Conference: "Hegemony or Consensus? Break of the Democratic Pact in a Bimonetary Economy: Inflation and IMF, Debt Crisis and Political Fragmentation."

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

10 March 2023 · Viedma, Argentina

Context
Fernández de Kirchner addressed a conference at the National University of Río Negro in Viedma on March 10, 2023, upon receiving an honoris causa doctorate.
Main themes
Argentine democracy and institutional crisis, IMF debt and bimonetary economy, inflation and economic fragmentation, political hegemony vs. consensus, Néstor Kirchner's legacy, state governance models, Peronism and political history, University of Río Negro honoris causa, Patagonian sovereignty, democratic pact breakdown
Duration
~69 min
97th percentile
Words
8,222
97th percentile
Sentences
358
96th percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
10.7
28th percentile
Syntax
3.06
56th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
16th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 48%44%
  • Institutional 33%31%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Social 6%5%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

358 sentences in 8 paragraphs

Thank you very much. Good afternoon to all the people of Río Negro and those who came from other provinces. From Neuquén as well, as there are some from Neuquén, and to all the people of Viedma who are also, in these days remembering, it was on March 7, but I know that the festival continues until tomorrow, right, mayor? Until tomorrow. Well. Or the Patagonian battle for sovereignty, which was one of the three milestones in our history, and as we were just saying with Pesatti when we were coming, this was victorious, because in the end the bandeirantes could not pass. I also want to especially thank the authorities of the National University of Río Negro, Mr. Rector, Mrs. Vice-Rector, for the distinction and to all the academic body and all the university sectors that have participated in… I hadn’t seen you, in this event.

Well, another honoris causa, the last one was in another Argentine province, this time in the north, in Chaco. It was on May 6, in a few months it will be a year. On that occasion, the master class was about democratic dissatisfaction, revisiting a talk I had given at the European Parliament in Brussels about democratic dissatisfaction in societies in the face of unmet demands that are not covered by the states. And I referred to the fact that that State, at least as it is formed in much of the West, is a State, a model of state management through a division of powers that dates back to the French Revolution. This was a bit the tone, the thesis, and that well, we are really trying to manage from the State a society that has the internet and has cell phones and that has absolutely modified everything with a form of state, legal, and political organization that dates back to the French Revolution. I mean: Legislative Power, Executive Power, Judicial Power is a model from the French Revolution, Montesquieu, and that well, we were trying to manage the State with a model from an era where teeth were pulled, tied with a thread and then with a door, and well, they pulled out the tooth. And that evidently generated a lack of instruments and actions that could lead to the State providing satisfaction, responding to the multiple demands it faces. Well, but how are we today, 40 years into democracy as the rector just said? In Argentina, it seems that not even these three powers function. We are… I want to pay tribute here because of the difficulties that this democracy had, to a person who took office with just… a Patagonian like you, who took office with only 22% of the votes back in 2003… I want to vindicate that man who, with just 22% of the votes, received a country in 2003 that everyone remembers the economic part, that we were in bad shape, that the corralito, but there was something that was prior and that he received in the midst of a phenomenal institutional crisis in which today a 20-year-old boy may not remember because he was born in 2003, but there was a time that is not very far in this our country, in the year 2001, where a great institutional crisis occurred that led to five presidents succeeding each other in a week, where people demanded that they all leave. There was no Executive Power, people did not see that the authority, that politics was the one that decided things in the Casa Rosada. People felt that things were decided anywhere but in the place for which they had voted for a person to do the things they had voted for and decided in a free and democratic election. The Legislative Power was strongly questioned. Remember that the first alliance, that of 1999, its vice president resigned amid bribery allegations in the National Congress. In the Senate. I remember it very well because I was a national deputy and a great scandal erupted because a labor flexibilization law was bought by the then ruling party bribing senators, at that time from the opposition, who were from our party, from Peronism. Great scandal. No investigative journalist denounced it, no opponent denounced it. It was denounced by the vice president himself, a leader who was an intellectual who came from Peronism, from the ranks of Peronism, he had denounced it. He finally resigned and this caused a great institutional crisis, but notice we did not have Executive Power, we had a Legislative Power… well, where laws could be bought and sold and we had a Court, finally, known as the automatic majority, which was the one that legalized all the privatizations, everything that was, if you will, in a certain way, the plundering of what was the national heritage. This was… we did not have at that moment what I called in 2007, when I gave my proposal speech for the first presidency in the city of La Plata, what I call the constitutional democratic State. This power that today does not provide and that I said in Chaco that no longer provided answers. We didn’t even have that at that moment. And Néstor in 2003 rebuilds this, first placing the Casa Rosada as the center of gravity of the democratic political power voted in the Argentine Republic. The decisions are made by the President. The Legislative Power is once again what it should be: ruling party and opposition. I happened to be in the ruling party and the truth is that I was a national legislator since 1995, I believe it was the only time when a ruling party in the Argentine Republic voted for laws that it was proud to vote for and sanction because they were laws that granted rights, they did not take anything away from anyone, on the contrary. And I believe that the ruling party was also proudly ruling party. And the opposition, well, was opposition because it had different ideas. This is the system, this is how the system works. It is not that everyone has to vote the same or think the same. At least that is how it was conceived by Montesquieu back in the French Revolution. We had also recovered that Legislative Power. And then, finally, when the people, when the Argentine State, not the President or the Government is threatened by the Supreme Court by its president to dollarize the economy, that memorable speech of Néstor occurs shortly after he took office, where he requests as it corresponds, to the Argentine Parliament, in the Chamber of Deputies to initiate impeachment proceedings against those magistrates. What do I want to say with all this? That finally when I took office as the first president, Argentina was a constitutional democratic State where everyone fulfilled the roles they had to fulfill and it continued like that because in addition to being the President who signed the least emergency decrees, my management during those years of government was characterized by sending everything to Parliament. From the recovery of the AFJP, through the media law, through the recovery of YPF and strategic sovereignty in terms of resources and hydrocarbons, everything absolutely everything. Everything, absolutely everything, was done in that framework. With tensions, with differences, with debates, I am not afraid of that because they were always within the framework of the constitution and the laws. And today, 40 years into democracy on December 10 of this year, well, I believe that what we are experiencing in terms of the division of powers when we see the opposition, or at least the most important sector of the opposition, allied with the Judicial Power to do what we know is being done… Well, I believe that today we are not facing a constitutional democratic State. Look: not to mention, today an hour or two before this conference that everyone knew, from the judicial party, it can no longer be called judicial power, at least from the sectors… an hour or two before this master conference, this honoris causa that has been bestowed upon me, from the judicial party they separate Senator Martín Doñate who was the representative in the Council of the Magistracy and restore the member who had legally challenged him. More mafiosos cannot be found because, the truth is, the mafioso messages… Well, what am I going to say about mafioso messages if here, precisely, in Río Negro, in Lago Escondido, all Argentines could verify the chats where, by those casual coincidences, the judge who instructed the case in which they just disqualified me yesterday, was one of those who recommended how to make fake invoices. I mean: the truth is that I believe that at some point, at some point… because all these sectors and mafias that revel in power and in the impunity of power, at some point always collapse. Sooner or later.

Look: when one has many years, one has seen many things that seemed eternal and that would never end, and that finally do end. Because I believe that the system itself will need to cleanse itself because we are also in a framework of these 40 years of democracy, and I want to specifically talk about the issue that concerns us today, which is the bimonetary economy, which will also require a State and decisions that will imperatively need legitimacy before the whole of society. Those decisions are made by men, by women, by organizations, by bodies that truly honor the demands not of a sector but of the whole of society. And the truth is that the rupture of the democratic pact is what we need to talk about, and I believe that the main and most terrible one was on September 1st, which, yes, I truly tell you from the bottom of my heart, I hated being a protagonist of that. But the rupture of that democratic pact, not the one we had built since 2003 when Néstor reconstructed the constitutional democratic State, but that which was reconstituted on October 30, 1983, and which solidified on December 10 in Plaza de Mayo. And that was the pact that one could not even think that the suppression of the adversary was the suppression of life. That one could eliminate them. That if they were an opponent, I kill them, I make them disappear, or I have to go into exile. This was something that was absolutely validated by society. And yet, that September 1st was broken. But if one really looks at what happened from 2015 onwards, one almost observes a logical sequence of that September 1st. Even in that very year 2022, in March 2022, the day that the agreement with the International Monetary Fund was being discussed in parliament, in the Chamber of Deputies to be more precise, my office was destroyed. First, it was marked with paint, then for half an hour, without any intervention from any force from the City of Buenos Aires or any federal force, my office was stoned and destroyed. The same judge who instructed the case is the same judge who instructs the case. It’s as if everything fits together. And a few days later, in the billboards of the City of Buenos Aires, a sign appeared, with a photo of one of those that Clarín usually takes of me. You see? They can’t do it when I stick my finger up my nose because I never stick my finger up my nose, but if I did, that would be the preferred photo. A photo with a very bad face where they say: murderer of 35,000 people. Curiously, this is on March 28, four days after what is remembered on March 24 and the 30,000 disappeared. The number 35,000 was not casual. You see how they question the issue of the 30,000 disappeared? No, they are not 30, they are this, they are that. Here, then, they had to put more. If we are responsible for 30,000, you, who are the most visible head of Peronism, are responsible for the 35,000. It was never known who the responsible parties were despite the fact that there was evidence, measures were requested… It doesn’t matter. This means that that September 1st had many precedents before it started, even here the rector just mentioned one of the objectives of the university, which is to close the gap and achieve gender parity for the vice-rector. I think that’s fantastic, but I want to remind you how the first woman who is President of the Argentine Republic was totally anathematized, but not for the policies because one can and must accept all differences and all criticisms of the policies. No, they were all issues and allusions to my condition as a woman. Not to the policies. This also contributes, as the Pope told me when he called me the next day, Francis on August 2: physical violence is always preceded by the violence of words and attitudes. Always, and this always happens. We then arrive at this difficult moment in Argentina within the framework of what I call, well, the foundations of yesterday, more than foundations, is a euphemism: millions of words and adjectives, not a single proof and one sole objective, the proscription. I believe that the one who best defined it was the Minister of the Interior, Wado de Pedro, when he said they have replaced the electoral code with the penal code. This is the truth of the matter today in the Argentine Republic. But how are we if the institutions are like this in the Argentine Republic? How are we doing with the economy 40 years into democracy? Wow… it’s what I call the bimonetary economy. March 24, 1976, I believe was the moment of rupture of what was the industrialist economic model by import substitution that Peronism strongly inaugurated and which had already been incipient during the time of Yrigoyenism when the first import substitution had to be made due to the First World War. And the reform of financial entities, the famous Martínez de Hoz reform introduced a modification of the accumulation pattern in our society and also in our leadership, business, and economic elites. A model that we could call fundamentally financial capital. And that, as such, and from the globalization of financial capitalism, the dollar becomes the pattern of conduct, I would say. Because today it is a pattern of conduct, more than a monetary pattern, at least in Argentina. A pattern of conduct. And I say: the industrialist model of import substitution had problems, it was not all smooth sailing. It had what was known as external restriction. We also lacked dollars, but we lacked dollars because what the agricultural sector produced was not enough to meet the dollars that we needed to develop industries that generate much more work, because that’s what it’s about, right? I mean… generating work and well-paid work as well. And well-paid work as well. And then that external restriction that the industrialist model of import substitution had begins to deepen with this pattern of conduct that I am talking about. And then first the leadership and business classes that make up Argentina begin to form external dollar assets that are of course taken from our economy and placed outside the circuit of Argentina abroad. I skip over the nationalization of the debt of the large concentrated groups of the dictatorship in 1982. Those who speak against the State should remember that the one who later came with convertibility, when he was at the Central Bank at that time, was the one who nationalized the debt of the large economic groups that we Argentinians are still paying in general. So that behavior, then, as a result of devaluations, of economic crises that occurred from the hyperinflation of 1989, the other hyperinflation that came in 1990, plus the crisis I referred to in 2001, began to permeate all of society. And then it was no longer just the businessman who formed assets abroad but also the people who, as a defense mechanism, even the lady who worked in the house and gathered what she could, and when she could gather a little more money, went and bought 50, 60, 100. This is the behavior, this is the pattern of conduct. Why? Because the peso is relegated only for domestic issues but becomes a currency that we do not have, as a savings currency. And a payment currency as well for certain operations. Go buy a house, a piece of land, if you don’t have dollars. And if you want a luxury car, the same, they won’t sell it to you. This means that today, 40 years into democracy, we are not only without a constitutional democratic State but we are also without currency. This is what is called a bimonetary economy. And look how it shows even in small things. Let’s see: the other day I was reading, and I know it because Calafate… try to find a rental in Calafate if you can, if you can. It cannot be found anywhere in Patagonia nor will it be found in the tourist sectors that are waiting for RNB to arrive… and it’s logical, and I don’t criticize those who do that because, in the end, they are defending themselves or defending their assets. But we have to think about the political leaders who pride themselves on wanting… Because what is it to lead, what is it to be a political leader, to be a Senator, to be a President, to be a Governor? No, to lead is that, to lead. I mean: the leader has to see a little further ahead what is going to happen because they have to guide and lead their societies to good and safe places. That is being a leader. And this bimonetary economy leads us to this scenario of this Argentina with inflation. Because, and this is key to understand, there is a great discussion or at least it seems to appear that there is a great inclusion regarding what causes this absolutely excessive inflation, compared to any other country in the world, that Argentina has and that is not the first time. We went through the hyperinflation crisis of 1989, then the one of 1990… it’s not the first time. And well, for a long time it was said that if salaries are increased too much, this generates inflation. Which means that in times when salaries are good, we should have inflation. I want us to put up the first graph, do we have it? There it is.

That graph that you see that says “real salary RIPTE, constant pesos from January 2023.” Look, it’s from 1995. I want to say the origin. I took this from the newspaper La Nación so you can see that it doesn’t come from Página 12 or Pravda or Havana or anywhere. It’s a chart published by a prominent columnist from the centennial newspaper La Nación, I believe on Monday or Tuesday, and where it measures the RIPTE. Look: the RIPTE, of course, when the crisis of 2002 came, look where it was when Néstor took office, down there. And it starts to rise and crosses the line, importantly, already in 2007 when he was President and then it continues and continues. Well, all that little line that goes up and up to the top, drops a little and goes back to… Guess in which government it was. In ours. And look how curious, look how curious. In 2015, when we had the highest salary in dollars in Latin America, the inflation of that year, measured by the City of Buenos Aires, was 24 point something, 24 percent. I remember that all the leaders, both friends and foes, were giving me lessons. All of them. Lessons on how to do it. Not to send the people from La Cámpora to the supermarkets to control prices, that that was not inflation. That how, that this woman is crazy, what is she doing? Well, those who gave me lessons and said that solving the inflation issue was a matter of a snap of the fingers, just like that, raised it to 54%. And look how salaries were in 2019 and look how they continue to be now that we have 100% inflation. First conclusion for people who only have to exercise their memory and if they don’t remember something, read a little: it is clear that salaries are not the cause of inflation, because with the salary of Latin America we had 24 and with salaries at rock bottom and with registered workers, as I said in Chaco, who for the first time do not make it to the end of the month, it means… And then what is happening? What is happening is what I said in December 2020, right, rector? At an academic event, not even vice-rector, but in La Plata. I remember, a very nice event that had been organized by the governor of the Province of Buenos Aires, to which the President went, the then President of the Chamber was also there, Máximo, Sergio, who was the President of the Chamber, and I remember that I spoke after Sergio, and Sergio had predicted that the economy was going to grow. And I said, “Of course it’s going to grow, but we have to align prices, salaries, tariffs, and services.” Why? So that the growth is not taken by four crooks. That’s what’s happening. Because it is true that there is growth, it is true that the economy is growing, and it is true that jobs are being created, but they are precarious and of very low quality, and of very low salaries. And this is what we have always maintained from Peronism, which is the participation of workers in the Gross Domestic Product. The second chart, please.

Look, look, the second chart is the participation of salary in the Product in a slightly longer historical series, from 1935 to 2022, and notice that the three peaks correspond: the first to the first Peronist government, the second coincides with the coup of March 24, 1976, and the other is ours. The period of the three government periods, which I must also say, in addition, that since the Sáenz Peña Law no political force has been able to fulfill three consecutive periods of government democratically, I mean, obviously, by popular election. Well, if it’s not the salary, it’s proven, today we have an inflation of 100% and salaries are super depressed and no one disputes that. And that the purchasing power needs to be improved, no one disputes that, which means that it’s not because of the high salary. When we had high salaries, was there inflation? Yes, but not this one. Clearly. Let’s go to the second, the one we hear most insistently today: fiscal deficit. That is, inflation is due to the fiscal deficit. This means that if there is no fiscal deficit, there is no inflation, it will disappear, or it will not be a problem. Here I want us to put up the other chart, this one is in English because I took it from The Economist, well, I did it to avoid them saying it’s a chart… No one is going to dispute me from The Economist, I suppose.

I want you to look, these are all the countries and you will see two columns, the first column is the current account balance. What is the current account balance for the lady who is watching us to understand? It is what you have left in dollars once you have paid all the imports, all the transfers you have to make, the negative tourism balance, it is what you have left as the merchant, what remains in the current account to pay the bills. That is, look. That is the first, now look at the second, the second which is all pink, because there are only 5 light blue ones, the second column is the fiscal deficit. Primary and financial. Look at all the countries there, of all the countries there, only 5 do not have a fiscal deficit and I will tell you: Norway, Denmark, Saudi Arabia, Israel, and Chile. All the others have a fiscal deficit. But how? And Chile, not even, only 4 have twin surpluses, only 4: Norway, Denmark, Saudi Arabia, and Israel. All the others have double red, both in deficit and in current account. Except in current account where there are many light blue ones, why? Because this is what determines the amount of currency you have in the economy to meet all the investments and all the obligations you have in terms of debt, that is the big issue. But also, and this does not mean, because I already see that Clarín will headline tomorrow "Cristina wants there to be a fiscal deficit." No, no, I do not want there to be a fiscal deficit. The virtuous thing is not to spend more than what comes in, but evidently in times of crisis this is an instrument that is needed to avoid recession, because otherwise, we could end up with the most feared hell which is recession with inflation and we are in trouble. AND WE ARE IN TROUBLE! Moreover, look at the 5 countries that do not have a fiscal deficit, in the case of Norway, besides being 9, 10 million people, they have a brutal surplus from Statoil, which is the fuel company, the entire North Sea is a lake of oil and everything they take from Statoil, which now has another name, I think they gave it another name, Norway, I think it is called now, which is the one that is going to drill here, off the Atlantic coast, in our country, goes to a pension fund. They have a trillion dollars, they have secured their pensioners, their retirees, I think until the end of the century. The same happens in the case of Saudi Arabia, obviously I do not have to explain why Saudi Arabia has an excellent current account. Denmark also is self-sufficient in energy and Chile does not have, has a negative current account because surely energy prices have shot up their bills and we already know what happens. Israel we already know, a power. And there are many other countries that are powers in terms of exports and, therefore, the important thing is to be in light blue in the current account. Look, I am going to give you an example to make it even clearer. Put the last one back, that one. Look there at Malaysia. Does Malaysia ring a bell? Surely not. There you will see Malaysia which has a fiscal deficit of 5.3 of GDP, a little lower is Argentina with 3.8. That is, Argentina has less fiscal deficit than Malaysia, however Malaysia has 2.4 in the account, and why do I talk to you about Malaysia? Because today marks 30 years since YPF was listed on the New York Stock Exchange, the president of YPF, Pablo González, a Patagonian like all of us, is currently in New York. You know, and it has been widely publicized in all the media, that he is in negotiations with Petronas. Look at what coincidences are: Petronas is the state gas and oil company of Malaysia, it would be the YPF of Malaysia, and just the head of Petronas, the ambassador of Malaysia, was also with me that September 1st. It was the last meeting I had when I left the Senate before getting home that night and… well. And an agreement is being negotiated because Malaysia, Petronas, which has a higher fiscal deficit than Argentina, would finance the construction of a plant in Bahía Blanca for liquefied gas and a gas pipeline that would come directly from Vaca Muerta to Bahía Blanca. They have a fleet in terms of liquefied natural gas to transport it, formidable. With an investment in infrastructure of 30 billion dollars that can reach much more when all the production and exploitation issues are done. LOOK! A country that has a higher fiscal deficit than us is the one that is going to finance this venture. Do you realize? How they lie to us, right? How the media lies to us when they give you economics lessons and talk for 20 hours about the fiscal deficit and do not talk about the assets formed abroad to evade taxes and take away the work of Argentines. The truth is… The truth is… And you will ask me why the master class also mentioned inflation and the International Monetary Fund, well, this is the second part. The second part is that the pandemic was terrible, the war is also, but there is no greater catastrophe for the Argentine Republic than the indebtedness that occurred during the government, in the period between 2015 and 2019, that is the truth of the matter. CATASTROPHE! Why do you think we could have 12 and a half years of government in the Argentine Republic and good salaries and make satellites and have scientists return to the country with the Raíces program and distribute more than 5 million computers to the kids and build the Universal Child Allowance? How…? No, no, this does not depend on people, it depends on policies made by certain people, it is not a personal issue, it is a political issue. It is a political issue because a man who besides rebuilding the constitutional democratic state, paid the debt, restructured, did the most formidable sovereign debt restructuring in all of history and besides doing the sovereign restructuring with a cut of capital and interests, paid the International Monetary Fund so that it could not interfere in the development of national public policies. And this agreement that has been signed. Ah, I want to first demystify a little this agreement, because it seems that one does not like the International Monetary Fund for dogmatic reasons or that we do not want to pay. Of course, if they gave you 45 billion dollars you will have to pay it back, this is clear, no one expects you not to pay it back. I also do not have a dogmatic or ideological issue with the International Monetary Fund. The other day this same columnist who published the RIPTE said, he titled verbatim "Máximo and Cristina." He was referring to Máximo obviously. "Máximo and Cristina condemned to an economic program they do not believe in." First issue, I believe in God, nothing more. In love, too, but in an economic program no one believes. What is this, a matter of faith? No, no, no. Economic programs are not a matter of faith, they are a matter of objectives they pursue and the effectiveness and efficiency they have to achieve those objectives. That is, I do not fall in love with anything but, I say this to clarify that there is no dogmatic issue with this, or that I did not want to agree with the Fund, or… I will tell you a secret, so you understand a little why so much that is published, so much that is said on and off and here and there, a jab here… So, I believe, look a short secret, the only one I will make: in December 21, I was in full negotiation with the International Monetary Fund, one day the president of the Central Bank, who is the current president of the Central Bank, calls me, he wanted to see me. I said yes. I told him to come to my house, I did not like receiving him in the Senate, because the president of the Central in the Senate, then you have 28 million articles, analyses of this, of that. And he comes to tell me, the negotiation was very tense, apparently, with the International Monetary Fund and the Minister of Economy and he comes to propose that they were willing from the Fund to travel to Argentina to meet with me because they thought I would solve it because, and I want to reproduce verbatim and finish, I will not talk more about this topic… "Because the Minister of Economy, at that time the minister who later resigned, well, was very stubborn, that he was very capricious, that he did not want"… "Well, no, no" I tell him, "I was taught from a very young age that when someone starts a negotiation it is the one who has to finish it and that there is no worse negotiation than those made in two or three windows, because finally the one who has more power ends up messing up the others, who are divided into 3 or 4 places." "In any case, well, tell the President if you have differences with the Minister of Economy, let the President decide and he told me that the President said yes to one, no to another"… Well, it does not matter, the point is that I did not want to intervene because I think the one who had to negotiate and do the things he had to do was the then Minister of Economy, who finally when he resigns, does not resign as it was said there because he fought with me or fought with, no, no, no. Moreover, I have my cell phone, I can show the cell phone as I always say, I have in my cell phone the last very attentive message he sent me, a month before resigning, in which he sent me the bill for Unexpected Income, which had been sent to Congress. I say all this to finish when one discusses and they put clichés and put you in a place that you are stubborn, that you do not want this, that you do not want the other, that you are very ideological, no, no, no. Look, I think I have shown pragmatism when it comes to the interests of the country that well, I no longer know what more I should do. I no longer know what more I should do. Well, this agreement, moreover, I strongly supported the restructuring of private debt, even though we did not obtain a single cut, not a single dollar of capital and interests, I believe that a better negotiation could have been made and I supported it because I thought I had to support it, I sat at the proposal table when it was presented in Olivos and I sat again at the Bicentennial table when it was closed, because that is also part of institutional responsibility but, part of institutional responsibility is also to say what can happen if certain agreements are signed that ultimately end up being inflationary. For a simple reason, if in a bimonetary economy like the one I have, I have to go in the devaluation above inflation and in the interest rate above all that and I also have to eliminate all kinds of subsidies to tariffs and public services, in an economy with the characteristics of Argentina… Because agreements cannot be like selling a package of cookies that is the same for everyone, no, no. This is what I have maintained, I maintain and will always maintain, and I think it is important and because they will have to do it, the conditions under which the agreement was signed will also have to be reviewed. Because I want us to put the debt one, please, which is the last one.

Look at the debt there, it’s very small, you won’t see it, maybe it’s bigger over there on the side. But look at what the debt is in dollars, this is paying debt year by year, here we have neither payment for imports, nor payment for the negative tourism balance, nor payment for freight transfers, for everything that needs to be paid in foreign currency, dividends, royalties, here it is only debt and we have in the year 2024, that is, next year, 15,421,000,000 dollars, the following year 18,546,000,000 dollars, the next 19,255,000,000 dollars, in 2027 they start at 23,000, 25,000, 24,000, 24,000, 23,000. That and we must also have, I repeat, the dollars for imports, of all kinds and for technological innovation, because I want to tell you something, we need innovation, we are in a university, Argentina urgently needs technological innovation for its exports because exports have been re-primarized in the Republic of Argentina in recent years. They have been re-primarized! Re-primarization means scarce and poorly paid work. We need technological innovation which is what provides qualified salaries in universities, in scientists. Who do you think invented the internet? Apple, Steve Jobs? No, it was the State that did it. The United States in its multiple investment agencies. I recommend a book by Mariana Mazzucato, “The Entrepreneurial State,” which demystifies that technological innovation comes from the private sector. No sir, the great technological innovation comes from the state sector! In the United States, in Germany, and everywhere. Now, if I don’t have the dollars how do we achieve this technological innovation? The other day I read a journalist, who is a reasonable journalist, saying that starting in 2025 with Vaca Muerta and lithium there will be plenty of dollars. Look, I’ll tell you something, we have also had a very important trade balance and the dollars went away because of what I told you at the beginning: the bimonetary economy. If we continue to have as a pattern and there are some who say that this is solved with dollarization, look at that! I would like it to be understood what this is: the other day a very important businessman from Argentina was talking to me about this, he was talking about Ecuador but I recommend that someone, when they have a little time, take a trip to Ecuador and see if they think Argentina can be like that and replicate it. Why do I say this? And I want you to understand it, because people in Argentina, or a significant part of society believes that dollarization will be something like convertibility, where we were convinced that 1 peso was worth 1 dollar. No, it’s not like that, the value of a currency is not given by any law, the value of a currency is given by the size of the economy of the country that issues that currency and if in addition to being the first economy in the world, it has a couple of aircraft carriers, we understand why the dollar is the standard of conduct. Today there is a great geopolitical issue, right? But if dollarization occurs in Argentina, the one who will pay taxes and the great sacrifice of that dollarization will be the Argentine middle classes. Think for a minute about those who block the streets and everyone gets angry, the welfare recipients, the poor, this, that, and the other. They will not have major problems if there is dollarization because the biggest consumer of dollars is not the one who eats once or twice a day, nothing more and has no other. The great consumer of dollars in Argentina is the Argentine middle classes, which means that if there is dollarization the impoverishment of the Argentine middle classes will have no limit. But how does it cross your mind to have a currency issued by another country? How much will your salary be worth in relation to that? We have to discuss and debate these things and force each and every one of us to think a little more before repeating monotonously, as if we were back in colonial times and they wanted to sell us colored trinkets. We cannot keep buying more colored trinkets, Argentines, we have been sold colored trinkets for a long time. No more! No more! But then is the issue that there is no solution, even if we have Vaca Muerta? No, no, of course, if we, for example, because we have another problem with the bimonetary economy, we also have an Argentina that has become informal and has a percentage of its population informal and a black economy. And one thinks that the black economy is only the informal employees who are not registered and their employers. No, no, I’m going to ask you a question: How many restaurants do you go to and when they give you the ticket, is it a ticket that says order, you see that it doesn’t say AFIP? Did you see that it doesn’t say AFIP? I’m not talking about the one who sells to you, because some get angry with the street vendors, there’s someone here from Río Negro who always had a problem with the street vendors, tremendous, because they were informal and because they were unregistered. And then those who complain about the street vendors or the informal ones go to a restaurant, maybe a fancy one, and in the restaurant they give them a ticket order, the order ticket that is not from AFIP. Well, wake up Argentines, if we look at the EAP, that is, the Economically Active Population, which will be about 30 million Argentines more or less. That is, Argentines between 18 and 65 years old, those of working age, we have registered, whether as private employees, public employees, self-employed, social monotributistas, family employees, about 11 million 600 thousand Argentines. Of those 30 million, we have registration. Then there are about 7,800,000 Argentines, Argentines who receive a check, an income that comes from the State, I’m not talking about retirees, which is the SIPA system, the Pension System, I’m talking about Potenciar Trabajo, AUH, Progresar, etc., which are social policies, social action policies. But there are 11,100,000, 37%, that is, look at what I’m telling you, economically active population, that is, the population that works, I have registered 11,600,000 and that I have no record of anything 11,100,000, almost 37% that we don’t know where they are, nor what they are, nor what they do and 38% that yes. That is Argentina in the black, which are not the welfare recipients, we have the welfare recipients registered, each one is registered with a CUIL, it is a registered fiscal income. But there are approximately 11 million who are not registered.

Now, the set of registered and unregistered functions as economic activity and the problem we are having is that the informal or unregistered issue demands from the State for economic activity either pesos or dollars, but it turns out that I do not have the counterpart of the tax I collect from the activity to sustain the State. Do you realize how it is functioning? Bimonetary economy and also practically a third in the black, I still don’t know how we are alive, really. We are miraculous, really Argentina is miraculous. So it seems to me that these are the issues we have to discuss. And what does it mean to discuss this? It means, for example, managing foreign trade so that there is no more import festival. Some got angry when I talked about the import festival but the new Minister of Economy had to take action to avoid the import festival. We need to have a Central Bank… some want to burn it. Gasoline cans are the easiest and fastest to get but,… Do you think things can be solved that way in the Republic of Argentina? I, personally, understand that no. I also understand that a profound reform in the Central Bank is required so that it really fulfills the role of protecting the currency. And what is protecting the currency? Protecting the size of the economy, for what I said before. Because the value of the currency is not the nominal value, the value of the currency is when it becomes the standard of other economies. That is the value of the currency. And I think, then, that the question is: what do we do, can we continue this way? Because the question was “Hegemony or consensus.” Well, between 2003 and 2015 there was democratic hegemony. Yes, there was a model of the country, debt reduction, production, industrialization, etc.… I won’t elaborate. Why was it a democratic hegemony? Because Parliament was functioning at full capacity, because not a single law was passed by bribing anyone, because no one was forced to vote anything, because those who voted in favor did so because they were convinced, because those who voted against did so because they didn’t believe in it… and that’s fine, if you don’t believe in it. Now, another party came and could not build its democratic hegemony, because what did it say… rate hike, people did not agree… pension reform, they did not agree… the IMF came and a fierce indebtedness, which was what caused the indebtedness to come. So, the one who came after could not build the democratic hegemony because… look, you can govern in two ways: by democratic hegemony, in a constitutional state, or by consensus… agreeing on the political forces the model of the country and where we are going. Now, if we do not have democratic hegemony and we do not have consensus either, “well buddy, may your brother help you.” So, I sincerely believe, and it’s not the first time you’ve heard me, because you also heard me say it in Chaco, I wrote it in my book Sinceramente, I am convinced that it is necessary to agree. We are not going to agree on everything because some will say that there should be labor flexibility and others will not, but in this bimonetary economy, in what pattern of accumulation are we going to make to have the necessary dollars to meet not only obligations but also the obligations of development and growth that our society needs and demands. We need to sit down and talk about that, without adjectives, without stereotypes, without clichés, because the truth is that we have an authority… The other day, one of the main candidates of the opposition said that whoever said they were coming and lifting the restrictions was a fraud… healthy gesture. And clarified a little right away and said that in 2016 it could be done because there were reserves in the Central Bank… “Hello, how are you?” They have lied and lied and continue to lie… Why don’t we try telling each other the truth, with the numbers? These are numbers, I don’t come with ideology or theories or hypotheses, I come with numbers. I contrast the Argentina we left in 2015, with 24 percent inflation, the best salary, debt-free, the Fund was not there, and the one who came had to settle with the vultures. And one more thing… we will need political leaders in Argentina to be united together in the face of our main challenge which will be to review that agreement so that necessarily, not to avoid payment, but to let us grow. So, a change of attitude is essential, which does not involve agreeing with them on things that we will surely not agree on but, yes on this. On the fundamental, on the axis. Then people will vote if they like how one pays their salary, how they like the rate of the other, but let’s agree on this. Because if we do not agree on this, we can have twenty Vaca Muerta, eighty thousand tons of lithium, but we will continue to lack dollars and, fundamentally, and this is my great fear, to conclude the talk because it is the end of the presentation, I am very afraid of political fragmentation. What is political fragmentation? Let’s look a little in the region, let’s look a little in Latin America. In 2011 two political parties in Peru had 65 percent of the elections; today, to gather 50 percent of the parliamentarians in Parliament five political parties are needed. No candidate reaches more than 20 percent. The same happened in Ecuador, the fragmentation of political power, the fragmentation of politics, because people take it out on politics and think, in addition, that one comes and promises one thing, another comes… and we go like this, and people remain convinced that politicians are the bad ones. No, it’s the economic models. And look at one thing, in Peru they have the Central Bank overflowing with dollars, mining exports of more than 50 billion dollars. Something that we will also have to address seriously. We can perform much better than we currently do. Chile exports 40 billion dollars a year in minerals alone, and the mountain range is the same on both sides. In fact, I believe that the vein -if there is one- has to extend a little more because we have more territory… you saw that Chile is very narrow… with all due respect, but it is narrow. This is what I want to tell you and it was the reason for my presentation or master class, on the occasion of the Honoris Causa… to contribute ideas and discussions. We cannot continue in such a flat and mediocre debate, and so managed by the media. We do not deserve it, and especially you, students of public universities. Thank you all, it has been a pleasure to be with you. Thank you.