Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the 47th Munich Security Conference on February 5, 2011, in Munich:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

5 February 2011 · 47th Munich Security Conference · Munich, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 47th Munich Security Conference on February 5, 2011, speaking on global security challenges amid the unfolding Arab Spring uprisings.
Main themes
Global security, Arab Spring and Egypt protests, democracy and freedom, NATO and European Union, post-Cold War world order, German reunification parallels, internet and social media, transatlantic cooperation, managed political transition, economic crisis
Duration
~22 min
69th percentile
Words
2,602
69th percentile
Sentences
130
75th percentile
Readability
52
70th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.92
36th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Munich Security Conference Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 73%72%
  • Economic 8%8%
  • Technological 6%5%
  • Ceremonial 6%5%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Institutional 3%3%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

130 sentences in 26 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

dear Mr. Ischinger,

dear David Cameron,

among all the guests, I would like to especially welcome the host of yesterday's lunch, Herman Van Rompuy, here in Munich. The lunch lasted six hours and was quite successful after all.

I am pleased to be here today at the Munich Security Conference, in what is undoubtedly an exciting time. The last two decades have profoundly changed the post-World War II order. We are becoming aware of this step by step. In the late 1980s and early 1990s – we remember with joy – freedom made its way. The changes in Central and Eastern Europe, the collapse of the Soviet Union, the end of the Cold War, and also the end of the world's bipolarity have left discernible marks to this day.

As a symbol – I may say this as the German Chancellor – the fall of the Berlin Wall, the opening of the Brandenburg Gate, stands out. Since Ronald Reagan would be celebrating his 100th birthday this year, I would like to remind you that he was one of the few who predicted and articulated the fall of the wall. When I heard his speech back then on the other side of the Iron Curtain, I thought: Well, many sentences have been said before. That it became true so quickly was something we all – at least most of us – did not foresee. Today, the European Union is different, NATO is larger, and the blocs in the world no longer exist as they once did – with all the consequences that entails. The world has also become more complex in many ways. It was indeed an unstoppable triumph of freedom, as we experienced it back then.

Then came some events that brought us back down to earth and reality. In the 1990s, books were already being written about "The End of History." By the time of the Balkan War, it was clear that it would not be quite so. In the first ten years of the 21st century, we experienced significant events again, first the September 11, 2001 attacks and second a major global economic crisis, the likes of which we had not seen for decades. Essentially, it was a crisis caused by market excesses and the irresponsible exploitation of freedoms.

We also experienced a third thing – something that, in my firm conviction, played a role in the changes in Europe at the end of the 1980s – namely, the breakthrough of a new technology of the information society. Information has become increasingly diverse and clearer since the end of the 1980s and the beginning of the 1990s. What we have been experiencing for several years now with the triumph of the Internet will change our societies in ways that we may not yet fully foresee. Twitter, Facebook, and social networks – in this world, no one can be easily hidden anymore; everything quickly gets a face.

In these days – which were not foreseeable at the time of planning this security conference – we are seeing images that evoke memories of what we have experienced in Europe: people daring to take a stand, people shedding their fear, people expressing what they find unacceptable, and naming injustices. Who would we be if we did not say that we stand on the side of those who express what burdens them? Therefore, we also say: It is absolutely necessary that the freedoms we consider universal – freedom of the press, freedom of expression, freedom of journalism – have their place not only in Europe, America, or other parts of the world, but that the Egyptian authorities are also called upon to secure these freedoms. I believe that yesterday's day, which was relatively peaceful, has shown this to some extent. We can only hope that this continues.

There will be a change in Egypt. Of course, a change must be shaped in such a way that it can proceed peacefully and sensibly. I would like to share a bit of my own history, even if everything is not directly comparable. After the fall of the wall, we did not want to wait a single day. We were always told: You have to wait until July 1, 1990, for the currency union to take place. But we actually wanted the Deutsche Mark immediately. We did not want to wait long for German reunification. When it finally took place on October 3, and we saw how much transition was necessary, we were glad that there were a few people who had prepared it properly.

This means that change must be managed. We, the European Union – as we said together yesterday – want a new partnership to help shape the change. We are neighbors to the North African coast. Cathy Ashton will travel there. We have foundations and many contacts in civil society. I just spoke with Hillary Clinton about how the United States and Europe can work very closely together in shaping the change. We want to do this; it is our duty.

Now, in the first decade of this century, we also had another experience that we should always keep in mind regarding what we are now experiencing in Egypt, Tunisia, and other countries. We experienced – the consequences of September 11 were the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan – that the simple export of what we call Westminster Democracy – I say this in the presence of the British Prime Minister – will not work in all regions of the world. This means that we are now faced with the task of helping on the one hand, while on the other hand, being clear about what we expect from our model in other places and what are, so to speak, their own cultures and developments that we must not and cannot interfere with.

In this regard, the red line beyond which we cannot compromise is the United Nations Convention on Human Rights. Almost all countries on this earth have agreed to this human rights convention. This means that we cannot compromise on the respect for the dignity of every individual. This means that in everything we do – we must also ask ourselves whether we have always done this sufficiently – and in every form of cooperation we maintain, we must always keep human rights and our shared principles in mind. Of course, we will not have shaped the world according to all the principles of the UN Human Rights Convention by tomorrow. Our foreign and security policy therefore faces great challenges.

I want to make it clear: On the one hand, we are obliged to pursue a values-based foreign policy, and on the other hand, we are of course also obliged to ensure security and stability. Both are often in a certain tension with each other. I believe, however, that one should never make compromises that completely disregard one side, namely the respect for human rights. Therefore, all negotiations in which I have participated – for example, those regarding the Mediterranean Union and neighborhood policy – have always also been tough negotiations about the principles of our cooperation; this will continue to be the case. Yesterday, we also said at our EU Council: We will pay even more attention to ensuring that these principles are upheld when we provide financial support.

Now I want to take a look at the development of the transatlantic relationship over the last two decades. The triumph of freedom and the enforcement of the values we share in the transatlantic relationship have been palpable. Nevertheless, we have had difficult times. Regarding the question of the Iraq War, there was a division in Europe and thus also a division in the transatlantic relationship.

However, there were also very successful outcomes that I would like to mention here. When I was first at this security conference as Chancellor, I spoke about my wish for NATO to become more of a place for political discussions, not just military discussions. We have achieved that. We have a new security concept. This NATO security concept is clearly one of military issues, but also of political issues. We went to Afghanistan together. My true and important wish is that we also leave Afghanistan together. We have agreed on a concept of connected security. With this, we have shown that we stand together for an important cause – here: in the fight against international terrorism, which has been our great challenge since September 11, 2001 – in the transatlantic relationship.

But we have also realized that we cannot solve any of the major international conflicts entirely within NATO or as the United States of America and Europe alone. In Afghanistan, we have many other allies. We are leading the E3+3 talks regarding proliferation, when I think of Iran. There are the Six-Party Talks regarding North Korea. In the Middle East, there is a Quartet in which the United Nations and Russia play an important role. We have built a completely new partnership with Russia, which is slowly but surely making the end of the Cold War a reality – step by step and despite all the human rights issues we still have to discuss there. We have also learned that we cannot combat international terrorism without cooperating with Arab states. I mention Saudi Arabia, Yemen, and also Egypt, as it was in the past.

Therefore, I also say that we have the responsibility, on the one hand, to continue to nurture the pillar of our alliance, NATO, and to discuss the new challenges intensively together. Because all these challenges did not exist to this extent 20 years ago. There was not the great danger of international terrorism. And we did not have to deal with proliferation issues with such sharpness. On the other hand, we must do this in the post-Cold War era with the certainty that NATO alone, the transatlantic partnership alone, will no longer solve the major conflicts in the world. This means we need partners in the world. And we must increasingly strive for these partners, as this is indeed a multipolar world in which certain new powers will also have to take on more responsibility.

Now I come with this brief connection to the question of the international financial and economic crisis and the new power dynamics in the world. I have always said: This international economic crisis will lead to a reshuffling of the cards in the world. That is exactly what has happened. When we look at economic strength, emerging countries today are significantly stronger than they were before. Their importance will increase. This means, on the other hand, that the emerging countries, which have a rapidly growing economic significance, must also gradually take on more security responsibility and foreign policy responsibility, in my firm conviction. That is why it was so important that Russia and China also supported the sanctions regarding Iran. That is why it is so important that China plays an important role in the Six-Party Talks. As tedious as it is, we should continually advocate in the transatlantic relationship that this responsibility is indeed taken on by those who play an important economic role in the future.

In my view, we must not beat around the bush: There are challenges for which we do not yet have a conclusive answer. When I look at our NATO concept, our new strategic concept, everything related to cyber defense and cyber attacks rightly plays an important role. We will have to learn together how to respond to this challenge. There is no longer the classic military threat. International terrorism is not so easy to grasp because there are people willing to sacrifice their lives – for those who are willing to do so, there is no real deterrence. We have a situation with cyber attacks where military and technical interplay occurs in a completely new way. This means we will need international agreements on how to deal with the threats posed by cyber attacks. If we do not agree on this, then everyone will build a high spiral of defense, but I suspect also include offensive capabilities in many places. We will waste a lot of money without seeing an army like in the Cold War, but we will still not solve our problems. This means we need to think about how we can reach international agreements in this regard.

Second

We will expand our concepts of interconnected security. Over the past ten years, we have also learned: military attacks alone do not promise a definitive pacification. This is also an important lesson. During the Cold War, there was deterrence; essentially, there were no military actions. The military actions of the 21st century show me that they must be embedded in a concept of interconnected security.

We will also have to learn how to handle information, with the infinite freedom of information exchange. I do not want to comment on WikiLeaks here – you understand that – but we can start with flight data or bank data, with SWIFT and the new flight data regulations between America and the European Union. We are conducting the most contentious negotiations on this. Here too, we must find ways to balance the individual right to informational self-determination, as it is called in Germany, and the necessary protection against terrorist attacks, just as we have done in many other matters in the past.

Final challenge: the transatlantic pillar will not be able to solve all the conflicts in this world. This means that, in my firm conviction, we must contribute with our capabilities in the world to ensure that other capabilities are also developed to resolve conflicts on their continents. I think, for example, of our partner, the African Union. We can contribute a lot of experience, but as a transatlantic alliance, it is impossible for us to carry out actions from Sudan to Somalia to Côte d'Ivoire and many other conflict hotspots everywhere – military actions in most cases certainly not, but even in peacekeeping, we are sometimes not welcome. However, we should be able to empower and enable peace to be created together.

These days, we are very much occupied with considering what we have done wrong in dealing with systems that are now proving to be fragile. I would advise us to occasionally reflect on what we may have also contributed positively. The great technological inventions that have changed our lives – for example, the computer and the internet – all come from societies based on freedom. They come from the freedom of spirit and from places where one can research freely, where one can develop, where one can bring forth creativity. This means I am optimistic that societies based on our model, which respects the dignity of every individual, which gives people the opportunity to develop and exercise their abilities in their own lives, are still the best to fight against terrorism and against attacks on freedom.

Therefore, even on days when we ask ourselves, "What have we done wrong?", we can perhaps proudly say: We have also enabled much that is now commonplace in the world. The existence of Facebook and Twitter all over the world and the increasing difficulty of blocking them – whether in China, Egypt, Tunisia, or elsewhere in the world – is also a small part of our achievement. If we are cooperative together with many others in this world, then, I believe, the transatlantic pillar can still achieve a lot in this world to ensure that it develops for the better, even though we still have many problems.