Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the discussions regarding the budget of the European Union, in Brussels on November 23, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

23 November 2012 · Press conference on the discussions regarding the budget of the European Union · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Hollande addressed a press conference at the European Council in Brussels on November 23, 2012, during negotiations over the EU's multiannual financial framework budget.
Main themes
EU multiannual financial framework budget negotiations, Common Agricultural Policy, cohesion funds, EU budget volume, rebates and corrections, European growth priorities, French national interests, European solidarity, structural funds, rural development, outermost regions
Duration
~27 min
79th percentile
Words
3,270
79th percentile
Sentences
136
77th percentile
Readability
54
73rd percentile
Grade
11.1
33rd percentile
Syntax
3.14
66th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

136 sentences in 46 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT -- "Ladies and gentlemen, I want to first talk about the method that has been adopted before addressing the content of the proposal that is currently under discussion.

On the method: I believe it was the right one. The President of the European Council and the President of the Commission met bilaterally with all the heads of state and government based on a document that had already been presented by Mr. VAN ROMPUY. This explains why the European Council did not truly begin until around 10:00 PM.

Then, based on these discussions, the President of the European Council made a new proposal that was submitted to the heads of state and government, who will therefore spend the night closely examining it, and around noon tomorrow, there will be a new meeting of the European Council to seek, if everyone wishes, a compromise.

That is the method, and it has allowed for progress to be made.

What I advocated, on behalf of France, in this meeting with the President of the European Council and the President of the Commission, is to start from a global volume that allows Europe to control its spending while financing its priorities.

It is based on the VAN ROMPUY document that I considered the discussion should open.

Furthermore, I had already specified several days ago that the two pillars of European policy, namely the Common Agricultural Policy and the cohesion funds, had been too diminished by the President of the European Council in his initial proposal.

Not that I am only defending France's interests by mentioning the Common Agricultural Policy. I am committed to growth; it is legitimate that infrastructure, innovation, and research expenditures can have significant growth rates. But the Common Agricultural Policy, in its dual dimension of direct aid and rural development, contributes to growth, trade, foreign commerce, but above all to the quality of food and to a competitive agri-food industry across Europe that also creates jobs.

I am not the only one defending this policy. Other countries have accompanied me or I have accompanied them. I am not the leader of the Common Agricultural Policy, even if I am part of a French tradition. The Common Agricultural Policy was the first European policy. Now it has a relative weight that has diminished given the second pillar that has been established concerning the cohesion funds.

I also advocated for the reductions to be corrected because the cohesion funds, too, are policies for growth. Countries that receive structural funds, that create facilities, that launch infrastructure projects, that engage in energy transitions, contribute to supporting the growth of others. France is also concerned by the cohesion funds, less than others, but it is concerned nonetheless.

My position was: to maintain the overall volume of expenditures that had been proposed by the President of the European Council, while some countries still want reductions.

And within this envelope, to raise the respective shares of the Common Agricultural Policy and the cohesion funds.

Finally, France's position is to revisit the checks, rebates, and discounts. France is the second net contributor to the European Union.

France does not ask for a check, nor for rebates or discounts. France has a conception of European solidarity. There are countries that—due to their history, geography, and circumstances—must receive more than they give to European construction, and others—due to the strength of their economy, their population, and their financial capacity—must contribute more.

I cannot accept that the richest countries in the European Union come asking for checks, rebates, and discounts, and that France, on top of that, has to contribute to it. Everyone must make an effort.

On these three points, I have been partially heard. Heard, because in the new proposal from Mr. VAN ROMPUY, the Common Agricultural Policy is increased by 8 billion euros, but it is still lower than what the Commission's proposal had been.

Heard also because the cohesion funds have also been revised. And this allows France to assert, for the outermost regions, to which Mayotte is added, that these regions can receive more than was initially planned.

We have only been partially heard since I am not yet satisfied with what is planned for the Common Agricultural Policy. For the two pillars, direct aids as well as for rural development, and for the cohesion funds, we will have to discuss this again.

On the checks, rebates, and discounts, the position that Mr. VAN ROMPUY is taking is to ensure that all countries contribute to it. This is already a step forward, and we will have to revisit it tomorrow.

That is why at the European Council tomorrow, I will continue to defend the overall volume against countries that want to reduce European spending to levels that would not be compatible with what we decided last June. That is to say, to prioritize growth in all its dimensions, in all its aspects, and I will continue to advocate for the Common Agricultural Policy to be corrected in the best direction, that is to say, so that it is on the two pillars that we can improve the system.

Finally, on the cohesion funds, it will be a very long debate because many countries are concerned, and I will uphold the European spirit. I will continue, in the face of countries that either demand their check without any reduction or demand one when they have not had one until now, to be firm on the participation of all in this contribution.

There you have it, ladies and gentlemen, the current state of the discussion and what awaits us tomorrow. The work will resume late in the morning. At that point, we will enter the heart of the negotiation since based on Mr. VAN ROMPUY's document, countries will come with their own demands for some, proposals for others.

I am in favor of finding a compromise; it is in Europe's interest. I am here to defend France's interest. I was elected so that we can have a policy of growth, of employment, so that agricultural policy has its full dimension, so that there are regions that can be supported; that is my responsibility. But what I want is a Europe that moves forward, so I will report back to you at the end of tomorrow's Council.

I will add one last point, which is that the Lisbon Treaty means that today, what is called the European budget framework—that is to say, what will be decided for 7 years—must also be approved by the European Parliament in addition to the heads of state and government.

The President of the European Parliament was present at our discussions, and he emphasized this point, meaning that it is not enough for the heads of state and government to agree—this is necessary—it is also important that the European Parliament adopts this agreement or aligns with it. I know—the President Martin SCHULZ also mentioned it—that for most groups—I do not say all—present in the European Parliament, there is rather a consensus based on the proposal presented by the European Commission, by Mr. BARROSO. It is not said that on the volumes proposed by Mr. VAN ROMPUY, which are acceptable for France, there is necessarily agreement. But what I can tell you, what I am sure of, is that if there were a proposal that was below the figure currently presented by Mr. VAN ROMPUY, it is unlikely that the European Parliament would approve it.

Therefore, I think we must keep in mind that Europe is a democratic construction that means that heads of state and government must deliberate but also be aware that there is a European Parliament endowed with budgetary power. This was the advancement of the Lisbon Treaty and was rather welcomed.

I am ready to answer your questions."

QUESTION -- "A clarification and two questions. You say that you are not satisfied with the current level of the CAP. What level would satisfy you tomorrow, at what level would you say 'banco' to Herman VAN ROMPUY? David CAMERON wants to save 6 billion on the administrative costs of the Union's institutions, on payroll, etc. Has Herman VAN ROMPUY responded to this request, and what do you think about it? What are you willing to accept on this? Finally, how do you assess the chances of success of the Summit this evening? And when? Tomorrow, the day after tomorrow, it's up to you to say."

THE PRESIDENT -- "I will take several questions so that you can all express yourselves, and I will respond afterwards in a general manner."

QUESTION -- "To follow up a bit on what my colleague said, apparently Mr. VAN ROMPUY has proposed nonetheless to increase the CAP budget. This does not satisfy you, but perhaps you can tell us by how much he has agreed to increase the CAP? Similarly, he has proposed to increase the cohesion budget; can you also tell us by how much, and you told us that this was acceptable for you. Second point, is it true that the British have softened their position on the amount of the envelope? They wanted considerable reductions; the reductions they are asking for today would be less considerable, is that correct? Finally, Ms. MERKEL and other EU leaders think that in any case another Summit will be needed at the beginning of next year; is that your opinion as well?"

QUESTION -- "Mr. President, to talk about David CAMERON: do you consider him to be the least generous in budgetary matters, and did you find him isolated when you think of the concert of the 27?"

QUESTION -- "Mr. President, should the British check be put back on the table, and second question, have you met, have you had a one-on-one with David CAMERON, or have you seen him?"

QUESTION -- "You also appointed Mr. MERSCH to the ECB this evening; the decision has been validated. You speak to defend the European budget of the role of Parliament and its democratic aspect that must be respected, yet Parliament voted against Mr. MERSCH. How do you explain this contradiction? Thank you."

QUESTION -- "Mr. President, a clarification as well. You said that Mr. VAN ROMPUY wanted all countries to contribute in one way or another to the reduction of the amount of checks and rebates; could you please clarify exactly what the President of the Council's proposal is on this subject?"

QUESTION -- "Good evening, Mr. President, Camille LANGLADE from Europe 1, here, to perhaps talk about something else if you wish, a little comment on the difficulties of the French right today; I know this is completely off-topic, but I am taking my chance."

QUESTION -- "In your one-on-one with Angela MERKEL, was the Chancellor perfectly clear with you and did she explain to you to what extent she wanted to reduce the share allocated to the Common Agricultural Policy in the budget, or to what extent she supported you in your demands? In other words, do you both agree on what budget should be defended for the CAP? Thank you very much."

THE PRESIDENT -- "On the level of the Common Agricultural Policy: in the new proposal from Mr. VAN ROMPUY, there is an increase of 8 billion euros, but there had been a decrease of 25 billion compared to the Commission's proposal. For those still enlightened at this hour, that makes 17 billion, and for us, this reduction is still too significant. You ask me about France's position; I would say that a priori France's position is to restore the level of direct aids—I am indeed talking about the direct aids we had previously—and to stabilize them. After that, we will see how the discussion continues, but that is the position I have reaffirmed.

The second question on the level of cohesion, that is to say, what amount Mr. VAN ROMPUY—on his new proposal—considered it possible to evolve: about 10 billion euros. But once again, what will matter is not so much the amount—though it is already important to increase it—but the distribution among all the regions, since all countries come to the table—if I may express it that way—to obtain support for their regions, including the richest countries that necessarily have within them regions considered fragile. This is the case for France, where we have ten regions that currently benefit from cohesion funds that I intend to defend. And France also has a very great concern regarding the outermost regions, and it is true that Mayotte— which was not considered an outermost region—has been integrated, but we still have an effort to make so that the intensity of aid is increased for the outermost regions."

Next, on the administration: there are always radical proposals in these matters, I am not opposed to some corrections and, at the same time, I am aware that there are currently 27 members - soon to be 28 - that there are many missions that fall under the community authorities because they involve all institutions, including the European Parliament. You know how attached I am to the seat in Strasbourg, which is regularly called into question, and behind the budget cuts, there is also this target on Strasbourg. But again, I reiterate that Strasbourg is in the treaty and for France, it cannot be a question of modifying the treaty regarding the very seat of the European Parliament.

Regarding the British - specifically David CAMERON - I did not meet him at this stage. I spoke to him on the phone a few days ago and I know his position. It is not the same as France's. Are there countries that are asking for even more reductions than the British? There may be, but that will not provide more support for that thesis, because - as I told you - it is not simply a matter of confrontation between countries. If the Heads of State and Government were to decide to set the bar too low, then there would not be the agreement of the European Parliament and we would revert to a budget that would have to be decided and defined annually. Who would benefit the most? Perhaps France, so if I were to look solely at France's interests, I could engage in this discussion hoping for a non-agreement. That is not my position, because I defend France but also Europe, so I wish for a negotiation that leads to a successful outcome.

Another question regarding the position of the British, particularly the rebate. The rebate can no longer be discussed in terms of its calculation method. However, the question is: who participates in the payment of the rebate? This refers in particular to the payment of all the other rebates that do not have the same status as the British rebate. I take an illustration, if there were no agreement at all, the European Parliament would therefore have to approve each year with the Heads of State and Government a budget. The British rebate would be preserved, but not the other rebates. The British rebate is therefore not the only one at stake, but the position that Mr. VAN ROMPUY has taken up in his latest proposal - a general contribution from all countries to finance the rebates - is a minimum for France, because France cannot accept being the country that, through all these rebates, would see its contribution increased over the next seven years. Hence the idea I expressed of capping France's participation at the current level, which is a reasonable position. It should not participate more; it is, moreover, a backward solidarity.

On British isolation, we have not yet had the time, collectively, to express ourselves. There have been bilateral meetings, either between Heads of State and Government among themselves - that was my case with Mrs. MERKEL and I will return to that - or between the Heads of State and Government and the President of the European Council accompanied by the President of the European Commission. I cannot therefore tell you today what the position of such or such country is; I can imagine it, after the new version of the VAN ROMPUY document. I will tell you tomorrow based on the agreement that has been reached or the absence of agreement.

I come to the question: what are the chances of success? If everyone is willing, we can achieve it as soon as tomorrow or the day after. If it is necessary to give time to time, to reach an agreement that can gain everyone's approval, that is probably the wise position that will be adopted. But we cannot prejudge that today, because that would mean that, ultimately, what we are doing does not matter. However, there have already been progress and advances, and now there is a clarification for each country based on this document that is expected tomorrow. France's attitude, and my position, is to seek a compromise as much as possible but not to consider that if we do not succeed tomorrow or the day after, it would be irreparable. At that point, we would have to revert to the exceptional procedure that we know of voting by qualified majority - because it would be by qualified majority - the annual budget of the European Union.

Another question that was asked of me is what did we discuss with Mrs. MERKEL? You often ask me this question and I always give you the same answer, we seek compromise and we do it in a good spirit, and again we found common ground to review Mr. VAN ROMPUY's initial document as long as both of us accepted that there would be an increase in the Common Agricultural Policy and an increase in cohesion funds. We had to find lower expenditures, lower increases in expenditures elsewhere as the President of the European Commission and the President of the European Council had envisioned. On this, we found agreement and it is an important position. Now, are Mrs. MERKEL and I completely aligned on the level of expenditure? Well, we will see tomorrow, but I find that it was rather a useful first step of convergence. That does not mean total convergence of our positions, because even on cohesion funds, each one - and it is quite legitimate - defends the interests of their regions and thus their country.

Since you mention Mrs. MERKEL, we also discussed the question of Greece, since last Tuesday there was a meeting of the Eurogroup, the agreement was very close, there are still a few technical details to clarify, there was another group that worked this evening, perhaps even tonight, and will continue to do so. There is a Eurogroup meeting scheduled for next Monday, we must work to ensure that this time there is an agreement for Greece.

Regarding the European Parliament and the appointment of Mr. MERSCH, the European Council - that is the only decision it has made at this stage - has approved the appointment of Mr. MERSCH, which it had already done at the summit on June 28 and 29. The European Parliament contested this choice, particularly regarding the lack of - I do not even dare to say parity since there are only men on the Executive Board of the Central Bank. It did not seem possible to correct this decision, since there had been an agreement in this Council for the Eurogroup to continue to be chaired by Mr. JUNCKER without that preventing Mr. MERSCH from accessing the Executive Board. The only country that opposed this - and I perfectly understood, he had warned me - is Spain.