Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the progress of European construction and government policy, in Brussels on December 14, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

14 December 2012 · Press conference following the European Council · Brussels

Context
Hollande addressed a press conference in Brussels on December 14, 2012, following the final European Council of the year, discussing eurozone progress and EU policy.
Main themes
Banking Union, eurozone crisis resolution, Greece situation, growth pact, European defense, Syria transition, European integration deepening, banking supervision, structural funds, French socialist politics
Duration
~49 min
94th percentile
Words
5,844
94th percentile
Sentences
357
96th percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
9.5
15th percentile
Syntax
2.83
26th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
16th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

357 sentences in 122 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT

“Ladies and gentlemen, this was the last European Council of the year and the fifth in which I participated. It concludes with two decisive steps that have been taken: one to resolve, for a long time I hope, the situation in Greece and the other to establish the Banking Union and give it the necessary strength to prevent crises from occurring. Crises that have, I remind you, been the origin of what we are experiencing today.

Europe has thus emerged from this period of questioning its future, its destiny, and where the eurozone was asking itself whether it would remain in its current composition. There was doubt both about its ability to resolve the crisis and its willingness to deepen its union. This European Council marked the response that was awaited to address the problems of the past and open the way for strengthening for the future.

Regarding the Banking Union, which may seem like an eminently technical issue, we reached an agreement on supervision, a regulatory mechanism, the recapitalization of banks, and finally a resolution fund. It is, in fact, simply everything that will allow — architecture, oversight, and intervention — to prevent savers from being harmed in Europe by banking behaviors.

In concrete terms, this means the protection of savers and also the protection of States since the banking crisis required State intervention. With what is planned today and will be structured for the coming year, no State will have to intervene in a banking crisis, as long as that crisis has been prevented through supervision and even resolved without calling on a contribution from States, that is to say, from taxpayers. It is therefore, I believe, a relief for many Europeans to know that crises can now be contained, prevented, and that even if they were to occur within a banking institution, there would no longer be a call for contributions from States.

The second topic that was to be addressed at this Council, even if it was discussed with little time to talk about it: the review of the growth pact that I wanted to initiate from the first European Council, which has translated, as you know, into 120 billion euros. There will be an annual review of growth in Europe that will allow for a precise evaluation of this plan. But already, the European Investment Bank will be increased by 10 billion euros, starting in the first quarter, and structural funds can be engaged from the beginning of 2013. This means that the growth pact will be able to fully demonstrate its measure and effects in 2013. The year 2013 will therefore be a full year for Europe since there will be the execution of this growth pact and the implementation of banking supervision and the recapitalization of banks.

There was also, for the first time at the European Council, a declaration on European defense. We have the will to strengthen the defense capacity of countries while also developing the European defense industry. An European Council at the end of 2013 will allow for decisions to be made in these two areas.

Finally, the last question that was to be addressed at this Council — and this was a good part of the debates this morning — is Syria. Three principles were established. First, that of transition and the departure of Assad and everything that can be done to prepare the opposition to take its responsibilities. The second principle is to provide all necessary support both in humanitarian terms and in terms of hosting refugees. The political support for the Coalition during the meeting of the Friends of the Syrian People group in Marrakech was welcomed. Finally, it is to ensure that the countries facing the influx of refugees can themselves be supported by the European Union.

These are the main themes of this Council. I think it has allowed us to turn a page and open another, to close one period and engage another. What has been completed and accomplished there is the resolution of the problems that had troubled and even disorganized the European Union with a historic crisis. The page that is opening is one that will allow for the establishment of all the mechanisms that Europe has decided to engage: budgetary mechanism, stability mechanism, banking mechanism.

Finally, the deepening of the Union will find its place through the report of Mr. Van ROMPUY. It will be further specified next June, so that we can, after the elections of 2014, engage in another step of the European Union, a political step.”

QUESTION

“I would like to ask you a question concerning your government. When he was here, your minister, well, the minister of Jean-Marc AYRAULT, Arnaud MONTEBOURG stated that ‘socialism has been colonized by Reaganism.’ He alluded to Blairism, Zapaterism, and said that it was time to put an end to it. I would like to have your opinion on this; do you think, like him, that Reaganism and liberalism have corrupted the socialists?”

THE PRESIDENT

“We are talking about a period that the younger generation has never known! We have to build an original path, always, because we are France and because we have principles and values that bind us. Now, and I experience this in this European Council without being surprised, we have to compose. Compose with others who do not share our convictions, but who are sincerely European, and then compose with reality. Reality has not adhered to socialism, it is there! It must be worked on, transformed. But we cannot decide in place of reality. So we confront it and ensure that France can move forward.

The challenge for the government is to position France at the best level, because — this European Council confirms it — there will be a recovery of growth. Everything is now ready for this recovery of growth: the confidence that has returned, the stability and solidarity mechanisms that have been introduced, electoral deadlines that have been passed — I am thinking particularly of the United States — a geopolitical situation that can be managed, and efforts that have been made by many countries.

France is taking its responsibilities in terms of public account recovery, in terms of competitiveness. The role of the French government is to seize this recovery when it occurs so that we can benefit from it to the fullest. That is what justifies the effort we are making; it is not a vain effort, it is not an austerity that we should accept, we do not want it. We are dismissing everything that could affect the purchasing power of the French. But we are facing a situation of unemployment. We must therefore do everything to be ready to take full advantage of the recovery of growth when it comes, and I believe it will come in 2013.”

QUESTION

“At the beginning of your term, you were impatient; you said that the timing of decisions in Europe did not correspond to either the timing of the markets or the economic timing. Do the decisions you have just made in this European Council allow you to say that the timings are better aligned now?”

THE PRESIDENT

“Yes. I think one of the problems that Europe faced is that it was not ready to confront a crisis of this magnitude and nature. A banking crisis and a financial crisis linked to imbalances in the management of public finances. It was caught off guard and took time to grasp the situation and find the necessary remedies, the indispensable mechanisms. Finally, it thought that only austerity could be the solution, the way out of the crisis.

However, for several months, we have been able to make decisions both on mechanisms that are now in place. They were prepared beforehand, because nothing is invented, everything has been in gestation, but it was necessary to make these decisions, particularly the stability mechanisms: the forms of organization of the Central Bank to complement this mechanism and also solidarity mechanisms for growth.

We have been able to make these decisions. The main one, even if it is complicated for many of our fellow citizens to understand, is about banks because finance was at the origin of this crisis. Finance therefore had to be controlled. It will be. Banking supervision, crisis resolution mechanisms, the separation of deposit banking activities from speculative activities, all of this is now decided. France will not waste time; we will be one of the first countries to pass a banking law. In this banking law, there will be a crisis resolution authority, that is to say, the national authority that will be under European authority.

Yes, decisions have been made, and it is because decisions have been made for several months that there can be a return of confidence. There is no longer any doubt today about the integrity of the eurozone; no one is asking the question that was on everyone’s mind a few months ago: ‘Is a European country in the eurozone going to exit this system?’ This question has found its answer.

Similarly, six months ago, we had many questions about interest rate spreads, about the ability of certain States to bear these burdens. The interest rate spreads have narrowed, and we now have the possibility, with the intervention of the ECB — if a country requests it — to provide liquidity.

It is because there are decisions that there is confidence, that there can be growth, and that now I can say that Europe will no longer be caught off guard since it has prevention mechanisms, resolution mechanisms, and solidarity mechanisms. Is everything resolved, however? No.

What is not resolved? Unemployment, low growth, not to mention recession in some countries. And again, in this European Council, there was a commitment to youth employment. You know how much this issue matters to me. There will be a presentation from the Commission of a Youth Employment plan, for training, for qualification, for alternation. We have also anticipated since we created ‘future jobs,’ but also formulas to prevent unqualified young people from remaining without solutions. Finally, we invented the ‘generation contract’ which may one day be generalized at the European level.”

QUESTION

“Mr. Van ROMPUY's roadmap on the deepening of the monetary union does not seem to generate excessive enthusiasm, to say the least. Do you see this as a brake related to an electoral situation, a conjunctural one — I am thinking of the German elections in 2013, of course, and the European elections in 2014 — or do you think there is a deeper brake?”

THE PRESIDENT

“First of all, I want to commend the work that Mr. Van ROMPUY has done, because he has taken his responsibilities by gathering the proposals from different States and indicating the path that seemed best to him. What has been retained from his report at this stage? It is the possibility of concluding contracts for competitiveness and growth, and for the countries that would subscribe to them and would need an incentive, to have a solidarity mechanism that would make possible a number of structural reforms. That’s already quite a lot!

What has he not yet been able to make appear for the year 2013 that could possibly be considered after the European elections? It is notably everything that was about cushioning shocks and the funds that could be mobilized for that purpose. But I think he has given a direction that will be further specified next spring, and which seems to me to be the right one.

Then, there is a political responsibility; there are countries that no longer want new transfers of competencies to the European Union. I note this at every Council. These countries believe they have gone as far as their European commitment should go, and I respect that choice. There are even countries that want to withdraw from competencies that had been transferred until now. You will recognize these countries without difficulty.

So what do I propose to resolve this issue? This is not in Mr. Van ROMPUY's report even if he mentions it through the budgetary capacity of the eurozone. I advocate for a new step to be taken for the eurozone. If some countries — and I can accept this — do not want to go that far, we will make enhanced cooperation.

I can illustrate my point with the financial transaction tax. Just a few months ago, there were too few countries defending this position. We could not even have the 11 participants necessary for enhanced cooperation. For the past six months, we have been sufficiently convincing since we found the 10 other countries — apart from France — that were ready to engage in this cooperation. And I note since then that two others have joined us, including one country that is not in the eurozone, Lithuania.”

"There is therefore the possibility, as we can see clearly, for those who want to move forward, for those who want to do more, for those who want to either find new resources or develop new ways of organizing themselves. I will advocate from 2014 that we go even further in enhanced cooperation."

QUESTION

"I would like to return to this new notion of competitiveness and growth contracts. You spoke last night about a voluntary approach. This morning, a European Member of Parliament, Sylvie Goulard, who is close, as you know, to Mr. Monti, claims that these contracts are somewhat a gateway to all possible financial bargaining. She even refers to them as soft caramel. Do you not consider that this new initiative is making the European process even more complex, even more Byzantine, even more unreadable?"

THE PRESIDENT

"For once, when we are capable of doing tailor-made solutions and not just norms and constraints, let us seize these formulas! What does a competitiveness and growth contract mean? It means that for a country that wants to undertake a number of reforms in terms of innovation, research, improving its competitiveness, vocational training, different work organization, and that wishes to have support from Europe, because it corresponds to desirable convergences or orientations that were set long ago by Europe -- remember the Lisbon process! -- this country will therefore be able to receive support from Europe.

I do not see why I should be alarmed by this. It would be much more problematic if we forced all countries to enter into some contract with Europe to accept a policy that the countries themselves would not want. However, the word contract rules out this hypothesis. As long as it is voluntary, as long as it is accompanied, as long as it concerns issues of growth, employment, and competitiveness, I think it is a good formula. I think we have had enough of the automatic procedures that have now been reinforced and that lead countries to have budgetary policies more than under surveillance. So that is not at all the framework that is being proposed."

QUESTION

"On defense: is France abandoning its ambition to create truly civilian or military structures to plan and conduct missions and operations?"

THE PRESIDENT

"France has its defense policy. It is ready -- when it considers that essential interests are at stake and within the legal framework provided by the United Nations -- to carry out operations or participate in operations. France will maintain this autonomy and independence.

But we want to act in Europe, we want Europe to assert itself as a major political actor. And to be heard, to be respected on the international stage, defense means are essential. We therefore accept cooperation, we accept that there are common missions, and I will take an example.

In the Sahel, it is not just France that is on the front line; it is Europe in the sense that it is Europe that will help train Malian soldiers and provide support to the African force that, if the Security Council gives it the mandate, will participate in the operation to reclaim Northern Mali for the integrity of this country. Therefore, it is Europeans who will train Malian soldiers and provide support to an African force, but who will not participate in the military operation itself.

You can see that France is trying, whenever possible, to pursue the same objective that it would pursue alone, but with all of Europe. For that, we need a European defense industry. For a long time, there have been very national conceptions, including from France, and you will find illustrations through a number of equipment. Here, we say that we need to better organize ourselves on an industrial level, and that is the objective that has been set today."

QUESTION

"Mr. President, two questions. A clarification regarding these competitiveness and growth contracts, more specifically the solidarity mechanism associated with these contracts. Ms. Merkel says: no more than 20 billion euros. She says: 10, 15, 20 billion at most. For you, is that enough or do we need more or much more?

And then the second point, the FITCH rating agency maintains, of course, France's triple A rating, but also its negative outlook, meaning it reserves the right to downgrade this rating in a few months. It is even estimated that the probability of this rating being downgraded is about 50%, or even a little more than 50%. What do you think about that? Is FITCH more credible than MOODY'S and its sister agency S&P or less credible?"

THE PRESIDENT

"You are asking me to rate the rating agencies, to create a hierarchy among them? I would necessarily put first the one that rates us the best! Each has its own rules, parameters, and criteria, often quite convergent. FITCH has just confirmed the rating that was set several months ago. It has not changed any of its aspects, including the negative outlook for the triple A.

We hear what is being said to us, but we do not determine our policy based on one agency or another. We determine our policy based on the interest of France, based on what we want to give it in terms of strength in competitiveness and what we want to remove as weakness in terms of debt and deficit.

Moreover, I note that the rating of France, which we can verify every day on the markets, is the interest rate. Since I have been at the head of the State, interest rates have continued to fall. I do not take personal satisfaction from this; I am not the one who makes the markets. But I note that France, or at least the sovereign debt of France, is particularly appreciated by the markets, to the point of having an interest rate that is now below 2%, and which is even negative on short maturities.

But all of this is fragile, all of this is vulnerable. We must therefore have credibility. Credibility is not about austerity; credibility is about having a line, a coherence, an action over time, and that is what I have to explain to the French and to Europeans. Here is what we want to do: we want to strengthen the economy of France to enable it to seize all opportunities, today to emerge from the crisis and tomorrow to have the strongest possible recovery of growth.

Finally, the only consideration I have in mind is employment. We must create jobs. In this regard, measures have been taken and there will be negotiations -- which are not yet finished -- on job security. We expect the conclusion in the coming days.

Regarding what Ms. Merkel said in terms of amounts, she mentioned it at the European Council and we had discussed it. Frankly, if we could already quickly free up 10, 15, 20 billion for the solidarity mechanisms, I would take it! 120 billion for the growth pact, 15 to 20 billion for the solidarity mechanism, we will see for the future... For the bank resolution fund, we will need to find a certain number of amounts. Everything that can be put to the service of solidarity, employment, growth, and competitiveness, I will take!"

QUESTION

"You say that we need to get Bashar al-Assad out as quickly as possible. The Syrian National Coalition was recognized by a hundred states this week. Patriot missiles are going to be installed at the Turkish border. What can be done to get him out quickly? I mean, are there countries that would be willing to host him, for example? Are there negotiations that are possible? Can we exfiltrate Mr. Bashar al-Assad or are we waiting for Security Council meetings?"

THE PRESIDENT

"First, he must be a candidate for exfiltration! For the moment, I think we must first strengthen the pressure on the ground. The opposition is gaining ground every day. There is therefore a vulnerability that was not yet evident a few weeks or months ago.

Then there is the political pressure. Hence the decision that France took, the first nation to do so, to recognize the Coalition. Today, there is a movement to go in this direction. France has given the decisive signal for this recognition.

After that, there are pressures in terms of sanctions and also the aid we can provide to the opposition. The challenge remains to convince the members of the Security Council. You know that Russia is still in the same position today. But Russia hears, sees, and observes what is happening... It is up to us to tell them -- and I have not ceased to do so and I will continue -- to convey this message. Russia has nothing to lose or fear from a change. It has interests and relations with Syria, which is respectable.

But the National Coalition, which I hope will be the government of Syria tomorrow, must also provide guarantees that it is indeed a democratic process that is planned after Bashar al-Assad's departure. There is also this work with the Coalition. The declaration of the European Council allows for this dialogue to clearly determine what can be accepted in the Coalition -- and notably a number of groups since one has been considered more dangerous than others even if it intervenes to oust Bashar al-Assad -- and to ensure the protection of minorities. The text indeed refers to the protection of minorities."

QUESTION

"Next week, you are going to Algeria. Today, the lawyer for the civil parties in the case of the assassination of the monks of Tibhirine complains about the slowness of the procedures, the lack of cooperation from Algeria in this matter. Will you discuss this with your counterpart next week in Algeria?"

THE PRESIDENT

"I do not want to talk about Algeria here in Brussels. You would be the first to reproach me for it; I know you well. But I will talk with the Algerian authorities and with President Bouteflika about all the subjects."

QUESTION

"You alluded to certain countries that are reluctant, that have gone too far in integration. David Cameron has promised what he calls 'repatriation' of competences. Is France in favor of this, of a discussion with Great Britain to 'repatriate'?"

THE PRESIDENT

"When a country commits, generally, it is for life. I therefore think that treaties are made to be respected. And I have not heard Mr. Cameron in a European Council, for now, ask to withdraw from certain competences. If this discussion takes place, because it can take place, Europe is not a Europe where competences could be removed.

One can choose not to participate in new competences. I understand and fully accept that. For subsequent steps, Great Britain can very well say that it does not want to participate; it has every right to do so. This has indeed been verified for the budgetary treaty.

When I speak of enhanced cooperation, I am precisely making sure to accommodate the countries that do not want to go further. And when I speak of strengthening the eurozone as such, without excluding the countries that want to join it -- which is not the case for the United Kingdom -- it allows us to respect everyone's positions, without giving the unfortunate impression of excluding a country. No country should be excluded, but no country should be forced. I think that is the right position."

QUESTION

"Mr. President, since we are in Belgium, I would like to ask you a 'Gaulish' question... What do you think of the exile that I will not qualify as Gérard Depardieu in this country?"

THE PRESIDENT

"You did well to ask the question for the ethics of your profession, because the word ethics is particularly appropriate. Everyone must have ethical behavior, regardless of the profession they practice, and even more so for the head of state -- not to answer your question!"

QUESTION

"Two questions quickly. You said earlier that at each European Council, you noted that some states no longer want a transfer of sovereignty... Are these states in the eurozone? If so, which ones?

And a second question on social Europe. It is briefly mentioned in the conclusions. Martin Schulz called yesterday for states to better take into account the social dimension of the economic and monetary union. You advocate for solidarity integration. How can France contribute effectively to the debate on social Europe, what concrete proposals do you have in mind in this area?"

THE PRESIDENT

"I want to get to the point. First, regarding a united Europe, that is my position: whenever an integration instrument is proposed, there must be solidarity to access it. We cannot only deal with the economic; social issues are now at the heart of the European agenda. That is why I wish for the Eurogroup to also involve -- on certain topics and at certain times -- the ministers of Labor. The European Parliament is also driven by this ambition.

Europe cannot simply be a market and a currency -- undoubtedly now better organized -- that would have no social counterpart. I want the issue of youth to be a European issue, not that it would be a European competence, it is not. But when youth unemployment exceeds 25% in France, which can even go beyond that in Spain and is starting to be very present in Germany as well, we all have an interest in addressing the issue of training, qualification, and even education at the European level.

The second question you asked me is: are there countries in the eurozone that do not want more transfers? Yes, there are, and they say: 'I do not have the authorization today -- that is their phrase -- I do not have the authorization from my Parliament to go further.' This is what we are told each time, including regarding the solidarity mechanism linked to the competitiveness and growth contract.

So what do we do? We respect these countries. Moreover, they told us: 'I do not have the authority to implement the financial transaction tax either.' Well! So we proceed with enhanced cooperation. That is the idea: we cannot be constrained by countries that do not want to go further, but I do not want to force countries that do not want to go further either.

For that, we need to find a certain flexibility; I did not say freedom. It is not a à la carte Europe that we want, but it is a Europe that has different levels of competence and different speeds. This idea has been around for a long time; it has never been truly accepted, it has often been proclaimed. It is time to implement it.

QUESTION

"Mr. President, you did not want to answer the question about Gérard DEPARDIEU...

THE PRESIDENT

"Yes."

QUESTION

... So I will ask you two peripheral questions, which will allow you to still not answer, but at least respond to some European concerns. The issue of tax exile raises the problem of tax harmonization in Europe. What is your view on this? Is it time for tax harmonization to happen, or should each state maintain its freedom because taxation is a weapon? That is my first question.

The second question relates to something that was mentioned by your predecessor; he said that the French -- wherever they are in the world -- should pay their taxes in France. Are you on the same line, or is that something that is totally unthinkable?"

THE PRESIDENT

"Ethically and politically, I can answer your double question. Yes, we are harmonizing our budgetary policies; we must harmonize our tax policies. Harmonization is not just about converging corporate tax rates; it is also about ensuring that no tax collection gap can be maintained at a level that allows -- citizens of member countries of Europe -- to seek tax optimization through a number of mechanisms. We therefore need to have this discussion on tax convergence. This does not mean that it would be the same tax system, but that we cannot have tax dumping in a number of situations for businesses or individuals.

Then, what do we have to do regarding situations that exist at the heart of Europe, in member countries of the Union or in non-member countries? A non-member country of the Union is Switzerland. I met with the President of the Swiss Confederation a few days ago in Paris. I told her that we were ready to review a number of tax conventions or tax situations, particularly for inheritances.

On the other hand, I am not in favor of amnesty procedures. You saw that an interesting situation occurred in Germany that serves as a reference: Germany had considered making an agreement with Switzerland to allow taxation of tax exiles, and the Bundesrat did not accept it. This means that with Switzerland, we must first allow for an exchange of information, a convention on inheritances -- and that is in progress -- and then see how we can further improve things. But there cannot be -- and Switzerland is convinced of this itself -- an amnesty or what could appear as an amnesty.

Then, there are the member countries of the European Union, like Belgium, with which we have a tax convention. We will therefore review these tax conventions. I think that was the spirit of what my predecessor declared. There is no other way to do it. It cannot simply be a French will. We are obliged to renegotiate the tax convention to address the case of those who have settled in some Belgian village. But he should be careful; it is a socialist municipality, I was told..."

QUESTION

"Sorry to return to a detail: the 10, 15, or 20 billion euros that Ms. MERKEL speaks of and that you adopt, regarding the small budget of the eurozone, is that per year, per month, over 7 years...?"

THE PRESIDENT

"Let us be clear. She wanted -- and she was right -- to give a rough estimate, allowing for a good understanding of what was at stake. This is not a budget for the eurozone! The budget for the eurozone will be a question that can be discussed once we have adopted the budget of the European Union, which I hope will be in February."

QUESTION

"Is it per month, per year, for 7 years?"

THE PRESIDENT

"The idea would therefore be to create a fund that could initially be endowed with 15, 20 billion, perhaps partly drawn from the financial transaction tax. Once this fund is consumed, we would replenish it. It is therefore a fund that allows us to initiate a process.

But I want to distinguish things: there is this fund to support reforms in countries that request it, and then there will be what we can possibly decide -- if the eurozone agrees on this principle -- to allocate as a specific budget for the eurozone. But we are not there yet, and that is why it seemed rather intelligent to me to start with a specific fund dedicated to these employment, growth, and competitiveness contracts rather than waiting for a possible budget for the eurozone that may never come."

QUESTION

"Regarding the resolution and notably the resolution fund that we apparently discreetly set in motion last night, what is, ideally, your idea on this resolution fund? Should it be a mutualized fund, unique for all countries participating in the common supervision? What is your objective there?"

THE PRESIDENT

"There will be resolution authorities in each country. I told you: in France, we will create this authority as soon as the banking law is passed. And then, there will be a European resolution authority.

This seems complicated; I will give another translation. There is a supervision that will be that of the European Central Bank. In each country, there are supervisors: the central banks of each country. That is for supervision.

For resolution, what does that mean? There is a problem, intervention is needed, there are resolution authorities in each country and a mutualized authority at the European level. How to intervene? Precisely, by using all these resolution funds. It is therefore a principle of mutualization and solidarity.

As you said, it was done discreetly, but it was done, and the main thing is that it happens, because again for countries that do not want new transfers, it is still a subject. It took convincing, and it took the time of the night as always..."

QUESTION

"Sorry to come back to subjects like these, but the debate in France seems to be crystallizing around 'marriage for all,' as there are protests against protests, petitions against petitions, etc. Are you afraid of further dividing French society on this debate? That is my first question.

The second: by a curious media coincidence, three ministers from your government, close to Ségolène ROYAL, are questioning the future of Ségolène ROYAL, believing that there is talent and that it should be expressed. Can you envision a place for Ségolène ROYAL in a governmental setup?"

THE PRESIDENT

"The more time passes, the more you let yourself go, and the more I control myself! Do not expect an answer. Wherever you would have asked me this question, I would not have answered you; the time is not right.

On the other hand, regarding marriage, I can respond in another way. We are in Belgium; marriage for all has been voted on and is being applied. We are in a European Council, with countries that have very different ideological positions. Nevertheless, Mr. CAMERON has just announced that he will propose 'marriage for all.'

Again, Europe is not simply an economic space where we discuss budgets; it is also a living space. When countries choose to modernize, one might say, in any case to grant freedoms within a framework that must be specified, it is true that other countries are led to reflect on it. Since we live in the same space, why in some countries could we have marriage for all and not in others? I therefore think that Europe is also a community of life with rules that can be common. Thank you all."