Joint interview with Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, and Mr. Mario Monti, President of the Council of Ministers of Italy, notably on the community budget, the reduction of public deficits, and European policy in favor of economic growth, in Lyon on December 3, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

3 December 2012 · Joint interview with François Hollande and Mario Monti · Lyon, France

Context
Hollande and Monti gave a joint interview to Euronews in Lyon on December 3, 2012, discussing the failed EU budget summit and European economic policy.
Main themes
EU multiannual budget negotiations, economic austerity and growth, European solidarity, public deficit reduction, Franco-Italian cooperation, community spending priorities, David Cameron's budget demands, youth unemployment, eurozone stability, cross-border investment
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,797
84th percentile
Sentences
235
92nd percentile
Readability
57
82nd percentile
Grade
9.2
13th percentile
Syntax
2.62
8th percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
55th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

235 sentences in 106 paragraphs

Mr. President, Mr. Prime Minister, good evening, welcome to Euronews. First question about Europe: the last summit on November 22 ended in failure, there was no agreement on the budget. In this period where national governments are making budget cuts, how can we make European citizens understand that the Union is not taking the same path?

Mario Monti, President of the Italian Council:

First of all, it must be recalled that the budget of the European Union represents about 1% of the Union's GDP. This is important, but if we look at the percentage, it is quite small. Therefore, it is evident that in this time of economic downturn and budget cuts, we must carefully control our spending to ensure that our policy is effective.

But we must not simply say that everyone must make savings and therefore the European Union must do the same because it is clear that there are expenditures at the community level that allow us to save in the long run rather than having these savings fragmented at the national level. This is entirely true for large cross-border investments, but also for common defense projects because it would be much more costly to have national defense policies that are not harmonized. Of course, this applies in other areas as well.

Italy's position is that we are not against having higher expenditures at the community level if we can demonstrate that it is useful and that we will save in the future.

François Hollande, President of the French Republic:

As President Monti said, Europe's spending is 1% of European wealth. Do we consider that too much? No. I think it is the right level to prepare for the future because Europe is essentially an investment budget, a growth budget.

Should we do less? We are already making efforts in each of our countries. If we were to impose excessive disciplines at the European level as well, it would be detrimental to the ambition I have had to create more growth through Europe.

So we have to make a compromise, as always in European matters. And I have no doubt that we will find a solution. This is not the first time that Europe has had to take two or even more attempts to finalize its budget.

But I am convinced that the cohesion countries, the countries that joined Europe not long ago, will have to work hard to create a good budget for Europe. We too, and those who ask for checks, rebates, discounts, should consider that Europe is not a cash register where one comes to deposit funds and withdraw the same. Europe is a solidarity for a growth policy that is beneficial for all.

We will have, as often with Italy, the same approach to reach this compromise. But what I want to emphasize above all is that beyond this budget, which I have no doubt will be found in 2013, the year 2012 has been a year that has allowed Europe to move forward, and we are now seeing the results in Greece since we found the solution but also on interest rates, on the confidence that has returned to the markets, and we owe this to the policies that have been conducted, and to the actions that we have been able to carry out, Mario Monti, Mrs. Merkel, myself, and others to reach a good compromise.

Sophie Desjardin, Euronews:

Just since you are talking about those who ask for discounts, regarding the budget, David Cameron stated at the last summit that there were expenditures that we could not afford at the moment and he is asking for savings. 200 billion, I believe, in savings on the budget, what do you think about that?

François Hollande:

He is not asking for that much, but it is already a lot. He is always attentive, and one must be, to administrative expenses. But at the same time, there are institutions that exist in Europe and we must preserve them, and I am thinking in particular of the seat in Strasbourg. So we have in the Treaties a number of European locations and it is always convenient to make savings where one is not affected. The President of the European Commission made a very good demonstration during our last Council where he pointed out that most of the spending dedicated to higher education benefited the United Kingdom. That is not why I will ask for cuts in the budget for higher education or research in Europe.

Claudio Rosmino:

I suggest we look at some images and then we can discuss.

Claudio Rosmino:

These images date from November 14, it was a day of general strike in Europe against austerity. The situation is dramatic in several countries like Greece, Spain, Portugal, or Italy. European citizens feel strangled by austerity plans. Is the treatment not worse than the disease?

Mario Monti:

First of all, we must realize and understand the cause of the disease: the cause of this unemployment and particularly the cause of youth unemployment. The cause is not so much the discipline that is being imposed today on the public budgets of the different countries to be part of the eurozone.

The cause is rather the absence of this discipline in the past. For example, for Italy, until a few years ago, before the constraints of the single currency, successive Italian governments, whether right or left, all had public deficits as a percentage of GDP of 8, 9, or even 10% per year. This was not even a subject of discussion, there was no debate and no one paid attention. But even at that time, it could be understood that this situation allowed everyone to be satisfied by creating an immediate consensus. But in reality, it harmed all future generations: the children, the newborns who cannot yet vote.

The problems we see today, particularly youth unemployment, are not due to the "malice" of Brussels or to an anti-social Europe, but rather to the excesses of the Italian political class and other countries that in the past always wanted to achieve immediate consensus by thinking each time of the next elections and not of the next generations.

Europe has introduced this culture of stability. This will, of course, have a recessionary impact for a transitional period.

I believe that the solution is not to circumvent budgetary discipline, but to enrich the arsenal of European economic policy, as Mr. Hollande has demanded several times with vigor and as I have also called for. We are in the process of achieving this. This involves investments in infrastructure, but also measures in favor of youth employment.

I believe that in this way, in particular, we can reconcile public opinion - and especially the youth - with Europe and ensure that it is no longer seen as a wicked creature that has no heart and no sensitivity to social aspects. Europe is exactly the opposite; it is a tool that imposes discipline on today's politicians so that there are no abuses that weigh on future generations.

François Hollande:

There have been very harmful imbalances in a number of countries in recent years regarding the management of their public finances, and therefore it was necessary to put things in order, and this applies to a country like France because otherwise we would have been overtaken by speculation on our debts, so discipline was necessary but it cannot be enough.

So the countries that have balanced public accounts, that have high competitiveness must support their domestic demand. This is coordination, this is solidarity, so that the countries that have to make efforts can have demands addressed to them from the outside.

And then there is Europe. And Europe is not simply a place of correction, a place of discipline where we whip those who behave badly. It is also a place and a space of solidarity and growth. We return to the European budget. To the growth pact that I presented. And we must show coordination, solidarity, and support. What remains is what each of the countries must do.

I want my country, France, to have well-managed public finances but at the same time to have high competitiveness, higher than today, and finally growth for the youth, jobs. And that is why I have placed youth at the heart of my commitments for my term and I am making a considerable effort despite all the budgetary constraints, on education, on training, and also on youth employment, which is the most distant from the labor market, and it would be a beautiful policy for Europe if it placed this objective at the heart of its choices for the coming years.

Sophie Desjardin:

We were talking about austerity, so there is really a risk of impoverishment, so let's talk about Greece which received a new tranche of aid last week. Let's skip the technical details, the goal is to reduce the debt to 124% of GDP by 2020. 124% is huge, 2020 is in 8 years, that means 8 more years of sacrifices for the Greeks. Will they hold on?

François Hollande:

I think these objectives are necessary. But at the same time, everyone knows their relative nature. Who can say where we will be in eight or ten years? What matters is where we are today and where we will be in the coming months.

Greece now knows that it has support that has been granted to it. And so it will be able to breathe again, regain confidence. It will be able to issue on the markets tomorrow or the day after. Ireland did it even though it was also in a very difficult situation. Finally, the act that was awaited has occurred. There are no more doubts now about the eurozone. A few months ago we could ask ourselves questions. Is the eurozone going to break apart? Are interest rates going to explode? Look where we are at the end of the year. Greece now has its support, its recovery plan, and therefore there are no more doubts. Italy sees its interest rates falling. Spain has also received support for its banks. France has low interest rates as well. Confidence has returned.

We have succeeded in this step. We must now take the next ones.

And that is called growth, solidarity, but while being careful to deepen our Union and have disciplines that are respected by all.

Sophie Desjardin:

So don't you think, Mr. Monti, that the inevitable is a partial write-off of Greece's debt? Yesterday for the first time Angela Merkel mentioned it as a possibility and the IMF has been advocating it for a long time, what do you think?

Mario Monti:

It is difficult to predict whether there will be actions of this kind which, by the way, are not new in the history of international financial relations. Germany benefited from this at the beginning of the 1950s, for example.

I believe we must look at the situation in Greece with a certain perspective. Before joining the eurozone, Greece - and I say this with much affection and sympathy for Greece, its culture, and its traditions - was a country where rules were little respected, tax evasion was perhaps the highest in Europe, competition was an unknown concept, meritocracy did not exist while corruption was widespread.

Thus, Greece concentrated elements contrary to a modern market economy and to this culture of stability that particularly developed in Germany in the post-war period with the social market economy, and indeed, the rest of Europe decided to follow this policy with the single market and single currency projects.

The negative side is that Greece did not do in time everything that was asked of it to recover. But there is also a positive side: if Greece had not been part of the eurozone, it would not even have begun its structural reforms, all its painful discipline policies that may be required too quickly, too concentrated in a very short time, but which are modernizing the Greek economy and society. This is a real revolution and generally, it takes a generation to do this, and that is exactly what is happening in just a few years.

Once, I told Chancellor Angela Merkel: "You should not see Greece only in terms of its shortcomings, but also consider that it is the best testimony of the success of your best export product, namely the euro." The single currency has contributed beyond borders to the culture of stability.

Sophie Desjardin:

I would now like to show you a drawing from our colleagues at "The Economist," a drawing dated June. For our audience who do not speak English, it says: "Please can we start the engines now, Madam Merkel?"

Beyond the comic anecdote, for some time now, it feels like Europe is a sinking ship, on which patches are being put here and there to keep it afloat, with Germany at the helm dictating the course. Is there a willingness on your part to create a Franco-Italian front to face the German diktat?

François Hollande:

Germany is a strong economy, but it cannot do anything without the other European countries, including for its own prosperity. And Madame Merkel has understood this perfectly.

France plays a prominent role in Europe because we are a founding country, like Italy, and we have a solid economy, but we do not claim to lead Europe in place of the other countries. However, there must be a common conception at some point. Therefore, we must not isolate one country, in this case, us, Germany. Nor should Germany put itself in a position of domination, which would not be good for it and not good for Europe.

We must work together. And Germany's interest is that the European economy gets back on track. If the recession continues, Germany will also plunge. This is indeed the case today. Its growth is slowing down. So it must make an effort, as I said, to support the economy. And we must show that we can be competitive.

So we must avoid lecturing each other, but we must work together.

Because why is the European ship, I am not sure that The Economist is the most objective newspaper on the European issue.

Sophie Desjardin:

You are referring to the latest issue about France...

François Hollande:

Not just the latest issue about France. But after all, it is not the English who will lecture us on Europe.

So, I am talking about the English and the British press, I am not talking about the government.

So, Europe is a ship on which we are all aboard, and we must steer it in the right direction, and I note that despite all the difficulties, the slowness because everyone has their public opinions, we have managed to pass milestones, we have not yet reached the right port, but we must put the European economy back on the path of confidence and growth. And we need Germany, but Germany needs France without which it cannot ensure leadership, and Italy, which is the third largest European economy and which I believe has brought coherence and a sense of responsibility in recent months.

Mario Monti:

I am neither French nor German, as you know. I think that Franco-German collaboration - I prefer to speak of "collaboration" and not "axis" - is absolutely vital for Europe. It is a necessary condition because if France and Germany do not agree, it is a problem for Europe. But I do not think that it is a sufficient condition for Europe that France and Germany agree.

I think it is easier for France and Germany to find an agreement if they can dialogue with others, and Italy seeks to play an active role. This may not have been the case some time ago.

Today, we are very well received in the Franco-German dialogue, and in my opinion, all these discussions are increasingly fitting into the community method, which ultimately is the one that must manage Europe.

Claudio Rosmino:

You are both advocates of growth as the engine of recovery. But the engine is stalled. How do we get it running again? Why not consider, as suggested by several economists, a devaluation of the euro?

Mario Monti:

I think that in economics, there should be no taboos because what is a taboo today may be interesting tomorrow and vice versa. That said, I do not think it is a concrete avenue for the future of Europe's economic policy for several reasons.

I think rather that in other areas of economic policy and not in that of the single currency, there needs to be a degree of coordination and common policy. Europe works when decision-making is common: for example, in the area of budgetary policy, investments, major projects, industrial policies, we need more Europe.

If it is possible, and I am convinced that it will be possible little by little, we will have a strong Europe. It will not be on the brakes, but it will have its foot on the accelerator. The brakes and the accelerator will not be in conflict, the Europe-car will not make dangerous maneuvers, but it will be more balanced by having both budgetary discipline and strong growth. I place a lot of hope in this engine that until now has not been running at full capacity. I see the European single market as a growth engine.

François Hollande:

The euro has seen its parity decrease in recent months, which has not been favorable to growth. So I do not believe in using the monetary weapon to restart our economies.

In the same way, interest rates are relatively low, except in a number of countries, but that is not enough to kickstart investment. So what do we need? First of all, trust. We need to restore it, and that is the case.

Secondly, we need to have competitiveness. It should be remembered that Europe is the world's largest economic power, stronger than the United States, stronger than China.

So it is up to us to create a context of innovation, research, know-how, and qualifications so that we can be better in competition.

And finally, we need solidarity and growth, and that requires national policies and a European policy.

I think the worst thing for Europe is to doubt itself. It is to think that it is in decline. As soon as the word decline is spoken, it is already engaged. So we need to restore hope, we need to restore encouragement, we need to restore, especially for future generations, a vision of what Europe should be.

On December 10, the Nobel Peace Prize will be awarded to Europe. Some have even expressed surprise at this decision. So Europe, which has been able to overcome conflicts and wars, which has been able to ensure the reunification of the continent, would not be able to provide a vision today for its economy and for its growth? Well, that is the challenge of our generation. Of those who are in power today or those who aspire to it for tomorrow.

Sophie Desjardin:

We will, if you agree, look again at some images since we are talking about war...

Sophie Desjardin:

This is Gaza, of course. 166 dead on the Palestinian side, 6 on the Israeli side, that is the latest toll following the last Israeli offensive. 20 years of blockage since the Oslo process. What is Europe doing? Where is it?

François Hollande:

Europe is the one that speaks firmly and repeatedly about the necessity of dialogue and negotiation.

Europe is a friend of Israel and a friend of Palestine. And so it can tell the protagonists of a conflict that has lasted too many years that the time has come for negotiation.

You mentioned Oslo. Why do we not find the foundations and principles of Oslo to finally put an end to this?

Sophie Desjardin:

Yes, but why is Europe not being heard? Why is it not progressing?

François Hollande:

Because once again, this Europe that has this economic power does not yet have the political voice that corresponds to it.

And this is due to the fact that some countries want to have their own diplomacy, France being the first, but it is also due to the fact that too many European countries consider that it is the United States that should decide in their place. Well no, we need to conduct a European security and defense policy, a common foreign policy.

That is Europe, the ambition. And look, we have managed to ensure that many European countries voted for the recognition of Palestine as a non-member status at the United Nations. We could have been more numerous, but we were already a sufficient number.

Sophie Desjardin:

It is a bit of an illustration of Europe's divisions this vote...

François Hollande:

Yes, but at the same time, there is a majority opinion that has been expressed on this occasion.

We do not yet have the institutions that correspond, and perhaps not necessarily the will in each country to carry this common foreign policy.

I would like to add another word on this. I am entirely in favor of this Europe, the great Europe as it is today: 27, tomorrow 28, and perhaps more, but I think we must also build a Europe of vanguard.

A Europe that goes further on a number of industrial projects, economic projects, including even political projects, and the time will come when in this great Europe we must have a Europe that is more ardent, more daring, and that puts resources in common. And it is in the eurozone that this must first happen.

Sophie Desjardin:

I wanted to ask you both one last question. There is the head of state, it is the costume, the function, the responsibility, and underneath there is the man. What keeps the two men that you are awake at night? What can prevent you from sleeping?

François Hollande:

There are so many issues that could keep us awake at night that we cannot single out one in particular. You mentioned Gaza, we could talk about Syria, about Europe, about these protests, about these popular anger, about these young people. What is the role of the political leader? It is to act. It is not simply to observe and express one's emotion. It is to be able to say that at the end of one's term, one has done everything possible to solve the problems that were posed.

Mario Monti:

You spoke of the head of state. I am only Prime Minister, perhaps that is why at night, I sleep rather well. When one has the feeling of having done everything one should do, even in very difficult conditions, one finds sleep.