Joint press statement by the President of the Republic and the President of the Council of Ministers of Italy.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

18 September 2019 · Joint press statement by the President of the Republic and the President of the Council of Ministers of Italy · Rome, Italy

Context
Macron addressed a joint press conference in Rome with Italian Prime Minister Conte days after Italy's new government formation, emphasizing bilateral ties and European migration solutions.
Main themes
Franco-Italian bilateral relations, European migration policy, right to asylum, EU solidarity, Dublin Agreement reform, automatic migrant distribution mechanism, sea rescue and disembarkation, returns and effectiveness, European cooperation, friendship between France and Italy
Duration
~16 min
54th percentile
Words
1,861
54th percentile
Sentences
58
38th percentile
Readability
42
40th percentile
Grade
14.9
75th percentile
Syntax
3.57
96th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 28%28%
  • Ceremonial 21%21%
  • Economic 17%17%
  • Social 16%16%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Environmental 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

58 sentences in 17 paragraphs

Thank you very much, Mr. President of the Council, dear Giuseppe.

I have very little to add and nothing to take away from what has just been said by the President of the Council. I am very happy to be here among you, very happy to be in Rome today just a few days after the formation of your new government.

I have just spoken with the President of the Republic, Sergio Mattarella, after our discussions last spring during the commemorations of the 500th anniversary of the death of Leonardo da Vinci in France, and I am pleased to see you here, dear Giuseppe, in Rome in these responsibilities.

My presence today is primarily a strong desire to work together for the bilateral relationship and for the European project, as you have perfectly recalled. It is also a strong and clear message of friendship sent to the Italian people from the French people. Your President said it a few months ago, this friendship is indestructible. Sometimes we do not agree, we may argue, we may misunderstand each other, but we always come back together. And I believe we are at that point, and the will of the French people is truly to work with the Italian people and to succeed fully. As you said, Mr. President, our wish is to strengthen, and we have just discussed together, bilateral and European cooperation, and I want to simply revisit a few topics.

The first, of course, is the issue of migration. On this subject, I do not underestimate what the Italian people have experienced since 2015, what Italy has endured, and there too with many misunderstandings, misconceptions, and injustices that have been seen, perceived, and that have sparked anger. I deeply believe, as you said, that the response to the migration issue is not in retreat, in nationalist provocation, but in the construction of real and effective European solutions and cooperation.

First of all, we are living in a situation today that is no longer that of 2015 because a lot of work has been done to prevent, with the countries of origin, to work better with many African partners, the situation we experienced then. But what we want to do together is to continue this work. Our Interior Ministers will meet in a few days to work based on our exchange. They will broaden their discussion to other European colleagues, particularly their Maltese colleague and all the countries on the southern shore, and they will meet precisely in Malta, continuing the work we were able to launch in Paris last July, also including several international organizations.

Our approach must meet three requirements to which I believe I can say we are both attached. The first is a requirement of humanity. We cannot resolve this conflict at the expense of human lives or by accepting people stranded at sea or scenes of drowning that we have too often witnessed. The second is solidarity, and that is what has been lacking far too often in Europe. I have said it, the European Union has not shown enough solidarity with the countries of first arrival, particularly Italy, and France is ready to evolve on this point within the framework of the overhaul of the Dublin agreements. I hope that we can work together towards a new, stronger, and more solidary solution. And the third principle is that of effectiveness. Political disagreements have led to an approach that is, in essence, very ineffective, ineffective in preventing arrivals, ineffective also in managing what are called secondary movements, because with our current organization, we have, in essence, too much non-cooperation among member states, resulting in a situation where many women and men who have taken all the risks to leave their country find themselves on the shores of Europe, wandering from country to country, where responsibilities are passed from one to another and where we are collectively ineffective in properly protecting those who have the right to asylum and in quickly returning those who do not have that right.

Regarding rescues at sea and disembarkations, as you mentioned, Mr. President of the Council, I am convinced that we can agree on an automatic European mechanism for the distribution of the reception of migrants coordinated by the European Commission, which would ensure that Italy or Malta, before an arrival, can count on its partners to quickly take charge of all disembarked persons, and have a much more solidary and effective organization, as I just said, more broadly.

To be fair and effective, we must therefore be able to defend the right to asylum everywhere, which is often part of our Constitutions, as is the case in France, which is part of our most fundamental texts, I am thinking specifically of the text of the European Convention on Human Rights. And thus protecting the right to asylum also means ensuring that those who do not have that right are returned as quickly as possible to their country of origin. It is our common will to have, at the European level, greater harmonization of asylum law, more cooperation, and a more effective readmission policy to the countries of origin when cases do not fall under asylum. Overall, I believe that we have today a window of opportunity to finalize, to relaunch on certain points, more fundamentally, the work of overhauling the migration and asylum framework in Europe today.

The discussions we have had in recent days and that we have just had with the President of the Council, as well as the discussions we have had with several of our partners, in any case, make me determined and proactive on this issue alongside you. I also believe that we will be able to defend a common position with the new European Commission so that all countries participate, in one form or another, in European solidarity in this matter, or are financially penalized.

The second extremely important topic we discussed, which is at the heart not only of the bilateral agenda but of the European agenda, is that of growth, job creation, and the macroeconomic context. The President of the Council mentioned it. We all see the figures in Europe, and while today growth is holding up somewhat, it is below what we have experienced because of geopolitical uncertainties, because of global trade conflicts, because of a slowdown in China that weighs on several eurozone economies, and also perhaps because of a coordination of our economic policies that is no longer adequate.

I want, in this regard, this evening, and doing so here has a particular significance, to pay tribute to the work of Mario Draghi, and especially to his recent decisions. Once again, with a lot of courage and foresight, the President of the European Central Bank made the right decisions, but he also made the right statements, even if some do not want to hear them. I say this emphatically, he is, in my eyes, right. Monetary policy, since 2012, has done the maximum it could do to preserve the European situation, to avoid deflation, and to spare us the worst. It is now up to heads of state and government to take their responsibilities regarding their own budgets as well as the decisions we will have to make at the European level, to have a real policy of recovery and domestic demand. Some member states have room for maneuver, and I also commend the recent announcements in this regard from the Netherlands, which have decided on a future investment plan in which, I must say, I find myself, 50 billion in investments over the coming years.

I look forward to the decisions of other member states, and I believe that the budgetary decisions we will collectively have to make must take into account this macroeconomic context and meet the investment and recovery challenge. We need it because we have educational challenges in terms of research, in strategic matters, that are fundamental. And I believe that we can maintain the seriousness that is part of our treaties, we can maintain the reform policies that pertain to each country, but that we must conduct, and we can maintain lucidity about the macroeconomic context that is ours, and refuse, in a way, to let our continent fall into stagnation and instead prepare for its future.

We discussed, with the President of the Council, several other topics, obviously cultural policy and cultural cooperation between our countries. We have extremely important upcoming deadlines: the Leonardo da Vinci exhibition, the Raphael exhibitions that will be the subject of exchanges, partnerships between our two countries and that are at the heart, I believe, of this mutual regard, of this pride that we share.

We have discussed and will work this evening on climate issues. Here too, we both believe in an ambitious European investment agenda, a climate bank that must be at the heart of the next Commission's project, a carbon price that must also take this challenge into account, and a carbon neutrality strategy by 2050, for which we hope to finish convincing the last reluctant partners. It is this same strategy that we will defend together in New York at the climate summit, and then when we have to make our commitments to the Green Fund in the coming weeks.

Finally, as the President of the Council mentioned, on several international issues, we have also combined our efforts and views. And I believe that the issue of the Libyan crisis, which has occupied us a lot in recent years, is now the subject of a real Franco-Italian convergence, a real convergence because we have been able to work together to send messages to our partners. I want to commend the meeting you had with President Al-Sarraj this afternoon, and with a fully shared conviction: the solution can only be found through political compromise and discussions. This is what we also advocated together at the G7 in Biarritz by defending the idea of an international conference for Libya including all stakeholders and an inter-Libyan conference allowing for the reconciliation of all parties within Libya. You just recalled this point. And in this regard, the initiative led by our two foreign ministers in a few days in New York, gathering all their concerned counterparts, is, in my eyes, the very concrete implementation of this will and will be, as you said, an important step.

That is a brief overview of some of the important topics of economic, cultural, and industrial cooperation, on defense issues that we will continue to discuss in a few moments, on European issues, the will that is ours to work together. In a few weeks, we will meet around the Council table to discuss these topics and a few others, and I look forward, Mr. President of the Council, to the prospect you have opened of a forthcoming summit between our two countries at the beginning of next year, which will therefore take place in Italy, which will allow us to continue this joint work and also to pursue the work we had launched for a Quirinal Treaty, and thus to finalize all the common cooperations between our two countries. Thank you.