Press conference by Emmanuel Macron – Summary of the G20 meeting

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

8 July 2017 · G20 meeting · Hamburg, Germany

Context
Macron addressed press at the Hamburg G20 summit on July 8, 2017, summarizing outcomes of two days of discussions on terrorism, trade, climate, and globalization.
Main themes
G20 Hamburg summit outcomes, counterterrorism cooperation, financing of terrorism, FATF strengthening, multilateralism, trade regulation, climate discussions, Africa and development, globalization governance, anti-protectionism, divergences among major powers, civil society concerns
Duration
~21 min
69th percentile
Words
2,556
69th percentile
Sentences
67
44th percentile
Readability
35
25th percentile
Grade
17.9
93rd percentile
Syntax
3.38
88th percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
48th percentile

G7 / G20 Summit Communiqués Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 35%34%
  • Economic 26%25%
  • Environmental 15%15%
  • Social 11%10%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Institutional 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

67 sentences in 32 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen.

I wanted to report to you on this G20 that took place yesterday and today in Hamburg.

First, I would like to thank Chancellor Angela MERKEL for her hospitality and the immense work she and her team have done to ensure that this G20 could take place and to prepare for it over several months.

I would also like to acknowledge the law enforcement and civil security forces who secured this G20 and who faced numerous attacks, often violent, coming not from what I would call activists but rather from vandals.

And finally, I also want to commend the city of Hamburg and its mayor, Olaf SCHOLZ, because we are in a city of openness, hospitality, and culture that I have had the opportunity to appreciate on several occasions, I must admit, with a bit less crowd, but which the tensions of recent days should not overshadow.

We had a G20 summit, which was marked by difficult discussions, as we knew it would be, and this was confirmed.

There is an explanation for this: the G20, created ten years ago to respond to the turbulence, economic and financial imbalances of the crisis that was then raging, has become the forum in which we now debate the major issues of globalization, its necessary regulations, namely trade, climate, terrorism, immigration, and at the moment we speak, there are growing divergences between major powers, there are emerging authoritarian powers, and there are divisions, uncertainties, and unpredictabilities within the Western world that did not exist a few years ago.

All of this means that what we had sensed at the G7 has proven to be even tougher at the G20, and in this regard, despite these difficulties, I believe that the communiqué and the nature of the discussions we reached have allowed us to maintain essential balances, joint interest declarations, and to avoid any backward steps. And in this regard, the role that France was able to play over these two days is in line with both the commitments I have made and our role.

We first had a long discussion on the subject of terrorism. On this issue, there are certain convergences, given the nature of the challenge, and thus in terms of terrorism, we were able to advance along the lines of what the joint declaration of Taormina had allowed us to establish, which the European Council a few weeks ago had also helped to advance at the European level. And I consider that the common declaration on terrorism is a good declaration that allows for progress, which marks the commitment of all G20 members in the fight against propaganda on the Internet, which engages in resolute action and particularly calls on operators for greater responsibility and responsiveness in combating terrorist propaganda and also establishes a resolute, organized action in the fight against the financing of terrorism.

In this regard, given what I have just recalled, the G20 is the right forum, and in my eyes, it is one of the main achievements of this G20 for which France has pushed hard and which was a French proposal: to acknowledge the strengthening of the Financial Action Task Force, the FATF, which is a structure too little known but which plays a crucial role in controlling financing to make it a stable, sustainable body with continuity, based on its secretariat. What is today one of the weaknesses of the G20 is not having permanent structures; there will be around the FATF in the fight against the financing of terrorism, and I think this is an important advance because when we look at all the theaters of operations, whether in the Near and Middle East or the Sahel, it is always the trafficking of arms, drugs, and people that feed the financial networks of terrorism and allow for the continuation or development of these activities over time.

So in this regard, I see it as a good advance of this G20.

For the rest, we had discussions on trade, climate, development, and Africa that perfectly illuminate the global debates that are ours today, namely that of a doubt that has settled in the regulation of globalization, a doubt that has settled among some regarding the relevance of multilateralism and a questioning of a model in which we have lived since 1945.

I say this very clearly, I will concede nothing to those who push in this direction, and the sense of my interventions over these two days has been this. Why? Because today more than ever, we need multilateralism, great coordination, and the institutions that were created after the Second World War. Otherwise, we will return, we will return even faster to national egos and great imbalances.

In terms of trade, we need trade that is both free and fair. We all lived for two days in a city that was devastated by vandals, to whom I will concede nothing but who also mark the expression of civil societies that are beginning to doubt our collective ability to regulate globalization; we must hear it.

The response to this is neither protectionism nor dumping, and there are today different temptations that exist around the table that consist of saying on one side, "dumping is a practice that we must allow and which is a new grammar of trade," no; and on the other side, there are statements, positions that consist of saying, because global trade is no longer functioning as it should, "we will close the borders and move towards renewed protectionist practices." Both are bad responses; we need free trade because it allows for better functioning of globalization for citizens, businesses, and consumers. It is what pushes when we are more competitive to win the game, when we are less so to lose, but this international competition must be fair, and it is not when we do not respect the rules of trade and industry. It is dumping, and so I am pleased that last year at the G20 in China, there were strong initial statements made against overcapacities in certain areas, particularly in steel; I hope we continue in this regard. This issue is taken into account, and France will continue to be very vigilant.

The second mistake we often make is in fiscal matters: France will continue to carry out a resolute action in international forums and in Europe to combat fiscal dumping that distorts international trade.

The third is in social matters: we cannot accept that global trade is organized solely towards the lowest social standards because then all countries are losers.

And finally, there is the environmental issue, and I say this to show you how everything is interconnected: international trade works if everyone adheres to the same rules in terms of emissions, in terms of environmental constraints. If we consider that we can optimize our position by not respecting climate rules, then we deteriorate the nature of global trade, and that is what lies behind both free and fair trade, that is to say, trade that is based on rules of reciprocity and regulation. This is what France advocates, this is what our discussions have allowed to clarify, but it is also what has allowed us to note the existing tensions and the risks that exist on international trade.

For my part, I recalled that the approach of looking at international trade only through surpluses or bilateral deficits is a profound error that will fragment our international balances again. Why? Because when I buy an iPhone, certainly in the United States, I am not just increasing my trade deficit with the United States; the United States has purchased a maximum of components from China, from other countries, and so all of this shows that many of our productions today are made globally with a distribution of added value that depends on our comparative advantages and our capacity to produce. So we must not fall into any of the short-term traps that our public opinions or our difficulties can sometimes lead us into.

France has, in any case, defended this path of free and fair trade, and I think that in this regard, the balances of the text allow us to express what we think; but a text does not erase the existing tensions that exist and that will continue to exist on this subject for a long time.

On the subject of climate, we reiterated our commitment as 19 and noted as 20 that there was an American choice not to remain in the Paris Agreement. This is a way to have a declaration at 20, and I commend in this regard Chancellor MERKEL's willingness to avoid having a declaration limited to 19 member states and to be able to write something at 20. Nevertheless, for my part, I continue to believe that it is a mistake made by the United States of America not to remain in the Paris Agreement; I reiterated this, and I hope that, under no circumstances, will this American decision lead to any backward steps for the signatories of the agreement and for the concrete advances we must make.

This was the subject of my bilateral and multilateral discussions on this issue. I noted with satisfaction that President PUTIN had the willingness to confirm his adherence to the Paris Agreement and thus his willingness to act; in all my discussions, I also noted a real willingness to act and achieve concrete results.

This is indeed what allowed during the bilateral exchange I had with President XI a real advance and the willingness to identify common projects that we could inaugurate together, in any case, to push a shared agenda beyond what our two countries are already doing in several areas, particularly civil nuclear. And China reaffirmed its willingness to move forward in terms of environmental transition. This is what I discussed with President PUTIN, and it is also what we will do very concretely with Prime Minister MODI since before the end of the year, I will travel to India for the summit of the International Solar Alliance, which is a realization of the Paris Agreement that will allow us to launch several projects, to gather several countries in support, and to have a real concrete action in this regard.

I was also able to discuss this climate issue with several other counterparts, the World Bank, the United Nations, and I want to announce here that on December 12, two years after the adoption of the Paris Agreement, I will convene a Summit to take new actions for the climate, particularly in terms of financing, and thus France will host a milestone summit, two years after the Paris Agreement, which will particularly allow for mobilizing private and public financing for the financing provided for by the said agreement, but also to identify the projects that can thus be financed and that will demonstrate a concrete advance of what France has allowed to come about, which is an international commitment that today mobilizes 195, perhaps tomorrow 194 states.

I believe that in this regard, it is essential to advance concretely, and this is the very coherence of the G20 that is at work. I tried to explain to some: we cannot claim to fight effectively against terrorism if we do not have a resolute action against climate change, or else we must go explain to the people living in Chad, Niger, and elsewhere that climate is not a problem. Today, terrorism, the great imbalances in our world, what we are experiencing is linked to the climatic imbalance that our international productive model has generated. So we must respond to it because everything is connected, and if we want to address the issues of Africa, development, industry, and climate separately, I think it makes no sense. As this agenda is linked, our responsibility is to coherently uphold all these commitments.

This morning, we had a long exchange on development, particularly the development of Africa, and I want to commend here the concrete advance of this G20, notably the establishment of partnerships with several African countries, clear commitments involving the World Bank, the African Development Bank, and in this regard, the methodology that has been adopted by this G20 is, in my eyes, the right one. Again, if we want a resolute policy in terms of development, it is the indispensable complement to the real policy of combating insecurity that France is conducting, particularly in the Sahel, and these are the two pillars on which we must constantly rely for Africa.

I had the opportunity to remind everyone of this last Sunday when I went to Bamako for a G5 Sahel summit while announcing the Alliance for the Sahel; this is exactly the spirit of what we discussed today, the desire to bring together all funding, to associate with this funding partner countries, international organizations, and to work on concrete projects to avoid wasting time, unnecessary intermediaries, and institutional waste.

What matters in terms of development are the actors on the ground and the projects, and it is in this spirit that I wish to move forward on this subject, and it is in this spirit that we discussed this morning development for Africa.

We also talked about migration, which is a global and sustainable challenge that was the subject of discussions last week in Berlin when we prepared for this Summit, and which we will certainly revisit next Wednesday with some Europeans at the Trieste summit. All these topics, as you can see, are interconnected, and for my part, I do not share any of the schizophrenia that some may sometimes fall into, which consists of thinking that we can address part of these issues without looking at all their components.

Finally, we had a very consensual discussion on the fight against poverty, pandemics, the desire to mobilize more funding for education, particularly in Africa, and to take concrete actions regarding inclusive growth and particularly gender equality. We were able to reaffirm our mutual commitments at the national level and our willingness to move forward on these issues.

Here is a quick overview of the main topics that were covered during this G20. As you have understood, in my view, there have been real advances in the fight against the financing of terrorism, there have been setbacks avoided on many other issues, and there is now a need for awareness to be raised among everyone: our world has never been so fractured; centrifugal forces have never been so strong, and the common goods that belong to us have never been so threatened. What are these common goods? Democracy, the relationship to individual freedoms, gender equality, education, and climate. When we look at the planet today, do we think that these issues are at their optimum compared to what they have been for the past 60 years? No! So we have avoided saying the opposite in speeches, but there is still much to be done for action to match what we owe to those who live on the planet today, but also to those who will live there tomorrow.

For my part, I consider this to be the main challenge of our generation, and as such, it is essential that we can very quickly, in the coming weeks and months, on many of the topics I have mentioned, go further.