Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on Greece and the Eurozone, European immigration policy, Great Britain and the European Union, Uber Pop and taxis, and the surveillance of French presidents by the NSA, in Brussels on June 25, 2015.

France François Hollande · President of France

25 June 2015 · Press conference following the European Council · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Hollande addressed a press conference at the European Council in Brussels on June 25, 2015, covering Greece, migration, and other EU issues.
Main themes
Greek debt crisis and eurozone negotiations, European immigration and refugee policy, EU border management and asylum, development aid for migration source countries, European solidarity and burden-sharing, British relationship with the EU, NSA surveillance of French presidents, Uber and taxi regulation
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,900
74th percentile
Sentences
132
76th percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
11.4
37th percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

132 sentences in 42 paragraphs

"We spent the first part of this European Council discussing three topics.

First, there was a report from the President of the Eurogroup on Greece, and it was mentioned that there is a lack of agreement at this stage, with still differing approaches between the institutions, the European Commission, the European Central Bank, the IMF, and Greece, but with gaps that can be narrowed.

It was therefore decided to allow more time for the negotiators so that a new Eurogroup meeting, that is to say, the meeting of the finance ministers of the eurozone, can take place on Saturday afternoon.

I consider that this meeting on Saturday is crucial because we are on the eve of the deadline, June 30. At that point, the Greek authorities will have to face payment demands. It is also crucial because there are Parliaments that will need to convene in the event of an agreement. It is finally crucial because there is a European Council that will conclude on Friday and there will not be another one before July. It is crucial because for several days an agreement has been in sight but is still not concluded. Therefore, we must do everything we can, and France is working on this, to ensure that there can be a comprehensive and sustainable agreement and that Greece makes proposals that allow the institutions to enter this concluding phase.

The second topic that took time was the issue of migration and the problems faced by Southern European countries in light of the scale, which has been ongoing for several months, of population movements, refugees, migrants, and with a solution that must be European. Everyone understands this well; there is no debate about it. The response cannot be national for any country. And if Europe has any meaning, it is indeed in the face of human tension and pressure, because it is men, women, and children who are at stake, and Europe must be there. First, to ensure the protection of its borders, to address the root causes of migration, and to ensure the dignified reception of refugees while allowing the return of migrants who have come irregularly.

What has been decided? First, to amplify development policies, that is to say, towards countries that are facing migration, to find responses as close as possible to the populations. Europe has already engaged in a policy regarding Niger that will gradually bear fruit. Europe has also set a date with Africa; it will be at the Valletta Summit in Malta so that development policies can once again be defined and amplified. And also to have relations with countries of origin to both allow for readmission, that is to say, the return of migrants when they have not been authorized to stay in Europe, and at the same time, to have policies that can allow them to experience development and a perspective for growth.

Then there is the European operation that is gaining substance to combat trafficking and smugglers.

And then there is the reception, and decisions have been made to establish hotspots, as they are called, that is to say, places where people arriving on European shores, in Italy, in Greece, and perhaps also in Hungary in a certain way, can be registered. So that there can be this identification of people who fall under the right of asylum, refugees, and other people who are migrants and who do not have the possibility of settling permanently in Europe. At that point, return policies could be decided and implemented in the very places where these migrants have been received. This requires additional means and resources; it is the role of Europe to provide them to the host countries. France will do its part since we have also decided, as part of this cooperation, to allocate a number of resources, including services from OFPRA, to ensure registration and identification. But it is FRONTEX, that is to say, the European operation itself, that will take on this responsibility.

Finally, it has also been decided to find solutions for 40,000 refugees, to which we must add 20,000 Syrians, primarily, and Iraqis who are currently in camps and who would be resettled in Europe.

The foundation of this policy is the agreement that was already reached in April, which will mean that each country must make a commitment regarding its own responsibility. In other words, all European countries, the 28 except of course those countries that are already involved in hosting, all countries will have to make commitments. And the European Commission will report to the next European Council on the reality of these commitments. France will do its part based on what our situation already is.

So this is also a comprehensive policy that has been decided. If it has taken a long time, it is because we know that these issues are particularly delicate in all countries, and that for Eastern European countries, there is also the fear that refugees may not only come from the South but also from the East if the Ukrainian crisis were to worsen.

So there were many discussions. Of course, the debate could be on one side, those who demanded obligations, and on the other, those who called for positions based on voluntarism. And ultimately, this compromise was found for the commitment of each country to ensure that the issue of these 40,000 people who fall under the right of asylum, who are part of the duty towards refugees, to which we must add the 20,000 resettled, can be resolved by our decisions this evening.

Finally, the third topic was the presentation by the United Kingdom of its desire to engage with European countries bilaterally, but also with the Commission, that is to say, with the European authorities, in arrangements whose exact content or legal consequences are still unknown, allowing the British government to move towards a referendum planned for 2016. There will therefore be a progress report presented by the President of the European Council in October on this subject.

There you go. Europe is facing challenges that concern it directly, in its spirit, I would even say in its identity, its future. Is it capable of responding when a country risks default, as is the case with Greece, to find a solution that respects the rules but also takes into account the situation of a country that has already suffered a lot?

Is Europe capable, in the face of crises, in the face of population displacements due to these crises or due to poverty, is Europe capable of protecting itself? It is indeed its role to protect its borders while also being up to the level of distress? Particularly that of peoples who are being driven out or exiled, of families who may be in danger. Is it capable of showing solidarity, Europe, and at the same time, of responsibility?

Responsibility, solidarity, these are the two principles that apply to every issue, especially for those that were extensively discussed this evening at the European Council. The responsibility lies with each country when there is a monetary, economic, financial situation. It lies with each country when it comes to taking its share in the face of migration. And then solidarity must be established within Europe.

And I hope that tomorrow the name of Jacques Delors can be seen as proof of what the European ideal has been since it is proposed that he be made an honorary citizen of the European Union.

The idea of the founders of Europe, the builders of Europe, was solidarity. It is still solidarity but with the responsibility that goes with it. Because it is not a solidarity that would ultimately be general, that would be unconditional, but solidarity must be the foundation of the European Union. Responsibility being that each nation that makes up Europe must also do what is necessary in the face of situations that can be economic, that can be financial, that can also be humanitarian.

That is the report I wanted to make on this first day of the European Council."

- Mr. President, on the issue of migration, we heard a very severe tone from Matteo Renzi, we also heard about painful exchanges between Donald Tusk and Jean-Claude Juncker. How did this very long discussion unfold?

The discussion was long and had some moments of tension. This is quite legitimate. Between Donald Tusk and JC Juncker, it was essentially regarding the role of initiative of the Council and the Commission. And it had nothing to do with the substance of the issues being addressed. This is not the first time I have witnessed this type of exchange, even before these positions were held by JC Juncker or Donald Tusk.

On the issue of migration, yes, there was first the expression from Italy, from Greece, from Malta, from Hungary as well since it is affected by the migration coming from the Balkans, there was the expression of what these countries expected from Europe, saying that they could cope, that they had their dignity, that they had their capacity to act, but that at the same time Europe had to be there, and I shared this position because we cannot leave, when we are a continent, the European Union, that respects rules, principles, we cannot leave one country, on the pretext that it is the border country, to face everything alone.

Other countries were very attached to voluntarism and wanted nothing to be imposed on them. And I understand this position as well. But the only way to respond to this, and this is ultimately what prevailed, is what I defended along with others, it is the commitment, that each country must commit. Because if voluntarism means "I prefer to do nothing," that is not a conception that can be accepted. And if the obligation is with numbers that can be contested because they are not the right criteria, that is not the right method. That is why I rejected the idea of quotas.

So the commitment, yes: each country will have to say, the interior ministers will soon meet - regarding the quantified objective of 40,000 plus the 20,000 relocated, what is possible to do in each country. Then the European Commission will have to see if the sum of the commitments indeed meets the expected figure, the 60,000.

In a certain way, I apologize for this comparison because these are not the same subjects, but look at climate: Europe has been able to set a target: a 40% reduction in CO2 emissions. Each country must position itself to achieve the overall objective. I ask each country to make a contribution. Well, it is the same thing. Each country must provide its own contribution, and we see if the sum of the contributions allows us to reach the objective, and if that is not the case, there will be corrections that will need to be made. That is why the discussion was long. It touches on principles, on human situations, it touches on methods to achieve the objectives. I think that the objective this evening was to ensure that the 60,000 people who are refugees can have solutions.

- Mr. President, the assessment of the day today in Paris is 70 damaged vehicles, 10 arrests, 7 police officers injured, and an American celebrity who, through their expressions on social media, attracted the attention of the media from other countries to this day. What impact does this have on France's image abroad? We are candidates for the Olympics in 2024. Could the law enforcement not have prevented such excesses that shocked many today in Paris?

When violence occurs, it is not the law enforcement that should be blamed. They did their job. When cars are overturned, others are burned, it is not the law enforcement that is responsible for that. There are forms of violence that are unacceptable in a democracy, unacceptable in a country like France, even when there is a subject that, it is true, can provoke anger, in the face of unfair competition, particularly for taxis, with this group Uber Pop that respects no rules.

We can understand that there are protests. They are a right in our country. We can understand that there is exasperation because it has been going on for months, and that judicial decisions are slow to be rendered, and therefore unacceptable, intolerable situations can persist.

My first reaction as President of the Republic is to denounce and condemn this violence, even if it is the work of a minority, of a few individuals. And nothing can excuse violence because violence is not only unbearable for the people who are victims of it, but it is also unbearable for the image of our country.

Nevertheless, there is a problem and it needs to be resolved. This problem is difficult since it involves unfair competition from a group, and the Minister of the Interior made a good decision: to declare once again illegal a service that is illegal. Because not respecting the rules of law, not respecting social rules, not respecting tax rules, is illegal. Therefore, this group Uber Pop must be dissolved and declared illegal, and the seizure of vehicles must be ordered and carried out.

Nevertheless, we are in a state governed by the rule of law. It is not the state that can seize vehicles by itself. It must be authorized to do so by court decisions. And the sooner these court decisions are made, the simpler the situation will be, particularly for taxis.

The law must be respected; this applies to everyone, and the law must also be effective. A law was passed by Parliament. It must be applied. Competition is necessary, but it must be based on common rules. And when competition is distorted, it must be absolutely challenged.

- A question regarding the revelations concerning the electromagnetic interceptions on your mobile phone and that of two of your predecessors. This is the third set of revelations of this kind since your election. Have you, on a technical level, tried to further secure the level of communications? Have you had any contact with Ms. Merkel, who herself was the target of such interceptions? And regarding the diplomatic reaction, is the ritualization, the rather classic theatricalization of the protest, with the inadmissibility of these wiretaps, with the summoning of the ambassador, with your phone call with President Obama, with the visit of the French intelligence coordinator, is that sufficient given the scale of this espionage that directly affects the sovereignty of the French state?

These practices are condemnable, and I have condemned them every time there have been revelations. Those that have been published are not the first, and they will certainly not be the last. I have condemned them, and I have called for these practices and behaviors to cease.

When it concerned Ms. Merkel, but also when it involved aggressions, because that is indeed what it is, that could relate to our own territory, our own authorities, there were reactions on my part that led to commitments from the United States, which, starting in November 2013, declared to us that they would cease all these practices, all these behaviors. When I went to the United States for a state visit in February 2014, President Obama reiterated the commitments that had been made.

Following the revelations concerning interceptions or analyses derived from I don't know what conversation, regarding two of my predecessors and myself the day after my election, in the days that followed, after the Élysée had been the subject of a cyber-attack on the very day of the transfer of power between me and my predecessor, these revelations are from a period that no longer needs to be extended, given the commitments that have been made.

Therefore, I consider that if anything were to happen from the commitment that has been made, it would be a serious breach of our relations. But President Obama, even during the phone call I had with him following the revelations, confirmed to me that the Presidency of the Republic was no longer being targeted as it had evidently been previously.

- Your Minister of Justice, Christiane Taubira, has stated that she would not oppose asylum for the two whistleblowers who enabled the revelation of these wiretaps, Edward Snowden and Julian Assange. What is your opinion on the matter?

First of all, we have not received any specific requests. Furthermore, every time this question has been posed to me - it was asked from the very first revelations - I have said that we are not in that situation. The United States are allies. We must behave as allies. This implies that we are to be respected.

I had a clarification with President Obama regarding the relations we should have in terms of intelligence. The intelligence coordinator will go to the United States to ensure that these commitments are being respected. In the same way, we have requested the communication of what was, let’s say, taken by Edward Snowden and disseminated on a network. Even if it is very difficult for the United States to measure the extent of it, we want to know; we want to understand what happened.

But what matters is from November 2013, I insist on this point. Because from November 2013, I am myself committed, and the United States are committed to me.

Thank you.