Excerpts from an interview with Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, in "Le Monde" on March 6, 2017, on the challenges and priorities of European construction.

France François Hollande · President of France

6 March 2017

Context
Hollande gave a Le Monde interview ahead of a Versailles summit on March 6, 2017, discussing European defense, NATO, and EU reform before the Treaty of Rome's 60th anniversary.
Main themes
European defense cooperation, NATO and transatlantic relations, Franco-German partnership, European Union reform, Brexit and UK defense ties, European sovereignty, burden-sharing, Sahel and French military operations, 60th anniversary of Treaty of Rome, eurozone governance, Donald Trump's impact on Europe, structured defense cooperation
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,125
77th percentile
Sentences
212
90th percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
8.7
8th percentile
Syntax
2.72
14th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

212 sentences in 68 paragraphs

(...)

Q - But Europe, which will celebrate its 60th anniversary on March 25, is in crisis...

R - Yes, but I do not limit myself to the observation, and I do not give in to despair. I want to present Europe in the image that is expected of it: a project, a force, a power. What Europeans are asking for is that the EU can protect them more. That European sovereignty secures their borders, shields them from the risk of terrorism, and finally preserves a way of life, a culture, a community of spirit.

Q - To protect themselves, Europeans must be able to defend themselves?

R - Defense is a subject that was deliberately set aside at the signing of the Treaty of Rome. Europe could have started there; it was France that did not want it in the early 1950s. Today, Europe can relaunch itself through defense. Both to ensure its own security, but also to act in the world, to seek solutions to the conflicts that threaten it. This is what Europeans must have, in coherence with NATO, as a priority.

Q - How does this European defense relate to NATO?

R - The Alliance is necessary, and European defense is in no way contradictory or competitive. It is based on solidarity: when a country is attacked, all others must assist it. President Trump seemed hesitant, but ultimately, he has just reaffirmed his support for NATO to better discuss burden-sharing. What matters is the reliability of partners. France is credible; it has provided, like other Europeans, its support to the United States, particularly in Afghanistan.

The new American administration also has duties towards its European allies. It is not just a matter of budget; it is the very conception of the values we carry in the world. Nevertheless, Europeans must increase their defense efforts. France has decided to raise it to 2% of GDP in the next five years.

Q - So Donald Trump acts as an accelerator for European defense?

R - Yes. Our conviction was established even before his election. We had already made significant progress with Germany. But it is true that the announcement of an American disengagement has raised awareness. Europe must avoid any dependence that would place it in submission, which would be serious, or in abandonment, which would be worse. The awareness is there; it just needs to be translated into better coordination of our defense policies, the integration of our forces, the strengthening of our armament capabilities, and our military projection tools.

Q - Does France feel less alone in these operations?

R - In the Sahel, in Central Africa, and even in the Levant, France was the first to intervene, but it has never been alone. It has always been followed by its European partners. But let’s think: wouldn’t it have been even more symbolic if the decision I made on Mali had been shared from the outset by the Europeans themselves and executed quickly? That is the next step for European defense.

Q - Does the United Kingdom have a role in this European defense?

R - Yes. France and the United Kingdom have strong defense relations, including in the strategic area of nuclear deterrence. Regarding European defense, not all EU countries need to be members; some do not have that tradition, but the door must be open to all. I therefore propose structured cooperation to bring together the countries that want to go much further. In my mind, the United Kingdom, even outside the EU, should be associated with it.

Q - You are receiving the leaders of Germany, Italy, and Spain this Monday, March 6, in Versailles. Why bring these four countries together?

R - Angela Merkel and I consult regularly, before all European councils and on all subjects. It is in Europe’s interest. But this is not an exclusive relationship.

With the 60th anniversary of the treaty taking place in Rome on March 25, it seemed logical to involve Italy and invite Spain. This is not about imposing the viewpoint of the four most populous countries in the eurozone; it is about advancing Europe with a determination and commitment that go well beyond our respective mandates, at a time when the President of the Commission, Jean-Claude Juncker, is presenting his scenarios for the future of the EU.

Q - Is the Franco-German couple no longer enough?

R - It is indispensable. I speak from experience; if there is no trust and unity between France and Germany on the main issues, Europe cannot move forward. But that is not enough. When Ms. Merkel and I reach an agreement, we do not impose it on the other countries; we must convince. In France and Brussels, some find the Franco-German axis unbalanced. You are accused of having been too weak towards the German Chancellor.

France has led Germany further than it had planned to go, for example on banking union. Another example is Greece: France highlighted what the departure of that country from the eurozone would have cost, and Germany ensured, in the discussion, that rules and commitments were set, which were respected by the Greek Prime Minister, Mr. Alexis Tsipras.

Q - Did you stop Wolfgang Schäuble?

R - Let’s say he understood on his own. I could have shouted "cocorico," but that is not the right method, because in the game of formulas "it is France that has won against Germany," or "Germany that has made France yield," we will all lose. Also, at the moment when France was undertaking structural reforms to improve its competitiveness, Germany agreed to give us time to reduce our public deficit, with the goal of being below 3% of GDP in 2017. We are there.

I was therefore right not to provoke a crisis that would have dislocated Europe. We needed, Germany and France, to be together for the eurozone, for the European budget, for the refugee issue, for Ukraine, and fortunately we were. As for concluding the Paris Agreement on climate.

Q - Have you succeeded in "reorienting Europe," as you promised?

R - Yes, the reorientation has indeed taken place. Flexibility has been introduced in the interpretation of the rules of the European budgetary treaty. This shift has allowed Italy and Spain to escape any sanctions, and France to avoid destructive austerity. Banking union has put an end to the crises in the sector. Today, if a financial institution were to fail, it would be the banks that would be called upon to bail it out, not the taxpayers. Finally, the Juncker plan for investment, which has even been amplified and extended, is indeed a reorientation in favor of growth.

Those who say that we have not reoriented the EU are those who actually reject its rules.

(...)

But what worries me most about Europe as it is today is the return of national egos, that each country comes to seek its immediate interest without carrying a common ambition. For some, the benefit of structural funds; for others, the advantage of a single currency; for many, the assets of the internal market and the mobility of workers. No one is satisfied, and Europe is the loser. Without a new European spirit, the EU will sink into dilution and ultimately dislocation.

Q - Are you talking about aid to Greece?

R - Not only. The principle of solidarity is reached when countries refuse to make commitments on refugees, when they deviate from the obligations related to the climate agreement, when they are ready to exclude a country from the eurozone to avoid contributing more. And I hear more and more often, as soon as a new policy is mentioned, this ultimatum: "We no longer want to pay more than we receive." It is the return of Mrs. Thatcher's formula: "I want my money back." The United Kingdom has left, but the bad spirit has remained! If everyone comes to seek what they have paid in, the common flame is over.

Q - What common resurgence can we envision with countries like Poland or Hungary, which contest the authority of European institutions?

R - Europe is not a trading post; it is a system of values. It is therefore legitimate for the European Commission to ensure respect for the principles of the EU. Sanctions are possible, including financial ones. But we cannot suspend a country based on its government to reintegrate it later. European institutions have the duty to ensure cohesion and uphold the treaties. But beyond these difficulties, I am aware that we are reaching a turning point. The European resurgence requires a clear choice about its form of organization.

Europe with twenty-seven can no longer be the uniform Europe of twenty-seven. For a long time, this idea of a differentiated Europe, with different speeds, distinct rhythms for progress, has faced much resistance. But today, it is an idea that is imposing itself. Otherwise, Europe will explode.

Q - Is there no alternative?

R - No. Either we do things differently, or we will no longer do them together. In the future, there will be a common pact, an internal market with, for some, a single currency. But on this foundation, it will be possible for member states that wish to go further in defense, further in tax or social harmonization, further in research, culture, and youth. In short, we must imagine degrees of integration.

Q - But no pause in integration?

R - No. No country should prevent others from moving faster. Let’s be frank: some member states will never join the eurozone. Let’s acknowledge that. And let’s not wait for them to deepen the economic and monetary union. Hence my proposal for a eurozone budget. Because wanting to do everything at twenty-seven risks leading to doing nothing at all.

Q - And the countries that do not want refugees?

R - In the fall of 2015, when the discussion became tense in the European Council, I told the reluctant countries: "You do not want to welcome refugees, you will not have any, and you will politically bear this situation." We preferred a formula based on voluntarism, and today the observation is that the objectives are not being met? How can we be surprised?

Europe is capable of imposing sanctions in case of failure to comply with budgetary discipline or competition rules, but seems disarmed in the face of states that trample on the principles of solidarity and tolerate all abuses in terms of posted workers. Europe must more strongly establish its hierarchy of priorities.

Q - Such a relaunch of integration does not risk further dividing Western and Eastern Europe?

R - It must not be closed to anyone.

Q - The leader of the ruling party in Poland, Jaroslaw Kaczynski, has indicated that his country would oppose the renewal of his compatriot Donald Tusk as President of the European Council. Does this pose a problem for you?

R - I myself supported Donald Tusk's candidacy two and a half years ago for the presidency of the European Council. I have no reason to call it into question, even if, in light of the political balances, it would be a socialist's turn: I try to have a more European vision than a partisan or national one. Can a country prevent one of its nationals from being president of a European institution? Legally no, since the decision is made by qualified majority. It is up to the European Council to discuss it politically. It has the possibility to choose a candidate rejected by its own country. As far as I am concerned, I will not participate in this eviction.

Q - How do you explain the disenchantment with Europe? Has the demand for national identity been underestimated? The resentment towards globalization? What mistakes have been made?

R - The enlargement of Europe was carried out in the name of entirely respectable political principles, but it allowed countries to come and compete with others under very favorable conditions. Shouldn't there have been a longer transition phase? Surely, but it is too late. And it is easy for populists in the West to denounce relocations and for those in the East to defend freedom of movement at all costs.

Then, Europe has not seemed to sufficiently defend its commercial interests in the world. It wanted to be an example of openness because it believes in exchange, but it may have given the impression that it conceded too much to emerging countries. But we are not going to fall into protectionism, nor refuse any balanced trade agreement like CETA - the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement with Canada. On the other hand, it is necessary to fight against all forms of dumping. This has been done regarding Chinese steel.

Finally, the major problem of the EU is not the meaning of its choices, but the slowness of its decision-making. Europe acts quite well but always too late! Thus, for Greece, how long did it take to reach the agreement of July 2015? And since that night of negotiation in the European Council, how many Eurogroup meetings to pay Greece what was already promised to it! On banking union, it took three years to introduce the rules and establish the authorities.

On refugees, how much longer will it take to set up the coast guards, the "hot spots," and conclude the agreement with Turkey? And for strengthening our instruments to combat terrorism? The decision-making processes in Europe are no longer suited to a world that is one of urgency. Populists, on the other hand, operate in the immediacy of tweets.

When Donald Trump issued those immigration decrees that sparked widespread outrage, his aim was less about their practical effectiveness than their media impact. An effective EU means authorities that decide quickly. This is the great lesson of the last few years of crisis.

Q - Is the EU over-regulating?

A - Yes. Even if it is the consequence of the internal market and if the Commission is the guardian of the treaties. There was a logic: Europe did not establish itself by accident or perversion. Moreover, far too many issues are brought up to the European Council which, I remind you, operates by consensus. Heads of state and government should only be seized with the essentials.

Q - What message would you like to send to the United Kingdom, which wants to leave the EU but keep its benefits?

A - That it is not possible and that it will therefore become a third country in relation to the EU. That is the problem for the United Kingdom: it thought that by leaving Europe it would forge a strategic partnership with the United States. But it turns out that America is closing itself off from the world. The United Kingdom made a bad choice at the wrong time. I regret it.

Q - Are you worried about President Trump?

A - It is not just a matter of emotion or fear. It is a political reality for four years. We now know his lines of conduct: isolationism, protectionism, closing off to immigration, and a budgetary rush forward. In short, concern faces uncertainty, and the euphoria of the financial markets seems quite premature to me.

As for his ignorance of what the EU is, it compels us to demonstrate our political cohesion, economic weight, and strategic autonomy to him.

Q - Ignorance or contempt?

A - Some in his entourage have expressed it on his behalf. But he offers Europe a considerable space and opportunity. A space, since the United States no longer wants to play a role on the international stage at the level they once did. An opportunity, because we are the world's leading economic power, so we have the means to act. Do Europeans now have the will? It will all depend on the elections that will take place in the coming months in France, Germany, and Italy.

Q - Can Mr. Trump's victory strengthen populist parties, or work against them?

A - Both are true. On one hand, Trump gives credit to populists and nationalists. He tells them: "It is possible because I am doing it." On the other hand, he gives those who are open, progressive, in the broadest sense of the term, and who are European, the opportunity to clearly present their project. In a way, he contributes to the clarification.

Q - Is this the new divide, no longer left-right, but nationalists against Europeans?

A - Yes, but that does not mean that right and left are merging. It means that at a certain moment, part of the right and part of the left can find common ground on the European question. By the way, what have we been doing in Europe since 2012? I am on the left, Mrs. Merkel is center-right, but we manage to agree on essential issues as long as we share the same European spirit.

Q - What level of threat does Russia currently represent for democracies and on the international stage?

A - What is Russia seeking? To exert influence over the areas that were once its own in the former Soviet Union. This is what it attempted in Ukraine, in particular. It wants to participate in the resolution of conflicts in the world, to its advantage. We see this in Syria. It asserts itself as a power. It tests our resistances and measures the balance of power at every moment.

At the same time, Russia uses all means to influence public opinion. It is no longer the same ideology as during the USSR, but sometimes the same methods, with added technologies. With a strategy of influence, networks, and very conservative theses in terms of morals. It also claims to defend Christianity against Islam. Let us not exaggerate, but let us remain vigilant.

I am often told, "Why don't you dialogue more often with President Putin?" But I have never stopped dialoguing with him! With the Chancellor too, by the way. And that is good. Vladimir Putin is at the head of a great country, linked to France by a long history. But talking is not yielding, it is not accepting the status quo. Talking is acting to find the right solutions. On Syria, it is clear that if the opposition is sidelined or minimized, there can be no political outcome within the framework of the negotiations in Geneva.

Here too, Europe is at a crossroads. If it is strong and united, Russia will want to maintain a lasting and balanced relationship. As for ideological operations, they must be unmasked. We must clearly state who is with whom, who is funded by whom. Why are all far-right movements more or less linked to Russia?