Speech by the President of the Republic, Dilma Rousseff, during the 43rd Ordinary Meeting of the Plenary of the Economic and Social Development Council (CDES) on June 5, 2014.

Brazil Dilma Rousseff · President of Brazil

5 June 2014 · 43rd Ordinary Meeting of the Plenary of the Economic and Social Development Council (CDES)

Context
Rousseff addressed the 43rd Plenary of Brazil's Economic and Social Development Council (CDES) on June 5, 2014, outlining plans for PAC 3 and future infrastructure investment priorities.
Main themes
PAC infrastructure program, public investment planning, Minha Casa Minha Vida housing program, public-private partnerships, logistics investment program, Pronatec vocational training, Brazilian economic development, civil society engagement, government capacity building, fiscal history and debt crisis, long-term planning framework
Duration
~50 min
94th percentile
Words
6,001
94th percentile
Sentences
297
95th percentile
Readability
51
67th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.92
37th percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
59th percentile

Translated from Portuguese

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 44%41%
  • Social 25%24%
  • Institutional 16%15%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

297 sentences in 46 paragraphs

Good afternoon everyone.

I would like to greet our Minister Mercadante, Minister of the Civil House and Executive Secretary of the Economic and Social Development Council.

I greet Minister Guido Mantega,

Minister Tereza Campello,

And Minister Paim, on whose behalf I greet all the ministers present here.

I greet the councilors: Clemente Ganz Lúcio, technical director of Dieese, who made a very significant presentation, as well as Jorge Nazareno Rodrigues, president of the Metalworkers' Union of Osasco and Region. And Antoninho Trevisan, who delighted us with his passion for football, which is always very good to see and experience.

I would like to greet all the ladies and gentlemen members of the Economic and Social Development Council, CDES.

I greet the journalists, photographers, and cameramen.

I will basically make a very different speech. The Economic and Social Development Council makes a great contribution to the country, because in the Council we have a diverse representation of Brazilian civil society, entrepreneurs, workers, we have members of academia, we have members of the government, in short, we cover a very large spectrum of segments of our population.

So, I would like to share with you a perspective for the future. Whenever we share a perspective for the future, we have one eye on the past and one on the present to define the future. So, what I want to share with you is how the continuity of the PAC and Minha Casa, Minha Vida looks, basically. Minister Paim will, together with our partners from the private initiative, which are CNI, CNA, CNT, and all those, the entire confederation of commerce and transport, our guidelines for the continuity of Pronatec, I believe will be next week, right, Paim? That's right. And what I wanted to discuss here is to see the Council as a very qualified forum for debates and to raise some of our concerns regarding how the future is outlined in the coming years in this regard.

So, I will basically divide it first into an assessment of what PAC was, the so-called PAC 1, PAC 2, and our Investment Program in Logistics. And then discuss how PAC 3 and the Investment Program in Logistics 2 could be directed. In fact, I think all of this will show that we have accumulated experiences, accumulated knowledge both in relation to the government and in relation to the private initiative and all those who participated: social movements, in the case of Minha Casa, Minha Vida, urban and rural.

Well, at the beginning of 2003, Brazil had been for practically two decades without investing, making large investments and thinking about the planning of the country. So, since the 80s and 90s, when the debt crisis began and this crisis turned into a fiscal crisis, we not only did not make large investments, but we did not carry out projects, nor did we build the planning framework that would allow us to define medium and long-term goals and manage short-term goals.

It is good to remember that we resumed planning in 2007 with PAC. And we started to think about investments in the country in a context of great need, because all planning processes and all management processes always incorporate the experiences and knowledge that you acquire precisely in the previous phase. Without a previous phase, there is no updated project and there is no experience.

So, PAC, conceived as a strategic plan for the resumption of investments in infrastructure, has a great merit; it contributes decisively to consolidate a new way of carrying out large works in Brazil. First, it emphasizes that it is not possible to carry out works without a partnership and active action from the federal government, looking at the states and municipalities. Second, we affirm that it is also not possible to make significant investments if there is no public-private partnership, whatever form it takes, from the direct construction of large works to concessions, passing through all other derived forms such as PPPs.

So, when we started, we came from a very low organizational level in the public and private sectors. In the public sector, for example, we had several norms and regulations that were aimed much more at restraining and limiting the execution of works, due to the ongoing fiscal adjustment. It was much easier to create barriers than to deny. That was the logic. I give an example, the so-called "dumb queue," the queue for sanitation, for sanitation investments. Whoever entered first, as long as all possibilities were not exhausted, you did not move on to the second. So it was an investment queue and not an investment portfolio. It became known as the "dumb queue."

In addition, the Ministries did not have technical staff, they did not have engineers, they did not have qualified managers, because also, let’s remember well, there was a dismantling of planning, management, and execution bodies in Brazil, and we prioritized the oversight bodies. This is very clear in the salary discrepancy; the salary difference reached seven, five, or six times the salary of the inspector, compared to that of the executing engineer.

Well, in the private sector, there was... the dismantling of project companies occurred. There were no project companies, nor were there companies to carry out environmental studies in significant numbers. In addition, there was a reduction in the number of heavy construction companies, since there was no heavy construction being offered in Brazil. There was an outdatedness of construction technologies and there was an absurd limitation of credit, because credit did not have a long-term credit standard compatible with investment in infrastructure. No one invests in infrastructure with long-term credit being seven years. With interest rates being Selic, investment is unfeasible. There is no model that can withstand the absence of long-term credit, and a flight of engineers not to the construction sector and even less a devaluation of the engineer. A good engineer was an engineer who was absorbed by the construction sector… by the financial sector. You did not have a disseminated experience of engineers. I remember when I went to discuss local content for making platforms, there were no designers. Why? Because of the following. Because a designer works according to the availability of industrial resources. What was complained about at that time, as projects were contracted abroad, the engineering project was done according to the logic, the dynamics, and the characteristics of the industry abroad.

With that, we did not have to change the tire while the car was running, no. I think Miriam is right. She always says that. We changed the engine of the car. And we took several measures and, progressively, we overcame. From the public sector's point of view, we equipped the public sector with better conditions to execute and oversee. And the private sector also changed its production conditions with great agility.

So what happened in PAC1? We expanded the capacity to plan and execute, in some areas decisively. For example, in the energy sector, we created a regulatory framework for the electric sector, the Energy Planning Company (EPE), the Electric Energy Trading and Compensation Chamber (CCEE), because the wholesale energy market was great, but it did not pay. There was energy exchange, but there was no payment. Those in the energy market remember this characteristic of the MAI very well. The Electric Energy Trading and Compensation Chamber began to pay, and there was also a gentlemen's agreement within the Chamber that payment would not be judicialized, which was a practice in the electric sector, that is, lawsuits piled up and no one paid anyone. Well, and the Electric Sector Monitoring Committee was also created, responsible for, within a two-year horizon, looking at the security of the system, the security of the electricity supply in the country. In addition, we implemented the Light for All program.

Well, we also had a whole interest in improving conditions for private investment. For example, we improved some models, such as Rede, Reporto, and Repetro. We created better credit conditions, lower interest, a longer term, grace periods, and we built, in the oil sector, the sharing model, since the risk conditions and, therefore, remuneration had changed, since in the concession the risk is greater, there is no certainty of finding oil, there is a very low success rate, and in sharing, you know where the oil is, the quantity of oil, the quality of oil. And therefore, it made no sense to remunerate two differentiated situations from the market perspective in the same way. This explains why large companies… a large one like Shell or Total and two careful Chinese companies, the two largest in the world, one in the marketing area and the other in refining, were willing to pay 15 billion reais for 75% of the income for us and 25% of the income for them. It is precisely because of the expected and guaranteed return.

Well, and we structured, with the decisive participation of the private initiative, but decisive, Minha Casa Minha Vida in 2009, and we set an ultra-ambitious goal at that time to contract one million housing units by 2010. In PAC 2, it was centered like PAC 1, on public works, but then we added the PIL, which is the Infrastructure or Investment in Logistics Program, which was a concession program, increasing the presence and participation of the private sector in the concession of highways, railways, ports, and airports, and therefore clearly defining a second strategy, which was a strategy more centered on public-private partnership, with the private sector in the concession model, and not in public works.

Then we set the Minha Casa Minha Vida. For Minha Casa Minha Vida, we initially defined a contract for 2 million, we moved to 2 million and 400 thousand housing units, and we reached, in the end, 2 million and 750 thousand housing units, and we will... we have already contracted, adding Minha Casa Minha Vida 1 with 2, and it is good to remember that 1 did not have time, 1 was created at the end of 2009. So we only managed to contract, and we started delivering 1 in 2011. So if you add 1 with 2, it gives 3 million and 750 thousand housing units. Of the 3 million and 750 thousand, we have already delivered 1 million, 702 thousand and 70 housing units, and we contracted 1 million, 706 thousand and 114. We still need to contract about 300, 350 thousand housing units. And with a great partnership with the private sector, because this program was conceived with them, it was conceived with the presence of companies, small and medium-sized companies from CBIC, and large construction companies. In a second moment, we had the very important partnership of rural and urban social movements. Rural social movements also participated in the construction process of Minha Casa Minha Vida 2, and urban ones did the same, making a great contribution.

We changed the model of highways regarding concessions. How did concessions work in Brazil? Before President Lula's government, no one granted concessions to expand highways. There was no concession for duplication, there was no concession for a third lane. Why was a highway concession granted? To maintain what was not good. We evolved to concessions only for investment in duplication, for investment in comprehensive improvement, redefinition of routes, modernization, or a third lane. And then in our PAC 2 we changed, and the model became this: you can only charge tolls if you build 10% and within 5 years you must build everything that was contracted, and enjoy the concession in the following years, because otherwise it was an immense cost for the State. It took 15, sometimes 20 years to complete the investment. This change is significant, I note it, because it will mean that the contribution of these concessions to the population will be faster. For the population, not only individuals, but also companies, the service sector, in short, all those who use the highways, and, obviously, a compatible financing structure. Otherwise, there is no investment in infrastructure. And this compatibility is very important. The investor must feel rewarded, otherwise he will not invest either. So the long-term financing structure in Brazil requires that there be amortization conditions, that there be adequate investment conditions with what is required from the concessionaire.

Furthermore, Tereza showed there... I will speak because Tereza spoke. I believe that the Água para Todos program is a fundamental program. It includes cisterns, and we have the goal of building 750,000 cisterns during our government period. Adding those from Lula's administration, we will have 1,100,000 cisterns in the northeastern semi-arid region. Building 1,100,000 cisterns in the northeastern semi-arid region was a challenge, and I commend the Ministry led by Tereza [of Social Development and Fight Against Hunger] because it, along with the Ministry of Integration, is responsible. But, in fact, this cistern program is combined with a significant structural investment in water security in the Northeast. Our goal is to radically change the conditions of access to water in the Northeast. For every 1 real of the 8 million reais invested in the Transposition, we are investing almost... a little over 3 reais, because we are investing 33 billion reais in water security, in structural works from Ceará to Bahia: Eixão das Águas and Cinturão das Águas in Ceará; Canal do Sertão Alagoano in Alagoas; Adutora do Feijão and Adutora do Algodão in Bahia; coastal springs, if I’m not mistaken, are in Rio Grande do Norte… is it Paraíba? Paraíba. Anyway, I won’t remember all of them off the top of my head. Bocaina, there in Piauí. These are large-scale works that require the federal state to unite with the regional state, and, in some cases, with the municipalities.

In addition, we created the Differentiated Contracting Regime, RDC, to accelerate public works contracts. We built the Planning Company in Logistics to rethink Brazil in the long term. We greatly improved the environmental licensing process, with more personnel and simplification of procedures. We structured two models: the regulatory model for ports and the regulatory model for railways. And we recognized the importance of investment in urban mobility. Even though it is not a constitutional responsibility of the federal government, we allocated a portfolio of 143 billion, of which 120 billion has already been activated by the states and municipalities. The remaining 113 billion are in progress. Now, obviously, the states, like the Union, also faced the same difficulties: there were no projects, anyway. The governors and mayors made a great effort in Brazil to change this reality. We expanded the FI, FGTS to improve financing structures, created the Brazilian Agency for Managing Guarantee Funds and Guarantees. We created debentures and infrastructure, and executed the first phase of the investment program.

To give you an idea, I can later provide a summary of everything that has been done in all periods. But I think there is something very important. During this period, with PAC 2, right, during my government, we granted 5,348 kilometers of highways. Added to what was granted during President Lula's government, which was 3,281, it totals 8,630 kilometers of granted highways, which shows that we managed to make a leap in concessions. And we changed the highway concession model, which will be very important in PAC 3 for expanding concessions, and to give you an idea, 15% of the federal highway network, 15%.

Well, I would like to highlight that, in addition, we expanded and built 13 shipyards. Added to the five from President Lula's government, that makes 18 shipyards. And now, we have built 19,000 transmission lines, 21,000 megawatts of energy, combining both periods, right? And in my period, we built six airports: Guarulhos, Campinas, Brasília, Galeão, Confins, and São Gonçalo do Amarante. And the ports have already yielded significant results. There are 21 authorizations issued, totaling 9 billion. And there are many more, right? It’s because, as it is an authorization, there is a necessary documentation process and consultation to see if anyone else wants the same location, because if they do, they are required to conduct a simplified bidding process.

Well, what are we thinking? First, in the case of Minha Casa Minha Vida 3, we believe that, once again, it is necessary to open the same methodology that we have always used: consultation. Consult the companies, consult the movements, consult all interested parties, including the states; we have always done this. But we believe it is possible to define an initial amount just as we did back in 2010 for 2011 when we defined 2 million, and ended up with 2 million and 750 thousand homes. We are proposing a definition of 3 million. We conducted a survey, and we are at 3 million. If it is the same expansion as the period [20]11-[20]14, we will reach 4 million, around 4 million, which would give 1 million homes per year. We have not yet built 1 million homes per year. We built almost in one year. We built 960 thousand, if I’m not mistaken. So, it is possible to reach this number, but we do not set it as a goal. The most realistic goal, closer to what the companies have been able to execute, is 3 million, and we start with these 3 million. I made this clarification to say that the goal is like this: when you see that you will meet it, you expand. A goal is like that. Otherwise, it is an easy goal to meet.

Well, so this is the first piece of information, so it is a consultation information. I think it is also important here in the Council, for anyone who has contributions to make, who knows the program, who knows its characteristics, that has a range that goes up to 1,600 reais, right, which is a subsidy between 90 and 95% of the value of the house. Another range that goes from 1,600 to 3,230, which is a smaller subsidy. And a range that goes from 3,230 to 5,000, which is a subsidy based on a lower interest rate and the non-requirement of certain things, for example, insurance, where we have a guarantee fund.

So, this is the first consultation I am bringing here to the Council. This is a process that has a timeline and shows the important role that a Council has in the policy formulation process in Brazil, without compromising the role of the Legislative. They are different roles, right? The Legislative supports, approves the body, and where do we get all the characteristics of the body? We get the characteristics of the body from a consultation with society. Now, it is reviewed and re-evaluated by the Executive, which also shows, on our part, a commitment to the Councils and consultation. We are in favor of consultation, we are in favor of the participation of all segments in the process of structuring government policies. Many heads think more than just the head of the Executive, many heads. It is a conviction we have and is part, I believe, of building democracy in our country.

We intend to continue creating a favorable environment for increasing and accelerating our investments in infrastructure to enhance the country's competitiveness. The country needs this. If you look, you increase microeconomic competitiveness, thus increasing macroeconomic competitiveness, and we must continue to face challenges. In some cases, there are bottlenecks; in other cases, there are no bottlenecks. It is the continuity of investments that we, over time, are obliged to make; otherwise, the country falls behind.

Thus, in the area of logistics, we will continue investing in highways. We will make every effort to increase investment in railways, and in the energy sector, we will maintain investments in generation and transmission to ensure – in the area of electric energy – to ensure supply security and tariff moderation, which are the two models, the two objectives approved by law, in the regulatory energy law, made, if I’m not mistaken, in 2004.

In addition, we will also continue with the issue of access to urban infrastructure. The federal government today invests in metro systems. We currently have nine metro projects underway in Brazil, VLTs, and BRTs. And I want to tell you that it unequivocally improves the quality of life and transportation for people living in the peripheries of our large urban centers. I was there on Sunday, participating in the inauguration of a project that was carried out between the federal government and the city of Rio, a 39-kilometer BRT, which has articulated buses compatible with the metro, and has a segregation of line viaducts, passages, which ensures speed for people to leave Galeão and reach, passing through Madureira, and all the periphery of Rio de Janeiro, the suburbs of Rio, and reach Barra directly, making connections with other lines. This is the idea of urban mobility; it is an interconnection of modalities, allowing for a unified ticketing system.

Well, but we cannot stop there, expanding concessions, etc. We need to increase the coverage of sanitation in Brazil. It is very low coverage. Sanitation and sewage, for water, we are almost universalizing. In some regions or cities, we have already universalized. We need to ensure the development of new strategic areas. First, Brazil has 12 major river basins. We do not utilize them as we should. We believe it is essential for the country to plan and execute all necessary works so that we can use the rivers as our waterways, which were responsible for the interiorization of Brazil's colonization in past centuries, hence the concession model for waterways, dredging, rock removal, signaling, and marking. Priorities, everything above the 16th parallel must be prioritized because all our grain production has a gain of 30 dollars per ton when it flows through the combination of highways-waterways or railways-waterways. It will flow through this modal. So, the Amazon River Basin, the Madeira River, the Solimões, Tapajós, Xingu, and one that is to take the Tocantins… by the way, the Araguaia along with the Tocantins. These are fundamental norths for the country. The São Francisco, of course, the Paraná-Tietê waterway, which is a strategic waterway due to the wealth of the region, and, obviously, to make the Paraná-Tietê we need to resolve the issues of water supply and related investments, which are not decisions of the national state, they are not decisions of the federal government, they are decisions of the state. But, to ensure the continuity of traffic on the Paraná-Tietê, we must guarantee water security in São Paulo. In addition, the Paraguay Basin and the integration of Mercosur via the Mirim lagoons, etc., in the southern part of the country. This is what we conceive in the area of waterways.

In the area of telecommunications, we believe that telecommunications will become one of the most important... in fact, one of the most important investments in infrastructure. One... perhaps the government's priority challenge in the coming periods. This means expanding the network, the so-called backbone, the broadband transport network. Then expand the so-called backhaul, which is the distribution network, access network; it is not the last mile, but it is the backhaul. The last mile the federal government has no interest in securing. It must be an option for the private sector, just as we also think of adopting the partnership model in backhaul and backbone. Well, in addition, to build two continental communication lines, one with the United States and another with the European Union. Launch the Brazilian geostationary satellite, and finally, we need to modernize the regulatory framework for cabotage, the legislation governing cabotage, expanding and promoting its development in a country with the number of kilometers we have of maritime coasts and river entrances.

We believe it will be necessary to implement new measures that further enhance public and private investment. For example, promoting the private long-term credit market; developing guarantee instruments for financing large-scale projects, especially the challenge that we have always come close to but never surpassed, which is the construction of guarantee models in which the investment itself is considered a guarantee, like the so-called "Finance" project - we have variants of the "Finance" project, and Minister Guido, who always tries to do the "Finance" project, knows the difficulties and challenges of doing the "Finance" project in Brazil -; improving the environmental licensing process.

In short, in PAC 3 and in the Investment in Logistics Program 2, which is the concession program, we will have to focus on two modalities that Brazil has abandoned for years and years, one is rail and the other is waterways, being very straightforward in this area. In the case of logistics, that is it and cabotage. In the case of investment in oil and gas, we must continue to view oil and gas as a chain and not just as oil extraction. One of the most important things Brazil has done in this area was the resurrection of the shipbuilding industry and oil and gas suppliers. We went from shipyards functioning for, vegetatively, or almost for their subsistence, to the fourth - the other day I said fourth, they said three, I will say fourth - the fourth shipbuilding industry in the world. That is what we have gone through. Between shipyards and shipbuilding sites, we built 18. They will specialize; you will tend to have some large shipyards producing offshore equipment, and others smaller, producing support ships, anyway, all the naval paraphernalia that is necessary to explore oil in deep waters.

We still have – and here I would like to connect this with the issue of Paim – we have, in relation to oil, the possibility, and this is not just an assessment from the Ministry of Mines and Energy or a consultancy done by the Ministry of Mines and Energy, but you can look at the American energy department that believes Brazil will be the sixth largest oil producer in the world due to the potential we have in what is called the picanha, because the pre-salt is like a picanha. The pre-salt area is like a picanha. There is nothing gaucho about this, and I did not invent it; it is the ANP that calls it picanha. And in this area, an extraordinary amount of wealth will be generated for the country. For me, one of the most important pieces of legislation passed in recent years, last year, for example, was the law that allocates royalties, 75%. These royalties are little, because it is ours, it is only from the federal government, but what is significant is the 50% of the excess oil from the pre-salt. The excess oil from the pre-salt is expected to accelerate its emergence starting in 2017, or perhaps even a little earlier. Until 2017, it is not that there will be no resources, but it will not have a revolutionary proportion for education, because to provide quality education in the country we will need money. And if you were to ask me what is the most important thing Brazil needs to do in the coming years, I would say educate, educate, and educate.

I would like to publicly thank, first, the CNI. Why do I thank the CNI first? Because the CNI, along with Senac, were our first partners in Pronatec. Pronatec is an education program made in partnership with the private sector, which is very important because that was the great challenge we deciphered. The challenge we deciphered in Pronatec is that we were able to bring together the best in the area of education and technical qualification, and offer it for free. The structures of the Federal Technological Institutes, which, by the way, I want to remind you were prohibited in 2005. It was prohibited for the federal government to invest in technical and technological education. We had to send a law to the National Congress to end the prohibition. Well, we expanded the federal technical institutes during Lula's government and my government, and the expansion has a meaning: the interiorization of this in Brazil. So that is one thing, the other thing is the capacity for professional training that Senai, Senac, Senar, and Senat have. Today, the CNA participates, training in the same way that we train a machine operator for the urban area, we train a harvester operator. So, what I… I believe it was a joint effort through which we established the most ambitious training program. When we said it was 8 million, half looked at us with disbelief and the other half did not look at us because they thought it was impossible. But I am immensely grateful to CNI and Senac, the people from the National Conference of Commerce, CNC for the initial effort and also to CNA and CNT, from Agriculture and Transport.

We will need a lot of money. The money will come from there; if it does not come from there, you cannot pay teachers. If you tell the municipality to pay teachers today, it will break; if you tell the state, it will break. No one provides support; the Union also does not guarantee a decent salary for teachers. Along with a decent salary for teachers, there will have to come demands for them to truly commit to education in Brazil. It is a pact of society. I firmly believe that this is essential to change Brazil, essential. If we do not have daycare for children coming from the poorest segments of our population and beyond, if we do not have quality daycare, if we do not have education… in fact, literacy at the right age, full-time education, if we do not have widespread vocational education, and note that that part of education which is the professional qualification of our workers is crucial, because with it what are we doing? The transition. We are looking at our workers who did not have training because they were not given the opportunity; we are creating the bridge between today and tomorrow. That is why when I look there, is it 4 million or 5 million? Five million in professional training and qualification of workers – women, youth, black, adults – I think we are also fulfilling a duty to end social inequality in our country, to provide more opportunities, and I believe that more and more education will need the greatest possible access to higher education.

We have much to celebrate this year. The Enem reached 9 million and 519 thousand people, and the ENEM opens the door to Sisu, the Unified Selection System for federal universities, opens the door to ProUni, opens the door to Fies, and to something very important which is Sisutec, the Unified Selection System for Technological Education, which today we have 300 thousand. We also need to train technologists.

And then I would like to conclude by saying the following. Paim will also announce in the coming days the Ciência sem Fronteiras 2.0, right, Paim, the Ciência sem Fronteiras. We currently have 74 thousand, right, or 73 thousand? Seventy-four thousand already scholarship holders abroad. We selected one group in September and another in December. We will fund 101 thousand. Whatever is lacking, the federal government will cover. I hope it does not fall short, right, Guido, who has the task of ensuring that the 26 thousand previously conceived for the private initiative are fulfilled, because there were 75 thousand for the government and 26 thousand for the private initiative. I am asking here for the private initiative to see if they can hold the 26 thousand; otherwise, we will have to cover the difference, whatever is lacking, because it makes no sense for us not to meet the goal.

And finally, I want to tell you that more and more education plays a dual role. We have had in Brazil, in recent years, the greatest reduction in inequality. Today there is a French author who is an international sensation, because there is an absurd increase in inequality in developed countries, Mr. Thomas Piketty, who says that there was a great increase in inequality from the end of the 19th century until the wars, post-war there was a reduction in inequality in the world, in the United States and in Europe. He uses income tax data that, in some countries, is old. In France, it dates back to the time of the French Revolution. In England, a little later, and he shows that there was an absurd concentration of income starting in the 1970s, and that this concentration of income explains a lot of the difficulty of countries to maintain... he talks about democracy up to economic growth, post-crisis, right. So we have… we are not in that case. We are a country that has reduced inequality; we have this advantage against the current of the world. One thing I suggested to you is to ask Marcelo Neri, minister of SAE and also linked to IPEA, to present this issue of the growing reduction of inequality. It has been progressive, and continues; the good news is that it remains strong also in 2013.

This reduction, it... I would have liked to have started with this, but I did not, it is a very special reduction because it did not take from anyone to give to anyone. The processes of reducing inequality, when they take from someone, create a certain political instability. What did ours do? Ours, everyone increased their income, but the poorest increased much more. Since they increased more, obviously the ladder of social ascension became congested. The congestion is due to two reasons. The first reason is that the 42 million who moved to the middle class entered the ladder, and the 36 million who came out of poverty also did. Well, so there was a congestion on the ladder due to the increase in people, but there was also congestion on the ladder due to access to services. Why? Because... everything I said here is to prove the following: do a service to see how long it takes. Access to goods and income improvement is quick. Access to services implies planning – look at urban mobility – it implies planning and offering. Look at the construction of federal universities, look at the construction of health posts. Access to goods in Brazil is impressive; it grew – according to Marcelo Neri's data, and here I will quote Marcelo Neri – access to goods grew 48%. By the way, sorry, access to goods grew 320%, access to services, 48%. Why is that? Because, to grow services, I need stock; I have to have stock. We did not have stock.

So, Brazil has to make a huge effort to grow services. Services are social infrastructure, services are logistical infrastructure, services are energy infrastructure, services are that. And this is not built in… it is not built when there was no project, there was no financing structure, and there was no political decision from the government that had to invest. We have the political decision that has to invest, and I want to assure you that logistics services change the country's competitiveness, education changes the country's competitiveness, and if I want to perpetuate the reduction of inequality and want to make this country enter the knowledge economy, add value, use innovation as a method to enhance competitiveness, I have to have education. That is why I said it serves two objectives: it perpetuates the distribution… the reduction of inequality. By the way, Mr. Piketty said that this is the only converging factor he sees, aside from taxing everyone, right, taking taxes from everyone; his great factor of convergence is education, I prefer education. And, at the same time, it increasingly allows you to form a country of technicians, of university graduates, of scientists, and of researchers. That is what we want for our country.

So, I conclude by saying the following: infrastructure is as essential as access to goods and income. Thank you very much.