Speech at the Puebla Group meeting "Popular Will and Democracy. From the Military Party to the Judicial Party, the Threats to Democracy."

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

22 March 2023 · Puebla Group meeting "Popular Will and Democracy. From the Military Party to the Judicial Party, the Threats to Democracy."

Context
Fernández de Kirchner addressed the Puebla Group meeting in March 2023, analyzing threats to democracy from lawfare and judicial persecution of left-wing Latin American leaders.
Main themes
Lawfare and judicialization of politics, democracy under threat, military coups and judicial party, neoliberalism and Chicago school economics, income redistribution and social mobility, Peronism and Argentina's political history, criminalization of progressive politics, media complicity in lawfare, Latin American popular movements, memory truth and justice, Kirchnerism and democratic reconstruction
Duration
~29 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,518
82nd percentile
Sentences
176
86th percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
10.1
22nd percentile
Syntax
2.97
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
51st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 32%28%
  • Economic 25%21%
  • Social 19%16%
  • Ceremonial 15%13%
  • Geopolitical 9%8%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 14%

176 sentences in 31 paragraphs

Thank you very much. Well, good evening. Good evening to everyone. Presidents, because really when someone is a President, they are called President for life. Thank you very much for being with us. Gisele, Eduardo, Marco, Baltasar, thank you very much to all.

A night of many emotions and as someone also said, of many caresses, right? After so many blows. And even attempts at shooting. Ah, Pepe, oh, Pepe, I had forgotten about Pepe, and Lucía! Pepe and Lucía. Both of them. Pepe and Lucía. And, well, when I was waiting to enter, watching the last part of that video you brought, Rafael, about that, well, we could make movies out of that, series, we could make series on Netflix, several episodes. So I don’t want to… there were explanations from legal experts, everyone spoke. But it seems to me that this issue of lawfare and that Gisele was just talking about enemy criminal law, co-optation of the system. Media. Articulation with the media, fundamental. Lawfare cannot be explained without the media. Sentences are written in the media and then a judge or a prosecutor subscribes to the accusation or subscribes to the sentence. This is how lawfare works.

But what interests me fundamentally is to analyze it first from a historical perspective. And second, what is the true objective of lawfare because as Gisele just said, it is the criminalization of politics. But not of all politics. But of one that has to do with income redistribution, with upward social mobility so that our societies do not remain eternally crystallized between rich and poor. It is something that we have also experienced, not under the form of lawfare, because the call today was from the Military Party to the Judicial Party. It is difficult to talk to young people of 20 about the disappeared from 40 years ago. But in reality, this lawfare, which today floods the entire region, was preceded by other previous instruments.

During the National Security Doctrine when the world was divided between East and West, the Armed Forces played the role of interrupting popular processes throughout the region, processes that today are called populist and that have always been national, popular, and democratic processes, which come from the very history of the construction of our nationalities in South America. It has to do with that.

What was the Military Party? Well, this, what happened in 1976. An accumulation model that had emerged after the wars in the Argentine Republic was interrupted and that symbolized above all things, Peronism. Which was essentially upward social mobility. I am a daughter of that Argentina. Of the Argentina of upward social mobility where the daughter of workers. A child of a worker could access the University and also access the presidency of a country. We are children of that model. In 1976, that Argentina of production and work was broken. There had been other coups that had ousted Peronism from government, in 1955 the Revolución Fusiladora, but it is directly the coup of 1976 that marks with fire and destroys that model of country, that model, that pattern of accumulation that was not only economic, it was cultural.

Because it was Argentina where progress was made through work and where it was possible to believe that if you studied and worked, you would do well. That was Argentina. And those coups, perhaps, the bloodiest here in Argentina and also in Chile. There Marco Ominami, also like our children, is also a child of that coup d'état of Pinochet. And coincidentally, it is in Chile where the first laboratory of neoliberalism was established in Argentina.

Did you see that lately there is talk of Von Hayek and a new politician talks a lot about Von Hayek? And wants to put Argentina in the wave of Von Hayek? Von Hayek was an economist of the Chicago school, along with… Milton Friedman. The years do not come alone, they say. Milton Friedman and that neoliberal laboratory was established in Chile with the dictatorship of Pinochet. Then came another neoliberalism, a wave of neoliberalism throughout the region with privatizations. But it was the military coup that broke that pattern of accumulation and that culture and from there, the bimonetary economy in Argentina emerged and was reaffirmed.

Excuse me for talking so much about the economy lately, but believe me that everything that happens and all the persecutions and everything that is suffered has to do with the economy. It has to do with that Argentina that on May 25, 2003 came to rebuild, again, what I call the constitutional democratic state. A man with barely 22% of the votes built that Argentina that came from many tragedies. From the tragedy of the dictatorship, from the tragedy of privatizations, of the neoliberal model, and it was precisely that along with that reconstruction there was also a reconstruction of memory, truth, and justice. Because part of this persecution of which perhaps I, because I represent it or have the highest degree of representation of that space, is particularly fierce against me.

Because it is not only the economy, but also what we were able to build in terms of Human Rights, they will never forgive us. Never. They will not… I still remember that cover of Página 12, that cover of Página 12 that is over there in the Mausoleum in Río Gallegos where the genocidal said that his worst time, Videla, right? His worst time had come with the Kirchners. I will never forget that.

And really when Néstor came to government, the demand for memory, truth, and justice, José Luis, Rafael, did not exist in Argentina. It was not in the polls, it did not appear. The organizations stubbornly, Madres, Abuelas, Hijos, relatives, kept marching, marching, marching, but there were even offers to declare the Laws of Impunity constitutional. Which of course, Néstor rejected. And I had, José Luis, dear presidents, friends, the honor of being a legislator who voted precisely for the nullification of those laws of impunity. And the truth is that when we talk about the reconstruction of that constitutional democratic state, it was profound and thorough. We reconstituted the authority of a Casa Rosada, of an Executive Power, perhaps those who are 20 years old today do not remember, but back in 2001, Argentines were in the streets shouting “that they all go, let not one remain.” It was the repudiation of politics for what had happened.

And the role of the Legislative Power was also reconstituted, which for those who do not remember either, the other day someone who launched their candidacy for president of the opposition party that seems to have come out of the craters of Mars recently discovered, because they talk about sending some and others home, was part of that government that was left without government, when its own Vice President denounced that they had bribed opposition senators, the Peronists of that moment, to sanction the Labor Flexibility Law.

Yes, young people, and young Argentines, Peronists, libertarians, from Cambiemos, yes, there was a government, the first coalition government, or first alliance, whose Vice President resigned denouncing corruption because they had bribed legislators. Yes, laws were bought in the Argentine Republic and others were obtained with the threat that such a thing had to be sanctioned, zero deficit, the other deficit, because if not the Fund would come and cut all our heads off. Yes, there was a time when the Legislative Power was that, and we came to rebuild that too.

When I took office as President in 2007, in the National Congress, I had been a national legislator since 1996, there was a ruling party and an opposition. And the laws were voted according to each one's convictions, without threats, and we also rebuilt that. And it also fell to him. With barely 22% of the votes, he also had to rebuild a Judicial Power that at that time had the so-called “automatic majority” that had threatened, not the government but the Argentines, with the dollarization of the economy. This was Argentina in 2007, you knew Néstor, José Luis. Because I am going to tell something, when Néstor went to Spain for the first time they told him, José Luis was obviously the President of the PSOE, you were president of the PSOE, secretary general. Ah, of course, you have a secretary general, I am Peronist, you see, we are all… no, no, yes, a lot of that I don’t understand, that is more to the left, we are Peronists. But, eh, and yes the truth, well, nothing. And then they told him “no, why are you going to receive Rodríguez Zapatero, if he is not going to put…”. Of course, the right, Aznar, reigned more than governed in Spain and Néstor said “I am going to receive him anyway, even if I don’t have a vote, I am going to receive him anyway” he said, and he received him.

And well, and then José Luis in a wonderful election in which it was practically impossible for the PSOE to win was the president of the Spanish government. He trusted a lot in his intuitions, in his feelings. What do I want to say with this? That in 2003 the construction of a new Argentina began. And it is not a narrative nor foundational, nor as they want to tell us as if everything… and if a different Argentina began because besides that man together with Lula in Brazil, simultaneously, decided to pay the IMF so that never again, so that never again it could direct the economy in Argentina.

Many things came, the recovery of the AFJP, the recovery of our flagship oil company, YPF, social policies, satellites… Look, and at the same time throughout the region, the governments of Rafael Correa in Ecuador with his Citizen Revolution, Lula in Brazil with the PT, Evo Morales with the Movement Towards Socialism, Hugo Chávez in Venezuela, dear Hugo! When I went to Europe they asked me “but the populisms there, the chavismo…”. Pepe, the Broad Front in Uruguay, Fernando Lugo in Paraguay, it was the virtuous decade. I do not say it. There is a book by Thomas Piketty that says it was the moment when economic and social inequality was most reduced in the region. This is the key, this is the key.

They do not persecute us because we are populists or from the left, or from the right, or from below and from above. No. Because we equalize societies, because social justice, the right of workers to actively participate in the Gross Product of what they produce. The Military Party when it overthrew the Peronist government of ’76 under the pretext of the guerrilla. Because I want to tell all those who did not live through that time that the guerrilla had already been militarily defeated in our regions. They had had previous political defeats and then were militarily defeated. They were the excuse for what came next, which was the entire neoliberal wave.

But I want to say with this that in the same way at that time workers participated in 51% of the country’s Gross Economic Product. The same, exactly the same participation they had in December 2015. For 12 and a half years, for 12 and a half years we were able to rebuild with a lot of effort, with… I don’t know if the best because that would be… but look, you saw what was built from 2015. From December 2015. This blessed “roadway trial” that begins, as all of you know have read, with a complaint in January 2016, in January 2016, of course there was a jurisdiction in Comodoro Py, all the complaints, the 600 and something complaints always fell into the hands of two judges. One who is no longer there, and I will not name him, and Judge Ercolini, the one from Lago Escondido, the judge from Lago Escondido. No, let’s not whistle.

And fundamentally it starts there, it had already begun in Brazil with Lula, the stage of lawfare. What is lawfare? What the Military Party was to the popular governments of the 20th century in the first half of the 20th century in Latin America, lawfare is to the national, popular, and democratic governments of the 21st century. Exactly the same. Exactly the same. And something begins to be built… look, in these electoral days that are running in Argentina one can collect wonderful phrases. Eh, because, from that construction that began from the new wave of neoliberalism that began in December 2015 in Argentina, which also began later in Ecuador, which began with the impeachment of Dilma in Brazil, they begin to build the theory that they stole everything, took everything, they are in debt, we had to go back into debt, we had to bring back, we contracted 100 billion dollars of debt to pay their debt.

Of course, they forget the things they said. I want to remember some phrase. Perhaps if we can… the first, from Nicolás Dujovne, an Economy Minister, José Luis, Economy Minister who, finally, with the previous government, we ended up in the IMF; he said when he took office as Minister “Argentina had very low levels of indebtedness, both at the government level, and at the level of companies, and at the level of families.”

A few days ago, one of the candidates of the opposition force, which governs the city, said that when Macri took office in 2015, when asked if they were going to lift the capital controls, the capital controls are the figure that does not allow anyone to buy all the dollars that… that was… that we took as an administrative measure in 2012, and it was 2500 dollars per month. Now it is 200 dollars. “It was different,” he said in 2015, “there were reserves in the Central Bank.”

Look, eh, I didn’t say it, the Chief of Government of the City said it, candidate. You cannot do the same thing that was done in 2015 because in 2015 when Mauricio arrived there were reserves in the Central Bank. And just yesterday reading La Nación, you saw that always from the newspaper that I bring you news… no, you have to read, you have to read everyone and listen to everyone.

A recognized radical economist, when asked how they are going to deal with the salaries that are so lagging today, the real wages, how they are going to do it if there has to be fiscal and monetary adjustment. Well, it is that "unlike in 2015, today real wages are lagging." Well, well, well, so what? Let's see, let's see.

In 2015 there was no debt, neither corporate, nor state, nor family debt, nor was the International Monetary Fund present, I add that. Moreover, there were reserves in the Central Bank, which is why the currency controls could be lifted. And also, real wages were not lagging, I add: not only were they not lagging, but in dollars they were the highest in Latin America.

So, guys, if there was no debt, there were reserves in the Central Bank, and real wages were not lagging, can you tell me what you did in four years that left the country in tatters in 2019?

It is that, as someone said, "you can fool everyone for a time and you can fool some people all the time, but you cannot fool everyone all the time," and this is what is happening. That is why, after 2015, they immediately began to construct a narrative about "they had stolen a GDP." A GDP! They took the GDP with the International Monetary Fund, and we still do not know where it is!

This is to stigmatize, to convince, because they also said "they had convinced the Argentines," said a leader who later became president of the National Bank or the Central Bank, I don't remember, "they had convinced the Argentines that everyone could have a cell phone, that everyone could have a flat-screen television," this was essentially what they came to challenge, to convince that everything that had been achieved was the product of corrupt leaders who had stolen. Exactly that. Now, stigmatization also has, and this persecution also has another objective, it is not only to reimpose an economic model, but it has another great objective which is to discipline. To discipline! Who to discipline, José Luis? Who, Rafael? The leaders of the national and popular field, and they discipline them.

To discipline, to instill fear because who is going to dare again to, for example, undertake tasks like recovering the AFJP, or recovering YPF, or saying no to the Fund. No, no, no! This is not the task of one person, this is the task of a society and of popular, national, and democratic forces that must also organize themselves, with the conviction and with the same faith with which, just now José Luis said he has faith. Yes, I don't know if it will take one, two, or twenty years, but finally, finally the truth always comes to light. And perhaps we all have the feeling that it is all very unfair. And yes, it is very unfair, but it is more unfair because ultimately this Judiciary that pursues political leaders, in my case a former president. Well, these are the risks of politics, when one decides to play on one side, one knows it is not free. If you go with the others and with the media, you have no problems, they see you as blonde, beautiful, tall, with blue eyes, no problem. The problem is when one decides to play on the side of the interests of the people and of the great national majorities.

But, ultimately, we must not, because this judicial system, Baltazar, is not only used for this, because there are also deep segments and numerous segments of society that also suffer from the lack of a judicial system. And this neoliberalism that ultimately displaces the State allows the entry of the other great drama of our time, of our region, of our societies, which is drug trafficking. When the State disappears, this phenomenon of the narco has appeared that occupies the place of the State and, ultimately, they want to convince us that they are fighting against drug trafficking because kids or women who are involved in drug dealing are in prison. No, no, no. Look, if we have to fight against drug trafficking, first we have to dismantle the financial system that is the one that launders the drug money, the one that launders the drug money!

Let’s see if we are going to believe that bands with pompous names of illiterates are the ones who set up the engineering to launder the billions of drug money. Please, wake up everyone once and for all! So, it is also necessary to recover a judicial system not only for what may happen to political leaders committed to popular interests, but also to face the dramas of our time that we are living from drug trafficking to when they come for natural resources as well. This is necessary!

I am not interested, ultimately, if they are going to convict us, if they are going to disqualify me, if they are going to imprison me, I do not care! What matters to me fundamentally is that we rebuild a democratic and constitutional state in which the guarantees established by the Constitution are not just painted cardboard. This is what it is about, rebuilding a country like the one we once had, because it can be done, because we did it once and because Peronism did it in the last century. And because they also did it with the construction of the homelands or the great Latin American homeland in the 19th century. I loved that conjunction you made of San Martín with Evita, Rafael, I thought it was not only a literary finding but fundamentally a historical one, to articulate San Martín, I loved it, I clarify that with what you said about Rosita Campuzano, all those who… And, why, let’s see why. I explain to you why.

Because whenever they construct the heroes, it is supposed that the heroes are not men and women of flesh and blood, why? Because if we all realized that San Martín, that Belgrano were men and women like us, who had a boyfriend, or lover, or spouse, or did things that perhaps… Then it would fall apart, they have to denigrate you because if the hero is someone immaculate who is up there flying, almost like a saint and none of us is a saint, and therefore, no one feels worthy of emulating San Martín, but believe me that San Martín was a man like all of you, only that he had a lot of courage and a lot of love for the homeland. That is what is needed today and always, courage and love for the homeland! Thank you very much to all.