. Above all, it has also put a number of initiatives up for disposal. This means that the number of proposals reaching the European Parliament and the Council from the Commission has now decreased. There is an interinstitutional agreement between the European Commission, the European Council, and Parliament. It is about more transparency, it is about better cooperation. This agreement has been adopted by the three institutions in the meantime. I believe this is a good step.

Of course, it also depends on the individual member states to ensure that as few unnecessary burdens as possible arise from EU regulations for the member states. This is exactly what we as the federal government are working towards with the so-called EU ex-ante procedure. This means that the federal ministries closely examine the Commission's planning and impact assessments from the very beginning and assess how plausible the cost and benefit evaluations are. If the Commission expects particularly high fulfillment efforts from its legislative proposal, the federal government itself estimates what effort is to be expected for Germany. We then engage in the EU legislative process. However, we are only one country out of 28 – albeit certainly not the smallest. And the trilogue with Parliament must still be taken into account. A lot can still happen there – especially since there is the systemic peculiarity that the German Bundestag has not yet subjected itself to all regulations even in laws it makes itself. The same applies to the European Parliament; but we do have this interinstitutional agreement there.

I believe it can be said: Over the last ten years, a cultural shift has taken place. This is thanks to the members and the staff of the Normenkontrollrat. Some bureaucratic monstrosities have not seen the light of day. The overall approach, the entire way of thinking has changed significantly. It has also become clear how it works on a factual basis to measure bureaucratic costs.

However, there is still much to be done. Mr. Ludewig would not be Mr. Ludewig if he had not thrown a stone into the water today with a contribution about Germany's position in the field of e-government. Since I visited Estonia this summer – one could say in anticipatory obedience – to inform myself about how far one could be in terms of e-government, and since the entire federal government had already invited the Estonian Prime Minister to the retreat in connection with our digital agenda, I am aware of the work that still lies ahead of us.

I believe that this is not only about factual issues, but in times of digitalization, it is also somewhat about speed. Therefore, we want to – I gladly repeat this here – use the discussions on the federal-state financial equalization to improve cooperation between the federal levels with regard to e-government and to take a broad perspective in accordance with the life situation concept. Citizens are not interested in whether the municipality, the state, or the federal government is responsible; they want a citizen portal from which they can access the various services that can then be handled digitally.

We currently have a very interesting situation. The most efficient form of e-government is taking place in connection with refugees. The Federal Office for Migration and Refugees, the state level, and the municipal level in the form of foreign offices are interconnected through the core data system for refugees. We have gained an initial interesting insight into the various interfaces. There is a high variability at the municipal level. But users are now realizing that data can be shared. I think that something like this must also be possible elsewhere; this is the expectation we as citizens have for the future. Therefore, there is still a lot of work to be done. If the Normenkontrollrat also turns to what needs to be addressed in the Federal-State Council for IT, there may be conflicts, but in the end, something good will come out of it. I am quite sure of that.

So I think that the Normenkontrollrat will not run out of work even in its third term. The body has always brought together members with different areas of expertise. This allows for the task spectrum to be viewed from various perspectives, even though it is broad. I would like to sincerely thank you, especially the chairman Johannes Ludewig, but also all the members of the Normenkontrollrat. Some of you have been involved for many years. Thank you also to the staff for that.

I would particularly like to highlight Mr. Rainer Funke and Mr. Johann Hahlen, who will be leaving the Normenkontrollrat. They have been deeply involved. I also have the impression that the work has brought them joy. They have spared others from effort by not shying away from their own. Therefore: Thank you. I wish the continuing and new members every success. Your success is our collective success. Therefore, today is also something like a mutual congratulatory session. In this spirit: Here’s to further constructive, productive, and sometimes harmonious collaboration.