Interventions of the President of the Republic during the plenary session of the European Committee of the Regions.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

1 December 2021 · Plenary session of the European Committee of the Regions

Context
Macron addressed the European Committee of the Regions via video conference one month before France's assumption of the EU Council Presidency, discussing European values and rule of law.
Main themes
French Presidency of the Council of the EU, rule of law, European values, subsidiarity and local democracy, European Committee of the Regions, fundamental rights, democratic backsliding, COVID-19 pandemic response, regional recovery, Paweł Adamowicz legacy, conditionality mechanism, free media and judiciary independence
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,306
88th percentile
Sentences
182
87th percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
12.9
56th percentile
Syntax
3.09
60th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
52nd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 41%41%
  • Geopolitical 21%20%
  • Social 13%13%
  • Environmental 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

182 sentences in 35 paragraphs

[Introduction of the President of the Republic]

Thank you very much, thank you Mr. President for your words, and I would like to greet all of you, ladies and gentlemen members of the European Committee of the Regions, thank you for welcoming me through this video conference.

I am indeed very happy to be before you today, exactly one month before the French Presidency of the Council of the European Union. I would like to thank you, dear Apóstolos, for this invitation, thank you very much.

The French Presidency will be keen to involve all institutions and European bodies in its work and ambitions, including the European Committee of the Regions, and you have reminded us of the representativeness and importance of your Committee. The importance also in a Europe where subsidiarity is an essential value that I do not want to forget. I would say that every time Europe has faced or had to endure criticism of sometimes rampant bureaucracy, it is each time that it has forgotten this principle of subsidiarity and the importance of those who bring it to life closest to our fellow citizens.

The pandemic crisis has also shown this with great force: without our local elected officials, we would have been unable to face the shock we endured. This is absolutely true in France, where mayors in particular and all local authorities played an essential role. It is true everywhere in Europe, both in health and economic terms. Regions are also today at the heart of the recovery that we have chosen to support at the European level, whether it is about supporting economic recovery, digitization, or ecological transition; future investments in our territories are absolutely essential, from the recovery plan to European cohesion policy. And here too, regions play an absolutely key role.

That is why your work is particularly important at this moment, and I want to assure you that it will be fully taken into account during our presidency, because you are this daily matrix of European local democracy.

It was also the fight, and you have reminded us, I want to do so in turn, of the mayor of Gdansk, Mr. ADAMOWICZ, who was one of yours, and the prize you have chosen to create in his memory means a lot to all of us, to us Europeans and to France, and I want to thank you for that. It is synonymous with the fight against discrimination, against intolerance, hatred, but also with the promotion of freedom.

That is why I am pleased to have a discussion with you today about the values that underpin the European Union. Because respect for human dignity, freedom, democracy, equality, the rule of law, as well as respect for human rights, including the rights of persons belonging to minorities, are essential to our Europe. In the architecture of our values, of our law, they are at the heart. We Europeans know that democracy, the rule of law, and the protection of fundamental rights are never a given. We also know that they constitute an inseparable block. We cannot choose some of these rights or select a part of the European values that would suit us while forgetting the rest. It is indeed for these values that Paweł ADAMOWICZ lived and that, unfortunately, Paweł ADAMOWICZ fell. Yet, our Europe continues to face challenges, contestations, and criticisms regarding what we might want to consider as conquered. So I would like to make a few remarks in the time allotted to me.

First, of course, to recall the importance of defending the rule of law. The rule of law is not an abstract notion. It is very concrete, defined by our texts. It is a political community founded on justice, freedom, and equality. It states the value of laws and who makes the law. It states who judges and on what basis they judge. And to every right, it assigns duties, to every power a counter-power. And at the top of the edifice, it places the protection of our fundamental freedoms. That is all the rule of law.

To ensure respect for the law by all, there must be an independent and impartial judiciary in the conditions of appointment, dismissal, and especially in practice that are free from pressure. There must also be non-corrupt powers, active counter-powers, and I will return to this, free and pluralistic media. Defending these principles requires great firmness, an ability not to compromise when the essential is at stake. That is why we have equipped ourselves with new instruments, particularly financial ones. I am thinking of the rule of law conditionality mechanism, but also of the conditionalities including respect for the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union.

They support existing procedures, such as the one based on Article 7 of the Treaty on European Union. This has its own merits, it targets violations of fundamental values and paves the way for regular assessments that could lead to political sanctions.

This element is essential and will be at the heart of the coming weeks and months, we know this, because in several Member States these notions are being called into question and their effectiveness is today weakened. Our duty is to put in place all the mechanisms so that in their entirety these rights, these rules, these counter-powers are restored.

I want to highlight the stakes behind this, which is being used by many enemies of our political project. It is, in a way, to show that it is possible to grant the same rights in the same place in the concert of nations and in our European Union to democracies gradually becoming illiberal, that is to say democracies where there is no longer, in a way, than a democratic formality, but where the substance of the rule of law is progressively emptied of its content. This is indeed a historical and existential struggle that we are waging and that we must continue to wage.

The second major challenge is the protection of democracy and our democracies against all forms of manipulation. The truth is that democracy has always been threatened; perhaps we had somewhat forgotten this. It depends on the countries we come from, as I speak to an assembly made up of many women and men who have fought hard in their lifetime to conquer these rights and to have their fullness. But in, I would say, a good part of our Europe, we thought that this struggle was won.

However, there is always, and we see it today at its very foundation, a fragility of democracy and vulnerability to these manipulations, because at the very foundation of democracy lies the possibility of its own contestation. What is the supreme strength of our democracy is to allow all voices to be expressed, to give them a place, when we are besieged by authoritarian powers that use all means, means of manipulation and hybrid warfare; they use what is a strength of democracy to undermine us at our foundations.

The authoritarian powers that have designated our Europe as an enemy operate in a completely unrestrained manner, which is a new fact of recent years. Their mode of action remains insidious while their reach is multiplied by digital means. Sometimes they come, under the guise of being journalists, they create channels, information sites. Other times, they use what are called trolls, they multiply direct or indirect messages, they fund political parties, activists in our countries to manipulate democratic life and weaken it.

Manipulation of information, exploitation of online platforms, their moderation flaws, cyberattacks: all means are good to amplify content and instill doubt. Today, there is a spectrum that ranges from quasi-political intervention to propaganda to the quasi-militarized cyber threat. This spectrum is being used today by the enemies of Europe and liberal democracy, fully on our territories.

The trust of citizens is shaken, and the consequences are not yet fully taken into account by many decision-makers in Europe and sometimes by many of those who sincerely defend democracy. I want to say here that if we want to defend our Europe, our principles, our democracy, our values, we must not let ourselves be done and act to better protect our electoral processes, our elected representatives, our journalists, our citizens, and the very possibility of a calm, rational, free debate.

This is what emerges from the action plan for European democracy presented by the Commission last December. This plan sets a course to defend the integrity of elections, freedom and pluralism of the media, and the fight against disinformation. I am thinking, first of all, of the creation of a European electoral resilience mechanism that will be presented at the beginning of 2022 so that we can pool our experts to anticipate and counter cyberattacks targeting electoral processes. I am also thinking of regulating the financing of political parties to increase the transparency of donations made to parties and to guard against the interference of foreign actors. Finally, I am thinking of regulating online political advertising. This will involve strengthening moderation obligations related to the fight against disinformation and obtaining more transparency on the origin and dissemination algorithms of advertisements, particularly during election periods.

Thirdly, the vitality of democracy requires independent media. What does this mean concretely? Here too, we thought it was a given, and indeed our experiences, our democratic paths mean that it has now become almost surprising that political leaders can express themselves on what the media should be, because we had acquired such collective maturity that the less politicians were involved in the life of the media, the better it was, because it meant that this life was free, independent of any intrusion, of any pressure. Nevertheless, we must today return to the fundamentals because they are also threatened by the destabilizations I mentioned. Having independent media means that editorial lines must not be, cannot be dictated by funding. Then, that access to information must not be reserved for the most complacent media. And finally, that every journalist must be able to practice their profession without being threatened, exposed to abusive prosecutions or even physical attacks. These imperatives will translate in 2022 into two important initiatives. The first will concern abusive legal actions, the second will be the act for media freedom. This text will complement our range of instruments aimed at supporting media independence and acting on the governance and funding framework of media structures. Under the French presidency, media freedom will also be at the heart of an event to feed a reflection with journalists, but also academics, intellectuals to continue this fight and update it to the hybrid threats and new destabilizations we are experiencing, which are sometimes the result of European decision-makers, unfortunately, or of foreign and non-European pressures.

The rule of law and democracy must serve a priority: the enjoyment by citizens of their rights and freedoms without any discrimination. A major issue today lies in the exclusion of our citizens due to their beliefs, origins, or sexual orientation. The mere mention of these grounds reveals all the injustice. And yet, despite the weight of history, discrimination continues to tarnish the face of Europe. Again, I commend the commitment of European institutions to act against these drifts. The year 2021 saw the birth of the first European strategy to combat anti-Semitism and support Jewish life - which is a tremendous advance. At the same time, the Commission reacted against local policies targeting LGBTQ+ individuals with a rapid success that I also rejoice in. It has also marked its broader commitment by presenting the first strategy of the European Union in favor of equality for LGBTQ+ individuals. To strengthen their protection, France, in anticipation of the presidency of the Council of the European Union, will be keen to act even more. Through the criminal sphere by proposing to integrate hate crimes and speech into the list of European criminal offenses; in civil matters by promoting mutual recognition of parenthood in cross-border situations; and finally for social life by acting for full integration into society.

Women, too, although they represent half of our humanity and that of our continent, still suffer in Europe from discrimination, hatred, acts of violence, and violations of their freedom to control their bodies. France will continue to advocate for all member states of the European Union to ratify the Istanbul Convention on violence against women, and complementarily, France will support the initiative announced by the Commission on violence against women and domestic violence in order to equip the Union with the necessary tools to prevent such violence, protect victims, and sanction perpetrators. Women must also find their rightful place in political and professional life. Thus, certain legislative initiatives deserve to progress significantly in the coming months, and we will work towards that. I am naturally thinking of the directive on equal pay between women and men, which aims to reduce the current and persistent gap of 14%. I will conclude by mentioning the right to abortion. You mentioned, and I thank you for that, Mr. President, the memory of President Giscard d'Estaing, whom we will honor tomorrow. He had the courage as President to pass important legislation championed by the first President of our European Parliament, Simone Veil. Even today, regardless of the cultural specificities of each member state, the right to abortion, the right of women to control their bodies remains a struggle in our Europe, a right to be guaranteed, and we cannot turn a blind eye to the disproportionate violations of this right, which still exist on our soil today.

These are the few remarks I wanted to share with you, and I will simply conclude in line with your comments, Mr. President, by saying that all of this constitutes the agenda for the coming months but, surely, also that of the coming years, as democracy is changing, being destabilized, as well as the rule of law within our Europe. The rise of a new form of conservatism, antiliberal, deeply, that is rolling back our values, our fundamental texts is a concern we cannot ignore because it is also working within our societies from the inside. I believe that all of this must prompt us to reflect on the profound responses we must provide. This is echoed by threats from outside that have been enemies of the European project since its origins, but which are even more so today.

It seems to me that all of this imposes on us the need to equip ourselves with three things. The first is a sense of belonging to the common project. If we do not regain this sense of belonging, if the relationship to democracy and the rule of law becomes an abstract, secondary kind of relationship, then we will lose our citizens. This is a task you undertake every day, and I want to thank you for it, because in contact with the specificities of our territories, this sense of belonging to what our democracy has of existential, of flesh-and-blood for our Europe, you are essential relays. The second thing is that we must, at the same time, build a European demos. That is why I will continue to fight for this Conference on the Future of Europe, for the conclusions we will draw from it in May. As you have very well said, for the indispensable institutional reform that must follow in order to have a Europe closer to the ground, more subsidiary, in which our fellow citizens feel that they, with their local elected representatives, are the true decision-makers, in which we will manage to move away from the idea that Europe has become distant, remote, sometimes technocratic. At the same time, we also need to build the rules so that this Europe exists more across all territories. That is also why I deeply believe in transnational lists and the possibility of a truly European debate during the European elections. Finally, after belonging and the European demos and all that goes with it, we need to protect our democracy. That is why the sovereignty of Europe, its independence, and its military, technological, and industrial sovereignty is inseparable from the strength of its democracy. If we allow our democracies to be weak, they will eventually be swept away. If we allow, for even a single second, the idea to settle that being democrats, we would be vulnerable to hybrid attacks, provocations, that we would be unable to secure our borders or no longer protect our territories, then we would take the disastrous responsibility of leading our compatriots to believe that democracy has become a weak regime. It is quite the opposite. It is a strong regime against enemies, against deadly destabilizations, but it is also a strong regime because, by protecting its borders, it knows how to protect within itself dissent, pluralism, opposition, and the generosity of values that are ours. It is through this balance that we have been formed and that we must build the future. I will not be longer, Mr. President, thanking you again for allowing me to speak, and for the honor of being able to express myself in this way before you.

[Conclusion of the President of the Republic]

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you, Mr. President. Just a few words. First, thank you to all the group leaders and the Vice-President for their interventions. I also want to reiterate, several of you have returned to the subject of rights and the rule of law. And so, I will not repeat what I stated in my introductory remarks, but you can count on the determination of the French presidency.

There was then a question regarding borders. I want to say, in the same way, this relates to what I was saying in my final remarks. We indeed need to improve our system of protection for our common borders, and we know very well that our response, and it is the only one that will allow us to converge the ideological differences that sometimes exist between the different political formations, is to have a comprehensive approach to the phenomenon of migration, that is to say, a policy of aid and development with the countries of origin of these migrations. Among other things, we will address this in the context of the summit between the European Union and the African Union that will take place at the end of February. But this is not exclusive to other regional areas. Then, better protection of external borders. And here, we need a real policy of solidarity and efficiency in investment, both with community instruments, but undoubtedly a solidarity, an interregional responsiveness, because we are facing a new phenomenon which is the hybrid threat, in which migratory phenomena are used by hostile powers. We saw this with Belarus. And then a system based on responsibility and solidarity for the management of the women and men who are then on European soil and to avoid non-cooperative phenomena and behaviors between member states. And I hope that those for whom we will have to decide on strong solidarity measures on external borders will show the same solidarity and spirit of responsibility when it comes to managing asylum statuses or the migration question within Europe. Member states are facing different situations, depending on whether they are first-entry countries or secondary arrival countries. Therefore, we must succeed in finding the right compromises.

On the Northern Ireland protocol, I consider it to be an existential question for us, in two respects. The Irish protocol is fundamentally about how to reconcile the Good Friday Agreement and the integrity of the single market. That is the debate we have had for many months with our British friends. This protocol is therefore both an existential question for Europeans: not to compromise on the uniqueness and integrity of our single market, otherwise, if there are no more borders, there are no more rules, everything would fall apart. But it is also a question of war and peace for Ireland. And so, I think we should not play with this subject. But it is a subject that we will address as Europeans in a spirit of solidarity, as we have from the very first day. Whether it concerns fishing, the Northern Ireland protocol, or migration issues, these are subjects between the European Union and Great Britain.

I was then asked about taxonomy. I will take a position on this, sheltering, if you allow me, behind the experts. Because in climate as in health matters, I think it is always better to decide by referring to those who, as experts in these issues, tell us what it is. What the IPCC experts write is that nuclear energy is part of the solutions to decarbonize our economies. It is not Europe, France that invents this; it is what the IPCC writes. And therefore, deciding to deprive ourselves of nuclear energy would simply be a completely contrary posture to what scientists and climate experts tell us. And this all the more so because it would worsen our situation in terms of sovereignty and independence. The strategy that is ours is to decarbonize our economies. We need to develop renewables for this. Several have done so, and we continue to do so. Renewable energies today, with constant technologies, allow us to produce electricity, but they are intermittent sources of electricity. They are therefore not fully substitutable, even with our interconnections, for non-intermittent electricity production sources, which are mainly coal, gas, and nuclear. Among these non-intermittent electricity production sources, by far, nuclear is the one that emits the least CO2. By far.

The priority for Europe is first to exit coal. To exit coal and maintain the sustainability of electricity supply for our fellow citizens, member states will move a bit towards renewables, but for several decades massively towards gas and nuclear. Gas and nuclear are not equivalent in terms of CO2 production. Gas is a fossil fuel that produces much more CO2 than nuclear, and therefore they are not even equivalent. Nuclear is much better. I point out that in Glasgow, even those who held positions like yours made commitments and called for an end to international financing of gas, not that of nuclear. Alongside this, in terms of sovereignty, many of you have mentioned the risks. We no longer have gas in our soil. Gas in the Netherlands has collapsed, Norway is significantly reducing it. Consuming more gas means importing Russian, Turkish, or gas from other powers. There is no need here to describe what this situation of increased dependence would mean for our Europe. Nuclear is a sovereign solution. For all these reasons, I ardently defend, indeed, a nuclear energy integrated into the taxonomy, and I ardently defend the fact that nuclear is not even equivalent to gas. It is less polluting and more sovereign.

As for the remarks made by several presidents on subsidiarity, the work with your committee, I want to tell you here first that we will work throughout this presidency with you on all the projects: that of social cohesion, that of the outermost regions, as the Vice-President rightly pointed out. And as has been recalled by several of you, President ROUILLON among others, and also President DECOSTER, the importance of your role in the climate and digital transition and the importance of your role in social responses to the crisis.

And so I indeed think that when we talk about subsidiarity and openness to reforms, the idea that your committee, and especially those you represent and of whom you are, have an increased role and that we reflect perhaps according to sectors to produce the norm differently is a reality. I also speak for my country, which is more centralized than many others. I myself, who have a reputation for being someone who makes decisions when I need to, have come to the conviction that on many public policy issues — housing, ecological transition, or others — decentralization - including as you have expressed, I subscribe to this approach, of normative power and responsibility - is probably an element of greater efficiency, and in any case an element that allows us to face the shock we are experiencing.

And so what we need to rearticulate, as we can see clearly, is to have a Europe that focuses on issues of general interest that require a lot of unity, on issues of power, as you said, and sovereignty that are existential, on their rules, and that also knows how to apply more subsidiarity on certain everyday issues where the centralization of norms and uniformity of norms become counterproductive because they are not adapted to the heterogeneity of ground conditions, because they are not understood by our fellow citizens, and because, ultimately, the actors also need to be producers of norms on the ground. And in this regard, that is why my presence is not simply, if I may say so, of a diplomatic nature, but stems from the conviction that you have an important role to play. And you mentioned after that foundational moment that Jacques DELORS supported, I believe that the coming months and years must lead us to dare to have that trust, as you very well said, but to move forward in a concrete manner with responses that are much closer to the ground.

These are the few words I wanted to share in response to your interventions, and I thank you very much for that. And I really wanted to conclude by thanking you for these shared convictions and your frankness, and I would like to especially thank you, Mr. President, for your welcome and also for your commitment to Francophonie, because I am very sensitive to the fact that you had the extreme delicacy to express yourself in French, which touches me deeply and is important.