Interview with Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, in "Le Monde" on August 30, 2013, on the use of chemical weapons in Syria and on the reforms initiated since the beginning of his term.

France François Hollande · President of France

30 August 2013

Context
Hollande addressed Le Monde on August 30, 2013, outlining France's evidence of Assad's chemical attack and its readiness to join military action against Syria.
Main themes
Chemical weapons use in Syria, French military intervention, Syrian civil war, international coalition building, UN Security Council deadlock, humanitarian crisis, regime accountability, Russia's role, comparison with Iraq intervention, France's foreign policy, proportionate military response
Duration
~22 min
71st percentile
Words
2,671
71st percentile
Sentences
191
88th percentile
Readability
54
73rd percentile
Grade
9.2
13th percentile
Syntax
2.68
12th percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
57th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

191 sentences in 58 paragraphs

Does France have proof of the use of chemical weapons on August 21 in Damascus?

The question is no longer whether chemical weapons were used on August 21 in the suburbs of Damascus. It is an established fact. Even the Syrian authorities no longer deny it. No, the question is to know who the authors of this horrific act are. France has a body of evidence pointing to the responsibility of the regime. First, several chemical attacks had already taken place in Syria. But the one on August 21, due to its scale and effects, marks a change in nature. It is established that the opposition does not possess any of these weapons, while all stockpiles are controlled by Bashar al-Assad. Furthermore, the targeted neighborhood was not hit by chance, nor inadvertently: it is a key area for the regime's control of communication routes to Damascus. Finally, everything was done in the hours following these atrocities to erase the traces through bombings whose origin we are sure of.

What would be the legality of military action?

The 1925 protocol prohibits the use of chemical weapons. Gassing a population constitutes, as Ban Ki-moon himself said, a crime against humanity. That is why the UN has been seized. And an inspection mission has been sent to the site. But there is a fear that, regardless of the evidence, the Security Council will be prevented from taking the necessary resolution for action. It has been blocked for two years on the Syrian issue.

And if it remains blocked?

The chemical massacre in Damascus cannot and must not go unpunished. Otherwise, it would risk escalating the situation, normalizing the use of these weapons and threatening other countries. I am not in favor of an international intervention aimed at "liberating" Syria or overthrowing the dictator, but I believe that a stop must be put to a regime that is committing irreparable harm to its population.

What are the war aims?

I will not speak of a war, but of the sanctioning of a monstrous violation of human rights. It will serve as a deterrent. Not acting would mean allowing things to continue. The civil war in Syria has lasted too long. It has caused 100,000 deaths. France took initiatives very early on. It brought together the "Friends of Syria" in the summer of 2012 and recognized the National Coalition as the sole legitimate representative of the Syrian people. It provided political support, then material and humanitarian aid, and more recently military means in accordance with our European commitments. Today, a step in horror has been crossed. And it is the response, not inertia, that will impose a political solution.

What form can the intervention take?

All options are on the table. France wants a proportionate and firm action against the Damascus regime.

Which countries would be likely to intervene?

If the Security Council is prevented from acting, a coalition will form. It must be as broad as possible. It will rely on the Arab League, which condemned the crime and alerted the international community. It will have the support of the Europeans. But there are few countries that have the capacity to impose a sanction through appropriate means. France is one of them. It is ready. It will decide its position in close consultation with its allies.

The first parliament consulted, the British, refused the principle of an operation in Syria. Can we act without our traditional English allies?

Yes. Each country is sovereign to participate or not in an operation. This applies to the United Kingdom as well as to France. I will have a thorough exchange with Barack Obama today.

How does this choice differ from what has been reproached to American neoconservatives regarding military intervention?

In Iraq, the intervention took place even though no evidence had been provided regarding the existence of weapons of mass destruction. In Syria, unfortunately, chemical weapons have been used. In fact, the operation in Iraq aimed to overthrow the regime. Nothing of the sort for the response envisaged in Syria. France, since the beginning of the civil war, has stubbornly sought a political solution. What has changed since August 21 is the chemical massacre. It is a red line defined a year ago that has been crossed. Undeniably.

Libya, Mali, Syria: is France not risking multiplying interventionism?

In 2011, I approved France's engagement in Libya. But I regretted that its consequences were not controlled. In January 2013, I made the decision for an intervention in Mali. I note that it was effective, coordinated with the Africans, and carried out in a short time. It led to free and uncontested elections. For Syria, I will ensure that the international community's response puts an end to the escalation of violence. Each situation is different. For each of them, France takes its responsibilities in the name of its values and principles.

How to manage the relationship with Russia in the aftermath of the strikes?

Russia refuses to admit that the regime could have committed this abomination, fearing that in the event of Bashar al-Assad's collapse, there would be chaos. I therefore want to convince them that the worst is the current situation. It is this situation that fosters the rise of jihadist groups. I have always told President Putin that I do not question the privileged ties his country has long maintained with Syria. And it is in Russia's interest to reach a political solution as soon as possible.

Are you confident of public opinion's support?

When I decided to send our armed forces to Mali, the French were not yet fully aware of the extent of terrorism in the Sahel. Today, they are proud that our armies liberated a friendly country. What I owe them at all times is the truth about France's commitments, their legitimacy, without hiding the threats to our own security. There is no question of dragging our country into an adventure. But what is the greater danger: punishing a country that has used chemical weapons or allowing a desperate clan to have the temptation to do it again? Chemical weapons are a danger to humanity.

Do you exclude strikes before Parliament has had a chance to express itself?

I exclude making a decision before having all the elements that would justify it. I have convened Parliament for an extraordinary session on Wednesday. It will debate the situation in Syria. And if I have engaged France, the government will inform it of the means and objectives pursued, in accordance with Article 35 of the Constitution.

Do you exclude an intervention before the inspectors leave Syria?

Yes.

You regularly refer to the fragility of French society, to the possibility that it may crack. Is that why you refuse to reform it deeply, preferring the logic of small steps, as is the case with pensions?

Never, in fifteen months, has France undertaken as many structural reforms. When you align the competitiveness pact, the European budget treaty, the agreement on job security, the banking law, and now pensions, I do not see what allows you to speak of "small steps." It is rather "good strides," if I judge by the path traveled. What also matters is the destination. I want, by the end of my term, for France to be fairer, its economy stronger, and our society more harmonious. This method seems more relevant to me than that of haste and brutality.

Is it a structural reform when we continue to make taxpayers bear the deficit of the civil service system and do not challenge special regimes?

A lot has already been asked of civil servants: freezing the index point, stabilizing staff levels, limiting categorical measures to the most modest. Furthermore, public agents will take their share in the general effort since their rate and duration of contributions will follow what is decided for all employees.

Regarding special regimes, there are two possibilities: either a reform was initiated by my predecessor, and then why make another? Or this reform had only a limited impact and was merely a smokescreen, in which case the opposition must admit it. If the government were to challenge the commitment made in 2008 to these employees, it would risk having many people in the streets without being sure of carrying the reform through to the end.

Is there in the country, as your Minister of Economy, Pierre Moscovici, said, a "fiscal fatigue"?

In the stability program presented by the previous majority, the level of mandatory levies was to reach nearly 46% of national wealth by 2015! Let us not attribute to the Ayrault government what was decided by others. But I recognize that in the fall of 2012, in the face of the extent of the deficits, an additional effort was asked of the French. Particularly from the most privileged, but not only. Thanks to the commitment to substantial savings, the time has come to make an earlier tax pause than originally planned. That is why the option of the CSG has been ruled out. And the income tax scale will be re-indexed. For businesses, Jean-Marc Ayrault's government has committed not to increase the cost of labor and not to cut into their margins. We will not take back with one hand what we have given them with the other through the Tax Credit for Competitiveness and Employment (CICE).

You wanted the government to work on France in 2025. But how would you summarize your vision of the country in ten years in three words?

In three words? Sovereignty, first, because we must always be able to decide for ourselves. Excellence, next, because we must - in what we consider to be essential sectors - demonstrate that we are the best in globalization. And finally unity, because what threatens us is a form of civic, social, and territorial disintegration.

You announced in the spring that France and Germany would take initiatives on the European front. Not much has happened. What are your intentions?

Elections are coming in Germany. The chancellor who emerges victorious from the election will be there for four years, the time that is still given to me. We therefore have the necessary duration to take initiatives. I see three. 1/ Put content into the European project on energy, new technologies, and defense. 2/ Improve the functioning of the eurozone, with better coordination of economic policies and tax and social harmonization, with the establishment of a minimum wage. 3/ Create a pioneering Europe that can operate with variable geometry depending on the subjects. There is no need to amend the treaties to achieve this.

As the European elections approach in May 2014, how can these projects stem the rise of populism?

Under three conditions. That we make Europe a space for growth and protection, which would prevent populism from blaming European construction for our failures. That we restore confidence in the European destiny, because when France is pessimistic, Europe cannot be in a joyful mood. That is why the Union cannot be content to be a management structure with a derisory budget and rules perceived as constraints: it must become a project for the benefit of the peoples again. Finally, Europe must show that it is useful to the world. What has struck me the most in the past fifteen months is that it has to apologize constantly. Apologize for the euro crisis, but also for not having growth, for not taking political initiatives. I do not want a Europe that apologizes. I want a Europe that speaks out, a Europe that is a reference, a model. A Europe proud of itself.

In the long term, could this Europe be federal?

I do not yet see enough willingness to participate in a common ideal. I do not believe in the United States of Europe. Let us start by ensuring that the states are united for Europe.

Harlem Désir, the first secretary of the PS, now speaks of the need to fight against a "right-wing bloc" uniting the right and the far right. For you, are the UMP and the FN comparable?

I am no longer the head of a party. I am the Head of State. My only concern is national cohesion and respect for the values of the Republic. Extremism feeds on the European crisis, social anxiety, but also on the excesses, complacencies, and failures of the political system. The governing parties have a particular responsibility. I do not ask for debates to be smoothed over; on the contrary: they are essential in a democracy. But what is the point of exacerbating conflicts at the risk of allowing the most radicalized elements to benefit from it?

Will you advocate a "republican front" in the municipal elections in spring 2014 in the event of a FN/UMP duel?

For my part, I have always respected this rule. Throughout my political life, I have never confused the right and the far right. And I demonstrated this in the aftermath of April 21, 2002.

Is a new law needed to combat religious proselytism at the university?

"Unnecessary laws weaken necessary laws," reminds us Montesquieu. Today, in universities, it is possible to intervene without the need for additional text.

Should we rethink our family reunification policy?

There is no reason to modify the system. But having a debate about the future of our immigration policy within the framework of a reflection on what France should be in ten years is entirely legitimate.

* A debate took place this summer between your ministers of the interior and justice regarding penal reform. What are your decisions, particularly concerning minimum sentences and the fight against recidivism?

My sole objective is the safety of our fellow citizens. And the effectiveness of the penal response. Today, prisons have never been so full. And too many sentences are not being served, which is unacceptable for the victims. I have contested "minimum sentences" for their automatic nature and their consequences. Not only are they contrary to the principle of individualization of punishment, but far from preventing recidivism, it has tripled from 2004 to 2011. The law will introduce a new penalty for certain offenses, which we will call "penal constraint," allowing for the monitoring of the convicted person without incarceration. I also want to avoid "dry" releases of offenders at the end of their sentence — that is, releases from prison without support, follow-up, or supervision — especially for those who have committed the most serious acts.

* Is it a good thing that the debate between Manuel Valls and Christiane Taubira on penal reform was public?

Within a government, discussion is always necessary. But what cannot be accepted is for the arguments of one side or the other to appear in the press, even if it is in Le Monde. This is an ethical as well as a political rule. Nothing should undermine governmental solidarity.

* Are you considering a cabinet reshuffle soon?

Everyone should think that nothing is fixed and that nothing is immutable. But all ministers must mobilize to achieve the objectives I have set for the end of the year. There are three of them: reform pensions and vocational training, reverse the unemployment trend, and continue the recovery of public accounts while supporting growth. Because a recovery movement is taking shape in France and Europe — I mentioned it on July 14, and it has been confirmed since. I bet that we will be able to slightly raise the growth forecast for 2014. The government will indicate this at the end of September during the presentation of the finance bill.

* Are you able to say that France has never cooperated with the American surveillance program Prism?

Today, there are regular exchanges between French and American services. I noticed this during the Mali war as well as in the Syrian dossier. But I do not have, at this stage, any specific information about the existence of cooperation that may have taken place in the past regarding this program.

Comments collected by Arnaud Leparmentier, Natalie Nougayrède, Thomas Wieder, and Vincent Giret.