Press conference of the President of the Republic following the European Council.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

27 October 2023 · European Council

Context
Macron addressed journalists at a press conference following the European Council meeting in Brussels on October 27, 2023, summarizing key discussions on crises and EU policy.
Main themes
Ukraine support and military aid, Middle East crisis and Israel-Hamas conflict, Western Balkans stability, Armenia-Azerbaijan tensions, EU economic governance, electricity market reform, multiannual financial framework, COP 28 preparation, European defense industry, hostage release efforts
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,693
90th percentile
Sentences
231
92nd percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
11.7
41st percentile
Syntax
2.97
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

231 sentences in 52 paragraphs

Happy to see you again to report on this council. Several topics have been discussed.

This morning, a Eurozone summit was held, and we were able to discuss the economic situation more broadly; I will be very brief on this point. It is fundamentally about both the evolution of the cyclical situation, the question of our competitiveness, and the implementation of the Versailles agenda, as well as the response to the IRA that were discussed, with an exchange and conclusions that did not lead to many changes.

We were also pleased with the progress on several important issues that we now need to finalize in the European Parliament. I am thinking particularly of the reform of the electricity market. Several other points were raised, particularly regarding the finalization of economic governance and our new rules as quickly as possible.

We also worked on the preparation for COP 28 and discussed last night the multiannual financial framework, providing guidance so that by the end of the year, the Commission and the presidency can come back to us with a new proposal that corresponds to more realism, taking into account the national financial priorities that various members have mentioned. With all these topics being discussed, I could answer the various questions you may have in this regard.

Of course, this council focused much more on the major crises, and it is important to see that today we live in a world, and particularly a neighborhood, where crises are accumulating and multiplying.

We discussed this morning the situation in Ukraine, which allowed us to reaffirm very clearly our unwavering support for its independence, sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the fact that, regardless of the context, our support remains, and our strategy remains obviously the same, after hearing President ZELENSKY speak yesterday. We also committed to ensuring the continuity of our military support to Ukraine over time. This relates to part of what was discussed on the budgetary front, but on this subject, and we can return to it in December, we must above all strengthen the European defense industry to ensure the sustainability of our effort by adapting to the needs of the Ukrainians, while also reinforcing this European industrial strategy that makes sense in the long term. I could also respond to the various points you would like to raise, but our discussion focused on other issues related to the situation in Ukraine. The core of my message is this: "we remain committed, in concerted support and also with the will to provide credible support over time to Ukraine."

We also revisited several regional situations, particularly in the Western Balkans. We indeed reiterated our concern about the situation between Serbia and Kosovo, following a meeting that took place yesterday with Prime Minister KURTI and President VUČIĆ, with Chancellor SCHOLZ, Prime Minister MELONI, President MICHEL, High Representative BORREL, Special Representative LAJČÁK, and myself. On this subject, we reaffirmed and obtained very clear commitments from both parties to implement the Brussels-Ohrid agreements, to implement the agreement on the establishment of an Association of Serbian Municipalities as soon as possible. And we truly want this to become a reality now and for the normalization of relations to continue after having obviously reiterated our condemnation of the attacks of September 24 and called for clear measures and prosecutions from President VUČIĆ.

I was also able this morning to revisit the situation between Armenia and Azerbaijan to reiterate our great vigilance and concern. We wish to continue the mediation work between these two governments and these two countries. But there needs to be a clear and unambiguous message of support for Armenia, particularly regarding its territorial integrity. The latest statements from President ALIYEV, the signals sent, do not go in the right direction. And whether it concerns territorial integrity or a desire to forcefully ensure the continuity of Azerbaijan's territory, we will be vigilant that the borders of 1991, as recognized, reiterated in the Prague declaration that we negotiated, are respected by all parties. I want to reiterate our great vigilance here.

Finally, we returned to the situation in the Middle East. We had a useful debate that allowed us to express our solidarity with Israel, our unanimous condemnation of the terrorist attacks by Hamas, and our determination to act for a just and lasting peace in the Middle East. In this moment of extreme tension, beyond the very clear condemnation of terrorist acts and Hamas, all states also converged to recognize Israel's right to defend itself and to do so within the limits of international humanitarian law.

We are all also extremely involved in the release of our hostages. I had the opportunity yesterday to speak several times myself, from Brussels, with Prime Minister NÉTANYAHOU and the Emir of Qatar to advance on this subject. And so, we remain obviously in constant contact with the negotiators, hoping to obtain the release of all hostages. Similarly, we are all coordinating to allow the evacuation of our nationals and dependents from the Gaza Strip. I had the opportunity to say that France has about 170 French nationals, personnel working in our institutes, and dependents. We wish to evacuate them as soon as possible. This is what we are currently organizing with both the Israeli and Palestinian authorities and Egypt. And this is what several other European countries wish to do in coordination with us.

More broadly, we revisited the most determining elements of the situation. I was able to report on the visit I made, and in my view, our response - this is what builds a bit the peace and security initiative we developed during this trip - rests on three pillars on which, with several member states as well as several non-European ones, we wish to continue to advance.

The first pillar is the fight against terrorism. We cannot say that Israel has the right to defend itself while respecting international law and to say that, in a way, we would only be commenting. We have always taken our responsibilities in the face of terrorist movements in the region, considering them a threat to ourselves, by getting involved in the international coalition against Daesh and being active members of the so-called "Inherent Resolve" operation, which justifies our presence today in Iraq and Jordan. We wish that, more broadly, the region and international partners advance with us on this subject. France is legitimate in doing so. We, who have lost about thirty of our nationals in this terrorist attack launched by Hamas. The aim of this initiative is primarily to tell Israel that it is not alone in fighting Hamas terrorism. Secondly, it is to say that terrorist groups cannot be isolated from one another to have an effective action. It is also to say that the right action against terrorist groups is not a massive operation endangering civilians, but rather targeted operations based on information sharing, operational cooperation among the best armies. This is how we wish to collectively draw conclusions from our experience in the fight against terrorism. And I will have the opportunity in the coming weeks to propose to our partners to meet to structure this initiative, draw all the lessons from our coalition against Daesh, and share an approach with all regional powers that wish to fight against terrorism in the region.

The second aspect is humanitarian aid. It is crucial, indeed, as I just said, that Israel acts in a targeted manner in Gaza, that is to say, by fighting terrorism and without endangering the lives of civilians. In this regard, we advocate for humanitarian access and the protection of the population of Gaza. This is what I was able to discuss with Prime Minister NÉTANYAHOU or President HERZOG, as well as with all the regional leaders I was able to see afterward. And this is what led France to decide, in cooperation with Egypt and Jordan, in agreement with Israel, to send the BPC Tonnerre to the area and to strengthen our intervention capabilities from Egypt for the benefit of the civilian populations of Gaza. The French humanitarian response will therefore be adapted in the coming days to the conditions of the crisis as much as necessary. But already we have sent humanitarian supplies that arrived yesterday on Egyptian soil, and we have also sent this BPC, which will arrive at the end of this week or the beginning of next week, off the coast of Gaza to be able to act. We will also build a humanitarian coalition with several European countries, particularly Cyprus, which will serve as a rear base for this maritime humanitarian corridor - we had a discussion in this sense with the President - with a close link to Greece as well, which is ready to send - as confirmed by the Prime Minister - equipment, and all European partners who wish to get involved in these concrete operations. This response also involves a humanitarian ceasefire that we advocate for and which is essential to protect the most vulnerable populations while finalizing discussions and negotiations on our hostages. We will therefore ensure, as I said, that this humanitarian action is fully coordinated regarding primarily the populations of Gaza, as well as the populations of the West Bank, with an initiative that we wished to take to provide unprecedented economic and social support given the complete blockade of the populations. And I reiterate in this regard the request made to the Israeli authorities to put an end to the violence of certain settlers against civilians.

Finally, the third aspect on which we wish to work together: it is the political perspective. There needs to be a decisive relaunch of negotiations for a two-state solution. We need to demonstrate that it responds to Palestinian aspirations and also strengthens Israel's security. And we need to continue to work with our American partners and all partners in the region in this regard. I note from our discussions in the Council that all European partners share these priorities. There are differences in perception on this issue among us, but we have managed to converge on a common text, above all, we will continue to build very concrete responses around these priorities. And I believe that this initiative for peace and security for all - which we have taken because it clearly combines the fight against terrorism, humanitarian support, and the political question - is a comprehensive response that meets both Israel's legitimate demands, avoids division and escalation, and also allows us to do our duty and follow what I believe should be the collective line. I will not be longer. I will now answer your questions.

Journalist

Hello Mr. President. You have said from the beginning, and you reiterated today, that Israel has the right to defend itself in accordance with international humanitarian law. Simply put, do you believe that the ongoing response, the Israeli strikes in Gaza, and now the first ground incursions into Gaza in recent days, meet these criteria of respect for international humanitarian law? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Today, we have said, we fully recognize this right and the legitimate desire to fight against terrorism. We are ready to provide our assistance. But we believe that the complete blockade, indiscriminate bombing, and even more so, the prospect of a massive ground operation are not likely to adequately protect civilian populations. That is why we really ask that time be taken to properly prepare a targeted initiative against the terrorists, on the one hand, and that we are, these are not just words, we are ready to provide our cooperation, making a clear distinction between terrorist groups, political authorities, and the population. But we believe that a humanitarian ceasefire is today useful to protect the populations on the ground who have suffered bombings. And I have a particular thought, of course, for all civilian populations, regardless of their nationality, but also for the agents of UNRWA, which is the United Nations agency that has lost several dozen agents who are teachers, doctors, personnel who are there to provide support to populations who are dying under the bombs.

We cannot act as if nothing exists. These people have nothing to do with terrorism, nothing! And so, a humanitarian truce would allow us to truly organize the protection of the most vulnerable and to better target useful action against terrorists. And I think this is completely consistent with the position we have held from the beginning.

Journalist

In the statement published last night, the European Union calls for humanitarian pauses, meaning the possibility for Israel to continue its military offensive. You are speaking today, and you even repeated it several times just now, about a humanitarian truce in the singular. Do you therefore regret this position? What is going to change? You say you do not want to comment, but when will this humanitarian corridor be established and how will peace be brought back to the region?

Emmanuel MACRON

First of all, I think we need to be clear-eyed. We are in a situation of war that will last. Because the fight against Hamas will not be quick, and there is, as we can see, a rise in tensions occurring everywhere.

The second thing is that if a war against terrorist groups is to be waged, it is essential that the distinction be made from the very beginning, very clearly, with civilian populations. Otherwise, the risk is one of escalation, of confusion of minds. And paradoxically, I think this is also very counterproductive for the security of Israel itself. If you have millions of people in the region starting to consider that, after all, their brothers and sisters are being killed in the name of the fight against Hamas, they will eventually adhere to that cause. So I think that is where it becomes very dangerous. We really need to succeed in maintaining this line.

I do not want to enter into a debate. We had a very long debate about plural or singular; very sincerely, given the situation, I think we need a humanitarian truce to protect the populations, finish the negotiations on the hostages, and address the problem of hospitals, which is a very complicated issue.

Because, in fact, what is the complexity of the situation? To put it simply, so that it is clear to everyone, beyond the terms, is that Hamas is a terrorist organization that has committed terrible barbarity. But they are organized in the Gaza Strip in a very sophisticated manner. They live in tunnels, but they have created a system of interdependence of their resources with those of the civilian population. And so, when I discuss with the Israeli authorities, when I tell them: "restore electricity for the hospitals," they explain that, in fact, Hamas has tapped into these same hospital systems. So I understand the difficulty posed to the Israeli authorities who have to conduct this intervention. I am very respectful; I do not underestimate them. That is why it takes time; it needs to be prepared. We need to create the conditions either to establish other electrical systems for these 10 hospitals before cutting off their electricity or to evacuate people. That is also why we are doing this humanitarian work with our own equipment and with the United Nations and other states. So, it is very important to be able to have this truce to coordinate things well and to ensure that people do not become completely unjustified victims of this legitimate fight against terrorism. I think that, there, we need a humanitarian truce. Then, as this lasts, we will need to arrange pauses anyway to have humanitarian moments.

Journalist

A question regarding Ukraine, and especially regarding Viktor ORBÁN, who arrived yesterday somewhat boastfully in Brussels saying he was the spirit of Europe, etc. Plus the handshake he had with Vladimir PUTIN last week, his speech on Monday where he compared the European Union, well Brussels, to Soviet Moscow. Have you had the opportunity to speak with him? Or have several of you told him that, well, maybe he should stop? Knowing that we expect things from him on Ukraine, gestures, etc. Have you also had the opportunity to warn, so to speak, his Slovak colleague FICO?

Emmanuel MACRON

Listen, first of all, I think this is at the very heart of the European spirit. A remark on the substance of what you said, and then I will come to these situations. I think that very often, indeed, in the speeches of Viktor ORBÁN or others, the comparison is made between Brussels and Moscow. I have already had the opportunity to tell him, and I repeat it here with great solemnity: there is a fundamental difference, which is that Brussels has not invaded Hungary, nor the European Union. Hungary has sovereignly decided to join our Europe; it has benefited greatly from it and has been benefiting since it joined. And the Hungarian people live much better since they joined our Europe.

But it is a sovereign choice. And if we start to confuse in our minds what is a sovereign choice, which then carries constraints because we all decided on a delegation of sovereignty to our Europe, all - it is easy to say "it is Europe"; we decided it - but if we confuse a sovereign choice with an act of military domination, which they have had to experience, then it is a confusion of minds. And it is serious to make this confusion. So I want to condemn it again here and make it clear.

What I said to Viktor ORBÁN publicly around the table, I can tell you. First, I respect all the heads of state and government around the table, and they have that sovereignty, and therefore we absolutely do not have to prohibit a head of state and government from seeing this or that other leader. That does not shock me. What I ask, out of respect and loyalty, is that we have coordination beforehand and that we have coordination afterwards. And that, especially in the situation we are in regarding Russia, we do not use these bilateral contacts to negotiate things for oneself that would weaken the unity that is ours.

I do not have moral or behavioral lessons to give to a Prime Minister, whoever he may be, and particularly to Prime Minister ORBÁN. So I do not judge what he has done; I think it may perhaps be useful, who knows, even at some point. I just say, it must not weaken us. And I think that since the beginning of the war in Ukraine, our strength has been to have been united and to have been quick and to have maintained a line. And I note that both the Hungarian Prime Minister and the Slovak Prime Minister did not request any modification of our text. They adhered to it. They have different sensitivities, which they express, but which do not tarnish today the continuity of our action. And I think we must respect these sensitivities in order to maintain unity over time. We must listen to their arguments; I consider that all arguments are always legitimate. We remain engaged; we are respectful of these differences, but I think we must be able to move forward.

Journalist

To return to the question of the Middle East, the police prefect of Paris announced that he would ban the demonstration in support of the Palestinian people tomorrow, scheduled in Paris. This is not the case in many other European capitals. Do you think this kind of decision is likely to calm the climate in France, especially since the organizers maintain their call to demonstrate and assure that they will be extremely vigilant about all slogans? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

I trust the competent prefect to make these decisions. I want to say two things: several demonstrations have been authorized when they were in support of the Palestinian cause or for peace, several of them; other demonstrations were banned when there was sometimes ambiguity among the organizers or an intention to convey messages in support of Hamas. These decisions are made on a case-by-case basis and are each time submitted to the judges, I remind you, in the context of interim measures. And so, in this case, I think the decision made by the prefect is made in light of what he has been able to know, knowing that a few days ago, a demonstration for peace and the Palestinian cause was held in Paris and others before that. And the judge will have to say whether he considers this decision to be proportionate or not. I will not comment further.

We are the country in Europe with the largest Jewish community; we are the country in Europe with one of the largest Arab-Muslim communities as well. And so, if we import the conflict and if we allow, in a way, extreme voices with all the shortcuts to carry the public debate, we will divide ourselves unnecessarily. So I am in favor of there being discussions. By the way, you have an eminent role to play in this theme, and I thank you for doing so, to inform, enlighten the debate, and show all its complexity. And we see it in the comments we can make or what we try to build usefully. But I think it is essential for us to preserve our unity.

Journalist

A question on the multiannual financial framework. What do you think of the Commission's proposals? Should there be increases for European officials, while we in France have to make savings? And if the STEP sovereignty fund were to be scrapped, would that be a problem for you?

Emmanuel MACRON

More directly, I think the priorities defined by the European Commission and the Presidency are the right ones. And so, indeed, from immigration to the sovereignty fund to support for Ukraine and a few others, they are useful. The amount proposed seems too high to us, and therefore we have requested a reduction. But I do not think this reduction should come at the expense of sacrificing priorities. I will not enter into an easy debate between European officials and national officials. I think it is clear that to the extent that in our countries we are making savings to maintain our investments and sovereignty and defense or others, we have rather called on the Commission, indeed, not to have increases in that area, in the context.

Journalist

What form would your maritime humanitarian corridor take? Can we imagine, for example, floating hospitals off the coast of Gaza that would take care of humanitarian aid on the shore? And do you think a peace conference, I believe called for by Spain, could take place while military operations continue?

Mr. President, you said that the conflict in the Middle East was set to last. Are you fearing a potential migration crisis that could be triggered by this conflict? Could it be comparable to that of 2015, as the President of the European Parliament said?

And furthermore, Viktor ORBÁN stated that those who support immigration support terrorism. We can guess that you do not think that, of course. But what link do you make between immigration and terrorism? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

So, on the first question and the maritime corridor. Our objective, first, has been to send as quickly as possible by sea and air medicines, support. That is what the BPC Tonnerre will do. Then, we will organize, in connection with, of course, the Israeli authorities, the United Nations, and of course Egypt, the means and ways to have humanitarian support on land, to have it if possible along the coast. And then — Cyprus is indeed our closest territory — to be able to either transport patients or at least make the connection to more quickly convey elements of care, food, or basic necessities. And so all this will be defined over time, but there are already contacts that have been made between us and the Israeli authorities on this point, to allow point-to-point transit and thus mobilize several of our navies to have the most effective system. I think it is very important to be effective, and I really thank the Cypriot President for his responsiveness, goodwill, and commitment on this issue.

On the peace conference, I think in any case that we need to relaunch the peace process and I believe we must do it now. It is very difficult, you are right, because the fight against Hamas is ongoing. Nevertheless, I think it is necessary to clarify that the fight against Hamas is not a fight against the Palestinian Authority or the Palestinian people. It is always the same thing, and that is why the triptych we have defined with the peace and security initiative, in my eyes, makes sense and is complete. We are determined to fight against terrorist groups, but we are committed to providing a response to the political question. And one without the other does not work because otherwise it creates resentment. People, who quite legitimately for a long time say, "you are not providing an answer to our political question," end up finding sympathy, we may regret it, for the most violent actions. So it is good for us and it is good for the security of Israel. Therefore, I think we need to relaunch it now. We need to convince our Israeli partners, we need to engage the international community, but we will put all our strength into it.

Next, on the questions you may have asked. I do indeed think that this conflict is likely to last, in forms that will evolve over time, and I do not want to paint a harsher scenario here. There may be migratory consequences, but it is too early to say. It depends on whether it expands or not. And so the main concern today is humanitarian and security-related. Because if the conflict were to expand, the consequences would be much broader. But it is clear that if the conflict were to expand, it would likely have consequences in terms of migration as well. So that is a point we will need to prepare for, anticipate, and foresee collectively.

Regarding the link between immigration and terrorism, I will refrain from making statements that draw such shortcuts, but we have very close cooperation within Schengen to combat terrorism. There is no existential link, but you have women and men who have terrorist plans or who may be led to commit terrorist acts, who enter through migratory routes. That is true. And so we must neither simplify nor deny, as is often the case on this subject. We must be realistic and pragmatic. We have had terrorist attacks that came from individuals who entered through migratory routes. I remind you that the attack in Nice that we suffered was carried out by a Tunisian who entered through Italy and made his way to France in just a few days. And that is why we want to continue to improve our cooperation to prevent migratory flows, to - and this is at the heart of the provisions we are finalizing and that we launched under the French presidency - improve the control and registration of people arriving on European soil. This is the core of what our interior ministers finalized a few weeks ago, which you may have heard about sometimes in a technical manner. That is exactly it. It is to ensure that when people arrive on our soil, we have an approach that is as professional and comprehensive as possible, allowing us to detect dangerous individuals from others and to have very good internal cooperation and obviously to dismantle networks. So that is my position on this subject. And that is what makes us continue to be very vigilant, very demanding. This is also why, for my part, I wish that our interior ministers could have increased coordination in the fight against terrorism, as it is a subject that requires even stronger European cooperation.

Thank you very much. I will have to leave for Paris. Thank you.