Response from the President of the Republic to the members of the Citizens' Convention for Climate

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

29 June 2020 · Response to the members of the Citizens' Convention for Climate

Context
Macron addressed the 150 members of the Citizens' Convention for Climate on June 29, 2020, responding to their proposals for reducing France's greenhouse gas emissions by 2030.
Main themes
Citizens' Convention for Climate, ecological transition, deliberative democracy, greenhouse gas emissions reduction, social justice, carbon tax and yellow vest movement, citizen participation, parliamentary democracy, climate policy, collective intelligence, democratic innovation, professional recognition of civic engagement
Duration
~57 min
95th percentile
Words
6,896
95th percentile
Sentences
271
94th percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
12.7
53rd percentile
Syntax
3.15
67th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
26th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 28%28%
  • Institutional 26%25%
  • Economic 19%19%
  • Social 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

271 sentences in 66 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers, Mr. President of the Economic, Social and Environmental Council. Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians. Ladies and gentlemen, dear friends, dear 150, thank you for being here. On this somewhat special day and in this house that is yours and that of all French women and men. And listening to you for a moment, I must say, it was quite moving to hear both the conviction, the ideas, the proposals you have put forward, but also what you have experienced and the pages you have transmitted - and I will be your ambassador starting this afternoon, I assure you - do not doubtless convey the entirety of the unique human experience you have carried and shared. And our democracy is also that, it is being able to debate among people who have agreements and disagreements on issues as essential for the present and future of our country as for our planet, and knowing how to draw some conclusions, some lines of convergence.

It was in April 2019, at the end of the National Grand Debate that followed the yellow vest movement, that the decision to create this Citizens' Convention was indeed made. With this pressing question throughout the country: how, after the anger sparked by the carbon tax, among others, how to better involve the French in the decisions that concern them and that impact their daily lives? At that time, one could have said: there is a terrible social crisis in the country, it is better to abandon, to let go of this matter and to consider in some way that we cannot reconcile the end of the world and the end of the month. A formula now well-known to which you referred, and let us move forward to manage the country's urgencies. It would have been unjust, including unjust for our fellow citizens who opposed this tax and who never wanted to pit one against the other, and who considered that the ecological transition should be just and that, fundamentally, we had probably gone about it the wrong way, not explained enough, not shared enough, not prepared enough.

A collective had then proposed the principle of an assembly of randomly selected citizens. We talked about it together dear Cyril DION. And many at that time qualified this idea, I must say, as fanciful, even illegitimate, and we, with the Prime Minister, with the Government, decided to take the plunge, to trust the citizens, to assume, to build a deliberative democracy that, of course, does not oppose parliamentary democracy, but complements and enriches it.

And by the way, in listening to your work, in reading your conclusions, I was able to see how much you had measured from where you were the importance of the work done by parliamentarians and the necessity of articulating this work of deliberative democracy where randomly selected citizens who do not have the same legitimacy as elected citizens, but because they reflect, work, acquire knowledge, represent nonetheless something; well how this collective intelligence could marry with the responsibility that belongs to the executive and the legislative power.

Everything in this democratic and human adventure constitutes a world first, both in its ambition and in its scope. There had been comparable experiences on much more limited subjects to try to untangle divergences in a society; never on such a broad subject. And your constant and strong commitment has also been a first. You took time away from your family, friends, including under the exceptional health conditions that our country has experienced, and you reminded us of that for a moment. And the seriousness with which you have worked should now fully allow you to value this experience in your professional life. That is why I also asked the Government that this commitment in the Citizens' Convention could be valued in professional and training pathways; but that all those who will follow you in the experiences we will have to take up again, could benefit from the same validation.

I also want to acknowledge the involvement of the governance committee and I thank Laurence TUBIANA, Thierry PECH, the support group, the legislative committee, the guarantors, the facilitators, all the teams and those who made this convention come alive.

In 9 months, the Citizens' Convention has renewed in an unprecedented way the forms of democracy and shaken up the system. And if this experience is a success, it is above all due to the quality of the work you have produced. You reminded us, it is a difficult question that no country in the world has really resolved at this stage that you were posed: how to reduce our greenhouse gas emissions by at least 40% compared to 1990 by 2030, in a spirit of social justice? You trained, you heard testimonies, you worked, you debated and you responded with depth and intelligence. You responded with a plan touching on many areas: transportation, agriculture, building, the accountability of businesses and consumers. And at the end of these 9 months, this time of a pregnancy that allowed you to achieve this work, you handed over to Minister Elisabeth BORNE what you had managed to do, combining ambition and the search for consensus. And I want to commend in the work you have constantly carried out this ambition because you too understood the state in which our democracies find themselves. Some of you said it, we have been slapped. Some discovered the urgency. But you all weighed in on the fact that we cannot respond to this urgency by dividing, opposing, blaming. That is sometimes the mistake we made, myself first. We can only succeed by bringing all our fellow citizens along and thus finding the paths to a true consensus. That is what you sought among yourselves, and that is now what we must collectively seek within the country so that all your proposals become a reality.

First of all because the urgency is here, you reminded us, even more pressing than at the time we launched your work. The planet could be on a trajectory of more than 7 degrees by 2100, biodiversity continues to degrade, things do not improve spontaneously. For the past 3 years we have begun to deploy an ecological agenda by being the first country in the world to close its coal-fired power plants, by ending hydrocarbon permits, by setting the goal of classifying 30% of our maritime and terrestrial space as protected areas. But what you have demonstrated is that we must go much further, much stronger, that fundamentally even if we already have a record, with history accelerating it is insufficient. The climate challenge requires us to do much more. Essentially, what you are telling us is that the time has come to do, to act. And this time for concrete action is what your work inaugurates.

So when we met in January, I told you that all the proposals that would be finalized and precise would be transmitted without filter either to the Government for what falls under the regulatory domain or for what falls under the law, to Parliament, or directly to the French people. And so our exchange today is not a grand speech on abstract principles, it is the response to which I committed myself and the launch of a new process. And I confirm to you this morning that I will go to the end of this moral contract that binds us by effectively transmitting all of your proposals with the exception of 3 of them - the 3 jokers we discussed in January, out of 149 on which I will indeed return.

I want all your proposals that are ready to be implemented as quickly as possible. Some, the first ones, particularly all those that fall under the regulatory field, will be addressed at a forthcoming ecological defense council - a restricted cabinet meeting dedicated to issues of biodiversity, environment, and climate - by the end of July.

Others will be integrated into the recovery plan which, as I told the French, will be economic, ecological, and social and will be submitted to Parliament by the end of the summer. Already, your contributions and our exchanges have helped to clarify and profoundly influence part of the sectoral plans. I think of what we have decided on autonomy, automobiles, or aeronautics which has already been able to take into account several of the proposals that were yours and I will return to that.

Then a specific bill will be presented at the end of the summer. It will integrate all your measures that fall under the legislative field which will be finalized in the coming weeks; and including those that still need to be refined or completed within the framework of a work to which I want you to be closely associated. The Government and Parliament will work on it and, as I committed myself, I want you to be involved in the follow-up. Starting tomorrow, what I propose is to set up working groups on your proposals that will allow, with parliamentarians and the Government, to fully involve you in the transformations into laws, into concrete rules. And as early as next week, the President of the National Assembly will meet with you for this purpose.

Some of your proposals also depend on local authorities. To increase the number of park-and-ride facilities, to ban polluting vehicles in city centers, to accelerate recycling waste streams, to establish environmental clauses in public contracts, we indeed need to dialogue with mayors and local elected officials. I therefore propose that the Government bring together associations of elected officials to discuss all these proposals, their implementation, and thus be able to integrate the fruits of these exchanges into the necessary legislative modifications that will thus be included in this bill.

Finally, several of your proposals fall under the European level, sometimes international. This is the case with trade policy. You say "no trade agreement with countries that do not respect the Paris Agreement." I share your proposal and that is why on MERCOSUR, I halted the negotiations and the latest reports that have been submitted to us confirm me in this decision.

On CETA, and we discussed this point in January, as you know it is currently being implemented on a transitional basis and after work that has improved its control, verification, and evaluation - which is also the result of a commitment from the Government and our parliamentarians. I respond to you on CETA, let us continue to evaluate. I have no taboos: if the evaluation shows that it is not in line with the trajectory of the Paris Agreement, I will be the first to propose that we abandon it.

Issues such as the establishment of a carbon tax at the borders of the continent or the greening of the common agricultural policy fall under the European level. I share them. France, during the health crisis, obtained that the next budget includes massive investments for the ecological transition. We also carried this recovery plan at the European level, first through a Franco-German agreement and then a proposal from the European Commission. The coming weeks will be decisive for investments to meet its ambitions at the European level, with the appropriate rules. I will be in Brussels on July 17 to continue this fight and you can count on me. The European level is essential if we want a real carbon price, a real border tax, the real investments for our industries and to transform them and our agricultural policy. So that is the method of no filter.

On the follow-up of your proposals to which I committed myself in January, I want the Government to meet with you every month. Deliberative democracy should not stop at the doors of ministries or assemblies - and it is indeed a partnership work that will continue that I propose to you. So that is the method, the calendar, but I want to go further.

You said it very well, what you propose is a coherent project. It is not a series of measures that add up. It is a coherent project for better living, a humanist project to which I adhere. Our society needs a profound transformation that allows us to respect our international commitments and that allows us to do our part, we French, to fight against climate change and to fight for biodiversity. And to remain a great geopolitical nation, to continue to finance our social model which is also very ambitious and requires us to produce to finance it, and that together we manage to live better and improve the quality of life.

That is why there are four principles that I share with you and which are for me the pillars of your project and of what I see as truly the ecological transformation that our country can carry.

The first point is that you have taken on, decided, and I share the view of placing ecology at the heart of the economic model by betting on investment in transport, energy, and the technologies of tomorrow. And when I say this, it is not just a formula; it means that together, we are choosing not to make two other choices. There is a possible choice to continue saying that the heart of our economic model is to produce without caring about ecology. More precisely, ecology is what economists would call a negative externality, and we correct it afterwards. This is no longer possible! We are at the limits of the system.

We must put ecological ambition back at the heart of the productive model, which means seeking through its transformations and investments to produce differently, to evaluate it, to measure it, to transform our capacities. This is the choice behind your proposals, and it represents a profound change in philosophy.

But the second choice you are also turning your back on is what is called the model of degrowth. You are not proposing, and I have heard, as you have, many caricatures of your proposals, you are not proposing to stop producing. And I believe, as you do, that this would not be a response to the challenge we face. You want us to produce to serve this model, a humanistic model. But if we were to collectively say that to succeed in this ecological challenge, we need to work less, produce less, I would have a simple answer for you; I would tell you in good faith: if we produce less, we work less, and we will no longer be able to finance the social model that is ours. The health crisis has shown us this, and the debates we are having in the aftermath of this crisis demonstrate it; we also need to invest public money in our health. We can invest it because we produce. A degrowth model is also a model of degrowth for our social model. And the figures we experienced during this period certainly allowed metropolitan areas to improve air quality, and that is what we need to consolidate by changing modes of transport, which is what you propose.

But an economy almost at a standstill has only reduced emissions by 8%. And so we can see that the choice of degrowth is not a response to the climate challenge either. No, putting ecology back at the heart of the productive model, betting on investment in transport, energy, and the technologies of tomorrow is, for me, the first pillar that reconciles economy and ecology, which you embrace and in which I believe.

Investing, transforming, innovating is what corresponds to our country, to this philosophy of the Enlightenment that has shaped us. It is by being smarter, by knowing how to change behaviors, by investing in the most important areas for our country and our economy that we will be able to meet these challenges.

Investing in clean transport, renovating our buildings, inventing the industries of tomorrow, also investing in areas that you have sometimes not addressed in your work but that we must embrace, such as decarbonized energies, networks, and the preservation of water resources. I think of this subject that we have begun to embrace as part of a major effort with local authorities. We continue to be a country that wastes an enormous amount of water; we will also need to invest in our distribution networks, and that is part of this spirit, this philosophy, of the measures you advocate.

The State will play its part. That is why, from the recovery plan we are preparing, an additional 15 billion euros over two years will be injected into the ecological conversion of our economy.

We will set up a fund for the ecological transformation of our economy in the recovery plan, with, again, an underlying objective that appears throughout your proposals: the fact that this model is consistent with a goal of independence. Putting more ecology into our productive model is also, through our organization, strengthening European and French independence. I will take just one example, that of food sovereignty. If we want to succeed in following your line, we need to strengthen our capacity to produce our own proteins; indeed, as you say, we need to reduce our imports of GMO proteins from the other side of the world and succeed in having a much more independent model in this regard.

The economy at the heart of the productive model and greater independence is at the core of this project. The State has its role to play, and public authorities alongside it. The private sector also has a role to play, and that is why, I say clearly, I disagree — I had said I had a few jokers — with the 4% tax on dividends that you propose.

I am not saying that we should not redirect part of the investments towards greener investments, but imposing a tax on all investments reduces our chances of attracting additional investments. I believe in the growth of our economy; I believe in a model that innovates. Our companies need to innovate. They therefore need to attract capital, both French and foreign, to our soil to innovate and change the model. We are already a country that is heavily taxed. I think that increasing taxation to respond to this challenge is not the right way. However, I am ready to continue to think about a more incentivizing tax system towards what is greener and therefore should be more profitable.

The second principle of this transformation is a principle of social justice. You have returned to this with great conviction; you rightly invoked Condorcet, and I share this philosophy. I say this with even more humility because we did not see it enough at the beginning, and I believe that the path we have collectively taken in our country over the past three years, which you illuminate remarkably, is that ecological transformation is only possible if it is also, at the same time, as the saying goes, a social and solidarity transformation.

Ensuring that this ecological transition leaves no one behind. And on this subject, you have many strong proposals that I wish to see all taken up: proposing food vouchers to allow the most modest to buy quality products from the agriculture you want to transform, from the agroecology whose promotion you want to accelerate, and you are right; proposing enhanced assistance so that the most modest can acquire clean vehicles. You also propose to ban thermal sieves. We all wish for that. And you are reviving a debate that has taken place within the Government with Parliament, which is very complicated and poses all the difficulty of articulating environmental and social issues; and you have indeed experienced this in your debates. We stopped at a position that seems too timid to you because we did not completely ban thermal sieves with a date; it was in my campaign proposals. If the Government, with sector actors and Parliament, has not completely banned it, it is because it saw that if we applied the current means, banning it would, in essence, put households that are sometimes in modest situations in impossible situations and would reduce the housing supply, thus increasing the issue of inadequate housing in our country. There is undoubtedly a path that makes this possible — and that is what we will work on based on your proposals, with you, to finalize it — to invest more to meet this ambition, and therefore, on the one hand, to invest to transform more quickly everything that is in the public housing stock or with landlords by providing financial support, and to invest to support the most modest households so that they do not face a dead end.

We can only win this battle by finding the necessary support, by ensuring financial aid for these households so that no owner and no tenant is in a dead end; ultimately, always ensuring that the transition does not exclude the most modest, does not relegate them, which should be the hallmark of a French-style ecology.

It is also for this reason, I mention a point you did not address, that you did not return to the carbon tax. We had discussed it in January. You sometimes had the feeling that, in essence, it was the hidden plan, saying: "if they want us to legitimize the carbon tax, they have not succeeded in doing so, so they would like 150 citizens to come back and put it on the table." But I have seen your debates on this subject. So on this point, I will speak to you very frankly; I believe that setting a true price for carbon, and you know it, you have said it among yourselves, is one of the most powerful means to achieve our objective. There, we still bear the scars of this debate.

So, in essence, what you have sent as a message is: "we are going to cool the engine a bit on the Franco-French level; do it already on the European level." Yes, and to avoid all biases and all distortions of competition, the priority for me in the coming months is to have a truly European carbon tax, that is to say, to genuinely raise the reference price, to have a floor price, to have a border tax; this is key if we want to not only meet our objectives but, as we must, raise our 2030 objectives and have a credible trajectory. This is the goal for the coming months at the European level; it is essential. And there, I will have a task of persuasion, and I will start it this afternoon.

At the national level, we will need, in the coming years, this is not something we can engage in over the next two years, to reflect on a profound transformation of our taxation to integrate a fair pricing of carbon, but which requires reforming other taxes to simultaneously make this taxation fair. And so that is what we need to do in a calm manner in the country. I believe you are right not to propose a carbon tax starting tomorrow, but I think we should not leave the subject of a profound reform of our taxation so that it is more ecological and fairer still. This is a project that will undoubtedly fuel the debates of 2022.

The third principle of an ecological transformation of our society and our economy is to succeed in the planning of our territory, and this is everywhere, also in your project, fundamentally to build new balances. You have returned to some very concrete proposals, but I think this is a very important element.

First, with this desire to ensure the accessibility of each territory, of each region, but to strengthen wherever possible the transport modes that are most compatible with our environmental ambition. For example, by banning, by eliminating domestic flights when a train journey within reasonable time frames is possible. So yes, this is what we have done with the Government as part of the aeronautical plan. When there is a TGV journey possible in two and a half hours or less, we do not continue domestic lines with planes. However, I have seen that sometimes in the debates it was four hours; I believe we need to be reasonable. We cannot re-enclave territories. When it is more than two and a half hours by train, it is very difficult to completely cut domestic lines because you have some of our fellow citizens who need to travel, who need to work. We must also maintain factories everywhere in the territory, not concentrate them in the best-served metropolitan areas.

So we need to be able to articulate these two objectives: a harmonious planning of our territory and production everywhere, and the reduction, if I may say so, of trajectories by plane that are no longer useful when one can travel by TGV in less than two and a half hours. It is this balance that we will therefore maintain. Never, it seems to me, should the ecological transition be made at the expense of the municipalities and regions that are the most isolated. And that is why, as a second joker, I believe that we should postpone the debate on the 110 kilometers per hour.

So believe me, I make this proposal as a specialist because I have presented many very ambitious plans, with many wonderful things, which have sometimes been summarized to a measure or a small phrase. It would be profoundly unjust for all your work to be reduced to this proposal. I tell you this very sincerely. I understand the objective, but you have debated a lot, and you have reiterated in your remarks: for it to work, we must not stigmatize people. We must not divide them. We must succeed in bringing everyone together. If we do that, I assure you, our fellow citizens who are in the most isolated territories, who sometimes spend 45 minutes to an hour using the main roads to go to work, who need to use them to reconnect with their families, whose lives are organized around these transports, will say: "Okay, their project is a project where there is no place for me; it is an urban project; it does not exist." That is not the response you want to provide. It is not true. It is not a caricature.

I have read your proposals, I have listened to you, I have just heard you, and I think we need to let this debate mature in society, that of speed and others. It is also necessary for people to have multiple options each time. But let us never give the impression to some of our fellow citizens that we are blaming them or sidelining them. Therefore, I propose to postpone this debate. I would not want you to experience the same fate as I did, which is to have months of work tarnished by controversy.

Your proposals to preserve our natural environment and our landscapes are very important to me. There are transportation issues and then there is everything you say about, fundamentally, quality of life, our landscapes, the organization of space; and that is very important because it is our daily life. It is our daily life and many of our fellow citizens, when they went out during the yellow vests movement, also expressed something about the malaise in a France, I do not particularly like the term periphery, but in a France that has often been denatured by large commercial zones, its wastelands, by city centers that have been abandoned by housing and commerce, by landscapes that we have degraded, roundabouts that we have multiplied often to allow for continued concrete expansion. They found a use for it, that of protest, but they expressed something about a poor quality of life in these medium-sized towns where economic activity had sometimes left but where the quality of spatial planning had disintegrated.

And so the halving of urbanizable areas, the sanctuarization of natural agricultural and forest spaces, the development of the city on the city by facilitating the conversion of wastelands, all the measures you advocate in this area resonate with me with a project I believe in very much that we have started for three years, which is also to change the space of our country, its planning, to make it more human, fundamentally more beautiful. And it is consistent with the "Action cœur de ville" project which aims to revive medium-sized towns, village squares by renovating housing, often commerce, but everything you propose improves this quality of life, this beauty. It is a humanist project for both the city and the countryside that aims to put an end to a trend we have seen for 40 years in our country that has disintegrated our common space, the space in which we live less well today.

And this choice of continuous sprawl, of housing that constantly expands, of transportation costs that, as you have very well understood and described, increase. I believe this is a model from which our fellow citizens want to escape. They want to find a city on a human scale where life is better. They want to find forest, agricultural, and natural spaces. They want fewer cars. They no longer want new large commercial areas on the outskirts. They want to find downtown shops and human exchanges as close as possible. They also want, in their daily lives, as you have described, a new project for living together, much more humanist and of quality. It is possible. Your measures contribute to this.

The development of short circuits, the sanctuarization of agricultural land fully contributes to this. You want to go further with strong decisions to put an end to concrete expansion, you are right and I share that. I am all the more ready because we have included in the biodiversity plan the principle of zero net artificialization. And what you propose goes further and stronger. So let’s go for it!

You propose to avoid new constructions that misrepresent nature when rehabilitations are possible, let’s commit! Let’s go for it!

You advocate for a moratorium on new commercial zones on the outskirts of cities, let’s go for it! Let’s go for it, let’s act!

And then, the fourth and final principle, Lambert just spoke about it with great strength a moment ago, is that of individual responsibility. What you have demonstrated through your work, your commitment, your conclusions, is that this change in society, in model, is not just the business of the Government, simply of Parliament, it is not just a matter of texts, it is the commitment of an entire nation in all its components. The State, local authorities, of course, must act with the courage to shake up the system. But alone, they can do nothing, because success depends on changing perspectives, changing the behaviors of each individual. Businesses, by promoting good investments, and citizens. That is why I believe strongly in all the measures, as you have very well said, of training, of incentives that you propose.

With you, I believe in education, in the sustainable development of schools. With you, I believe in the CO2 score that should allow everyone to know if what they eat or buy is good for the climate and thus empower everyone to be an actor in their own life, to make choices in consumption that are consistent with their choices as citizens.

With you, I believe in the social and environmental responsibility of companies. For example, in the annual carbon balance which, tomorrow, could be at the heart of brand image, I believe in a true social and environmental responsibility of our companies, which is a profound lever for transformation on which we must go much further and that is what you propose.

These four principles show how coherent your project is, as you said, and constitutes a whole, should allow us to act concretely to transform our society by bringing everyone together, by involving all our fellow citizens and the active forces of the country. And that is why I still have high expectations of you and your commitment and all of us, it is not over, it is only a step today.

You have finally wished for ecological ambition to be enshrined in the marble of our laws by proposing that three strong legal modifications be submitted to a referendum. And symbols matter, the social Republic, the Republic of territories are now inscribed in our Constitution. It was therefore legitimate to consider inscribing ecology in turn. You thus propose to rewrite the preamble of the Constitution by placing the environment above our values, our other fundamental values.

As I told you in January, from where I stand, I am the guarantor of our institutions and my role is to ensure that nothing could undermine the balance of powers and the values that underpin the Republic.

However, as proposed, the wording for the preamble threatens to place the protection of the environment above public freedoms, even above our democratic rules. And that is why I do not wish to adopt this proposal because I consider it would be contrary to our constitutional text, to the spirit of our values. And by the way, I believe I can say that I understood what you were proposing, it seems to me, you propose a humanist project and everything we are doing for the environment, all these transformations, is not because we place nature above us, but because we consider that defending the rights of nature is one of our duties as human beings in the generic sense of the term. That is why it is essential to place it at the right level, but not to place a right of nature above human rights because I believe that this is not consistent with the project and philosophy of the Enlightenment that underpin our Republic.

On the other hand, you propose the rewriting of Article One of our Constitution and you propose to introduce the notions of biodiversity, environment, and the fight against climate change into our fundamental text. I am in favor of this proposal.

I want us to be able to first engage in the National Assembly and the Senate, based on your proposal, a text aimed at a constitutional reform. I wish to see it come to fruition by the end of 2021 and I am ready to resort to a referendum if it were then constitutionally possible after the vote of the chambers within the strict framework of our Constitution because, as I explained to you in January, I cannot take this proposal and immediately put it to a referendum, that is not in accordance with our constitutional text.

On the question, finally, of creating a crime of ecocide, I think this is an extremely structuring notion for the protection of ecosystems and the defense of ecology and biodiversity for today and tomorrow. I believe I was one of the first leaders to use this term when the Amazon was burning a few months ago. I fully share the ambition you defend, your emotion also in the face of actors who, knowingly and with impunity, deliberately ravage entire ecosystems. The mother of all battles on this point is primarily international. We must ensure that this term is inscribed in international law so that leaders who are tasked by their peoples to protect natural heritage and who deliberately fail to do so are held accountable for their misdeeds before the International Criminal Court. Rest assured, I will therefore carry this fight on behalf of France in multilateral forums and it is consistent with what we have launched for a Global Pact for the Environment, that is to say, creating new rights allowing at the international level, to give citizens, NGOs rights and rights of recourse against those who act in a manner inconsistent with our ambitions.

On the French level, I wish that we could study with you, with the support of justice, how this principle can enter French law, in respect of our fundamental principles. This is not the case with the wording currently proposed, but I wish that we could together give a follow-up to your proposal and inscribe it in our law. Because it is a structuring notion and we also need to evolve and move forward, this is part of the follow-up groups that I wish to set up.

Beyond the three points on which I have clearly expressed my reservations or disagreement, I wish to keep open the possibility of conducting a referendum as early as 2021 and even, by the way, if you have not asked me, but as early as 2021 on the basis of Article 11 of the Constitution on one or more texts of law incorporating your proposals.

Indeed, on all your proposals you wished for them to go through Parliament. I told you that this is what we would do with these working groups and these texts of law. But if things do not progress quickly enough, within the framework of the follow-up I want to involve you in, and if we think it is relevant, I wish to keep open the possibility in 2021 of proceeding with a referendum with several questions and attach the texts so that within the framework of Article 11 of our Constitution we can decide on a referendum.

I have trusted you, you have lived up to that trust. Together we can also, at the moment we choose, on subjects that may block, trust the French people. I believe this very deeply. That is why I want to leave this option open today.

Ladies and gentlemen, there will be, as I told you, a follow-up and for all those who are ready, a commitment that will continue. You have done remarkable work in your diversity, from all ages, from all regions, with so many opinions, as you have very well said, different. I need you first to be your own ambassadors. It is essential that what you have experienced, carried, the coherence of this project you go and explain, disseminate, share with our fellow citizens. I think we need to continue to have, in a way, this strength that is at the heart of our Republic. The Republic was made by the peddlers, you know, who went door to door to speak of the strength of our values. You must be the peddlers of this ecological ambition of our country, that is to say, each and every one of you must continue to go convince, engage our fellow citizens, to say how much the responsibility you have taken is now also theirs.

I need you, beyond this work of persuasion, to be involved and to accept to be further involved in the follow-up work with the administrations and with the parliamentarians so that you are, in a way, your own guarantors of the work you have put on the table, that you are involved at all stages. And in a way, the moral contract made in April 2019 and then again last January with you, reiterated today, I am passing it back to you by giving you a right to alert in this follow-up. If something seems to you not ambitious enough without it being explained, because you have integrated many constraints, you have sometimes revised ambitions that were yours by incorporating the disagreements that were those of others. You will be involved in the follow-up; if there are things that seem incomprehensible to you in the blockages, you will have a right to alert with respect to the Government and to myself, that is to say to express on this point without explanation that the ambition we have carried and the coherence of our project is betrayed. I have told you, there will be this meeting every month. And I have told you, this work is only at a stage and it will continue because I know the Government is committed and the Parliament is committed.

Finally, there will be other Citizen Conventions. During these 9 months, you have shown that it is possible on a difficult, even inflammatory subject, to create consensus, to take courageous measures while seeking concord and calm. This is what our country, our democracy needs, to know how to stay together even when we do not agree, to know how to have ambition while being calm. I therefore wish for other Citizen Conventions to be created on other subjects. A reform of the Economic, Social and Environmental Council will be presented at the next Council of Ministers which will make the CESE the chamber of Citizen Conventions.

There you go, my dear friends, I will not be longer, I wanted once again to say a big thank you. The citizen score I believe of the Convention should be around 98%. We are not doing badly but you will continue to follow it with me. We will continue to deploy together this ecological transformation agenda to live better, this humanist project that you have described.

Thank you immensely for your commitment, the strength that you have brought. But this is just the beginning, the time is for action and we will act together.

Long live the Republic and long live France!