Cristina with Ban Ki-moon in New York, prior to presiding over the UN Security Council.

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

5 August 2013 · Presiding over the UN Security Council · New York

Context
Fernández de Kirchner met with UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon in New York on August 5, 2013, ahead of presiding over a UN Security Council session on multilateral cooperation.
Main themes
UN Security Council presidency, multilateral organizations, Falkland Islands sovereignty dispute, regional organizations (CELAC, UNASUR), Security Council reform, espionage and privacy regulation, Latin American conflict resolution, international law, sovereign equality
Duration
~11 min
37th percentile
Words
1,261
37th percentile
Sentences
35
21st percentile
Readability
34
23rd percentile
Grade
16.7
88th percentile
Syntax
3.69
98th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 56%54%
  • Institutional 18%17%
  • Ceremonial 18%17%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

35 sentences in 12 paragraphs

Tomorrow we will be at the Security Council. You know that Argentina has always placed great importance and emphasis on multilateral organizations, fundamentally on the United Nations; we have always attended those general assemblies. Moreover, I recently had the opportunity to attend the Decolonization Committee regarding our stance, more than our stance, our decision that Resolution 2065 of the United Nations, issued precisely in 1965, which declares the existence of a sovereignty dispute between the United Kingdom and the Argentine Republic over the Falkland Islands, be respected.

You know that since 1982, the Secretary-General of the United Nations has been requested to use his good offices as a mediator; I have done so again today, but, well, the Secretary has said that, in reality, the United Kingdom refuses to discuss. So, he sees it as really very difficult.

We also raised the participation for tomorrow in what will be the fundamental topic, which is cooperation between multilateral organizations and the United Nations.

I believe that tomorrow is a very important day, more than important, not because Argentina is presiding over the session of this Security Council, but because of the participants.

CELAC will participate for the first time, which is presided over pro tempore by the Republic of Cuba, and what is more important, I believe it has significant precedents. You know that CELAC is the immediate predecessor of the Rio Group, which in the Dominican Republic managed to prevent a military confrontation between the Republic of Ecuador and Colombia, you remember, due to the violation of the territorial space of the Republic of Ecuador. UNASUR will also participate, whose pro tempore presidency is held by Peru through its Foreign Minister. We also discussed the effectiveness of UNASUR as a regional multilateral instrument to resolve problems, not only in the region, as was the opportunity when the then Secretary-General of UNASUR, President Néstor Kirchner, successfully mediated in the Santa Marta Agreement between Colombia and Venezuela, but we also had to intervene on two occasions with internal conflicts: one in Bolivia, which threatened to break the constitutional democratic order of President Evo Morales. At that time, the president of UNASUR was President Michelle Bachelet, and we convened a meeting at La Moneda where the La Moneda Declaration was issued, which precisely prevented and fortunately regularized the situation in the Republic of Bolivia, and later, the Buenos Aires Declaration, when there was also an attempt to impeach President Rafael Correa of Ecuador.

The truth is that multilateral organizations in the South American region have been very effective. I compared them a bit, and it was commented to the Secretary of the United Nations, they are organizations where resolutions are made by consensus. Perhaps that is what forces us to debate for a long time until we reach an agreement. When what happens in organizations like the Security Council occurs, where it is enough for one of the permanent members to oppose for nothing to be resolved, well, it is much more difficult to reach an agreement, because the one who does not benefit says "no," and then it is all over, and there is no need to debate and discuss. I believe that, it is not that... You know that we have raised for a long time the Republic of Argentina along with other countries, the reform of the Security Council, not with the perspective perhaps of others to expand the number of permanent members, because in reality, if we only expanded the number of permanent members, the only thing we would be expanding would be the problem, because instead of 5 opposing, there would be 9 who could oppose global solutions in a realm and in a universe of hundreds of countries, but rather really choose a different methodology of operation.

We also raised the issue of President Evo Morales, an issue that has touched all the leaders of South America and all of Latin America and the Caribbean very closely. We believe that it was a clear and flagrant violation of International Law, of the Vienna Convention, of national sovereignty, in addition to a personal affront to a head of state and, of course, to a society. The Secretary-General shared this, and we also raised what several countries have already raised; I believe that this morning the foreign ministers did so, and that is the issue of espionage, right?, as the need for global regulation in this matter. Not only for a matter related to the peace and security of nations but also with the security and privacy of individuals.

I reminded the Secretary-General of a movie that surely all of you have seen, "The Lives of Others," do you remember?, that fantastic movie that narrated the adventures of the "Stasi" during the Cold War, where everything was spied on in a way... let's say, a bit more rudimentary because there were not the technological methods we have now that allow spying with much more precision, with much greater sophistication if you will, but spying nonetheless. And I believe that humanity has advanced a lot in technology, in the matter of respect for human rights, placing human rights in an important position. But we want that... I think Humberto Eco also says at some point when he says that we are in a sort of crab civilization, that we are going a bit backward. So, we believe that these issues must be debated with dignity, without the need for adjectives or barricade speeches. I believe that neither barricade speeches nor hiding one's head like an ostrich in the hole and ignoring the problems are useful. I believe that the problems are there, they exist, and we must address them.

We also talked about the situation in several places, from Haiti, where the issue is not resolved electorally; also the issue of Egypt, which, well, there has been a coup d'état and it is not resolved, and this creates strong instability in a country that is very important for the region. I believe that, ultimately, what we have been maintaining on repeated occasions in the framework of the General Assembly is a bit of the rethinking of multilateral organizations and, fundamentally, the effectiveness, the effectiveness of those multilateral organizations to be authentic and impermeable in conflicts and to be able to resolve them with a positive outcome for all. It seems to me that this is what is at stake; we must continue to work tirelessly, we must never give up, hope is the last thing that should be lost, and I believe that some things we have done in South America, which are often treated as peripheral countries or sometimes populist governments, we have achieved things that perhaps have not been achieved in other more developed nations.

So, nothing, it has been a good meeting as Ban Ki-moon always has us accustomed to, and I hope that tomorrow, when I have the honor of presiding over the Security Council, we do so in this framework, right?, in a framework of dialogue, in a framework of mutual respect, which I believe will indeed exist, and, well, I hope that my experience as a parliamentarian for so many years, I was a parliamentarian for many years before being President, first as a provincial deputy, and then as a national deputy and national senator, will be a useful tool to carry out a good meeting of the Security Council on such an important topic as this of multilateral organizations and how to achieve peace and security in the world.

Thank you very much.

Cristina