Intervention in the session on the Voluntary Termination of Pregnancy Law

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

9 August 2018 · Session on the Voluntary Termination of Pregnancy Law

Context
Fernández de Kirchner addressed the Argentine Senate in August 2018 during the historic debate on the Voluntary Interruption of Pregnancy bill.
Main themes
Abortion rights and legalization, women's health and reproductive rights, legislative debate on IVE law, poverty and social exclusion, state obligation to address unsafe abortion, progressive social legislation history, violence against women and femicide, contraception access, solidarity with legislators facing harassment, life as a political value
Duration
~22 min
69th percentile
Words
2,580
69th percentile
Sentences
109
67th percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
3.16
68th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 74%72%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Economic 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

109 sentences in 7 paragraphs

Yes, Madam President: I want to express that, as our bloc informed on June 28 when the IVE institute was sanctioned in the Chamber of Deputies, we will support this partial sanction. And first of all, I want to express my solidarity with all the legislators who have suffered insults, slurs, and disqualifications. We have, for example, in the case of the vice president of our bloc, Nancy González, who in the city of Puerto Madryn faced the situation where the front of her business was painted calling her a murderer or saying that she killed her grandchildren, among other insults. This is almost to say: "Welcome to Argentina," right? Especially when, as legislators or as governors, we take positions that break a bit from the status quo. This is never free: it is never free to oppose or work against the status quo, whatever it may be. And I think the first issue will be to characterize what we are talking about. I have always voted for life and I have governed for and by life: always. I voted for life when, in these same seats, we voted for the nullification of the laws of Obedience Due and Final Point; a tribute to the lives that had been cut short of thousands and thousands of young people, women, pregnant women, children stripped of their identity, and appropriated babies. I voted for life when we voted for humanized childbirth in 2004; the comprehensive protection of children and adolescents in 2005; comprehensive sexual education and tubal ligation and vasectomy as contraceptive methods back in 2006; patients' rights. That was already when I was president. The comprehensive law for the prevention, sanction, and eradication of violence against women. Then, when same-sex marriage was sanctioned; or in 2012, gender identity; with the modification of the Penal Code to include the figure of femicide. We owe this to a foreigner in Argentina. Two French tourists were murdered in the province of Salta: Cassandre Bouvier and Houria Moumni. And when I had the opportunity to travel to France as president, her father, Jean-Michel Bouvier, requested a meeting in which he earnestly and emotionally asked me to include the figure of femicide in the Penal Code; and so it was done. In 2013, assisted reproductive techniques; Civil and Commercial Code in 2014, as well. And we carried out health policies that were a model, such as the Plan Nacer; the National Vaccination Calendar – nineteen free vaccines –; emergency contraception; a regime for surgical contraception interventions; an operational plan for the reduction of infant mortality; policies for children; and we could go on. Universal Child Allowance: perhaps one of the most important creations to defend life, because there is not one life, two lives, three lives: there is one life and it must always be defended. Also, when we allocated funds for the prevention of unwanted pregnancies. Between 2003 and 2015, resources for this sector increased by 1,046 percent. If one looks at this year's budget, it has only been executed at 12 percent. That is why, when today the senator from Mendoza spoke and recounted the experiences of her fellow citizens from the Lavalle department, where they do not have enough contraceptives and have to wait hours for 25 women in a day to be able to access them, I believe it is essential for us to agree on what we want in terms of prevention and care for women and the policies that are an obligation of the State.

I want to tell you that it is not easy to address a topic of this nature, but it is indeed an obligation to do so based on the understanding that, beyond our beliefs and convictions – all respectable – beyond these issues today, when it is rejected… This is the most serious thing about tonight, it seems to me: one can agree or not; one can propose a modification, but we are rejecting a project without proposing any alternative and the situation will remain the same. Look: if I were certain that by voting negatively or rejecting the partial sanction coming from the Deputies there would be no more abortions in the Republic of Argentina, I would have no doubt in raising my hand. The problem is that this Body will today reject what comes as a partial sanction from the Deputies and abortions will continue to occur in Argentina; and there it is no longer a matter solely of convictions or beliefs, but of responding as legislators to a problem that exists. I want to tell you that in the first speech I heard, which was that of the informing member, when he also rejected this project – I will read it so I do not make a mistake – he said something that I believe constitutes a stance that underlies many of the speeches of those who reject today. I say that the real problem is poverty and that we should fight against poverty, against the lack of resources, etc., etc. Look, here I have what the informing member said: This is the real drama that is not visible in this project. We are not resolving the issues and conditions of exclusion, vulnerability, subjugation, asymmetrical power relations, poverty, absence of resources… No, no! This is only about the voluntary interruption of pregnancy. This description obeys the abolition of patriarchy: for example, asymmetrical relationships, abuses of power, discrimination suffered by the female collective. In that framework, this issue we are addressing is one of its aspects, but not the only one. I believe we have an obligation as legislators to build ourselves a little and our vision of society. Some say it was my daughter, a feminist activist, who made me change my mind. No, it was not my daughter. The truth is, Madam President, ladies and gentlemen legislators, she opened my mind regarding addressing the feminist issue from a different place than one had seen it. Perhaps because I was fortunate, from a very young age, to be part of the generation – educated, formed or shaped, if you will – of those years of the sixties and seventies when the birth control pill emerged, the miniskirt, Woodstock, the Cuban revolution.

Ultimately, we did not have this gender issue. Suddenly, this was a gust of wind in the world; then there were setbacks. But the truth is that in that generation that was later annihilated, there was no distinction between man and woman: we were equals. Moreover, I was fortunate to marry and be the partner of a man who never considered me “his” woman, but “his” equal. But we must also understand that this is not the reality for many women. Those who believe that only poor women suffer the power relations of men are mistaken. Or are you going to tell me that you do not know middle-class and upper-class women who also suffer the blows of a patriarchal society? Or are we not going to find out when a woman is beaten for not wanting to have sexual relations? And it is not necessary to be poor for that to happen: it can happen to someone who is rich or middle class. I believe we must take into account that it is more than a gender issue; it is a generational issue. Young people, once again, perceive the change of era and demand to be heard. If you want to know who made me change my mind, it was the thousands and thousands of girls who took to the streets! Seeing them address the feminist issue; seeing them criticize, but also describe the reality of a patriarchal society, must place us all in a different position. This law will not pass tonight, but I want to tell everyone that it will not be this year, it will be next year or the year after. I also want to tell all those young women who took to the streets that the feminism they are building is slowly deconstructing a macho society. So, at the same time, a feminism is being built that must also incorporate other issues that, ultimately, are always economic. Because – as Senator Fuentes said today – there is always an economic issue in the relationships of subordination and power; although he states – and forgot to mention it today in his speech; this is his, not mine – that there is also in men an atavistic fear of women's sexuality. He says that so that tomorrow no one headlines “Cristina says they are afraid of her because of sex.” No. I say, Madam President, that it is necessary for all of us to deconstruct a vision and an idea of society. I ask all young women and the entire feminist collective not to be angry with religions or with the Church or with priests. Keep building that strength that I could clearly perceive last March 8. The first March 8 occurred in 2015; there – I was still president – the “Ni Una Menos” collective – which at that time was led or had developed a group of journalists – was fundamentally concerned with femicides, with gender violence. They fought because “Ni Una Menos” meant “not one more woman dead due to gender violence.” Look at the evolution that the movement has taken in such a short time! That first year was exclusively linked to gender violence. However, already in 2016, the social aspect could be seen as part of that growing movement; and in 2017, the economic issues of feminism began to be clearly discussed regarding wage differences, employment, working conditions; also the violence that occurs in a society where the decision-making system is predominantly occupied by men.

But however, this year, this March 8 of 2018, one could observe in that immense mobilization, protagonists… They are celebrations; calm down.

Because I really believe we must understand – and especially also from my own political movement – that we will have to incorporate the feminist issue into the national and popular that characterized Peronism for decades. After the decade of the dictatorship, we incorporated the democratic issue; and then we said “we are national, popular, and democratic.” We will have to add “national, popular, democratic, and feminist,” because within the exploitation of workers, of capital over labor, there is also a subcategory of exploitation: a worker is exploited, but a working woman is more exploited because she earns less and works more. I almost forgot, because it seems that everything about women could only revolve around the IVE, but I remember in our government the incorporation of women, of the housewife's work, recognized in retirement. This is also empowerment. I remember what even Eva Perón could not achieve, which was to sanction as law the labor agreement for domestic workers; something that Evita could not achieve and we did. The truth is that life is defended in all aspects and at all times. There can be no defense of life when the budgets for Education, Health are continually being cut; when there are more and more people with greater problems of food subsistence or because they cannot pay their bills, because that is also living; it is impossible to live without resources or with those resources shrinking more and more. So, it seems to me that we should all be very careful when we try to claim that some defend life and others do not. I have always defended life. I defend life every time I vote against economic policies that mean that people are worse off. I have always voted here for life every time I have opposed policies of social restriction, of denial of rights, of precarization of rights. Precarizing rights is voting against life; because we ruin people's lives when they do not have good health, when they do not have a good salary, when they do not have a good job, when they do not have enough money, when entire families are sleeping on the street! And we see that it is people who until recently had a quality of life, because some are surrounded by furniture, beds, cushions…! This is what is happening!

So, I believe we need to have a lot of strength. In this, I also want to address the thousands and thousands of young people who are in the streets: I think we need to make a very big effort because today we are not proposing an alternative to a problem that exists. The problem of abortion exists in Argentina, it happens, it happens; whether we agree or not, it happens! And we have to provide an answer as legislators. If you don't like this answer, let's discuss another one, but we are not discussing any answer. Today we are closing the curtain, bringing down the curtain, rejecting. We should never reject. I believe we essentially need to propose an alternative. That is why, Madam President, and in this I also want to acknowledge that… And I have discussed this with many feminist women: the issue of convictions. We always vote with convictions, we always vote with convictions. The problem arises when the convictions we want are imposed on other people who do not share those convictions: that is where the conflict erupts. Because, ultimately, our role as legislators is to regulate relationships in society so that everyone can articulate and harmonize, but here, in this specific case, in the face of a society that is demanding a response to a problem it has or to rights it wants, because they want rights… So, I believe we should all make a very big effort to respond to those demands, which –I reiterate– will not be this year: it will be in two years or in one year, when, by regulation, following the rejection, it can be addressed again. Well: with all the convictions of each one, let us think about whether it is really fair that, in a society that has reached this level of mobilization and understanding, we continue to impose our behavior on others. Because it is clear that this was not a law that forced anyone to have an abortion. Moreover: let us not use that word anymore. Just as in the United States Martin Luther King insisted that the term "black" not be mentioned because it meant stigmatization, let us speak of voluntary interruption of pregnancy. That is why, Madam President, it is a pity that we have not been able to reach a consensus, because the problem will continue to exist exactly as it did before we addressed this discussion. It is necessary, I reiterate, to make an effort to provide a response.

Look, I was thinking: I have two granddaughters and I am 65 years old. In fifteen years I will be 80: yes, 80 years old. Elenita, my granddaughter, will be in 5th grade and María Emilia in 4th grade. And the truth is that by the time they are in 4th and 5th grade, this will be sanctioned. Do not doubt it. And the truth is that I was thinking that their classmates at school will ask them: “Hey, what about your grandmother, when she was a senator?” And, well: I think I do not want to occupy the place where, when young people remember me, they remember me in the way many often refer to those who never understand what is happening; thank you very much, Madam President.