Statements by Cristina at the closing of the United Nations Security Council sessions

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

6 August 2013 · Closing of the United Nations Security Council sessions · United Nations Security Council

Context
Fernández de Kirchner addressed the UN Security Council on August 6, 2013, advocating for structural reforms including elimination of veto power and drawing on Latin American regional conflict-resolution successes.
Main themes
UN Security Council reform, veto power abolition, conflict resolution mechanisms, UNASUR and CELAC as models, Latin American regional diplomacy, national sovereignty, individual privacy rights, multilateralism, democratic legitimacy in international governance
Duration
~6 min
18th percentile
Words
666
18th percentile
Sentences
20
11th percentile
Readability
36
27th percentile
Grade
16.3
85th percentile
Syntax
3.76
98th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 70%70%
  • Institutional 20%20%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

20 sentences in 8 paragraphs

I believe that what is important, at least what we propose, not from the presidency, but from our character as a country, is the need for reform, which we have been advocating for a long time regarding the Organic Charter of the United Nations, in general, and specifically the Security Council. We believe that one of the main problems in conflict management, which is fundamentally the area where conflicts are resolved, in the Security Council, is precisely the veto power exercised by countries. We believe – as I said yesterday – that expanding the number of countries that have veto power, that is, that become permanent members, only exacerbates the problem, because instead of having five vetoes, we will have seven, eight, or nine, which will make everything absolutely chaotic, unsolvable, almost like a Tower of Babel, a tower of interests. So I think that in a world that has changed substantially, we cannot continue with the methods that were created in 1945, when the United Nations was established – through the San Francisco Charter.

I was just reading a bit about the 61 rules that govern the Security Council, and they really do not make it operational at all. I compared it to what happened with UNASUR; with CELAC, where we have mechanisms that allow us to reach consensus. This fundamentally forces us to discuss, to debate, and not to leave our place until we have obtained a solution. This has yielded us great results, as was the case with the Declaration of La Moneda, when during the Pando crisis, President Evo Morales was on the verge of being ousted; during the Ecuador crisis, when President Rafael Correa was also on the verge of being ousted; in the Buenos Aires Declaration, when there were also a series of issues between Ecuador and Colombia that led us to meet in Bariloche. You remember the plan that had apparently been discovered by the United States in Colombia, and there were serious divergences, and we navigated through it, while the Bariloche Declaration ensured mechanisms where they explained to us, do you remember the issue of the bases that were going to be installed in Colombia fundamentally?

Then there was the very strong episode between Colombia and Venezuela, where the then Secretary-General of UNASUR, President Néstor Kirchner, mediated, and in the Santa Marta Agreement, he finally sealed an agreement between both countries. And before that, there was the Rio Consensus, which is today the current CELAC, which was able to save that serious conflict regarding the presence of the Colombian Army on Ecuadorian soil during the presidency of Álvaro Uribe in Colombia.

I believe we have demonstrated a way to address problems. Now, if each of us had had veto power, we must do an exercise: if, for example, Colombia had had veto power, what would have happened? If Venezuela had had it, or if some intra-national organization within Ecuador or Bolivia had had it.

We believe that the veto power, which is a typical government management mechanism in all democracies, has little to do with the Security Council, which is a conflict management area. When there is conflict management, the exercise of veto power, far from contributing to resolving those conflicts, prioritizes the particular interests of some country or region and hinders solutions.

I think, then, it is time to rethink and redefine new practices. This was a bit of what we proposed; I believe there was also an interesting debate around issues that are of public and notorious knowledge that affect, I believe, not only the sovereignty of countries but also the freedom of individuals, the right to privacy of individuals in all countries of the world, because that is already a global issue, and I think that was also put on the table.

Well, I think the challenge that some countries have is that, right?, to articulate their security while respecting the sovereignty of countries and the privacy of all citizens, including their own.

Thank you.