Speech by the President of the Republic, Emmanuel Macron, in English at the NEXUS Institute, The Hague.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

11 April 2023 · Speech at the NEXUS Institute · NEXUS Institute, The Hague, Netherlands

Context
Macron addressed the NEXUS Institute in The Hague on April 11, 2023, delivering a major speech on European sovereignty and strategic autonomy.
Main themes
European sovereignty, strategic autonomy, Russia-Ukraine war, European identity, economic security, competitiveness, European integration, pandemic lessons, energy dependence, political philosophy of sovereignty, Spinoza
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,336
88th percentile
Sentences
232
92nd percentile
Readability
43
43rd percentile
Grade
11.9
44th percentile
Syntax
2.89
33rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
34th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 48%44%
  • Geopolitical 27%25%
  • Social 8%7%
  • Environmental 7%6%
  • Institutional 7%6%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

232 sentences in 36 paragraphs

I wanted to take advantage of this speech and the opportunity you have given me to discuss our Europe and, above all, our European sovereignty. I believe this concept is particularly important in the current context. Indeed, just over a year ago, Russia launched a barbaric war against Ukraine, leading to one of the most dangerous periods for our European Union. The European Union is certainly supposed to emerge stronger from crises. However, we have never faced such a danger: the existence of a war at our borders where the specter of nuclear weapon use looms, an inconceivable event that threatens lasting peace and has revived violence and conflict on the European continent. Since the European summit in March 2022, organized in Versailles by the French Presidency a few weeks after the war began, Europe has continuously asserted its position and reacted quickly and effectively.

The pandemic and the war have both acted as catalysts for European sovereignty. This is what I wanted to emphasize, and I would like to delve deeper into this concept, the meaning it holds today, and the significance it should have in our current context.

The term "European sovereignty" may seem strange. For years, it may have been considered a French utopia, or perhaps a pious wish of Europe. It must be said that after the speech I delivered at La Sorbonne in 2017, there were many skeptical comments: "European sovereignty is just a French idea, it's just words, it will never exist." However, I decided to place this term at the center of my political project, and I have never forgotten that the very concept of sovereignty partly finds its roots in the Netherlands. It is a deeply European notion. Three hundred and fifty years ago, at this very spot, in the city of The Hague, Baruch Spinoza, one of the founders of political modernity, wrote in Article 17, Chapter 2, of his Theological-Political Treatise: "The right is defined by the power of the multitude. This is what is called sovereignty." I assure you, I will not elaborate on Spinoza. I simply wish to highlight the fact that, in Spinoza's thought, sovereignty offers a means to guarantee the essence of being, allowing one to persist in one's being. Thus, to be oneself, one must be sovereign. In other words, and I want to emphasize this point, identity and sovereignty are intrinsically linked. I think it is very important to grasp this connection and to understand that Spinoza makes it one of the founding concepts of political philosophy.

Indeed, if one accepts to lose their sovereignty, which amounts to depending on others, it becomes impossible to make decisions for oneself as well as to preserve and develop one's own identity. In fact, defending one's sovereignty does not imply distancing oneself from allies, but only being able to choose one's partners and shape one's destiny rather than merely being a passive witness to the dramatic evolution of the world. Thus, we must strive to contribute to setting the rules instead of merely enduring them. We can achieve this if we cooperate and maintain our spirit of openness and partnership.

I believe the trigger occurred during the pandemic. We suddenly became aware of our dependence on many devices, medicines, products... Even some allies, who were supposed to cooperate with us, decided to ban exports for months, until they were served and protected. And during the war, those who chose to cooperate, to trade with their neighbors, including non-allied countries (like Russia for energy), believing that trade could represent the best form of possible cooperation, thought they could forge unbreakable ties and escape external aggression. But the Russians decided to weaponize energy, dragging us into a nonsensical situation.

The pandemic and the war made us understand that to preserve European identity, we needed to reduce our level of dependence. Otherwise, it would gradually extend to all areas. This situation is likely due to the fact – and this aligns with what I have heard – that the approach taken by Europe, and particularly by the European Union, has too often been motivated by a client logic, rather than that of a citizen and a producer. And we have not sufficiently reflected on how to ensure our economic security. I do not intend to revert to a form of protectionism; that would make no sense, but to try to conceive with you, in a few minutes, the elements that could constitute this comprehensive doctrine on economic security and guide all our European actions. I wish to find a way to protect ourselves, to preserve our identity, and to allow us to define our current and future models autonomously. In my view, this new doctrine should rest on five pillars.

Competitiveness and European integration

The first is very well known, but I want to emphasize its importance, as it is the foundational element of our European Union: competitiveness and the strengthening of European integration. This first pillar is crucial. Indeed, one cannot want to set an example, promote one's identity, and defend the European model in the long term without being competitive and being able to produce the most effective solutions.

Competitiveness is therefore necessary, just as reforms are, to return to the subject addressed at the beginning of our exchanges today. As an illustration, here is an example. Within a continent, a country cannot renounce being competitive and leave it to others to be so. That would amount to destroying its own economy, but also to hindering the competitiveness of the continent as a whole and, in a way, production: how can one produce planes, cars, and even software or anything else without being competitive? Customers will refuse to buy them at too high a price. Everywhere, purchasing power is the subject of debate. People want to pay a fair price. To buy products at a fair price and to manufacture them in Europe, one must be competitive, which means implementing reforms, ensuring innovation, and having adequate labor laws that protect the population and its rights, but also allow enough flexibility to be competitive in an open market. One must find such a balance. To be honest, France lost that balance five or six years ago. Thanks to the reforms we have implemented, our unemployment rate has decreased by more than two points. We are currently undertaking a pension reform. I am not sure everyone is well aware of this, as this subject is quite complex, but we have special regimes for certain categories. They are not justified and must be abolished, as we are in debt and have a deficit much higher than that of the Netherlands. And I doubt that Dutch taxpayers would accept that we finance a French social model in the long term with European taxpayers' money. So I must act in our country. The retirement age must therefore increase from 62 to 64 years. The French should not be so angry with me, as in your country and in many other European countries, it is well above 64 years. In reality, competitiveness and the corresponding reforms are absolutely necessary if we want to remain a continent of producers and be able to make decisions for ourselves, that is to say, produce for ourselves. At the same time, we must place a central focus on simplifying and streamlining regulations. And we must act more in the field of education, higher education, and training. Indeed, producing in a world of constant innovation requires talents and skills, and involves ensuring that the population – citizens born in the country as well as immigrants – is trained and has the necessary capabilities to adapt to the current environment.

And such a policy is absolutely essential if one wishes to be sovereign and adopt this comprehensive doctrine on economic security. However, at the same time, we need a Europe and strengthened integration. We must go further, much further. We must work towards the integration of our markets. Why? Because it is the best way to bring forth major players. When one creates a business in one of our countries, one must comply with 27 different regulations across many areas. In China or the United States, that is to say, where competition is played out, the internal market is much larger. Our single market is the opportunity, the strength of Europe. We must aim for better integration of this market in areas such as digital and industry, and this through collaboration based on sometimes contentious discussions as well as an evolution of our European regulations made possible by this maieutics that is our own. It is about building a common approach.

This is even more important regarding the financing of our economy, and I wish to emphasize this point. The financing of our economies will become increasingly important, as talents and capital are essential in a world of constant innovation. Today, we are not well prepared. We have very good European regulations and have made significant progress after the financial crisis. However, we are still very fragmented and do not have a true Capital Markets Union, which is essential. Why? Because even though many rich countries hold considerable savings, they are not allocated in the right way. They must be directed towards small and medium-sized enterprises at the forefront of innovation as well as to European countries with low and middle incomes. To be able to properly assess risks, choose suitable investments, and thus benefit from interesting opportunities and returns, a Capital Markets Union is needed. And today, we do not have one. Our savings are in very rich countries, but they do not circulate and are not allocated in the right way, which, it seems to me, weakens our competitiveness and our prospects.

European industrial policy

So here is the first pillar of our economic doctrine: competitiveness and the strengthening of European integration. It is a necessity in our current economy and environment. The second pillar is as follows: an industrial policy. This element has long been taboo in Europe, as the first pillar was self-sufficient. For decades, it has been the alpha and omega of our economic policies. Having an industrial policy was prohibited because it involved interventions in the markets and thus decision-making, interference, biases... But we need it. Why? Because today, our competitors intervene in the markets, that is a fact, because we must act faster and because the lack of balance between the market and public intervention places us in a situation of excessive dependence. For example, without an industrial policy, one cannot develop autonomy, nor even reduce energy-related risks. It is impossible. Without political intervention or, let us say, without the establishment of an industrial policy, one cannot create their own net-zero industry. One cannot create or strengthen their own semiconductor industry. Why? Because other powers intervene and have an industrial policy. And one cannot be the last place in the world without a market governed by an industrial policy. The United States has such a policy and has strengthened it. China has one as well. It is now Europe's turn.

It is not about adopting a self-sufficient operation, but about gaining autonomy or better diversifying dependencies to ensure that we do not find ourselves trapped in an unreasonable, even dangerous, situation. Thus, the establishment of complementary policies seems essential to me in many areas and would facilitate many things. I would also like to highlight the remarkable collective work done this year in the field of energy. Indeed, we have managed to diversify our gas supply, despite our excessive dependence on Russia. We achieved this through our interventions in the market, particularly by finding new gas suppliers. But we now need to develop a new strategy that will allow us to gradually reduce our dependencies and strengthen our sovereignty in energy matters. I believe it is therefore possible to reconcile the climate issue, sovereignty, and industry by creating our own energies, that is to say, by reducing our consumption and increasing energy efficiency and innovation in Europe, by producing more renewable and nuclear energy on European territory. We must continue to work towards the implementation of this industrial strategy. It is indeed necessary to establish European and national subsidies to strengthen and accelerate these policies, but also to define relevant incentive measures, with a long-term perspective that takes into account specificities and prices.

Our industrial policy must integrate the issues of independence, sovereignty, and climate change. It must bring together industrial issues, climate challenges, and the principle of sovereignty. We must also adopt all the necessary technologies to combat climate change. We will be able to face climate change with the help of numerous regulations. Sometimes it is necessary to ask the population to make gradual transformations; your country knows this well. This is our project, and that of all of Europe. We will achieve it by creating a solution on the European continent – a sine qua non condition to reconcile climate and industrial issues, the creation of economic value in Europe, and the financing of our social model. Without production, there is no justice: if you are not the source of wealth production, you have no say in how it is shared. And this represents a great risk: the risk of rushing, in the fight against climate change, to favor solutions that we buy from third parties and that we do not produce ourselves. However, this is where the current challenge lies.

Thus, we need to develop a European policy in favor of a net-zero emissions industry. In this regard, the European Commission published a crucial document a few days ago aimed at promoting this approach. We must accept certain subsidies, certain current regulatory frameworks, while being sure that we can produce and attract a maximum of innovations and new industries that will allow us to achieve carbon neutrality. This is a crucial issue, upon which our sovereignty and decision-making autonomy depend. We could comply with the requirements and achieve carbon neutrality by 2050, but with Chinese or American technologies, which would endanger us and cause great upheaval, accompanied by job losses and the loss of our decision-making autonomy. The same goes for defense: to achieve this common industry, we need to adopt this approach and streamline our organization. From the legislative package on semiconductors, which stimulates research and development and production in this key sector, to the legislation on the net-zero emissions industry, this pillar of European industrial policy is essential.

To be brief, I would simply say that this principle also applies to the other pillars. We must keep this desire for decision-making autonomy in mind: let us remain open to the world, surround ourselves with allies, good friends, partners, but always be able to choose them, and never depend on them 100%. The same goes for agriculture. We have much to do to adapt our agricultural and food model to the challenges of climate change. But if our policy results in increased imports from countries that are less restrictive or demanding than ours, we will have also failed. We must therefore develop an agricultural industrial policy, in order to produce on our territory, according to our regulations, while helping our farmers. That is why we have advocated for the adoption of a "plant protein" plan in Europe to be less dependent on proteins and to produce more on our territory.

Protection of Europe's strategic interests

The protection of our interests constitutes, in my opinion, the third pillar of our strategy, and its defensive aspect. Indeed, we must be willing to protect the interests of our strategic assets when we believe they are threatened by hostile actions or distorting practices. This is a crucial element. For the first time, the European Union has equipped itself, based on security and public order criteria, with a tool to block or prohibit foreign investments or acquisitions in certain strategic companies. This decision marks a true ideological turning point, as not long ago, we were open to the world without any conditions. We now rightly believe that in the case of certain key assets, we must filter foreign investments.

During and after the financial crisis, we took the opposite approach by pushing some member states to sell strategic assets to Chinese interests, such as energy companies or ports, for example. Today, we choose to proceed differently. Thus, regarding essential infrastructures and cybersecurity, we can activate this protection mechanism and implement this preventive device as soon as national and European security is threatened. The same applies to many other issues, whether in defense, technology, etc. This is a crucial point.

And in my opinion, this is precisely how and why we must ensure the monitoring of digital content, in the fields of education and culture. Freedom of expression has absolutely guided our approach. I firmly defend this notion and I am a strong proponent of the freedom of expression-based approach, which is an integral part of the European model. But let us be clear: when one does not benefit from the protection offered by regulation, one exposes oneself to external propaganda, to algorithms defined elsewhere. One also endangers one's children, one's population, and sometimes one's democracy, which can be manipulated to serve the interests of people who make decisions on your behalf. Thus, we have expanded our strategy regarding the protection of our social networks, our artificial intelligences, and all these innovations that expose us to real danger and can harm the education of our children and the functioning of our democracy. We must demonstrate great skill and true coordination, based on a common approach. To this end, we have started by adopting the famous DSA [Digital Services Act]. We have begun to regulate content. However, we know well; to protect our models, including our European model, and to avoid serving only the interests of non-European private or public entities, we must go further. And I believe that this pillar focused on prevention and protection is of great importance.

Reciprocity

Reciprocity, in my opinion, constitutes the fourth pillar of our doctrine. And in the context of a transactional and mutually beneficial approach, this notion would represent a circle of actions, crucial for the European Union. I know that the dimension of reciprocity, which is certainly the most demanding concept at the European Union level, is sometimes difficult to accept. But I also see that mindsets have gradually evolved in this area as well. It took almost 10 years for the European Union to adopt an instrument related to international public procurement to ensure reciprocity within it. Why? Because the European approach always consists of a complex addition of national interests. And sometimes, the offensive interests of some countries diverge from the defensive interests of others. As a result, we wanted to let the situation regulate itself in the markets. But we need reciprocity. And I want to emphasize this point: reciprocity will be particularly important for the new generation of trade agreements. We will debate this issue.

We know that within MERCOSUR and other trade agreements, this concept is well known. It appears everywhere: in our media, in yours, and within our Parliament. I deeply believe in an open system. I think that trade has greatly benefited Europeans and most regions of the world, and that it is one of the best tools to combat poverty. But it must be fair trade, based on the principle of reciprocity. Thus, a free trade agreement must follow a logic that goes beyond purely economic reasoning. Therefore, I would like to emphasize at least three points.

First, sustainability. It is simply impossible to conceive that the European Union's trade policy is not entirely sustainable. We must stop signing and accepting trade agreements with countries that do not respect the Paris Agreement and our commitments to biodiversity. Otherwise, we would impose constraints on ourselves, or at least impose constraints on our producers according to our requirements and commitments, but we would also accept importing products from less demanding countries that do not respect the Paris Agreement and biodiversity agreements. However, there would be a real lack of coherence, as you would be participating in the denial of what you believe in and thus jeopardizing your industry.

Therefore, we must put an end to these practices. In this regard, the free trade agreement between the European Union and New Zealand serves as a reference in this matter and should serve as a model for all future free trade agreements. Not merely as an ancillary element, which would come as the cherry on top, but as an essential clause: the fight against climate change and respect for commitments to biodiversity must thus constitute an essential clause of future free trade agreements.

Second, fairness and balance of concessions to avoid any adverse effect on the economy of the European Union, particularly in the most sensitive sectors. And, third, the clarification of the strategic interests of the agreement for the European Union. How could the agreement offer privileged access to essential raw materials, for example? How would it concretely contribute to diversifying the suppliers of the European Union in key sectors? And so on. But beyond these questions, we must absolutely establish a mechanism and mirror measures to ensure that the same constraints are imposed on producers of the signatory country of the agreement as those we impose on our producers. This is the only way to make these trade agreements sustainable and acceptable for both the population and the industrial sector.

Cooperation

The last elements I wish to raise regarding these principles relate to cooperation. We must highlight and promote our strategy by establishing a series of cooperations aimed at strengthening and extending our multilateral rules and instruments, and thus accomplish more together and carry our European model to the international level.

In this regard, we must first revitalize and expand the multilateral framework. Currently, the World Trade Organization is not functioning, while we need it. That is why we must continuously promote our strategy with the United States and other countries. However, an agreement was reached in June 2022 regarding the fight against illegal fishing. The new Director-General of the World Trade Organization is doing an excellent job. We must help her return to the essential strategy we launched to resolve conflicts and have clear mechanisms in case of conflict. This represents one of the best ways to build a more open and sustainable world.

Next, we must ensure that third countries adhere to a high level of standards in terms of values. To this end, as mentioned earlier, we have a very powerful tool: our single market, or rather its external dimension. In this area as well, the European Union has undergone a very rapid transformation. It is now implementing a set of strategies, beyond the simple framework of its trade strategy. We have begun efforts in this direction. Among other things, the instruments to combat deforestation will help tackle imports of raw materials and processed products whose production contributes, directly or indirectly, to deforestation, for example by imposing conditions for access to the single market. Cooperation around a common goal is a guarantee of effectiveness.

We place great importance on respecting fundamental rights and work to promote them within the framework of the directive on due diligence and forced labor. I am convinced that we should adopt this cooperative approach and work together with all European actors, namely the European Union, its member states, its development agencies, the European Investment Bank, and the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, by combining our efforts and defending our objectives, our interests, and our values with third countries. But cooperation with third countries is equally crucial if we want to gain in effectiveness.

This is the approach we want to promote in the development model that we will present at the summit in June, which will allow all Europeans to work in synergy towards establishing a new standard centered around five pillars: competitiveness and the single market, industrial policy, protection, reciprocity, and cooperation.

We can establish a new economic doctrine that will allow us to reconcile job creation, financing our social model, combating climate change, as well as strengthening our sovereignty and decision-making autonomy. This is a key point in my view, especially in this time of war and the instrumentalization of the economy.

Furthermore, everything related to our economy will gradually become an element of national security. This is a crucial issue if we want to preserve the openness of our system and base our approach on this model of capital markets. The same applies if we want to remain independent, preserve our values, and our European model, which is based on humanism, freedom, and solidarity.

Twenty years ago, right here at Nexus, George Steiner delivered a remarkable speech on European identity. "Cafés make Europe," he said. They range from Pessoa's favorite establishment in Lisbon to the cafés of Odessa, haunted by the gangsters of Isaac Babel. I often quote this phrase from Steiner, and I deeply believe in this Europe of cafés, this great populated continent, from Lisbon to Odessa, of places where people meet, discuss, argue, debate, and also dream. Our Europe is made of dreams, but true dreamers are very pragmatic. Without this quality, they would end up adopting only the dreams of others. I am a dreamer, an idealist, but I do not expect my dreams to exist in the language of all peoples; I wish for our music to be the one played everywhere, I dream of a permanent exchange between the different capitals of our continent, which brings together so many languages and lives to the rhythm of translations. I wish to preserve our model of unity and its complexity, which is expressed through respect and diversity. That is why we need to reset this economic doctrine. That is why, far from being an imprecise concept or an abstract ideal, European sovereignty is an absolute necessity in a dangerous context. A necessity to live, to dream, as Europeans. Thank you.