June 25, 2014 - Speech by the President of the Republic, Dilma Rousseff, during the meeting of the Council of Science and Technology and Business Mobilization for Innovation (MEI)

Brazil Dilma Rousseff · President of Brazil

25 June 2014 · Meeting of the Council of Science and Technology and Business Mobilization for Innovation (MEI)

Context
Rousseff addressed the National Council of Science and Technology and the Business Mobilization for Innovation meeting in Brazil on June 25, 2014, emphasizing innovation and education.
Main themes
Science and technology innovation, government-industry-academia collaboration, education reform, business mobilization for innovation, poverty reduction and social mobility, research funding and institutions, technological cooperation agreements, Brazil's development strategy
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,182
87th percentile
Sentences
201
89th percentile
Readability
55
76th percentile
Grade
10.5
26th percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
46th percentile

Translated from Portuguese

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 30%30%
  • Social 23%23%
  • Institutional 19%19%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Technological 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

201 sentences in 46 paragraphs

I would like to greet the Minister of Science, Technology and Innovation, Clélio Campolina Diniz. And I would like to congratulate him for the effort that, once again, we are making to improve a challenge that is, starting from basic science, to create technology, to create innovation, based on a tripod that is, on one side, the government, on the other side the companies, and on a third side, academia and research institutes.

I would also like to greet our president of CNI, Robson Braga. And, in greeting Robson Braga, I greet all the leaders of the business mobilization movement for innovation, for the strategic role that this movement has for us to advance, in the sense of an ever greater integration of the relationship between scientific research, technology generation, and innovation.

So, here we are, at the National Council of Science and Technology, and also in a meeting with the Movement for Business Mobilization for Innovation. This is very symbolic, because it represents precisely what Felizzola said, which is the basis of leadership in this process that each country builds its own path, but learns from others.

I would also like to greet all the ministers present, greeting the ministers who are at the table: Campolina, from MCTI; Minister Mauro Borges, from MDIC; Minister Paim, from Education; Minister Mercadante, from the Civil House.

I greet all the other ministers present who have an interface with this process: Minister Celso Amorim, from Defense; Minister Luis Alberto Figueiredo, from Foreign Relations; Minister Gilberto Occhi, from Cities; Minister Marta Suplicy, from Culture; Arthur Chioro, from Health; and Minister Francisco Teixeira, interim from Integration.

I also greet General José Elito, who honors us with his presence here.

I greet José Pimentel, the government leader in the Senate.

I would like to also greet the members of the National Council of Science and Technology who spoke: Carlos Sanchez, president of EMS; Sérgio Gargione, president of the National Council of State Research Foundations; Ênio Gandotti, vice president of SBPC.

I greet the representatives of MEI who spoke: Adriana Machado, vice president of government affairs and public policies at General Electric; Ricardo Felizzola, president of Altus; Bernardo Grandin, president of GranBio.

I also greet Luciano Coutinho, president of BNDES,

Glauco Arbix, president of Finep,

Jorge Guimarães, president of Capes,

Gláucio Oliva, president of CNPq.

I would like to greet the entrepreneurs who today signed technological cooperation agreements: João Fernando Gomes de Oliveira, for Emprapii; Rafael Luchesi, general director of Senai; Domingos Manfredi Navero, director of INT; Fernando José Gomes Landgraf, director of IPT.

I would like to extend a special greeting to scientists and academia, greeting two people: Professor Rogério César Cerqueira Leite and Professor Jacó Pales, president of the Brazilian Academy of Sciences. One, a mathematician, and the other, a physicist, the two basic sciences that we consider crucial for the production of basic science, technology, and innovation in our country.

I would also like to greet the president of Sebrae, Luiz Barreto, who is present here,

And greet the ladies and gentlemen journalists, photographers, and cameramen.

Ladies and gentlemen,

We all know that the issue of education is fundamental for Brazil, and education is becoming increasingly important because it fulfills a dual role in Brazil. On one hand, it ensures that the process we started in 2003, of elevating millions and millions of Brazilians, first, by lifting them out of poverty and misery, from extreme poverty, and raising these millions of Brazilians, in practice, 42 million, to the middle classes.

This process, to have sustainability, will indeed require education as a strategic issue, education as a condition for us to ensure not just exit doors, no. It is to ensure a country made up of technicians, of professionally qualified people, and thus, ensure that these people do not regress to a loss of income, should any different process occur in our country. And the second path, which is also a consequence of basic education, is to ensure the quality of our education, to ensure that we have schools with two shifts that teach elementary education in the second shift, right, Paim? Not teaching, as I jokingly tell Paim, how to make cake, but teaching Mathematics and our language, Portuguese, something essential for you to be able to think. Also teach notions of science, ensure access to a second language. That is what is done in the second shift.

We, to do this, made a great effort. If you ask me: are the 60,000 full-time schools the ones we need? I would still say: no. We still have to do much more in these schools and spend a lot of money from the Social Fund to produce this, to make this happen, because we need educational infrastructure and we need to have a policy of paying teachers well that is not demagogic. Pay well by demanding quality of education. Now, universities also have to train teachers, universities have to train technicians, have to train scientists, and we have to have first-class professional training programs, because we will not have a change in the Brazilian workforce and life, we can plan for 20 years, but it is lived every day.

So, the Brazilian workforce has to be trained. That is why Pronatec will go from 8 million to 12 million and we will reach 20 million Brazilians trained, that is, technically qualified, and also ensuring, at a high school level, a clear technical training. We have a great task ahead because this is the basis of what we are discussing here. I believe that the law that allocated 75% of the royalties for education and the social fund for pre-salt is one of the conditions for us to have the basis. Just as it is necessary for technology to have basic science, it is necessary, for any of this, to have basic education.

And there, the issue of pre-salt is strategic. Also because, gentlemen, it is important for you to know that yesterday we assigned, because the law allows it, the law that created the sharing model in Brazil allows the federal government to assign Petrobras the direct exploration of some fields. We assigned Petrobras the exploration of the Búzios field, the surrounding area of Iara, Florim, and the northeast of Tupi. We assigned four areas to Petrobras. All these areas, it had received, in a restricted manner, in 2010, through the model that was called “onerous assignment.” I am explaining all this because it is crucial to understand where the money in this country will come from. This resource was restricted to five million... billion, sorry, equivalent barrels of oil. To give you an idea, when we auctioned Libra, Libra had a reserve of 8… between 8 to 12 - that was what was expected - billion equivalent barrels. These four fields that are in this area that was previously assigned to Petrobras, but restricted to 5 billion, they, taking out the 5 billion, have between 10 to 14 billion equivalent barrels of oil. This means that, for health and education, we will have, in the next 35 years, a flow of a little over 600 billion reais. Along with the others… and the advantage of this is that it starts to be paid from 2015. Obviously, it is a curve, and this curve grows as it approaches five years later. The closer it is to 2018, the greater the amount of resources.

So, we will have to use them for basic education in this country. Using for... what I call basic education is not elementary education, no. It is elementary education... it is daycare, elementary education, high school, Pronatec, that is, technical education, access to Federal Technological Institutes, access to university, research laboratories, and research institutes with a determined level of quality and requirements. None of these resources will be... and it is possible to do in previous bureaucratic models. We have to stop a little and ask ourselves: what do we need to change to transform our country and make it capable of making this transformation? That is what we need to ask ourselves.

I believe that we need to integrate education, science, technology, and innovation, and here we need each of those present and we need all the institutions. I think, despite my extreme value for basic science - so much so that in… I am sure that if we do not train mathematicians - no, right, Jacó? - if we do not train mathematicians, physicists, biologists, and chemists, we will not have decent engineering, I am sure of that.

And I want to say the following: that two numbers show our challenge. Between 2000 and 2012, the number of articles by Brazilian researchers quadrupled, which is very good. Multiplied by 500, it would mean 500%, if it quadrupled, is that not so? Well, in the same period, patent applications to INPI grew only 62%. I know there is a delay between research and patents, but, in our country, we must recognize that we have few patents. This is a discussion that I and the minister have: We have 50 thousand (...), they have 150 thousand papers, but you look, please, what is the level of registration they have of patents, and look at ours, do not multiply by three, if ours multiplied by three, I would be very happy, very happy. But, no, they multiply patents by a thousand, for more than a thousand.

So, I think we have to use knowledge platforms to narrow this process and to allow two things. We are an open country, there are two ways to access technology. One is through transfer, which requires practice and skill, requires the power of those who receive a certain negotiation capacity. Opening sources, which we know are very complicated to be opened, but we cannot abandon this vein. But, I think a country like ours needs to create internal conditions, also, to generate science, technology, and innovation. And there I consider it absolutely essential the unity of all this sector with the industrial sector. I think without a strong industry, it is difficult to carry out an innovation process. An industry or agriculture, because Embrapa is a product of strong agriculture.

I believe that we will have a challenge in what some call energy, others call shipbuilding, others call research in deep waters. We will have to do this because, if we do not, we have two risks: one risk is called the “Dutch disease” and the other risk is called “the oil curse.” A country rich in oil, poor in industry and population.

So, being able to create technology in this area is a matter of stability even in exchange rates, because we will have, in the coming years, a specific influx of dollars, we have to know this, this will happen. Today, we are in a certain situation of the balance of payments, in three years the situation will be different. And those who think about the future can prepare. That is why we need to have a producing industry here, of equipment for this area. We have the possibility to develop the health area. Several other areas we have to enter, use the purchasing power of the country, we have to use the purchasing power of the country. No one has made any leap in this area without using the purchasing power of the country.

Today, the NSA is working... The NSA, the American National Security Agency operates as a variant of the defense complex company. It generates, today, all the complexity of (incomprehensible), which everyone will use in the future, it generates technology in this area, it generates the entire system of supervision, control, and monitoring, therefore, it generates cutting-edge technology in the area of ICTs. Those who are generating this have a name, address, and phone number. They know ours, but we know theirs, we know perfectly where they are. There are thousands, regardless of what the byproduct is, you have to know that this is happening, as additive manufacturing is happening. It may not be stabilized, but it is happening. And this will be the future, or a variant of this, or this may not work. Everything is a maturation process, these are not completely stable technologies yet, but we will have to look at all areas. That is why our situation is a complex situation. It is not enough for us, it is not enough just one shot, we have to hit several shots, at least 20 that you mentioned, okay, Tourinho. I am already very happy with the 20 shots from the 20 platforms of Campolina or others that, in this process, you will build.

I believe that we have adequate financing structures. At a certain moment when I was president of the Board of Directors of Petrobras, Petrobras invested in research and I wanted to increase the amount that Petrobras allocated to research, and there was - I told you this already - there was a questioning from Petrobras regarding the quality of what was offered to it. It may be Petrobras's mania, but if we go down a middle path, we also have to improve the research we do internally in Brazil to be able to connect companies, and companies also need to have a greater willingness to invest in technology and take risks, because our representative, Adriana, said very well that “there will always be this trade-off between disruptive processes and profitability.” In any area of activity this will happen, and disruptive processes and profitability is risk. The name of this is risk, and risk is priced, and risk frightens.

Therefore, the financing and action processes of the funding agencies must be adequate. We have suitable funding agencies, and it is reckless to say that we do not have resources, because we were just looking at the amount spent on Inova Empresa. We rationalized Inova Empresa. How? We aggregated all the sources of financing and spending from the federal government, totaling 32.9 billion. Of these 32.9 billion, a little over 18 billion has already been applied. So, we still have 22... no, 24, right? 24 billion in the pipeline.

We also have the budget for federal universities, which has grown by 159% in real terms since 2011. We created 18 federal universities and 173 campuses. We also increased the study of Brazilians in private universities with Prouni and Fies. We increased the number of enrollments in higher education courses. We managed to create a meritocratic system for access to universities, without entrance exams, which is the Enem. In the last Enem, there were 9 million, 519 thousand registered, which shows the size of the pressure on higher education in Brazil and the extent of our effort, the effort that needs to be made. We ended that law that prohibited investment in education, in technical schools, and we returned to invest in technical schools. Between the Lula government and mine, there will be 422 federal education institutes.

And I want to tell you that I have, shortly, to implement Pronatec 2... By the way, sorry, I have already implemented Pronatec 2, it is Ciência sem Fronteiras, Ciência sem Fronteiras. Why do I have to do the 2? I have already done Pronatec, I am doing Ciência sem Fronteiras 2. Because in both you need to provide a perspective for the future. In Pronatec, it has to be given to our partners, our partners from the Sistema S. By the way, Pronatec is not just about enrollments. Pronatec is the ISI, the Senai Innovation Institutes, the 26 institutes of Senai, and the 60 Senai Technology Institutes, because we structured, we are providing structure for the private sector, which will share this challenge with us, and we are providing structure for universities and federal institutes.

In the case of Ciência sem Fronteiras... Ciência sem Fronteiras is something interesting, I thanked the Chinese Minister of Foreign Affairs, I thanked him for the 5,000 places he had made available to Brazil, even guaranteeing... he is willing to guarantee accommodation, etc. Saying: "Ah, thank you, it is important for us." He said the following to me: "Five thousand is? Five thousand is very little for you, because South Korea is smaller than you, much smaller than you, and places 50,000 - 50,000 students in China. I am saying this to show the size of the challenge we have. The federal government holds 100,000. Now, we would very much like to have partners who would share with us the meritocratic criterion. Because here, in Ciência sem Fronteiras, there is no "Who Indicates." What earns access to this, the scholarship, is the merit of the student. If he scored 600 points on the Enem, if he has competence and masters a language or if he was also accepted into a university. And it has to be at the best universities in the world. We do not place students in just any university, because then it is not worth it.

We want this, when it comes to undergraduate studies, to create a perception base for the Brazilian segment to know that there is a teaching standard that we need to achieve, there is a laboratory standard that we will have to meet, and there is a teacher performance standard that we will also have to demand. All of this because we need to make a revolution in this area. I believe that in all areas we will need to allocate resources. More than we have allocated in the past and present, without a doubt. Inexorably more, because otherwise, we will not have all the necessary resources to make the leap we need. Now I am sure of one thing: I have never seen such awareness, nor such closeness of conception as we see now between entrepreneurs, government, and academia. Do we have some differences? Oh, yes, we do. We can very well coexist with these differences. The art will be for us to be able to coexist with different visions, but always knowing that it is essential that we articulate them, this does not mean refusing to discuss, on the contrary, I believe that whenever necessary we should explore these differences and see how close we are to a vision, but opening this debate is something very important.

I believe that all areas in Brazil, be it Finep, and there I want to greet Glauco, because I told Glauco: all right, Glauco, money means reducing the time of entry and exit of the project within Finep. If there is this speed, we will seek the sources of resources, because I was in charge of... and I want to greet him, because it has changed. You all recognized it today. I greet Luciano as well because things have changed, and I believe that we have all the resources with Capes and CNPq, and all these funding agencies acting together - not one pulling to one side, another pulling to the other - we will be able to focus on what is relevant.

I think we need to experiment, and here researchers know this, we need to experiment with various models, combining public and private and their gradations, OS, in short, we will also need to have inventiveness in governance. And allow me, Minister, I think that in the governance of the platform it is important to include academia and companies as well. I think these different visions... but it does not have to be ten, it can be five. It does not need to be five ministers. It can be three and we can... include more companies and academia, a representative from companies and academia. Why? Because I think the difference in vision is very important in this area... at this moment.

I am sure that we will reach a point where not only the calls will be larger, not only will we try - and I think someone here said this and I totally agree - we will have to have clearer and more defined legal frameworks. Now, legal framework, you see, folks, is a difficult thing to do. I even wanted to explain to Gandotti. Do you know why, Gandotti, that the lock is not paid in the energy tariff? Because when I passed, in 2004, the regulatory framework for electric energy in the National Congress, it was simply, either I accepted to remove it, or the regulatory framework was not approved. So, in your room, we have to put a lot of people, you see? And I want to say the following: that I have already experienced this method, it does not work. Better is persuasion. You lock someone in a room and say: "Now you give me the answer," it does not work, no. But... because it would not fit in a room either.

But I am explaining this to you because in Brazil things are not trivial, they are not trivial. The legal framework, we will all have to face together. The Legal Framework, we managed now, through a whole process of discussion with the people from the sector, the Biodiversity Framework, 7 ministers and the sector, and we managed to unify the position, and we took the law out. Now we will have to go to Congress, there, to defend the law, everyone together defending the law. This, we can do in several areas. It implies participating, participating, and participating, because neither the government does this alone, no, it does not work, we cannot, nor can you. So, it is a point of unity, now, I think that the legal framework is something easy to do, it is not a difficult thing, and we can start to list, via knowledge platforms, because it is fundamental for the knowledge platform, the legal framework gives you the legal umbrella to do various things. So, I think one of the items would be to prospect what legal frameworks are pending.

Finally, I want to say the following to you: I trust, I had here a speech that was almost a report of what has been done during this period, but I do not want to say that, and I want to say the following: I trust that the platforms will have very clear criteria for being chosen. From my speech, it is the part I want to recover, that all platforms need to combine the participation of groups of excellence in research and one or more companies or consortia of companies, that the representatives of MEI here know well that if there is no entrepreneur to take a new technology or a new production process to the market, they will only remain as an idea.

I tried, some time ago, it even matured, I was happy to see there, in your company. When we negotiated the Brazilian digital TV system with the Japanese, we set as a condition the implementation in Brazil... Celso Amorim, at the time, was the Minister of Foreign Affairs, he even went to Japan negotiating with the respective Minister of Foreign Affairs. We set as a condition the transfer of technology in the area of semiconductors. It was a long discussion, and for me it became clear, there was no entrepreneur on our part here, or it was not mature, and there was also no research center to replace at the beginning of the negotiation. So, it only happens when there is this component. Somehow, someone, a company, an entrepreneur, a research institute has to be in a hub for you to negotiate effectively, right? This happened with Embraer, this happens with Petrobras via Cenpes. The level of negotiation with Embrapa is also different when this happens. So, this is the first point.

The second is that all platforms need to have economic relevance and should be oriented to produce science, technology, and innovation for strategic areas for Brazilian productive development. There will be a day, further down the line, when we will do without having this immediate economic relevance, but as we are starting, we need economic relevance. There will be a day when we will do research and apply it to what will or will not generate knowledge in the future.

Third, they must contribute to the development of relevant technologies for improving the quality of life of the population. Fourth, they must have a research institute capable of anchoring the technological development process. Our success will depend on our ability to identify the best and most suitable research institutes and, when necessary, modernize them to compose the platforms. All platforms must have flexible institutional frameworks and appropriate governance. They cannot be bureaucratic or extremely burdensome. You are looking at my paper there, and I copied it from you. That's right! I copied it from that paper you gave me.

So... because I found it extremely relevant and clear, and I believe that is what we want with these platforms. We want, in fact, to transform Brazil, to transform Brazil and empower Brazil in the next 10, 20, 30 years for whatever comes our way.

Thank you very much, everyone.