Speech delivered at the Provincial Plenary of the CTC, held at the CTC Theater, on the

Cuba Fidel Castro · President of Cuba

3 September 1970 · Provincial Plenary of the CTC · CTC Theater

Context
Castro addressed the Provincial Plenary of the CTC in Havana on September 3, 1970, closing a session focused on combating worker absenteeism and improving labor productivity.
Main themes
Labor absenteeism, worker mobilization, union leadership challenges, voluntary work, production difficulties, workplace conditions, worker discipline, battle against obstacles, subjective and objective problems, party cadre role
Duration
~96 min
98th percentile
Words
11,501
98th percentile
Sentences
588
99th percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
10.0
20th percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 35%32%
  • Economic 30%27%
  • Social 27%25%
  • Ceremonial 6%5%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

588 sentences in 161 paragraphs

Well, comrades, if you agree, I will say a few words to say goodbye.

Comrade Risquet has drawn his conclusions brilliantly and has presented the essence of this plenary session and the purposes we pursue in this plenary.

For my part, I have been presenting some ideas, some thoughts throughout the discussions.

As I mentioned a moment ago, with this plenary session, we begin to wage a battle. We not only have to wage a battle to move forward, but at least a dozen battles, and perhaps more will arise along the way. One of the first and immediate battles is this battle against absenteeism; also a battle to avoid misinterpretations of what was raised about voluntary work, both in my appearance and in Comrade Risquet's.

It is undeniable that in the face of a situation that we expressed very clearly regarding the difficulties we had, the appropriate reaction had not yet occurred. Because if, in the face of a crisis situation on a battlefield, people do not react by attacking, counterattacking, or fighting better, the battle is lost.

Of course, all this happened in the midst of a process that was the holidays, after a very long period of work. The month of July, the carnivals, the festivities, all those things. So it actually makes some sense, right?, that during the month of August this type of problem would arise. Furthermore, in the same statements, it was said: "No, now we will have the workers' holidays and then we must start working hard." But it can be said that there was no adequate reaction to the difficulties and obstacles that we have ahead. That is undeniable.

Is it true that in these days, due to all that mix of circumstances and not having a sufficiently alert awareness of how we should solve these problems, absenteeism increased? It is true. Was it also true that, even without this plenary session, absenteeism would naturally decrease in September? That was to be expected. When all the workers who were on vacation returned; in short, when many from the "Lenin" column at the workplace were there, and when people finally got tired of abusing absenteeism — one can say. So in September, it was to be expected.

But that is not enough. Even winning the battle against absenteeism is not enough. It is only part of the problem. Although we do believe it is of utmost importance, because it relates to how workers must react to difficulties.

Now, we have countless problems. Of the problems we have... That is, we have objective problems — as we explained in the Federation of Women — of all kinds. But these problems are aggravated to the extent that we do not know how to put what the man has to put in that situation. Now, we have many problems that are also subjective. And it affects production, it even affects the worker's attitude towards work, countless issues, some of which have been pointed out here.

While it is true that only part of the problems was mentioned here, while it is true that dozens and perhaps hundreds of comrades would have many things to contribute regarding the different types of difficulties in their workplace and elsewhere, despite that, enough has been said, and a series of issues have been presented that reveal the magnitude of the struggle we must wage to overcome all those difficulties.

It is undeniable that the objective conditions in which the work of the union leader, of the political party cadre, must unfold are difficult. If you have an administrator who is indifferent, if you have an individual who is incapable, if you find that you have a series of real difficulties — let’s say, the ones we saw, for example, today, when we visited the factory of the comrade who mentioned yesterday that the roof was falling and it got wet when it rained.

We set out to visit some of the places pointed out in yesterday's meeting today. Because she said that several times they had gone there to take measurements, but nothing was resolved and that they had been in that situation for four or five years. I invited Comrade Almeida and we went there to seek an immediate solution to the problem. And it happened to be raining when we were going to the factory, and while we were there, the rain intensified a bit. In reality, anyone could have thought that anything said about what is seen there when a downpour occurs was exaggerated. It is a tremendous amount of water that seeps in there! So, we understand how difficult the battle of the union leader is, the battle of the party cadre, in that center where these things have been happening for five years. In a center with so many workers, that center does not even have a workers' cafeteria; or it has a workers' cafeteria, but where the food is so bad that the comrades do not eat. A cafeteria there quite poorly stocked.

So, there the paper that is truly wet, already done. The work done, printed, you see that it gets wet. What costs foreign currency is lost. The machines are at risk there due to the humidity conditions. Accidents can occur, fires due to short circuits in the electrical board, all those things. So, what happens? This has been happening for five years. And one asks: Can one talk, for example, about the struggle for savings, the struggle for foreign currency, the struggle for development, the struggle for the economy, and in front of a mass of 400 workers see that spectacle of water falling, see that spectacle of raw materials being lost?

It is indisputable that this makes the work of the Party and the unions very difficult.

Of course, the opposite of this would be for everything to run perfectly. And really, we would be idealists if we were to pretend that everything would run perfectly. It was very difficult. In reality, the change that has occurred in the life of the country is so great that we, in a certain sense, are receiving the positive fruits of the Revolution, but we are also perceiving the negative fruits of the Revolution.

Because the Revolution first creates a tremendous disorder in the entire life of a country, a tremendous change in the mode of production. We really go from a virtually slave mode of production to a free mode of production. That is the essence of the problem. It was not about a man with shackles and chains on his feet, but about a more subtle yet no less efficient slavery, the man deprived of all personal or social wealth forced by vital reasons to work, or he would die of hunger, or his child would die, his family would die. He was under the penalty of death forced to punctual and disciplined work. The unemployment of half a million: men fought for a position in a factory, men congratulated each other when someone got a job in a factory like the rayon factory in Matanzas, where they were practically going to poison themselves.

Today, what has happened? The conditions created by the Revolution swept away those ominous circumstances. Work today is voluntary, one can say, no longer at the level of going to work on Sunday in agriculture. Work has practically become voluntary for any citizen of the country under current conditions.

This is determined, first of all, by many vital problems solved. The issues to which the baker referred: housing resolved for many, medicine, education, social security, the possibilities of life assured for all. There are no beggars, prostitutes, helpless elderly, orphaned or abandoned children in any corner of the country. The current generation of young people has not even known the scourge of unemployment. On the other hand, the existence of a quantity of money that is above the available goods makes it so that even money — which is the means by which work is compensated to then acquire certain goods — has a relative value. One can buy limitedly, up to certain limits, the goods and services that we have available.

It is undeniable that if we had much more merchandise and material services available, that factor would not be affecting a situation in which even a large number of families have excess money. Although not all, because there are still cases of workers who barely have enough salary to cover their family expenses.

But it is unquestionable that the circumstances in which a man today is forced to work, or is led to work, are fundamentally factors of a moral order, factors of consciousness, healthy habits, a sense of the social and human importance of his activity.

So, under those conditions, there has been a total change in working conditions. That is to say, some people without moral consciousness or sense of their social duty can take the liberty today to despise work, not work, shift the productive effort onto others, deceive, do all those things.

A tremendous change has occurred, then, I repeat, in the mode and the relationships of production and distribution of social wealth. Furthermore — as I told you yesterday — by becoming collective property all means of production, the use of these and human resources in the production and distribution of goods and services creates a problem of administration on a gigantic scale. I said that even human brains cannot keep track of many things. The stock of goods today cannot be managed by any human brain, no group of accountants. Just as today one cannot make a trip to the moon without computers, because the amount of calculations required and the speed with which complicated problems must be solved would make the task impossible for the human brain. Nor can the economy, inventories, what is lacking, what is available, what is needed on the enormous scale imposed by the socialist economy be controlled without computers, without calculation centers. Even the imperialists, the developed capitalists, had to develop computers, without which they could not manage their businesses. General Motors today would not function without computers. Moreover: that giant Yankee plane, of which one recently landed, which has millions of pieces in its construction, pieces that must arrive in simultaneous flow to the workshop through various routes, where the effort of thousands of engineers and technicians who participate in the production and assembly of its components for the mass production of those planes is channeled, would be impossible without computers.

Compared to that, all our work is artisanal. We have an enormous scale because the problems are the problems of millions, the goods must also be counted for millions, and yet our methods are still artisanal, the methods of administration, the methods of direction.

Administration, on a large scale, is already a science. And we really lack that type of scientists. Therefore, the amount of confusions, errors, and messes of that type is almost explainable. But there are also ideological problems, political problems; there is the petty-bourgeois spirit still very much embedded in public administration; there is the problem that sometimes some public officials do not resemble the rest of the workers at all. It is true that there are many administrators who come from a working-class background, who have the habits and spirit of proletarians; others, on the other hand, are like paratroopers who descend from the sky with undeniable insensitivity and indifference and without the slightest proletarian spirit.

It is undeniable that this anti-worker spirit, a bit of contempt for workers, exists in some administrators. And some of those things were manifested here.

There is also the fact that we explained yesterday, that the administrative method does not resolve and cannot resolve the problem in a revolutionary process. That is a very clear thing.

Because even the most efficient administration cannot generate the control, vigilance, efficiency, combativeness, and energy of the masses that the difficulties to be overcome require.

So we have to wage a battle in every workplace, in every service, in every fundamental aspect of our political, economic, and social life, solidly supporting ourselves on the masses. A true battle of which this meeting is nothing more than a first step. What we have dealt with regarding absenteeism is nothing more than a first step. The thing against which we must react most vigorously at this moment is against absenteeism. But we have all the other things left, such as maximum efficiency in organization, optimal use of material and human resources, the great battle for labor productivity, which in the coming months and years we must wage, without which our problems would have no possible solution.

The work we are doing we have been carrying out, not limiting ourselves to simple public pronouncements, but analyzing, meeting, studying all the problems, all the causes, working, deepening, acting. Because we not only have to invest time in discussing, in analyzing. We must also take a series of concrete measures everywhere. We are trying to promote them in agriculture, in industry, in the provinces, everywhere.

That is to say, we are currently under tremendous pressure to analyze and reflect on the measures that need to be taken for the development of the Revolution in this phase and in the coming years, in addition to the concrete work that must be carried out immediately.

These ideas summarize our main difficulties today. And as the inhumane factors that previously forced work disappear, the alternative to this is the maximum development of collective consciousness and the use of the coercive force of the working society against those who aspire to live parasitically off the efforts of others, evading the fulfillment of their most basic social and human duties.

The law that the workers are requesting against vagrancy, which was mentioned by comrade Risquet, is not a simple task. The preamble and the provisions of the project will need to be modified in some aspects and additional elements added that are in tune with the current situation, with new experiences and criteria.

Perhaps it would be better if, even before drafting a bill, a series of opinions were gathered, a kind of consultation, a survey with the workers so that they could provide a whole range of criteria. In this way, even knowing all those criteria, the bill could be drafted capturing the essence of them. And then, finally, submit it for the consideration of the workers.

We must take into account the international political aspect, lest the bad attitude of a minority, of 5%, 10% of the people, lead to judgments about the Cuban working class.

I believe that the best thing about the law will be that it arises from the workers. I believe there should be wide dissemination through television, through radio, of all their criteria. I believe we should encourage workers to speak on television, radio, and in newspapers about these problems, expressing their views on what should be done with the lazy and the absentee workers. So that it is clearly seen that this is a popular law and not an administrative one, so that it is evident that this is a law that comes from the will of the working people of Cuba. This is very important for international purposes. Because surely the enemy will start to launch slogans: “Look, in capitalism there are no laws against vagrancy...” Of course, capitalism is inhumane, with its blind, criminal, and ruthless mechanisms forcing people to work and also forcing many to wait years to occupy a modest job. In capitalism, millions of people are deliberately kept in ignorance to have those with whom to carry out the most brutal tasks and an army of unemployed as a reserve of labor.

In a rational and just society, the majority, looking out for its interests, has the right and the duty to adopt coercive measures against the small minority that refuses to fulfill its social duties, once the odious prerogative of some men exploiting others has been eradicated. Capitalists cannot make laws against vagrancy because they are the lazy and parasites of the society in which they live. The first great law against vagrancy was promoted by the Revolution when it abolished capitalism.

Now that we have abolished capitalism, who are the only exploiters that remain? Who can exploit us today? Today, those who seek to have privileges over others can exploit us. Privilege can be a factor of exploitation of the working people. We must always fight vigorously against any manifestation of privilege.

It is necessary that the men in charge set an example in work and sacrifice. And we must achieve this across the board.

We have, for example, the problem of housing. At the beginning of the Revolution, there were tens of thousands of apartments and houses available waiting for tenants willing to pay their exorbitant rents. The Urban Reform Law was at that moment a remedy for the situation. Many families were able to obtain housing, and suddenly for millions of people, the property where they resided ceased to be an obsession and an instrument of exploitation. However, today the situation is different. The population has grown, and it has not been possible to build a corresponding number of houses; there are tremendous tensions. In this situation, the administrative official, or worse yet, the political leader, who receives preference for a vacant house, in view of thousands of people who do not have even a room and of the entire population, inflicts tremendous damage on the authority and prestige of the Revolution: immediately the worm comes out, the disaffected come out, the lazy come out, the lumpen come out, all the enemies of work come out to use that as an argument against the Revolution and demoralize the revolutionaries.

Fortunately, our vanguard is not a vanguard that has become corrupted. Our vanguard is fundamentally made up of people from the working class. The vast majority of the members of our Party have been selected in workers' assemblies. Those who perform administrative or leadership tasks have been selected for the Party taking into account their revolutionary backgrounds and their conduct in the process. If there are exceptions, if unfortunately, as has happened, manifestations of privilege and even corruption occur, we must eradicate them and sweep them away with all energy.

If a cadre or member of our Party has gone astray, they must be changed, they must be immediately removed from the ranks of the Party.

Then, that moral factor will not be difficult to obtain. The battle against all manifestations of privilege will not be difficult to win. However, the other is more difficult. The battle against that part, that minority that does not yet have sufficient consciousness, that does not have the necessary education, that has mismatches and maladaptations in a society of workers, that will be more difficult.

That minority exploits us because they do not work and they wear, dress, drink, eat, go to the movies, ride a bus, see a public show, receive medicine if they get sick, have their lives saved, and even get buried for free if they die, gentlemen. That is an unquestionable fact. They have everything. But each of the goods and services that that person receives is produced by someone.

That can be our exploiter today. Against those manifestations of exploitation, we must rebel with as much hatred as the worker rebelled against the imperialist monopoly, against the landowner, against the exploiting bourgeois, against the thieving merchant. That is a manifestation of delinquency in a collectivist society that we must prevent. I am absolutely in full agreement with the criteria put forth by comrade Risquet that it is fundamentally political, that the measures taken must not only come from the people but must also be educational, that 90% of the battle must be won in the discussion and in the simple approval of the law, that this law applies to a minority, that we know how to orient ourselves well in how to apply it, that we know how to make distinctions, that we know how to avoid mechanistic approaches.

Furthermore, I believe, gentlemen, that we must have the worker's file. Because everyone knows each person in each place: the liar and the good one, the honest and the dishonest. Everyone knows this in all workplaces.

We must avoid simplistic solutions at all costs; we must avoid mechanistic approaches in this matter at all costs. We must act more than ever with political criteria, with intelligent measures, distinguishing incessantly. Moreover, the problems in one center are not the same as in another. Additionally, there are workplaces that have difficult problems; many do not even have guaranteed snacks. There are workers who, to work eight hours, have to spend four more traveling from one place to another, and they have to do it under very difficult conditions. And, of course, there are all those administrative, objective factors that we see in a factory.

I said: if you see that factory getting wet for so long, you have to have a deep conviction to believe in the Revolution. Because it would not be difficult, it would not be difficult to say: this is garbage, this has no perspective, if you see a factory getting wet for five years. That happens there.

Of course, there are many other positive things that encourage people, but those are factors of discouragement, of demoralization, of all that.

So, the situations in workplaces are different. There are still many, I repeat, that do not have cafeterias, that do not even have snacks. There are some that are much better than others; we have seen them. And one of the things we must see is how to improve the cafeteria problem, so that over time each workers' cafeteria becomes like a reasonably pleasant and good restaurant.

Unfortunately, we do not have all the means; this is not an easy thing.

There are some things that the country can relatively quickly increase. The fishing fleet is growing, there is already a high dairy potential that we must take advantage of, our breweries can significantly increase the production of malt for the workers' cafeterias. There are more means today than ever to continue increasing rice production and give a drastic boost to the production of vegetables and tubers. Much more difficult, in the immediate future, will be to increase meat production, since although the cattle have been genetically improved for milk production, pastures have not received all the attention in recent years, births have not been sufficiently high, and slaughters, due to low weights, have been elevated. Maximum attention is now being paid to this issue, including the increase in pig and poultry production.

So, if not in all, in many important areas of food, we can increase production relatively soon. And we must fight and see how we achieve this since we need to raise the number of quotas in childcare centers so that women can go to work, we need to raise it in school cafeterias for the same reason, and we need to raise it and improve it especially in workers' cafeterias, many of which do not even have quotas yet.

So, we are going to implement a policy aimed at improving the situation of the worker; first in food, then in transportation. We are developing a plan with the genetic centers of the province of Havana to supply a milk quota to the workers' centers that perform hard work and whose health requires better nutrition. We have asked the Ministry of Labor for a list of those places and centers that, for health reasons, should have priority.

Of course, we should not only adhere to this priority. There may be centers that, although they were not on a priority list, due to the type of work, must be taken into account, as they have absolutely nothing. If it is possible to provide even a snack: some soda crackers with devil's ham and a little milk, even if it is not a prioritized center due to the type of work, it is fair to do so. There will be cases of centers that, due to their sanitary conditions, are not as hard as others, but while those already have something, these have nothing.

So, we must seek the most equitable distribution of those products. I believe that within a year we can provide 100,000 workers with a third of a liter of milk, of course, if we finish those dairies, those that were mentioned here that the construction workers could finish more quickly with less absenteeism. If the construction brigades increase productivity; if in Niña Bonita, in Nazareno, Flor de Itabo, in Picadura, in Niña Sierra, in all those places, the dairies are built at the appropriate pace. Because we have the cows and we not only have the cows; the milking equipment is already arriving. Similar plans can be developed in all provinces of the country. For there is already a high number of dairy heifers in all of them, with which we can supply not only the workers' cafeterias but also increase the consumption of children and the population in general and, in addition, reduce current imports of this product. The problem lies in the milking facilities and putting them into production.

We are studying another formula. Perhaps the banana fruit plan from Artemisa can organize the distribution of this product in the workers' cafeterias. Likewise, the soda crackers, from the “Albert Khuntz” factory, and thus we can study ways to improve the snack or the meal.

We intend to organize some brigades to build cafeterias where none exist, taking as a model the one from CONSTRUIMPORT or a similar one.

While here, a worker also brought me a little note that said: “Comrade Fidel: unit 209, formerly ‘Edelmira’, from San José de las Lajas, we invite you and the comrade from the ‘Lincoln’ central who expressed the difficulties with the cafeteria in that center, to see our cafeteria built by the workers of the unit, where from the blocks to the construction itself, we did it with voluntary work.” This means that there are possibilities to do.

So we are going to study how many compressors are needed, how much cork, how much raw material is required to make the refrigerators or cold rooms that are needed. How they should be when there are up to 250 workers, when there are up to 500, 750, when there are 1,000. In a few days, we will have all that data and try to gather the necessary materials.

We are also studying transportation problems in the factories. In some factories, we are going to assign some transportation. We have started with Santiago de Cuba. Why? To complement the rest of the urban transportation for the night shifts, for those who have more difficulties.

We have the project —the thing is that now with the 300 medium buses we are building this year, they barely reach anything, since the great needs of rural transportation are now joined by the needs of the factories. What are we going to do with that transportation? Convert it into the collective car for the workers. The bus with its driver, which makes a route and picks them up. Those who have easy access arrive by the normal routes. The factory buses will be for those who have greater transportation difficulties. We will use those same means in the vacation plans for the workers and their families in the summer, during the hours when they are not used to transport the workers. So we can coordinate the vacation plans through that.

We also believe, gentlemen, that we can make certain distributions through the factory. How do we distribute those refrigerators that are already being built in Santa Clara? Well, we have to put part of them in the apartments of farmers in the agricultural plans, which we are doing when we build the towns. But we can distribute approximately 15,000 in 1971. How do we distribute those 15,000? It occurs to me that we should sell them through the factory, through quotas that are assigned proportionally to the workplaces, with the corresponding cards to be distributed in those centers, with which the workers can present themselves at the distribution unit. How should we sell almost half a million pressure cookers? Well, it occurs to me that we should also sell them through cards assigned to the workplaces.

So, what do we do? The absentee, well, he has no chance of getting a refrigerator. It is already known that he will not get it in any way.

And when we have sufficient production of furniture and other durable consumer goods, we will also distribute them through the factory.

The formula that someone proposed with cigarettes is something that resembles this, but we will have to discuss cigarettes; that is another discussion we must have: what do we do with cigarettes? Because I suggested to my colleagues that they look for the data on the tens of thousands, the hundreds of thousands of people we would have to employ in that if we want to maintain exports and consumption with the increase that is taking place, at the pace it was going.

So we will have to look for a price solution for cigarettes as well as for drinks. There are cases of people who do not smoke. They take the box of cigarettes and trade it with others even for food, gentlemen. It would be preferable for the worker to be able to consume his food at a modest price and pay a little more for the cigarette. Even the kids are acquiring smoking habits because they had the possibility of getting it for 20 cents. It is preferable to work to bring milk, malt, and other foods to the workers' cafeterias than to invest additional energy in a consumption that has been proven to be highly harmful.

In short, we believe that for some things like cigarettes and strong drinks, we should look for a price solution and not a rationing solution.

When I spoke on the 26th, I said: We do not like the price solution. Why? Ah, because then you have the inequalities that exist in salaries, we will have the situation where with high prices only part of the population can acquire meat, milk, etc. Everyone needs vital products. The same does not happen with cigarettes, because the first problem that arises is who smokes and who does not, who should receive a quota and who should not. If we do it by rationing, everyone would ask for their quota. If we do it through the factory, we would only achieve that workers smoke more and preserve the health of the lazy. We must use the refrigerator, use food, use a lot of things to improve the workers, but we should not use cigarettes. We must resolve the cigarette issue in another way, through prices that at the same time constitute a limitation on consumption and serve to collect the excess circulating money. Of course, these measures must be well analyzed and discussed with the workers themselves. They have enough sense to decide whether it is correct or not for the country to dedicate the work of 100,000 or 200,000 more people, which on the other hand do not exist, and other resources, to continue increasing the consumption of a harmful product, at very low prices, while maintaining a level of export that cannot be renounced as it is a source of foreign currency for development. The same if it is said: we are going to ration it, well, it is rationed. But we will have a black market, we will have a man trading food for cigarettes. Do not forget that type of situation, but we will discuss and analyze the problem well.

Returning to the issue of absentees. First of all, they are deprived of the right to acquire durable consumer goods. The time comes to repair a house in the district, and say: well, wait a moment, you do not deserve it, kid. We will give priority to this one, who is a better worker, compliant and all, before you. Need alone is not a sufficient reason. We will take into account, among two who have the same need, we will give preference to the one who is a compliant worker there in the district. And at a certain moment we say: well, you are becoming a little more sluggish, more non-compliant, look: we are going to take away your right to the food quota in this cafeteria, because you are coming three days a week, only two. It is a somewhat more drastic weapon. We can go a little further and take away their personal consumption booklet.

The issue of salary we will have to take away when it is lacking. Will the family suffer? No, because there is social security there. It is preferable to take the family of a lazy person —do you understand?— and send them a pension so they can acquire what they need, than for the lazy person, being lazy, to show up as the "cool guy" in the house, who brings the money and continues to maintain.

CAPTAIN JORGE RISQUET.- When those elements do not go, they are not paid.

COMMANDER FIDEL CASTRO.- They are not paid currently, right? But we have to see even in the vanguard factory, that we established certain provisions...

CAPTAIN JORGE RISQUET.- Yes, but not for him.

COMMANDER FIDEL CASTRO.- Correct. We will exclude him. All that range of things for which we can combat, isolate, and corner the antisocial element, and when necessary apply the most energetic measures, so that the case of the individual who was given the seventeenth warning nine months ago and has still not shown up at the factory does not happen again. It is not only what he steals from society with his behavior, but also the time he makes others lose.

We must be a little more energetic. But today we can be, because we have enough awareness in the majority of the workers. The difficulties, the problems, the complexity of the revolutionary process help us to form awareness. Because what must be said is that it is a very difficult process, extremely difficult!

Now, another issue: the battles for the solution of economic and production problems we must fight concretely, not abstractly. Problems must be resolved factory by factory. The same there, where the problem of graphic arts is, as in the "Téllez" factory, where various difficulties were pointed out. It must be fought concretely in the thousands of production centers in the country. The administrative bodies must do concrete work, and we all must carry out concrete work, problem by problem. Problems —I repeat— are not resolved abstractly but concretely.

In our opinion, this plenary has been a great experience, very rich in experience. I wonder what it would have been like if we had had the meeting of the sector in question —for example— of construction, or of light industry, with the representatives of the corresponding administration.

Of course, it is even better if the various sectors are present, because there is interrelation between one another. And many times the problem is seen better and discussed better when different branches are represented. But imagine if here were gathered 8 or 10 of the most important sectors of the economy, and that the corresponding ministers and deputy ministers were also gathered here and a type of assembly of concrete problems from each of the production centers were held.

That it would no longer be discussing absenteeism, that it would no longer be discussing voluntary work, or discussing —as we will have to discuss— the law, or what we do with cigarettes.

Developing that type of analysis and discussions would be of tremendous interest, because then the colleagues could raise all the problems, and the minister, or the deputy minister, or the company director, or the corresponding official, from foreign trade or any service, could provide the information they possess, explain what is being done, what is not being done and why, what can be done and what will be done.

It could help to improve the State extraordinarily through that route, making us all aware of our realities.

I tell you that it hurts me a lot to see a factory like that getting wet. Because I think that no minister has the right to fix the roof of his building, nor to even have a building, while the workers' building could fall on their heads. I truly believe it! I sincerely believe it!

We must make our officials have a clearer, more precise idea and a much more vivid reality of what is happening. We must make the ministers go to the workplaces, gentlemen. They should go there, because that is where you learn. And really, if I want to find out about the problem, I do not go to the ministry, I go to the workplace. That is where I learn about the difficulties and the problems. That is where one draws lessons, that is where one gains experience, that is where one takes on a proletarian spirit.

We talk about instilling a proletarian spirit, creating awareness. It is a lie. We are in a situation today where we must go to the factories where the workers are to take awareness from the workers, not to bring them awareness. Because the man who is carrying a sack there for eight hours, running, on his back, or is perched on a scaffold, or is hammering constantly, or working with fire and iron, has more proletarian awareness than we do, because he is there at work, in the struggle, living all the problems and all the realities, suffering there up close the impotence of seeing many things that no one explains to him and that he cannot resolve.

So by going to the factories, we can bring the elements of judgment that we have and that the workers may not have, and gather the elements of judgment that the workers have and that we do not have. And above all there in need, in struggle, seeing a worker with torn pants, seeing a worker with broken boots. I am sure that when a man sees that and has sensitivity, he will immediately worry threefold, fourfold about the problem; he will find out, first of all, if he does not know.

Then also promote among the workers: here are the consequences of broken shoes —to the footwear workers. Promote connections between factories, management between factories. Because sometimes they are depending on such a small factory. Not going to a consolidated one, going directly there. Look: this is the unit that, according to the plan, has to produce this product for me. When will it produce it? When is it ready? If it lacks labor force like in the case of the small workshop that produces rollers for graphic arts, tell them: look, here we send you three men from the factory so that you can make this roller for us, without which our production stops. If it is a small bushing, go to the unit that has to produce it. Establish interconnections between factories, management among workers, fighting for production. The fundamental duty of the worker is to fight for production. Why? Because only from production can the improvement of living conditions come. Only from production can there be more footwear, more clothing, more of everything.

These problems, of course, do not think they are so easy.

With shoes, we have more solutions. Plastic will help us a lot, because next year we have the possibility of producing about 20 million pairs of plastic shoes. With them, the problems of women's and children's footwear will be greatly alleviated. So between plastic, leather, and other types, we can approach 40 million pairs. That is already more than four pairs per capita. Now, we must fight for quality, especially in leather footwear. They should not break in two minutes, they should not come apart, they should not be garbage. And study all those factors that are affecting that.

Regarding the textile issue, the problem is more difficult. Even if we solve the labor force problems, the installed capacity is insufficient, the machines and factories have been in production for many years, a large part comes from the United States, and the raw materials are not always within our reach. The problems of textiles are aggravated by the amount of clothing distributed for certain activities, such as the harvests, which consume considerable amounts of fabrics and garments. The population has grown, we have imported fewer textiles because we had problems maintaining certain levels of imports that had been ongoing. And the per capita is extremely low, gentlemen. The per capita of manufactured clothing and fabrics that are reaching the population is impressively low. And it is one of the problems that we must pay preferential attention to.

There are two tremendous problems at this moment: one of them is housing, and the other is textiles. The government, the country's leadership bodies, those who manage the economy, all of us, must find a way to address the housing issue, which is becoming supercritical, and also to find some solution, some palliative for the textile issue in these next two, three, or four years, while we create new industrial capacities and provide a definitive solution to the problem.

That is to say, some of these problems require very special efforts from the nation and optimal use of means and resources.

When I saw today in the MINAZ warehouse the amount of steel they had there, I clearly saw how, under the 10 million plan, MINAZ, a sector of the economy, was dispatched with a big scoop, receiving steel that they have not been able to use, machines that they have not yet been able to install. They do not even know what to do with everything they received, while there were other factories that could have been improved with a better distribution of those resources that were dedicated to the 10 million plan.

Now, the technocrats, the "smart" ones, the "wise" ones, the "super-scientists," they knew what needed to be done to produce 10 million. It was first demonstrated that they did not really know what needed to be done; and secondly, that they exploited the economy, sectorially dispatching large amounts of resources. Many times, there were missing steel sheets to make a sugar cane planter, and they had tens of thousands of tons of steel.

So there has to be a planning and distribution of resources work that is far superior to what we have achieved so far.

I want to tell you that the problems are not easy: the problems are difficult, the problems are complex. There are some difficulties that are objective, with which we have to see how we confront them, and others that are absolutely subjective. It is in these subjective matters — the attitude of the worker, productivity, organization, administration, leadership, the behavior of the leader — where we have to tackle with all our strength in this immediate future, because that is where we can advance.

So I told you that this assembly has been extraordinarily enlightening, and that we must continue to hold them. From this experience, we will draw the possibility of another type of assembly, no longer to discuss voluntary work or absenteeism — I repeat — but to discuss the concrete problems of each important workplace.

It is a pity that we do not have the labor movement more developed, because if we could bring the representative of the union section from all the main factories; that is, let the union representative come here, let the advanced representative come, and even, gentlemen, they can bring the factory manager to the meeting, and all these things can be analyzed.

It has been demonstrated that with a few microphones there and a few companions, moving them from one side to another, everyone speaks. And if we put a little light down there, we see those who are in the back. And if we have to spend three days discussing, there are so many lessons and things that can be drawn and so many ideas!

What would we be doing with that? We would also be teaching our workers to solve problems, to contribute their ideas, to discuss, to reflect, to have a more global idea of the interrelation that all industries, all branches have, to better understand the problems, to have arguments to combat, to speak, to fight.

I understand how hard it must be for the comrades in the union there and from the Party, in that factory where the water is falling and they have been waiting for five years for someone to go there; I understand. It must be very difficult. It must take a super-revolutionary, a genius, to be there wielding a good argument, because all those things are hard to understand.

Because I said that there are people who have no idea of the complexity of a process, they do not explain all the difficulties and inefficiencies, and what they do is lose faith.

That our country has come this far, that our country has resisted for 11 years against the most powerful imperialist country in the world, the one that could do us the most economic, military, and ideological harm, a country that had us completely indoctrinated even, that had instilled its capitalist, selfish, reactionary culture everywhere, its vices, everything: the fact that our country has been able to resist demonstrates the strength of a revolution, the power of a revolution. But we have demonstrated much more capacity to confront the enemy, to be willing to die, to be willing to do things, even for great sacrifices, than our capacity to develop and employ the tremendous energy and initiative of the masses in the face of difficulties.

I would say that this is a kind of atomic energy, that if we unleash it, there will be nothing that will not crumble before its push. So we have to learn to develop the science of unleashing the nuclear energy of the masses.

Our Party and our revolutionary organizations must develop that technology.

Today the baker comrade said that we have a social security and rights letter so generous that there are not even equal ones in other communist countries. Ah, what a shame for the Revolution if it had to retreat from that path, what a shame if we had to start charging for education, medical care, housing for everyone, the children's circle, the school cafeteria, the ball... No!

We would go very far if with mass work we win this battle. We would go very far if we introduce to its maximum degree the democratization of the process. There can be no state more democratic than the socialist one, there cannot be; nor should there be. Moreover: if the socialist state is not democratic, it fails. Because the socialist state is society organized to solve the problems of the masses, and through levers that are of consciousness and not of life or death as in capitalism.

If we used capitalist levers to solve our difficulties, what communist man, what man of mentality, of culture, of superior consciousness, would we create by that path? No way! We cannot be socialists with capitalist methods.

Thus, socialism, if it is not of the masses, fails, because it has to work for the masses and can only solve problems with the masses. Because it is no longer the capitalist who is making money taking care of his little business, taking care of his factory, taking care of whatever, all day stuck there and using the levers of the capitalist economy; it is now the administration of the economy by the whole people, it is the work of the whole people.

And then without the masses, socialism loses the battle: it bureaucratizes, it has to use capitalist methods, it has to retreat in ideology. So there can be no society more democratic than the socialist one simply because without the masses, socialism cannot triumph.

Now, if there is no contradiction within society, if there are no parties representing landowners, or owners, or bourgeois, or bankers, or anything, if it is a single party, if it is a single ideology, if it is a single society, as we eliminate all the residues that remain, why not establish the maximum participation of that society in its struggle for its life if it is — in my opinion — the most beautiful thing that socialist society can have?

It is not about a group of super-intelligent men directing the masses, who would be passive, towards their well-being. That is not a revolution. Moreover, that could not exist in the reality of life, because no one with administrative methods — I repeat — could solve the problems.

Battles are only won, within a collectivist society, with the broadest participation of the masses in solving their problems. Remember this.

Socialism can only move forward, the immense obstacles that socialism has in front of it, and especially if it is a underdeveloped economy like ours, can only be overcome with the broadest participation of the masses.

We have to eradicate administrative methods, because they would never lead to true solutions. It is understood in the first phase of the Revolution, gentlemen. In the first phase of the Revolution, there was not even an ideology. What did we have? A terrible ideological confusion: many people were influenced by reactionary, capitalist, selfish ideas, all those things. Today no, today we have a people that has advanced extraordinarily. So we have to completely eradicate administrative methods and establish mass methods everywhere: in the district, in the city, in the region, in the province, nationally.

We are not going to do it overnight. It would be ridiculous for a few of us to lock ourselves up to draft a constitution, all this, for it to work wonderfully. I believe not, we have to go progressively; but in a relatively short period. Saying progressively does not mean that we are going to wait 10 years to do that. No! Start with some of those mechanisms: organizing the district, holding plenary meetings like this one with the main responsible officials of the administration in the production fronts. All of these are steps.

One of the fundamental steps: create a powerful labor movement, so we can say, alongside the Defense Committees, alongside the federation, we have a powerful labor movement. That is one of the first steps of democratization. Start with the workers, start with the unions, hold absolutely free elections.

Where we find that a workplace elects a slacker, it is a political red light about the backwardness, about the confusion, about the poor political work that is there; where we find that they elect an absentee or a person who is not a worker of conditions, it is a red light too; where they elect a demagogue, an agitator, who may appear exploiting some justified irritation will demonstrate to what extent our political work in that center is weak.

I am sure that a proletarianized workplace with consciousness does not elect a slacker, nor does it elect a slacker, nor does it elect a demagogue, nor does it elect a liar, nor does it elect a politician, because the workers have enough instinct, mental clarity, to distinguish all that type of people.

Gentlemen, let us trust our workers and quickly carry out elections in all the union sections — let us call them sections now — that is, in all factories, in all factories! And we will carry them out in an absolutely free manner, in which those whom the workers wish to nominate are nominated. No one can buy the masses, no demagogue can deceive the masses.

Do the same as when exemplary workers are elected. And then, gentlemen, submit to absolutely democratic voting, so that the workers freely choose their leaders. When they elect a man unworthy of representing the cause and spirit of the proletariat — and I am sure that this could only happen very exceptionally — it will give the measure of the political situation of the center, and we can say: this center is politically wrong, there is not enough consciousness, they have allowed themselves to be deceived, they have allowed themselves to be seduced by this demagogue, who is a liar, who is a fraud, who is a shameless person, who is an ambitious person, who is a vain person, who is anything. And this would not weaken the Revolution, but would help keep it alert, vigilant, and combative within the masses.

Let us start by democratizing the labor movement. If the labor movement is not democratic, it is useless.

If it is a worker who has truly been elected by the workers by majority, when he arrives there he has authority, he does not arrive as "Mr. Nobody," he does not arrive as the person pointed out by a finger. He arrives as the individual who has the moral authority of having been elected, and when the Revolution draws a line, he goes there to defend that line, to advocate for it, to fight for it. If that leader strays from the spirit of the Revolution, the masses can sweep him away at any moment.

Because we must establish that any official can be renewed at any time, day or night. An election, calling for an election in that center to submit, ratify or not this, so that no one feels that because they were elected one day, they will be there for a year doing whatever they want. No. After three months or at any moment there can be another assembly, another election in that section — and that's it! — and they appointed someone else or ratified him. But follow democratic procedures. If the labor movement is not democratic, I repeat, it is useless.

We can apply the same principle that if socialist society does not support itself on the masses, it fails. And to support itself on the masses, it must democratize to the maximum, it must eliminate administrative methods.

If we put millions of people to think, there will be no problem that we cannot solve. If we put millions of people consciously to work, there will be no administrative problem that cannot be resolved. Because a person who is doing things wrong, a ministry that is working poorly, a regional office that is abusing people... None of those things that were raised here can endure, gentlemen, if the masses are participating. Then there will be sand on the beach, there will be no sea urchins, there will be this, there will be that, what should not rot will not rot, what should not be wasted will not be wasted, the burlap sacks will not be left lying there, the materials will not deteriorate there at a dock.

None of that will happen the day we truly have the masses consciously thinking and acting!

We believe wholeheartedly in that, and we think about the wealth of intelligence that exists in the people. There have been a series of manifestations here, comrades who have spoken with magnificent spirit, concisely, with a clear idea, who have impressed us with the way they have presented their problems here. So there are infinite thinking intelligences in our working class.

The capacity to think is not of a ruling minority. It is a lie! The capacity to think is in all the people. And we could seek all those intelligences. It is not necessary for them to hold a position.

Can’t a forward-thinking worker come here to express, to present a problem, as has happened now? I believe that when we hold meetings like this, in addition to the Party, the union, we should bring, as we have done now, invited forward-thinking workers, even if they do not hold positions in the organizations.

Of course, the most likely thing that will happen is that the most talented and honest workers will be chosen. The most likely thing is that they will be in the advanced bureau, or they will be in the union. But there may be a very prepared and revolutionary worker who is not in a position. Because even due to the task they perform in the factory, it is not advisable to give them a union position. It could happen. There may be workers who it is best to free from all types of activity of that kind and yet can come here to present us with very important issues.

Now, if we go down that path, we will win the battle. And we believe that the 8, 10, 12 battles we have to fight, we will win by this path.

For the workers, their number one contribution, first — I refer to the phase of democratization of the revolutionary process — is to self-democratize. To constitute a strong and powerful labor movement, which in order to be strong, powerful, and a labor movement, must be one hundred percent democratic. Do not forget that. In order to be a labor movement, strong, powerful, efficient, it must be absolutely democratic. That battles are fought with ideas, with words, not with the finger. That the demagogue is fought with arguments; that the revolutionary does not act timidly. Even that the revolutionary trains in the art of discussing and telling the truth.

Here we have seen comrades who have discussed: one with one argument, another with another, another with another. We must even train the leaders, the cadres, the militants in the art of discussing, defending their point of view, their position, reasoning, seeing all those problems.

So I truly believe that this plenary will be a kind of historic plenary. We will not give it a title ourselves. We will leave it. It will be historic depending on how we continue to work down this path.

From this plenary, the discussions will be published, all the things. It is not what I say here, that one speaks more freely, sincerely, than when one has the television or the radio in front of them. Because when one is speaking for television, there are thousands of people, the enemy is listening to you, the outside is listening to you, what you say will be at hand. All those things. Although, of course, I understand that the Revolution should not be afraid to say anything in any sense.

We understand that work has been done well. It is true that some turns were prolonged too much. It is true that the comrades who stayed until the end could hardly speak and were under time pressure. And it is regrettable, because perhaps many of those comrades would have spoken earlier and contributed ideas, as the others did. What we will have to do, based on the experience gained this time, is to adhere to a time regulation. When there are interruptions, here with a stopwatch, interruptions do not count because sometimes one has to ask a question, another and another, from which useful things are drawn. Establish the time issue. And I believe we can do it, without reaching 3:00 in the morning. Maybe we can take a Sunday, and say: voluntary work, meeting at the CTC.

So one of those meetings can be held on a Sunday from 8:00 in the morning. From 8:00 to 12:00, from 2:00 to 7:00, and from 9:00 to 12:00 again, and we get 12 hours.

CAPTAIN JORGE RISQUET.- And an artistic act.

COMMANDER FIDEL CASTRO.- Well, maybe with some indirect music, at least, right? Maybe we invite one of the 150 artists who are out of work to play a guitar here. Do you realize? And we can discuss.

In general, why have we developed a phobia for meetings? Because we have had mechanical, silly meetings, where nonsense is spoken, the same things. But meetings like this, gentlemen... Look: we have been here for a bunch of hours, and I swear I prefer this meeting to the best movie. Here we truly learn. It is life revealed.

Those of us who have a passion for all that social stuff, for all this political stuff, receive tremendous stimuli here. Discovering things, seeing things, learning things.

It is true that we would like to multiply ourselves. I wish we could go to all the factories, to all the places. I wish we could be tops; not yoyos of the type that points to a worker here, but tops. It is not the same: the yoyo spins, but it is another thing. (FROM THE AUDIENCE THEY SAY: “Up and down!”)

So, you cannot spin so much. But I will do my utmost to go to the factories. Is it to please the workers? It is not about that. It is to learn, to see the problems, to gather that experience. That is to say that in each of those places one learns a lot every day.

And do you know how we will learn to be efficient, and how our ministers can learn to become efficient officials of the people? Do you know how? By going to the factories, going to the factories! (FROM THE AUDIENCE THEY SAY: “Like Che did!”)

Che, who was one of the greatest defenders of moral encouragement, of the merits of workers, and also of voluntary work, and also of the connections between workers, and also of democratic procedures; he felt all these things very deeply. That is why the phrase that the baker remembered about Che is very logical, which said: “There are still many unemployed.” That is to say, we are in a factory, but we are not producing. What was exactly the phrase?

BAKER.- “That unemployment had ended, but that there were still many unemployed who were being paid.”

COMMANDER FIDEL CASTRO.- Many unemployed, yes, exactly. That is the truth.

And he had all those problems and lived all those problems. And he was always trying to set an example of how to act.

I was speaking there in the factory today, and I said: “You have to establish connections.” And they told me: “Those are the CILOs (Local Industry Committees).” I said: “What do you mean by 'CILOs'?” “No, the CILOs that Che said had to be established between the factories.” Even that same thing of establishing interconnections between the factories.

So, in reality, I repeat this idea: to be efficient officials of the people, the best thing the men of the administration could do is to go to the factory. They discover the realities, discover the difficulties, they can give a boost to the worker, they can provide an explanation.

I was asked about a blade there for the guillotine, but what can I answer them? At that moment I would have liked to be from MAQUIMPORT, from one of those organizations, or from the company, to say: “Yes, gentlemen, these blades were ordered, they come from such a place, or they do not come, or so many have come, or we are making such a management.” Because what is not supposed to happen is that one can cut there without a blade. That is the truth.

So, our ministers would fight for the best solutions at the levels where the pertinent decisions are made. They would say: “Gentlemen, I ask that this, this, and this other be taken into account, because it is affecting this, this, and this.” Constantly, because it may happen that there is a serious problem, and if awareness of it is not taken in the direction of the State, what can we do? If at the time of deciding the resources we do not have awareness of the problem, of a prioritized, tremendous need, there, then mechanical and inefficient plans are made. Why? Because all the ministers start asking for the sky and the earth, and so many millions. And when you balance it, you say: “This is impossible.” To cut, to cut, to cut and to cut. And sometimes they even cut a blade. A blade that perhaps received a terrible cut at the time of making the import plan. Yes, yes: a blade cut before being a blade. That is the problem. So, there is no guillotine blade. But I cannot conceive that place functioning without a blade. It is like conceiving the textile factory without thread, or without a spindle. It cannot. Or if it does not have paper, or if any of the other things are missing.

So, if the ministers were much better informed and were more aware of the realities, a much more efficient and balanced plan could be made. And all the management would be done, and everyone would know more about the problems.

Do you think that sometimes when one talks about a problem in a factory, one knows something, right? No, man. What we have is an encyclopedic ignorance of the problems of the factories. I wish we could truly know about all the problems of the factories. Because we are sure that to the same extent that we had information about those problems, we could help to solve some of those problems. But I also say this about all the other comrades: to the same extent that they were informed about the problems, I am sure they could do something and would do something to solve them. But I do not believe that anyone will do anything to solve a problem of which they are not even aware. That is the reality.

I believe we have already abused your patience enough. We hope that you leave here encouraged to work. Not with the idea that we have solved anything. Take that with you: we have solved nothing; we have taken a small step. Now, that small step, take it forward, that small impulse of yours take it forward; it is nothing more than a beginning. Start working on the most important and urgent things, start meditating, thinking, seeing. All the experiences, all the issues, all the matters. Start preparing, let’s say for when we have another meeting to address the concrete problems of production. But concrete here, without journalism... That is to say, with journalists, but without publicity; or with minimal publicity.

I am sure that the journalists are more interested here in this act for what is discussed here than for what they can write. I am completely sure, because yesterday I saw them very interested in the meeting and in all the topics of the meeting.

And what we will do is that: without spectacularity, without publicity, to do this work. It has been proven that a large mass can reason. The only thing that needs to be established is the procedure for everyone to speak, explain; to develop some controversies, some discussions within that framework, and for everyone to express themselves with absolute freedom. That when the time for problems comes, they bring the concrete problems. They can bring from that factory, they can bring from another. That is to say, if we meet at a given moment, if we have in the province of Havana, for example, 67% of the non-sugar industry and we bring the industries of this type that have 60% or 70% of national production, and we resolve the problems of those industries and wage a concrete battle one by one... But, gentlemen, a concrete battle cannot be waged by anyone alone here. Not even Risquet alone. Risquet tries to find the workforce they request, and I can do something on my part. But if all the other comrades are here, and ministers and vice-ministers, waging the concrete battle in each of those places, ah, I am sure that within a year we can have a radically different situation from this year.

It would be interesting to see what we do and what we advance in a year with this policy. And to be able to measure it this way: to be able to say, like with the pressure cookers, that they are already making over a thousand daily; and to be able to say, like with the refrigerators, that they are already making 60 daily. That is already something. Everyone applauded here when the refrigerators were mentioned, because refrigerators are refrigerators, they are 15,000 families that can benefit from having a refrigerator in their home. And 400,000 families that can benefit from having a pressure cooker in the house. But if they also have something to cook in the pot, even better, of course!

Well, comrades: that is all. We will see each other soon.

Homeland or Death!

We will overcome!