Intervention in the session on the Productive Financing Law

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

22 March 2018 · Session on the Productive Financing Law

Context
Fernández de Kirchner intervened in a Senate session in March 2018 to critique the government's Productive Financing Law, arguing it prioritized financial deregulation over SME support.
Main themes
Capital Markets Law reform, financial deregulation, SME financing, productive financing law critique, speculation and financial derivatives, economic model under Macri government, 2012 Capital Markets Law, Lehman Brothers and 2008 financial crisis, regulatory oversight, negotiable obligations and investment funds
Duration
~42 min
91st percentile
Words
5,015
91st percentile
Sentences
193
88th percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
13.4
60th percentile
Syntax
3.31
83rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
32nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 55%54%
  • Institutional 35%34%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

193 sentences in 50 paragraphs

We are discussing an initiative titled "productive financing." And just as we have come to expect from the government when it presents projects, the titles are always plausible and present principles or campaign slogans worthy of approval, but upon reading the project, one observes that it has little to do with the title.

To begin with, when one speaks of a law on productive financing, one should find the message signed – of course, as is appropriate – by the president and the chief of staff, and in this case, given that this is a country with a Ministry of Production, it should be the Minister of Production, who is Cabrera, accompanying and presenting the productive financing project.

However, the productive financing project, which is presented as productive financing for SMEs, is only signed by the president, the chief of staff, and the ineffable Minister of Finance, Luis Caputo.

This is a bill that has exactly 219 articles, but dedicates the first 26 articles to SMEs, meaning the remaining 193 articles relate to the modification of the Capital Markets Law enacted by this body in 2012 and also to the modification of other important laws, such as those on negotiable obligations – also enacted during the previous government – or investment funds.

Thus, one realizes that we are not facing a law for financing or assistance for SMEs. SMEs that, by the way, certainly need help. In the very report and in the records of the Ministry of Production, it is stated that between the last quarter of 2015 and the third quarter of 2017, 4,900 micro and small enterprises disappeared.

One expected to find not only the electronic invoice, which is the first title – and which we will surely support in the particular vote because it is the only instrument for SMEs included in the project that has been sent – but in the remaining 193 articles, even the one presented as the panacea for mortgages, it is clear that this is a law intended to further accentuate the financial and speculative nature of the current economic model. The modifications introduced and the new legal, financial, and derivative figures are a true festival for speculation.

I will start with a brief overview of what the current situation is regarding capital market regulation in the Republic of Argentina.

In 2012, in this very chamber, the Capital Markets Law was enacted. It had not been a unilateral, unthought-out project of the previous government. It responded to recommendations from the World Bank and also to requirements from an international institution that groups all the securities commissions in the world.

Look, I always love to refer to debates to understand what we are modifying, what we approved six years ago, and what we are modifying now.

In this case, we are in a closing speech, and I will also refer to a closing speech that took place in 2012, in this very chamber, by, of course, the president of the block or whoever the president of the block decides. And notice that the reasons for enacting the law that is now being turned upside down were, for example, the need to regulate financial markets… I will read verbatim, because I do not want to add or take away a single word: “In the need to regulate financial markets, there has been a position taken on this issue. It should be remembered that the concept of financial deregulation [this is what this law is about, financial deregulation], it should be remembered that the concept of financial deregulation [we said or they said at that time] led to the bankruptcy of the main financial entity of the main power in the world, as Senator Giustiniani [another senator from socialism who is no longer here in the body] mentioned very well, like the financial giant Lehman Brothers.”

And the speaker used a very good phrase, a very good metaphor. He said it was the fall of the Berlin Wall in financial terms. I found it to be a correct metaphor. Yes. Lehman Brothers, the 2008 crisis, was a true fall of the Berlin Wall, of a Berlin Wall that had begun to be built with some bricks like, for example, the resolution, during President Clinton's administration and Larry Summers' management at the Treasury of the United States, to transform commercial banks into investment banks, generating derivatives, selling product over product, the subprime crisis, and all that was the history of financial derivatives. It is nothing more or less than when banking stops focusing on financing production and wants to produce money without the money going through the usual circuits of production, of the consumer market, and of what has been the basis of capitalism, because, ultimately, unless Adam Smith or David Ricardo are wrong and we have exegetes who have improved their theory, they remain – you will agree with me, Mr. President – the great theorists of capitalism.

In short, the speaker continued and provided an example. There were also other interesting facts to highlight, such as the case of Madoff – I believe there is now a movie about Bernie Madoff – that mythical head of the electronic markets, of Nasdaq, who ultimately ended up in a monumental scam, which condemned him, I don’t know, to one hundred fifty, two hundred years in prison in the United States.

The speaker said: “The world has decided to move towards a scheme of very strong regulation and controls of the financial system, of the stock exchanges, of operations, and of securities. All this issue is in regulated control schemes.”

And he highlighted a very important point, which is Article 20 that this project today repeals. There was a great discussion regarding that Article 20, which was actually modified in the Chamber of Deputies. And the wording that is still in force is not the one originally sent by the Executive Power in the project, but was modified in the Chamber of Deputies, in a discussion, in a debate in the Chamber of Deputies, so broad, but so broad and so participatory that deputies like Alfonso Prat Gay – who had been president of the Central Bank during the administration of President Duhalde and during the administration of President Kirchner and later was Minister of Economy of this government – voted for this law as did a deputy, whose term has ended, like Deputy Claudio Lozano. Notice what a broad ideological and conceptual spectrum approved the law that we are now modifying, but not under the name of modification of the Capital Markets Law, but of financing for SMEs or productive financing.

And notice that the speaker at that time said that the last point relates to Article 20. What does the expansion of Article 20, heavily questioned in this debate, mean? The possibility for the National Securities Commission, as a control body, to place observers in a company and to take measures that are in line with those to which the Central Bank is subject, according to the Financial Entities Law, in Article 34.

The same concept is incorporated in the National Securities Commission. That’s right. Exactly. Moreover, the speaker wondered why the importance of this article had not been insisted upon in the debate in the Chamber of Deputies. He did so by insisting on the importance of this article, which the opposition, or those who opposed the norm at that time, said would be an instrument of the government to intervene in companies, to wipe out boards of directors, and so on. Well, look, from 2012 until the end of the term, no board of directors was intervened, no oversight was placed, and all companies in the Republic of Argentina were able to have their corporate bodies without this Article 20 ever being used, which claimed, as did Article 19, the powers of the National Securities Commission, as very important elements in the matter of regulation. And what this modification today is doing, beyond creating or incorporating the electronic invoice into current legislation, is modifying the Capital Markets Law, modifying the Common Investment Funds Law, modifying the Negotiable Obligations Law… And I could continue with two or three very important laws.

Why, Madam President? Why is it not true about SMEs? First, because to introduce these norms, no law was needed. It’s like with the historical reparations, you see, which had almost nothing to do with reparations and even less with being historical. But of course, the laundering was necessary, which later allowed many relatives of government officials, starting with the president of the Republic himself, to launder money. Thus, the law of historical reparations was introduced as a sort of Trojan horse. Litigation continues to rise, which will now be joined by the modification made in Parliament of the retirement formula, which was also enabled by the law of historical reparations. I have a letter from CAME here… That law was approved by 43 to 19 votes here.

Today it was also said that business chambers were asking for this. In reality, what CAME, for example, has asked all provincial governments is to see how they can lower electricity rates for SMEs. Because do you know what happens, Madam President? If there is no consumption in the Republic of Argentina, if the rate hikes continue, if the indiscriminate opening of imports continues, and if putting money into financial gambling – into LEBACs, into carry trade – yields me an interest of 26 or 27 percent, why would I want to set up an SME?

If I put money in and do nothing – without fighting with employees, without fighting with unions, without having to pay rate hikes, without having to be attentive to whether I sell or not, without having to be attentive to whether imported goods came in or not – and I get paid 27 percent for my money, why would I want to open an SME?

In other words, we can pass thousands of laws, and SMEs will not open because, you know what? The economy is not managed by laws. Look how easy it would be to manage the economy by laws; there would be no government that would not succeed in managing the economy. I believe that the economy is something more than a law on electronic invoices. In fact, we introduced many instruments: deferred payment checks, negotiable obligations – the law is ours – the common investment fund law as well, the trust law too. We introduced a lot of regulations, but fundamentally we secured the internal market and ensured aggregate demand, which is the great engine of the economy, Madam President. There is no entrepreneur who will invest if one of the two fundamental premises for sinking investment, for sinking capital, is not met: either the country has a strong internal market that is advantageous for me because I will sell and therefore invest, which was what happened in large part during our twelve and a half years of management, or the territory is an attractive enough platform in terms of costs for exporting. If neither of these two conditions is met, that is, if a country does not serve as a platform for export nor as a platform for consumption, I ask why I would invest money if, moreover, in that country, they are paying me rates of 27 percent. I believe that we can ask entrepreneurs for everything; they can be labeled as whiners, but what cannot be done is to ask them to do things that you or none of us here would do. There is a maxim in politics, always: we must ask others for what we are willing or capable of doing ourselves. If we are not doing it, what enables us to ask the rest of society to do things that we would not do?

In this sense, Madam President, the reform being made to the Capital Markets Law I believe will cause more problems than solutions. Moreover, there is much to say about this because, in reality, all the battery of powers and empowerment that was given to the National Securities Commission is being reduced. Powers that were also of the Central Bank of the Republic of Argentina are being eliminated under the pretext that there is an overlap between the National Securities Commission and the BCRA. No, Madam President, there is no overlap of functions. There are absolutely complementary functions between those who have monetary regulation and those who have regulation of securities on the other hand. They are not overlapping; they are absolutely complementary.

Adding a little more to what is the development, because this is presented for development, I regret to say that I have bad news to give you: this will not contribute to any productive development.

I listened to Senator Closs from Misiones talk about why credit lines that had been created with the modification of the Organic Charter of the Central Bank of the Argentine Republic were no longer being affected, which required banks to have a portion of their deposits in productive loans. Well, because this is not an industrial model, because this is not a model of value-added production. It is a model of financial value-added and speculation. Because when we modified the Organic Charter of the Central Bank of the Argentine Republic and required banks to lend, they also made good business. It is not that banks were losing money. One can look at the balances of the Central Bank of the Argentine Republic and of financial entities and see that they were making money too. It was not that we were forcing them to lose money. No one can force the financial system to lose money because if you force the financial system to lose money, the system collapses, as it has collapsed at other times.

So, here powers are eliminated like those in articles 19 and 20, which must have been one of the most "lobbied" modifications, the subject of the most lobbying, by the large law firms and the large consulting and financial advisory companies in the city to repeal this article 20. Moreover, article 20 was the subject of precautionary measures by the current president of the Republic when he was the head of Government of the City of Buenos Aires. At the behest of some group that said that this article could be used against him, a precautionary measure was presented in court to ensure it was not applicable to any company based here in the Autonomous City of Buenos Aires. I am talking about this article 20, which we never actually applied. And its precautionary measure was presented before a judge in the first instance in administrative contentious matters who declared it valid. Finally, as it should be, a chamber, two years later, almost when we were finishing the government and were leaving, decreed the precautionary measure of article 20. And on the other hand, today the jurisdiction is also changed, moving from administrative contentious to commercial what was previously in administrative contentious. It is not that one jurisdiction is better than the other or that they are interchangeable. It is simply that when it is decided to move from commercial jurisdiction to administrative contentious, it aims to make a distinction between what are competencies in commercial and civil matters and what is administrative contentious matter. Why? Because when the State exercises the superpowers it must have to ensure that the macroeconomy, the currency, and an economy do not overflow and affect society as a whole, it does not do so as a private agent, as it can be a subject of commercial or civil law, it does so precisely with its state power to safeguard the common good.

This was also modified, and in general, the norm reverts to the situation prior to the enactment of the Capital Market Law of 2012, which was the old Capital Market Law from the Onganía era – dating back to the time of Onganía – and had as its main objective total deregulation, that is, self-regulation of the markets, this theory that markets self-regulate, which fell spectacularly like the Berlin Wall, as a speaker pointed out in that year 2012.

The second title, which is "Mortgage Bonds," to which they dedicate only five articles, relates to what is happening and will happen in the Argentine Republic with the famous mortgage loans adjusted by UVA. This aims to "securitize" the mortgage market. And some believe that with these loans, which are for the acquisition of already constructed goods, they are activating the market. No, look, the best productive mortgage credit program to activate the entire market was Pro.Cre.Ar. That was the real mortgage credit. Do you know why, Madam President? Because it was for things that were being built. When you give loans for goods that are already built, you also run the risk of a bubble and price inflation because, naturally, when financing is accessed for already constructed units, prices go up. And is it speculation? Yes, it is speculation, but it is also the law of supply and demand. Prices rise because there is a greater amount of credit, there is greater demand, the supply is not sufficiently large, and then they begin... In fact, one can see the chronicles in the newspapers, where the increase in property prices, in dollars, is recorded as a result of an increase in mortgage credit. When in reality, the best, the most virtuous mortgage credit is the one that provides loans to build houses because that is where we are truly stimulating the economy.

But I will also address, Madam President, some of the figures that are being created and with which we really need to be very careful. Investment management agents are being created. What does this mean? They are defined as investment management agents who provide regular advisory and management services, that is, in addition to banks. What does this mean? That what has been one of the most opaque systems in the world is being created, which has caused the greatest number of crises: shadow banking. That is, banking in the shadows. Investment managers appear who are regulated by the CNV, but who are not banks, therefore, they are not subject to the regulations of the Central Bank of the Argentine Republic. This is called shadow banking in the world, shadow banks. They have banking functions, produce derivatives, generate circulation, but they are not banks, that is, they are not regulated by the Central Bank of the Argentine Republic. This is very dangerous, Madam President, because it was precisely the modification, as I pointed out at the beginning of my intervention, that involved transforming commercial banks into investment banks, which originated the crisis – among other issues, obviously. The "securitization" of mortgages was also another cause, which is also here with the "securitization" of mortgages.

Look, we already have two "foundational" elements of the serious crisis of 2008 that, do you know why it did not impact our country, Madam President, and devastated other economies and governments? For a very simple reason: first, because since we did not have foreign financing, we financed ourselves with our own money. We did not have access to the capital market, as a result of the default that had occurred, even though we had already paid the IMF, and therefore, Argentina financed itself, it did not resort to the capital market for financing.

The other issue that prevented the contagion of the crisis with us was that our financial system was not connected by financing channels with what was happening in the United States and with what was happening in Europe with the subprime crisis. The world has still not recovered from the 2008 crisis. Some were crying on the stock market. I remember that when I went, they told me: "We are peripheral markets, we are not even emerging, it would be good if we were emerging, so we could connect with the whole world...". Well, look, I tell you that when a country and its financial system is connected today in the world without controls and safeguards and, moreover, with the vulnerability of an economy that requires external financing – as the economy of the Cambiemos model currently does – for its financing, well, we are in trouble. Here, contagion channels are being created in what we are sanctioning today with this modification of the Capital Market Law.

I will mention three or four things just so you can see the importance of what we are modifying, because I think there may not be a full understanding of all the derivative mechanisms that are being created through this capital market.

Look: in the case of mutual funds, the joint and unlimited liability between the managing company, the depositary company, and the quota holders, those who make up the mutual fund, is eliminated. This is serious because we are separating responsibilities, as if preparing the ground for, in the face of potential international financial stress, not to have responsibilities.

A new type of fund is incorporated with the capacity to replicate the behavior of a financial or stock index, or a basket of assets. A form of funds is created that is for very qualified investors. Also concerning.

In the case of derivatives, it is allowed that instead of being contracted in a clearinghouse – which is more transparent because it is more concentrated and there are more operations – the bilateral nature of financial derivatives is enabled, which also increases the risk of these toxic products, because ultimately these financial derivatives, after a while – which is not measured by electoral deadlines, but by economic deadlines – end up producing stress, end up producing problems throughout the system.

They also modify article 9 regarding the requirement for a person who has performed tasks in companies, in investment funds, in short, who has dedicated themselves to finance, in banks or whatever... The law required that at the time of being a member of the oversight body, the regulatory body – in this case, the National Securities Commission – there should be a gap of no less than two years between being a public official and performing those functions, so that there would not be what is now called a conflict of interest, but which in my neighborhood is called something else. In short, now they reduce it to just six months.

Thus, we could continue.

Well, article 20 is modified.

The prescription is also interrupted. That is, the current law establishes that when a company or a firm is sanctioned for having committed irregularities, the time of prescription for the sanction of the irregularities is interrupted when the company commits another type of irregularity. Well, we could continue mentioning many cases, but the truth is that – and this is what I am getting at – we are not dealing with a law for productive financing for SMEs. We cannot continue legislating titles. We do not legislate titles. We legislate content, norms, and therefore I want to warn that we are legislating in a direction that is absolutely contrary to what international standards indicate, which were the ones we received in the law that was enacted in this Chamber in 2012 and which was then subject to review for a year and a half by the International Organization of Securities Commissions and which even the SEC – that is, the regulatory commission of the United States – and also the regulatory body of England requested that we increase the penalties in the Penal Code regarding harmful conduct that violated the regulations.

In 2014, international organizations continued to warn that this law was about regulation and transparency. Because, moreover, after the enactment of the law, Argentina was removed from the gray list of the GAFFI. I say this for those who do not remember. After the enactment of the law and with various presentations made, finally, Argentina ends up removed from the gray list of the GAFFI. Now we are going backward, like a crab. We are returning to pre-regulation, we are returning to the self-regulation of the markets.

I want to tell you that, regardless of the fact that the government has changed, what cannot change is the responsibility of those of us who legislate to control when, in reality, we are doing exactly the opposite of what we upheld just two or three years ago.

Do you know why? Because this law, which will surely be enacted, will have effects. There is a creation of derivatives. Evidently, Caputo's hand is there. It is very well written. I must say that in terms of generating derivatives and introducing new figures, it is very good and reaffirms the character and the speculative model of the current economic model. Do not have any doubts about that. So, it is very well written for those interests, but not for the interests of Argentines and much less for SMEs. I reiterate, Madam President: SMEs require that today the tariff hike be interrupted, that consumption be increased, that imports cease, and that money stop earning, simply for being deposited in a LEBAC, 27 percent interest.

I believe that for the responsibility that being in opposition demands, but more than that, I firmly believe and maintain that this is not a problem of opposition or government, it is a problem of whether we enact norms that we know will have a bad result. In reality, it has already had a bad result. We know that figures and derivatives are being created and that they are being absolutely permissive in terms of regulation and conduct of new agents and new forms of intervention in the financial market.

It is, then, simply an exercise of responsibility because, ultimately, to the vulnerability that the Argentine model currently has, which is being carried out, which is the permanent financing in hard currency, vulnerability is added to the national financial system. I remind you that the Argentine financial system was absolutely healthy and passed unscathed through the 2008 crisis. This financial system passed unscathed through the 2008 crisis, which caused the collapse of banks worldwide. Banks that were centennial closed, but here not a single bank fell. And it did not fall because there was a healthy financial system, because there was an economy based on production, on demand, on value-added, on consumption, and on wages.

Today, by sanctioning this law, what is being done is adding to the vulnerability of indebtedness the vulnerability of the Argentine financial system. I must say this because I believe that at some point, things finally happen, especially because – to conclude, Madam President – I have had the opportunity – I have said it on other occasions – to be a national legislator since 1995, in this chamber and also in the Chamber of Deputies.

I remember that in the Chamber of Deputies, in the months leading up to the collapse of 2001, laws were passed that ensured convertibility, that ensured that one peso was equal to one dollar. I believe that the last one passed back in October or November of 2001 was that law that stated that one peso was equal to one dollar and where it was said that everything was very well and that the financial system was very healthy.

I believe that with this regulation, far from creating a capital market aimed at production, we are generating an absolute festival of speculation that will not be free. Do you know what happens, Madam President? When these decisions and measures are taken, especially regarding banks and financial matters, there is nothing neutral, nor are there possibilities afterwards to patch them up through a law.

We are, I reiterate, adding a lot of vulnerability to the financial system. Notice that yesterday I read that in the Chamber of Deputies the possibility of "securitization" that the government now wants to do with the loans was frustrated. Do you remember when on December 27, in this same chamber, we talked about the almost 50 billion pesos that had been given through the Argenta card in loans months before the elections? Well, in the famous megadecree, they also wanted to pass the "securitization," in addition to the seizure of salary accounts, of those loans. Now, this is not for greater mortgage loans; this is for greater "securitization" of those being given with the UVA system.

In short, Madam President, I want to tell you that we, as we also did in the Chamber of Deputies, will vote negatively on the regulation, but when it is discussed in particular, we will support Title I, that is, the first 26 articles of the 219 that the law has, the 11 percent of the productive financing regulation, which is the only thing in the entire law that can be talked about as financing in this case for SMEs, reiterating that with these tariffs, without consumption, with this degree of importation and with the payment of LEBAC at 27, I don’t know why anyone would want to set up an SME in the Argentine Republic.

To conclude, when the incident occurred between you and Senator Fuentes following the motion made by Senator Petcoff Naidenoff, I know that you were upset and thought that they did not want to respect your call for a vote. Look, I believe that both Senator Petcoff Naidenoff and Senator Fuentes did a favor because, you know what happens? If we had approved a motion where we violated the regulations, anyone could have come forward to declare the nullity of this session, because we would not have convened according to the regulations. So it is not that someone wanted to bother you and not respect your authority to submit a matter to a vote. Simply, the regulations cannot be modified in that way.

With this clarification, which I wanted to tell you, so that you would not feel upset or mortified, I conclude my intervention.

Did you see? I respected the time: 40 minutes, 28 seconds.