Trip to Israel from January 31 to February 1, 2011 - Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel during her visit to the Institute for National Security Studies on February 1, 2011, in Tel Aviv:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

1 February 2011 · Visit to the Institute for National Security Studies · Institute for National Security Studies, Tel Aviv, Israel

Context
Merkel addressed the Institute for National Security Studies in Tel Aviv on February 1, 2011, during an official visit to Israel for German-Israeli government consultations.
Main themes
Israel-Germany relations, Middle East peace process, Israeli national security, regional instability and Arab Spring, European debt crisis, shared democratic values, German-Israeli partnership, global economic shifts, Hezbollah and Lebanon, Egypt protests, Shoah and historical responsibility
Duration
~16 min
56th percentile
Words
1,972
56th percentile
Sentences
101
63rd percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
11.4
37th percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 74%73%
  • Economic 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Institutional 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

101 sentences in 28 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Chairman,

dear Mr. Director,

dear conference participants,

esteemed guests,

dear Tsipi Livni, if I may single out one participant,

it is a great pleasure for me to be here today and to speak at the Institute for National Security Studies.

You have gathered as participants of this conference to address the impacts of new risks and global threats on national security. I believe that hardly a more current topic could have been chosen, as we see that the world is indeed undergoing changes in various ways.

At home in the Federal Republic of Germany and in Europe, we all still feel the significant effects of the international financial and economic crisis. This financial and economic crisis was the largest in decades, since the 1930s. I said very early on: This economic crisis will reshuffle the cards in the world, new forces and balances will emerge. We now see in the recovery phase that this is quite obviously the case, especially when I think of the economic significance of Asia, particularly China.

This economic crisis has had an impact on Europe that we did not foresee. It has shifted the focus of the markets towards the weakness of the Euro. This is not a weakness of the Euro itself, but rather a result of the excessive debt of various Euro member states, which presents us with very, very significant challenges. It requires us to make a clear commitment to the Euro, which we are doing politically. But it also demands that we in Europe come closer together, coordinate better, work together economically, and finally learn that we cannot live excessively on credit and debt, but that we must generate what we consume.

In your region, in the neighborhood of Israel, there have been unrest in recent weeks and days that will be of great significance. There is a very difficult situation in Lebanon, a Hezbollah-dominated government, protests in Tunisia such as this country has never known before. Today there are protests in Egypt on a scale we have not seen before. One can only hope that the general strike in Egypt will proceed peacefully. It was an important signal that the army stated that it is the right of the people to demonstrate. Nevertheless, this is accompanied by great uncertainty about how the political process in Egypt will continue. We can only hope that all of this unfolds peacefully.

What all this means for Israel's security situation is very, very difficult to say today. I want to tell you that Germany is committed to Israel's security and that we will do everything politically that we can to ensure Israel's security. But the situation here is also a reflection of upheaval and completely new challenges for Israel's national security.

Global developments are very much related to national issues and national security. In Israel, this question of national security presents itself quite differently than in Germany. Because the threats to your country are manifest, they are visible. You have a multitude of hostile neighbors. Therefore, the close partnership between Germany and Israel is of utmost importance.

What characterizes this partnership? It is primarily characterized by being founded on shared values: democracy, human rights, freedom, freedom of science, freedom of economic activity, freedom of expression, and democratic structures. Of course, we also demonstrated this again yesterday in our third German-Israeli government consultations.

These government consultations have now developed into a cornerstone of our cooperation. I believe that today, after the terrible experiences of the past, the Shoah, after having succeeded in building partnership and friendship, it is of inestimable importance that we develop cooperative projects in the daily affairs of politics across all departments that bring us closer together and, of course, make the understanding of each other much clearer. Thus, the concerns of one country – in this case, the concerns of Israel – are naturally also our concerns and our tasks to solve these problems.

What is naturally always very close at hand and what is particularly to be discussed in this circle – during the awarding of the honorary doctorate at Tel Aviv University, I spoke more about the scientific and economic relations – is the Middle East peace process, which I would like to bring to the forefront of my remarks. We currently find ourselves in a state that I must describe with the word "stalemate." I believe that this state of stagnation is unacceptable, intolerable. It serves no one, especially not the interests of Israel.

Of course, it seems – I spoke about this yesterday in a very intense and very friendly conversation with the Prime Minister – that there are many reasons, some more acceptable than others, why one should not negotiate right now or why there are more important matters or why one might want to wait. I say very clearly here – and I say this as a friend of the State of Israel: The situation in Egypt should not be an excuse for not continuing the peace process. I would even say that waiting could worsen the situation and that it may be very, very important to act precisely in this situation.

I know that there may also be many in your country who say: The economy is doing well – we are all pleased about that – we have a strong recovery, we have low unemployment. Therefore, there is great skepticism about whether now is the right time for further negotiations. There is also great skepticism about whether the Palestinian partners are truly capable of making peace. But I am convinced – I want to say this to you very openly – that further stagnation helps no one. The calm that seems to exist could prove to be a deceptive calm.

Where deceptive calm can lead, I would like to illustrate with an example from Europe, where we did not look closely for a very long time. Greece was admitted to the European Union. There were even times when Germany and France jointly undermined the Stability and Growth Pact for the Euro. We did not sufficiently address how we could adhere to the criteria for lower debt. Suddenly, after the international financial and economic crisis, after we rescued banks and implemented stimulus programs, we experienced a point where things became very difficult, first regarding Greece and then regarding the Euro as a whole. We were forced to act massively in a short time and to undertake measures that I could not have dreamed of having to take just a year ago. It was an action taken under very high pressure.

I know that the topics of the Euro and the Middle East are completely different topics. What I want to say is: Waiting and letting things run their course can ultimately lead to situations where one must act very, very urgently, perhaps not always taking the best actions and not representing the interests in the best way.

The goals are actually clear on the table: There must be a two-state solution with Israel as a Jewish, democratic state and a viable Palestinian state. I believe I am not saying too much in this room that such a solution will only be possible if there are painful compromises for both sides. When one considers what the outcome of such a compromise, such a conclusion could be, the advantages are, of course, obvious.

It is about security. It is about borders. It is, of course, about all final status questions. But I say quite openly: Perhaps not all questions need to be resolved in the first step, but one can first address the security questions, combined with the border questions. It seems to me that one has often been very, very close to a solution, and that these matters should therefore be advanced now.

I also say quite openly – I told the Prime Minister this yesterday as well: If there is a necessity to impose a halt to settlement construction, then I say: I know that this may be painful for many; but how will one think in ten, twenty, thirty, forty, fifty years about the question of whether one did not build for three months, six months, or nine months? If the result is truly a conclusion that allows for a peaceful and secure life for Israel, then I would say that this goal outweighs the harshness of the compromise that one must make now.

My conclusion is: Those who believe they can wait are mistaken. The matters are on the table. I do not believe that the situation will improve in the coming months, in the near future, but that the interests can be well represented if one takes it seriously now. It is not about negotiations for the sake of negotiations, but about truly achieving the result. I know – I have often spoken with the Palestinians about this – that this is not easy. I also know that one can have many doubts. But I believe there is no better answer than to say: We will try with all willingness to compromise, because the interests of the country, the interests of Israel are so clearly on the table.

What can Europe do about this? We feel that we should actively take the floor and show our willingness to be helpful. We should take the floor in discussions with our American friends, with the American President and the American Secretary of State, as well as within the European Union. We know that we have obligations and responsibilities. We are also aware that from a solution to the Middle East conflict and the establishment of a two-state solution, new responsibilities for us may arise. We must be ready for this if we take seriously what I have told you, namely that for the Federal Republic of Germany, the security of Israel is a matter of state.

I want to mention another aspect that is also among the threats we must anticipate: the situation in Iran. Iran's nuclear program is a threat. The entire stance of Iran, especially regarding Israel, is a threat. After a long time, we have managed to impose sanctions internationally together with China and Russia. I do not rule out that further sanctions may be necessary, as Iran's willingness to negotiate about the nuclear program and to show transparency is not evident. I know that this threat is felt much more strongly by you. But I also repeatedly say in Germany, regarding the capabilities of carrier rockets: It is ultimately also a threat to Europe, it is not just a threat to Israel.

In addition to the threat posed by Iran's nuclear program, there is another threat, namely that of international terrorism. Here too, we stand in shared responsibility. I will only mention the keyword Afghanistan, for example.

When we talk about global upheavals, it is also about access to energy, climate protection, and free world trade. It is about many global challenges. The world is in upheaval. I believe this is the assessment we share. When a world is in upheaval, it is very important that we clearly represent our interests, but also implement them clearly. This certainly includes that painful compromises are often necessary. I hope that we can work out in the discussion how we can deal with these upheavals to our advantage.

In any case, I believe that in Israel – in an environment where there are few friends and where, especially in the country that has lived in stable peace with Israel for decades – the upheaval we are currently anticipating raises new uncertainties and question marks. My conclusion from this is: The more important it is that what we and, in this case, Israel can move is also moved, and for the good of the country and for the good of all of us.