United Nations Security Council Meeting

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

6 August 2013 · United Nations Security Council

Context
Fernández de Kirchner addressed the UN Security Council on August 6, 2013, during Argentina's presidency of the Council, advocating for institutional reform and regional cooperation in conflict resolution.
Main themes
Regional and subregional organizations in conflict resolution, UN Security Council reform, veto power and consensus-based decision-making, Latin American peace and stability, CELAC and UNASUR roles, democratic stability in South America, multilateralism, post-Cold War international institutions
Duration
~17 min
56th percentile
Words
1,986
56th percentile
Sentences
43
27th percentile
Readability
20
3rd percentile
Grade
22.1
99th percentile
Syntax
3.68
98th percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
49th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 40%40%
  • Geopolitical 31%30%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

43 sentences in 21 paragraphs

My country assumes the presidency of this Security Council for the ninth time, but in an unprecedented regional framework. Today we have the presence of 14 foreign ministers here, 12 of whom belong to the Latin American region, and the representative of CELAC has spoken today, through the representative of the Republic of Cuba, and of UNASUR through the representative of Peru.

Both regional and subregional organizations count Argentina as a founding member. But the most important thing is that both organizations have faced situations of great conflict in the region that allowed us to provide a response, a response that is ultimately what this Security Council should provide in the face of various conflicts that arise in different scenarios around the world, making peace and security two very vulnerable values in the contemporary world.

One of the examples we had to resolve when we were not even CELAC, but rather the Rio Group, in the Dominican Republic—Rio is the immediate predecessor in the formation of CELAC—was the harsh confrontation that arose between the Republic of Ecuador and Colombia, which almost ended in an armed conflict, and thanks to the intervention of the Rio Group at that time in the Dominican Republic, we were able to successfully navigate through it.

Later, UNASUR was also able to successfully navigate various situations that were even internal to different countries and that affected the democratic stability of governments, for example, that of President Evo Morales in Bolivia during what was called the Pando Crisis, which led to the Declaration of La Moneda in the Republic of Chile when Michelle Bachelet was the pro tempore president of UNASUR. And also the Declaration of Buenos Aires, when we addressed a topic that was also aimed at the ousting of President Rafael Correa in the Republic of Ecuador; we were able to avert the crisis and allow the continuity of the democratic system, which in our region is not a minor issue, but rather a matter that has marked the possibility of economic growth and fundamentally doing so in a framework of peace and security.

That is why I believe that the choice we have made regarding debate topics, about how regional and subregional organizations can collaborate with this Security Council, with these United Nations, to find methods of solution, is also related to some dilemmas, to some problems that have been pointed out by other representatives.

I cannot overlook the intervention made by the representative of the League of Arab States on a point that I find crucial in conflict resolution and in the effectiveness—I want to emphasize this attribute—of the Security Council to resolve serious issues. What the representative of the League of Arab States specifically raised was that all member states of the United Nations comply with United Nations resolutions. It seems almost obvious, but in reality, it is not an obvious matter; the distinctive feature has often been that those who sit in this forum, because they are permanent members with veto power, use this authority granted to them by the United Nations Charter, the rules of the Security Council, but they are the ones who obstruct the true resolution of conflicts.

And I allow myself to compare it with the doctrine that I could call the "doctrine of South America." How do we make resolutions in CELAC or UNASUR? Resolutions are made by consensus when there is conflict, and this is what we must distinguish.

All organizations and all states normally in our institutional organizations have what is called the right of veto, natural to all executive powers, but one thing is government management and another is conflict management. When the right of veto appears in conflict management, the solution becomes much more difficult and at times impossible.

Therefore, we believe it would be necessary to review the functioning of the institutions of the United Nations in general and particularly of the Security Council, which respond to a different logic, which was the logic of its founding after the Cold War in the face of the danger of a nuclear holocaust; the right of veto was almost a safeguard precisely to prevent that nuclear holocaust.

With the end of this sort of Cold War and given that those who were opposed in that Cold War are all sitting at this table and do not have major conflicts, I believe we must rethink the functioning of the organizations because we have a new world, a new reality, and we cannot face a new world, a new reality, and new problems with old instruments and old methods, because they will not provide us with an answer. That is why we believe in the need to develop consensuses, consensuses that are not based on the particular interests of each state that has the right to veto, but rather on seriously ensuring peace and stability.

In that sense, we can affirm that South America, Latin America is today a region of peace. My country is a leader in nuclear energy, but it is also a leader in nuclear non-proliferation and peaceful use of nuclear energy. However, just as today the representative of the League of Arab States spoke of the conflict that shakes the world in the Middle East, in the face of the non-acceptance of a State of Palestine that has been demanded not only by Arab countries but also by numerous countries in the region, including mine, we can also say in our region, as the representative of CELAC rightly mentioned, there is a conflict due to the failure to respect a United Nations resolution regarding the need for my country and the United Kingdom to engage in negotiations, discussions within the framework of what was resolved by the United Nations in resolution 2065 of 1965 regarding the sovereignty of the Falkland Islands.

This is not a capricious stance; it is not a stance to reaffirm that we are right. We simply say: we want the United Nations resolution to be fulfilled and for both countries to sit down to discuss a contentious and controversial issue.

It was pointed out that there were discordant opinions; one can have discordant opinions about something that is not resolved by the United Nations, but when from this organization that shelters us all, of which we are all signatories, in which we have all committed to respect its resolutions, emanates from its General Assembly, the highest body of this organization, a resolution, we are not facing discordant opinions; we are facing a United Nations resolution and those who are willing to comply with what we are obligated to as members or not. I take this as an example; I do not want to introduce a controversy here because I believe that the problems the world is facing are so great and numerous that they not only pertain to security from a military concept but essentially from an economic concept. The ongoing crisis since 2008, which tends to further aggravate existing conflicts, demands that all of us adopt an absolutely different attitude and rethink how we function in these organizations and how to change rules, how to imagine and design new instruments that allow us to be effective, because ultimately I believe that the respect of global society will be achieved when we are able to demonstrate that we are effective in our management.

Being effective in management means mediating and providing a solution to that mediation, especially when the mediation has also been the subject of a resolution from the highest body. Just as within each of us the results replicate when a parliament makes a decision and the executive power respects it. Something similar must be understood if we want to address global governance.

There has also been much talk about human rights. My country, I am proud to say, is an example in terms of unrestricted respect for human rights, after having suffered during the 1970s one of the most tragic and terrible dictatorships that caused the disappearance not only of Argentine citizens but also of citizens of other nationalities. We are also leaders in this area; we founded the Permanent Human Rights Commission of the United Nations along with other countries, and we also celebrated the Convention on Enforced Disappearance of Persons, which we have co-authored with France and other countries.

That is why I wanted to explore these ideas, which are reflections, that do not have the arrogance of having revealed truth or being absolute certainties, simply comparing how we resolved very serious moments for the South American region with a methodology in which no one would leave until the issue was resolved and it was done by consensus.

Finally, I also discussed this yesterday with the Secretary-General of the United Nations, Dr. Ban Ki-moon, who once again graciously received me in a private audience—the need to establish global regulations to ensure the sovereignty of states and the privacy of citizens in the world in the face of events that are publicly and notoriously known. I believe—I told him—that many things have happened since the fall of the Berlin Wall, and precisely one of the most distinctive reasons for the fall of that wall was that the citizens on the other side wanted to live in freedom, they wanted to live without being observed, and I recalled yesterday that excellent film that I am sure all of you have seen, which received an Oscar from the Academy here in the United States, "The Lives of Others," where citizens felt spied on, they felt controlled.

I believe this should serve us so that those values that were so useful in building an ideal, the ideal of democracy, the ideal that we can live and coexist in plurality, in diversity, with different ideas, and that those different ideas do not make us enemies of the state or enemies of another compatriot, must be taken up again because they are what ultimately gave rise to the San Francisco Charter, they are what gave rise to multiple conventions that we have signed, and I am absolutely convinced that deep down—perhaps some more deeply than others—we think exactly the same way. It is not merely a matter of sensitivity; it is not merely a matter of intellectual generosity; it is a way, I believe the most intelligent perhaps, for this democratic form to be conceived by the largest number of global citizens as the best way of life. For that, peace, security, economic growth, inclusion, respect for human rights, and the diversity of people are, I believe, the inalienable values that no one is willing to renounce.

That is why today we wanted to introduce this debate, which is the debate of how we cooperate from regional and subregional organizations with our mother organization, which is the United Nations, to ensure a world with more peace and more security, but I also said that peace and security is not a military concept; those who believe that peace and security are ensured solely with weapons, well, I think there are multiple examples throughout these thousands of years of human history that assure us that what truly builds societies and builds stability are values and ideals for which a society and millions of global compatriots are willing to give their lives, as was done in our emancipatory revolutions during the 19th century, fundamentally in America, as was done in Africa during the 20th century, and when we are faced with this new global village, which also requires another type of emancipation and another type of independence.

Thank you very much, and now I return once again to my role as president of the Security Council, and with 30 speakers still remaining, I invite you to a recess until 3 PM, because I believe we all need to eat something in order to continue dialoguing and debating. Thank you very much, and good morning to all.

CFK