Inauguration of the Microstadium President Néstor Kirchner in Quilmes

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

27 April 2024 · Inauguration of the Microstadium President Néstor Kirchner · Microstadium President Néstor Kirchner, Quilmes, Argentina

Context
Fernández de Kirchner spoke at the inauguration of the Microstadium President Néstor Kirchner in Quilmes on April 27, 2024, honoring her late husband while critiquing current economic policies.
Main themes
Anarcho-capitalist experiment, suspension of public works, fiscal deficit and surplus debate, privatization policies, Kirchner legacy and tribute, Peronist governance record, labor and tax reform opposition, Argentine economic history, infrastructure investment, critique of Milei administration
Duration
~72 min
97th percentile
Words
8,594
97th percentile
Sentences
602
99th percentile
Readability
67
96th percentile
Grade
7.3
2nd percentile
Syntax
2.65
10th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
28th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 51%46%
  • Social 17%16%
  • Institutional 16%15%
  • Ceremonial 14%12%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

602 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Well, thank you very much. Thank you very much and welcome to everyone. Congratulations Mayra because this comes with congratulations first, and gratitude afterwards. Congratulations because there is no better way to remember and honor my life partner than with management, with work, and with deeds. So, congratulations. And gratitude as well (this is a bit more personal) gratitude on my behalf and on behalf of my children for having remembered my partner. I also want to thank the mayor of Avellaneda, my comrade Ferraresi, who just a few hours ago inaugurated the CCK in Isla Maciel. Thank you very much also on behalf of my children for having inaugurated that work, a replica. It must be quite a bit smaller than the original CCK.

The truth is that when I received the invitation from Mayra, I… I don’t like to come to places where there are things of his. It’s strong and it’s difficult. Well, what can I explain? But that same night I heard the President (let’s not whistle or boo, I ask you please). I heard the President in a national broadcast and the truth is that I decided to come here, to reflect on this particular moment that Argentina is experiencing and what I have called the anarcho-capitalist experiment and the useless sacrifice to which our people are being subjected. Why do I say this? Mayra just told us the story of this place, which was a Bicentennial Work suspended with the arrival of Macri’s government in 2015, then restarted again and today re-inaugurated.

Today there are 2,308 public works throughout the country, suspended far and wide. 119 works paralyzed in national universities across the country. So I say, exactly 21 years ago, I was still in Río Gallegos. We didn’t know the results but I feel as if we were in the game of the goose and had gone back to the starting point again. Why do I say this? I want today’s reflection to not come from dogmatism or ideology. What I am going to tell, what I am going to compare, what I am going to reflect on is empirical. Absolutely: we lived it. It’s not ideological.

Honestly, I don’t believe in this right, left thing. In Argentina, reality has never been explained from the right or from the left. They are categories of thought foreign to our history, foreign to reality. They come from the dominant countries, from the colonizers, or colonized. So, it is difficult to unravel what happens to us from the same categories of thought. But the truth is that when I heard, for example, congratulating for the public deficit of the first quarter and… well, it turns out that you didn’t pay CAMMESA, the energy, when you didn’t pay for public works, you didn’t pay what you owe to the provinces, you didn’t pay what you owe to the universities… It’s like if you at home, after not having paid for electricity, gas, water, maintenance fees, rent, the lady who works, the nanny, say “I have a surplus.” No brother, you don’t have a surplus. It’s not true. It’s not true. Look at all that you owe, where is the surplus from? No. You don’t have a surplus. This surplus that has no basis and that, moreover, raises the fiscal deficit. Be careful… I don’t want you to say that I wasn’t congratulating those who have, no, no, no. But to believe that in the Argentine Republic the problem is the fiscal deficit is to not understand Argentina, the economy, and the world. Of all the countries in the world, only three (three) have a fiscal surplus. Until recently there were two: Denmark and Norway. Now Australia has been added.

Do you know which country has the largest fiscal deficit in the world? The United States. Of course, they have the dollar printing machine and a few aircraft carriers, so - between the dollar printing machine and a few aircraft carriers - yes… you can afford to have a fiscal deficit and pass it on to everyone else in the world. Obviously, but well… We didn’t come to make a nationalist apology or anything like that, but the curious thing about all this is that they want to present to us - 21 years after the Argentina we received on April 27, 2003 - the same policies. On Monday, the famous “Framework Law” will be discussed in the Chamber of Deputies, whose main axes are privatizations, labor reform, tax reductions, etc., etc.

I want to tell you that when Néstor arrived at the Presidency, when on that April 27 he came in second because the country had collapsed, the convertibility a year earlier, everything was private. Even pensions, YPF, Aerolíneas Argentinas, everything, everything, absolutely everything was private. Even pensions! I was a national deputy, I was a senator since 1995 and, permanently - especially after 1999 - the fiscal deficit and zero deficit began to be raised. And we had a zero deficit. In 2000 and 2001 they deducted salaries, pensions and we had a zero deficit. And it still fell. But, I reiterate so that no one thinks I am beating the drum against the fiscal surplus: in this country, in the six years that there was a fiscal surplus, Néstor Kirchner was in power and in 2008, the one speaking. Yes, gentlemen. Let’s see… fiscal surplus 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008. And what happened in 2008? Well… the world fell. Lehman Brothers fell. Global crisis on a global scale. It could not be sustained and later, two years later, our energy balance was reversed. From a surplus of more than 4 billion dollars in energy exports, we went to having to import the same amount. This was the reason why we had a deficit. It’s not that we are defending the deficit, but for this reason I say that that feat, that of the historical feat and so on, for a quarter, historical feat? So we, who were there for six years, what are we? National heroes? No, no, no. What are we, national heroes? No, no.

I know that the militancy likes heroism, but no: men and women of flesh and blood with special responsibilities who take charge of history and face it with courage, that’s what we were. We were not heroes. And, fundamentally, with clear ideas.

I also want to be very clear: no one is denying the legitimacy of origin of the President, eh… if there is something I have always recognized it is the forcefulness and the unappealable nature of the popular vote. No one is disputing that, but the legitimacy of origin also needs to be legitimized in management and in the results of management. Look, I want to tell you an anecdote related to this particular circumstance from 21 years ago. Everyone knows: Menem came in first with 24% of the votes, Néstor second with 22%. Look at this… if the election we just had was an election of thirds, that one was an election of quarters. Neither reached even 25% and the trailing group didn’t even reach a fifth. It was an election of quarters and fifths. Such was the fragmentation that society had… there were people who left not to vote, at kilometer 501. Yes, in the previous parliamentary election, the salami vote, the clemente vote had come out: total discredit. Everything privatized, zero deficit. And then? The same as always. The dollars ran out, it was necessary to pay and when the dollars run out and you have to pay, Argentina falls. It’s the story of the last 40 years, I think we need to be very clear about this.

I was going to tell you an anecdote because, in those days, after April 27, as there was a whole slogan that the vote was going to regroup, as the runoff votes regroup, the rumor began to arise that the one who had come in first was going to resign to delegitimize the government that was starting, and José Saramago, who was a Nobel Prize in Literature, had just arrived in the country. He and his wife, Pilar del Río, dear friend, I didn’t know them, and a dinner was held in his honor at the house of an important Argentine businessman, to which many personalities from human rights were invited. Estela de Carlotto was there, intellectuals, journalists, writers. And the topic was already that he resigns, resigns, resigns to the runoff. “What are you going to do?” I will never forget this. Everyone asked me, from Pilar to the hostess and those who were there. What are you going to do if he resigns and you are left with 22% of the votes with this mess of a country? And I told them, very sure of myself, as sure as he was, not to worry, that we were going to have, not legitimacy of origin because we had only 22 percent of the votes, but we were going to build legitimacy in management by defending the interests of society and taking charge of the things that needed to be done. Because, brother, sister, you may have been voted by 60% of the votes but, if afterwards, when you are in government, people are starving, losing their jobs, unemployment rises, can’t make ends meet, what good is it? This is very clear. So legitimized that from that 22%, Néstor left with a 70% positive image when he finished his first presidency. But I wanted to tell you that, then, one thinks that well… this is a government then like that one… no, not either. A neoliberal government like the Menemism (which he claims was the best president in history and his star Minister of Economy, the best in the history of Economics… (no whistling, no whistling, no whistling…) So… don’t get angry. That I scold them, you already know that I am a bit bossy, I will never lose that.

And what is, then, this government? It has some points of contact. For example, foreign relations, well, at that time they were carnal relations. Now I don’t even want to mention the word with this President because it could lead to an extravagant interpretation, but well, nothing… carnal relations. An international episode also occurred, just like now, with the Middle East episode between Israel and Iran. At that time it wasn’t Iran, the theocratic regime of the Ayatollahs, it was Iraq, with a K. And it was Saddam Hussein and chemical weapons. And the government at that time, when Saddam Hussein occupied Kuwait, Bush Sr. was president of the United States, sent two Argentine missile frigates to combat in the Middle East. Mambrú went to war… Mambrú went to war… even that.

Privatizations… and not to mention these half privatizations they are carrying out now. At that time, all state assets were privatized. All hydroelectric plants. All the trunk lines. To give you an idea: SEGBA, among other things, was divided in distribution between Edenor, Edelap, and Edesur. Look at the magnitude of what state assets were. Chocón, Cerros Colorados, Futaleufú. Everything, all the water resources, the telephone lines and it is that we are against… and that when we returned we brought everything back and said “everything returns to the State”? No, no. Because neither privatizers nor statists. What did we recover? First, water and energy through a law from Congress because the French company was not complying and there was no water in all of Greater Buenos Aires. There wasn’t a single line laid. We recovered Aerolíneas Argentinas but why did we recover Aerolíneas Argentinas? Because by 2008 the national state was paying for the fuel of Aerolíneas Argentinas’ planes which was from the state company Iberia and was paying the salaries of all Aerolíneas Argentinas personnel. Absurd. The state paying for fuel and all salaries… I mean, there was no other choice but to recover Aerolíneas Argentinas due to the irregular state. And YPF as well when Repsol had turned an oil company into a financial company and then it had to be recovered because we had to regain energy sovereignty as it was really regained starting in 2012. A separate mention: I’ll give a notice, in March (I will talk more about that later), Vaca Muerta is breaking production records. Record production! almost 400,000 barrels a day. For nothing, eh… for nothing. And we also recovered…

Well, we also recovered pensions for a very simple reason: the state was paying 60% of pensions. Why? Because the AFJPs kept the cream, with the highest salaries and the lowest salaries were paid by the state. Absurd. And it was recovered but, then, if all that didn’t yield results, moreover, in an international framework absolutely favorable to that neoliberal project, in 1989 when Menem took office the Berlin Wall fell, the Brady Plan came out, which was the bailout that the U.S. Treasury did for the banks that had gone into debt with petrodollars and presented it as if they were helping the external debt of Latin American countries. No, no, no. They rescued the banks and stuck it to the Italian, German, Japanese retirees, with whom we later had to negotiate the restructuring of the debt. That was the international scenario, but also, nationally, there was a Bonex Plan that took all the remunerated liabilities that no one takes now, for the time being until now. And there was a plan that is what this government lacks, no matter how much the President gets angry and makes faces and all those things: it has no stabilization plan. Look how I tell you: it has no stabilization plan, which the previous government did have, which was convertibility. A convertibility sustained moreover by the sale of national assets, and by indebtedness. And why do economists insist so much on the… they are right. Because Alfonsín also had it, the Austral Plan was a stabilization plan, it lasted little. But, note, inflation was at twenty… look that he does some calculations, I don’t know, one ends up I don’t know where.

Well, the reality is that in 1985, June 1985, inflation was in double digits, between 25 and 30%. The Austral Plan came out… excuse me, the Austral Plan, which involved a currency change and so on, and inflation the following month was in single digits. Because a stabilization plan is not just a technical issue; it is a profoundly political and social issue. Economic agents, consumers, entrepreneurs, society must believe in it for it to be effective. This one does not have that. It is merely an adjustment plan. But then, if it is not a neoliberal plan because it lacks any of the ingredients or conditions, ah, and also, excuse me, I don’t want to be pejorative or bad. Sometimes it’s not that I’m being mean; I just speak bluntly and am a bit harsh in some expressions. But in addition to all those international and national conditions, there was a congress, there was a president with a solid political party, the General Confederation of Labor, and there was a team. When one looks at what exists today in all areas, well, it’s not that it lacks one peso; it lacks 30, 40, 50, or 90 pesos. Really. I don’t want to be pejorative. Look, I end up praising Menem’s government, from which I was expelled from the Menemist bloc. I mean, I speak of what I know. I am not talking about ideology or what I read; I am talking about what I lived as a legislator and as a companion of someone who was governor three times from 1991 to 2003. This is the country we had. So one wonders, well, if it is not neoliberal, what is it then, anarcho-capitalism? And now here, I think there is indeed a clue in the president’s speech in the national broadcast on Monday. He said on Monday that recovery and growth will come from four areas: oil, gas, mining, and agriculture. In other words, agriculture. That is a sector that has growth, as I just pointed out in Vaca Muerta, but as it is developed in our country, it foreshadows an extractivist economy. In other words, taking all natural resources without added value, without technology, without industrialization. In other words, pre-capitalist. Because it reminds me of Argentina during the Viceroyalty of the Río de la Plata, where all the wealth was taken away, and nothing was left for you.

So more than anarcho-capitalism, it seems to me that it sounds like anarcho-colonialism. And I think we do not agree on that. Because these activities today are of an extractive nature, but also: does anyone think that with these four activities of a purely extractive nature we are going to generate quality jobs for 47 million Argentines seriously? The numbers don’t add up for me. Because, for example, in Santa Cruz, the leading exporter of gold and oil, there are about 9,000 jobs. And the same happens in oil. One can go to Neuquén, but those who work in oil, the workers, with very good salaries, miners, oil workers, but what are we going to have? It won’t be enough, and it has already started to happen with the other great phenomenon that will be the same as the other, which is unemployment. And I know that perhaps many Argentines have become unaccustomed to unemployment. Because it is true that starting in 2003, we began with industrialization and full employment, so that people have jobs.

But the truth is that when Néstor was elected, or came in second, rather, on a day like today, there was 25% unemployment… a quarter of the population was unemployed. And it is terrible that the salary today is not enough. And how it didn’t even suffice during our government, which was the problem we had. I see here first-line union leaders. For the first time, registered work has workers who are poor. That had never happened. And it is ugly and bad. But worse than not having enough salary is not having a salary at the end of the month. This is the great drama that is looming and that the president must understand. The president must understand that he must take a turn in this policy. This idea that the market has no failures. That everything should be left without regulation. What happened with the prepaid medical plans? He had to backtrack. And he didn’t solve anything. Because what he should have done is, having noticed what was happening, annul the relevant part of the prepaid medical plans in the other decree with a DNU and regain the state’s capacity to regulate the price of prepaid medical plans, which was a capacity we established at the end of our first government, mine, in 2011. And why did we only think of regulating prepaid medical plans in 2011? Why didn’t Néstor do it? Because, guys, when Néstor arrived at the presidency, the misery in this country was such that no one had prepaid medical plans. Only those who had money had prepaid medical plans. By 2011, a lot of the middle class had fallen and could afford prepaid medical plans. Then they forget. And they become anti-Peronists, anti-Kirchnerists, but it doesn’t matter. We love them anyway. We will always love them. And today the solution doesn’t even involve recovering those powers over prepaid medical plans. Prepaid medical plans must be subjected to the insurance law. They are health insurance. Those brutal sums of money can no longer be managed. They say they all go bankrupt. And the one who until recently was president of the chamber got tired and doesn’t stop buying everything related to health, clinics… How can you go bankrupt? How can you keep protesting against regulation because you go bankrupt and never go bankrupt? How? How? It’s a lie. And this doesn’t make businesspeople bad people. I’m not saying that either. I’m saying that when one is a businessperson, the only thing that matters is profitability, and maybe that’s very well. Because they have to keep producing. No one can ask a businessperson for social sensitivity. No. And I don’t think they are insensitive either. Not at all. They are businesspeople; the one who must take on the role there is politics and the state to regulate and establish a harmonious relationship in society. Harmony. Harmony.

But then what is the problem with this president who says that the state has no failures, that businesspeople are heroes, even those who… the problem he has is that he is very dogmatic. So he wants to fit the head to the hat. No, president, when the hat doesn’t fit the head, enlarge the hat. That’s the way. That’s the way. And if he does it, we will help him because no one wants him to fail. Because if you fail, all Argentines will fail. Look, I tell you this very bluntly, but I also want you to know, president, that if you want to turn Argentina back into a country where all its wealth is extracted, where there are no industries, where they want to impose a sort of elimination of the entire middle class, well, look, there I will declare myself an avatar, in blue and light blue, men and women in blue and light blue like the flag to defend the homeland. Not again as a colony. Avatars. Not again. Not again as a colony.

I want… and speaking of blue avatars. Speaking of blue avatars, how are we doing, the avatars of the national, popular, and democratic movement? Well, we are moving with some certainties that we didn’t have in 2019 with this government. What are they? Uh, a lot. Do you want me to tell you? I’ll tell you. Should I tell you? Well, here it goes. First certainty, how many times did you hear back then… I’m talking until 2019, right? How many times did you hear from those opposed to us, but even within our own ranks, this idea of Cristina’s manners? The intensity of Cristina… in other words, there was a need to… well. The manners. Or the disrespect or I don’t know what else. Or I don’t know what else. Well, you will agree that after this president, I am Countess María Eugenia de Chicoff, right? Don’t mess with me anymore about this. Don’t mess with me anymore about this. The truth is… it wasn’t the manners. And well, with the manners and all, we all know what it was really about, right? About those who cannot be subdued, those who do not lower their gaze before anyone and who are not afraid. And this does not mean, I repeat, that I am a heroine; it just means believing in what one does. But well, based on that, we decided in 2019 because I knew, I knew why it was, right? But we had to rebuild the national movement again because it would have been catastrophic at that moment for the one who had contracted the debt with the IMF, with everything that happened, I had to guarantee under any circumstances that the national movement, Peronism, Kirchnerism… because, let’s see, in the national movement, there are Peronists who are not Kirchnerists, Kirchnerists who are not Peronists, Peronists like me who have been Peronists all my life but, well, I’m called Kirchner, what can I do? Sure, it’s a small… I know some are bothered by it, but I don’t know… I’m not going to abandon the name, nor take it away from anyone. But well, here we are. With our name and with the K in tow, we take responsibility for everything. With the good and the bad. And we built what we built.

Well, why did people choose us back in 2019? Very simple, because they remembered how things had been until 2015. Of course. That’s why we won. The problem was when someone thought it was because of good manners that they voted for us. And it wasn’t like that. So when you believe it was because of good manners and that everything else should be set aside. Well, we ended up as we ended up. I also take responsibility for everything as I have all my life. I don’t shift the blame to anyone. I face things head-on. I’m not one to throw stones and hide my hand. No, no, no. I take responsibility for everything. I believe then that this is a first lesson. It wasn’t the manners; they voted for us because they wanted to have quality of life and an organized life again. Not even great quality of life. An organized life, right? Where kids go to school, eat at home, the father has a job, the mother too, they go to school, they have classes every day… and a second thing that is also good now, even though it may seem contradictory, is that what we are living today also forces us to rethink and reconsider many things. At some point, we tried, but for various reasons. I said it in the last document, that of February 14 of this year when I mentioned the things we had to discuss, to talk about again. I talked about education, I talked about a lot of things. But I omitted to mention one thing, to talk, and the truth is that I didn’t talk about energy. About public services, about tariffs. And the truth is that it has acquired tremendous and dramatic relevance today, and one hears on television that the electricity tariffs that are reaching homes, clubs, universities, businesses, and industries are because we gave subsidies. In other words, the subsidy policy would be the response… and what is worse, one turns on the TV and sometimes hears a comrade or the journalist saying that… even some journalists who are supposed to be well-informed say that the problem was the subsidies. And the comrades nod in a certain way. It’s not a reproach to anyone, mind you, not at all. Simply, no, no, no… it’s not time for reproaches. It’s time for reflection and analysis. Because there are a lot of fools out there, and quite a few smart ones who, taking advantage of that foolishness, as I say, install things that are not true. Look, if there is something we should reconsider, it’s because we couldn’t reverse the regulatory framework of privatization in energy matters back in those years. When in 1992 energy was privatized. The English model was copied. The English model is a… business model. Generation on one side. Transport on the other. Distribution on the other. And it is… dollarized with convertibility; the tariffs were dollarized. Moreover, two prices are set, a single price which is the generation price. It’s a bit complicated, but it’s good for you to listen because leaders and militants must be prepared; we can’t go out anymore unprepared. Or go to a TV channel to insult another comrade. When you go to TV channels or the radio, go to talk about these things that interest people. Why is my bill so high? Who cares what you think about Juan, Pedro, or José? So, I know it’s a bit sensitive. Someone is going to get angry, especially Máximo, who always tells me, “you’re starting with your master class again because you’re driving me crazy.” Yes, well, I’m driving you crazy, but if everyone knew and studied a little more, we could defend things better too.

Then this was done… a wholesale market was created and CAMMESA was established. You have heard about CAMMESA in recent days. They do not pay CAMMESA; they owe CAMMESA. CAMMESA might seem like an organization almost made up of employees and militant fat. No, no, no, no, CAMMESA is the one that buys and manages the entire wholesale energy market in the Argentine Republic. Who makes it up? It is presided over by the Secretary of Energy, but 80% are the large companies in the country. Large users, Techint and Aluar, Edenor, Edesur, Transener, Pampa Energía… part of the owners of the energy in this country are the ones who control CAMMESA. What happened when convertibility fell? During convertibility, the monomic price, which is the price of generation, was in dollars because one dollar was one peso. And the seasonal price, which was also a price… was also in dollars. The seasonal price is what they charge the distributors; it is the transportation and distribution. Good. When convertibility fell, this was already being said in 2002, the price of transportation and distribution was pesified, but generation remained in dollars. The contracts are in dollars. Can you imagine what happens every time there is a devaluation? And during convertibility, where the seasonal price was often higher than that of generation, the opposite phenomenon occurs when everything falls. This is how it was received in 2003, and what does it do? What had the State done during the privatizations? It had maintained the regulation of transportation and distribution with the ENRE but had left the generation deregulated and at the mercy of the market. This is one of the big messes we have today in the Argentine Republic.

Look at how inefficient it is. I look at Oscar Parrilli here, from Neuquén. The megawatt in Neuquén costs the Neuquén consumer more than the megawatt here. When Neuquén is the great producer of electric energy with gas and hydropower, with the dams. And why? How can it be that in the place of origin it costs more? Because with the scheme they have developed, everything converges in Buenos Aires. So the energy comes through nodes to Buenos Aires, in Ezeiza, and from Ezeiza it goes back, and they charge for all that transportation. And then they talk to us about market efficiency. Don’t mess with me anymore about market efficiency. There is no efficiency in the market. There is appropriation of society's profitability. But also, what is efficient about remunerating for the same service that is practically integrated? It has a natural monopoly like transportation and distribution and, practically, also generation because there are seven or eight players, no more. Shouldn’t it be vertically integrated instead of paying one business structure in distribution, another business structure in transportation, and another in generation? What kind of business is that? Why do they tell us we have to shrink the State while they, however, expand into three, four, five companies to charge more? What do they propose to us?

And this is very important because look… But that’s not where it ends. Because that is structural. The structural problem of energy is a product of privatizations, but there is a contractual problem. If we could please put up the first slide. No, wait, wait. Percentage of contracted power in megawatts. In contracts, do you see? These are all the generation contracts in dollars. There it is from 2003 to 2019. The price today of the generated megawatt is made up of 32.2% of contracts in dollars generated in our period, but as you can see, the majority of the price comes from contracts signed between 2016 and 2019.

Are you following me, right? It’s a little complicated, but follow me. Because the path is like you saw in Hansel and Gretel, throwing breadcrumbs. Well, you keep following the breadcrumbs. Remember this. Price of 32.2 with those contracts. Look at 2, that is the increase in installed power by government and type of generation. Those are the megawatts generated. There are colors, do you see?

The pink one is thermal, that is made with gas, the hydroelectric one we already know is with water, the dams, plants, turbines. Nuclear, which is the one we incorporated with Atucha II, 725 megawatts. And renewable, check this out, look at this, renewables, the wind ones. Do you remember that one who was looking for and recommended a football player to make wind contracts? Now I’ll explain why.

So you see that between Néstor Kirchner, CFK I, and CFK II we increased the power by almost 10,000 megawatts. 9973.75, that’s the sum. Macri increased it by 6155, a lot too in four years. And in the following government, 3209. Very well. Now we go to the second because the megawatt, the energy, is like gas; it has to have a pipe to get it in because if not, I better not say anything but… right? We have to have it. So let’s look at high voltage lines.

That is 500, built by the government. Néstor Kirchner: 355 kilometers and we, well, in total between the three government periods, to make it shorter: 5080 kilometers. Look at Macri: 2 kilometers. No, no, no, it’s not for applause. Keep going because now the best part comes. And Alberto 431. Now comes the map.

Look: the light blue ones are the existing lines as of 2003, the burgundy ones and the dotted lines are the ones we built. What’s the issue there? As you will see, there is a line that goes from Choele Choel, Río Negro, all the way to the bottom, to Río Gallegos, Río Turbio, Calafate, and there is a light blue line. That light blue line is Futaleufu, which was built during the dictatorship of Lanusse; it is the one that feeds Aluar. Aluar has 60% of the shares of that hydroelectric plant. Good, and look. Not only did we integrate all of Patagonia, but we also reconnected 10 Argentine provinces. Why? Because we made rings. Because before the lines didn’t connect. Now they form, do you see that there are rings that close around the provinces? This closing off by the provinces provides greater security for transmission. It prevents cuts, falls, etc… So now we go to the source of composition of how the average generation cost turned out. This is very important.

Notice that in 2024 the contracts are green, a lot, contracts in dollars, then comes nuclear, fuels, renewable acquires a very strong weight as it didn’t have before. Good, now I go to the sixth.

Look at the prices: nuclear… it is the average by source in CAMMESA. 60.5 for renewable, wind and solar 61.4, 7.9… Well, leave it there. What am I going to explain about this? As the contracts were. The contracts in dollars during our management, we built through several projects, the FONINVEMEN for example. The FONINVEMEN we made Central Térmica San Martín, Vuelta de Obligado, Almirante Guillermo Brown. What was the FONINVEMEN? We told the generator, we established the generation cost, generation cost, and we also left them a profitability that we regulated. And with the rest of the subsidy, we began to do all those works that ultimately ended in 10,000 megawatts of capacity. What did Mauricio Macri’s government do? It made financial deals instead of…

What is a financial contract in energy matters? First, small thermal plants, what is called project finance, which is where you go to an investment fund without money and present a project that pays for itself, with which the rate, you can imagine, is much higher. And finally, they incorporate all those renewable contracts, renewable energies… but how do they incorporate them in addition to at a high cost? They give them dispatch priority. What is dispatch priority? Today the peak consumption is about 20,000 megawatts, 30,000 megawatts. And I believe that when this deepens, it will fall because commerce, industry, residential consumption, etc. will fall… But they introduced 6000 megawatts but did not build a single line. This means that today we have almost 43,000 megawatts of capacity. And what happens, what is dispatch priority? That if the line is congested, the renewable contract, the wind one, has to enter first despite being the most expensive energy. It can displace the hydroelectric one, which is much cheaper.

So what’s the issue here? We are paying for energy that is much more expensive than it should be because, in addition to giving dispatch priority, they gave payment priority. What does payment priority mean? That even if it doesn’t enter the line because it is congested, it still has to be paid. Payment priority means that if CAMMESA does not have the money to pay the wind and the projects they presented, they are paid by the FODER, which sounds like “to mess with,” right? But no. It’s FODER, which is the Renewable Energy Development Fund. And if the FODER does not have resources, the national state is obliged to buy the project, and if the national state has no money, the World Bank gives it to them. Because all those contracts were signed under CIADI jurisdiction; they cannot even be discussed in Argentine justice. You have to go discuss them at CIADI, and we get into debt.

These are some of the problems we have and also the cost of energy. And I want, for example, the hydroelectric plants that are all concessioned, there is an average… Pampa Energía is paid 19 dollars, Yaciretá is paid 5 dollars. Yaciretá is a binational project, and Salto Grande is also a binational project. 5 dollars for Yaciretá and 3 dollars for Salto Grande. But I want to point out… and it’s not that… I’m not speaking against any businessman; I simply mention this company because it is very important in terms of production. It has 8% of the gas production in the Argentine Republic and is part of the board of CAMMESA, that’s why I mention it. Just like Techint as a large user, but at the same time, CAMMESA is the one that buys all the available energy, and Techint is one of the main gas producers. So we have people sitting on both sides of the counter. What can go right? And I’m not accusing anyone of anything; I’m just saying how the State has abandoned this.

Now, I want… give me number 7. This from Pampa Energía is a declared profit margin before the SEC. As you all know, the SEC is the commission that controls… if you lie to the SEC here, the FBI comes looking for you. You don’t mess around there.

Well, look, what you see highlighted is the Parque Pilar thermal power plant. The mayor of Pilar must be around there, right? Hello, how are you, Fede? How are you? And then there is the Ingeniero White thermal power plant. Well, look, 126 is the price. 103 dollars is what remains as profit, in dollars. In dollars. 4 or 5 times. The first plant is the Loma de la Lata thermal power plant 31-26; that is only one turbine. The other is the Güemes Thermal Power Plant, which was built by Perón; it is part of the privatized lot. The other is the Piedrabuena Thermal Power Plant, which is… look, it’s all in dollars. The last one is the Ensenada de Barragán Thermal Power Plant, which Pampa Energía also bought; it is not included because this was in 2021. That was the one the State built with financing… there are a series of impressive data.

Well, the issue is that clearly, because we are also talking about profitability in dollars. It’s not Steve Jobs selling you the iPhone at a price he wants because, well… that is market. So we understand where there is market and where there is no market. When you complain because the iPhone is expensive, well, tough luck because that is market. It’s a valuable product that everyone wants and has a very high price. If you don’t like it, you buy the Samsung; if it’s too expensive, you buy a cheaper one. That is market. But when you are charging these prices with captive demand and with essential public services, that is not market; that is absence of State. That is absence of State.

So I believe it is necessary for us to re-discuss in Argentina. Because energy is not a minor issue. Believe me. It is one of the vectors, energy, central to any economic development project. I’m not even characterizing development as industrial or… Economic development. It is impossible to generate a project, a process of economic growth if we do not take the bull by the horns in energy matters, which does not mean taking anything away from anyone. Sit all the players down, clarify the costs, establish reasonable profitability because we are talking about public services. We are talking about the input for industries, commerce, households, schools, and universities.

And since we are talking about universities, also about education, about rethinking the tax system that is so linked to how education is financed. I posted this week when it was about universities, what we had achieved by reversing the equation of debt and what we affected education. We had turned the tables, and it was 6.3. If I am satisfied with the education of those years… I could say that in the university it was really good. We wouldn’t have so many university students in the Argentine Republic if we hadn’t created the universities we created; I am sure of that. In school… The truth is that we have to re-discuss all that, especially primary and secondary. I wanted to perhaps start a discussion in 2012, and they kicked me out. Do you remember that message from May 1st where I was very critical? But we have to talk about it, guys, because if we don’t talk about it, they come and impose things that…

I remember. Look: the President talks about indoctrination in schools; if we had indoctrinated in schools, he wouldn't be President. What is this man saying? What is this man saying? Moreover, I dare say that if we had a primary and secondary public education system like the one I had... I remember the names of the six or seven teachers I had: first grade, first superior, second, all of them... I had one teacher per year, nothing more. And I had classes every day. That is not enough, no... but you don't know how much it helps. So I think we need to start discussing these things. I heard the other day from the governor, I think of Santa Fe, who said that when he took office, he had a problem because he was allocating 23 to 25% of the resources to teacher salaries, to the teaching sector, that he was paying and that they were not attending due to substitutes, licenses, or whatever. We need to discuss seriously. Because resources are scarce, and we need to make them count, and we need to discuss. Because if we don't want to discuss ourselves, others will come and discuss us from the outside and from a filthy place because it's not that they care about the kids knowing. We need to understand this.

Look: a curiosity as well. Knowing how they run us. You saw that this week a lot of attention was given to an ERSE education survey that said it had been a disaster, this and that. That the last twenty years, because everything happened in the last 30 years. They talk as if 21 years ago we were in who knows where, but this has a purpose, it has the clear objective of demonizing, denigrating, and helping to create collective amnesia; people have many problems. Young kids, what do they know about what happened in 2010, in 2011, in 2015? A 20-year-old kid, even a 30-year-old. So I sent a colleague to study how this ERCE works, and it turns out that the result they disseminated, listen well, is from 2019. Why did it take so long to be released? Because then the pandemic came, it took time to do... And then I asked when those tests were conducted: in 1997, in 2006, in 2013, and in 2019. And guess what? Between 2006 and 2013, that ERCE test showed that we had increased in score; it is taken for kids in third grade and for kids in sixth grade. Well, the one that evaluated between 2006 and 2013 practically, no, not practically, seven years out of twelve, showed growth and improvement in everything, in mathematics. Who did this...? Where are you, Luana? Luana must be around, I sent her... Hello. Well, Luana has always taken care of education until in 2017, I thought to tell her to abandon education a bit and focus on the elderly, because we had no one to care for our old people, and the truth is she did it very well. She did it very well at PAMI. I was not wrong when I put my eye on you. I thought to tell her, Luana, why don't you look into this for me? Well, in reading we have 2.44 in 2013, in mathematics we had improved by 27.9 percentage points, almost 28, in sixth grade in reading 2.13 and in mathematics 17.2, again better. And in science 12.59. Do you know when that was that they said was from the last 20 years? From 2013 to 2019, the entire management of Macri and only two years of our management; this is how it is distorted, misinformation is spread, and common sense is formed in society.

So, what do I want to ask you today, this afternoon, to leaders, militants, neighbors, citizens, compatriots? We need to study, we need to educate ourselves, we need to go out and discuss these things, not nonsense, these things that interest people, that change people's lives. They are discussing how to change the lives of the leaders. We need to start working and discussing to change people's lives, to improve. We need to form common sense and information, essentially. And speaking, and to conclude, well, hey, it's cold already, excuse me. Enough, another day we can set up a master class at some university that allows for a long discussion, but here how what... Look: the other day there was a wonderful mobilization of Argentine society; no one should be fooled, eh. There were young kids, but they were with their parents, with friends. I don't remember such a large, transversal one in recent times, from people of high class, middle class, lower middle class, low, for the university. Because also among the things we need to discuss is a new tax system; it is true, there are too many taxes, it is a mess, you have to hire 20 professionals. I think we need to simplify the tax system so that it is easy for the taxpayer and modify it as well. Not for what they want to do now with the Law of Bases, which lowers personal taxes for those who have money and imposes a tax that can no longer be called profits, because that is not even income, what they are trying to impose. But well... And there was a lot of discussion in the media, in the streets, about the issue of educational financing, and look at what mention and what relationship it has with the system and all the things we need to discuss in Argentina. But we need to start discussing seriously, not with euphemisms. I see leaders in the media who don't, everything is superficial, biribiri, and no one says because, let's see, let's call things by their name. They know that the university budget has eleven openings, right? Of course, 18% of the university budget is: first, teaching staff and authorities of the universities; the second is non-teaching staff, that is it. But then it has other openings that triggered the problem and the mobilization, which is the opening for the functioning of the university, which are the expenses needed to operate, for electricity, for paper, in short. More, that is about 6% more, and the 1% that are hospitals, which fulfill so many social functions today in society. Put up slide number 9.

Look, Mercado Libre, tax benefits. Again, no one whistles, no one whistles! Mercado Libre, this is taken from the SEC, from the same place I took it. Well, under the knowledge economy regime in 2023... Mercado Libre is the most important company in the Republic of Argentina, and its owner is the richest man in the Republic of Argentina. He had a tax exemption for the knowledge economy of 42 million in Social Security, which are the contributions to finance retirees of 67 million and a discount of 6. Well, 103 million dollars; with those 103 million dollars, we have enough to cover all the operating expenses of all Argentine universities and hospitals. For those who say. Please look at slide 10, and I will finish.

Look, Mercado Libre has 59% of its employees graduated from public universities. Globant, the other great Argentine unicorn, which was created in 2003, has 71% from public universities. So they can say, "See, he is anti-business, they are..." Do you know who sent to the Legislative and had the first regime of tax promotions with tax exemptions in Social Security and income tax sanctioned? Néstor Kirchner, 2007, the first. The first. Do you know why I remember? Because I was a presidential candidate and went to a dinner, an event at the Hilton in Puerto Madero of the chambers that group all the technology companies to thank them for what we had done. And it was very well done, moreover, because it was something that was just starting. Globant was a company with a group from La Plata, from my city. Go La Plata, of course, always! Small, and today it is a unicorn that is listed on Nasdaq, and we are very proud to have these entrepreneurs. But is it normal that the richest businessman in Argentina has these exemptions? It was good to promote because tax promotion is that, it promotes, just as you promote a child, but the child, when he reaches adulthood, has to manage on his own. And these are companies that, fortunately for them and for all Argentines, have reached adulthood; they are big businessmen. They should start giving back to the Argentine people and society everything they have received.

It has gotten dark; people have to return home, the visitors are sleepy, so since the visitors are sleepy, we will finish, thank everyone, and ask all comrades, militants, and compatriots in general, please let us all join efforts, so that they do not turn Argentina back into a wasteland of unemployed people with scientists leaving. How much did it cost us to bring more than a thousand scientists with the Raíces Project! Let us not allow them to leave again, please, this is what I ask of all comrades, all militants.

When in Avellaneda I said one day that each comrade has in their backpack the marshal's baton, it was not to hit another comrade on the head; it was to take the marshal's baton and go out into the street to achieve that people can live and denounce all this. To explain all this to society because society does not know; they poison it all day long by saying, distorting as happened with this test, as happens with the energy issue; it is necessary to rediscuss the country we want. We have an immense responsibility, also as an opposition, to rediscuss that country, recognizing what we did, admitting what we lacked, and looking forward, because we always have to look forward. Thank you very much to all, I love you all.