April 23, 2014 - Speech by the President of the Republic, Dilma Rousseff, during the opening ceremony of the Global Multistakeholder Meeting on the Future of Internet Governance - NET Mundial - São Paulo, SP.

Brazil Dilma Rousseff · President of Brazil

23 April 2014 · Opening ceremony of the Global Multistakeholder Meeting on the Future of Internet Governance (NET Mundial) · São Paulo, Brazil

Context
Rousseff addressed the opening of NET Mundial in São Paulo on April 23, 2014, a global meeting on the future of internet governance she helped initiate after 2013 NSA surveillance revelations.
Main themes
Internet governance, privacy and freedom of expression, multistakeholder model, surveillance and espionage, Marco Civil da Internet, human rights online, digital democracy, NET Mundial conference, global internet policy, civil framework for the internet
Duration
~20 min
65th percentile
Words
2,392
65th percentile
Sentences
109
67th percentile
Readability
29
15th percentile
Grade
14.5
71st percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.33
80th percentile

Translated from Portuguese

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 40%40%
  • Ceremonial 24%24%
  • Social 20%20%
  • Technological 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

109 sentences in 40 paragraphs

Good morning everyone. I thank our dear representative, Nnenna Nwakanma, for her perfect pronunciation of the Brazilian "bom dia," and I greet her while also greeting all the women participating in the web and all the girls and guys participating in the web.

I would like to acknowledge our mayor of São Paulo who welcomes us, and above all, I would like to first greet two Brazilian parliamentarians present here: Alessandro Molon from the Chamber of Deputies, the rapporteur of the Marco Civil da Internet, and Deputy Walter Pinheiro... actually, I apologize, Senator Walter Pinheiro, through whom I extend my greetings to the Senate rapporteurs who were able to approve this legislation in record time. Senator Vital do Rego, Senator José Perrella, Senator Ricardo Ferraço.

So, to Senator Walter Pinheiro and Deputy Alessandro Molon, I thank you for the approval of the Marco Civil.

I would like to greet the Secretary-General of the United Nations, Wu Hongdo.

I would like to greet and extend a special greeting to the creator of the web, Tim Berners-Lee.

I would also like to greet the Vice President of Google and a major participant in the creation of the Internet, Vincent Cerf.

Once again, I greet the CEO of ICANN, Fadi Chehadé, with whom we had a meeting on October 8, 2013, and in that meeting, the idea of this NET Mundial meeting took shape. So, I thank all of you, I thank the state ministers, the foreign delegates for being here, and I would like to greet... the approval of the web that was built with the participation of all Brazilian society.

I would like to greet the Minister of Foreign Affairs, Ambassador Figueiredo; the Minister of Justice, José Eduardo Cardoso; I would like to greet Paulo Bernardo from Communications; the Minister of Science and Technology, Clélio Campolina Diniz.

I would like to greet the Senator and Minister of Culture, Marta Suplicy.

And our Secretary-General, Gilberto Carvalho.

And I greet everyone present, especially the journalists here, photographers, and cameramen.

I want to say that you are all welcome to Brazil for this Global Multistakeholder Meeting on the Future of Internet Governance, NET Mundial.

At this moment, I would also like to greet the organizers, both the Internet Management Committee in Brazil and the One Net coalition.

I am pleased to see in this plenary representatives from all sectors involved in internet governance. We have here civil society, academics, the technical community, businesses, and governments. This healthy diversity, because it is a healthy diversity, also characterizes the groups participating in the meeting via the internet. And I want to take this opportunity today to establish a dialogue about the issues and purposes that brought us to São Paulo.

In mid-2013, revelations about comprehensive espionage mechanisms and collective communication monitoring provoked outrage and repudiation in broad sectors of Brazilian and global public opinion. In Brazil, citizens, companies, diplomatic representations, and the Presidency of the Republic itself had their communications intercepted. These facts are unacceptable and remain unacceptable. They attack the very nature of the internet; an open, plural, and free nature.

The internet we want is only possible in a scenario of respect for human rights, particularly privacy and freedom of expression. That is why in my speech at the 68th UN Assembly, I proposed combating these practices and suggested a discussion on establishing a global civil framework for governance and use of the internet, and measures that would ensure the effective protection of the data that flows through it. Together with Chancellor Angela Merkel, we brought to the UN a resolution project on the "Right to Privacy in the Digital Age." We approved this project by consensus and also called on states to cease arbitrary or illegal collection of personal data and to uphold the right to privacy. Moreover, it is important to reiterate that the rights people have offline must also be protected online.

NET Mundial aims to boost this effort. And this meeting responds to a global desire for changes in the current situation and for the systematic strengthening of freedom of expression on the Internet and the protection of basic human rights such as the right to privacy and, without a doubt, also the right to treat discussions on the internet in a respectful manner, ensuring its democratic and open character.

We came to São Paulo, therefore, with the common purpose of improving and democratizing internet governance, through the construction of consensuses, consensuses around principles and also the development of a roadmap for its evolution. We, and I want to reiterate this, do not think this is about replacing the numerous forums that already deal with the subject, but rather about giving the debates a new dynamic and a necessary sense of urgency.

We start from two premises: the first is that we all want to protect the Internet as a democratic space, for everyone, as a common good, a true heritage of humanity. More than a mere tool for work, and beyond its known contribution to economic growth, as long as it is increasingly inclusive, the internet has enabled the permanent reinvention of how people and institutions interact, produce culture, and organize themselves, including politically. The open and decentralized architecture of the network favors access to knowledge, the democratization of communications, and its constant innovation. These basic characteristics, we want, and must be preserved, in any scenario, to ensure the future of the Internet and enhance its transformative effects on and in society. The second premise is the desire we share to incorporate an ever-wider audience into this process. The commitment to open and inclusive debate guided the organization of this meeting. All sectors participated in its preparation and are represented in this plenary. There are thousands of participants from around the world, along with virtual spaces in various parts of the planet. The topics to be debated were the subject of extensive international public consultation, receiving contributions from actors situated in all points and in various countries. These proposals served as the basis for the drafting of the document to be debated and improved over the next two days.

I salute the Multistakeholder Executive Committee and the Multistakeholder High-Level Committee for this collective effort. The interest of Brazilians in the Internet was reflected in significant participation in the national public consultation promoted by the PARTICIPA.BR portal. At this moment, civil society is organized in the NET Mundial Arena, the Brazilian locus for access to this meeting.

And I would like to say to you, ladies and gentlemen, friends present here, that Brazil advocates for internet governance to be multistakeholder, multilateral, democratic, and transparent. We consider the multistakeholder model to be the best way to exercise internet governance. In line with this vision, our local governance system, in operation for 20 years, includes the effective participation of representatives from civil society, academics, businesspeople, and the Government in the Internet Management Committee.

In a non-exclusive manner to what I have just said, we also consider the multilateral perspective important, according to which the participation of governments should occur on an equal footing, without one country having more weight than others. This defense of multilateralism is a natural consequence of a fundamental principle of contemporary international relations, enshrined in the Brazilian Constitution: "equality among States."

We do not see, therefore, opposition between multilateralism and multistakeholderism. Its opposite is unilateralism, which is indeed indefensible. An internet subjected to intergovernmental arrangements that exclude other sectors is not democratic. Nor are multistakeholder arrangements acceptable that are subject to the supervision of one or a few states.

We truly want to democratize the relationships between governments and society and the relationships among governments. We want more democracy, not less democracy. It is necessary and urgent to give a global character to the organizations that today are responsible for the central functions of the Internet.

The complexity of this transition – which involves jurisdictional competence, accountability, and agreements with multiple actors – does not diminish its sense of urgency. Therefore, I welcome the intention of the United States government, recently announced, to replace its institutional link with the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority (IANA) and the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) with a global management of these institutions.

From now on, the new institutional and legal arrangement of the Internet Domain Name System, under the responsibility of IANA and ICANN, must be built with broad participation from all interested sectors, going beyond traditional actors. Each sector, of course, plays different roles, based on equally differentiated responsibilities.

The operational management of the Internet must continue to be led by its technical community. And I publicly acknowledge, on behalf of my government, those individuals who dedicate themselves daily to maintaining an open, stable, and secure Internet – a fundamental, albeit invisible, job for all of us users.

Issues related to sovereignty – such as cyber crimes, rights violations, transnational economic issues, and threats of cyber attacks – are primarily the responsibility of states. It is, above all, about ensuring that states have the tools that allow them to fulfill their responsibilities to their citizens, including the guarantee of fundamental rights. Rights that are guaranteed offline must be guaranteed online. These rights thrive under, and not in the absolute absence of, the state.

For global internet governance to be effectively democratic, mechanisms are needed that allow for greater participation from developing countries in all sectors. Issues of interest to these countries, the major users of the internet, such as expanding connectivity, accessibility, and respect for diversity, must be central to the international agenda.

It is not enough for forums to be open from a formal point of view. We need to identify and remove visible and invisible barriers to the participation of the entire population of each country, under penalty of restricting the democratic role and the social and cultural reach of the Internet. This effort also requires strengthening the Internet Governance Forum as a dialogue instance capable of producing results and recommendations; a broad review of the 10 years of the World Summit on the Information Society; and deepening discussions on ethics and privacy at UNESCO.

That is why I would like to say to you that we believe that cyberspace, and I am sure, like all of you, must be the territory of trust, human rights, citizenship, collaboration, and peace. To achieve these goals, we need to agree on basic principles that guide internet governance.

Regarding privacy, the resolution approved by the UN was an important step, but we still have much to advance. Any type of data collection or processing must have the consent of the parties or legal support. But the debate on principles is much broader. It must, I insist, include the universality of access to the Internet, essential for social and human development, in favor of building inclusive and non-discriminatory societies. It must include freedom of expression and, necessarily, network neutrality.

Brazil has its part to contribute, stemming from the broad internal process of discussion, debate, and contributions that resulted in the law of the Marco Civil da Internet, approved yesterday by the National Congress and which I had the honor of signing here a little while ago.

The law, and here I would like to take the words of Sir Tim Berners-Lee who considered it "a gift to the web on its 25th anniversary," demonstrates the viability and success of open discussions, discussions that are multistakeholder, as well as the innovative use of the Internet in the discussion itself as an interactive debate platform. This was an extremely virtuous process that we carried out here in Brazil.

Our Marco Civil has also been further valued by the process of its construction. Therefore, I would like to remind you that our Marco Civil establishes principles, guarantees, and rights for users, delineating duties and responsibilities of different actors and the public power in the online environment. Something very important, it enshrines network neutrality, which is an achievement that we, throughout this process, managed to make consensual. By establishing that telecommunications companies must treat any data packages equally, without distinction by content, origin, destination, service, terminal, or application, it indeed enshrined network neutrality. Companies are also prohibited from blocking, monitoring, filtering, or analyzing the content of data packets. It protects the privacy of citizens, both in relation to the government and in relations with companies operating on the Internet. Communications are inviolable, except by specific judicial order. The law also brings clear rules for the removal of content from the network, always ensuring the presence of judicial decisions.

The Marco Civil, an example that the development of the Internet cannot do without this process of discussion with the participation of the states, is an innovative reference because, in its drafting process, the voices of the streets, the networks, and the institutions echoed.

That is why we have a conviction: in a network, each node is important. The large nodes – such as the mega portals, to which a good part of the world's data traffic converges – are important. The small nodes are also important.

And I would like to point out to you a fundamental issue: Brazil has taken a great step in the process by which we include and guarantee income to a part of our population. As important as income is access to the internet; as important as income is the guarantee of a society with citizens who have their own opinions and express them. Hence, for us, the invaluable value of the internet. And we also have another great asset, which is our immense ethnic, cultural, political, and religious diversity. We must respect and promote our cultural diversity. We do not want to impose beliefs, customs, values, or political conceptions.

And I want to highlight, especially, these millions of users who multiply every day, here and in developing countries, in our urban peripheries, in traditional communities. They enrich the network with other ideas, other narratives, and worldviews. These people make the Internet stronger and more universal. And it is on their behalf and because of them that I thank the presence of all of you here. For us, the internet is a modern, emancipatory, and transformative instrument of our reality. Welcome, and I hope you return for the World Cup, the Cup of Cups. Or watch it online.

Thank you very much.