Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the relations between France and Israel, in Tel Aviv on November 19, 2013.

France François Hollande · President of France

19 November 2013 · University of Tel Aviv, Tel Aviv

Context
Hollande addressed French nationals living in Israel and faculty at Tel Aviv University during a state visit in November 2013, reflecting on Franco-Israeli friendship.
Main themes
France-Israel relations, French Jewish community in Israel, shared history and values, Holocaust memory and responsibility, Dreyfus affair and antisemitism, French diaspora in Israel, innovation and economic partnership, cultural and human bonds, French Revolution principles, bilateral continuity across governments
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,116
77th percentile
Sentences
150
81st percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
10.2
23rd percentile
Syntax
2.97
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
22nd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 35%33%
  • Geopolitical 32%31%
  • Ceremonial 27%26%
  • Economic 4%3%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Institutional 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

150 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Mr. President of the University first,

I want to express our gratitude for the warm welcome you have extended to us, as well as for what this University of Tel Aviv is doing, which has the largest French department in Israel and engages in active cooperation. I want to acknowledge here its professors, its students, and tell them that they can be proud to be part of such an institution.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I have been in Israel since Sunday. As I mentioned to the President and the Prime Minister, we have settled here with a significant delegation: no less than six ministers, but also many personalities who wanted to accompany me to Israel and also to the Palestinian territories, and to ensure that this visit could be not only a rite, a tradition, but also a success.

I think back to the first visit made by a President of the French Republic here in Israel. It was in 1982. Since then, every President of the Republic has come to Israel, marking a continuity, a coherence, a faithful, loyal, and frank friendship. Beyond all the personalities who could, in both countries, preside over the destinies of the two Nations—beyond the political alternations in France and Israel—beyond the ups and downs of international life, which we know here have included a number of trials, there has always been this relationship, this bond between France and Israel. I therefore align myself with this lineage, with this approach made of loyalty and at the same time of understanding.

France has always stood by Israel, from the very first day. In our history, we have had so many ties! When the State of Israel was founded in 1948, it was a great joy for the Jews who finally found a home there, after the tragedy of the Holocaust. But it was also a joy for all those who had conceived the idea of a refuge, a welcome for Jews from around the world.

It was also a conception of values and principles: founded for the Jews on Judaism and for France on the principles that founded the French Revolution, then the Republic. There was even a kind of community of thought, because it was the same values that were promoted, those of dignity, justice, and freedom.

France would not be France if there had not been acts that profoundly marked History, particularly that of the Jews. For it was in 1791, you will tell me, only in 1791! that Jews were considered citizens. And then, there were also moments that raised the first questions about anti-Semitism. When the Dreyfus affair broke out and when great figures like Zola, Clemenceau, and Jaurès took the side of Dreyfus, that is to say, the side of truth, of innocence.

Many Jews around the world thought that it was in France that they could be sure for their lives. They indeed chose to come to France. That is why it was a tragedy among all tragedies to know that in France, there could have been the deportation of 76,000 Jews. It was a tragedy, yes a tragedy, to know that there was collaboration for this deportation. We always carry this memory, and I have expressed it several times, after others, to clearly show that we must not forget anything from History.

That is why, after the war, there was this passion that seized many intellectuals to express their feelings of solidarity and friendship towards Israel. The relationship between France and Israel also relies on a bond that is not just one of History or culture, even though it exists, but rather a human bond. And that is the one you represent.

That is why I wanted, at the end of this visit, since it is coming to a close, to come and meet you, who have chosen to live in Israel; you are more than 100,000, although our statistics are hesitant on this. There are those who are registered, less than 100,000; there are those who vote, I salute here the elected representatives; and then there are all those who are not registered, who live here sometimes even for a long time and whom we cannot count. 100,000, say the competent administrations. Some speak of 120,000 to 150,000.

There are 2,000 compatriots who come each year to live here in Israel. For several reasons. Some of you for Aliyah, depending on the personal, family ties you have here and of course religious ties with Israel, which bring you closer to your land but never distance you from France. And then, there are also those who are attracted by the exceptional dynamism of Israel, by this vibrant economy.

I was just testifying to this with the day of innovation, where what was presented to me was made by engineers, often French, but developed in Israel—with this shared idea with Prime Minister Netanyahu that we must have a partnership on technology, on research, and with the companies that you represent here. There are those who also come to study, often brilliantly, and whom we must support. And then, there are all those who have simply decided to settle here because it was the country that seemed to best meet their expectations.

But I know that you are also intimately linked to France. You support it by your presence here, you ensure that it can be recognized, loved, and that one can look at it for what it carries best. Of course, its culture, its language, I will return to that, but also its talents, its economy.

I jokingly said earlier, after Shimon Peres, the great Shimon Peres, mentioned what had been Israel's fortune to have nothing, to have started from nothing, I said then: our fortune in France is to have everything and to want to ensure that we are always capable of mobilizing all our resources, all our talents, all our assets, to be a great country.

One can be a great country because one is pioneering, as is the case here in Israel. And then, one is a great country because one is aware that one comes from far, from a great history, that one has all the conditions to succeed, and that it is simply a matter of having faith, faith in one's future, faith in one's abilities, faith in one's youth, faith also in the unity of our country. You know it well, even if you are geographically distant, you are informed.

It is a country that is capable of dividing itself, of quarreling, but that in great moments and especially in great causes, and the economy is one of them, has the capacity to weigh in the world. The will to defend values is what brings us together. We therefore have, Israel and France, so many common points! You are precisely one of them. We also have the Jewish community of France, which is one of the largest in the world, the largest in Europe. I salute here its representatives, who have accompanied me throughout these three days.

We know what we owe to the Jews of France in our history. Even today, talents, commitments, successes that serve culture, science, and the economy. We also know how demanding it is, and it is right, regarding its security—how ardent it is in wanting the Republic to ensure safety for everyone, dignity.

Yes, this community, but not just this community, all our fellow citizens must be mobilized against anti-Semitism, against this evil, which one believes, after what happened with the Holocaust, that one believes is always extinguished, defeated, vanquished, and which resurfaces surreptitiously, sometimes violently, in other circumstances under the mask of terrorism.

We must return to the essentials, recall what the Holocaust was. I went with the Prime Minister to Yad Vashem. It was on the very first day of my visit, on Sunday. I saw in the photographs the site of Drancy, which reminds us that it was from France that Jews were deported. I saluted, or rather the Israeli authorities saluted the work done by Serge Klarsfeld, and many others, to bear witness to what had happened and to also seek those who had committed these barbaric and atrocious acts.

We must return to history, to memory; otherwise, we cannot combat anti-Semitism with the necessary weapons for generations that have not known any of this. Combating anti-Semitism means not tolerating any weakness, any deviation, any excess. We see, alas, today words being freed. They affect Jews; they also concern others in the population who do not have the right religion or the right skin color. No weakness towards anti-Semitism. The greatest firmness against those who propagate, against those who commit these words and these acts.

There is no difference, by the way, between words and acts. Words always prepare acts. I also wanted to come and pay my respects in the great cemetery of Tel Aviv to remember Jonathan Sandler, Gabriel Sandler, Arieh Sandler, Myriam Monsonégo, who were killed, murdered. It was on March 19, 2012, in Toulouse. I also thought of Ilan Halimi, who was kidnapped, tortured, and ultimately murdered by his captors.

We must always extirpate this evil, and I wanted to affirm here, once again, and you do not doubt it—our determination to combat it. I also think of your own security, you who live here. Prime Minister Netanyahu has repeatedly reminded me, that is to say, all the time—you know his reserve, his restraint; when he wants to say something, he does not use many words—to recall this demand for security. We share it.

You know France's positions. I have reiterated them, particularly regarding the peace process: the right for Palestinians to have a state and the right for Israelis to live in security, peace being precisely the assurance of security, provided that it is guaranteed.

Here too, we stand by your side, because I know that many live in southern Israel in Sderot, Ashkelon, Beer-Sheva and are exposed to rocket fire from Gaza. I also think of one of our compatriots, David Gritz, who was killed; he was 24 years old, in the 2002 attack against the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. We forget nothing. I also think of Gilad Shalit, who was held for so many months.

So, we must also ensure that France takes its responsibilities. What does it mean to take responsibility in the Middle East? It means that, regarding Syria, I could not accept that a country—what am I saying? a regime, because I do not want to confuse Bashar al-Assad with his people, who are indeed revolting against him—could use chemical weapons, the very ones that were used, we are going to commemorate the centenary during World War I, which had been prohibited by all nations.

Yes, it is this weapon that was used against children in a neighborhood of Damascus. I spoke out against this use of chemical weapons, but I did not stop there. Indignation is often the most convenient thing. I said that we were even ready to use military pressure to ensure that these weapons could be destroyed. And ultimately, thanks to the action we were able to take, thanks to the action we were able to exert, the United States and France, an agreement was reached to destroy the chemical weapons. We must be vigilant and verify whether the commitments are being honored.

In the same way, being responsible in the Near East means demanding that there be a political solution in Syria. Otherwise, we already know the result: the extremists who have settled there and the refugees who have fled and destabilized the neighboring countries: Lebanon, Jordan.

Taking responsibility in the Middle East also means ensuring that Iran does not acquire nuclear weapons. Because that threatens the security of Israel, yes, of the region, surely, but also endangers the entire world. In the negotiations that took place, France has upheld these demands and gathered its partners around this position. Then, if an agreement is to be reached, it is better that there be negotiation than the path of conflict. It is on the basis that we have established ourselves that we will have Iran's response.

Taking responsibility also means telling Israelis and Palestinians what we expect from the peace process. It means saying it in the same way, with the same words and the same language to both sides. Saying that there are necessarily concessions to be made, that it is surely an opportunity, as has been said, "historic." One must be cautious; we invoke History without always knowing exactly when it accelerates or when it stops. But in any case, it is an opportunity, a chance, for there to be peace around the solution of two states.

We have the possibility to speak to one another. I had frank conversations with the ministers and also privately with Valérie and Sarah Benyamin Netanyahu that were friendly and allowed us to situate the moment we were in. If efforts converge on the Israeli side with gestures—some have been made, and the one we are waiting for is the definitive halt to colonization. Other gestures have been made that were not the easiest to make; I think of the release of prisoners.

Other gestures are expected from the Palestinians; these gestures also involve taking realistic solutions so that there can be a peace agreement. In all the discussions I have had with the Prime Minister, with the President here, with the President of the Palestinian Authority in Ramallah, yes, France has been able to speak and be appreciated by both sides for its role.

Sometimes, even here I imagine, you are asked: does France matter? Does France weigh in? One can always have the weakness to imagine this when one is at the head of the State. No, one must have the strength to believe it when one is a French citizen, when one thinks about what our country is, what it represents in the eyes of the world, how it is awaited, how it is hoped for, how also our language is spoken.

I wanted to say a word about Francophonie. Israel is a French-speaking country: 10% of the population speaks French. This is considerable! There are many countries that are members of the International Organization of La Francophonie, where this rate does not exist! But we do not ask for a passing exam. Not even for French in France, including for the highest office of the State!

But what I want to affirm here, above all, is that language is not simply a wealth that we share; it is also a link, the promotion of values, of principles. You also contribute to making French spoken. I said that here we are in a great university where there is a very important French department, which has welcomed many prominent figures. I will not name them, because, even when they have passed away, one always angers their descendants for not having mentioned them. But it is true that all the great French personalities have come to Israel and notably, here, to this university.

I want to finally say how France continues, despite a number of budgetary difficulties, because you know that we must reduce deficits, that we must not raise taxes too much—I understood that this is true everywhere—and that we must reduce spending. But all spending sometimes appears essential: to maintain cultural institutes, to ensure that our presence can be everywhere, where there is precisely no other.

For example, yesterday, there was a conversation that could be established between two young people from Gaza, two young Palestinians, who said that for them the only chance they had, in fact, to access more than French culture and language to freedom, was to still have a French cultural institute in Gaza. This is France too; it carries its message everywhere in the world.

I salute all those who contribute to this, I also salute all the educational institutions that are here in Israel. There, I will name them because it is a ranking; it has a "prize-giving" aspect, but I brought nothing! The French school Marc-Chagall in Tel Aviv, the Franco-Israeli high school Raymond-Leven in Merk Israel, the French institute Romain-Gary in Jerusalem, the French research center in Jerusalem, the cultural centers, not to mention the role that certain institutions like the France-Israel Foundation can play and all the links it can establish. I salute all its representatives, all those who accompany me and who contribute precisely to this bond of friendship between France and Israel.

I will conclude because I do not want to keep you; I have all my time, it has already been 3 days since they have not seen me in France! I do not want to create disputes and protests for my return, so I will not rush, but I will try to respect the schedule.

I simply want to express to you the happiness that this visit has brought to all those who participated. I have no doubt about the delegation that accompanied me. There were moments of joy, great joy—of emotion regarding certain places like Yad Vashem, the cemetery this morning—but also great joy—the joy of being received as I was at the Knesset—great joy also to have these conversations with the leaders of Israel.

President PERES, for us, is the memory, the memory of the State of Israel; he is one of its pioneers, one of the founding fathers, the memory of the relationship between France and Israel. When I have a doubt about a French political personality, I call Shimon PERES; he has surely met them, he knows their background. He was even able to greet, yesterday at the state dinner, a forgotten personality—he thought he would please me—who was Guy MOLLET. This tells you how much Shimon PERES has remained a socialist, in fact! It was a joy to be with Shimon PERES, to listen to him again this morning, speaking about what the Israelis have made of their country.

Yes, it was also with the Prime Minister important moments where we talked, of course, about peace, where we talked about Iran but also about what the economy can do to bring us closer, about the innovation that must be our common heritage.

It was also joyful moments to be received, as I was, by the Palestinians who see us as those who can make the link, build the bridge, make peace. So, if we were welcomed this way, we owe it to you. It is thanks to you, French people who live here, in Israel, some even in the Palestinian Territories. Thank you for what you do for France. France is here with you today. Thank you!