Intervention in the session where we vote on the law to put a stop to the rate hike.

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

31 May 2018 · Senate session voting on the law to stop the rate hike

Context
Fernández de Kirchner addressed the Argentine Senate on May 31, 2018, during a legislative session voting on a bill to halt utility rate increases.
Main themes
Utility rate hikes, economic price distortions, peso devaluation, wages decline, energy subsidies, oil company compensation, YPF and Vaca Muerta, public vs private subsidies, Cambiemos government economic management, debt and reserves
Duration
~47 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,614
93rd percentile
Sentences
290
95th percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
10.0
20th percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
43rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 60%52%
  • Institutional 24%21%
  • Ceremonial 10%8%
  • Social 5%4%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 13%

290 sentences in 9 paragraphs

The session has been very long, but I would like to address my intervention with what I consider to be the real problem we have today. Many of the senators from our bloc who preceded me in speaking, as well as Senator Pais, have referred to technical issues. Senator Fernández Sagasti mentioned that, despite the rate hike, from December 2015 to the present, almost 90 percent of what was imported in crude oil during the period from 2003 to 2015 has already been imported. It can also be said that last year, gas production even fell. This year, it increased during the first quarter, due to the Vaca Muerta field. I will talk a little about Vaca Muerta later, because it seems that Vaca Muerta was given to us for free. It seems that Yacimientos Petrolíferos Fiscales is now Argentine because one day we woke up and what had been privatized had returned to Argentine ownership. But I want to return to the speech of the senator who reported on the majority's dispatch.

Today we talk about rates and rate hikes, but it is one of the five relative prices in the economy. The economy has five fundamental relative prices: the dollar, rates, interest rates, wages, and the prices of goods and services that are not public rates, but that pertain to private health insurance, educational services, etc. This is very important, because if one observes the price or the state of these five relative prices in the economy, their condition is catastrophic. Today we are discussing the rate hike, but the situation of Argentine society is aggravated not only by the arrival of the rate hike, but because the other prices have changed, and they have done so for the worse. There has been an exponential rate hike – we are talking about a 1,300 or 1,400 percent increase in electricity, gas, and 900 percent in water, etc. – but another fundamental price in the economy, wages, has depreciated. The dollar has skyrocketed, the interest rate is soaring, and the price of the things that people consume – food, clothing, goods, services, etc. – has also shot up. And this is somewhat what Senator Mayans was raising today in his capacity as a reporting member. When all of this comes together, the rate hike, the devaluation, the fall in wages, the runaway increase in prices, and an interest rate that makes access to credit for productive financing impossible because it is much easier and more profitable to do it speculatively, we are facing a very serious problem. The price of the dollar when Néstor Kirchner took office was approximately 2.98 pesos, and when we handed over the government on December 10, 2015, the price of the dollar was 9.86. In twelve and a half years, we had experienced a depreciation of 229 percent. The Cambiemos government, in two and a half years, has seen a depreciation of 155 percent. That counted at a dollar of 25; today it closed at 25.49, which means it is already more than 155. And since the dollar in Argentina is related to everything, despite what some legislators said at the door of the Casa de Gobierno, that one thing was inflation and another was the dollar, those of us who know how prices in the economy are managed and interrelated know that this will also impact even more on rates. Because the rate that is currently set has become outdated, due to the 25 percent devaluation that occurred in just fifteen days, when the government could not control and manage a currency run. Despite having had 62 billion dollars in reserves at the Central Bank, although most of those reserves were a result of debt, the truth is that it had the capacity to withstand, and yet, in fifteen days, it lost 10 billion dollars – this is the price of two YPFs and the price of restructuring the debt with the Paris Club – and still, they set the dollar at 25 pesos, with a 25 percent devaluation. Today we learned – and a senator from Santa Fe mentioned it – that a contract between the Ministry of Energy and the oil companies in their capacity as fuel distributors – that is, in the downstream – Axion, Shell, and YPF has become public. There, the Ministry – that is, the national state, the national treasury – commits to compensate the oil companies for the freezing of fuel prices, which is estimated to already have a 30 percent discrepancy. How is it that suddenly it is said that there are no resources to subsidize the rates for citizens, but we will have resources to compensate the oil companies for the freezing of fuels? It is a lie, Madam President, that subsidies have been eliminated. The subsidies financed by the national treasury have been eliminated, but now there are citizen subsidies: it is the Argentine citizens who are subsidizing the profitability of the companies; 16 billion dollars. Look, I want to show you something. You know that when we start to develop this type of analysis, they always start talking about populist governments, etc. Here I bring a PowerPoint from a conference that took place at FIEL through the chief economist of FIEL, Mr. Navajas, referring precisely to this issue of rates and the rate hike. Look, when the conference or presentation ended, in the final reflections they said: first, recognize that this – and they referred to the rate hike, the impact of rates – is a colossal income transfer operation from demand equivalent to 5 points of gross domestic product, half of which falls on families. Do you know what the figure is, Madam President and honorable legislators? It is 16 billion dollars, which means 5 points of GDP and which is transferred half by Argentine families, that is, the cost of residential consumption, and the other half, obviously, by the commercial and industrial sector, which extracts such a figure – 8 billion dollars – in two and a half years, to allocate it to the payment of services, instead of allocating a large part of those sums to the development of productive investment. I said, Madam President, that the five relative prices that are currently under discussion in Argentina have produced this serious situation, which will worsen, because the problem we have is that these rates will also have to be updated, starting from this devaluation that occurred. And it is not true that we all rejoice when the country or the government does poorly.

A little over a month ago, I was going to present a project – I have it here – on the issue of prepaid rates. We had decided in the bloc, given the constant increases in prepaid rates, to see if we could establish a system of public hearings so that there would be greater control over costs, to alleviate the issue of prepaid rates. But, you know what, Madam President? Following what happened with the rate issue, despite being signed by all the colleagues in the bloc – look at how far it goes, that it was not signed by Silvina Larraburu, who had not yet entered the bloc, that is, we had presented it more than a month and a half ago, almost two months – we have decided not to present it, because no one is happy to discuss these things. Moreover, anyone who can examine the projects I have presented as a deputy or senator – and not when I was in the government, but when I was an opposition senator or deputy – will never find issues related to policies of the Executive Power, because we were convinced that one can be an opponent, but that it is not good to politically speculate based on certain issues. And the truth, Madam President, is that in the face of the moment that Argentine society is experiencing, it is very difficult for me to hear colleagues say that there is no rate hike, or that the prices of rates are fine. It is also very difficult to hear when, for example, the president or some other colleagues ask where we are going to get the money. I ask, has anyone thought about the anguish, the despair of the people sitting in front of their electricity, gas, water, prepaid, expenses, rent, installment bills, wondering where they are going to get the money? Because, you know what happens? A president or a Parliament has many instruments. We have instruments of monetary policy, tax policy, and fiscal policy to be able to have resources and apply them one way or another. If some are anxious and say they do not have the solution to these issues, can you imagine the anguish of someone who only has a salary to face the payment of services and it is not enough? A salary that, moreover, today is much lower. When Kirchner took office as president, the minimum wage in Argentina was 85 dollars. When we finished the government on December 10, the minimum wage was 589 dollars. But not only had the minimum wage improved, but highly skilled workers, for example, workers at Siderar – the seamless pipe company that will soon celebrate seventy years of existence – had always had a historical average of about 800 dollars. They were always workers who were above the average of other industries. When our government ended, those workers earned, on average, 2,400 dollars. From the historical 800, they had gone to 2,400 dollars. Today, before the 25 percent devaluation, they were already earning 1,300 dollars. And I tell you something: I am sure that most of those workers must have voted for you. Do you know why, Madam President? Because they were promised that all workers who paid income tax would not pay. That phrase that “when I am president, no Argentine worker will pay income tax.” At that time, in 2015, 1,059,000 workers paid income tax; today, almost 2,000,000 workers pay income tax. We could also continue with the fact that this minimum wage in dollars of 589 on December 10 – and which, moreover, held the first place for a long time in terms of salary capacity in Latin America – has today lost a little more than 200 dollars and is at 380 dollars; more than 200 dollars and has dropped to fourth place, it has fallen four positions in the salary ranking. This is also related to rates, because if at the same time we are raising rates, we are lowering wages, we begin to decouple and disarm these five relative prices that must have a certain articulation for the economy to function, because the main problem we have in the face of this mess of rate hikes on one side, loss of purchasing power of wages on the other, runaway interest rates, devaluation…

The fall of GDP, well, in short… All of this together, Madam President, is creating a situation that I believe the government should observe and I think it should reconsider this tariff policy. And I believe that what is being proposed, which is to revert the tariffs to December and, in addition, to apply the salary variation to decide the increase, does not seem irresponsible to me. On the contrary, I can assure you that in terms of social harmony, in terms of keeping things from getting out of hand, it would be advisable for them to take it into account. Regarding the issue of the energy crisis, first, I think that the topic of the heavy legacy, as a rhetorical resource, as a media resource, is fine. But it seems to me that, at this point, we are the country that has incurred the most debt in the last two and a half years: more than 100 billion dollars. Does anyone believe that if the country had been bankrupt and in crisis, international markets would have lent us 100 billion dollars? Is it sensible? Does it make common sense? It seems to me that it does not. And I am not going to start pulling out here the copies of the debt issuances they made for the hundred years, or the debt bonds from last January. Or the prospectus, when they held the mini-Davos here, in Puerto Madero, where investors from all over the world came and the title was: “Argentina: land of opportunities.” It is very clear, Madam President, that the level of de-indebtedness with which the Cambiemos government started on December 10 was unprecedented in history. No one can deny this. The lowest level of indebtedness in hard currency, in foreign currency: 10 percent. So, to talk about a crisis in a country where crises have always been due to external strangulation, it seems to me, Madam President, that it is time to stop lying to the people. And I am not being aggressive; on the contrary. I do not call anyone irresponsible. I believe that these are misguided policies. Or not. Some say they are not misguided; some say they are policies aimed at benefiting certain groups. Look at the energy issue: Senator Mayans spoke about how Argentina, during the twelve and a half years of government, had a significant increase in megawatt generation. But not only in terms of megawatt generation: there has been talk of energy transport and energy generation. I want to point out that in 2003, in high voltage transmission lines, Argentina had 9,083 linear kilometers of high voltage lines of 500 and 132 throughout the country. To give you an idea, the first electrical investment in Argentina was made at the end of the 19th century. We will not calculate from there. Let’s calculate from 1910, for example. In 1910, the first large energy generation plant was inaugurated in Dock Sud. In the Centennial, the first energy generation plant was inaugurated. In those hundred years, Argentina had built 9,083 kilometers of high voltage lines. Do you know how many high voltage lines were built between 2003 and 2014? 5,500 kilometers of high voltage lines – of 500 – connecting the entire country, even to areas that had never been connected. This means, Madam President, speaking in terms of electric energy transport, that in twelve and a half years we built 61 percent of the high voltage transport of the Republic of Argentina. And, as they always say that these are works that do not exist, here are senators from all provinces and all regions, from both the ruling party and the opposition.

I will enumerate: NEA-NOA connection, 1,200 kilometers; Comahue-Cuyo, 708 kilometers; third line of Yacyretá… We completed the entire third line of Yacyretá, in addition to finishing the hydroelectric plant of Yacyretá, which no one had finished. We finished it. Third line of Yacyretá, 9,012 kilometers; Patagonia, 1,897 kilometers. Do you know, senators, that the high voltage lines, for electric energy transport, only reached Choele Choel? Kirchner took them, first, to Puerto Madryn, almost to Pico Truncado, and I ended up taking them to the other end, to connect them with Río Turbio, Calafate, and Río Gallegos. San Juan-Mendoza connection, 175 kilometers; Recreo-La Rioja, 190 kilometers. Look at the investment that was made. We were paying subsidies to the people! We were paying the debt that had been left to us. Do you remember that they “defaulted” the debt in 2001? We restructured it in 2005, first, and 2010, at 93 percent, and then, in addition, we had made this investment and were paying the debt. The famous corralito. The corralito that caused the fall of a government, because it was the corralito that caused the fall of the government. We paid for it. 5 points of GDP were issued in bonds; 9.8 billion dollars. Kirchner paid 1.9 billion in bonds. I think it was in 2007. Cristina “the fool” ended up paying in 2012 the 7.7 billion dollars of the savers whose savings were taken in 2001. Look: corralito, which was the debt of those who were here; debt of those who were outside, who had also been “defaulted” on the bonds. We invested in this and, what did we also do in generation? It is that, when we arrived, we not only found the debt of the corralito, the “defaulted” external debt. There was also debt owed to the electricity generators. What did Kirchner do then? Instead of paying the electricity generators, the Foninvemem was developed. What is this? A program by which, instead of paying the generators the debt prior to 2013, we said: “No, we are not going to pay the debt. We are going to build, with that money that we would have to pay you, thermal generators in the Republic of Argentina and you will then enter as shareholders of those thermal generators.” Six thermal generators were built for a total of 4,600 megawatts in the Republic of Argentina. The thermals are gas-fired. I heard today that the energy matrix in Argentina is oil-based. No, Madam President, the energy matrix in Argentina is fundamentally gas-based. That of gas, obviously, and that of electricity as well, because over 60 percent of the electricity energy matrix is gas-based. We built six generators: three in Santa Fe and three in the province of Buenos Aires. We named them: Manuel Belgrano, José de San Martín, Vuelta de Obligado, Ensenada de Barragán, Brigadier López, and Guillermo Brown, in Campana, Timbúes, Ensenada, Sauce Viejo, and Bahía Blanca. If I am lying, let any senator from those places, if it is a lie that these works exist, that they do not work, that they do not generate electricity, please say so. We named them after the national heroes because that is how we are; we love our country. Maybe, I don’t know, perhaps when you do them you will name them, I don’t know, “the wild puma,” “the cuddly jaguar,” but we love the heroes and well…, that’s why, San Martín, Belgrano, Obligado, Brown. It was 4,600 megawatts of generation in that Foninvemem plan. What did we do next? We began to transfer them to the private sector. To us, who are told that we are not a government friendly to the market, of these six thermal generators, four have already been transferred to private shareholders. And two, Ensenada de Barragán, located in Ensenada, province of Buenos Aires, and Brigadier López, located in Sauce Viejo, Santa Fe, are the two that you have put up for privatization in the famous decree that you will surely address with the laws later. Look: we were paying the debts, we were generating, we were transporting, and, in addition, what did we think? Since we believe that energy is something very important, fundamental for the development of a country, in order to recover energy sovereignty, we made the decision to nationalize Yacimientos Petrolíferos Fiscales. It is remarkable that no one has had this recognition, especially because now I see the president in Vaca Muerta all the time.

But, if it had been up to you, Madam President, Vaca Muerta would still belong to Repsol because all of you voted negatively on the nationalization of YPF…. Not everyone here, Naidenoff, it is true. I think Rozas also voted positively. But, you, Madam President, were a deputy. How did you vote? How did you vote on the nationalization of YPF, of Vaca Muerta? How did you vote? Ah, you voted negatively! Look how interesting… Look how interesting… Then they tell us that they had an energy crisis, that we had done nothing for energy, and now the president can’t stop talking about Vaca Muerta. He goes and takes photos. He almost takes it – he said the other day in the speech – as a personal company. But look at that! But instead of taking it as a personal company, the president should have institutionally asked his deputies, his legislators, to vote for the nationalization, because if we had not voted for the nationalization of YPF, today Vaca Muerta would still belong to Repsol. That is why I believe we have done a lot for energy sovereignty. This cost us criticism from you saying that we did not respect the market, that we were going to drive investments away from Argentina. Tell me, what investments did you bring, if the investments you are making, you are making in Vaca Muerta? You, who told us that we were the ones scaring the market because we had nationalized YPF, today are the ones telling the whole country: “And Vaca Muerta, look how great!” It’s incredible. This can only be done with a formidable media shield, like the one you have. There is no other explanation for this. But, well, here we are with YPF and Vaca Muerta and we are also, Madam President, with the issue of what is called “responsibility.” A lot has been said about the lack of responsibility of the opposition. I want to tell you something regarding this: I believe that there is a lot of irresponsibility in things that are happening. There are legislators here who are from the ruling party, but when they go to the provinces where the governorships are Peronist, for example, they file lawsuits in court over the increases that the provincial public service companies make in tariffs to pass on the price of the megawatt that Cammesa charges them today. Santa Cruz, for example, and also Catamarca. The other day I was talking with the governor of Catamarca and she told me that the Court of Justice of the province of Catamarca had made her return tariffs. It was said here today that they were going to make the provinces return the tariffs that they had charged the people in excess. This has already happened – I tell you – in the province of Catamarca at the request of presentations made by those who are from the ruling party here and say that the tariff hike is fine, and that when it goes down in Catamarca or Santa Cruz they say it is outrageous that the governors or provincial governments raise the tariffs. This is what is happening. This is indeed irresponsibility, Madam President. In 2011, a few days after winning the elections, we made a decision regarding tariff adjustments and subsidies. Look at what happened with the press. This is indeed irresponsibility. 6/11/2011: “The government prepares drastic reductions in subsidies.” “Buses: they warn that the fare could cost double.” This is from 2011, two days later. “The government rushes the removal of subsidies in the conurbation,” 27/11/2011. “Subsidies: official pressure to add more resignations.” One thing I forgot. Do you remember that we inaugurated a registry for voluntary resignation from subsidies? Out of 14,000,000 electricity users and 8,000,000 gas users, do you know how many signed up to voluntarily resign from the subsidies?: 32,000, Madam President. This also speaks to some other issues in the Republic of Argentina. And they continued. “The adjustment reaches the interior: taxes and tariffs increase.” “The removal of subsidies will reach the middle class in 60 days.” “They extend the elimination of subsidies to more households.” This is all from 2011. And the problem is that one can think about this: it’s the newspapers that say this. No, it’s not the newspapers. That is the script that then, twenty-four hours a day, echoes in newspapers and television generating adverse climates for a government when it had to make decisions. But it didn’t end there. They continued. This is from the anthology, because in 2014 also the Minister of Economy, Axel Kicillof, announces “a tariff hike,” they say. Look. “The Kicillof adjustment follows the most orthodox recipe of the International Monetary Fund.” It’s incredible.

This was published on March 28, 2014. "Business outlook: in addition to the devaluation of the currency, the increase in interest rates, and the visible decline in the purchasing power of wages, the government is now adding a significant increase in service rates." I want to read the beginning of this note, which is from an important economic commentator who is read not only by political leaders but also by businesspeople. Here it says: "Axel Kicillof, with the significant increase in public rates – which was decided by the Casa Rosada, obviously – completed yesterday the orthodox adjustment of the economy. On average, the adjustment reaches – can you guess how much the terrible adjustment was? – 20 percent, but in some cases, water rates rise by 400 percent and gas rates, over one hundred percent – look: rates over one hundred percent." Thus, the Ministry of Finance aligns itself with the traditional policies recommended by the International Monetary Fund – to which, of course, we have never gone, nor have they come to us – and leaves behind a narrative that has little to do with economic reality." If one were to read this, it would seem applicable now. But now they do not write it. "The minister applies the orthodox plan with an intention – this is the biggest thing of all –: to try to please international financial centers in order to be able to re-indebt Argentina." These things were said about us. What is happening now is hidden and silenced. But they invented things that did not happen. And what did the opposition of that time say? I was able to rescue a tweet from you, Madam President. It is from 10/11/2015, six days before the runoff: Gabriela Michetti, November 16, 2015: "Rates should not be increased. We must favor the humblest people who pay very high service fees." This is what you said, Madam President, when you were a candidate for vice president, six days before the runoff. "And you talk to us about lies and truth?! Do you really have the face to talk about lies in the Republic of Argentina?! But please…! Madam President: you have tired of lying about everything. To the workers, that they would not pay taxes; to the users, that there would be no rate hikes, that there would be no devaluation, that they would never go to the International Monetary Fund. Do you remember that expression: "But Daniel, you sound like a panelist from 6, 7, 8!"? Do you know why you can do all this? Because of the media impunity you have. But, you know what? It works against you, because you thought you could do anything; that is the issue of having media impunity. In the end, you end up overstepping in the decisions you make, and then the crisis becomes uncontrollable. Today, we have a level of indebtedness that we did not have even close in 2015. We have a dollar that we do not know how much it will end up being, but we presume it, because we know that the International Monetary Fund will require you to update the exchange rate to what they consider possible to pay, because those 100 billion dollars they have lent you we will have to pay back all. And the International Monetary Fund comes to guarantee that there are dollars to be able to pay them. This is what Senator Fuentes said today when he said that this began with the payment to the vulture funds. I have no doubt, Madam President, that there began the second cycle of indebtedness of the Republic of Argentina, which we are now seeing unfold in all its splendor. I think we should really take things differently – we cannot continue believing that with lies or because the media provide a media shield – because, at some point, the money will have to be paid back. And when the demands come, we will evidently have to address them here, in Parliament, regardless of whether you decide to or not. That is why, Madam President, I believe it is important for you to understand that the opposition is not irresponsible. On the contrary, it is not irresponsible because we have never presented projects… I was looking the other day and saw a project from Senator Naidenoff. In 2009, he presented a project to suspend the application of the rates. Let me see if I can find the project? Look… Here I have it. Look: year 2009, suspension of resolution 1.169/08, new electricity rates from the National Energy Secretariat for a period of 180 days for the provinces of the NEA and NOA regions.

Among the grounds, it asked us to suspend a rate for the NEA-NOA. And look at what it said: "In this case and many others, we consider that the current rate increase violates the essential rights of the human being, since the lower-income sectors, when paying for electricity consumption, will not be able to meet other expenses and minimum requirements for their dignified survival." I have been in opposition. I never presented a project like this. We are very responsible, Madam President, and I believe that the gesture and the signal – I will finish soon – that the government could give by accepting, in the same way that it sat down to negotiate with the… How can Aranguren negotiate with the oil companies and not negotiate with us the suspension of rates? Let’s see, what is the reason? What is the reason? Do we have to end up thinking that the reason is because those who collect, as Senator Anabel Fernández Sagasti said today, are the president's friends? Is it Caputo, is it Mindlin, is it Lewis? Is that why you cannot negotiate, sit down with the companies and tell them: "Do not raise rates anymore"? The increase has been very large, Madam President. So, I believe that a responsible opposition… And the truth is that you cannot complain about the opposition or, at least, a part of the opposition that you have had. I remember how you were when you were our opposition. You left us, in 2010, without a budget. We had no budget, Madam President. I believe you were also a deputy, right? You did not vote for the budget. You left us without a budget. So, I believe you have had a very large support from broad sectors of the opposition. It would be good if, perhaps, if you do not want to talk to another opposition, perhaps, if you do not want to talk to the opposition that you consider irrational, as a senator said the other day here, do not talk, but talk to the rational ones, talk to the rational opponents and reach an agreement with the rational ones so that the whole society does not live with the anguish that is being lived today. There are people who do not turn on the gas heater, Madam President. People's habits regarding heating have changed. There are buildings here, two blocks away, where one can shower until nine in the morning and from six in the afternoon because during the day they turn off the heating. Do you remember when you laughed when Chávez said how one should shower? Now, we find that they tell us how we have to change light bulbs, how we have to heat ourselves, at what time we have to turn on, how it is convenient for us to turn on, if it is convenient for us to be with boots, without boots, with a coat or without a coat. The truth is that I do not remember having lived these things in Argentina. But not only twelve and a half years ago, but I do not remember having lived them ever in the Republic of Argentina. The truth is that coming from such a liberal government that leaves everything so much to the impulse of each one, that they let us find work at the impulse of each one or that the salary also reaches at the impulse of each one, then, at what time can they shower, how will they heat themselves, because when one is liberal, one must be liberal for everything. So, Madam President, to conclude, I will refer to the legal part, because it was also said that this law was unconstitutional. This law is not unconstitutional. Look, this Parliament, if it gathers 66 percent of the senators and senators and 66 percent of the deputies, can enact a law to modify the Constitution. Modify the Constitution! I will finish. We can even modify the form of government. If we enact a law in which we say: declare the need to reform the Constitution and reform article 1, where it is declared that we are federal and presidential and we become unitary, like Chile, and parliamentary, like any European country, the Parliament can do it. How can a Parliament that can modify the Constitution with qualified majorities not be able to provide a regulatory framework and declare the emergency?! Moreover, the emergency can only be declared by Parliament. The Executive Power cannot declare the emergency. Emergencies are declared by Parliament, period. It is unconstitutional for the Executive to do so, not Parliament; therefore, it is absolutely constitutional. Regarding the budget, Madam President, as several senators have already pointed out, it ended on December 28. Ten hours had passed since we had approved the budget in these same chambers, and the Chief of Cabinet along with the President of the Central Bank, Caputo and Dujovne said that inflation was no longer 10, it was 15. Today everyone is already talking about 25 or 30. The dollar that was 19 in that budget…

So, Madam President, I believe that we are seriously making a contribution to improve a situation that is becoming quite unmanageable. Thank you very much, Madam President.