Joint press conference of Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, and Idriss Deby Itno, President of the Republic of Chad, on Franco-Chadian relations, the crash of Malaysian Airlines flight on Ukrainian soil, and the situation in Gaza and Israel, in N'Djamena on July 19, 2014.

France François Hollande · President of France

19 July 2014 · Joint press conference of the President of France and the President of Chad · N'Djamena, Chad

Context
Hollande addressed a joint press conference with Chad's President Déby in N'Djamena on July 19, 2014, covering bilateral ties, African security, MH17, and Gaza.
Main themes
Franco-Chadian relations, regional security in Africa, Mali intervention, Central African Republic crisis, Boko Haram and Nigeria, development aid and economic cooperation, counterterrorism, MH17 crash, Gaza-Israel situation, France-Africa partnership, IMF agreement
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,614
82nd percentile
Sentences
148
80th percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
12.5
52nd percentile
Syntax
3.08
58th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
47th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

148 sentences in 31 paragraphs

At the end of the discussions between the two heads of state, a joint press conference is scheduled. Before I give the floor to you, ladies and gentlemen of the press, we will first listen to the opening statements from the two heads of state. We will first give the floor to His Excellency Mr. Idriss DEBY ITNO, President of the Republic of Chad, Head of State.

Mr. Idriss DEBY ITNO - Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen of the press, before I allow you to ask your questions, if you have any, of course, I would like to once again thank our illustrious host, the President of the French Republic François HOLLANDE, for the honor he has bestowed upon us by making this visit.

I will repeat it again, as far as Chad is concerned, this is the second official visit of a President of the French Republic since independence to this day. The first was in 1970, it was the late President POMPIDOU. There have been quick visits, we had a working visit, this is the second of its kind in 60 years of independence. We celebrated the fiftieth anniversary ten years ago, so this is an act that is extremely significant for us and that also reinforces our conviction that the relations between the two countries are relations of friendship and cooperation, which have strengthened over time and have reached an extremely important level.

This visit, although brief, allowed us to take stock of the cooperation relations between Chad and France, and the possibilities of cementing them in the mutual interest of our two peoples. As you know, France is Chad's main partner. The issue of development aid was one of the topics discussed during our discussions. I take this opportunity to express my gratitude to this friendly country, which has always been and continues to be by our side. Its presence alongside us has regularly manifested itself through various forms of aid.

As you can imagine, the question of peace and security in Africa, as well as other topics of common interest, were not overlooked. I will spare you the details, as the joint press release has just been read to you, summarizing all our activities today. I thank you while remaining at your disposal for any questions.

THE PRESIDENT - Mr. President, I wanted to come yesterday and today to Chad to reaffirm the quality of our relations and to express my gratitude, that of France, for the solidarity you have shown in recent months regarding conflicts that could have disrupted the entire region. I am thinking particularly of what you decided with us for the intervention in Mali. If it had not been for Chad's reinforcement with its soldiers, its army, we would not have been able to achieve the results we know today.

I know the sacrifice this represented, as about thirty Chadian soldiers lost their lives in this operation. But our two armies have forged ties that mean that even today, we are present in Mali to prevent terrorist actions. There was a second moment when Chad took its responsibilities with France, which was in the Central African Republic, when the danger of a confrontation between communities could have suggested that there were all the risks of a genocidal drift. And Chad made sure in the early days, alongside France, to prevent many abuses. Then Chad, after having fulfilled its duty, decided to withdraw from the Central African Republic, and we fully understand its position.

I want to reaffirm France's gratitude to President DEBY, as we were able to hold two major meetings in which he played his role. The Élysée Summit between France and African countries was in December 2013, and it was there that we agreed to provide support and assistance to African forces, so that they could ensure their own security. And then President DEBY came to Paris, following the abduction of young girls in Nigeria by Boko Haram, for this meeting that I organized at the request of Nigeria, which allowed us to achieve results, not unfortunately the release of all the young girls, but a better coordination of actions, particularly between Cameroon and Nigeria. And here too, we will have to ensure that there can be a continuation.

So the reason for my presence here today, once gratitude has been expressed, is to show the closeness of the ties, ties linked to history, ties that have continued to strengthen in recent years and especially in recent months. Ties that are not simply those of security but also economic ties that must be further woven. And that is why I thank the business leaders who are accompanying me today. The embassy is working to multiply support in terms of development and assistance. There are indeed several projects that have been discussed, and we have also emphasized the agreement with the IMF, on European credits that have significantly increased, so that Chad's development can be accelerated.

But there is a third reason that explains this state visit, which is that I wanted to inform President DEBY of what France wants to do in West Africa, and how it intends to reorganize its entire setup, that is, Operation Barkhane. Our forces will be present in five countries and with the capacity to react, to be as effective as possible in the face of threats. And we have decided to set up our command structure here in N'Djamena with the full support, the full agreement, it would not have been possible without this willingness from Chad and President DEBY. And this is also an element of recognition that I wanted to convey to him. Because thanks to this setup, 3,000 men, Operation Barkhane will be able not only to secure the region or the countries in which it will be established, but it will be able to be much more effective in supporting African armies.

With President DEBY, we discussed threats, and there are many around Chad. One has particularly concerned us, even if I do not want to create a hierarchy, it is what is happening south of Libya. All the information we receive puts us on alert. What is at stake today is the existence of terrorist hotspots in a country, Libya, whose instability and weakness of state authority we know today, with all its consequences. So we have also decided to have a particular attitude regarding this threat.

Finally, France, as you know, will host the climate conference in 2015, we discussed these issues with President DEBY. There is mobilization around Lake Chad. He is very attentive to it; there is also everything we can do for the Green Fund and to carry out a number of development projects, and I believe that this is also part of friendship. Friendship is not just about protection, cooperation in security matters, it is not just about economic contracts; friendship is about preparing together for the planet of tomorrow. And Chad, once again, is fully responsible and is ensuring its development with all the necessary precautions for environmental preservation.

I will conclude by saying that for France, Chad has a special role, because of its geographical position, its geopolitical situation, and the courage shown by its leaders, particularly Idriss DEBY, France and Chad are linked. There will be no security in Africa without a Chad capable of being strong and responsible. And that is why I wanted to be present here at the end of this trip, which has taken me from Côte d'Ivoire to here, and having been able to spend what was indeed my wish, a night in N'Djamena, a night in N'Djamena, in the name of Franco-Chadian friendship. Thank you.

SPEAKER - We thank their excellencies for their opening statements. Ladies and gentlemen of the press, as the two heads of state have pointed out, the themes of this conference are focused on security and development. The first question will be posed by our colleague Gérard GRIZBEC from FRANCE TELEVISIONS.

QUESTION - Yes, Gérard GRIZBEC from FRANCE 2. Gentlemen Presidents, we understand that the relationship is good, we also understand that development is at the center of these discussions, and then the Barkhane operation that is being prepared, that is being set up. I would like to know if there is also a human rights component in this configuration. We remember that here, in February 2008, there were fights in N'Djamena, and following these fights, a number of opposition members were arrested, including one who disappeared after his arrest. Was this issue discussed, where do we stand? This man had studied in France, in Orléans, a complaint has been filed in France, there is a resolution from the National Assembly. So, Mr. Chadian President, can you provide us with more details on the disappearance of this opposition leader? And Mr. French President, does the Barkhane operation ultimately come at the expense of human rights?

Mr. Idriss DEBY ITNO - I would simply like to remind you that Chad is a country of law, a democratic country, a sovereign country. The Chadian justice system is a sovereign, independent justice system. Chad is an independent and sovereign country. What happened in this country between February 1 and 2, 2008, can only be evaluated by Chadians today. This attack that came from another country, a foreign country, remains vivid in the hearts and minds of Chadians. It is not just one man who is gone; more than 600 Chadians lost their lives. We had the courage, and the Chadian magistrates had the courage to look into the case, and they gave their verdict. There was an appeal, the magistrates are on the case, we are waiting for the result of the work that the Chadian magistrates will do, since this is an internal Chadian issue, a Chadian-Chadian issue, and the Chadian justice system is authorized to look into this matter.

THE PRESIDENT - I am aware of this case since there is a judicial procedure in Chad, but there is also a judicial procedure in France. This should lead to coordinating the investigations and ensuring that the magistrates can work together. Whenever it is a question of a person's rights or the disappearance of a political leader or a journalist, I always make France's voice heard. What I also want to say is that France does not compromise; there is an operation Barkhane, it will concern five countries, and there is no discussion for concessions that should be requested for some or others. We do this because it is in the overall, general interest, and therefore there is no rule that would suggest that because we have a relationship based on security, on the interest of West Africa, we should not have the same principles everywhere in Africa and elsewhere, based on human rights, democracy, and pluralism. I remind you that there are also senators, as you mentioned, who are working on this issue.

SPEAKER - Good. Ladies and gentlemen of the press, I remind you that the themes of this conference remain security and development. The second question will be posed by Mr. Jérôme BERTOLUS from I TELE.

QUESTION - Gentlemen Presidents, good morning, I have heard that indeed the theme of this conference was security, but there are two major international crises that have intruded into the French President's visit here, and if you allow me, I will ask him two brief questions. First, Mr. President, regarding Ukraine, do you have similar information to that developed by President Barack OBAMA regarding the fact that, according to him, a missile was fired from the pro-Russian area against the MALAYSIA AIRLINES flight? Do you have information from French services that supports what Mr. Barack OBAMA said? And a very quick second question, if you allow me, you wished to ban demonstrations in Paris and the rest of France, pro-Palestinian demonstrations, this was confirmed by the French administrative justice, but some French political parties maintain their call for the demonstration. Do you not fear additional overflow and that ultimately, this ban provokes frustration? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - First question: do we have any new information that allows us to know the cause of the destruction of the explosion of this plane? We, France, have requested, and the Security Council has granted, an international investigation, without hindrance, which must necessarily involve undisputed partners and an on-site investigation to ensure that all evidence is collected. It is on this basis that conclusions must be drawn, indisputable conclusions, conclusions that cannot simply remain a statement, and if we want there to be a follow-up, if we want there to be accountability, if we want there to be consequences, we must not rely solely on hypotheses; we must have certainties. It is true that there are services that inform me and can provide me with assessment elements, but I will not immediately publish what I have not been able to establish through French means alone; I am waiting for the results of the international investigation. I believe these are good principles because it is what will allow this tragedy, this misfortune, to have consequences and conclusions, including for what is happening in Ukraine.

The second topic is the situation in the Gaza Strip. The Minister of Foreign Affairs, who was supposed to accompany me throughout these three days, has been mandated to go first to Egypt, then to Israel, before the Palestinian Authority, and he will also be in Jordan. France wants the ceasefire to be proclaimed as quickly as possible, and that is also the message I conveyed to our representative at the Security Council. The entire international community must act to ensure a return to the truce. We have made sure to call on countries that are close to Hamas, or at least have contact with Hamas, to convey the message to avoid further Palestinian civilian casualties, and we have also told the Israelis, beyond restraint, beyond the protection of civilian populations, that the ceasefire must occur as quickly as possible. Demonstrations have been mentioned at one point in France; we remember a demonstration that particularly degenerated, and for the slogans that were pronounced there, at the end of the demonstration, I do not confuse all the demonstrators, which had an anti-Semitic character and a desire to intrude into two synagogues. Furthermore, there were movements that had been organized, notably by Jews from France, to respond to this with very serious risks, if these demonstrations were confirmed, of public order disturbances. What is my responsibility? Since I said that this conflict should not be imported into France, is it to allow French citizens to confront each other based on their religion, based on their preferences, and then have degradation of places, particularly places of worship? That is why I asked the Minister of the Interior, after investigation, that these demonstrations should not take place, which will not prevent other means of expression, but, again, I believe that the organizers have a particular role. Finally, for those who want to demonstrate at all costs, they will again take responsibility for that.

SPEAKER - The floor is now for ONRTV.

QUESTION - Thank you very much. My question is addressed to the French President. Mr. President François HOLLANDE, no one is unaware today of the commitments you are making, you, as President of the French Republic, and with the Head of State of Chad, Idriss DEBY ITNO, in the fight against jihadism and jihadists. What significance would you like to give, after "Serval," as you move the command zone here to Chad, to this fight you are leading against jihadists and jihadism in Africa?

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, you are asking me about Operation "Barkhane." Here, for a long time, President DEBY remembers, there was Operation "Epervier," whose motivation, at least its extension, was no longer very clear. So we decided, with the Minister of Defense, with the Prime Minister, to reorganize our presence in West Africa with the aim of being much more responsive, having reliable information, and coordinating with the armies of West Africa, particularly the Chadian army, our possible responses in terms of targeted actions. So I will give an example. Yesterday, I was in Niamey. In Niamey, where there is an air detachment. It is mainly responsible for collecting information. Then, let’s imagine there is a risk, a threat, and a need to launch an intervention. It could take place, for example, here from Chad, as we have a number of planes that can perfectly fulfill the mission. Sometimes, it can also be because our African friends may have information indicating a threat. Operation "Barkhane," therefore, involves a reorganization of our forces across five countries and also a different presence. It is not about having large gatherings but a more diffuse presence, to be as close as possible to the areas where the threat exists. I mentioned earlier to President DEBY the south of Libya. We cannot simply have information coming from afar, so we will also need to organize ourselves in relation to this threat. Earlier, we talked about Lake Chad, with a risk that we also know. We will also work in this very particular context where we need to be much more mobile, much more effective, much more rapid, and I think that will also support the efforts of the African armies. Operation "Barkhane" is therefore an operation where France rearticulates its organization to serve its principles but also to serve the security of West Africa.

Mr. Idriss DEBY ITNO - I would like to add a clarification on the question just posed by the ONRTV journalist. It should be noted that the current reorganization of the French deployment in West Africa is an essential element in the context of the pooling of efforts made, not only by the French army but by the French army in collaboration with the African armies, to face the multifaceted threats that are emerging today on the horizon, the origins of which you know. The second important aspect that we discussed with the French President is to ensure that in the coming years, Africans, as he mentioned in his earlier remarks, take charge of their own security. France cannot continue to be, can it, always alongside Africans to find solutions to crises or threats. It is time for Africans to find the possibilities that allow them, with the help of interested partners like France, to set up mechanisms that enable each country, each sub-region, or even at the continental level, to take charge of security, their security, the security of the continent. This is where France's important role comes in, in raising awareness among Africa's partners, partners of Africa who are numerous, and France can be the spokesperson for Africa to enable it to benefit from training, to acquire the necessary equipment so that African armies are able to ensure their own security, our own security in our countries, so that we are not, we do not continue to be a burden, at least I would say for France, for the French army that has already lost so many men for the cause of peace in Africa.

SPEAKER - Last question, private newspaper N'Djamena Bi Hebdo.

QUESTION - My question is also addressed to the French President. In which areas, Mr. President, will France provide or increase its aid for the development of Chad by 2015 within the framework of the national development plan? And can we already have the quantified amount of the envelope that will accompany this aid?

THE PRESIDENT - So, with Chad, we have a cooperation that is primarily French and allows us to act with the French Development Agency in many areas: health, education, and also infrastructure. What I wish is that, as we discussed with President DEBY, it goes quickly, that it is not simply quantified assertions but that very quickly, the institutions responsible for implementing these commitments can deliver these funds and launch the works. Similarly, I was able to obtain that the European Union provides much more than in the past its support to Chad, and we have increased by more than 50%, even 60%, the allocation that Europe granted and will now grant to Chad.

Finally, we have managed, I think now, to unlock the IMF issue, and so all these procedures, France with the French Development Agency, the IMF, and Europe, all of this can give Chad the means for enhanced and rapid development, but I want to add a word. Chad has conducted military operations in the international framework. And everyone was very happy to find Chad, and it is clear that this request for compensation that Chad makes seems justified to me; I would say almost the same about France. We are called to resolve a number of issues that are not simply regional issues. When it is for the Central African Republic, when it is for Mali, these are international issues. And when Europe is present, it is also a European vocation that France can thus assert. Well, it would be legitimate for the major international organizations, for the major development institutions to also take into account the burdens that weigh on a number of countries in terms of security so that these countries do not suffer, because they are in dangerous areas, or because they make the effort to defend themselves, from a lack of financial resources or a lack of development due to their international responsibilities.

SPEAKER - The President of the Republic's schedule being full, Your Excellency, with your permission, we will conclude this press conference. Once again, thank you very much.

Mr. Idriss DEBY ITNO - Thank you as well.