SPEECH BY THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC ON THE OCCASION OF THE TENTH ANNIVERSARY OF THE OPENING TO THE PUBLIC OF THE MEMORIAL SITE OF THE CAMPS DES MILLES.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

5 December 2022 · Tenth anniversary of the opening to the public of the Memorial Site of the Camps des Milles · Camp des Milles Memorial Site, France

Context
Macron addressed dignitaries at the Camp des Milles memorial site in Aix-en-Provence on December 5, 2022, marking the tenth anniversary of its public opening.
Main themes
Holocaust remembrance and commemoration, Camp des Milles memorial, transmission of memory to future generations, Vichy regime and French collaboration, antisemitism and the Dreyfus affair, deportation and internment of Jews, civic struggle for historical preservation, republican values and their erosion, education against intolerance, role of resistors and witnesses
Duration
~24 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,824
73rd percentile
Sentences
140
78th percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
11.6
39th percentile
Syntax
3.10
61st percentile
Vocabulary
2.63
98th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 42%42%
  • Ceremonial 32%32%
  • Geopolitical 16%16%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

140 sentences in 50 paragraphs

Gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians,

Madam Mayor of Aix-en-Provence,

Mr. Mayor of Marseille,

Madam President of the departmental council,

Ladies and gentlemen elected officials,

Ladies and gentlemen prefects,

Mr. Rector,

Gentlemen General Officers,

Madam Ambassador,

Mr. President of the Consistory,

Mr. President of CRIF,

Mr. President of the Camp des Milles Foundation, dear Alain,

Madam and Mr. KLARSFELD, dear Serge and dear Beate,

Ladies and gentlemen, in your ranks and capacities, dear friends.

"This place now preserved, we know it is in good hands, may it provide young generations with knowledge, with reference points allowing them in turn to combat intolerance."

These words, spoken ten years ago by Sidney CHOURAQUI, one of those who worked for the opening of the memorial site of the Camp des Milles, with confidence. For the camp to become the memorial, it took, as you reminded us Alain, thirty years of struggle inspired by many elders whom we celebrated today: Sidney CHOURAQUI, Louis MONGUILAN, Denise TOROS-MARTER. It took thirty years of perseverance, that of these pioneers, yours, dear Alain CHOURAQUI, who found in Simone VEIL, in Serge KLARSFELD tireless allies. That of former resistors, former deportees, historians, citizens, women and men for whom this space of horror could not disappear, must not disappear.

It took thirty years of perseverance since the first mobilization against the destruction of the mural painting room in 1981. After the laying of a commemorative plaque and the inauguration of a deportees' path in 1985, there were decades of civic struggle, of scientific deepening, nourished, among others, by the work of Serge KLARSFELD on the transfer of Jews from the Marseille region. In 2012, finally, at the end of this long march of consciousness to save the Camp des Milles from oblivion, dare I say sometimes from the refusal to see, the memorial was opened and became this place of commemoration and transmission.

And I want to thank you here for this struggle. Thank your companions on this journey, but also the current and past members of the scientific council, your teams, and all the volunteers who for ten years, as you reminded us, have allowed 800,000 visitors, - but are we simply visitors to this memorial? - 800,000 women and men who came here to confront their conscience and who, by giving of their time, some paid, others volunteers, enabled this memorial to fulfill its mission.

All these transmitters, you and those I have just mentioned, drew their perseverance from a powerful conviction that the Camp des Milles was not an accident of history, but the result of a deliberate slide into crime. That the Camp des Milles came from further back, from the anti-Semitic hatred of the Dreyfus affair and from the slow erosion of the Republican spirit and its brutal collapse. And that only education could break the repetition of the tragedy that took place here between these clay walls, in this dimness, in these wagons conveyed by the assassins.

The history of the Camp des Milles indeed began with the missteps of the last governments of the Republic that chose to intern here, without distinction, the nationals of the countries to which France had just declared war. These leaders failed to uphold the promise of the Republic, even before it experienced its eclipse on our soil.

Thus, from 1939 to May 1940, Germans, Austrians, Czechs, and primarily political opponents to the Nazi government, persecuted artists, dissidents were held at the Camp des Milles. "Somewhere between Kafka and Ubu," commented Max ERNST sarcastically, to name just one. Against all our republican principles, these foreigners were deprived of rights in the limbo of a warring Europe.

The Camp des Milles then bore the imprint of the Vichy regime, born of the debacle and compromise. Clause 19 of the armistice signed by Marshal PÉTAIN provided for the handover of German nationals to the authorities of their country. Thus, in July 1940, 700 internees were delivered to the Reich. At the same time, foreigners from the camps in the Southwest, former members of the International Brigades from Spain or Jews expelled from Germany, were transferred to Milles. They were crammed between ventilation chimneys, in squalor, vermin, and hunger.

Then in the autumn of 1940, Vichy decided to transform Milles into a transit and internment camp for all foreigners awaiting emigration, those it classified as "undesirables." Several thousand detainees, mostly men, of all nationalities, predominantly Jews, attempted to obtain a visa for a host country, through legal or illegal means. Four times out of five in vain.

The Camp des Milles reminds us that there were, on our soil, yes, camps and many others, from Struthof, Beaune-la-Rolande, Noé, Pithiviers, Récébédou, Rivesaltes, Drancy. And that in the free zone, there were these camps. And that in the free zone, deportation was organized. For the Camp des Milles, it was finally the crimes of the French state.

On Monday, August 3, 1942, at nine-thirty, the Camp des Milles was sealed off. Jewish men, from foreign labor groups throughout the region, were taken to the camp. In the evening, women and children from hotels in Marseille were also taken to the former tile factory. On August 10, this terrible day spoken of by Raymond-Raoul LAMBERT, Director General of the General Union of Israelites of France, "black wagons like hearses were waiting on siding tracks," he wrote. Under the arbitrary instructions of the French authorities, about fifty children, barely over two years old, were deported. A first convoy of 262 people was soon followed by another of 538 damned souls who left the camp three days later. More wagons followed in the weeks to come. In total, in August and September 1942, more than 2,000 Jews detained here were deported to Auschwitz, via Drancy or Rivesaltes.

The regime of Marshal PÉTAIN was then administering, in his name, a zone called free. This France was free from the yoke of the Nazis. The latter, among their requests, had not demanded that children be included in these roundups. Pierre LAVAL had, alone, taken the initiative. The Jews deported by the police, obeying his orders, were the victims of a regime forged by anti-Semitism. Yes, these Jews were the deliberate victims of the French state.

At the Camp des Milles, France in the hands of PÉTAIN and LAVAL lost its way again. It erased the principles of 1789. If the Republic was shattered in Bordeaux, in the Compiègne forest, in Montoire, it was at Milles that it experienced, as at Vel d'Hiv, one of its most complete betrayals. Here, it was the betrayal by the Vichy regime of the right of asylum. Refugees became hostages. It was state anti-Semitism, embodied by barbed wire and unjust laws. The hatred for Jews from collaborators did not stop at the nationality of their victims.

Here, every renunciation, every fault, every crime of the French authorities is sedimented. This mention "Legionnaires" traced where those who had chosen to serve France and for which they had sacrificed everything were grouped. The second floor where women and children were crammed onto straw mattresses. The station from which wagons departed towards the Holocaust without return. These reddened walls bear the indelible trace. They carry in the thickness of their clay the drawings of the prisoners. They resonate with the words of Pastor Henri MANEN who describes the shivering children "under the dew of the night." They are split by a single well of light from which the damned drank clarity. They support a window from which women and men preferred to attempt suicide rather than embark towards mass death.

The hell they experienced here was the result of a resolutely fomented, implemented, and executed political project. Yet, it was not impossible to prevent it. For proof, the attempt in May 1940 by Captain GORUCHON to remove the internees of the Camp des Milles from the arrival of the Nazis via a train to Bayonne. For proof, the courage of the Righteous Among the Nations, like the guard Auguste BOYER and his wife Marie-Jeanne, who helped those imprisoned at Milles.

For proof, this protest of the European spirit that found here the strength to endure even in destitution and disgrace. What passed through this camp was what the German civilization then counted as its best, playwrights, politicians, sculptors, illustrators, writers, Nobel laureates. The red walls of Milles are also the canvases of human conscience and bear the remnants of a Berlin cabaret imported here and more than 400 paintings drawn in the light of a candle. Among others, this "Last Supper" that we revisited just now, in a Dada style in the guards' room and a heart that bears these words, which are another motto of the republican spirit: "liberty, life, peace."

For proof, the reaction of all these ordinary French people, who as early as the summer of 1942 condemned what the French state decided to do, took risks, helped, denounced. And through this pressure exerted, gradually bent, step by step, the most absurd and most criminal decisions. There is, at the heart of this period, this chiaroscuro, and these sources of hope where courage awakens, and where also ordinary consciences are there to say that something can happen. And that evil is not installed everywhere.

It is therefore a paradoxical trust that is born here, for anyone who visits the Camp des Milles is seized with horror at the vertigo of the genocide of the Jews. A vertigo even doubled, since the designers of the Memorial wanted it to reflect other imprescriptible crimes: the Armenian genocide and the Rwandan genocide. But who nourishes this paradoxical trust by showing each time that nothing was entirely written.

This memorial of Milles, you reminded us for a moment, unfolds each step of this universal path. The thing is singular, unique, incomparable, but the genocidal mechanisms have controls and it is here that you deploy what starts from the hatred of the other and leads to mass crimes. The Memorial restores a political climate, dismantles the springs of the genocidal enterprise. It explains why the same causes produce the same effects in other places and at other times. Anti-Semitism, racism, all forms of rejection, carry within them the annihilation of all humanity as night carries within it the storm. He who wants to purify in the name of his ethnicity, his nation, his religion, begins with outrages, continues with incarcerations, ends with murders.

At all times, this escalation of hatred in the Camp des Milles was an example yesterday and remains a witness today. And there, this past allows us to illuminate our future because it is up to us to resist those who falsify history, pretend to adopt the Republic while betraying its values.

Here at Milles, France was as it must never be again and if we are here, 80 years after the deportation of the Jews from the Camp des Milles, it is to say that our Nation must be the path of humanism, of the rule of law, of the refusal of hatred. The regime of collaboration continues to recruit worshippers and they still have heirs. Let us open our eyes to the rise of xenophobia and anti-Semitism, let us listen to the resurgences of racism. Let us never be duped by the new clothes that the same ideologies of division adopt to deceive us. And let us repeat forcefully against silence, omissions, or compromises, that the victims were Jews, that their only crime was being Jewish, that their murder had no other motive than the hatred of Jews.

Those who founded the memorial wanted to enlighten us and pass the baton. There are still witnesses today but there is this work of memory and this courage that ensue from it that you have just spoken of. The countries that call us, and I thank the Minister of the Interior and the Minister of Education for being by my side in this regard, to fight relentlessly against all those who, today, disrespecting the law of the Republic, continue anti-Semitic, racist, or anti-religious violence and to forge consciences and teach and know how to thwart these paths of habit that are so well nourished by those of ignorance.

This struggle is that of the Republic and what this memorial teaches us is that this Republic is a daily struggle. Nothing is ever acquired, nothing! And that by knowing how to look squarely at the mechanisms that led us, a few decades after having revived this same Republic on our soil, to commit the worst here. It is also to tell us that we must continue here and elsewhere to build the future. It is also for this reason, uncompromising and clear-sighted, that we will be by your side in this project of a house for children and books, the prefiguration of which is almost suggested here by the exhibition prepared by Serge and Beate KLARSFELD.

Uncompromising and clear-sighted, that is how you appear through your struggles and your work, dear Alain CHOURAQUI.

Born in 1949, you are marked, and how could you not be, by this glorious father, Sidney CHOURAQUI, great resister, soldier of Free France, indomitable lawyer who was also your mentor, who instilled in you the conviction that humanity gives birth to both the best and the worst. Honor and horror, he who had been so close to both.

After a Moroccan childhood, you, who already had history as an inheritance, chose to specialize as a jurist and sociologist. And your brilliant academic career as a research director at the CNRS immediately intertwined with this quest to preserve the Camp des Milles, whose long history I have just briefly recounted here and which owes you so much.

You have been a teacher-researcher and, fundamentally, a fighter and activist, a complete intellectual who continues to write and will not cease this struggle. But thanks to you, the memorial forcefully inscribes in our history these anti-Semitic deportations carried out on its own initiative by the French state. You have given it international prominence through this multidisciplinary analysis of the racialist machinery that inexorably leads to mass crimes. Like a theorem whose formula you have highlighted, readable elsewhere, in Armenia or Rwanda.

Since 2015, you have held the chair "Education for Citizenship, Human Sciences, and Convergence of Memories" at UNESCO, inaugurated right here by my predecessor. And the rigor of your work has allowed for the gathering of a network of universities and memorial institutions, from the Auschwitz-Birkenau National Museum to the Kigali Memorial Centre, thus working towards reconciliation of all memories and this duty of contemporary courage and future.

The memorial enlightens the minds of thousands of students, from disadvantaged neighborhoods and beyond, from EPIDE, social centers, and inmates. Participatory workshops make unfamiliar or misunderstood words sensitive and intelligible. And almost every time, those who see and hear end up understanding, regardless of the prejudices with which they arrived, regardless of the unthoughts that preceded, forever illuminated by the springs of an evil revealed down to its roots.

The memorial also trains high magistrates, police officers, athletes, teachers, because you are convinced that it is by strengthening the entire social body that hatred will find ramparts against its course within us, among us.

Your work, To Resist the Machinery of Extremisms, Racisms, and Anti-Semitism, was awarded the Seligmann Prize against Racism, Intolerance, and Injustice, and was presented to you at the Sorbonne. To resist this machinery, we must again and again recall a past that some, here and now, falsify to absolve themselves of their designs. We must reject the revisionism of some, the euphemism of others, the forgetfulness that sometimes seeks to insinuate itself within us.

To resist this machinery, we must train citizens who invent their lives through knowledge, teaching, and memory. And in our time where brutality, violence, and hatred never disarm, we need those who are committed to push them back into minds, with the instruments of reason and transmission.

Dear Alain CHOURAQUI, you are one of those. A sentinel, a fighter. And at a time when these words of democracy, of the Republic, of human rights and of the citizen are contested by some and of which others forget, in a way, the struggles they presuppose and the consciousness they demand. You have offered them a place where they were annihilated, but from which they propagate anew. This memorial was your quest. Then, your thesis, so to speak, materialized. It is now your manifesto, here, and in the spirit of all those you have irreparably enlightened.

So, for this long-term and far-reaching work, for this memorial of the Milles which is a place of memory for the Nation, of vigilance for the world, and of building our future, I have today the joy and honor of presenting you with the insignia of Chevalier of the Légion d'honneur.

Mr. Alain CHOURAQUI, on behalf of the French Republic, we make you Chevalier of the Légion d'honneur.