Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the budget of the European Union, in Brussels on February 9, 2013.

France François Hollande · President of France

9 February 2013 · Press conference on the budget of the European Union · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Hollande addressed a press conference in Brussels on February 9, 2013, following the EU multiannual financial framework agreement for 2014-2020.
Main themes
EU budget agreement 2014-2020, commitment and payment credits, common agricultural policy, cohesion policy, budget flexibility, eurozone stabilization, banking union, national interests negotiation, European financial framework
Duration
~50 min
94th percentile
Words
5,995
94th percentile
Sentences
206
90th percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
13.6
63rd percentile
Syntax
3.24
77th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
22nd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

206 sentences in 62 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT I want to thank you for your tenacity, for your understanding, regarding an agreement that has taken as long as usual to come to fruition but which I believe is a good compromise, given the conditions we know and the circumstances we are aware of. I said that this is an agreement that took a long time to achieve because there were multiple national interests and there was a difficult European context, with already a first failure in November when it was impossible to reach an agreement on a level of spending.

If the agreement has been reached, it is because there was an awareness that after having stabilized the eurozone, found the necessary compromises for banking union, and being able to save Greece, we had to show the world and Europeans that we could also agree on a financial framework that, I remind you, will be valid for the next seven years.

This agreement is as follows: the amount of commitments, that is to say the sum of expenditures that will be made by the European Union for the next seven years, is 960 billion euros. This was the objective I set as soon as I knew that the main European countries wanted a financial framework that was at a lower level for the years 2014-2020 than that which had been established for the last seven years. 960 billion was undoubtedly the highest range that could be achieved. Moreover, initially, the proposal from the President of the European Council was lower.

The second amount that needed to be established was that of payment credits, that is to say what will be disbursed considering the commitments that have been made. The level retained is 908.4 billion, which is exactly 5% less than the amount of commitments. So 908.4 billion, 5% less than the commitments, taking into account the traditions that are observed, the habits that are noted but which, nevertheless, pose a problem that had been raised with me when I went before the European Parliament on Tuesday, which is that if the gap is too great between commitments and payments, the risk is that there will not be sufficient credits to settle the expenditures when the time comes.

To resolve this point, I argued, and I was not the only one since it was retained, and the President of the European Commission helped with this, that we needed to have maximum flexibility between the years and between the expenditures, so that the volume of credits called corresponds, over time, to the credits that have been committed.

All of this may seem complex but in fact, it is quite simple to understand. If we commit more credits than there are resources available, there comes a moment when a deadlock is observed, which is already the case. And to avoid this gap, there must be the necessary flexibility, what I call "flexibility." And in the text of the agreement, this flexibility will be sought at its maximum level over time and between expenditures.

What were the positions on this? The British wanted less than 900 billion, France was not the only one that thought that with 913, we could have a sufficient volume of credits and thus available resources. Ultimately, the compromise was reached, as I told you, at 908.4 billion.

Everyone will say who took the biggest step. I considered that it was possible to do so as long as we had this guarantee of maximum flexibility. I do, however, make a comparison: during the period 2007-2013, there were 855 billion in expenditures made, that is to say credits spent, not simply committed but credits disbursed; this time, for the next seven years, we are at 908.4 billion.

So in reality, if we spend everything that is planned for the next seven years, we will spend more than what was actually disbursed in the last seven years, contrary to many preconceived ideas where it is said that there could be a risk, which is indeed evident from the figures of a financial framework at a lower level than the previous one. I say that if the countries and if Europe spend everything that is planned, everything that is authorized by the agreement, we will have an effective volume of payments greater for the next seven years than what we observed in the previous period.

There you have it for the figures, there you have it for the volumes, there you have it for the overall agreement. Now I had four objectives in this negotiation. The first objective: I wanted to preserve common policies, agricultural policy, cohesion policy. And you know that for France, the common agricultural policy is a very important element, a community achievement, not simply because we have interests to assert, but because we believe, I believe, that agriculture is an opportunity for Europe, for the diversity of its productions, for the enhancement of its territory, for our agri-food industry, for the preservation of our environment, and even for our exports.

The fear, everyone knew it, was that there could be a decrease in resources allocated to the common agricultural policy, which was indeed the intention of the Commission. It is true that there is a decrease in the share of the common agricultural policy in the European budget, but it has been largely preserved, especially for French farmers, and I paid particular attention to this. We will have stability in direct payments, what is called the first pillar linked to production, and we will also have an improvement in our situation regarding rural development since we will have more than eight billion euros for rural development, with much more favorable co-financing rules, especially for transition regions, which will allow us to do more for the diversity of our agriculture.

We also ensured that the greening of the common agricultural policy remains at its level of 30% so that the protective environmental rules are also in favor of agricultural development, with a priority in my eyes which is livestock, animal production. And in this framework, it will be possible for us to act through direct aids and also through rural development.

I therefore consider that on one of the priorities I set for this negotiation, the preservation of the common agricultural policy and especially the credits allocated to France, the objective has been achieved.

But also on the other policy, I wanted that on cohesion, that is to say on the development of territories, we could also have guarantees, and this will be the case for all the countries concerned, this was the subject of much negotiation, especially with the countries that are said to be of cohesion. For these countries, these funds represent very important elements of their investments or their infrastructures.

But for us, cohesion credits are also opportunities for our companies to take contracts in these countries, which is why I was keen on this. Here too, we can consider that the objective has been achieved since for the French regions, we were able to maintain the category of transition regions, we were able, for the outermost regions, that is to say the overseas regions, with Mayotte which has also been integrated, to maintain our returns, that is to say our credits between the two periods.

Finally, we were able to allocate in these cohesion funds a special credit for youth employment amounting to 6 billion euros, of which France can expect 10% since one of the criteria, unfortunately, to benefit from this fund will be to have in the concerned regions a youth unemployment rate higher than 25%, which is the case in several regions of France.

So the preservation of common policies, that was the commitment I made before the European Parliament, it is respected. I also said since last June that I wanted Europe to be oriented towards growth, and here too, in the financial framework that has just been concluded, the section dedicated to growth increases in terms of credits by 40%. This is particularly true for infrastructures, whose budget increases by 140%, especially for transport, with 13 billion euros allocated compared to 8 in the previous financial framework. In this transport section, there is, for those who are interested, the high-speed line project Lyon-Turin. But beyond infrastructures, research and innovation see their credits increase.

I also wanted to preserve and increase the funding of the ERASMUS program for all, expanded to apprentices, high school students in vocational training. This program has not only been preserved but increased. I add, because this also has a link with growth, that the credits for development amount to 27 billion euros and are allocated to countries, notably Africa, where we consider there is urgency and necessity, I am particularly speaking for West Africa, but these development credits also have a positive effect for our companies as long as they correspond to major projects, to infrastructures or to calls for tenders in energy or transport.

So the second commitment, to ensure that this European budget is oriented towards growth, is fulfilled.

The third commitment I made was that Europe could be supportive of the most disadvantaged Europeans. I mentioned earlier the specific fund for youth; this is one dimension of what we wanted in this budget, but there was a program that was threatened and which had been the subject of questioning for several years regarding its sustainability.

This program, you know it: it is the one that allows charitable associations to feed our fellow citizens or to help them when they are in precarious situations. Not only has this program been preserved, initially 2.1 billion was allocated to it, but I obtained that the envelope could be raised to 2.5 billion, in order to meet all the requests that may be made in all European countries. I know that in France, many associations, many organizations that had expressed their concerns, including in meetings they had requested with me, can be satisfied regarding the volume of credits planned for their program.

Finally, the last commitment I made, still before the European Parliament, was that we could engage in a more equitable resource system and begin to chip away at the rebates, discounts, and refunds. I knew that there was no possibility of challenging the British rebate since you know it is provided for in the treaty and is therefore immutable until the day the treaty itself is renegotiated and that the British must keep this in mind, including when they request a modification of the treaty. But on the other hand, it was possible to cap a certain number of discounts, rebates, or refunds, which has been done and which has allowed France to save 140 million euros per year on the financing of these rebates. This is a reversal of trend because for thirty years, France had been contributing increasingly to the financing of this system, but at the same time, I am aware that we have not yet arrived at a true overhaul of the finances of the European Union and the introduction of genuine own resources.

That is why I believe this is an agreement that corresponds not to everything we could have wished for but at least to the commitments I made before the European parliamentarians and before the French: preservation of common policies, support for growth, action towards the most vulnerable Europeans, the youth and the most disadvantaged, and finally the introduction of a new resource system.

However, this agreement, which was reached at 27, and it was not without difficulty and until the last moment, and we spent hours on it, quite a night, a whole night, but this agreement that was made at 27, which took into account all the diversities that existed, geographical diversity, economic diversity, political diversity, diversity of demands, it required unanimity, this agreement that was reached among the heads of state and government, is not enough since now it will be necessary for the European Parliament to give its consent, that is the rule of the double decision. A discussion, a negotiation with the European Parliament will now begin, and the process of the European financial framework now depends on the will of the majority of the European Parliament that must be respected and convinced. The European parliamentarians had wished for a larger envelope of credits and also higher payment credits and surely different distributions. Now, the fact that there is an agreement at 27 is an important act whose significance everyone must measure, but I respect the European Parliament and I hope that discussions can begin between the leaders of the European Union and the different political groups that make up the European Parliament.

I am ready to answer your questions.

QUESTION - It indeed gives the impression, hearing you, that this is a fantastic success. However, this is the second financial perspective in a row that results in a decrease in constant euros, while the Union is integrating more and more each day and you yourself and some of your partners want more integration, and the figures are nonetheless stubborn. When we see that David CAMERON came here demanding 885 billion euros in payment credits and we end up at about 908 in payment credits, I have the impression of a victory on the battlefield for David CAMERON.

When I see that Chancellor Angela MERKEL has rather supported David CAMERON than you, I have serious doubts about the solidity of the Franco-German axis, which has not really been displayed during these two nights of negotiations. So I find it hard to see how these financial perspectives are a success. Second question: you spoke of a certain flexibility between the years and the expenditures; I wanted to know if you meant the headings, that is to say, for example, that we could move from the CAP heading to food aid, for instance? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, the old debate, "who won, who lost"? Who took the biggest step forward or the most obvious step back? Let's look at the figures. I am not talking about the previous financial framework; I was not there. I am talking about this one. I started with a payment credit envelope that could have been 30 billion euros. We are at 908.4, which is 21.6 below what the upper range of my approach could have hoped for. The British side, you mentioned 885, so we arrive at 908.4; there has therefore been an effort of 23 billion euros on that side. You can make the comparisons. There is a compromise; everyone has done their part. Did I not already consider the idea of making it 913 billion euros, since at one point the question was at 913? Yes, and I conceded 908.

At that moment, the British side was at 900. So I, if I may say so, decreased by 5 when I can say that on the other side, they increased by 8. But I will not say that because there are discrepancies in figures, there are discrepancies in performances. I try to see the European interest. I could very well not have made the agreement. What would have been the consequence? The budget would have become annual; it would have been very difficult to engage in long-term projects, which would not have been good for Europe. I saw the European interest because for many cohesion countries, they asked me; they wanted an agreement over several years for their own development. I ensured the European interest because on agriculture, I think it was appropriate to make an evolution and not simply reproduce what existed until then. I wanted an agreement because, from a European perspective, I considered that the expenditures that were increasing the most were those for growth, those for infrastructure, connectivity, energy, research, and innovation. I wanted the agreement because I considered that the priority given to youth was reflected in the proposals I was able to make and which were retained, the fund for youth, which will be an element of cohesion policy.

Now, if you ask me: is this the budget you would have wanted to see adopted? If I had been alone, no. But I often say, the problem of Europe is that we are not alone and that around the table, there are not just people of your nationality, and even when we have people of our own nationality, it is not always simple to reach an agreement.

But my responsibility was to propose the agreement that seemed to me to be the best possible in the context and circumstances. The context is the fact that, from a budgetary perspective, many countries are in difficulty and do not want to allocate, rightly or wrongly, additional expenditures to the European plan. A few months ago, or even a few years ago, there had even been an agreement between France, the United Kingdom, and Germany to reduce the European budget. I was not on that line, and France is not on that line, but at the same time, I knew there was this pressure. Then we are not in just any circumstances because for many countries, for many political leaders, there was also the concern to keep national interests present in the European budget, and everyone came to seek what they wanted, as we have seen; and so it seemed necessary to me to prioritize a European interest, beyond national interests. That is why I consider that, in this context and under these circumstances, at 27, I do not say that under a majority rule, it would have been the same result, but at 27, it was the best possible compromise and with a level of commitment of 960 billion euros, and whatever is said, these are the commitments that correspond to the expenditures of the European Union.

As for flexibility, I introduced it, and there was consensus in this regard, and it was not a given, and I thank all the countries that subscribed to it, with this same spirit of responsibility the President of the European Commission will also make a statement on this, the maximum flexibility. What does maximum flexibility mean? Precisely, that will be the subject of the discussion between the President of the European Union, the Irish Prime Minister, the President of the Commission, and the President of the European Council with the European Parliament, precisely to go as far as possible in flexibility, in the freedom that the Parliament would have to move credits from one heading to another and from one year to another, to convince a qualified majority of European parliamentarians to vote for this agreement.

QUESTION - You just mentioned the Parliament. Have you already received assurances from the Parliament's leaders that the agreement would receive a favorable reception from the parliamentarians? Are you assured of this? Do you fear or anticipate this evening a possible rejection of the text by the parliamentarians?

THE PRESIDENT - I have respect for the European Parliament, and no one could commit on behalf of the European Parliament in one direction or another. The European Parliament will now examine the agreement that was concluded at 27 among heads of state and government. The European Parliament will surely ask for explanations on the issue of flexibility, on the gap between commitments and payments, and the European Parliament will have to assess the financial framework that will be presented to it. But I can tell you that I have constantly warned my colleagues, saying: it is good, we are seeking an agreement, and it is necessary, and we must take into account everyone's positions because that is the rule of unanimity; one country can block. But we must know that we are no longer alone in deciding; there is now a change in the institutional landscape since the Lisbon Treaty; now, it is the double decision. So we cannot overlook or ignore the European Parliament because it will have to consider the financial framework that will be proposed to it. I must also say that Martin SCHULTZ's intervention yesterday afternoon was perfectly clear on what he considered to be lines that could or could not be crossed to get the financial framework voted on, that is to say, the European budget.

QUESTION - Two questions: a question of precision on the Common Agricultural Policy, first of all, if you will; it seemed to me that in the last budgetary exercise, the CAP budget was 421 billion euros and that there will be a decrease of 47 billion euros; as you said in substance that French farmers would not be impacted, I wonder if ultimately this decrease will not impact other European countries, that is my first question. And a second question, a bit of follow-up, I believe you did not have time to respond: we felt at this summit, shall we say, a united front between Angela MERKEL and David CAMERON and on the other hand perhaps the absence of a Franco-German axis. Do you confirm this feeling?

THE PRESIDENT - First on agricultural policy, to be completely precise, it is true that the relative share of agricultural expenditures in the European budget will decrease, but I have ensured that agricultural expenditures intended for our farmers are preserved. For direct aids, in the previous financial framework, it was 48.9 billion that our farmers received.

In the next financial framework, we will be around 47-47.5. For rural development, in the previous financial framework, it was 8.6 billion; we will be at 8.8 billion in the next. This means that in constant euros, I say in constant euros, which is an additional guarantee, there is stability, even a progression since it takes into account the rise in prices. And as you have perfectly described and expressed, this means that France maintains its agricultural expenditures in the CAP budget while other countries will see their credits decrease.

French agriculture has not only been preserved but consolidated, and it will have access to both direct aids and rural development with, for my part, a particular concern for breeders and surely reforms that will need to be made to the Common Agricultural Policy; that will come now, the whole question of capping or solidarity between animal and plant productions - so I consider that it is - I dare not say a success because I do not want to enter into such considerations; it is not for me to judge myself, but I consider that the objective is achieved, especially when we compare our situation to that of our neighbors who do not necessarily have the same agricultural structures.

Now on the axes, frankly in this European Council, there was a will to reach an agreement. It was not given in advance, and there were obvious differences between the British position and the French position; I described them as starting points and endpoints; there were also differences on the latitude to have on rebates, discounts, checks; there were even differences on the structure of expenditures, and we made sure to defend our points of view and preserve a number of situations: the British rebate and for us the agricultural policy. But it was necessary not to simply look at our respective national interests but to have a European interest; at least I had that. As for Mrs. MERKEL, the Chancellor, she favored the agreement as much as possible. And I also made sure that certain countries, as she did, could also be considered with great regard; I think of the countries that suffer the most from the recession: Spain, Portugal, Greece, Italy, and there too we were able to work together, Mrs. MERKEL and I, and I must say that the agreement on commitments, Mrs. MERKEL was with me on payments; she could have a more nuanced approach, but there too we found the compromise.

QUESTION - So there are winners; you have preserved, you tell us, the Common Agricultural Policy, at least for France, the regional policies; where are the losers? When we look, for example, at the budget initially proposed by the Commission, we are at 100 billion euros less than the Commission's proposals, so where did you find and who loses these 100 billion?

THE PRESIDENT - What needed to be done was for all countries to be able to find themselves as winners. What is true is that Europe has not necessarily won as much as it could have. That is to say, it accepted that the budget, given the circumstances I have described, the economic conditions, the difficulties of states to manage their own public account recovery, Europe did not give itself a budget of the magnitude that the Commission or the European Parliament might have wished. But within the envelope, each country was able to find at one point what it was looking for: the cohesion countries, the maintenance of a certain number of mechanisms, the countries with an agricultural vocation, the preservation of the Common Agricultural Policy, but what I wanted was for growth expenditures to also find their place.

The administration has therefore been reduced; savings have been found on certain expenditures; better management will surely be necessary, but we have also ensured that solidarity could find its place: solidarity towards the most disadvantaged; I mentioned the program for food aid, but I also mentioned the development aid program, solidarity towards others. And I prefer to say that, in an agreement, if there had been a loser, it would have prevented the agreement; therefore, it was necessary for everyone to be able to consider themselves as at least having preserved a situation and above all having given the best budget within the binding framework that we know, to Europe. But the framework is binding; I cannot say otherwise because the initial proposal of the Commission was 100 billion more for the European budget, but I arrived in this situation.

QUESTION - The preservation of a number of issues you mentioned, such as the CAP, the cohesion policy, etc., has nonetheless been at the expense of so-called future expenditures, that is to say Title 1a, whose envelope is much less ambitious than it was initially. Have the 27 not lost sight along the way in this negotiation, have they not lost sight of the great promises of the growth pact concluded six months ago, and does this not raise another question, should we not put an end to what some might call a kind of British blackmail that recurs at every negotiation and means that indeed at every negotiation, certain ambitions must be revised downwards?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, there is what is called heading 1A, growth, and you know that I made it a priority the day after my election through the growth pact. The heading in question is increasing by 40%, which is considerable. 40%! There is no envelope or heading in the financial framework that is increasing as much! I spoke to you about agricultural policy, which is, overall, declining; the cohesion policy is also, in a certain way.

So, common policies have been at best stabilized, and growth policies have been able, within a constrained financial framework, to be largely stimulated, and this is true for the growth heading 40% - mainly for infrastructure, research/innovation, but also for programs for ERASMUS.

So, we have really respected the growth pact that was concluded last June. Now, regarding the fact that there is one country, but it is not the only one, because we talk a lot about the United Kingdom, but it is not the only country that did not want European spending to increase; there are even countries that have the paradox of asking for more for themselves and demanding less for Europe! It is not easy, after stabilizing, reducing spending, to ask for more! It happens, I will not name them to avoid compromising them, but until the last moment, we see some who did not want agricultural policy, who asked for rural development credits, it happened! - I am putting you on the trail - and others who did not want cohesion spending because they find themselves too rich, who asked for their regions, because even in a rich country, there are poor regions! It is not just the United Kingdom that wanted a reduction in spending.

There is not a single country that took the rest of the 26 under pressure, to say the least. So what I wanted was for even these countries to be able, in relation to their own demands, to take a step and a big step. 960 billion euros was ultimately what Mr. VAN RUMPUY proposed at the end of the European Council as a possible agreement last time.

It is on payment credits that the most difficult debate took place, and there can be no way out of this difficulty other than through maximum flexibility, that is to say the capacity that Parliament will have to actually play with the headings and play with the years, and we should achieve that. But you know that what interested the United Kingdom was also to keep its rebate, but it was assured that even if there was a failure, so to speak, it would still keep its rebate. This is not the case for all countries, which would lose their refunds and discounts at that time if there was no agreement. This made them more amenable to the agreement.

QUESTION - On another subject, Mr. President, a former American ambassador to Mali claims on our airwaves that France, under the previous mandate, would have paid 17 million dollars to obtain the release of hostages in the Sahel, do you have any information on this? And more broadly, what is your policy regarding negotiations with kidnappers?

THE PRESIDENT - I do not have information on the previous period; I therefore have no comments to make on how hostages may have been released, and I speak conditionally. What I know is that today, and you know the situation in Mali, we are seeking contacts, but there are no financial questions that can be raised. But we will do everything to free our compatriots.

QUESTION - There is a related issue to the budget, which is that of the strong euro and the establishment of a currency policy in Europe: Pierre MOSCOVICI, the Minister of Economy, has estimated a 0.3 point loss for growth forecasts with this strong euro; does this mean that as of today, you foresee a revision of growth and lowering the forecast from 0.8 to 0.5 if we follow Pierre MOSCOVICI's reasoning?

THE PRESIDENT - A currency policy must be implemented and assessed over time, meaning that what matters is not so much the daily and even weekly fluctuations of the euro against other currencies like the dollar, yen, or others, but to have a realistic exchange rate objective over time. And in recent weeks, there had been a rise in the euro to levels that seemed to me not to correspond to the state of the European economy, even if it was a sign of the regained confidence in the eurozone.

I must say that the statements of the President of the European Central Bank (an independent institution) have had their effect since, in recent days, the level of the euro has depreciated or appreciated less. But what I wish is that we could - this was not the framework today and it was not on the agenda - but in the Eurogroup, it is also its competence to say what the strategy of the eurozone is in relation to other monetary areas, what the strategy is in relation to international currencies with which the euro is competing, that is to say, we can see when a currency appreciates. This had been the case in recent months by 11%.

This has favorable consequences; we pay less for our raw materials, our imports. It has less favorable consequences because our exports are also more expensive.

What is not necessarily the same for different European economies with the same consequences. There are countries that can export, even with an expensive currency, and others, given their industrial specialization situation, do not necessarily have that ability. This is the case for France. And that is why we must also improve our competitiveness. But if we let the euro appreciate beyond what would be its equilibrium parity, even with efforts at competitiveness, we will struggle with exports. But I told you, this is not the day we addressed these issues, and I must say that the European Central Bank and notably its president have allowed, through their statements and interventions, to return to a level of the euro compatible with the real economy.

And so, in the short term, in the very short term, there may be an influence, but it can only be measured in the medium term. For now, there is no impact on growth. The impact on growth is much more provoked by the recessions we are experiencing in certain countries in Europe. It was all the more important to reach an agreement on the budget because, for these countries, cohesion funds, structural funds will also allow them to support their growth and therefore ours.

QUESTION - Mr. President, the Parliament has just indicated that it refuses to accept the multiannual budget as it stands. What does that mean? What does that imply? Will it be necessary to renegotiate?

THE PRESIDENT - The Parliament has not met. Its leaders have made statements in recent hours saying that on this basis, they could question themselves.

The European Parliament, through its political groups, will now take up the financial framework that has been concluded by the heads of state and government, evaluate it, and then the European Parliament will have to express its opinion.

This is truly European democracy that is progressing. I do not complain at all that there is a European Parliament that poses a number of conditions or principles. So, after that, we need to discuss! And what is interesting is that there are heads of government, and it can happen to me as a head of state, who, when there is a European discussion, mention their national Parliament to say: "I cannot go further because I do not yet have the support or backing of my own Parliament." Well, when we discuss at the European level, we must also think about what the European Parliament can or cannot accept, and this has been present in our discussions throughout these last hours.

QUESTION - Two questions on foreign policy if you allow me. On Syria, there have been conclusions, perhaps not a deep debate. We seem to be reaching an impasse in Syria. Do you think it is time to move on: either to a political solution or to lift the arms embargo? Furthermore, regarding Hezbollah - There is a request, I believe, from Bulgaria for sanctions against Hezbollah. What is France's position on listing Hezbollah on the EU's terrorist lists?

THE PRESIDENT - So these two questions that are on people's minds, and you are perfectly right to raise them, were not addressed in this European Council. Not simply because the agenda was busy, but because on Syria, the embargo exists on arms and it can only be lifted - some countries are considering it - if we are sure that there is no longer any possibility of a political dialogue. However, just in recent days, the president of the national coalition had opened the idea of a possible conversation with the Syrian vice president. The mediator, Mr. BRAHIMI, despite the damning assessment he has made of the situation in Syria, is still in the idea of finding a political solution. Regarding the Bulgarian request, it has not yet been expressed and addressed. So let us wait for all the elements of the investigation's conclusion to draw all the consequences. Thank you.