Press conference of the President of the Republic at the European Council.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

17 October 2024 · Press conference following the European Council summit

Context
Macron addressed a press conference at the European Council summit on October 17, 2024, clarifying France's position on the Middle East and rebuking distorted media reporting.
Main themes
Middle East situation, France-Israel relations, anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism, European Council summit, media responsibility and public debate, hostage crisis, defense of Israel, French foreign policy, fight against Islamist terrorism, disinformation and distorted statements
Duration
~53 min
95th percentile
Words
6,380
95th percentile
Sentences
316
96th percentile
Readability
51
64th percentile
Grade
11.4
37th percentile
Syntax
2.92
37th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

316 sentences in 74 paragraphs

Good evening, ladies and gentlemen,

Thank you for your presence at this press conference following the European Summit. I will begin, given both its seriousness and its timeliness, with the situation in the Middle East. I take the time, as I do every time, to come and hold a press conference with you, and you take the time to be here in front of me. I do this at the end of every summit as well as every conference. I take the time, at the end of every conversation with a counterpart, to issue press releases to express the voice of France. That is why I would like to take the liberty, in starting this press conference, to remind you of a few rules.

There are weekly cabinet meetings. The cabinet meetings are reported to the press by the Government spokesperson and through a press release. For the rest, it is up to each participant in this council to show respect for the rules and their functions, through ethics, through personal discipline, so as not to circulate false, distorted, or out-of-context information, and it is also up to journalists and commentators to treat rumors and reported statements with the necessary precautions. And if words that are reported, distorted and deformed, are quoted, there is no longer any need to hold press conferences or to answer your questions, you will agree with me.

These rules being recalled, which apply to ministers as well as to journalists and which simply constitute the respectful, democratic, and transparent framework within which all my actions are situated. I must tell you how astonished I was to read so many comments, comments on comments, reactions, including from foreign or French political leaders, regarding statements I supposedly made without questioning what they were saying and what I would have actually said. I believe I say enough about the situation in the Middle East not to need ventriloquists. All of this is, in essence, evidence of a deterioration of public debate and a lack of professionalism among ministers who have repeated distorted statements, journalists who have picked them up, and commentators who have not taken the time to consider the reality and the truthfulness of such statements. It is therefore necessary to set things right and with honesty, because this concerns, on an extremely serious subject, the voice of France, nothing more, nothing less.

This is all the more serious as it has hurt many people, particularly several of our compatriots of the Jewish faith, and at a time when, for more than a year now, one of my priorities has been to preserve the unity of the country. I say this here, nothing should raise concern regarding the issue of Israel, at a time when our country is facing a rise in anti-Semitic acts. And consistently, successive governments, including myself, have fought against all forms of anti-Semitism in our country relentlessly and, dare I remind you, since July 2017, I have stated how anti-Zionism is a form of anti-Semitism. It was at the Vel d'Hiv and I had with me a Prime Minister named Benjamin NETANYAHU. There is therefore no ambiguity. All those who would seek to create it through this type of manipulation not only err, but also hurt some and weaken France.

France has always stood by Israel. The existence and security of Israel are intangible for France and the French. That is why I confirm the obvious: we have indeed stood by the State of Israel since day one, when David BEN GURION proclaimed it in 1948, in accordance with United Nations General Assembly Resolution 181. And those who give history lessons should read this proclamation; they will understand why France immediately recognized the State of Israel and has never failed it. This commitment remains, as we have shown again this year by participating in the defense of Israel against attacks from Iran and the Houthis in Yemen. We did so in April as well as in October without hesitation. And this support will not wane, for Israel has the right to peace and security, just like everyone in the Middle East. Israel has the right to defend itself against those who deny its existence, threaten its people, and attack its territory. We will stand by Israel in this fight, as we have since day one and even before.

That is why, as of October 2023, France has stood by Israel, that we have been alongside the victims, all the victims of October 7, that we have also been alongside the Franco-Israeli victims in particular, whom we paid tribute to on February 7 in Paris, at the Invalides. And France is thus the only state that organized such a ceremony. We did this with the experience of terrorism in our flesh, without any complacency, knowing what Islamist terrorism means. From day one, France has also fought for the release of all hostages, with this obsession constantly in mind.

We have also acted. We have mobilized our international partners and I proposed, as of October 2023, to launch a cooperation comparable to that established against Daesh, extending it to Hamas and other terrorist groups operating in the Middle East. On several occasions, the relevant ministers have coordinated international action, exchanged information, and coordinated measures taken in terms of sanctions, prohibitions, and vigilance. We have also provided our support for the targeted operations that Israel has conducted and could conduct against Hamas, so that they can never again commit their crimes. We have also warned Iran and those who are manipulated by this state against Israel, and we have warned them of the serious responsibilities they would take in extending the war to the region. We have condemned their actions from the beginning, particularly regarding Hezbollah, which not only threatens the security of Israelis but also deliberately endangers all Lebanese.

But we must also today face the facts. Adding war to war brings neither peace nor security, neither for Israel nor for anyone in the region. The hostages of Hamas remain detained and their families are in despair. The humanitarian situation in Gaza is catastrophic. Aid is hindered. Children are without education. Families are without shelter. And who can believe that this will ensure security in the long term? Today is marked by the death of Yahya Sinwar and this day is both a turning point and a military success for Israel. I think, in saying this, of the families of October 7. This opportunity must be seized for all hostages to be released and for the war to finally stop.

It is indeed necessary to put an end to military operations now, after this result, to accept a ceasefire in Gaza and finally to open a credible political perspective for both Israelis and Palestinians. We are working on this with all our Israeli, Arab, and American partners. In the day after the war in Gaza, it will be necessary to provide Israel with solid guarantees for its security, to reform the Palestinian Authority, and to move towards the two-state solution. In the immediate term, a ceasefire in Gaza is needed. Humanitarian operations, which are currently at their lowest point, must urgently be multiplied, and indeed, we must also work to put an end to the violence perpetrated by settlers against Palestinians in the West Bank. It is up to Prime Minister NETANYAHU to act and to hear what France and all those who are sincerely committed to Israel's security are telling him. Those who supply him with weapons to carry out operations in Gaza have a particular responsibility, for one cannot call for a ceasefire and continue to supply the weapons that enable these excesses.

That is why we will continue to call for a ceasefire, for urgent humanitarian response, and for a political solution. It is in this context that we must also act for Lebanon. Iran and Hezbollah bear a heavy responsibility in the current situation. By activating Hezbollah against Israel, despite Lebanon's fundamental interest in staying out of the war, Iran has made the cynical choice to expose the Lebanese and to preserve itself. It has hastened the elimination of Mr. Nasrallah and the triggering of Israeli operations. Hezbollah must therefore draw the consequences. It has obligations. First, to renounce weapons, terrorism, and violence. Today, as it is weakened by the death of its leader and the destruction of its military capabilities, which no one can regret, it must allow the Lebanese to come together and find solutions to the multiple crises that are undermining their country.

That is why France will hold a conference to support Lebanon and its sovereignty on October 24. This will aim to provide the necessary humanitarian aid to the hundreds of thousands of people displaced as a result of Israeli operations, to give Lebanese institutions the means to endure during this dangerous period, and to prepare for the future by taking the first steps for the Lebanese army to be able to deploy in the south of the country, but also by facilitating the essential dialogue to emerge from the political crisis. It is in this context that France asks Israel to end its military operations, not to extend its ground action, to respect the sovereignty of Lebanon as well as its obligations towards the United Nations, particularly regarding UNIFIL. I commend here the unwavering commitment of our soldiers within this force. For France, the sovereignty of Lebanon is an essential cause that it will always defend in respect of the diversity of Lebanese communities, convinced that Lebanon carries a message of peace and diversity that is useful to the entire region, and that it is, in a way, as I have had the opportunity to say several times, a country greater than itself. What is at stake in the Middle East is essential for the future of Israel, but also for international peace and security. That is why I am in regular contact with the Israeli Prime Minister, the Iranian President, all the actors in the region, obviously the Lebanese Prime Minister, but also all the leaders in the region, because it is indeed a general conflagration that must be avoided. This requires that Iran renounces threatening Israel directly or indirectly, that it returns to respecting its nuclear obligations, puts an end to its dangerous activities in the Middle East, and furthermore ceases to supply Russia with the weapons it uses against Ukraine. That is what I wanted to remind you of regarding this crisis, which is of utmost importance, far from caricatures or comments, but to also restore the complexity of this situation and to say that one can be alongside Israel, its security, its existence, which is what France is, irrevocably and intangibly, but that does not mean one does not have the right to disagree with the Prime Minister of the Israeli government. It is even sometimes a necessity and it is the responsibility of France.

Beyond this issue, we held last night the first summit between the European Union and the Gulf Cooperation Council. It allowed us to mark our commitment to a future strategic partnership with the Gulf countries, which we must now realize through the negotiation of bilateral strategic partnership agreements and the identification of concrete projects in trade, connectivity, transport, energy, and security. We were also able to have a strategic discussion on the topics I just mentioned.

The European Council today was first able to exchange views with President ZELENSKY, who came to present his victory plan. I had the opportunity to see him on this subject in Paris a few days ago. The Council reiterated its resolute support for Ukraine, first through a new macro-financial aid package from the European Union for Ukraine's current and future military, budgetary, and reconstruction needs. As decided at the G7 summit in June, this loan will amount to 50 billion dollars, distributed equally among G7 members, and will be repaid from the exceptional revenues derived from frozen Russian assets. A substantial portion of the European funds that will be made available to Ukraine will allow for the purchase of military equipment, with a clear preference for purchases from the European defense industry. This is also reflected in the mobilization of the European Union's instruments to support Ukraine militarily. First, the European Peace Facility, which has enabled this year the financing of the purchase of essential military equipment thanks to the mobilization of a significant portion of the exceptional revenues derived from the same frozen Russian assets. Next, the European Union mission has already trained nearly 60,000 Ukrainian soldiers, and we are continuing, as you know, this effort. The European Council has called for strengthening the protection of energy infrastructure, supported efforts to enhance this in Ukraine as winter approaches, and bilaterally, France will finance the reconstruction of critical Ukrainian infrastructure in the coming weeks.

Regarding other international issues, we have been able to express our support for Moldova in this important electoral context, especially as it is affected by hybrid actions carried out by Russia. We have expressed our concerns about the situation in Georgia, as the government's drift effectively leads to an interruption of the accession process, even as the Georgian people will have to express themselves in a few days. We also revisited some major crises: Haiti, Venezuela, or the situation in the Great Lakes region, although the latter did not result in written conclusions.

On immigration, despite a decrease in the overall number of irregular crossings at the external borders of the European Union in 2024, the current migratory pressure requires us to remain united and to provide a coordinated response at the European level. The European Council had a strategic discussion on the various aspects of our action, and the work led to the identification of several measures conducted in a coordinated manner. First, the priority is to implement the asylum and migration pact. This pact, pushed under the French presidency and adopted at the beginning of the year, allows us to maintain the balance between responsibility and solidarity. It has therefore been decided to accelerate its implementation. We must, in parallel, complement this pact to revise the legislative framework on returns. The Commission has been invited to submit a new legislative proposal to facilitate, increase, and accelerate the effective returns of irregular migrants. We have called for intensifying European action on the external dimension of migration by strengthening cooperation with third countries of transit and origin through the conclusion of mutually beneficial partnerships to address the root causes of migration, but also to combat smuggling networks and trafficking and to maintain legal migration pathways, using the European levers available to enable an effective policy both to prevent and to facilitate returns and readmissions by mobilizing our visa, trade preference, or development aid policies. We have called for continued protection of the external borders, particularly in cases of the instrumentalization of migration; I am thinking specifically of the situation currently faced by Poland, but all of this must be done in constant respect for international law.

So, ladies and gentlemen, this is what I wanted to remind you of here. Other topics have been discussed, competitiveness, particularly the DRAGHI report, but we will return to this in more detail in Hungary in a few weeks, and I will have the opportunity to revisit it in that regard. Thank you. I will now answer your questions.

Journalist

You have already largely answered the question I wanted to ask you. However, I wanted to return to what you said regarding the controversies sparked by some of your remarks, for which you pointed fingers at ministers and journalists, and indirectly at AFP, which issued a dispatch. Do you not also bear some responsibility in this situation, with certain remarks that can arise at unexpected moments or in somewhat particular circumstances? And the second question was whether all of this does not considerably weaken France at a time when it wishes to play an active role in the Middle East?

Emmanuel MACRON

First of all, France is playing an active role in the Middle East. Secondly, precisely because the situation is serious and France is playing an active role, I say enough things in front of you and through my mouth, and through the statements that are written, as I said, to not need ventriloquists. Therefore, I think that no, the responsibility lies with those who do not have the ethics to uphold what a Council of Ministers is, meaning that the remarks are reported by a spokesperson and by a statement. They are not distorted, they are not reported out of context, because the subject is complex enough for everything to hold together, and every word is precise. I weigh my words on this subject every time from the beginning. Therefore, I think that from there, I will not start holding press conferences to deny remarks that I would have made and that I did not make. Otherwise, we go crazy. So there you go, we need discipline, ethics, and a sense of responsibility, precisely if we want France to be strong. Otherwise, I will not lament consequences whose causes you have collectively created.

Journalist

I have two questions, the first on migration. At the European level, we do see a willingness among Europeans to tighten the common migration policy, the common rules. I wanted to know what your red lines are, what France's red lines are. On this subject, the day began with a meeting between MELONI and about ten heads of state. Ms. VON DER LEYEN attended this meeting. Is it normal for Ms. VON DER LEYEN to participate in this preparatory meeting? And then I wanted to know, regarding the Polish case you mentioned, if you think specific legislation is needed because I did not quite understand when there are hybrid attacks or not. And then, I would also like to return to the G7 loan. You said: "fair distribution of contributions," but as it stands, that is not the case at all. So does that mean that the European Union will only participate if there is the same contribution from the United States or not?

Emmanuel MACRON

On the last question, the share of the $50 billion, it was indeed $20 billion for Europeans, $20 billion for Americans, and $10 billion for other G7 members. There is a whole debate, as you know, to provide guarantees based on the uncertainties that may exist regarding the reiteration of frozen assets and decisions made. Therefore, Europe has positioned itself to contribute between $20 billion and $35 billion, but the fair share is $20 billion. All of this is then negotiated over time based on the visibility we give ourselves on the mobilization of assets. No, so my wish is that we reach $20 billion; if you want my answer, my wish is that we hold our share, not that we do more. Because we will have given enough visibility, but I think it is important that everyone takes their fair share, especially, I dare to remind you, that the mechanism and its financial conditions were proposed by the Americans themselves within the framework of the G7. There you go. So my wish is that, and that this money can then be mobilized for reconstruction elements, macro-budgetary support, but also military purchases, and that the share of Europeans serves to buy European equipment, because others do that, so we have the right to be, in essence, no less clever than others.

On the question of Poland, I think that there should definitely not be specific legislation. In essence, I would compare the situation in Poland to what several states experienced in the fall of 2021, namely hybrid attacks coming through Belarus, if you remember, which had heavily impacted Poland and several Baltic states. It is exactly the same thing that is happening at the Polish border today, where they are indeed threatened, not threatened, but every day under the pressure of smugglers who, with a lot of violence, a lot of clashes at the border, are bringing in people that the Russians and Belarusians are bringing from the ends of the earth. So, it is clearly a manipulation of the migratory phenomenon to destabilize a country. And so, I think that Europe has shown, through its conclusions of October 2021 and the action we have taken, both the Commission and several countries, that we have been able to face this. Therefore, we need to help Poland cope with this attempt at destabilization. Then, regarding the evolution of our rules, I think that in recent years we have made progress, and I think the most significant advancement is precisely that of the asylum and migration pact, because remember, following the migration crisis, or rather the second migration crisis, if I may say, we were long blocked, and the whole migration and asylum issue was completely stalled in our conclusions.

We decided on a gradual approach, and that is what allowed us to relaunch under the French presidency this asylum and migration pact that was concluded at the beginning of the year. It is a very concrete advancement that has allowed us to tighten European rules while remaining coherent and faithful to our values. We are coordinating better to prevent illegal arrivals. We have much clearer rules at entry, and we have put mechanisms in place and financed systems to better register at entry. We have registration mechanisms that allow for follow-up later when large irregular migrants move from one border to another, and we have return responsibility mechanisms that are much more effective. So all of this is an advancement; that is why we do not say it is a tightening, we are accelerating, because with the pressure being increased, we are accelerating the implementation.

France has worked a lot in connection with our partners on this, and we do it without changing the balances of the asylum and migration pact because it is a balance that preserves the interests of first-entry countries and secondary movement countries. So, if we accelerate simply for secondary movement countries, we destabilize everything and open up other issues. So that is the first point, the acceleration.

Then, the return directive is one of the elements that is currently blocked since 2018 in the terms of negotiations. And so we have given the political impetus to relaunch this discussion so that the Commission, in connection with our competent ministers, can take up this subject and make progress. So all of this is about efficiency in light of what we have been able to do in recent years and which allows us to put an end to many divisions that existed.

On the side of that, there are what we call innovative solutions. And on this subject, the meeting was held this morning. That the President of the Commission was present does not shock me. I think she has defended by construction the treaties, and the treaties are clear. That is to say, we want to better protect our borders. We want to combat irregular immigration, smugglers, and all these clandestine movements, but we want to do so while being faithful to the history, values, and principles of Europeans. It is in our treaties, and by essence, if I may say, the President of the Commission is the guardian of that. So, she was there this morning to explain what we could do while remaining within this framework, and that is a good thing.

Journalist

I would still like to return to the red lines that could be the votes on this immigration issue. The Government, through the voice of Bruno RETAILLEAU, seems to support the idea of return centers outside of Europe. He also believes that the rule of law is not untouchable if we want to tighten the fight against immigration. What is your position? What limits will you set to this tightening, and do you approve of it? Do you see a risk of violating human rights? And more generally, very concretely, on the solution of return hubs, what is your position?

Emmanuel MACRON

I am in favor of deterring and preventing people from arriving on European soil when they are following organized clandestine movements. I am in favor of welcoming women and men who, as fighters for freedom, are entitled to asylum in our country, and I am in favor of being much more effective in return policies to their countries of origin.

Then, the red lines are those that we have in our preamble and in the texts we have internationally contracted. But we can be effective by using much better everything that these great rules allow us to do, which seem to me to fall under a form of common sense. Therefore, that we have discussions to make returns to countries of origin more effective, I am very much in favor of that, but that we have discussions with third countries that would agree to keep people we do not want to accept, whom we have turned away, that the countries of origin do not take back, I am more skeptical. But for me, the rules are clear. They are in our texts, and I have always recalled them.

Journalist

Are you skeptical, or do you think it is a communication from the Minister of the Interior?

Emmanuel MACRON

No, I do not make a qualification. The Minister of the Interior, the Government, is there to solve the problems of the French people. So I do not prosecute anyone. Having a Government and a Minister of the Interior who wants to fight more effectively against clandestine immigration, irregular immigration, and all these movements that exploit misery is a good thing. Then, it is looked at on a case-by-case basis. What the Minister defended in the competent council, justice and home affairs, is exactly the line I just gave you.

Journalist

Is there not an exploitation of misery by using third countries?

Emmanuel MACRON

But that is not what Europe is doing today. That is not what France is doing. The line that has been defended at the Justice and Home Affairs Council is exactly the one I described to you earlier, which is to accelerate the implementation of the asylum and migration pact, to resume discussions on the return directive, and to act as Europeans. And why? Because France is not a first arrival country. That is the key for us. If we act in isolation, and if everyone acts in isolation, we collectively destroy our interests.

That is why I hear a lot of comments about this or that model. The only model that works in the face of irregular immigration and all these clandestine movements is a pragmatic European model, but one that respects these values. It is the asylum and migration pact. It is the return directive. It is the only one that has shown its effectiveness. The other models have not shown their effectiveness. Moreover, I do not see anyone using them. What has blocked Europe is when countries wanted to play solo, when countries said: "We are not playing with others, we do not want to participate in such solidarity. We have our own rules." And there, Europe became divided and it was a disaster. But the minister is following exactly this line in the councils he has participated in so far.

Journalist

I will return to Ukraine. You spoke of a plan, there is money, but everything is blocked because a member state, Hungary under Viktor ORBAN, refuses to give its approval and wants to wait for the election, hoping for the election of Mr. Donald TRUMP. Can we accept behaviors like that in a Union that claims to be in solidarity with Ukraine? And how can we circumvent this? Because today, everything is blocked.

Emmanuel MACRON

No, first of all, today, not everything is blocked since we decided at the beginning of the year at the European level to give new visibility to Ukraine. And then, we have precisely taken the measures, that is the whole subtlety between 20 and 35, to give our partners and ourselves the possibility to act, so it is not blocked. And I note that each time, there have been tough discussions with the Hungarian Prime Minister, but that each time, we found an agreement, including a few months ago. So, I think Europe has shown its credibility over all these years. It has been united to sanction, to support Ukraine, and each time to make decisions. So, we know there are disagreements, but they have always been resolved in the end, so we are not blocked at all. We are moving forward in accordance with the agreements that have been made, and the disbursements will be made in accordance with the agreements that have been made.

Journalist

Can you describe the change in dynamics that has occurred in recent months?

Emmanuel MACRON

On which subject?

Journalist

The dynamics within the Council among the political forces in recent months. What consequences? And what do you say to the criticisms that say that in a context where emergencies are multiplying, Europe entered an electoral sequence in April, the Commission could take office on December 1, and the first text of this Commission in the first quarter of 2025? Do we not have a way to accelerate the schedule?

Emmanuel MACRON

First of all, I think that anything that allows for acceleration, which was also mentioned in the exchange with the President of the Parliament, is a good thing. I think we need to make decisions. The Council is making them at a fast pace, and I hope that the Parliament can also carry out its work as quickly as possible.

Then, you know, the political developments over the past seven and a half years, thank you for reminding me of this reality, you are right, things go back and forth, but I still see a certain consistency. It is that in the end, when I look at what has changed a lot, our Europe is increasingly aware that it has multiple challenges to address at the same time: migration issues, climate and the ensuing climate disruptions, technological revolution and artificial intelligence, and wars, and thus its security. And so, compared to seven and a half years ago, for me, the most fundamental change is that there is a strategic awakening among Europeans and that there is much more alignment on the fact that we need, as Europeans, to act together and to preserve what we have called this strategic autonomy. That was not in the discussions seven and a half years ago.

On immigration, it is a question that has been at the heart of European discussions for ten years, so I cannot tell you that it is a change. And afterwards, we know the solutions that work, we have seen those that did not work. And I think we have put in place common mechanisms that are being deployed, so I see rather a consolidation.

Now, I think the big debate that awaits us, and that is why I also think we need to act, is obviously the two wars, the one in Ukraine and the one in the Middle East, where Europe must be a strategic power for peace, that is to say, one that produces just and lasting peace, not through capitulation or abandonment. That is our entire challenge. It is a huge effort for us, Europeans, because we are the main power affected. And I think the challenge regarding competitiveness is absolutely key. It has been very well articulated by the reports of Mario DRAGHI and Enrico LETTA, to which I subscribe. I expressed myself during the Sorbonne speech a few months ago. And that is a challenge that, I believe, is even stronger than it was seven years ago and which will require us to make much bolder decisions in terms of speed of execution, simplification, and collective budgetary boldness.

Journalist

To return to your opening remarks, do you clearly deny? I specify, you questioned the work of our colleagues. I do want to clarify that the colleagues who released this information corroborated their information, as is always done in journalistic ethics, and that moreover, your teams did not deny these remarks for 48 hours. So that is my first question. Do you deny? Second question on Mercosur, is France finally ready to sign Mercosur, as some actors in France fear?

Emmanuel MACRON

So, on the first point, I will be clear. I cannot be clearer than I have been. If it is not in the statement or the spokesperson's report, it does not exist. Throughout the year, we explain that presidential advisors say this, that the President would have said that, etc. At this rate, every day, I would be making denials or confirmations.

When I have something to say, I issue a press release or hold a press conference. That is the ethics, there is no other. And with me, there will be no rule other than this one. And for seven years, it has been like this. I am not going to start making denials about remarks that have been taken out of context and that were not meant to be made public. And I do not think two different things. What I think, the position of France is what I told you. And where it is serious is to take remarks out of context, to distort them, and then to want there to be a reaction. The work of my teams is not to make denials about remarks I would have made in such or such meeting, because these are remarks that were not meant to be public remarks. Otherwise, I will no longer make public remarks ever. That is the collective ethics, it is the ethics of ministers and it is yours.

So, I am fine with you corroborating, but you do not corroborate the remarks that are before, that are after the precision with which I express myself, as I did today in front of you. Otherwise, we enter a system that is impossible, where I spend my life making denials about what you write. And also look at the practice that has been yours in recent years, which consists of putting remarks in quotation marks after a conditional. If that is journalism, we no longer hold press conferences, we no longer do Q&A, because at that point, it is enough for people to repeat what I think and then you ask if I confirm it or not, between us.

So honestly, that cannot work. I am sufficiently available and I answer enough questions for us to have clear and healthy rules for public debate. And when afterwards, I see people overreacting in all directions about remarks taken out of context, and then even citing words I have never uttered, frankly, it is a pollution and a kind of degradation of public debate. There you go.

But of course, as they have been reported, yes. But the remarks I made are what I stated in my press release of the same day with Prime Minister NETANYAHOU and what I am telling you here. I am not going to start entering a game where I deny and confirm. It does not exist if it is not a remark that I make in such a way that it is written or said in front of you. That is all.

On the second point, France has had a clear position from the beginning. Mercosur, in its current state, is not an acceptable treaty. And we are asking for substantial respect for the Paris agreements, mirror clauses, and the protection of the interests of European industries and farmers because it is a question of fairness in the rules. And in the same way that we supported the Commission when it protected our automotive industry against a distortion of competition for Chinese electric vehicles, we support the fact that for our farmers and our industrialists, we should not have a distortion of competition. We must be under the same rules of the game. Today, that is not the state of the discussion. So I am still in the same position.

Journalist

Tomorrow you will discuss with President BIDEN and Mr. SCHOLZ about the Middle East and Ukraine. President ZELENSKY presented his victory plan to you. Can you tell us what you think in detail, and in particular about their request for an immediate invitation to join NATO?

Emmanuel MACRON

The request is for an invitation to come to the NATO summit, not what is called a full formal membership. Initially, at least, they want to be regular invitees to send that signal. France supports this aspect. The substantial question behind it is that of the nature of security guarantees. So that is what we will have to discuss tomorrow, among other things, also among Europeans, but which we will have to discuss in Berlin with Chancellor SCHOLZ, President BIDEN, and Prime Minister STARMER. I think there are many things in the proposals and requests of President ZELENSKY that are justified and that we remain on the same, I would say the same course, that is to say, we support Ukraine in its effort to resist against the Russian war of aggression, we do not want escalation, but we want it to be as quickly as possible in a situation that allows it to negotiate a just and lasting peace, that is to say, respectful of international law. And in doing so, it is essential that we continue to help Ukrainians concretely and that we look very closely at their requests.

In this regard, France is currently leading, as you know, a first in terms of support, which President ZELENSKY also recalled this morning with satisfaction. It is that we are training and equipping an entire brigade in the east of France. And so, we will have nearly 2,500 Ukrainian soldiers who will return home in early December, trained and equipped, and thus, with all the military equipment and ammunition that will allow them to defend their country. We continue.

Thank you very much, ladies and gentlemen. I wish you a good evening.