Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the European Union investment plan and the situation in Ukraine, in Brussels on December 18, 2014.

France François Hollande · President of France

18 December 2014 · European Council · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Hollande addressed a Brussels press conference on December 18, 2014, following an exceptional European Council focused on the Juncker investment plan and EU taxation reforms.
Main themes
Juncker investment plan, European Council meeting, EU economic growth, private and public financing, stability pact flexibility, energy transition and digital infrastructure, EU taxation reform, tax ruling and optimization, automatic exchange of tax information, Franco-German cooperation, European Investment Bank, Ukraine situation
Duration
~54 min
95th percentile
Words
6,531
95th percentile
Sentences
353
96th percentile
Readability
60
87th percentile
Grade
9.4
14th percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

353 sentences in 100 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

This was an exceptional European Council, first of all exceptionally short, and secondly because it was the first time it was chaired by Donald TUSK with Jean-Claude JUNCKER as President of the Commission.

It was also exceptional because it was the adoption of a plan that France had long wished for and initiated. Because during the first European Council in June 2012, there had already been a first plan for growth, but this time, with the JUNCKER plan, we are on a different scale and with a different mechanism.

The scale is 315 billion euros over three years and with a mechanism that calls for not only public financing, as provided, but also private financing, since there will be funding coming from both lending institutions and the companies themselves.

Regarding the mechanism, it will allow the contributions from States that will be added to the fund to capitalize it further to be considered by the European Commission as not falling within the definition of the stability pact obligations. This will not prevent investments from being made by States or regions. For example, for France, there can be not only capital intervention for this European fund coming, for example, from the Caisse des dépôts, but also from the Public Investment Bank.

And then at the national level, there will be investments that can be perfectly defined and decided by the State but also by the regions within the framework, for example, of the State-region planning contracts that are currently being signed.

So we can see that there is a European plan that will be all the more important as it can be accompanied. In this sense, I have said, I emphasize the fact that there are contributions to the capital of this fund that can be evaluated by the European Commission outside the notions of the Stability Pact.

On the nature of the investments, we, France, had wished that they be future investments, those that we support at the national level: energy transition, digital technology, infrastructure, connectivity, training.

We will therefore be able to participate even more in this investment plan as we have already identified the projects that we will present in France. The European Commission has entrusted the European Investment Bank with the task of selecting the projects, and surely projects that have a European character and concern several countries will be looked at with interest and goodwill. And I met with the President of the Spanish Council of Ministers as well as the Prime Minister of Portugal, and there will surely be projects that we will present together, particularly those concerning electrical infrastructure. Similarly, with the Chancellor, we have already identified the projects that France and Germany can present together.

Finally, the European Council also had this same approach, so that the JUNCKER plan can be engaged quickly. There are legal procedures that are necessary since the European Parliament will have to give its opinion. And it will therefore be in the first half, at the end of the first half of next year that the JUNCKER plan will truly have the legal form allowing it to be fully mobilized. But I consider that June 2015 is still late. And so a pre-financing has been made available for the projects that will be presented, so that very early in January, in February, the European Investment Bank can ensure the advance of a number of selected projects. There is therefore no time lost.

I also want to mention a second topic that was addressed in this Council, which is that of taxation.

You know that there have already been significant advances made in recent months at the initiative of France, Germany, the United Kingdom, ultimately of practically all countries, even convincing those who were the most reluctant perhaps also because they had the most interests.

So, the first step was the automatic exchange of information. You have already seen the consequences that this has had in terms of tax revenue for France through compatriots who came to settle a number of oversights, or funds placed abroad that have been repatriated. So, this is the automatic exchange of information, and also the lifting of banking secrecy, which is a powerful stimulus to clarify a number of operations and to put a number of situations in order. There is also the fight against tax havens that has been initiated.

And today, it was what is called tax optimization. There are practices that lead States and companies to propose advantageous tax formulas. This is the tax ruling, to stay within the vocabulary used for these procedures. In French, we call this the rescrit fiscal, not sure that it is much clearer for those who hear us, but at least it is in French. This means that all operations that were decided in advance to set a particularly favorable rate can no longer be implemented by the States that practiced this kind of facilitation. This is another important step in the fight against tax evasion that has just been decided.

This is what has been the meaning of what we have decided today. We did not take much time to decide because there was already a broad consensus that presided over the preparation of the JUNCKER plan, and thus its adoption. And what I want to highlight this evening is that this JUNCKER plan can have a much greater effect than one might imagine. For two reasons. The first is the confidence it can inspire. Europe is aware that it is necessary to support demand, to support investments, to provoke a movement so that future investments can be decided in a timely manner. And then there is a second effect, which is that 315 billion is a base that can itself lead to other co-financing being added. That is why we cannot truly know what the actual scale of this JUNCKER plan will be. Some have doubted that with 20-25 billion euros of public financing, it would be possible to reach 315 billion in investments. We can clearly see that the game of guarantees, the game of co-financing, the way to associate other funding, all of this can have a snowball effect.

The second major topic is Ukraine. We discussed it during the dinner that followed the European Council.

There was a broad convergence to first help Ukraine given the humanitarian situation that has once again been described as particularly dramatic throughout Ukraine. And that there is a need to provide as quickly as possible all means of support to the population, and to facilitate the delivery of this EU aid to Ukraine. This has not been possible in recent weeks.

There is also the political question, that is to say the implementation of the Minsk agreement. All Europeans feel committed to the Minsk agreement, more precisely to the respect of the Minsk agreement, since they are not signatories.

It is the Ukrainians who wanted this agreement and who must implement it, particularly on the side of the separatists. And so on the Russian side, this obligation is placed on them to move towards not only a ceasefire but the withdrawal of weapons, the withdrawal of troops, the release of prisoners, the respect of the demarcation line and also of the borders.

And so there was no decision to raise the level of sanctions since there is currently a process that is once again underway. The ceasefire is being respected or more precisely, there have been no deaths since it was proclaimed again. But we are still far from it; there needs to be new progress, particularly for the release of prisoners, for the respect of the demarcation line, and the withdrawal of weapons.

A few days ago, I had a discussion with Ms. MERKEL in what is called the Normandy format, with President POROSHENKO and President PUTIN. We will have to verify that what we established during this discussion can be applied as of Sunday or Monday, with the possibility of the contact group.

Throughout the coming days, we will have to look very closely at whether the Minsk agreement is being applied in all its dimensions. In March next year, there will be a European Council that will evaluate the situation. And it is possible that before this date, there will be progress; we demand it.

So there have been no new sanctions since we are in this process, and if there is to be a relaxation of sanctions, it will be based on the progress that has been observed.

I want to conclude on the economic question, which is serious. What is happening throughout the region. First in Ukraine, where it is very difficult for the Ukrainian government, for President POROSHENKO to revive the Ukrainian economy. Hence the challenge of the support that Europe must provide through the association agreement, but also through a number of decisions regarding the supply to Ukraine.

There is also the question of the Russian economy, which is surely experiencing a difficult and delicate situation due to sanctions, as well as the drop in oil prices. Russia must understand well that we all have an interest, Russians, Ukrainians, Europeans, and more broadly the global economy, in having an exit from the crisis. This is what we are working towards, and you know that I have been involved in this with Ms. MERKEL for several months and even in recent hours, I will surely have the opportunity to do so again in the coming days. The end of the year is an important moment since we must try to achieve as much progress as possible before it ends.

Questions/answers:

- Yes, Mr. President, good evening. Pascal VERDEAU, France3. On Russia, I have the impression that this is the first time we hear you use the expression "exit from the crisis." Earlier, Ms. MOGHERINI was calling for a radical change in behavior on the part of President PUTIN. Following the bilateral meeting you had, do you consider that President Putin is ready to change his behavior? In other words, is he ready to ease off in this strategy of tension in Ukraine, or does he want to maintain the conflict at a low simmer?

We will see the outcome in a few days. What we have already been able to observe, including with the visit I made to Moscow and the Normandy format meeting we had with Ms. MERKEL, President POROSHENKO, and President PUTIN, we have already had a number of beginnings: the ceasefire, which is being respected. The willingness to move towards a withdrawal of arms. A pressure that President PUTIN says he is exerting for the separatists to release prisoners. Finally, the implementation of the Minsk agreement in all its dimensions. So we will have the opportunity to verify this. And I prefer to place myself, given these first steps which are still insufficient but exist, I prefer to place myself in the hypothesis of an exit from the crisis.

If there were an exit from the crisis, we would have to observe it—but we must go to the end of the Minsk Protocol. The Minsk Protocol states that there must be local elections that allow for decentralization within the framework of the integrity of Ukraine.

So there are still several steps before we can definitively set our point of view, but I have noted the beginning of the emergence of a process, and that France's role is to promote it.

What we have decided as Europeans, all in solidarity, is to be firm on this process so that it succeeds, and at the same time open so that there can be a possible exit from the crisis. And on this, there is total unity among Europeans.

I also note that the United States at this moment have not taken any positions other than these. No other sanctions. And let’s see if this process that is beginning to emerge can lead to results, with the possibility of a gradual lifting of sanctions, if of course progress is observed.

- To stay on Russia, I want to ask you how concerned you are about the economic situation. Do you think this could be dangerous, for example, for Europe? And my second question, still on the economic situation in Russia: have we ultimately gone too far with Western sanctions, because we can see, of course, there is also the price of oil—that ultimately the effects may be stronger than what was expected?

When the decision was made to impose sanctions, it was indeed so that they would have consequences. Because otherwise, they should not have been taken. You remember what the form of Russian intervention was. That is to say, notably Crimea, and then the presence of armaments, to say the least, including in the eastern regions. So these sanctions were necessary. They have produced their effects. And I had also specified that when sanctions are decided, they have consequences for the countries that are targeted, in this case Russia, but also for the countries that decide on these sanctions, which has indeed happened.

Afterwards, there is the drop in oil prices which obeys multiple logics, which cannot be reduced to the Ukrainian or Russian question. But today there is an imbalance between supply and demand, and surely an update of an oil reserve that justifies the drop in oil prices. This has consequences for the economies of producing countries. Russia is one of them. It also has consequences for the United States, in a different way, particularly for the investments that could be made in what is called shale gas.

For Europe, I must say - at least for France - this is not a bad situation. If I look at it from the strict perspective of France, the drop in oil prices has a favorable economic effect, both for supply and for demand. Both for competitiveness and for purchasing power. So I will not lament the drop in oil prices. And the French are the first to be able to benefit from it, to some extent, since the price of oil only accounts for 30% of the price of fuels.

This has consequences for the Russian economy, especially the drop in the ruble, we must be careful, and ensure that the Russians, within the framework of a political process in Ukraine, do not expose themselves further. And that is why I say that an exit from the crisis in Ukraine would be good news for the entire economy of the region and for the European economy.

- Mr. President, two questions to stay on Russia and Ukraine. Does the fact that the Russian sailors who were training on the Mistral-type BPC ship have left Saint-Nazaire mean that this contract is definitively abandoned? And secondly, regarding the JUNCKER plan, you talk about the 315 billion euros and you have indeed mentioned the questions that can be raised from the 8 and 21 billion euros, which should, through leverage, lead to these 315 billion. Do you think there can be any doubt about this figure of 315 billion that some even wish to exceed, or do you feel today that these 315 billion, whatever happens, will be reached?

First question: the Russian sailors left Saint-Nazaire without the Mistral. They were not going to stay and wait for the coming days, since we are in a hypothesis that I have recalled several times: for now, there is not enough progress for there to be, from France's perspective, the delivery of these Mistrals. There you go, there is nothing more to say. I hope that the process can, as I said, find its conclusion. That the Minsk protocol can be applied. At that moment, there will be the resolution of the contract. If that were not the case, we would have to draw a number of consequences from it.

On the second question you asked me, is there not ultimately a form of inflation - forgive me the expression - through the JUNCKER plan? We put billions like that thinking it will make an impression.

What the specialists, and notably the EIB, argue is that it is rather a relatively reasonable leverage effect that has been used. It could, given the guarantees, given the capitalization of this Fund, be a leverage effect of 1 to 20. They limited it to 1 to 15. But it is up to us to ensure that the leverage effect is even greater. I said it: the contributions from states, or state-linked institutions that will be brought to the capital of the European Fund, can further amplify the investment. What each of the concerned states can also contribute can also amplify the plan. So I think it is a reasonable estimate.

Can we do more? Yes, we need to do more. But here too, let’s avoid proclaiming figures. Let’s ensure that we can have more support points, thus more capital in the Fund, to have more financing in the end.

What matters most, beyond the figure, which can be more or less contested, even if I believe it will be exceeded, what matters most is the speed with which the funds that have been released can be used.

If we wait 1 year, 1 year and a half, we may be in a different situation. It is now that this must be put in shape, therefore in the coming days, to be made available in the coming months. That is to say, we must not lose time.

This is perhaps the most important decision that has been made, even if it will not necessarily be highlighted, it is the aspect of pre-financing. That we can immediately present projects, have them accepted, have them financed and already engage them. These are often quite heavy investments, when we look at an infrastructure plan - I mentioned what we are going to do with the Spaniards, the Portuguese for electrical infrastructures. If we do not immediately engage the sums, they will not be spent before 18 months. It is therefore very important that we can, given the nature of the works, be quick.

There are, however, expenses that can be made immediately. I want to give a few examples. Energy savings in buildings can be spent very quickly. High-speed digital can also be done within the year. Or training, since training will be eligible in a number of specialties or qualifications.

So it is necessary not only that the sums are there, but that they are spent quickly, so that the effect on demand is as decisive as possible.

- Hervé ASQUIN from AFP, we are currently observing a sort of alignment of economic planets: the drop in rates, which are at rock bottom, the euro also declining, oil prices, and this evening INSEE reports a slight economic recovery, even if unemployment will continue to rise in the first half of 2015. Is this the long-awaited tremor? The one you have been waiting for, I believe, since May 2012?

In May 2012, it was very difficult to imagine that there could be a recovery in growth while there was a crisis in the eurozone that was not resolved with uncertainties even about the future of the eurozone. Remember what the summer of 2012 was like. It took the words and even the actions of the president of the ECB to avoid the worst. What we thought was that in 2014 there could be a stronger recovery, already anticipated in 2013. That did not happen. There was growth that was too weak, 0.4% in 2014.

Now, we do indeed have better situations. Why? First, because on the monetary front, the eurozone is solid. Interest rates, even for the peripheral countries, which were therefore the most threatened, have fallen considerably. The ECB has also provided liquidity to banks. Banks have seen their situation restored. The banking union has been established. Prudential rules, and even verification of the situation of banks have been put in place. This is therefore the first positive situation.

The second positive situation is that today there is a very low oil price, an exchange rate of the euro that has lost 10% against the dollar in the last 6 months. There are also interest rates for France that are now below 0.90. Which in a period where we need to borrow, borrow a lot, because we have to manage the debt from 2010, is what is at stake right now - we can borrow at particularly low rates, which also has interesting effects on the budgetary front.

The third positive situation is the JUNCKER plan, the investments that will be implemented, and in a global context that is still rather favorable to growth, particularly in the United States. Emerging countries are experiencing, of course, a slowdown, but in China, around 8% growth.

So what uncertainties remain? It is the political situation, which we have talked about, which is a real uncertainty, what you said about Russia. What is happening in the Middle East is an uncertainty, which can also have consequences on the price of oil.

In the face of these uncertainties, what do we need to do? Well manage the political problems. But as we also have competitiveness issues in France, we have taken measures. As we also have a number of growth levers to use, we have presented to Parliament the text "growth and activity". It is not because there are better indicators, that there are more positive signals, that we should renounce taking decisions in France.

What does INSEE tell us in its latest economic note? It tells us that there would surely be a growth carryover in the first half of next year. In simple terms, this would mean that we would have practically done two-thirds of the way to achieve 1% growth by the end of 2015. Well, that is quite close. A 6-month forecast can be seen as rather secure. This means that the 1% growth projected in our 2015 budget will likely be achieved. I won’t say more.

Is 1% growth enough to reduce unemployment? No, because in France the active population is increasing, unlike what is happening in Germany or in many countries where demographics are very weak, or very little dynamic.

In France, we have a demographic situation that means we have about 150,000 newcomers to the labor market. We would need to achieve more than 1% growth. This is indeed what we have in perspective for 2016. But since we have a risk on growth regarding the objective of reducing unemployment, we must continue the policy of subsidized jobs, future jobs. We must continue to be even more competitive, hence the challenge of the responsibility pact, the competitiveness tax credit. We are obliged to do more in France because we need to have more growth.

But I do not complain about having this obligation. Because it is better to have a country that is experiencing an increase in its active population than the opposite. So even if this creates tension at the moment, and I measure it, with unemployment that for now is not decreasing, but increasing. We must ultimately achieve more growth than others. This is the objective that France must set for itself: to achieve more growth. Even more than others in the medium and long term. If we know how to use the JUNCKER plan well, to make the right investments, we will raise the level of our growth. If we know how to train our employees well, we will raise the level of growth. Hence the importance of the reforms we are undertaking.

There are currently negotiations between social partners on social dialogue, on employee representation. I spoke about the "activity and growth" law that will be debated. We need to put our country in motion even more to achieve even more growth.

I do not complain about these first signs that you have recalled, and about this growth forecast that leads us to think that at least we will be in line with what we said in the PLF and which had been somewhat doubted. There are always grumblers who say we will not reach 1% growth. I do not want to say more to avoid giving the impression of being overly optimistic. I want the French themselves to regain confidence. It is true that we are on track regarding our growth forecast for the year 2015.

Which, nonetheless, will also help us regarding budgetary issues. Because if we achieve 1% growth, it will be as much as we can realize to reduce the deficit.

- Regarding the JUNCKER plan, ultimately, perhaps the most important decision of the Council is that investment will not impact the Stability Pact? Did you have, particularly with Mrs. MERKEL, the discussion to further fund this plan? To say "we are really the Franco-German engine." Since there is no impact on the Stability Pact, why not say "let's put in 30 billion" since you talk about confidence? Investors are fleeing Europe because they do not have confidence. If you both had said "we are putting in 30 billion" it would have carried a bit more weight. Would a Franco-German gesture not have been interesting?

Investors are not leaving Europe. On the contrary, investors are present in Europe. But they are lending money for the coverage of sovereign bonds. That is not what we are looking for. We believe it is necessary for investors to come and invest for the creation of activities and jobs.

Second remark, could we have done more in terms of guarantees and equity for the Fund? I think we could certainly have done more. But this was not a question that concerned Germany and France. It concerned all European countries. However, we had already recapitalized the EIB. That was the first decision we made in June 2012. It is the EIB that allows us to have the equity that also enables us to invest. Everything that is in the form of guarantees is not new resources as such, but it allows the banking system or the financial system to contribute its own share, without risk since it is guaranteed. It is also the leverage effect.

What have we decided, and this is very important. I would like to be precise here as well to avoid fostering any illusions. What will be excluded from the Stability Pact is the decision of the European Commission, it is the contribution that a given State will make to the European Fund, known as the JUNCKER plan. The contribution from the State, either in the form of capital provided by the State itself, or capital provided by a public institution such as the Caisse des dépôts in France.

On the other hand, the investment, which can complement that of the European Fund—for example: we are building an infrastructure that costs 100. 60 are provided by the fund, 40 provided by the State or the region. That investment counts within the Stability Pact. It is therefore essential to clearly distinguish the contribution to the Fund from the investment that is added.

This is what we will do nonetheless. France, for example, will be able to contribute to the JUNCKER Fund either through the State itself or through the Caisse des dépôts. This will be deducted from the Stability Pact and will have a significant leverage effect for our own investments. We will still add the investments that will be in our public spending, thus within the Pact, but we will still make these investments. They are useful. These can be investments financed directly by the State, or by a local authority, or by the future investment plan, which also allows us to complement.

As for the leverage effect, you will see that it can be even more significant as private financing is added. The challenge is to be able to combine public financing and private financing. The 315 billion, if it is over 5 years, will have very little effect. If it is over 3 years, and committed right away, it can have an effect on growth as early as 2015 or 2016.

- We have heard you speak of this reorientation of Europe, which you wished for and promised during your presidential campaign. Are you not going a bit too fast? 315 billion is substantial, but in relation to the European economy, it is not that significant. On the other hand, budgetary discipline is maintained everywhere in Europe. Are you not announcing the reorientation a bit too quickly in a Europe that remains dominated by conservative governments?

I make the same observation. I cannot change them. French voters cannot decide for all European voters. But still: that governments—who, it is true, have different political sensitivities, but many of whom are liberal or conservative—have been able to decide on a plan, a demand stimulus plan!

That is what it is about, even if it involves investments—which themselves have a structural character, to promote sustainable growth—that there has been, on the part of the European Commission, even in recent weeks, but which has been true for a year now, the postponement of a number of disciplines, since we ourselves did not meet the 3% target by the scheduled date, I am not telling you anything new, and that other countries have had the same leniencies. There has also been an adaptation regarding what could be a policy of budgetary austerity.

And, thirdly, there has been an independent central bank. The ECB has made decisions that allow us to have particularly low interest rates. This is also an important point.

The reorientation of Europe, if I look at what the situation was in June 2012: it was austerity everywhere. These were particularly harsh plans, with particularly high interest rates and a willingness from Europe to not put anything more in place to support growth.

For the past two and a half years, there has been an investment plan, interest rates have fallen everywhere. The level of the euro has adjusted to a level more in line with the economic reality of Europe.

I could say an even more significant investment plan, but I could not say that I can hope for lower interest rates. We will quickly find a point of equilibrium.

So yes, Europe has been reoriented. It has been reoriented under our pressure, if we want to put things on our side, but that would be presumptuous. It has also been reoriented in light of the circumstances. Why? Because as soon as it ensured its financial stability, as soon as it realized that growth was not picking up as quickly as possible, or as hoped, and that there was even a risk that deficits would widen due to lack of growth, then Europe had to change.

- Philippe MORAND, TF1, you mentioned the "growth and activity" law presented by the Minister of Economy Emmanuel MACRON, and a debate has arisen on the left, particularly within the PS, regarding Sunday work.

Do you think there will be a strong majority to adopt this text in Parliament, and what impact do you expect this law to have on the French economy?

This bill has multiple aspects and is not limited to Sunday work.

If it were only about Sunday work, frankly, it would not be likely to stimulate employment and growth at the level we hope for. It is because this text includes many provisions on regulated professions, to allow for more openness. I believe the word that fits this law is openness. Openness of professions, openness of markets, for example, bus transport, openness of shops in certain circumstances, particularly in tourist areas. Openness so that employees can be more shareholders of their company. Openness to allow for more flexibility on a number of provisions concerning work or the company. That decisions made by the Labor Courts be quicker, which is good for employee protection and good for business visibility. That there be more rights for employees, for example, salary compensation where there is activity precisely at night or on Sundays. There are many provisions that will lead to growth and employment. And there have always been debates about Sunday work; I have always known them, and now I find that there is even a certain vision regarding tourist areas that is no longer debated.

What interests me is to know the position of the opposition. I do not hear them on this: on regulated professions, on employee savings, on competition for transport, on Sunday work. It is up to everyone to contribute to the debate. I think it is very important that we can show that this future law will be a law that will allow the country to move forward, while also providing additional rights.

You know, there is a principle that I have established, but it applies to other subjects: what are the best possible laws of freedoms? It is when additional rights are granted without taking away from others, as in this "activity and growth" law.

If we work a little more on Sundays for some, those who want to, in tourist areas for example, who does that take rights away from? No one! Since it will even allow for better compensation for the salaries of those who work at those hours. It takes nothing away from anyone. I find that it is a good example of what should be done.

- Good evening Mr. President, Hélène FOUQUET from Bloomberg news, two questions: you spoke about the role that France wants to play in this beginning of a way out of the crisis with Russia. Could you tell us concretely how you see this role? Who are your supporters among your European partners in this facilitator role with Russia? Separately, regarding Greece, can you talk about the concerns you have, that Germany has, and possibly those raised by Mr. SAMARAS regarding the likely early elections?

On Europe, it is unanimous in its position. The one expressed this evening: humanitarian and economic aid to Ukraine, and support for the process that allows for the implementation of the Protocol or the Minsk Agreement.

The High Representative, Ms. MOGHERINI, was in Kiev a few days ago and is playing her role. She is ensuring that there can be, on the part of the Ukrainians, since she was in Kiev, participation in this process, and as much as possible, to meet the conditions for aid to be provided to Ukraine.

There is the role that France, along with Germany, intends to play since that Normandy meeting. Thanks to Germany and France, and this has been perfectly understood by our partners, there have been advances. The best proof is that in Normandy, POROSHENKO and PUTIN spoke to each other for the first time, POROSHENKO having become President of Ukraine. This process was able to lead, by the way, to the Minsk Protocol.

Then it deteriorated since all the conditions that had been set by Minsk were not respected. It was at that moment that the sanctions were confirmed again.

In recent weeks, we have resumed the initiative. Why? Because, first, the two parties have talked a lot, POROSHENKO, PUTIN, and have resumed the Minsk process.

What do we expect from France and Germany? From France: I went to Moscow to verify that this process could indeed be engaged and that the ceasefire could be respected, it is there that President PUTIN was able to say that he recognized and respected the territorial integrity of Ukraine, which is a very important point for us.

In the coming days, I can confirm to you, we will continue to talk, with President PUTIN, President POROSHENKO, Angela MERKEL and myself, considering what will happen on Sunday or Monday, the meeting of the contact group.

We want to work and we want to move forward, and move quickly so that there can be further progress by the end of the year and more at the beginning of next year, to ensure that all the provisions of Minsk can be implemented.

That is the role of France. I think that in doing this, France and Germany, it was good that we were together, Angela Merkel and I. We have always worked together on this position regarding Ukraine and regarding Russia. In doing this, we first address the problem of Ukrainians who are suffering. Whether they are in the East or throughout Ukraine, they are suffering, and especially at this moment, hence the importance of humanitarian aid.

In doing this, we also help to resolve a serious political problem, which is the isolation of Russia and the situation it is going through. We also allow for more economic visibility, and from this point of view, I think it is work that is useful for peace and for Europe.

We sometimes wonder what the Franco-German couple is. Look at what it can also provide from this perspective. We have been able to advance even though we have different sensitivities; that has not changed, Ms. MERKEL and I have been able to advance for two and a half years on banking union and on the stability of the eurozone, and even still today on the JUNCKER Plan. We can also work together on issues concerning the security of Europe. We do this in good intelligence with all European countries, and that was the case this evening.

So, it was an exceptional European Council.

Regarding Greece, we come back to the beginning ultimately: is there not a risk, with Greece? That things become complicated again? There is a political problem in Greece; they must elect a President of the Republic, and they must do so with a qualified majority. If they do not succeed by the end of the year, there will be early legislative elections, and the Greek people will be called to express their opinion.

It is not for me to decide in place of the Greeks, nor in place of the parliamentarians. It is the Greek people, if consulted, during these elections, who will have to say with which government and with which minister they want to work.

On the aid plan for Greece, you have seen that it has been extended. I am working with Ms. MERKEL to ensure that the IMF and the ECB do not complicate matters too much in Greece, and ensure that they respond to the conditions that have been set, and to ensure that the Greeks can also have hope. If we want to avoid a number of votes, it is not by stigmatizing, it is by giving hope, while making the necessary reforms.

That is what I can say about Greece. But even if there could be uncertainty, there is nothing comparable to what it was two and a half years ago. First, because Greece has undergone a policy—but it has also had results—the situation in Greece is not at all the same today as it was two and a half years ago. And I think that two and a half years ago, there were those who were questioning whether Greece should be removed from the eurozone. Today, no one is talking about removing Greece from the eurozone.