Joint press conference of Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, and Mr. Matteo Renzi, Prime Minister of the Italian Republic, on Franco-Italian relations, European construction, and the European Union in the face of the situation in Ukraine, in Paris on March 15, 2014.

France François Hollande · President of France

15 March 2014 · Joint press conference of François Hollande and Matteo Renzi · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed a joint press conference with Italian PM Matteo Renzi in Paris on March 15, 2014, covering bilateral ties, EU reform, and international crises.
Main themes
Franco-Italian bilateral relations, European Union reform, economic growth and employment, youth unemployment, Ukraine crisis and Crimea, Mediterranean policy, Syria conflict, climate negotiations, competitiveness and labor market reform, Libya and North Africa, Lebanon solidarity, Africa security
Duration
~33 min
85th percentile
Words
3,951
85th percentile
Sentences
248
93rd percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
9.3
14th percentile
Syntax
2.68
11th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

248 sentences in 68 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

I was pleased to welcome the new President of the Italian Council, Matteo RENZI, who has chosen, and I am sensitive to this, to make his first visit as head of government in Europe to us.

Indeed, between our two countries, France and Italy, we have relations that go beyond economics and politics, as they are rooted in a history, a culture, and even languages that we try to speak as much as possible, Matteo more than I! He makes the effort to express himself in French. He may give you an illustration of that... We also have many French and Italian companies that are engaged in cooperation or partnerships of excellence in all fields. If I were to mention a few, I would particularly highlight space, aeronautics, and high-tech industry...

But we mainly met to discuss the situation in Europe, in our two countries within the European Union, and also the major international issues. Regarding Europe, we share the same will. France and Italy have a particular responsibility. Should I remind you that it was in Rome that the treaty was signed that created the common market and that we are both representatives of the founding countries of Europe? We therefore have responsibilities.

We are on the eve of the renewal of the European Parliament, and we intend to exercise these responsibilities to convince our peoples that Europe is an opportunity for peace, an opportunity for democracy. But it is not yet seen as an opportunity for growth and employment. This must now be our objective. This has already been the case for several months, at the initiative of France and other countries, including Italy. We must ensure that the next step focuses on growth, on employment, particularly youth employment, because youth unemployment in our two countries has reached unacceptable levels.

We also have responsibilities because we must undertake reforms. President RENZI has announced reforms for Italy. We have been implementing them for several months in France. In these reforms, there are common points. There is, in particular, the effort we must make regarding the competitiveness of our economies, on political and administrative structures, the effort we must also make for justice, particularly fiscal justice, and the effort we must make to ensure that our countries remain based on a social model, even if it must itself evolve and change.

In the announcements made by President RENZI, in the choices I have made for France, particularly the responsibility pact, there are many common points: both the recognition that we must lower the cost of labor and modernize the labor market, but also ensure that social dialogue and commitments in terms of jobs can be respected by all economic actors.

We will have to work together, before the renewal of the European Parliament, on some major issues, particularly the climate issue, as we will need to provide guidance so that Europe can be fully involved in a negotiation that will conclude in Paris next year during the climate summit.

We also discussed the most pressing international issues. Regarding Ukraine, we believe that the "referendum" or consultation has no legal value in Crimea and that everything must be done to return to the path of negotiation while respecting Ukraine's territorial integrity.

We also talked about several issues that we have in common in our respective policies. For the Mediterranean, President RENZI has just returned from Tunisia. We expressed our solidarity with this country that witnessed the birth of the "Arab Spring."

More generally, we must strengthen the link between Europe and the Mediterranean. This first concerns Libya: there was an important meeting in Rome in recent days. It also concerns the entire question of North Africa. We plan to work together on these issues.

There is also Syria. Unfortunately, it is a tragedy that has lasted for three years, and both France and Italy do not intend to turn a blind eye. There are dramas and massacres occurring every day. There was a conference held in Geneva that did not yield results. We must continue to apply the necessary pressure to find a political solution.

There are issues that sometimes fade from the news not because nothing is happening, but sometimes the worst is happening because others are taking a new place. I believe that regarding Syria, we have not finished as long as there are these massacres, these dramas, these tragedies, these refugees, these displaced persons, and these women, as we know today, who are being raped for the rights they are trying to defend. There is a threat hanging over Lebanon. Here too, we stand in solidarity with this country. An important conference on Lebanon was held in Paris.

I will conclude on the question of Africa, because Italy and France want to be fully present on this great continent of the future! and ensure that it can also live in security. You know that France is present in the Central African Republic. A European mission has been decided as part of an operation. I hope that Italy will take its full place there.

To conclude, Matteo and I will have as many consultations as necessary. He is taking on the responsibilities of a great country. I have only two years of experience, but everything I can tell you about what to do and what not to do, I will tell you!

MR. MATTEO RENZI

Mr. President, for me it is very important to have the opportunity to be here in Paris, in a city that I love, especially with the very friendly welcome from President HOLLANDE!

I believe that the relations between Italy and France are excellent, and I also think that we will work together, which is very important for us, in a very effective way. For the interest of our countries, but also, I think, for the interest of Europe. Because we can, we must change Europe together. This is the first challenge we must face in the coming months, in the coming years.

I want to emphasize very clearly to my colleagues in the Italian press that, for us, the relationship with France is not just a relationship that dates back to the past. After the meeting I had today with Mr. HOLLANDE, I can confirm this once again. It is a relationship that is based on the future. We need to win together an important battle, a battle of values in the world.

You have heard Mr. HOLLANDE's words about Africa. We are strongly convinced of all this, we are perfectly aligned with what Mr. HOLLANDE has said. We will ensure that the Mediterranean becomes increasingly an attractive place for the European Union and for Europe.

My personal opinion is that Europe, lately, has not looked sufficiently at the Mediterranean, which is the heart of our continent. That is why I believe that the work done by France in certain African countries, and that can be done again in the future, is very important.

Our objective, of course, is to implement cooperation and partnership between our two countries. We wish to work together, right away, starting from the next European Council on the themes of climate and energy. We will consult regularly and constantly. This is very important for our countries and also from a personal point of view. It is very important for Italy and for France, regarding the commitments we have with the European Commission.

We also have a fundamental political objective. We must tell some of our citizens who have lost trust, who no longer believe in Europe, that we must tell them that Europe is the place of the greatest political challenge we can face. If someone today no longer believes in Europe because they have experienced the economic crisis firsthand, we can only have more euros in our pockets if we have more Europe in our institutions and in our policies! The greater the presence of Europe, the stronger the possibility of recovering wealth, particularly for the social categories that have suffered the most from the crisis.

This is also a political consideration. I respect the role of the President of the French Republic, of course. I have nothing else to add because I share everything that Mr. HOLLANDE has said about Ukraine, everything that François has said about the importance of the upcoming international meetings.

After the meeting in Paris, which marked the first appointment against youth unemployment, we will have a next meeting in Rome. In Italy, the situation of youth unemployment is very concerning. In July, we will relaunch these reforms. That is why the reforms we have envisaged must be implemented effectively.

I hope that the semester of the Italian presidency of the European Union will be a semester where the objectives shared by France and Italy are shared by all other countries and thus by all of Europe. It needs to be alive! We always say that we must respect the limits set by the treaties. We do so. But first and foremost, we must respect the founding fathers of the European Union; we owe them that respect. We must ensure that Europe is the meeting place for citizens and peoples.

QUESTION

A question for Mr. RENZI. You discussed the reform plan with Mr. HOLLANDE. Given that among the financing reforms of this reform plan you have planned a possible deficit overshoot, will there be a delay in the budget balance that had been planned and that the European Commission requested for the year 2014? The LETTA government had already postponed it to 2015. Will there be a delay, or does it remain a priority objective?

I wanted to ask you about the other Europe that Italy and France will perhaps build in the coming years. A criticism that President RENZI has made several times in recent months concerns the limits of the stability pact. He said that Italy will respect all the parameters of the stability pact. But at the same time, he expressed the need, perhaps, to review the stability pact. I wanted to know if France would agree with this type of path, especially regarding the 3% deficit parameters?

MR. MATTEO RENZI

First of all, there will be no overshoot of the 3% ceiling. None. We need to be precise about this. There is, however, a margin between 2.6% and 3%. We are currently at 2.6%, so we might be able to use this margin while respecting the imposed limits.

When I talk to you about the stability pact, I am actually talking about the national internal stability pact. We have modalities for applying the stability pact. This prevents municipalities in Italy, for example, from spending money on schools even if they have these resources in their municipal budgets. We will therefore change this national stability pact to allow our children to have schools worthy of being called schools.

It is normal to care about bureaucratic stability. But we care even more about the stability of our children and our schools. We will, of course, respect all constraints. We believe that while respecting these constraints, we must think with the new European Commission about how the European Union can help member countries stimulate growth and combat youth unemployment in particular.

I would like to conclude by specifying that for 20 years Italy has had a primary surplus. This has almost always been the case; sometimes it has not been, but there has been a significant primary surplus for a long time. Right now, we are experiencing a phase of economic difficulties, of employment difficulties. So, in order to change, we must respect the rules that we have imposed on ourselves. This is not a set of rules imposed by an enemy. But at the same time, we must clarify that we need to be attentive to those who are in difficulty. We must ensure growth. I believe this is fundamental for those who are in politics, especially for those who are in left-wing politics in Europe.

THE PRESIDENT

France and Italy are members of a European Union. We must respect the commitments we have made with our partners. There is a framework, there are rules, and we must work together to ensure stability and that the euro can be recognized as a solid currency. Which, by the way, is the case. When I look at the level of the euro compared to the dollar or other currencies, we have not only emerged from the eurozone crisis, but we are surely one of the strongest, most robust currencies in the world. But this requires that member states respect a certain number of rules, which we do.

Italy, as the President of the Council has said, has been in primary surplus for years. I would have liked to say that France has been in primary surplus for 20 years! France has long been in deficit, primary, secondary, and tertiary, by the way! And at higher levels, for years, than Italy. This does not mean that French public debt is at the same level as Italy's. It is below. But we still have to work to reduce deficits, we in France, because we are above 3%, which is not the case for Italy.

But at the same time that we respect our commitments, we must give even more strength to support, growth, and employment. That is the great challenge. This is what I obtained nearly two years ago with the growth pact. We indeed gave deadlines to the different countries. France and Italy benefited from this regarding the perspective of deficits. We must place more emphasis on youth employment; decisions have already been made, but the challenge is to have more growth. If there is indeed more growth, it will be even easier to achieve results in terms of reducing deficits and controlling public debt.

That is the objective we have set for ourselves: to create more growth. How do we create more growth? In Europe, there are both countries that are in surplus and must support their domestic demand, and then, other countries that have a trade deficit, which is the case for France for the past 10 years. These countries must still improve their competitiveness, and that is what I am doing; that is the meaning of the responsibility pact. Because by improving competitiveness, we will be able to sell more and have more growth and therefore have more jobs. I believe that this policy allows us to be both compliant with our commitments and the values that are ours, and at the same time compliant with the commitments we have made within the European framework.

QUESTION

On the Ukrainian issue, Moscow does not seem to be moving towards the de-escalation desired by the European Union; under these conditions, do you both fear that the referendum on Sunday in Crimea is just a prelude to a total destabilization of Ukraine? Mr. President, do you confirm the cancellation of the Franco-Russian meeting on Tuesday in Moscow? Do you not think it would be appropriate to suspend the MISTRAL contract in order to put pressure on Russia?

THE PRESIDENT

Thank you for all your questions. There is a pseudo-consultation of the population in Crimea because it does not comply with Ukrainian internal law and international law. There cannot be a consultation organized in part of the territory without the government of the country in question being involved in the organization of this vote. And that is exactly the case. That is why France, like the European Union, will not recognize the validity of this pseudo-consultation.

On Monday, there is a meeting of foreign ministers. There was a scale of sanctions that had been defined by the European Council. We were there. Therefore, there will be the use of these sanctions if there is no de-escalation on Monday, which, I remind you, concern visas and the financial assets of a number of individuals. I hope there will be de-escalation, and that there will be a contact group that can find solutions within the framework of Ukraine's territorial integrity and also the recognition of the links that exist between Russia and Ukraine. That is why the contact group must now, if I may say so, be in contact. But it still takes two to have contact.

As for the trip that had been planned for a long time, since it is within the framework of bilateral relations between France and Russia, I will wait until Monday to know exactly what the Russian position will be after the pseudo-consultation in Crimea. As for the other sanctions, particularly those related to military cooperation, that is the third level of sanction. We are at the first level.

MR. MATTEO RENZI

I completely agree with Mr. President. I think it is very important that we work together. It is very important that France, Germany, the United Kingdom, and Italy have worked together during this really difficult period, and this goes without saying with the Council of Europe. I think we will wait for the meeting next Monday.

QUESTION

President HOLLANDE, you said you had the same desire to share ideas for another Europe. Is the RENZI-HOLLANDE meeting the beginning of a change in European policy from the European socialist family? Matteo RENZI, have you convinced President HOLLANDE to choose a European policy to change the orientations in Europe? Italy is present in Europe; it is trying to explain its reforms while simultaneously asking for a change in policy from the European Union. In France, there has been talk in particular of the planned intervention in Italy; is this also a policy of change for the European socialist family?

MR. MATTEO RENZI

I think it is not necessary to convince Mr. HOLLANDE to change direction in Europe. Mr. HOLLANDE is very willing. But he cannot also know the slogan of our electoral campaign. I think without changing my mind. There is already a sharing. The limits and constraints of Europe must be respected. At the same time, the new European Commission and the new European Union will have the task of reducing the difference or rather the distance, the gap between the European administration, the administrations, and the citizens.

We are used to presenting ourselves for elections. We are convinced that in the next elections, populist parties will have a chance of success if we are not aware of the fact that we also need to change the European Union. It is not about changing the positions of one or the other but rather about working together. That is why it is important to talk about the congress of the Socialist Party that took place in Rome. It is important to work together within the large European political families to emphasize that we need to ensure that citizens believe in Europe again. This is a fundamental challenge.

We must be able to change the approach of institutions towards citizens. At the same time, we must be able to form a ruling class that sees Europe as our friend while in Italy, some think that Europe is our enemy. The European Union is our partner.

To conclude, I must reiterate that Italy must respect its constraints, not because Mr. HOLLANDE or Ms. MERKEL ask us to. But simply because we owe it to the children of our country. It is not normal for a political class to have spent the money of future generations. We therefore guarantee you that we will have this respect. For our children, we want a Europe that goes beyond ERASMUS exchanges. We need a Europe that is alive, strong, and competitive.

THE PRESIDENT

Another Europe, that is the slogan! I think we must ensure that Europe best corresponds to the aspirations of the peoples, that is to say, a Europe that ensures security; that is why it was founded, a Europe that allows for the free movement of goods and people, to have a political space based on law and democracy. Just for that, it was worth it to create Europe.

But there is an aspiration that we express through what we represent. It is primarily a Europe that can also be economically secure, that can give hope, especially in a period when unemployment is very high. That is what we must do, first at the level of governments.

Allow me to say that since I have been in the responsibility of President of the Republic for 2 years, I have always found in Italy, with Mario MONTI and Enrico LETTA, a partner to move in the direction of this Europe of growth. We have not always been able to go as far as we would have liked. But I want to pay tribute here to Mario MONTI and Enrico LETTA for the action we have been able to conduct.

It happens that Matteo arrives at a crucial moment for Europe, that is to say, on the eve of the renewal of the European Parliament and therefore the constitution of the Commission. France and Italy have even more, as governments, to make their voices heard, as we have defined them: respect for commitments and at the same time a desire for growth.

On the European Parliament and its renewal. Elections are scheduled for May 25. Is it a referendum for or against Europe? No. Regardless of the outcome of the European elections, Europe will be there. What is at stake in this consultation is what kind of Europe? The same or a Europe that corresponds to our objectives of progress, growth, employment, and solidarity? That is the challenge.

Governments will only be able to act based on the European Parliament, the political forces that will constitute it after May 25. Hence the importance of this vote. Let us not allow populists to pose the question. The question is not for or against Europe. The question is what kind of Europe do we want. In this area, indeed, there will be political competition.

QUESTION

The week has been particularly difficult for the government. You have not yet spoken about the political-judicial affairs. We have several questions to ask you. First of all, when did you become aware of the wiretaps concerning Nicolas SARKOZY? Did you know the content of these wiretaps? Do you renew your confidence in Christiane TAUBIRA? Finally, do you think, as shown by the first polls conducted since this affair, that this affair and the management of this week will have an impact on the upcoming municipal elections?

THE PRESIDENT

I am not sure that these questions quite correspond to the meeting we have today. But what is my responsibility as head of state? It is to ensure the independence of the judiciary, which is based on three principles.

First, the separation of powers, meaning that the executive does not intervene in the judiciary. I pay particular attention to this with a change in practice that allows me to salute what has been done over the past 2 years. The second principle is the respect for the rights of the defense. I will meet with the lawyers who at one point may have questioned the wiretaps that were decided by the judiciary, and by the judiciary alone, on a lawyer.

And then, the third principle is the presumption of innocence. There are cases, there are names that are mentioned, there are procedures that are ongoing. It is not for me to qualify them here. But justice will take its course, and I must ensure that it can be indisputable because it cannot be contested, because that is a fundamental principle, that of the independence of the judiciary. That is also why I will meet, at their request, with the judges' unions.

Thank you.