Intervention in the session where we discuss the 2019 Budget project.

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

15 November 2018 · Session discussing the 2019 Budget project

Context
Fernández de Kirchner addressed the Argentine Senate in November 2018 during debate on the 2019 Budget, arguing it was a zero-deficit austerity plan dictated by the IMF rather than a genuine development budget.
Main themes
Zero deficit policy critique, IMF influence on Argentine budget, fiscal deficit as counter-cyclical tool, 2019 budget debate, external debt and economic constraint, international comparisons of austerity failure, Argentina's development model, G-20 fiscal policy, unemployment and recession risks, bimonetary economy, industrial policy gaps
Duration
~48 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,728
93rd percentile
Sentences
286
95th percentile
Readability
55
75th percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
3.13
65th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 71%70%
  • Institutional 14%13%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

286 sentences in 6 paragraphs

I believe that several senators and perhaps some legislators who have a certain seniority in these matters and who have gone through different governments, different budgets, and various debates, must converge on something and agree on something. In reality, we are not discussing a budget law today; a budget law in the sense of what the budget is, of what it was conceived to be. The government's proposal uses certain instruments of macroeconomics, public policies, to guide state spending and investment and thus have a model of development, a model of state management. We are not facing this. In reality, we are facing spreadsheets that were designed to meet the zero deficit, which, under the title of zero deficit – which we already dealt with once in 2001, even as a law during the government of the first Alliance – under the zero deficit law, hides a design, a drawing if you will – as senators have repeatedly said – aimed at debt repayment and, fundamentally, under the aegis, the planning of the International Monetary Fund. So, in reality, we are not dealing with the budget law, but with a zero deficit law. Now, in addition to the zero deficit law that was discussed here in 2001 and that had no results, in reality, there must have been seven or eight experiences of zero deficit in the world and none were successful. Most of them were also under the planning or direction of the International Monetary Fund.

Look, Mr. President, Portugal attempted the zero deficit law in 1999; Argentina, in 2000; Pakistan in 2005; Ukraine, in 2008; Belarus, in 2009; Greece, in 2010; Italy, in 2012… None of these countries were successful. Some numbers: Portugal, in 1999, zero deficit law. They had to reach zero deficit by 2004. It failed. In 2004, Portugal's fiscal deficit was 3.8. Do you know what it was at the time of deciding on the zero deficit? It was only 0.4. So after five years of starting with a deficit of 0.4 and embarking on the zero deficit policy, it ended with a deficit of 3.8. In 1999, unemployment was 4.3 and ended 2004 at 6.6. And as GDP fell due to the recession, because revenue fell, public debt rose from 51% of GDP to 62%. Well. To conclude, as a summary, the three Ds: deficit, debt, and unemployment in 2004. Today, Portugal, since the assumption of a government that came in 2015 – the Socialist Party, which came in second in the elections but formed an unprecedented coalition with the Communist Party and the left – has managed to grow the economy. What’s the formula? Simple: they decided to stimulate consumption through increases in pensions and wages, among other measures and public policies. Pakistan attempted in 2006 and set the goal of reaching zero deficit by 2008. The case of Pakistan is notable because it had a primary surplus of 1.6 and reached 2008 with a deficit of 2.9. There, too, the International Monetary Fund had to intervene. Ukraine: in 2008 announced zero deficit for 2009. It failed; it went from 3 to 6. Greece, perhaps the most paradigmatic and well-known case. No successful case is known; no successful experience in applying the famous zero deficit. And, as I said on December 27 of last year, when the budget was discussed, I believe there is a misdiagnosis by the government in conceiving fiscal deficit as the great problem of Argentina. At that time, I said that the great structural problem of the Argentine economy was the external constraint, the scarcity of dollars to sustain the activity, development, and growth of the economy in a balanced and permanent way. This is the great problem that Argentina has, in addition to a bimonetary economy. Added to this is a lack of project, model, and international insertion in a world that is already in the fourth industrial revolution. We do not have a model of insertion. At least, the government does not have it. Because I was listening attentively today, as I came here, to the reporting member, head of the Budget and Finance Committee, who put forward as a model to imitate what Argentina was like a century ago. He said that a hundred years ago we were the first country in the world. But we were the first country in a completely primary, agro-exporting economy with no added value. And I want to remind everyone that the first centenary of Argentina was celebrated under a state of siege due to the level of repression and growing rebellion against widespread misery and poverty. I am not glorifying the fiscal deficit. I am not saying that “long live the fiscal deficit.” I am saying that the fiscal deficit can be a counter-cyclical instrument in times of recession. In fact, in a few days, a G-20 meeting will be held here. And do you know what the fiscal results of the countries and the largest economies of the G-20 are? It is a report from the World Bank from 2017. Fiscal result as a percentage of GDP: Brazil, 7.80% deficit; China, 4% deficit; India, 6.50%; Saudi Arabia, also a G20 member, 7.30%; Australia, which is always presented to us as a model to imitate and follow, 2.20% deficit; the United States, 4.60%. We all know that the largest deficit, both fiscal and commercial, is that of the United States, the world's largest economy. This means, then, that if the world's largest economy has the largest commercial and fiscal deficit, the deficit is an instrument and not the most important problem of the economy.

Look, of the countries participating in the G-20, only two are surplus countries, they have a positive fiscal result: South Korea and Germany. Germany, 1.10% and South Korea, 1.90%. Remember this well, because it also relates to another issue that is heard repeatedly; I hear it in all speeches. Additionally, one thing that we are taught as children in school is that Argentina is a country very rich in natural resources. But if one looks at the latest report from the World Bank, for example, The Changing Wealth of Nations, from 2018, when analyzing the endowment of natural resources per capita, Argentina turns out to be one of the lowest, $16,185 per capita in natural resources, compared to Peru, which has almost $25,000, compared to Chile, which has $45,000, compared to Brazil, which has almost $37,000, compared to Canada, which has $52,000; and I want to stop at one case, Australia. It should not be the first time it is heard that we should be very similar to Australia in development. Do you know how much Australia has in natural resources per capita? It has $180,000. But Australia, due to its geostrategic location, being part of the British community, and also being a major supplier, first to Japan, and now, along with New Zealand, also to the Chinese economy, has an economy different from ours. But I think there is a great fantasy in believing that, through natural resources, we will get out. Look, Argentina is not part of a high endowment of natural resources. Therefore, a strategy of concentrating on these resources is not only socially and politically unsustainable but also economically unwise. What do I mean by this, Mr. President? That a budget, ultimately, a government must define what the macroeconomic instruments will be with which it will promote the development of society. We have always maintained and executed demand – not the only one because investment is important, but there is no investment without demand – as the great device for economic development and growth. That is why our budgets were expansive. At one time we were criticized because it was said, for example, that we had a vocation for humble sectors; and someone pointed out that there were 17 million Argentines receiving a check from the state… In short, etc., etc. And today there is a great discussion about how to define the opposition, or the main opposition party, in this case, Peronism, and then there are discussions about what Peronism is, whether it is left, right, center, up, down. I have always been criticized by some colleagues for not mentioning General Perón too much in speeches, but I have a theory about Peronist leaders who mention Perón too much. To me, when Peronist leaders have government responsibilities, rather than talking about Perón, I prefer that they do the things that Perón did. I focus more on those things than on the repetition of things. Today I was listening to the senator from Chaco about the Argentine model for the national project, about this issue we are discussing regarding the budget, regarding inflation. Because the other great problem that exists – that Argentina surely has – is inflation; and some believe that inflation is due to the fiscal deficit or to issuance; well, let’s see what Perón said, the herbivorous lion, the one who came after eight years of exile, who came emaciated, according to his own words… An herbivorous lion, as he defined himself. And, speaking of animals, I want to remind you that mares are also herbivorous. Well, the herbivorous lion said: It is evident that “the recipes” – in quotes – international that have suggested we lower demand to stop inflation did not lead to anything but to halt the process and to maintain or increase inflation. I repeat: The international recipes that have suggested we lower demand to stop inflation did not lead to anything but to halt the process and to maintain or increase inflation. This is the Perón who speaks to the Argentine Parliament when he presents the Argentine model for the national project, and in the part where he talks about the economic regime, he speaks of these issues. Look at what he says: “In this matter [in inflation] the appropriate solution was not found. At times, public demand was lowered through spending restraint, forgetting the social sense of public spending. [The zero deficit: shrinking public spending.] At other times, the demand of companies was lowered through credit restriction, also forgetting the job-generating role that the expansion of companies plays, positive rates through the roof that prevent and destroy credit and companies cannot invest. [What is happening to us now]. And at other times, the demand of workers was lowered through the reduction of real wages.” All of this is happening today in Argentina: restriction of public spending, non-existence of credit due to impossible positive rates, and destroyed and pulverized wages. And he continues: “But since at the same time the measures were not adopted for everyone to participate in the sacrifice, ultimately, it was the backs of the workers that bore the weight of these demand repression policies to combat inflation that the country accepted and that it repeated, although its ineptitude was well proven by history itself. This is a very important experience derived from our process, and since we need to avoid inflation to move forward with authentic effectiveness, we must keep it permanently in mind.”

I believe it is important to understand that one does not emerge from a recession by adjusting public spending; on the contrary, what we are going to do with this budget is deepen the suffering of Argentine society. But you know what, Mr. President? It will also be a useless sacrifice. I have seen and heard everyone talk about the need for us to make sacrifices. The problem is that all of us who speak from these benches about the need to sacrifice are not, precisely, the ones who are sacrificing. None of us sitting here have the moral authority to tell the people that they must sacrifice themselves to get ahead! We are all well-dressed, well-fed, driven in cars, and travel by plane. Are we going to address the people to tell them that they must continue to starve or be unemployed, and that this is the sacrifice? But, in addition, will that sacrifice yield results? We all know that it will not. We all know that the recession will deepen, and it is necessary, Mr. President, ladies and gentlemen legislators, to adopt active public policies. Look, I am no longer going to talk about small and medium-sized enterprises, the SMEs, which are destroyed. The issue of this very important company, the multinational Arcor, an Argentine food multinational that is also reputed – apparently rightly so – to be very well managed; therefore, it is an important leading case to see how models function with budgets like ours, which were expansive and believed in demand, and what was your first budget, that of 2016, where you reduced taxes, because you are convinced that the economy is driven by supply and not by demand; and so you believe that by lowering taxes, entrepreneurs will invest. Well, this company, Arcor, has thirty-nine industrial plants: twenty-nine in the country and ten abroad. Of the ten plants it has abroad, four were installed or opened in 2005, 2007, and 2008, the last one. It has three that it started in Brazil: two in 2005 and one in 2007; one in Chile in 2007 and one in Mexico in 2008, which was the last one it opened. This group, moreover, and I will show the graph so that it can be seen… There is a belief that the group had problems because consumption fell. No. Arcor had operating profitability. The problem is that it incurred debt through negotiable obligations of 500 million dollars in 2016 and 2017, which added to the debt it had: 200 million in non-negotiable obligations until 2015, and the devaluation, obviously had an impact on the debt service. But I reiterate that it had operating results. Now, let’s look at how this important multinational company functioned. Here it is made from 2004 to 2017. Look: the average profit, the profitability of the company from 2004 to 2015 was 178 million dollars annually. But, if we take the so denigrated government period from 2011 to 2015, the average operating profit goes to 265.5 million dollars, being 201 million dollars in 2016 and 2017. 2018 is missing. What do I want to say with this, Mr. President? That the greatest growth and the greatest profitability of the company occurred when our budgets were expansive. I know some will be thinking: Yes, but well, the owners of the company and many entrepreneurs who surely also had profits during those governments are with the Cambiemos government, because one can see in their statements in the media that they fervently support this policy. Well, of course, the problem is that I said the main problem of the Argentine economy is the restriction of dollars, but also the other problem we have is also the mentality of some sectors of the business community that do not move based on economic behaviors but based on ideological, political, or cultural behaviors or patterns. Arturo Jauretche had already explained this much better than I can; and if you don’t like Jauretche because he sounds too Nac & Pop, I recommend you read the lecture by the economist Kalecki – already deceased – that he gave at the University of Cambridge in the Marshall Society in 1942, during World War II. This economist, of Marxist orientation, is going to give a lecture about the political aspects of full employment. What was the discussion at that time, so we can see this issue of the cultural, ideological, and prejudices? At that time, this Marxist Polish economist, as they were all allied against National Socialism in Germany and Fascism in Italy, raised the discussion about the full employment regime that National Socialism and Fascism in Italy had achieved; and how that National Socialism was supported by the bourgeoisie and how capitalism was reluctant to the full employment regime. He analyzes why entrepreneurs, despite the fact that it apparently benefits them to have a full employment regime – because if everyone has a job, they will be able to consume, they will be able to grow – reject full employment out of fears and prejudices. He gives the example of Blum, the socialist experience in France. Or also the opposition that Franklin Delano Roosevelt had with the New Deal. We all know that the big companies and the great fortunes in the United States were against the New Deal, despite the fact that it aimed to overcome the recession and the depression not from a financial point of view – they know that he took the money from the banks – but fundamentally through job creation and industrialization. It is very interesting, because one can notice the prejudices that exist regarding this, and what a full employment regime creates in many entrepreneurs, because the full employment regime needs state intervention, given that without public sector investment it is impossible to have full employment; without public sector investment through the budget, it is impossible to have full employment. So, that full employment can be achieved through a lot of public works, such as hospitals, schools, roads, etc.; through subsidies. I want to read the term that Kalecki uses, so you can see that subsidies are not something that we Kirchnerists, so to speak, or Peronists, I don’t know, whatever you want to call us, just came up with. Kalecki, when he talks about the subsidies that are given through public services, refers to subsidies for public services as indirect wages. Year 1942, University of Cambridge. There is nothing new under the sun in terms of behaviors and macroeconomic policies. There have been great discussions for a long time, whether it is supply, whether it is demand, whether it is the full employment regime. Some still believe and are convinced, even important leaders in Germany – I have had the opportunity to speak with German Chancellor Angela Merkel at G-20 meetings – that inflation caused the phenomenon of Hitler. It was not inflation that caused the phenomenon of Hitler. The phenomenon of Hitler was caused by the Treaty of Versailles, the ruinous and humiliating economic conditions and the terrible debt that Germany had to pay, which it could not pay and, therefore, generated unemployment, joblessness; and yes, finally inflation. But inflation was not the cause; inflation was the effect. The cause was the desire to burden Germany, which had lost World War I, with the payment of a debt it could not pay; and it ended up in that. We need to look a little at what is happening in the world with the rise of the right, because that National Socialism – and Fascism – used the Jews as the guilty minorities for the disasters they had in the economy: that they had no jobs, that there were unemployed; it was the Jews who were responsible. The new rights and the new fascisms place immigrants as the ones responsible for the nationals of a country not having jobs. Let us be alert to these things. Even the policies that Trump carried out – and Trump’s victory – are fundamentally due to the appeal to the lack of work in deep America. So, here Kalecki argues that the full employment regime is a debt and a debate that capitalism must have, because there is a business class that refuses to address the issue because it believes that this is granting too much power to unions, to factories, etc., etc. And to the state; and workers too. There is nothing more frightened than a businessman in front of a union or organized workers. I believe we should discuss these things. I simply believe that we are not going down the right path. We are going down the worst path.

Today, Senator Anabel Fernández Sagasti said that they are going to leave a country infinitely worse than the one they received. You don't even have to be a supporter of the previous government to notice it. The numbers are clear and concrete regarding debt. It seems unbelievable that today we have asked the International Monetary Fund for 57 billion dollars. Does anyone really think this is going to be the solution? Can any Argentine, after the experiences we have had here, sincerely believe that the solution is going to come from there? I can understand the political speeches, the media coaching, and so on, but I sincerely think it is time for you to call… Look, if you don’t want to call those who were here before, that’s fine, but you have to organize something because this is going to become unsustainable. I sincerely believe that despite the fact that you spent so much time talking about the heavy inheritance… I look at you as a sort of inverted mirror. It’s as if you project onto others what is really happening, what you are. So, you spent two years talking about the heavy inheritance, and the truth is that no one knows how you are going to pay the formidable debt that you have incurred in 2020, which we also don’t know where it is. Because ultimately, where are the more than 150 billion dollars, in netbooks, in works, in hospitals, in schools, in kindergartens, in roads, in better salaries for scientists, in better salaries for university professors? Everything is devastated, Mr. President. The question is where all that debt you incurred went. I believe that one of the problems we need to address regarding inflation, for example, and external restrictions is also that we have another record. Argentina is the fifth country in the formation of external assets. The business classes ultimately end up fleeing money and forming assets abroad. We are the fifth country. First, the United Arab Emirates; second, Venezuela; third, Saudi Arabia; fourth, Russia; and fifth, Argentina. Don’t you think that this is also related to the external restriction due to the low investment rate of those who produce, invest, trade, those who have businesses, industries, shops, companies here in Argentina? Don’t you also find it strange that it is related to inflation? Because Arcor in 2016, 2017, and 2018 also had operational profitability selling less in volume. Do you know why inflation is not going to yield despite what you believe, that because there is no money prices will go down? Because prices are going to rise to make up for what they lack in volume, which is what Arcor did, for example, which had profitability. Their problem was not operational profitability because sales fell, sales fell because they raised prices in such a way that they managed to make up for profitability. This is what we need to discuss, the concentration. You talk about inflation. Don’t you think that the concentration by sector of the economy is also related to inflation, to pricing and income policies? Arcor, along with Mondelez, which is also a multinational cookie company, has 60 percent of the cookie market. Fifteen companies explain almost 70 percent of Argentina's dairy capacity. Two companies, Coca-Cola and Pepsi, account for 78 percent of soft drinks. Pasta – a popular food if there is one – is controlled by a single company: Molinos Río de la Plata, which controls 50 percent. It says here – and I take up the challenge from Senator Naidenoff – “how many years ago.” And I say, when we tried… when we tried… And I don’t try to dialogue with you, Senator (to Naidenoff). When we tried price control policies, competition defense, what were we accused of? Look, we thought of carrying out, having the representations that corresponded to us in the Guarantee Fund of ANSES, in the companies, in Techint, in Molinos Río de la Plata… Having a representative and they already considered it an intrusion into the life of the companies, and they practically accused us of being almost socialists because we put directors that corresponded to us in the companies that participated in the Sustainability Guarantee Fund of ANSES. I remember that with Shell, when Aranguren was the president, we wanted to apply the price of fuels from the Ministry of Commerce and they said everything. We had no support from any opposition political party to address the problem of the concentration of companies in the Argentine Republic! It was a fight alone, ours! The opposition – senators – accused us of wanting to intervene and socialize and take over the companies, when in reality what we wanted was to control this level of concentration! Because this is also one of the causes of inflation, in addition to monetary restriction and the behavior and culture of bimonetaryism. But to end the culture of bimonetaryism, a great national political agreement will be necessary, Mr. President, from right to left. Because the problem of the scarcity of dollars is not an ideological problem. It is a problem of sustaining economic activity. That’s why I say, Mr. President, that we are not discussing a budget, because we can never discuss these things. And when there was a government that tried to discuss, with our mistakes, with our missteps, with our bad manners… But, and with your good manners, what investments came to the country? Because also, Mr. President, some senator says there is a perverse plan. Look, I’m not going to get into whether they are perverse… I look at the results, and the result is that none of the investments you said would come came. Because you believed, many of you believed that you, who are not Peronists, can we define you as “blond, with blue eyes”? Yes, blond, with blue eyes, friendly with the market, the investments would come. No, Mr. President. And you also believed that by giving each economic sector what that sector asked for, the sum of all those concessions, because they had gone to the Stock Exchange and there they wanted there to be no restrictions on the free entry of capital to go from a border economy to an emerging economy. You lifted all the regulations. What investments came? Speculative ones, Mr. President. Speculative investments. No other investments came. You believed that by paying the vulture funds investments would also come. Investments did not come either. And so we could list each of the economic sectors. Except for one sector, you didn’t give them what they wanted, which was the Income Tax and free bargaining. Except for the CGT, many of whom supported you, to the others you gave everything. The problem is that the sum of sectoral demands does not yield a virtuous total; it yields what we have today. Adding the demands of the sectors and fulfilling each of them does not yield a virtuous end; it yields what we have today. That’s why I say, Mr. President, that it is necessary to address a serious discussion in the country. And I also say that you have had what no other government has had: an opposition that, from the vulture funds, through historical reparation, through pension reform and everything else, voted for everything you asked for; even the presidents of the Central Bank. Look: I had Mercedes Marcó del Pont and I could never get her appointment approved. However, Adolfo Sturzenegger got his appointment approved. Look at that! You achieved something that I couldn’t even with my own bench. And this is also related to something that also happened in the last budget meeting, when we were there last year, on December 27. I remember that in the speech of the senator who represents the majority bloc, he said that, even with our differences and our visions, they were going to approve the budget. And look at what he said – this was pronounced on December 27 of last year –: “And we believe that the government must correct some directions. Otherwise, undoubtedly, some visions that have been expressed in this chamber may come closer to reality [the visions, of course, were ours]. I don’t think we are living that yet, but there are negative data. Put a Minister of Economy who regulates monetary policy, fiscal policy, spending policy. Have some centrality in the perspective of the political vision; otherwise, the president of the Central Bank will continue to apply interest rates of 30 percent. Last year they were 30 percent, happily. Who is going to come to invest in Argentina?” he asked. And well, look at how we are now. The rates are no longer 30 percent; they are almost 70 percent. So, I say: is it rational to approve this budget? I will skip the pitiful press meeting on December 28, 2017, where twelve hours after they raised their hands approving the budget, they changed all the variables with a stroke of the pen, leaving those who had voted not looking very good, Mr. President. So I ask, is it rational to continue supporting failure? Because the problem we have is that you have failed in what you proposed to society. Moreover; after this, a tax increase will be voted on. After this, a tax increase will be voted on, one of your battle horses. “We are going to lower the tax burden.” You are going to end up with a tax burden higher than the one we ended with in 2015. You are going to end up with a higher tax burden, with greater indebtedness, with recession, with double-digit unemployment! Don’t you think it’s time to say and rethink that what you believed, the country you believed in, and the world you believed in does not exist? And that the things that were well done have been destroyed and you have not been able to correct the things that were wrong? You have accentuated the problem of external restriction. When you dollarize tariffs, when you dollarize fuel, when you dollarize food, you deepen the bimonetary economy process we have today in Argentina. Don’t you think it’s time to sit down with the 92…? Look, there are 92 companies producing, transporting, and distributing electricity, energy, gas, water, and also the oil producers that are the only ones making money in the Republic of Argentina. 92 companies are making a lot of money. Now, the rest is on the floor. Don’t you think it’s time to sit down with those 92 companies – many of which are state-owned, provincial, like in the case, for example, of EPEC and the Santa Fe company, which are the two largest electricity distributors after Edenor and Edesur – and really discuss tariffs that are accessible and that return a little money to the people’s pockets so that they can put that money into consumption? Don’t you think it’s time to sit down with the industrialists to see how they decide on a protection and promotion policy for the industry, which is falling apart? We had managed to reindustrialize the country; we had managed to reindustrialize after what happened during the 90s. All over again. To those guys who invested in machinery again, after having gone bankrupt during the 90s, who is going to convince them to put machinery in a factory again? Moreover, if this recession deepens, in one or two years all the equipment, the machines, will be obsolete. Do you know that people are leaving the country again? We are going to have the fifth brain drain in the country. The first two, ideological – even of life – in 1966 with the coup of “the long sticks” and in 1976 with the repression. Then came the hyperinflation and the economic disaster of President Alfonsín’s government. Then came 2001; and now we are going to face a fifth exodus of scientists, who are going to leave the country. What are you going to do? We must have a model of international insertion that is not based solely on the added value of raw materials or energy. We must have international insertion with software, with energy, with nuclear industry, in which we had achieved great development as well as in service companies. We were really competitive. We are one of the ten countries that are part of the Nuclear Club. You have to start thinking about these things because this cannot go on like this, Mr. President. I believe that voting for this budget does not do a favor to governability, and I am absolutely convinced that it does even less for Argentine society. It may do a favor to those who are going to collect the debt, to the International Monetary Fund and to some friends in power; but not to society and governability. I don’t believe that governability goes through this. Sincerely, that’s why we are going to vote against it.

To conclude, I have heard some comparisons regarding the fact that in 2010 the budget for 2011 was not approved. Look, trying to compare the situation… First, the budget for the year 2010 for 2011 was expansive, growth-oriented, inclusive, and constructive. But, moreover, there was a special atmosphere in the country. Do you remember what 2010 was like, when the budget was discussed and you rejected it, then in opposition and now in government? We had just finished the celebrations for the Bicentennial, where millions of Argentines had come together with an unprecedented joy that had not been seen since that time. We had emerged from the crisis of 2009, because you cannot convince us, Mr. President, that everything we are going through is due to the Turkish lira or because Trump raised the rate by a point or half a point. I faced five financial runs, five currency runs, Mr. President, and I also faced as president the largest global economic crisis in living memory, which led to the creation of the G-20. Do you know why the G-20 was created? Because of the crisis of 2008, which some say was more significant than that of '30. However, that crisis did not serve as an excuse to shift the responsibility of managing society onto the people; on the contrary… I am almost done. And by 2010 we were already emerging from the crisis of 2008 and 2009. That is why I say, Mr. President, that it is necessary to rethink; the government needs to reconsider things. And I believe that the duty of the opposition, which is to represent an alternative to what is happening in Argentina, leads us to vote against this budget. Thank you very much.