PRESS CONFERENCE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC AT THE END OF THE 3rd SUMMIT OF THE EUROPEAN POLITICAL COMMUNITY.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

5 October 2023 · 3rd Summit of the European Political Community · Granada, Spain

Context
Macron addressed a press conference at the 3rd European Political Community Summit in Granada, Spain on October 5, 2023, hosted by Pedro Sánchez.
Main themes
European Political Community summit, cybersecurity and cyber reserve expansion, illegal immigration cooperation, youth initiatives and cultural access, Western Balkans engagement, EU enlargement and resilience, digital technology and artificial intelligence, combating human trafficking, migration policy coordination, collective European resilience
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,616
82nd percentile
Sentences
172
85th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.02
51st percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

172 sentences in 52 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, good evening. Thank you very much for being here.

I wanted to report on the discussions we had today during this third summit of the European Political Community. Almost a year to the day after our first summit in Prague, we have made progress on several issues, and there are certainly no shortages of crises in our Europe. I want to thank the President of the Council, Pedro SANCHEZ, and his teams for their hospitality today in Granada and for the discussions we were able to have.

The first point on which progress has been made on the sidelines and during this summit is the expansion of our European cyber reserve. During the round tables that were organized, the issue of digital technology and artificial intelligence was included. You know that we had several common ambitions on these topics, considering that it was the right scale. Therefore, the cyber reserve of the European Union continues to expand to the countries of the EPC, and it does so for all those who request it. We should achieve the effective establishment of this reserve in the coming months, which will allow us to quickly deploy trusted experts in each country that is a victim of a large-scale cyberattack.

The second pillar of strengthening this collective resilience is also the enhancement of our skills. In the coming weeks, we will sign with the Prime Minister of Montenegro the finalization of the Cyber Capacity Development Center in the Western Balkans, an initiative we launched with Slovenia, in partnership with Montenegro, which will be the host country. This center aims to provide cybersecurity training and combat cybercrime for all the countries of the Western Balkans, as it became clear during the Chisinau summit that the increase in attacks justified such a training effort to strengthen the resilience of the entire region.

Another challenge of the European Political Community is obviously to bring our citizens closer together, particularly our youth. In this regard, several other initiatives have advanced during this summit. First, the expansion of the DiscoverEU program, modeled on the Interrail Pass, allowing 18-year-olds to explore Europe for a few weeks and thus have easier access to exchange and transport. And then access to culture, with the expansion, also to the countries of the EPC, of access to various national museums and cultural access facilities that were so far reserved for strictly European Union member countries.

Beyond that, there are three topics I wanted to address more specifically that led to discussions. The first is that beyond cybersecurity and this policy towards youth, the fight against illegal immigration is a subject we aim to structure at the EPC level. At the initiative of Prime Minister SUNAK, whom I thank, we met with the United Kingdom, Italy, the Netherlands, Albania, the European Commission, and we were able to make progress on common action points that are largely inspired by the work we have developed in recent weeks with the Commission, Italy, and a few other EU countries.

We have therefore agreed on a work plan to harmonize our information and a joint effort of our services to combat traffickers and stop these movements, harmonizing our definitions of these traffickers because there are currently many divergences between the member countries of the EPC, and pooling resources.

Next, a joint effort on policies towards the countries of origin and transit countries that are at the top of the list of migration pressures we are experiencing, and a collaborative effort with the International Organization for Migration and UNHCR to help transit countries reduce the migratory pressure they are under. I could detail here, if you wish, beyond these key elements, what we discussed, but which somehow supports what we concluded on the sidelines of the Med9 summit in Malta with President MELONI and President VON DER LEYEN.

I believe that the EPC is precisely a relevant space to combat immigration. First, because there are several countries of origin among the Western Balkans, and cooperation allows for a significant reduction in illegal immigration. We demonstrated this from a strictly bilateral perspective with Albania five years ago, and the British are currently demonstrating it with the same Albania. So we want to structure it now. Then, and most importantly, because we want to have a much more coordinated approach with the countries of origin and transit countries. This is the condition for being effective because, as we can see, when we have policies that are unsynchronized or divergent, the effectiveness of the policies we can implement on a strictly bilateral level, with certain transit countries, countries on the southern shore of the Mediterranean, or Middle Eastern countries, or with countries of origin, decreases significantly. So, beyond cybersecurity and youth policy, immigration is truly becoming a third pillar of concrete actions that we are deploying within the framework of this European Political Community.

Finally, I wanted to address two crisis topics: Ukraine and Armenia.

Regarding Ukraine, I was able to see President ZELENSKY, and I was able to reaffirm to him very clearly the support of France, but more broadly of the Europeans in the context we know. I believe that for us, the situation should not change, and I was able to reaffirm our long-term support, including the delivery of equipment and weapons in accordance with our commitments in the coming weeks. We were also able to review the evolution of the situation on the ground together. France will continue to stand by Ukraine.

We then held a meeting with President of the Council Charles MICHEL and Chancellor SCHOLZ, along with Prime Minister PACHINIAN, to discuss the situation in Armenia and Nagorno-Karabakh. Together, we had the opportunity to express our unwavering support for the independence, sovereignty, territorial integrity, and inviolability of Armenia's borders. We also expressed our support for deepening relations between the European Union and Armenia through all possible avenues and means and the various aspects we had begun to explore. We also agreed to strengthen humanitarian aid to Armenia, which is currently facing the consequences of the massive displacement of Armenians from Karabakh, and emphasized that these refugees must be free to exercise their right to return to their homes and places of life, without any conditions, under international supervision and in respect of their history, culture, and human rights.

This very clear support from Europeans for Armenia is also the defense of the rights of populations to return to their territory, and it is the dialogue we have constantly had and the demands we have consistently made towards Azerbaijan. We continue to defend the normalization of relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan based on mutual recognition of sovereignty, the inviolability of borders, and the territorial integrity of Armenia. It was indeed during the first summit of the European Political Community that we first obtained a joint recognition of the texts from 1991 and thus the borders of 1991, which Azerbaijan had never officially accepted until then, which also shows the usefulness of these discussions. And we have continued to refer to this text. I could also elaborate on this situation, but I want to reiterate all our support for Armenia. I believe that having Germany and the President of the European Council by our side was a key element in this regard.

That is what I wanted to report. The next summit will be held, as you know, in the United Kingdom, presumably in the spring of next year. We discussed it with Prime Minister Rishi SUNAK, but it is up to him to set the date. But I thank him for his commitment and beyond the discussion we had on immigration, for the organization he will undertake for the next summit. I will now answer your questions.

Journalist

Mr. President, President ALIEV has finally agreed to discuss with the Armenian Prime Minister, but under the mediation of the European Union, which clearly means without France. So, do you have a problem with President ALIEV? And do you consider it acceptable for negotiations to take place without you, when you were at that same table in Chisinau a few months ago? Is France still a mediating country in this crisis?

A small side question as well, is it true that you opposed the presence of President ERDOGAN at these discussions today, which also led to the defection of President ERDOGAN and President ALIEV?

And finally, more broadly, what can the European Union offer to Armenia and what security guarantees do you expect from Baku? I apologize, that’s a lot of questions on a single topic.

Emmanuel MACRON

First, I want to say here that it is President ALIEV and President ERDOGAN who made the decision not to join this summit. I deeply regret this, and as you said, during the two previous summits, we had discussions. France was present at the last summit in Chisinau, Germany was also present alongside us with President ALIEV and Prime Minister PACHINIAN. It is their choice, and we — the Germans, the Europeans, the French — all advocated for Azerbaijan to be present.

We also wanted to have a discussion with Turkey, and France does not have a habit of vetoing the presence of any third country. So, I also regret this decision, which belongs only to those involved. It is up to them to explain the reasons for this choice.

Furthermore, this is not the first time that meetings have taken place in Brussels without France, simply because we have a demanding position and indeed, from the beginning, we have always been very demanding that the rights of minorities in Karabakh be preserved and recognized, and that, as we did in Prague, the borders of 1991 be recognized. Therefore, we may not be seen as accommodating partners. I believe we are just being fair. So, we will continue to be mediators whenever we can; I hope at the next summit of the European Political Community. We will continue to stand by international law, its respect, and thus alongside the Armenian people who are currently under pressure, under occupation of several areas at the border, as the mission sent by the European Union has very well shown, since we have about 150 square kilometers of Armenian territory currently occupied by Azerbaijan. So, we must be demanding. We cannot have two standards.

France's position is clear. It will not change. It is in good faith. I also remember the last two meetings where, on the sidelines of Chisinau and Prague, President ALIEV committed to never using force in Nagorno-Karabakh. So, it is not France that has a problem with Azerbaijan; it is Azerbaijan that has a problem today with the commitments it makes, with respecting its own word, and with respecting international law.

Next, the European Union is present alongside Armenia to uphold international law depending on the evolution of the situation. We will assess what we need to do, but there is a very strong unity with Chancellor SCHOLZ and President MICHEL, which I believe has led to the position you mentioned of President ALIEV.

Journalist

I wanted to know if you perceive among your European partners, particularly in the European Union, a growing concern regarding the American situation and the possibility that American support for Ukraine may weaken? And I also wanted to know if you perceive within your European partners a fatigue regarding the Ukrainian issue?

Emmanuel MACRON

We have not yet had the opportunity to meet as 27, but I think everyone is watching the situation, obviously with a lot of vigilance. I also noted the very clear statements made by President BIDEN and Secretary of State Mr. BLINKEN, who reaffirmed the strong commitment of the United States of America in support of Ukraine. So, I think that both the commitments made before the constraints imposed by Congress on one hand, and then afterwards, are likely to provide visibility. President ZELENSKY indicated to me this morning that he had also received reassurances on this point. So we are vigilant, we remain mobilized.

But this must also strengthen our commitment to Europe, and that is what I have always advocated. Within NATO, even though we are fortunate to have an American partner that is very engaged, we must be in our place, fully committed ourselves, because this concerns our direct neighborhood and a country of our Europe present around the table with us. American aid is wonderful as a complement, but it cannot replace the European mobilization that is ours. In this regard, I have rather sensed among my partners a willingness to continue the effort over time. We will see what Poland chooses to do after its elections. I have noted the recent statements made during the campaigns, and I regret them because they were not quite the positions held by the same individuals a few months ago.

But for all the others, I can tell you, there is a very deep, very strong commitment, because we all know that we are talking about Europe and the very possibility of lasting peace on our continent. Therefore, we do not have the right to be tired. There it is.

Journalist

Hello Mr. President, I would like to return to the third pillar you mentioned in your speech regarding immigration, which apparently is an important issue in your discussions today. So, I have a national question about the European aspect. There is good news at the European level, which is this pact on immigration in recent hours, which is going in the right direction. However, there is still this dissonance, particularly with the statements from Poland, which has vetoed it. So, how can we move forward under these conditions, with some members not going in the same direction? Also, various news articles today report on the journeys of migrants at the Italian border, particularly through the Alpine route and not through the city of Ventimiglia, in very complicated conditions. Some then potentially arrive in Paris. What is your view on these new routes that are being taken much more insistently today?

Emmanuel MACRON

First of all, I welcome the agreement that has been reached at the European level, which is also the result of the discussions we had last week in Malta, and then those we had with the Chancellor over the weekend, which has truly allowed us to consolidate our internal first-line organization, so to speak, that is to say how Europeans are organizing themselves to better register and to better protect both our borders and to register those who arrive on our soil. This is the fruit of the work of the French presidency and what we had advocated at the time. It is being integrated, it is coming, and it has been approved by our ministers, and now it will go to Parliament. I hope we can finalize it as soon as possible. It is a real progress. I thank all those who made concessions to make this happen, and it is very important in light of the second part of your question.

So we must continue to move forward. Next, we focus our efforts on preventing these flows because, fundamentally, when women and men arrive on European soil, it is already very late. And the difficulties we have with countries that have lacked solidarity until now lie in the distribution of the burden. Poland is part of this. And so what we must do is to register much better and be effective upon arrival on European soil. This is what the agreement obtained at the level of the Interior Ministers will allow, which was proposed by France in early 2022. And there is especially upstream how to better protect our borders, better prevent movements towards us, and also avoid tragedies in the Mediterranean Sea, which is all the work we want to do with transit countries and countries of origin. This is the core of what we have launched with President VON DER LEYEN and President MELONI, of what we have started with some of these countries and what we also want to do at the level of the European political community.

Then, unfortunately, these routes that indeed pass through the Hautes-Alpes and Alpes-de-Haute-Provence are known. They have existed for years and there is particular pressure given the movements we experienced a few weeks ago in Italy. First of all, they are organized by traffickers, and so our work with Italy and with other Europeans is to dismantle these smuggling groups that profit from misery, putting these women and men who are in destitution at risk.

Then, the best way to respond to this will be to implement as quickly as possible the agreement that has been obtained at the ministerial level because this agreement, by allowing better registration from the start, enables us to be much more effective both in combating these traffickers and immediately returning, sometimes even to their country of origin, those who use these routes.

In the very short term, we continue to strengthen border control cooperatively with Italy and the Italian services, which I thank for the good joint work, to fight against these traffickers and then, as quickly as possible, to process the cases that arrive to resolve the situations because you have women and men who take all the risks and who will be eligible for asylum and whom we must protect. Then you have women and men who have nothing to do with asylum procedures and whom we must return to their country of origin as quickly as possible. And that is where Europe must gain in efficiency. That is the whole meaning of these texts. I will take one last question before I have to leave.

Journalist

Mr. Jean-Louis BOURLANGES, who is not an opponent, who is the President of the Foreign Affairs Committee in the Assembly, said in the Assembly on Tuesday: enough complacency, enough indifference, enough cowardice. The honor of Europe is engaged in this tragedy in Armenia, and he specifically called for sanctions. Elisabeth BORNE responded to him in the hemicycle; you did not speak on this subject, specifically about sanctions. Do you think there is still a step to be taken in supporting Armenia?

Emmanuel MACRON

Listen, first of all, I think that France is at the forefront of the support we can provide. We denounced from the very beginning. We have committed ourselves, including for the populations of Nagorno-Karabakh, sometimes even beyond what the Armenian authorities themselves could publicly say. And above all, I focus on being useful.

What should we do? We must have a Europe that continues to bring President ALIEV to the table. And that is why I support the mediations in Brussels, and I hope for a next meeting in the United Kingdom. And I myself, by the way, will remind President ALIEV because we must maintain this pressure. The key, the heart of the battle today, is the humanitarian situation of families and the border. And then, it is up to us to continue supporting Armenian leaders to avoid any destabilization, particularly from Russia.

So I think the time is not for sanctions because they would be counterproductive and would not best protect the Armenian territory and its populations. The time is for demands, for clarity, for commitment, including support, by the way, in military forms that France has chosen and assumed, but not for sanctions, because we need to continue discussing with Azerbaijan.

Journalist

You spoke with Mr. RUTTE and Prime Minister SUNAK. What did you discuss in particular, and how does this partnership with the United Kingdom interest you regarding migration? And what is the contribution of Albania? It is a very different country from the other four present at the meeting.

Emmanuel MACRON

I specifically elaborated on this question in my introduction.

First, it is about creating synergies to prevent the organization of smuggling networks and all these trafficking activities. This is exactly what we have done with Albania. We did it already five years ago. This is what the United Kingdom is now trying to do with Albania with quite good results. And we agreed that the European political community is the right format. Because if the European Union, the United Kingdom, and the Western Balkans work together, we can prevent a lot of illegal migration from this region.

Secondly, together, we must address migration from the eastern and western routes and from central Europe, both towards the United Kingdom and towards France. And this is exactly the methodology we proposed to the United Kingdom 18 months ago with the Calais format, when we proposed to have an approach that is not only bilateral between France and the United Kingdom, saying: we need to work with Belgium, the Netherlands, and others precisely to be more effective against traffickers. We will further expand this format, this approach within the EPC, because it really makes sense.

So, we will carry out joint actions on a voluntary basis, that is to say, members of the European Union, the European Commission, plus Albania, the United Kingdom, and all those who wish to join this initiative in order not only to prevent trafficking aimed at our countries but also to work together with countries of origin and transit to combat these migrations. That is to say, we will also work with the southern Mediterranean coast to prevent these flows. There you have it, this is what we are working on, on a five-point document. Our teams will now work together. We will propose to all willing countries to join us. And then, it is about having something more binding that will be discussed at the summit organized by the United Kingdom.

Thank you.