Intervention by Cristina in Cochabamba, UNASUR meeting

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

5 July 2013 · UNASUR meeting of South American Presidents · Gran Hotel Cochabamba, Cochabamba, Bolivia

Context
Fernández de Kirchner addressed a UNASUR emergency summit in Cochabamba, Bolivia on July 4, 2013, responding to the forced rerouting of President Evo Morales's aircraft by European nations.
Main themes
Violation of international law, Evo Morales plane incident, diplomatic immunity, UNASUR solidarity, humanitarian security, intelligence agency failure, Latin American sovereignty, airspace authorization denial, UN Charter norms
Duration
~8 min
27th percentile
Words
913
27th percentile
Sentences
21
11th percentile
Readability
21
4th percentile
Grade
21.0
98th percentile
Syntax
3.68
98th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
51st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 48%48%
  • Ceremonial 38%38%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

21 sentences in 11 paragraphs

Meeting of South American Presidents from the Gran Hotel Cochabamba in Bolivia. Words of CFK. 04/07/2013

Good evening to everyone, when I refer to everyone, I am not just talking about the heads of state, ambassadors, and ambassadors, with whom we have already met, but to all the others who are here with us: brothers and sisters from Bolivia; workers from the national and international press who accompany us: well, in reality, we had agreed that I would make a small intervention, not only as President but also in my capacity as a lawyer, because it was a conversation we had with Evo, at night, when he was virtually a hostage, there in Vienna.

I think that President Evo Morales' account, especially the first part, where he describes the situation that arose, aboard a plane with a President traveling and suddenly being told that he cannot fly and that he has to leave a territory, I can imagine, as President, in a similar situation, one travels constantly all over the world – on official missions – and I can suddenly imagine that from a country I am informed that I am not authorized – as President of the Argentine Republic – having previously agreed to that authorization, and they tell me: “where do we return, we have little fuel,” it is a situation that exceeds a mere institutional situation to become a humanitarian situation, if you will, because ultimately it can endanger security, not just of a Head of State, but the security of a human life, which is exactly the same whether it is that of a Head of State or that of any citizen. It acquires greater relevance, obviously, the fact of being a Head of State because one wonders if they do these things to a Head of State, who is known to everyone, who has access to the press, to the media, what can happen with the situation or the fate of any citizen in the world, of any nationality whom no one knows, who can go through much more terrible things without anyone even realizing that this has happened.

The account is really ugly, it is chilling – at times – because they were also lucky that Vienna, in this case Austria, authorized the descent of the aircraft, but – from what President Morales recounted – they may not have had enough autonomy to return to Russia, which was the starting point, so the first situation is of serious humanitarian nature; the second is a serious legal situation, because there were authorizations granted by States to transit through their airspaces, in this case by Portugal, Spain, France, and Italy, which were later denied, that is, there is a double violation: a first, to the immunity of every Head of State and to the presidential aircraft that carries that Head of State and, then, a second violation of the agreements granted for flights that are treated as international agreements as if they were signed agreements, because there was no cause, no reason. Because, suddenly, there may be weather situations, technological situations but they were not properly explained. Well, the truth is that President Morales' account reveals a degree of violation of International Law norms, of the United Nations Charter and a degree of very serious legal insecurity for any country in the world and for any citizen. That is why I believe that this document we have been drafting and discussing today, on the one hand, reveals these situations and, well, we expect as democratic countries the respective explanations.

And also, to not give it so much drama, right?, and to put a little humor into all this. One thinks of the citizens of developed countries who spend so much money on their intelligence apparatus, on their security agencies and suddenly these security agencies have misinformed their governments because, evidently, they had informed or at least that on President Morales' plane was a person who was also exercising the right of asylum… You know that embassies or military ships are extensions of territory, so spending so much money for such bad information… And we had been convinced in the movies that they had a precision and accuracy that apparently is only for the movies and to win some Oscar, but not an Oscar for diplomacy precisely.

So, nothing, I would honestly be, if I were president of those countries, very worried, not only about the international embarrassment they have incurred, but also about so much money wasted. It would be assumed that they could invest it better and be more effective, right?

So, nothing, our solidarity towards the people of Bolivia, towards President Evo Morales and towards all the Latin American people. Because, in reality, we have all felt violated, to some extent or in some way, by what has happened and I also recommend to the brotherly peoples of developed countries and with so many years of, well, intelligence practices, with so much money allocated to these purposes, well, to demand from their governments that they do things a little better to avoid these true international embarrassments that constitute, moreover, in the 21st century vestiges of a decaying colonialism and, the truth, that is very ineffective.

That is all I wanted to say and thank all the presidents, ambassadors, and ambassadors who have attended this meeting for their solidarity with the people of Bolivia and with ourselves.

Thank you very much and good night to everyone.

Cochabamba Declaration.