Interview with Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, in "L'Express" on November 24, 2015, on the fight against climate change.

France François Hollande · President of France

24 November 2015 · Interview in L'Express on the fight against climate change

Context
Hollande gave an interview to L'Express on November 24, 2015, defending France's commitment to hosting COP21 despite the recent Paris terror attacks.
Main themes
COP21 climate agreement, fight against climate change, November 13 Paris attacks, terrorism and climate change linkage, France's global leadership, international climate coalition, binding climate agreement, IPCC warnings, French environmental tradition, Paris as symbolic host city
Duration
~34 min
87th percentile
Words
4,138
87th percentile
Sentences
257
93rd percentile
Readability
54
75th percentile
Grade
9.6
17th percentile
Syntax
2.68
12th percentile
Vocabulary
2.22
54th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

257 sentences in 65 paragraphs

Do the attacks of November 13 also endanger a climate agreement? How can we remobilize under such conditions?

I wanted to maintain the world's appointment with itself. And these tragic circumstances give an even more decisive meaning to this conference. Never has Paris hosted so many heads of state and government (140 have confirmed their presence). Never has the stakes been higher. Never has the obligation to act been so great. France will never renounce what it is: a great nation that speaks to the world and is capable of bringing it together to decide its destiny. Yes, it will triumph over dangers! But we owe our children more than a world freed from terrorism. We must preserve the planet from our own missteps and build a future of hope and progress.

What is at stake in this conference is humanity. Man is always his own enemy. Terrorism reminds us of this. It is up to us to rise to the height of our own history to determine our future. I know that citizens will have the will to mobilize to put pressure on the leaders gathered in Paris, but the planned demonstrations cannot, in the context we have known since November 13, be confirmed.

The NGOs that initiated them have regretted this but, I am sure, have understood it. Their commitment is intact, and it will likely be even stronger, as evidenced by the extraordinary diversity of initiatives planned on the agenda of solutions. Many events will still take place in Île-de-France, in closed and secure venues.

- How are the fight against climate change and the fight against terrorism linked?

But it is the same fight. One that consists, on the one hand, of protecting humanity from the deadly actions carried out by the "Islamic State" (Daesh), which strike, far more than France, the entire world. And on the other hand, of preserving the planet from our own inconsistencies, which can be, tomorrow, sources of conflict and war. With the same urgency. The fanaticism that kills today. And the indifference that consumes our planet. France is therefore on the front line. And it wants to be at the head of the broadest coalition for life.

- Just a few months after your election in 2012, you decided that France would host COP 21 in Paris, when no other major country was in the running. Did you fully grasp the magnitude of the challenge that awaited you?

We were coming out of a huge failure, that of Copenhagen in 2009. A great nation like France had to rise to the challenge. I believed that our country, capable of speaking to all the states of the world, could take on the responsibility of hosting this conference. Not just as a host country, but as a nation long committed to environmental issues. I made this decision after attending the "Rio + 20" Conference in June 2012, in the very first month of my term, which was intended to commemorate the holding of the first climate summit in 1992.

This mobilization had led to tangible results, notably the Kyoto Protocol, but then other issues and other leaders had prioritized other matters, and the cause had weakened even as expert reports, particularly those from the IPCC, showed us the extent and speed of degradation. Faced with this situation, there were two possible options. Either hope that another major country would step up, or take on this responsibility ourselves.

I knew that Paris represented a symbol. I did not imagine that the attacks of November 13 would remind us of this with such intensity. Our capital has, at certain moments in history, been the capital of the world. It is here that the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen was proclaimed in 1789, and where a revolution was launched that ignored borders. It is still in Paris, in December 2015, that the rights of humanity must be inscribed. And it will indeed be a kind of revolution if almost all the states of the world approve a binding agreement that includes obligations and financial commitments.

- Is this also a personal challenge for you?

There is a French tradition in the field of the environment. President Valéry Giscard d'Estaing was one of the first leaders to convene a conference in the early 1970s around the report of the Club of Rome, which questioned the dogma of growth at all costs. This awareness was swept away by the oil crises. Then, François Mitterrand personally invested in the preparation of the Rio conference. Ségolène Royal was already the Minister of the Environment.

Then Jacques Chirac, sensitive to the calls of Nicolas Hulot, delivered a speech at the Earth Summit in Johannesburg in September 2002: "Our house is burning and we are looking elsewhere." This phrase is still in all our memories. The tax on airline tickets, decided at his initiative, also showed his willingness to act at the global level. Finally, Nicolas Sarkozy was the initiator of the Grenelle of the Environment.

France has therefore been consistent. And it would be too simple for me to consider that nothing was happening before. To be able to speak on behalf of France, one must speak on behalf of its history. As far as I am concerned, I have never had any doubt on the subject. And my conviction was further strengthened when, at the very beginning of my term, I received the experts from the IPCC. They presented their reports, maps, and precise assessments. Their findings were devastating: melting glaciers, rising oceans, submerged islands, migrations... I then decided to engage our country in the energy transition, to work with Angela Merkel to redirect Europe and to bring the climate issue to the global level. We are there.

- In September, you raised an alarm, explaining that we were not making sufficient progress in the negotiations leading up to COP 21. Today you seem more optimistic. Why?

Because a true awareness has emerged. There is not a country I have visited in the past three years where climate change has not been identified as a risk of catastrophe. No region is spared. And even the cynical paradox that suggested that the countries that had been the most predatory were the least exposed to climate danger is no longer verified. We are all concerned. Both coastal countries and mountainous areas, the North and the South. Everywhere, temperatures are rising. 2015 is already shaping up to be the hottest year ever recorded in our country, and I do not forget that the Southeast experienced dramatic weather events a few weeks ago.

I also remind you that the vast majority of refugees are fleeing the consequences of warming. 80% of these refugees in the world are hosted in the countries of the Global South. Thus, even if we were to resolve the issue of Syria, we would still be faced with migrations of millions of people forced into nomadism due to the impossibility of cultivating their land. These disorders could only lead to new conflicts. It is therefore not just a matter of preserving our environment, but also of maintaining the great balances of the planet. And of fighting against hunger in the world, which still affects 850 million people.

The gravity of these threats allows us to understand that most countries - from the poorest to the richest - have now understood the importance of these issues, starting, of course, with those whose territory risks being simply erased from the surface of the globe.

- Nevertheless, there remains the deafening silence of India, Russia, and oil-producing countries...

162 state contributions have been sent to the conference secretariat. They represent 90% of CO2 emissions. One could therefore say that the conference is settled, since most countries have expressed their commitments, at least on paper. Those who have not responded are mainly hydrocarbon producers. Rather than putting them on trial - I remind you that we are also buyers of their oil - we must support them in the transition to clean energy.

Regarding Russia, from my discussions with Vladimir Putin, I am confident about the support it will provide to the process, first because it suffers like others from warming, and second because it mainly sells gas, which is less central than coal in the negotiations. China, the second largest emitter of CO2 in the world, uses coal massively, but its population can no longer bear the ravages of pollution. The Chinese president is fully aware of this. During our meeting at the beginning of November, he agreed to introduce a review clause into the agreement to regularly assess the efforts of each party to limit warming to 2 degrees by the end of the century. Political balance there goes through climate balance.

As for India, Prime Minister Modi does not want the development of his country to be hindered by overly strict constraints. He believes that he should not have to make financial commitments and must ensure that the conference will organize a transfer of technologies from the North to the South. He wants to make India a model in solar energy. We must support him in this endeavor.

- When you hear Barack Obama declare, "Thanks to American leadership, we will sign a great agreement in Paris," do you prefer to focus only on the second part of the sentence?

I prefer that we argue about leadership rather than about the agreement itself. But at COP 21, it will not be enough to utter good words; we will also need to commit to binding targets. However, I know that institutional rules can prevent certain governments from signing treaties as long as they must refer to their Parliament. Similarly, if the agreement is to be binding, it must also be universal.

Emerging countries cannot remain outside the framework; those that emit the most CO2 have duties from which they cannot exempt themselves, regardless of their level of development. Finally, wealthy countries must set an example in terms of financing and industrial choices. In this regard, Barack Obama sent a very positive signal before coming to Paris by refusing to authorize the giant oil pipeline project between Canada and the United States.

- For now, the contributions lead us on a trajectory of about 3 degrees of warming by 2100. However, the IPCC has warned that beyond 2 degrees, our societies would not be able to adapt without drama to the new climate reality. How can we go further?

A single degree of difference may seem small, but it means droughts, storms, floods. Political risks as well. On these issues that touch on the very long term, the illusion is to think that we have time and to imagine that science will eventually find solutions to what politics has failed to resolve. But while technological progress can accelerate the transition, it cannot replace it. No invention, however revolutionary, can repair the damage caused by climate change.

Wisdom requires that we act right now, and with the utmost disinterest, since present generations will be called upon to make efforts whose results they will not see. Political leaders must decide with that same disinterest. Those who will judge us are not yet born. But they will be severe, even if we are no longer there to hear them! If there is a cause that demands dedication and transcendence, it is indeed that of the climate.

- So, what is the solution to meet the 2-degree target?

First, acknowledge the current commitments, then consider that the general agreement engages all stakeholders in a differentiated manner. Next, introduce a mechanism to evaluate, revise, and correct trajectories to ensure that we do not exceed these 2 degrees. It is not a matter of postponing the problem to future Climate conferences, but of creating a regular appointment to ensure that the Paris agreement will indeed achieve the set objective in reality and over time.

This review clause is essential. It has been accepted by President Xi Jinping. His example will be followed by others. We have even agreed that this new assessment would be established as early as 2017-2018, before the binding mechanisms come into effect, that is to say, in 2020. This is a significant advance.

- All this without jeopardizing economic development...

This is where the main risk of blockage exists. Emerging countries - India, Brazil, China, South Africa... - do not want the fight against climate change to hinder their economies; they consider that they are indeed significant CO2 emitters, but that, relative to their population, their responsibility is low. Moreover, they argue that historically their role in CO2 production since the beginning of the industrial era is limited. But how can we grant them a right to pollute on the grounds that they need to catch up?

These arguments have their limits. On the other hand, we must build a system that can provide them with funding and access to new technologies to reduce the fossil fuel stage. India and China are already engaged in renewable energies and are set to become global leaders in this field. Africa is doing the same. It has also decided on a plan. And France is ready, along with Europe, to promote access to electricity for all Africans. This is a human issue. It is also an issue of growth and the environment.

Finally, we must also take into account the most vulnerable countries. They believe that nothing can be asked of them since they are the first victims. They demand emergency measures and do not want to wait, as they fear complicated mechanisms that would delay decisions. They are ready to block an agreement if it is too timid.

- How can we avoid a deadlock?

The solution lies in financing. It has been agreed to mobilize 100 billion dollars per year starting in 2020, in order to help them adapt as well as to mitigate the effects of global warming. But where will these 100 billion come from? From public funds and private institutions, from loans and grants. Today, we are not very far from reaching this goal, but I do not want an illusion to be compounded by a deception if nothing is clear regarding the source of these funds, their destination, and their sustainability.

To set an example, France has decided to increase its share of development aid dedicated to climate from 3 to 5 billion in 2020. At the multilateral level, an organization - for example, the World Bank - will have to guarantee and authenticate this financing. If there is not real transparency regarding the reality and functioning of the fund, there will be no agreement.

- How do you see your role during COP 21? Will you be a sort of referee or are you ready to bang your fist on the table to achieve real progress?

COP 21 operates according to UN procedures, that is to say, by consensus. A handful of countries can therefore block everything. There is no vote, and in fact, a majority decision would not make much sense, since the minority would not feel bound by collective decisions. Finally, the president does not have a casting vote, so France cannot force things: it must convince.

This is what Laurent Fabius has been doing for over a year. And his role will be crucial at the conference. He will have to work with the representatives of each country to improve the text prepared by the negotiators. He will have to lift their reservations and take into account the different starting points. To support his approach, I preferred to invite heads of state and government at the beginning of the conference. They must provide the necessary political impetus. In Copenhagen, they came at the end. It was too late! It was a failure.

- Would an agreement in Paris be credible without monitoring of CO2 emission reduction commitments?

No. And the monitoring methods will be part of the agreement. Few governments accept that independent institutions verify compliance with their obligations. I first raised this issue with the Chinese when Prime Minister Li Keqiang came to Paris in June to officially present his country's contribution to COP 21 here at the Élysée. I sensed his reservations, but it cannot be an intrusion. Thus, President Xi Jinping was able to accept a principle of evaluation, and China itself has imposed a ten-year plan to develop an "ecological civilization."

I also know the power of international public opinion. Today, everyone is informed about the situation of others and can understand that the disaster that occurred on the other side of the planet heralds the next one in their own region. Everyone sees images of melting glaciers in Iceland, burning forests in California, pollution peaks in Beijing, submerged Pacific coasts, terrible hurricanes in Santo Domingo, the ecological disaster experienced by Vanuatu, or the devastating storms that hit the Philippines, droughts and floods in Europe.

No one can say they did not know. In the absence of a manifestation of the world's citizens in Paris, I suggest a mobilization of social networks. Nicolas Hulot has already shown how effective this weapon can be.

- Is your position not weakened by a Europe that tolerates diesel, a France that has backtracked on the eco-tax, and which has an agriculture that is still far too polluting?

Climate change raises the question of our food. If arable land is becoming increasingly scarce, will we be able to continue feeding the population? Will we need to accelerate intensive production, knowing that these methods exacerbate soil depletion, and thus warming? The agricultural dimension is on the agenda of COP21, with this imperative: produce more and produce better. The solution lies in agroecology, as soils have a significant capacity for carbon storage, and in the circular economy, which, instead of wasting, turns waste into a resource and an outlet for new jobs and new activities.

EU aid must also continue to evolve so that it is linked - even more than today - to the quality of products and respect for the environment. Finally, there is the question of biotechnology, which could help combat climate change. That is to say, help nature adapt to human predation. We cannot dismiss this hypothesis, but we must frame it with the help of scientists to prohibit certain manipulations.

- And on diesel?

This fuel does not contribute more to warming than gasoline, but, due to the level of particles it emits, it can alter air quality. Europe must set an example. It has been decided that the standards will be more stringent and their enforcement more rigorous. As for the eco-tax, it consisted of charging heavy goods vehicles that used certain routes. The complexity of this system led to misunderstandings, and the government replaced it with a simpler system, which consists of increasing the tax on diesel for all heavy goods vehicles. This system will yield more than the eco-tax, and the ecological objective will be preserved.

Moreover, this government has also begun to gradually reduce the tax gap between gasoline and diesel. It has also introduced the climate-energy contribution, which taxes pollution rather than work. At the European level, the financial transaction tax could be used to help finance major energy-saving programs.

- Another major lever in the fight against climate change: the price of carbon. Today, a ton of carbon emitted is taxed at only 7 dollars on average, which does not encourage companies to invest in less polluting practices...

That is correct. The goal is to gradually set a global carbon price at a sufficiently high level to encourage better behaviors. A number of countries have already established a carbon market: Europe, China, a few Canadian states... Certainly, the price remains low, but these initiatives have the merit of existing. The generalization and harmonization of the carbon market are not on the official agenda of the conference, but I do not despair that heads of state and government will express its usefulness in their final declaration.

Already, companies and investment funds have agreed on the relevance of this solution. This is the condition for accelerating choices in favor of renewable energies and industries that will be both cleaner and more profitable. In France, the energy transition law has already planned a significant increase in the price of a ton of carbon, which will rise to 22 euros next year and should reach 100 euros by 2030.

Furthermore, in Europe, we will improve our carbon market while ensuring that the most virtuous countries do not become less competitive. But very quickly, a company that consumes less CO2 than its competitors will have a decisive competitive advantage.

- As COP 21 approaches, companies are communicating a lot about environmental excellence, but this often falls under the category of announcements, what is called greenwashing. Do you think the business community is really changing?

Is it greenwashing? I do not know, but one thing is certain: greenbashing, which consisted of mocking ecologically virtuous initiatives, is well and truly over. I do not think that large companies will be able to continue polluting shamelessly while maintaining a good image. The example of Volkswagen has shown that a lack of transparency - let alone cheating - comes at a cost.

Moreover, situations are evolving. In 2012, companies in the CAC 40 expressed their concerns about American shale gas, which created a distortion of competition between Europe and the United States. Three years later, this debate is less acute because the price of oil has fallen and shale gas, economically and ecologically contested, has lost much of its attractiveness. The companies that alerted me on the subject yesterday are now the most engaged in COP 21. Ecology is becoming an argument for growth, quality, and competitiveness.

- Should this evolution of consciousness among leaders, businesses, and citizens not call for, from the leftist you are, a redefinition of political ecology? Could it be the basis of a neo-socialism?

To paraphrase General de Gaulle, I would say that everyone will be ecologist or the world will no longer be. Why? Because the quality of life on the planet depends on the quality of our environment. The political debate does not disappear for all that. Because there are several possible methods to achieve the desired result. One trusts the market, the price, the signals revealed by scarcity to influence choices, and also to allow for economic and ecological optimum. This is the liberal response.

The other posits that it is the intervention of public power, whether European or global, that will allow for faster and more effective action. There are therefore differences in approach, both in philosophy and in instruments. But ecology also concerns the behavior of each individual, and there we need the social sciences to establish our priorities. What is more important: the present or the future? Consumption or preservation? My life or that of my children? My territory or the planet as a whole?

These are eminently ethical choices. Thus, politics can find new foundations through the climate challenge. These issues bring us back to the question of the collective. Not the collective that oppresses, but the one that liberates, since it is from the choices of others that our own future depends, which is the most beautiful definition of solidarity. To consider that ecology can only be partisan would reduce it to a sensitivity that is otherwise legitimate, but it must permeate all our decisions. I would also like to pay tribute to all those who, in the 1970s, often a bit alone, spoke of the planetary risks of warming amid sarcasm.

I also think of the contempt faced by those who called for degrowth to defend another way of growing! Today, green growth is recognized as the main driver of tomorrow's activity. Politically, I would have preferred there to be ecologists in the government at the time of COP 21. But I made sure to work with all forces and all personalities, because it is together that we must prepare for this meeting.

- Many see COP 21 as an opportunity, a celebration. But with its 45,000 VIPs, its official processions, its sirens, does it not risk giving ammunition to climate skeptics and feeding populism?

There will be inconveniences. Part of the traffic will be interrupted on the day of the conference. There will be security measures. Who could deny their necessity in these circumstances? There will be official processions as Paris will host 140 heads of state and government. There will be grumblers, protesters, fatalists, and skeptics. But what do these movements of discontent weigh on the scale of humanity, if Paris is to be not only the capital of the world but the city of a historic agreement for the future of our children?