Interview with Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, and Mr. Shimon Peres, President of the State of Israel, on BFM TV on November 18, 2013, regarding Franco-Israeli relations, anti-Semitism, the Iranian nuclear issue, and Israeli-Palestinian negotiations.

France François Hollande · President of France

18 November 2013 · Interview on BFM TV

Context
Hollande and Peres gave a joint TV interview on BFM TV during Hollande's state visit to Israel in November 2013, discussing bilateral ties and regional issues.
Main themes
Franco-Israeli relations, anti-Semitism in France, Iranian nuclear issue, Israeli-Palestinian peace negotiations, France's role in the world, Toulouse shooting commemoration, racism and discrimination, French Jewish community, bilateral friendship and continuity
Duration
~25 min
76th percentile
Words
3,020
76th percentile
Sentences
164
84th percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
9.5
16th percentile
Syntax
2.78
20th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

164 sentences in 44 paragraphs

Ruth ELKRIEF - Good evening, Mr. President Shimon PERES.

Shimon PERES, President of the State of Israel - Good evening.

Ruth ELKRIEF - Good evening, Mr. President François HOLLANDE.

François HOLLANDE, President of the French Republic - Good evening.

Ruth ELKRIEF - Thank you very much for agreeing to our interview. It is a very strong image, a rare image, that of two Presidents side by side, one a Nobel Peace Prize laureate. Thank you for agreeing to be together. Does this mean that it is a new honeymoon between Israel and France?

Shimon PERES - My dear friend, it is not a honeymoon, or rather, it is an extremely long honeymoon since the memory goes back more than sixty years and this taste of honey remains just as sweet and fresh. I believe we are all in love with France, and we are all in love with France because of the height of its values, the depth of its history, the firmness of its politics, and also because of its long-term vision and planning. From the Champs-Élysées to a united Europe, you know that it was Napoleon who was the first to highlight the importance of equal rights. So there are many reasons for a deep friendship between us.

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, there is continuity. The President PERES mentioned it himself; he was alongside General de GAULLE with BEN GOURION at the beginning of the Fifth Republic when the State of Israel was living its early years of independence. He knew François MITTERRAND. He recalls that it was with François MITTERRAND that they discussed the Oslo Accords that led to the Nobel Peace Prize awarded to Shimon PERES. He is with me today, or rather, I am with him. So there is this continuity. France has always been a friend of Israel, and at the same time, it has always said what it believed to be the right path to peace. For being a friend of Israel also means telling your friend the truth about what the outcome should be, namely peace.

Ruth ELKRIEF - Mr. President HOLLANDE, the welcome has been particularly warm in Israel and also among the Palestinians this morning. Does this provide comfort when coming from a France that is disoriented, questioning itself, and challenging?

THE PRESIDENT - France must be aware of what it represents for the world. It may have its problems; there are economic difficulties, everyone knows them, there are efforts to be made, but France is more than a country; it is an idea. It is also a contribution to peace. France is capable of being a friend of Israel and being recognized as such, of going into Palestinian territory and being awaited for the support that my country can provide to the ongoing negotiation process. That is France, and the French should be proud of it, not for the moments we are going through, but for the role that France continues to play in the world.

Ruth ELKRIEF - Mr. President PERES, tomorrow there will be a tribute to the victims of the Toulouse shooting who are buried in Jerusalem. Are you worried, from Jerusalem's perspective, about anti-Semitism in France, for the Jewish community in France?

Shimon PERES - I believe that the welcome we are offering here to President HOLLANDE expresses how much we appreciate his courage on the most difficult subjects. And I believe that the Toulouse attacks were precisely the expression of an anti-Semitism that we must combat. President HOLLANDE gave me a very strong speech against racism this month. He also took a very firm stance regarding Iran and terrorism. So this visit is not simply about exchanging pleasantries. The friendship between Israel and France is a deep, long-lasting, and durable friendship.

Ruth ELKRIEF - Anti-Semitism still exists in France; you have acknowledged it. There have even been expressions of racism recently against one of your ministers. Who is responsible? Are there people who encourage such behavior?

THE PRESIDENT - There are those responsible, those who let themselves go to lapses in language, those who are always looking for an adversary to stigmatize, those who are suspicious of the color of the skin or the origin of their own neighbors. There are always those responsible.

Ruth ELKRIEF - Who are they?

THE PRESIDENT - What we must do when we are at the head of the State, which is my case, and with the force of law, is to pursue, fight, and eradicate racism and anti-Semitism, leaving nothing unaddressed. If we let a phrase be spoken, if we let an act be committed, a child in a school because he is Jewish being mocked, an Arab because he is Muslim being targeted for his religion, and then later, a minister because she has a certain skin color! We must be completely firm because from this ease, this lapse in language, comes a terrorist act, like the one that was committed in Toulouse. It was not so long ago; it was barely two years ago. None of these wounds are healed, and as far as I am concerned, I will never be at peace, or rather, I will never let those who side with anti-Semitism and racism be at peace. But anti-Semitism, we also have our own history, and I wanted it to be mentioned after what President CHIRAC had declared before me, particularly regarding the Vel d'Hiv roundup. We must also look at our history because it has carried this anti-Semitism, and we must not let it resurface.

Ruth ELKRIEF - President PERES mentioned it; one subject brings you together today in a very clear and strong way: Iran. Mr. President HOLLANDE, you have made very firm statements about Iran. Has France joined the camp of the Hawks? Are we not going to isolate ourselves?

THE PRESIDENT - What are we looking for? Not just France. What does the international community want? It is that there be no nuclear proliferation, that is to say, that Iran...

Ruth ELKRIEF - Are we Hawks today in France?

THE PRESIDENT - We are the country that has set demands and has been able to convince all partners, particularly those known as the group of six, of the necessity to hold Iran accountable. It is out of the question for Iran to access nuclear weapons. That Iran wants to have civil nuclear energy, we understand perfectly; it is its right. But for Iran to have the capabilities of a nuclear weapon would be a direct threat not only to the security of Israel, the region, but also to the entire world. We had to set a number of stopping points, and these stopping points have been retained in a text, and now it is on the basis of this text that the Iranians must respond.

Ruth ELKRIEF - Mr. President PERES, you appreciated this position, but nevertheless, it is said that an agreement will come. Do you believe there will be an agreement? Would you still be in favor of an agreement?

Shimon PERES - Well, first of all, allow me to respond to President HOLLANDE's remarks. We must ask ourselves why Iran wants nuclear weapons. Iran has no enemies; it is not threatened in its security. Iran has more than enough oil to cover its energy needs, and Iran remains a poor country. Why do they want to invest so much money in this nuclear development? Iran is also building long-range missiles. Why? So many burning questions. However, Iran, and particularly its former President, wishes for the death of Israel and the death of the United States!

Ruth ELKRIEF - He does not say it as clearly anymore, the new President!

Shimon PERES - That is true; however, we have seen demonstrations, and these are not things that are forgotten overnight. Indeed, the new President is quite polite and urbane, but his position remains extremely firm. He could have said that he wanted peace, that he wanted to coexist with Israel. Why this reluctance to carry a positive discourse?! And you know, for a Jew, after the Holocaust, to hear a President who denies the Holocaust, who calls for the destruction of Israel, I do not want to exaggerate, but it is something extremely frightening not only for us but I believe for the rest of the world. Moreover, aside from Iran's nuclear efforts, we know that Iran also supports a large number of terrorist groups around the world. I believe the world is tired of these policies today.

Ruth ELKRIEF - Prime Minister NETANYAHU says that a bad agreement would lead to war; would you approve of a strike on Iranian nuclear sites?

Shimon PERES - I believe that given the economic sanctions and the political pressure we are applying, there is still the possibility that Iran spares itself these unnecessary complications. Not only has Iran ceased its very bellicose statements, but I believe they have also given up their hegemonic ambition over the Middle East. The time has come for Iran to change its attitude and to resume more normal relations.

Ruth ELKRIEF - Are you opposed to it?

Shimon PERES - Opposed to what?

Ruth ELKRIEF - To an Israeli strike against Iranian nuclear facilities?

Shimon PERES - Israel, which has never threatened anyone, is threatened today. Israel only wishes to defend itself. You know, in 66 years, Israel has gone through seven wars. No other country can claim this type of experience. We are not the United States. We are undoubtedly facing forces superior to ours, and if we were to lose a single war, it would directly threaten our existence. We seek peace; we are looking for peace with the Palestinians and with the Iranians. We support the efforts of the international community to influence Iranian policy. We are serious about these efforts. We certainly hope and wish that this can be done without military intervention, but there comes a time, and that is why I admire France's current position, when one must be firm, when one can no longer turn back.

Ruth ELKRIEF - Is an agreement possible soon in Geneva?

THE PRESIDENT - The solution of negotiation is always preferable. France, along with its partners, is seeking an agreement. Not just any agreement. We have set demands, preventing access to military nuclear capabilities for Iran. If Iran accepts these demands, and I believe the sanctions are having an effect, that Iran is reflecting, then there will be an agreement, and it will be good for the entire region, for Israel, for Iran, which will end this situation, and for the whole world.

Ruth ELKRIEF - You spoke, Mr. President HOLLANDE, in Hebrew to the Israelis - "I will always be your friend," you said - in Arabic, to the Palestinians, this morning "long live Franco-Palestinian friendship," it is a gesture that was appreciated on both sides. Does this mean that you are telling the Israelis what they want to hear and the Palestinians what they want to hear?

THE PRESIDENT - I do not seek balance; I do not have two languages, one language in Israel, one language in Palestine. I try to have the same position. If we want Israelis and Palestinians to find the path to peace, it is high time; it has been nearly 65 years that they have been looking at each other, fighting each other - so for there to be peace, there must be countries, France being one of them, not alone, that can tell the Israelis what gestures must be made and what must also be accomplished by the Palestinians so that there can finally be not just another agreement but a definitive agreement that exhausts all claims and allows both peoples to live in two states with security for each.

Ruth ELKRIEF - You asked this morning, Mr. HOLLANDE, for a total and definitive halt to colonization to advance the negotiation. Are you on this line, Mr. President PERES?

Shimon PERES - First of all, allow me to say that President HOLLANDE has excellent Hebrew, for which I congratulate him, not only for the quality of his language but also for the content of his message. Let us be serious: each of us knows that we must reach an agreement and a shared solution. This is a process that began in Oslo, which must lead to a solution for our two states, which of course implies that each will have to give up some territories. I completely agree with President HOLLANDE when he says that we must take this step all at once and not in two stages. We have made enough progress to consider this, and the Israeli position, which has evolved over time, today states that these negotiations must bring a final end to all claims. We cannot stop these negotiations and then resume later - we have nine months ahead of us.

Ruth ELKRIEF - Do you believe in miracles?

Shimon PERES - It is not a miracle, I believe in reality. You know, one can always get lost in small phrases, in quotes from one person or another, but there is a reality, and I know, based on my experience, that it is this reality that we must face; we cannot afford hope. Reality does not allow us today, whether for the Palestinians or for ourselves, to consider any other solution. We cannot allow the suffering to continue.

Ruth ELKRIEF - In both countries, there is currently a climate of distrust towards Barack OBAMA and his administration regarding Iran, regarding the negotiations perhaps between Israelis and Palestinians. Do you understand this sentiment?

THE PRESIDENT - No, because here, Barack OBAMA, through John KERRY or directly, has made statements that were appropriate to call for negotiation, to also put an end to colonization. The United States has played its role perfectly, but let us not expect too much from the United States. It is always tempting either to point fingers at them while complaining about their power or to consider that they are not where they should be. But great countries, and France is one of them, must be able to determine their position as we have always done, sovereignly and freely. This also applies to Israel, which has to make these choices, taking into account, of course, the position of its friends but not simply depending on a statement, whether it be from the American President or the French President. It is based on its own interests but also on its own responsibility because Israel is a country that has made itself, even if it has been recognized by international law. This country also has a responsibility for the entire region and the world.

Shimon PERES - Allow me to respond to the President's remarks. We know roughly how to manage the issue of the settlements. We have not yet reached a perfect agreement, but we know what principle must be applied, and this principle is as follows: settlers will be offered the choice to either return home or join one of the three blocs under Israeli sovereignty where they will have the opportunity to remain. Settlers who wish to stay in place must join one of these three blocs of territory. Final negotiations still need to be completed, but know that we are in favor of a Palestinian state. We coexist today perhaps better than people sometimes believe. We have in Israel two million Arab citizens who are treated perfectly equally. I know Mahmoud ABBAS well; I have negotiated with him for a long time, and I believe that we can reach an agreement. This does not make me an optimist but a realist.

Ruth ELKRIEF - One last question, what strikes me, Mr. President HOLLANDE, since the beginning of this trip, is the tribute to your firmness, to the courage of your positions, from both sides, Israeli and Palestinian. This is not the image you have today in France; you are being criticized, there are concerns about a lack of authority. Do you plan to respond to this? Do you plan to take an initiative on this?

THE PRESIDENT - What have I done in France for the past eighteen months if not make decisions, not easy ones, not necessarily popular ones, I agree. But when it comes to restoring public accounts, it is always easier to let deficits run, which is what my predecessors did; I did not accept that. Regarding competitiveness, it is not easy, you know which political family I come from, to say: today we must support businesses; supporting businesses means supporting employment. I have done that. When it came to making a number of reforms, including social ones, which do not bring together all the French people even today, but regarding marriage for all, I did it. So every time I have to make a decision that seems necessary for my country, I do not say that it is popular, I do not say that it always convinces, but I make it. For international affairs, I did not hesitate either. Many French people were wondering what we would do in Mali, asking the question, "Is it really France's responsibility to fight against terrorism in a Sahel country?" We did it. I still pay tribute to the soldiers who are still there. It was necessary, not simply because we would have had an interest, no interest of France, but because it was the responsibility of a country like mine. I made this decision; it still matters today, which also changes the relationship that Africans have with France. I will gather all the African heads of state at the end of the year, at the beginning of December, not for them to come and ask us for support, but simply to tell them: it is up to you to ensure your own security. And believe me, the image of France in Africa has radically changed.

Ruth ELKRIEF - Thank you very much. Thank you very much, gentlemen, the two Presidents, thank you for granting us this interview. Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - Thank you.