Launch of the Néstor Kirchner Justicialist School in La Plata

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

27 April 2023 · Launch of the Néstor Kirchner Justicialist School · Teatro Argentino de La Plata, La Plata, Argentina

Context
Fernández de Kirchner spoke at the launch of the Néstor Kirchner Justicialist School at Teatro Argentino de La Plata on April 27, 2023, delivering a political master class.
Main themes
Peronist political education, Argentine economic history, convertibility crisis, political analysis methodology, Néstor Kirchner legacy, past repeating in present, Justicialist School founding, 2003 presidential election anniversary, coalition government failure, political training vs technical training
Duration
~78 min
97th percentile
Words
9,305
97th percentile
Sentences
544
98th percentile
Readability
65
94th percentile
Grade
8.4
7th percentile
Syntax
2.73
16th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
36th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 68%62%
  • Institutional 14%13%
  • Ceremonial 9%8%
  • Social 7%6%
  • Geopolitical 2%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

544 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Thank you very much, it is a very special moment for me, as you can imagine, to be here in this space, in this place that has regained the splendor of its inauguration. The Ginastera room of the Teatro Argentino de La Plata is beautiful, Axel, beautiful, very nice!

And the truth is that I thought I was coming to give a master class, but it seems to me, Nicolás, colleagues, that it is going to be something more than a class… No, no, calm down, calm down! Don’t get all worked up, I’ve told you many times! I said it was going to be a master class, plus a little bit of life experience because today, exactly today, marks 20 years since we were in Santa Cruz. At this time, an hour ago, the electoral act had just closed and well, the first testimonies started to arrive and in an hour and a half we were celebrating having entered the possibility of a second round. And of course, due to the situation at the time, for the presidency of the Argentine Republic. We were there with Néstor…

But, I am interested in rescuing because in this circular Argentina, it is as if the present appears again, the past appears again here in the present. Today we are in a situation where figures, ideas, and events from the past seem to want to come back and settle in the present to condition it and also to condition the future. We are in that strange moment when the past becomes present and, perhaps, frustrates the future. That is why it is very important to generate spaces like this, like the School. The Justicialist School, which is not a school for technical training. It is a school for political training, for political analysis. Why? Because many times we find ourselves with technicians, intellectuals, who know everything, but perhaps understand nothing. And so, we must return to what we were. Here are colleagues who were militants with me, who are laughing in the second row, militants from Altri tempi, right? Altri tempi, very far away! Too far, given the years.

So, that is why I speak of life experience, and that day there in Santa Cruz, Néstor burst onto the national stage and then became president, son of an Argentina that shouted a year before the election, a year and four months before the election, “they all must go,” as the video says. Who had to leave and why? And this is what is happening today in the present. We have to, suddenly, that past is back in this present. And I will try to analyze, to think together with you without adjectives or qualifications, because one of the problems we have today in politics, in general in the Argentine Republic, our personal and daily dealings, not only in politics, in any social space is the excess of adjectivation and qualification. And when we start to adjectivate and qualify, well, positions are taken one way or another, then it becomes impossible to analyze. That is why I will try not to adjectivate or qualify. Who had to leave? Well, there was a government that had won the elections, it was the first experience of a coalition government in the Argentine Republic, in 1999 the Alliance, a coalition of political parties was constituted in the first experience of a coalition government in the Argentine Republic and during that government the explosion of convertibility occurred. Yesterday I heard someone on television whom I respect and care for, and who wrote a book that says “115 days to deactivate the bomb.” In reality, the bomb was never deactivated because the bomb exploded in the face of 40 million Argentines, it exploded in the squares, it exploded in unemployment and finally exploded in the seizure of fixed-term deposits, because convertibility ended as it began. This is in economic terms the convertibility that is good, because a 20-year-old kid, besides, probably doesn’t even know what the hell convertibility is. Well, convertibility, since we are in the School, we have to explain it, Nicolás, even if we seem a bit like Maestra Ciruela. Convertibility was an idea or a solution that occurred to a gentleman, who later became Minister of Economy, a gentleman with light eyes. No, no whistling, we are not going to name names or anything, because no… A gentleman with light eyes, who then has disciples, also with light eyes in the present who say he was the best minister. Now with more hair, that one was bald. I am not adjectivating, a bald man is a description, it is not a valuation, like tall, short, fat, thin. I am not adjectivating.

So, what was that convertibility? We were told that one peso was equal to one dollar, it was the dollarization of the economy, a not extreme dollarization of the dollar currency, but it was a dollar… This meant a very tough fiscal discipline, but fundamentally it meant that first all the fixed terms that were in the banks had to be captured and the quasi-fiscal deficit of the Central Bank, at that time was around 8 points. That was the Bonex plan. Bonex 89, I remember it very well because it was announced when I was in this city, in La Plata, with Néstor and with Máximo, Florencia had not yet been born. Look, eh, look at what history is, Florencia had not yet been born! And what happened? We were at my mother’s house, in the same house where my sister still lives today, in the kitchen watching television, we had rented a house during the month of January, a country house because we liked to come during the summer to spend time with family. And on television, the then Minister of Economy, Erman González, announced that no one would be able to withdraw their fixed-term deposits from the banks. There were millions of australes, we also had many australes. Néstor and I, at the bank, 89.

Well, I don’t even want to tell you the things Néstor said that night, I think it was the night of January 29, we had spent Christmas Eve and Christmas in Río Gallegos and as always we came to spend New Year’s in La Plata. That New Year’s, there was not even food, everything was closed. And that Bonex plan meant that when you went to the bank instead of giving you the money from your fixed term, they gave you a bond, it was paid later, only 10 years later, in 99. By virtue of that Bonex plan, later the gentleman with light eyes could announce the famous convertibility, a year and a bit later. This is the history of convertibility, which was sustained with the dollars that came from privatizations and when the dollars from privatizations ran out, with the dollars from the debt that the nation took so that the monetary base was backed by dollars, that did not last, obviously. It began, with the indiscriminate commercial opening, to destroy the entire industrial apparatus, to increase unemployment, as the prices of raw materials also fell at some point, I remember that in 1998, in the province of Santa Cruz, Néstor was already governor, the price of a barrel of oil reached 9 dollars. That is why one should never fall in love and believe that something is the salvation of everything, to believe that because we have Vaca Muerta we are going to be saved, because when one does not have added value and only produces raw materials, it is very subject to price and international volatilities. Well, I don’t want to overwhelm you. The point is that convertibility explodes and it explodes on another government, it does not explode on the government that created it, to God what is God’s and to Caesar what is Caesar’s. But the campaign of the Alliance had been “we will maintain convertibility” and convertibility exploded. And it ended as it began, with the seizure of all fixed terms, plus all deposits, it was allowed to withdraw, if I remember correctly, two hundred pesos a week, something like that. I don’t remember exactly how it was. The point is that, well, people went out into the streets, dead, violence, repression. This is the history of convertibility in the Argentine Republic. And it is the history of dollarization.

And I would also like to analyze this that is being discussed so much in Argentina today, which is dollarization, where they come to tell us that what failed years ago can today be the solution. When Néstor took office as president, unemployment was in double digits, with a 2 in front, he always said he had more unemployed than votes, he had received 22% of the votes. With Gross Product plummeting, this is the history of Argentina, commercial opening, deindustrialization, in short… And today, they come to propose exactly the same thing and we are all discussing what failed more than 20 years ago. And the leaders, this is the disciple of the gentleman with light eyes, and the leaders of the other political sector, of what is now the Alliance, which was once in government, were also the officials who at that time said “they all must go.” It is remarkable, it is remarkable! Because the Head of Government of the City was in charge of PAMI, he was part of the Sushi group along with the then Minister of Labor who had deducted 13% from retirees and workers. No whistling! It doesn’t help, because it separates us. These are objective data, absolutely objective data, he had deducted 13% from state workers and retirees. A gentleman who is also promoting himself as Head of Government of the City had been Minister of Economy, who lasted 10 days if I remember correctly, and was fired by the Franja Morada. Neither La Cámpora, which did not exist, nor Peronism! No, no, the Franja Morada when it proposed charging for public universities. That is, eliminating free university education in the Argentine Republic. Yes, these things happened, these things happened. Well, now they propose vouchers for education. It’s like it’s an eternal, a circular Argentina, in the characters, in the proposals, that is why spaces like this are important, for discussion, for training, where we can overcome the 20 minutes of Tik Tok, calling on young people to overcome the 20 minutes of Tik Tok and to think a little about what happened, because it is impossible to move forward in the present and in the future if we do not know where we come from. It is impossible! To finish with this topic of dollarization, because surely they will say that convertibility is not the same as dollarization, no of course, no, no, dollarization is much worse, because we got out of convertibility and look what happened. Imagine a country like Argentina, dollarized are, I believe, 14 countries, not countries. Only Ecuador, El Salvador, and Panama. Panama since 1900 for very special characteristics. And then, small archipelagos. Imagine a country in which there is a lack of monetary policy and exchange policy, a country where our main trading partners, for example Brazil and China, one day devalue the yuan or devalue the real and we do not have the monetary tool because we are with hard currency. Without monetary policy, without exchange policy and also depending on a currency of an economy, like that of the United States, which is absolutely competitive with Argentina. While the economy of Ecuador, for example, which has the highest GDP of those with dollarization, there is no other country in the world, is absolutely complementary to the United States for raw materials, for remittances, the same as El Salvador. Argentina has a competitive matrix with the productive matrix of the United States. Why? Look, there is a book that I always recommend, Torre, “A Season on the Fifth Floor,” where he tells when Machinea, at the time he was part of Sourrouille’s team, during President Alfonsín’s government. He went very happily to the United States with a formidable project under his arm, to privatize the entire Argentine petrochemical sector and the entire steel sector. And to ask, in return, at the World Bank for a loan of two billion dollars. He was absolutely convinced that they were going to give it to him, he went with a big package to privatize and to ask for two billion dollars, when he arrived in Washington and presented the project at the World Bank, the then president of the World Bank told him “no, look, this is not going to work.” But why? “Because the representative of the United States is going to oppose it,” but why? And because the steel and petrochemical sector of the United States competes with the steel and petrochemical sector of Argentina, they are competitive. We are an industrial country, with nuclear energy, with a developed sector, with an integration, imperfect there, in industrial matters, but really thinking that the problem of inflation, because besides the issue is that dollarization is presented as the answer and the solution to inflation, this is, at least, what one hears. And if we see what happens in Ecuador, please, the first slide.

Inflation does not stop because of dollarization, look, the upper line with an accumulated inflation of 355 in the period from 99 to 22 against an inflation of 75% in the United States. Inflation continues, worse not only that. The second slide, please, of Ecuador.

If you can see, this is the evolution of the debt from 2008 to 2021. Ecuador starts with a debt to GDP ratio of 24.62% and today it is at 62.28%. Why? Because since it does not issue currency, its currency is the dollar, when it goes into debt it has to do so through external borrowing; there is no possibility of having monetary policy, as we had, for example, during the COVID issue, where without access to capital markets, Argentina issued to meet the expenses related to vaccines, health, etc., etc. Of course, that issuance of 8 or 9 points of GDP causes an inflationary process, as happened all over the world, as it also happened in 2008 during the Lehman Brothers crisis. Because issuance, everything is related to everything, the issuance of the European central banks or the Federal Reserve, when it was to fund all the banks that went bankrupt due to mortgages in 2008, no one said a word, nothing! When it is issued for banks, it seems that it does not produce inflation.

So, I think it is good that this School can delve into these issues, discussing with colleagues and, fundamentally, going out to the streets to discuss, as we did in our time, everywhere, not only in the faculty, in the bar, in the bakery. Suddenly, the events are beautiful and we all love them, but let’s also replace that a bit with face-to-face discussions with colleagues and citizens, engaging in debate. Engaging in debate!

To conclude on this topic, because I am always very distrustful, you see? Women are very distrustful, culturally distrustful, we have been taught to be distrustful. But, what is going on then, why is there so much discussion about this, what do they want with this dollarization and so on? Reading an article a few days ago in Infobae, can we please put it up? That gentleman there, Emilio Ocampo, is the economist chosen by the political leader who is proposing dollarization in Argentina, that we have the same currency as the United States.

I took from the interview the part where he explains how he will do it without touching anyone's money, without taking anything from anyone, how he will replace the currency, the liabilities of the Central Bank, etc., etc. Without touching anything. And he says, "that’s why we created a vehicle outside of Argentina to which we transfer the assets and liabilities of the Central Bank," the Central Bank has liabilities and assets, "the FGS of Anses," ah! How? Oh well, the FGS of Anses, how do they want to transfer the Guarantee Fund of retirees? What does that Guarantee Fund for retirees have? Well, it has many bonds, but it has other things. Next, please.

There you can see, the FGS has equity participation, it has shares, a stake in the shares of the main Argentine companies: Banco Macro, Edenor, Gas Distributor, Termium, Consultatium, Transportadora, Mirgor, Endersa, Endesa, La Anónima, La Anónima! Molinos Agro, Molinos Río de la Plata, a digression on this, Molinos Río de la Plata, which we will see later when we talk about prices and economic concentration, Molinos Río de la Plata modified the company’s statute so that a director from the FGS could not sit on the board, of course, we judicialized that, that was during my second term and I believe that the Judiciary still has not resolved that. Transener, Grupo Financiero Galicia, Pampa Energía, Banco Patagonia, Camuzzi, Telecom, Grupo Clarín, Cablevisión. Yes, why? Why does it have all this? Because during the time when the resources of the workers were privatized in the AFJP, many of those resources were lent to the main Argentine companies. Was it wrong? No, it was not wrong, it is a capital market, it is good to have a capital market that can lend. But did you see any headline in any newspaper or on TN saying "look, they took the retirees' money and lent it to Banco Macro, to Edenor, to Molinos"? No, no, no, not at all, that was never known. But this is the capital, they want to take this capital to a trust abroad, for what? For cheap repurchase of shares at bargain prices, this is, it seems to me, some of the intentions. Look, the truth is that during convertibility not only did the assets of those who had money in banks explode, no, not only that, the main Argentine companies were on the verge of bankruptcy. That is why the figure of Asymmetric Pesification was created and at the same time the countdown that prevented foreign companies, for example, a company like Clarín, let’s take an example, had a partner who was an American bank. With the brutal devaluation, the American bank was left with two cents, or with two dollars, it was left with everything. This happened in the Argentine Republic due to the effect of convertibility and when it collapsed. And the Argentine Parliament passed laws like the Defense of Cultural Goods, the modification of the Bankruptcy Law so that Argentine companies would not go bankrupt, those congresses that are often so denigrated, right? But this is the reality of what happened. So, when these theories that have been very harmful to society as a whole resurface, the truth is that one says, is it possible that 20 years later we are discussing what failed and what exploded in Argentina 20 years ago? What is happening to us, compatriots? What is happening to us that it is like a circular Argentina that cannot move on and keeps returning to its ghosts and its old failures? Please, I am not saying that we are right, but please do not try to convince me that we have to go back to solve this present and the future! No, please! No, please!

However, there is also a point of contact with that past, because the situation at that time, not in terms of economic model, let’s say it clearly, 22% unemployment, Gross Product falling, today we have other problems. Today we have growth but with low wages and we are facing, I spoke about this in the Master Class we gave in Chaco last year, when I said that we are facing a new phenomenon of real and genuine economic growth, but poor income distribution and for the first time, dependent workers are poor. This had never happened to us, this is one of the new challenges we face. But the truth is that after the pandemic, economic activity grew and the jobs created were more precarious, more informal, with a lot of self-employment, it is not the quality of employment that was generated before. The model is not the same, it has absolutely nothing to do with that model that generated unemployment, deindustrialization, now there is again a process of generation… The production of goods played a leading role in economic growth, in fact, economic activity, to be honest, was 0.4% higher than in 2015 and private consumption was 1.5% higher than in 2015. But then what happens? This happens. What I also said here in La Plata in 2020, in the unique state Diego Armando Maradona when Sergio said, and rightly so, "that the country was going to grow" and I said behind him, be careful, of course we are going to grow a lot, but be careful, let’s align prices, wages, exchange rates, because if not, the growth will be taken by four smart ones. That is what is happening now, this is the issue. This is the issue!

And if there is a point of contact, it has to do with everything. Everything is related to everything, as I always say. There is a point of contact with that past and it is a presence that we, and when I speak of us, I speak as a process and political project, that starting in 2005 was able, by paying the IMF, to initiate a virtuous cycle in which workers returned to participate in income distribution with more than 50%. Exactly 51.8%. And the truth is, for them to come and talk to us about the last 20 years from the opposition. The truth is that it hurts us, it hurts us because I believe that there is no good Argentine who can ignore the burden that the return of the IMF to the Argentine Republic means for society as a whole. I believe that no one, with intellectual honesty, can claim that we are facing a dilemma and a brutal problem. That IMF that Perón always rejected and that entered the country precisely after the coup that overthrew General Perón and that settled in our country, was the protagonist of the worst moments experienced during democracy in terms of economics and conditionalities. And conditionalities. And I also say that linked to the serious problem we have today, the great problem that Argentine society has today, politics, the State, businessmen, workers, intellectuals, artists, and that is inflation. I say and continue to maintain that this agreement, that agreement signed with the IMF is inflationary.

Because it is a canned policy. Canned that is applied as a monothematic recipe to all countries. And I would like you to put up a little graph of… There it is. Look: the agreement with the IMF is inflationary. Look at the moment the agreement is signed and see how inflation skyrockets from the signing of the agreement when tools are lost and then we have that the devaluation rate has to accompany inflation in a bimonetary economy like ours where the main cause of the price surge is the variation of the dollar. It is something that the IMF technicians cannot grasp because, I also admit, it is difficult to understand us Argentines. Let’s concede a little that we are very special. I already told you in the master class in Chaco. That famous Nobel Prize winner who said that there are four types of economies: developed, underdeveloped, Japan, and Argentina. This is the case. So they want to apply canned policies that, moreover, not only in Argentina, in reality, IMF policies have not worked anywhere. There is no successful model. Look: and here I remember something else. Do you know who was the one who most supported convertibility and put the then President and applauded him at an IMF assembly? Well, the author of convertibility. That was indeed supported by the IMF. Look how we ended up: a constitutional government blew up, five presidents in a week, dead in the streets of Buenos Aires. Repression, misery, pain. So I think it is necessary to review those clauses. That agreement. They tell me. They say, right? that in the IMF there are hawks and doves. Hawks and doves? Just like here in the opposition, we are full… There are hawks and doves everywhere. It is hard for me to understand the logic of the hawks and the doves because since I am a penguin, I am a bird but… And yes, because you see that hawks and doves fly alone. They are solitary, individualistic. Penguins are all collective. You see that we are all together, we go here, there, we are very collective. So it is hard for me… it is hard for me.

It is true. These birds, the penguin is also a bird but it is a collective bird, a group bird, going here and there, all together. The others are… the dove flies alone, only the falcon and alone, dear, alone we do nothing and never get anywhere. We have to learn this too. I then say that it seems there are falcons and doves and then suddenly they think that… some falcons say: “no, what they have to do, what they have to fulfill…” Look: the graph really clearly shows that the result has not been good. Later we will also talk about the instruments that could not be used until intervention occurred this week in the foreign exchange market using reserves, an instrument that was also prohibited by the signing of the agreement. But focusing on the issue, the big battle horse was the fiscal deficit. Last year the fiscal deficit target was exceeded. There was overcompliance. In other words, it was fulfilled more than what the fund required and yet inflation skyrocketed anyway. Why? Because inflation in Argentina is tied to the scarcity or abundance of dollars. In a bi-monetary economy like ours, with the… I have explained it several times but it is always good to do it again. The external restriction, the stop and go, always that thing that well… the industry needed dollars, perhaps the ones produced by the field were not enough, then that tension was produced, a devaluation would come, stop and go. To that historical external restriction of Argentina was added, for multiple reasons, a societal inclination to choose the dollar as a reserve currency, as a savings currency. And in many cases also as a unit of payment, especially in large sums or in certain types of operations. This produces stress in the economy that leads, if there is no proper management, to problems. But going back to the IMF, it is necessary to review but, not to avoid payment. No one says that we should not pay beyond the discussion of the surcharges, etc… What we want, fundamentally, is for the conditionalities to be reviewed and I believe that also, in the future, it will be necessary to discuss that the sums paid to the IMF be tied as a percentage to the trade surplus. Because we, the only dollars we produce are the dollars from the trade surplus. So, when we face a problem like the one now, like the drought which was very serious… We also had a drought, not as severe as this one but serious in 2008. We lost 10 million heads of cattle between 2008 and 2010 approximately. But it is clear that it is necessary to tie it to the trade surplus. And why not the fiscal deficit? Look: I am going to… you remember that in the master class in Río Negro I showed… let’s see please if you can put the second… You remember that I showed the countries that had a fiscal surplus… Well, you remember there were five. That talk I gave on March 10. Is today April 27, right? Well. A month and a half ago there were five countries, in all the countries listed by The Economist magazine, only five countries, starting with the United States, Russia, China, the most important.

Only five countries had a fiscal surplus. In a month and a half, two fell. Game over. Only three remain. Israel is out, it has a fiscal deficit. Chile is out, it has a fiscal deficit. Who remains with a fiscal surplus in the world? Well, Norway, self-sufficient in energy, Denmark the same and Saudi Arabia. The rest all have deficits.

But if one goes to the second, to the other image and also sees inflation listed. You see that in the other countries, despite inflation having grown, it has not become the problem that it has in Argentina.

The other issue that could… The fiscal deficit is clearly not the cause of inflation. Furthermore, if we talk about the fiscal deficit because normally when the fiscal deficit is discussed they start: “what the state spends, that the state spends more, that it spends less, that this and that.” Do you know how much is spent, and we are going to put it in parentheses, in what could be called social spending? From here I see the Minister of Social Development. So how much in Potenciar plans, how much in AUH, how much in the Alimentar card, how much in Pro.Gre.Sar? 1.9 of GDP. Do you know how much is spent in terms of exemptions, broken rates, exemptions, people and sectors that do not pay taxes or pay half of the taxes? 4.6 of GDP. 4.6 of GDP. In other words: I remember that the one who was president of my block always complained about the checks that those who have a plan receive or the checks they receive from the state. I complain more about those who have money and do not pay taxes. This is much more serious. Look: if we were to review the tax expenditure that is in the national budget, tax promotions, tax exemptions, broken rates, we would not have a fiscal deficit. We would not have a fiscal deficit. Hello, how are you? Hello, how are you? But also, if we go a little bit and scrape a little more tax-wise. Did you see that businesspeople always go on television and complain about all the taxes they have to pay, that profits, that the rate? The profits rate is 35%, right doctor? It is from the AFIP that is why I ask you if I am not saying something out of tone. 35%. Do you know how much the large companies pay of the 35 rate on the income tax? Guess. 2.45. But how? You will tell me. An employee in the fourth category who is subject, perhaps due to the level of income to pay income tax, if he has no deductions, pays 35 month by month. If he has deductions he can be around 16%. 2.45 the largest companies in the country. But how can that be? Oh yes, I will tell you how that can be. First: recognition by law of the adjustment for inflation. In other words, when you go to the supermarket and pay the owner of the supermarket, you pay in cash or with a card. Either he collects in 30 days or collects at that moment. But he has to pay the profit on what he sells to you today, only next year. He only pays it next year but, he took the money now. What does the inflation adjustment recognized by law do? When he goes to pay the following year he discounts all the inflation. They deflate the profits for inflation and index the expenses. I think we need to start yes, to ask, yes… sincerely.

The second mechanism that is used is to recognize, as a loss, the expenses, also indexed to the following year. With which. Look at what a phenomenal business? They deflate the profits and index the expenses. This way it is impossible for you to lose. I also want to be a businessman. And this is not a criticism of businesspeople but, we need to sit at a table seriously to talk about these things to see how much each one puts in. To see how much each one puts in. Because if the one who collects, which is the state to take care of investments in education, health, infrastructure, etc… deflates the profits and indexes… There will be a chronic fiscal deficit. So I am absolutely convinced that it is necessary to sit down and also simplify tax-wise. Perhaps we have over a hundred taxes that could be eliminated some that demand more paper and worker expenses than what is effectively collected. But seriously to sit down. Enough of the slogan of the fiscal deficit. Politicians line up to go to the plenaries of businesspeople to tell them how much they are going to hit the people, how many employees they are going to lay off, how much they are going to lower… This is no longer valid. It is not serious and it is not sustainable in political terms.

Look: yesterday I was reading… someone sent me an article and everyone competes to see who is worse and who is going to adjust more. But do they really believe there is a viable Argentina like the one they want to create? And I was looking at an article from the Head of Government of the City that said: “there must be a brutal economic deregulation like Cavallo’s.” What are they saying? But what do they want to do with the country and with society? I believe we need to have a discussion without adjectives but, with objective and concrete numbers of what is happening. But when one goes to inflation and also sees, for example… the installed capacity as well.

Because another of the issues, the fiscal deficit is not inflation… The other issue is supply and demand that as there is a lot of consumption the installed capacity is collapsing and therefore there are increases. It is one of the issues that are also discussed from liberal ideas. Well, there is what the occupation was when I gave the talk last year. Those are all the industrial blocks of the Republic of Argentina. Well, with respect to February 23 which is the last measurement, only three blocks increased the use of installed capacity, all the others reduced it. However, prices increased. There is oil, Vaca Muerta obviously increased strongly, substances and chemical products and the automotive industry. In other words: it is not due to the fiscal deficit, it is not because we do not have installed capacity and therefore investment is needed and that is why it is not invested. Neither. So when one sees what happened during the week, during this week in the Republic of Argentina, one begins to notice that the problem is elsewhere. Because the dollar moved and prices moved. This means that it is neither the fiscal deficit, nor supply and demand and then we will talk at the end about prices and how prices are finalized in the Republic of Argentina and if the markets are so competitive when it comes to setting prices. This week we had and still today what has been called currency runs. Please the next one.

This is the history of currency runs in the Republic of Argentina from 1972 to 2014. You can see the persistence which is the last column is given, fundamentally, by the times in which the run lasts. Well, the run… to me, of course, outside of Alfonsín’s which was strong too. We had six runs in the first term and five in the second. And why? But no one found out. How come so many currency runs? Two issues: why didn’t they find out? Because they did not impact prices with this madness of “I close, that there is none” that they store. First because the market, the Central Bank intervenes in the management of the exchange rate. This could not be done until this week when the decision was made to do so because the agreement with the Fund prohibited the Central Bank from intervening in the foreign exchange market to prevent a run. It is prohibited by the agreement with the Fund. Part of the discussions that the previous minister had were not with me nor because of me. They were precisely because of this situation of the Central Bank that did not intervene not only here but in other situations like, for example, sitting on the reserves because the other issue is, not only to intervene in the foreign exchange market but to be able to do so because the Central Bank has reserves. Look that they hit me, they ran and we also did not have access to international markets. But with the reserves, sitting on the reserves… Yes, sitting on the reserves, with the management of the exchange rate, with the regulation, we were able to quell the currency run. No, it is not about one person. It is necessary to rebuild government programs. It is necessary that it no longer depends on one person.

Look: the issue of… We had reserves, of course, especially those that we could also sit on in the second term when the regulation was established that we will now see the problem that the exchange regulation also brings. Because there is no perfect solution, it is not that you choose between the best and the worst. When you are in government, normally, at least in the Republic of Argentina, you always have to choose between the least bad. I wish the rulers had the possibility to choose between the good and the bad. Now, we have to know that when we make a decision and face interests, they confront us. But these are the rules of the game. These are the rules of the game.

Look: during the second term. If one looks, and speaking a bit about foreign direct investment, which is said to be very good. And it is very good that foreign direct investment comes. But of course, foreign direct investment also remits profits. Obviously, and it is fine that it remits profits. No one is against that. If one looks at history, Eduardo Basualdo explains this very well in his latest book… If one looks at the history of what it means for a dollar to enter. I am talking about dollars that come in through foreign direct investment, not dollars for financial speculation. No. Dollars that come from foreign companies that come to invest in the country. To put the dollar in. Well, between the year 1930 and the year 1975, throughout the entire period, for every dollar that came in from foreign direct investment, three dollars were remitted abroad in terms of profitability. Between 1975 and 1985, for every dollar of foreign direct investment, 1.68, almost 1.70 dollars were remitted in profits. If one studies the period from 2003 to 2019. That is: our three governments plus Macri's government. If one looks at all four government periods, the surplus is approximately 6 billion dollars between foreign direct investment and outflows. But do you know where the most significant inflow occurred, the most important surplus between the dollar that came in and the dollar that went out as profit? In the period between 2012 and 2015, when there was regulation and what was popularly called the "cepo" came in. And that is regulation and exchange administration. This is what happened. If one, for example, takes only Néstor's government, my first one, and Macri's, the balance is a deficit of 821 million dollars. 7.1 billion dollars due to regulation. What did we do? It is not that we took away the profits. We forced them to reinvest the profits in the Argentine Republic and now we should, we should… because we had a trade surplus of 45 million dollars between December 2019 and… 45 billion dollars. But a very important part went to pay the private debt of private companies. That money or those dollars should not have left. The argument… “but you can't let private companies default.” Do you honestly believe that an Argentine company that obtains a dollar loan abroad is given it abroad? Or is it a loan from the companies themselves or is it a loan that is leveraged by funds abroad? Who is going to lend billions of dollars if they are not backed by a guarantee abroad? What happens is that then they pay with the dollars that should be dedicated to industry to sustain economic activity to pay debt. Of course, it could have been avoided. Surely some would have gotten angry, but, well… This is the problem of wanting to govern and please everyone. In the end, you end up angering everyone.

I want to… and I am talking about exchange regulation not as a virtue… let that be clear. I do not speak of regulation and exchange administration as a virtue and as the solution or the panacea, look, that discovered gunpowder or the hole in the mate. No, we have not discovered the hole in the mate. Simply. Look at that, I already presented it in Chaco. The previous one, the one about exchange rate gaps.

The green means formation of assets abroad. What does that mean? People who take dollars out of the Argentine Republic and form assets abroad. Most are not fully declared because many times they are the result of tax evasion and the blue are the periods of gap. Look. When there was no regulation, they formed assets abroad. When there is regulation, assets abroad fall but, the exchange gap arises. And when the exchange gap arises. Let's go to the other…

There we have that when the gap is too large… we end up with a gap… there it is very clear, with a gap of 38% in the financial markets. And in the blue, which is not so important, 50%. Totally managed but, it is not the best. Why? Because it is produced from that or it is directly incentivized and deepened because in reality we have always had the problem of over-invoicing of imports and under-invoicing of exports… When the gap grows, this problem of over-invoicing and under-invoicing is exacerbated. And the other problem we also had is that during our management, especially in the second term in which the workers of the Argentine Republic had the highest salary in dollars in the Argentine Republic. They also chose to dollarize. It is not a criticism, it is a description of the problems. And this also brought demand, hence the famous cepo that was 2500 dollars per month. Almost Disneyland. But the things they told me for that 2500 dollars per month that could be bought. Then they are at 200.

So the problem is that when there is no regulation we have a very significant formation of assets abroad. And when there is regulation we have the gap and everything it generates. And all because? Because of the de facto dollarization that exists in Argentina. And so when I maintain that it is necessary to sit down all the political forces… not to see if there will be labor flexibility because surely some will think one way, others will think another, or public education if you want it free or not free. No, no, no, I am talking about this. I do not want to agree on everything else but, we need to have an agreement on this so that the country functions normally and is not a struggle every election. And it is not a drama every exchange movement in the Argentine Republic. Above all, all this is aggravated because we were twelve and a half years managing the country but, the Fund was not there. The IMF was not there. We had freedom in the tools, in the tools to govern and, in addition to that, we were reducing debt. The problem arises from the year 2016.

In 2016 and 2017, Argentina was the country that most indebted itself with international private investment funds, the country that most indebted itself. When they came here, as they had no money to pay back - this is the story - we went back to the Fund. What happened was criminal, really. But it happened and here we are, and we have to address this issue. But then I think we must also address a structure in the Argentine Republic regarding price formation that is far from what liberal theories say. I love to see them on television when they say "no because competition, markets are transparent and they should be left alone." Let's see, let's see… What does liberal theory say? How are competitive markets? They are very atomized markets, that is, a lot of supply, very diverse. One can choose Juan, Pedro, Andrés, I choose this, I choose the other, very diversified. Second condition, homogeneous products. That is, Pirulo milk is the same as Fangulo milk but I like this one more and I buy the other. In addition, all factors have perfect information and there is free entry of everything, everything circulates freely. Well, this would not be happening in Argentina. Let's go to the second…

Look, there we have the top twenty companies, those twenty companies that appear there - because we need to start talking with names and surnames - Unilever, Mastellone, Coca Cola, Sancor, Danone, Molinos, because otherwise it seems like the prices are being marked up by Cristina, Nicolás… no, no. These twenty companies account for 74 percent of the revenue of what you buy on the shelf. Well, atomized, as they say, the market would not exist. In some cases, like in the case of milk, for example, milk in cartons, which is what the popular sectors consume, 90 percent is produced by a single company, La Serenísima, Mastellone. Just one. The pasta, put the pasta that arrived, the company Molinos, after having bought the unit from Mondelez, controls 50 percent of the pasta market in the Republic of Argentina. Between Arcor and Mondelez, 60 percent in cookies. Bimbo, which is from the Mexicans, 80 percent of the bread. Coca Cola, well, we already know. The beer is the same. And in other widely used inputs like polyethylene, Dow Chemical, one hundred percent. Flat steel, one hundred percent Techint. And we could continue listing the degree of concentration of the economy. And in the face of these concentrated sectors - concentration is a global phenomenon, this is not criticism, it is description - in the face of increasingly concentrated economic powers, a policy, a State that is increasingly fragmented, more divided, and more confrontational. Who are the politicians going to make believe today, whatever their origin, the idea, that they will be able to control what concentrated economic power does, and that they will solve the problems of Argentines, in this state of affairs. Don’t mess with me. Don’t mess with me anymore with those fantasies. Here the only one, and I want (no, no, president, no)… look, it is no coincidence that the only political leader who has been condemned, banned, disqualified, and attempted to be assassinated is one, and I don’t want to be self-referential. Those clowns who go around saying that "the caste is afraid," what are they afraid of? if nothing has ever happened to you, brother. Don’t come to me with that you think we are afraid of you, where do we have fear? What shamelessness! It’s incredible, persecuted, my children, they wanted to kill me… They don’t want to investigate those who wanted to kill me and have obvious commitments with business sectors in the Republic of Argentina. I am afraid, you know why… because my grandchildren might grow up in such an unjust, inequitable country, that’s what I’m afraid of. I have already lived, I have already given what I had to give, I have already lived. I fear for the young people, I fear for the kids, because there is too much cowardice, there is too much hypocrisy, and this is what is happening in the Republic of Argentina. And I want, finally, to say that it is necessary to have a program again in the Republic of Argentina, we need to create a government program where we discuss these things we have been talking about today. We should not fight, and it is not a program where we make faith, anti-capitalist and nothing of the sort. I repeat what I have said many times, today capitalism is no longer an ideology, it is simply the most efficient way of producing goods and services. Look, moments are coming in the world where we will have to be prepared for great changes. The big discussion will not be whether capitalism yes or capitalism no, but who leads the production processes to not harm the environment so much, to have greater equality. If we leave it to the markets or the State, politics will take the lead again. This is what Perón said. Look at the evolution of this financial capitalism detached from reality, who is the richest man in the world today, do you know? When capitalism meant that money, to reproduce itself, had to go through the circuit of production of goods and services, and not just in finance, the richest man could be Henry Ford, because he sold cars and was technologically innovative. Later it was the owner of oil, Paul Getty, because it was energy. Then it was Bill Gates because it was technological innovation, technology. Until recently it was Elon Musk, who is also technology and all that. Do you know who is today the richest man in the world? A Frenchman, Bernard Arnault, who owns the luxury brands that he sells to the rich of the world. He is the owner of Gucci, Christian Dior, Tiffany, all the luxury brands. This means a modification and a deepening of income concentration; nothing good can come out of that in the end. And we are going to have a discussion about this in the coming world. A different world is coming. Look, when one sees that the Saudis shake hands with the Iranians and in the middle there is a Chinese, start to open your eyes, something is happening. Something is happening that we are not seeing. And please… because tomorrow, Clarín will put "Cristina, the Iranians with China, it was discovered… the plot was with China, the Iranians and the Saudis, no, please"… they will surely set up a new case against me at any moment. No, it’s the new world. The world fell with the crash of 1930, when the gold standard fell and was replaced by the dollar standard. Yesterday the minister was signing with China the exchange, our main trading partner, China, and Brazil. Yesterday the minister was signing with China the agreement so that everything we import from China we pay with yuan and we can use the SWAP we have, which was granted when I was president, after we signed the strategic agreement with Xi Jinping in 2015. So I think it is necessary to open our eyes as Nicolás said. New things are happening and are going to happen, we have new problems. We cannot have such an old mindset, to keep discussing nonsense. We cannot have such an old mindset, the new generations deserve that we have an open mind and that we help them to use this (cell phone) as we used to use the dictionary, as we used to use books, because it is true that there is a modification. We should not deny it, we should use it; we should use the things and the instruments of technology to help a society build a better future. Believe me that I have and feel towards our country, towards our Homeland, an infinite love as I know millions and millions of Argentines feel. And I believe we have the obligation to have discussion and debate. But, first, when I told the comrades in Avellaneda to take out the marshal's baton, I thought it was good but it is not to hit another comrade or another comrade over the head. Please keep that very clear. Do not use the baton to hit another comrade or another comrade over the head but, precisely, to help think about a different society, a different country, and see how each of us can contribute to a better future. Believe me that we need a government program, we need to see how we are going to manage our resources. Chile has just presented a strategic plan for lithium, we need to know what we are going to do with lithium, if we are going to declare it a strategic resource and form an association with private entities, with provinces that manage the resources. We also need to know how we are going to manage what will come from the inauguration of the Néstor Kirchner gas pipeline with Vaca Muerta. That Vaca Muerta that we recovered in 2012, when we decided to recover hydrocarbon sovereignty. But we also need to know that there are no miraculous salvations. I told you at the beginning of the talk that in 1998 the price of a barrel of oil fell to 9 dollars. Let’s not believe that because we have Vaca Muerta, it will save us or that lithium will save us. What will save us is work, technology, innovation, taking care of resources, generating income distribution that reproduces a fairer and more equitable society. That is why I want to congratulate all the members of this table and other comrades who I know have participated in the development of this fantastic idea that is the Justicialist Training School. I believe it is needed, it is not that we justicialists, Peronists or Kirchnerists have the reason, but it is a perspective. I want you to understand our perspective without telling us that it is our fault, that 70 years, you know it is not true. You know that today the main problem we have is that brutal indebtedness that they have left us. We are not going to tell you 24 hours a day either but, please, a little more intellectual honesty from everyone when discussing the problems of Argentines. Thank you very much.

BRIEF WORDS ON THE OUTDOOR STAGE

Hello. How are you? Thank you. Thank you very much to all the comrades who came tonight to the Teatro Argentino, so dear to our… to our memory and to the things we lived here. I wanted to thank all of you and well… you surely have been listening to what we have been sharing, reflecting, saying, and living because politics is not only about saying, it is also about living. And living means doing all the things of life in politics. Not only when we are at an event or a mobilization. Politics is everything. When we are at school, in line at the bakery, at the stadium. We need to debate compatriots, comrades, we need to debate. We need to go down to discuss, to fight for ideas, to fight for the homeland. To fight for history and for memory.

The truth is that this is what we want to do and that is why I came today to support the comrades who had the fantastic idea of creating this Néstor Kirchner Justicialist School. Really a great tribute to who was my life partner and my best friend. Thank you very much to all of you. I love you all very much. Thank you.