February 16, 2011 - Words of the President of the Republic, Dilma Rousseff, at the opening of the PAC Urban Mobility meeting in Major Cities.

Brazil Dilma Rousseff · President of Brazil

16 February 2011 · PAC Urban Mobility meeting in Major Cities

Context
Rousseff addressed governors, mayors, and parliamentarians at the opening of a PAC Urban Mobility working meeting to outline criteria for large-city infrastructure project selection in February 2011.
Main themes
Urban mobility, PAC 2 Growth Acceleration Program, mass public transport, large cities infrastructure, federal-state-municipal partnership, population density prioritization, project quality, public investment allocation, metropolitan regions, social impact of infrastructure
Duration
~14 min
49th percentile
Words
1,675
49th percentile
Sentences
88
57th percentile
Readability
58
82nd percentile
Grade
9.6
17th percentile
Syntax
3.09
59th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
11th percentile

Translated from Portuguese

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 45%42%
  • Institutional 28%26%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

88 sentences in 22 paragraphs

Well, I would like to start by greeting all the governors, all the mayors here,

I also want to greet our parliamentarians who honor us today – senators, congresswomen, and congressmen,

I would also like to greet the state secretaries, the secretaries, and also the municipal secretaries, and the other officials present here who will participate in this working meeting.

This is a meeting – it is the first meeting – it is a preparatory meeting for the selection of projects. The objective is to provide the criteria so that you can define how you will participate in PAC 2 – Social and Urban Mobility.

It is a PAC for the large cities, and its goal is to ensure urban mobility and also to ensure that people can move around, especially considering that one of the biggest problems we have in Brazil is the issue of cities, especially large cities, understood as the large metropolitan regions of the country.

So, this portion of the PAC that we call PAC 2, which is the second phase of the Growth Acceleration Program, has a total of R$ 18 billion [until 2014], and in this first selection, we will start to do... We made a first selection of PAC 2 last year to ensure that there were projects this year, and now we will do another selection of this portion. We have already selected, or are in the process of selecting, R$ 29.4 billion, but that is not for this part of the PAC. It is basically... it was for UPAs, for daycare centers, for preschools, sports courts, squares, sanitation, drainage, housing, slopes, paving, equipment. And now we will make the selection for Mobility, item Large Cities.

That is why we are here, basically, the metropolitan region, the states, and the large capitals. In fact, all the capitals are included. We selected 24 [capitals].

___________: Larger than 800,000.

President: Yes. Well, the selection will occur in a single stage. We intend for this selection – and then Miriam will explain this better – what will this selection encompass? We do not have much money; it is R$ 18 billion [until 2014]. We know perfectly well that an urban work concentrates a very large amount of resources, depending on its extent. And even in short stretches, if it is densely populated, you have a necessarily very large investment to achieve a result of improvement in the urban area.

We will prioritize – I would like to focus on this – first, areas of high population density. Since we do not have all the money that would be interesting for us to have – we have R$ 18 billion [until 2014] – we will prioritize one thing: we will prioritize the population that lives in large cities, due to the concentration. It will be an investment that will have a greater social impact. In this sense, it is a PAC that also encompasses urban social mobilization, right?

The second issue is that we will prioritize mass public transport. The third is that we will not make isolated interventions. If possible, the more the work is related to a larger population set, the better the work will be. This will be a criterion. Therefore, we do not prioritize isolated paving. Why is that? Because, within what we conceived as investment in the urban area, the more we can – the federal government – participate with municipalities and states, contribute to ensure that there are structural works, considering that there are some that you would not do if we could not help, and within a vision of partnership between state, municipality, and the Union, our participation will be to provide a substantial amount of resources.

So, we will prefer, instead of making scattered investments, to concentrate on some works that make a difference in your regions. We will participate with our share; obviously, you will participate with your share, but we can leverage the resources and do the best for each large region.

I also think that, from previous experience, it is important to be careful regarding the quality of the projects. The higher the quality of the project, the more defined the quality of the project, it will be easier for you to quantify the work, easier for us to oversee the use of the resources, but, above all, better for the population, because we will have managed to combine and add various efforts to solve a very difficult problem.

We divide the cities into three levels: above three billion... in fact, three million in metropolitan areas, with a population of three million people; between one and a half – it is one and a half, right? One and three – and... no, above one and three... Give me the values. It is above three million, obviously municipalities with more than three. Then, between one and three million; and then above 700,000. Above three million, we are allocating an amount around R$ 2.4 billion. No, no, my dear, that is the limit of the proposal. We are allocating a limit of proposal – just a little – of R$ 2.4 billion. Let’s suppose: the municipality and the metropolitan region have three million people; they can make a proposal. We will look at a proposal for an amount up to R$ 2.4 billion, but it cannot be zero, right? So, it is R$ 2.4 billion, it is a reference value. It can be R$ 2.6; R$ 2.3; R$ 2.2 – it is a reference. Between one and three million, around R$ 430 million, a reference value; and from 700,000 to one million, around R$ 280 million.

The idea is that these works are significant and, therefore, if there is any work that falls outside these reference parameters, it is subject to discussion and negotiation. What we are indicating is a reference value; it is not an exact thing. It is a reference value. Let’s suppose it fits, if it is significant and has justification, no one is inflexible about not taking it into consideration. But we give these indicators so that a larger number of cities and regions can be contemplated. And, obviously, the quality of the proposals will be closely observed.

I know that there are several places applying – not many, but – applying for metro. I want to emphasize to you that we will not build metro in regions that are not densely populated. Why? It is not that smaller municipalities do not deserve metro; everyone deserves and can have their metro. What we do not have is enough money to build metro for everyone. So, as it is one of the most expensive works, to have metro there must be a high population concentration. First, to benefit the population, and second, because there is a very serious urban problem in Brazil that exists in some large cities. Either we solve and help to resolve these serious problems, or we are failing in the role that the Union has in relation to states and municipalities.

Obviously, other alternatives in urban mobility are valid. We consider BRT to be very important; we consider... in some cases, monorails are appropriate, in other cases, other solutions are suitable. All solutions will be considered. Now, we warn that the individual municipality that does not have a high population should not propose metro, because it is losing the opportunity to have an investment in urban mobility. A large municipality or a combination of municipalities that has a significant population is the typical characteristic for metro.

We will give... we will prioritize, to grant financing for metro, those who take on, who take on – this is a fundamental point – those who take on the management. Along with the financing goes the management. Because it cannot be, it is not feasible for the Union to take on the management of metro. It finances metro, but it will not take on the management of the metro. It is important for you because you will have the conditions to evaluate – let’s say – how the different types of mass urban transport combine.

I will insist that this is a completely preliminary meeting; it is to provide guidance. We will even give a large space here for the technical staff from the municipalities to have a discussion with our technical area, from the Ministries of Cities and Planning, within the spirit of the PAC, which all of you who have participated in the PAC know, which is a republican spirit of partnership with states and municipalities, respecting the autonomy of states and municipalities. I am sure that both we, the federal government, and the states and municipalities have learned a lot in this process from what we did before.

I hope that this phase of the PAC is better than the previous phase, when we did not yet have all the training in the art of making projects, licensing the project, having basic projects, executive projects, and having conditions... That is why we are having this meeting, because it is to prepare, to give you time. Make your projects – and I believe many people already have – complete what is missing and send it to us. And we will once again make a common partnership. I am sure... I see so many people here with whom we have worked over the past few years, in President Lula's government, and I see new faces. I am sure we will have a partnership as good as we had before. And now we have two ministers, who I am sure will make a difference: one, Minister Mário Negromonte, of Cities; and the other, Minister Miriam, of Planning. And now, as a very important person for you to consult, complain, and express what you think, here is the Minister of Institutional Relations, our dear Luiz Sérgio.

So, I thank you, wish you good work and much discussion. The ministers will be available, and then, the technical part, you will do as you see fit.

Thank you very much, everyone.