Press conference by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the refugee crisis and the situation in Syria, in Brussels on October 15, 2015.

France François Hollande · President of France

15 October 2015 · European Council press conference on the refugee crisis and Syria · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Hollande addressed a press conference at the European Council in Brussels on October 15, 2015, summarizing agreements on refugee crisis response and Syria.
Main themes
Refugee crisis, European Council decisions, hotspots registration centers, Frontex border management, EU-Turkey action plan, Turkey visa liberalization and accession, Syria and Libya destabilization, Africa development summit in Valletta, migration policy, climate conference funding, humanitarian support for displaced persons
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,841
84th percentile
Sentences
189
88th percentile
Readability
55
76th percentile
Grade
10.5
27th percentile
Syntax
2.97
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

189 sentences in 50 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

Today's European Council was primarily dedicated to the implementation of the decisions made on September 23 regarding the issue of refugees, and we were able to reach an agreement on all matters.

First, to establish the "hotspots," that is to say, the centers for registration, recording, reception, but also for the return of individuals who cannot access refugee status, and to note that there will soon be six hotspots in Italy and that in Greece, there are now some being built, notably on Lesbos. I confirmed that France would do its part as we will send specialists from the Office for Refugees, known as OFPRA, as well as other personnel, experts for reception, and identification of individuals with Frontex. All countries are called upon to make the same effort and to participate.

Next, we also need to strengthen Frontex, and a French proposal that I had presented before the European Parliament in Strasbourg has been accepted, namely a reserve of border guards available in each Member State and mobilizable when a State is facing, as is the case, strong pressure at the border. This body of European border guards will therefore be gradually established.

We also wanted the States and countries that are currently hosting refugees outside the European Union to be supported by Europe since these countries have been making the bulk of the effort for months and months to ensure that Syrians, Iraqis, and all those who are victims of war or dictatorship can be welcomed in the region. It was therefore legitimate for there to be direct action from European countries and the Commission to support these countries, whether it be Jordan, Lebanon, or Turkey.

An action plan was presented by the President of the European Commission regarding Turkey. This action plan can be summarized in three main orientations. Border management, but also support for Syrians who are settled in Turkey, and finally the readmission of individuals who do not have the right to enter Europe, these are migrants who would be registered in a hotspot center and would not be considered refugees and therefore should be readmitted to Turkey. On this basis, there will be assistance provided to Turkey. There will also be joint actions between Europe and Turkey, and this is part of what the European Commission has now been reinforced in this approach.

We also insisted that if there is to be visa liberalization with Turkey, it should be based on extremely precise and controlled grounds. I emphasized this because I believe there should be no misunderstandings or ambiguities. Visa liberalization, which could therefore be granted to Turkey, should not lead to individuals coming from Turkey whose identity we are not sure of, or who have not been controlled beforehand. There can be no visa liberalization unless there is this process of control, monitoring, and vigilance to ensure there is great clarity in exchanges between Turkey and the countries of the European Union.

Regarding the negotiation process itself for Turkey's accession, it can resume. You know that this had already been decided; it must be based on the criteria and conditions that were initially set. There may be chapters that can be examined, but it is within the framework of the entire process, which we know has not yet reached its conclusion, far from it, that the question of Turkey's accession can be raised, and here too, the clarifications that were expected have been provided.

Next, we discussed Africa since there will be a summit in a few days in Valletta, Malta. It has been planned to allocate significant sums for the success of this summit, for the development of Africa, all of Africa, since this is not a summit that would concern just part of Africa. It is truly a meeting that we also want to frame within the preparation for the Climate Conference, where there will also be funding that could be allocated to enable African countries to access renewable energies and new technologies. It was therefore very important to give meaning to this Valletta meeting, which is not simply to prevent migration, even if that should be the result; it is to provide all the conditions for the development of Africa and to put this continent in a position, as it shows in some countries, to experience sustained growth and activity and to have an exceptional partnership with Europe. Financial resources were therefore planned to ensure the success of this process.

We also discussed Syria and Libya. Why? Because these are two countries that are deeply destabilized, not necessarily as a result of the same processes, but nonetheless, the outcome is there.

The fact that there is still no unity government in Libya fosters all kinds of trafficking. The EU has announced that it will move to phase 2 of its project specifically for maritime trafficking controls as part of an action that had already been planned a few months ago.

With regard to Syria, we had a meeting before the Council with the United Kingdom, Germany, and France to take positions that we believe should be those of the European Union and which have indeed been included in the communiqué. What are these positions? What are these conclusions?

First, there must be a fight against terrorism, against Daesh. All initiatives that can be taken must go in this direction. The Russian intervention in this regard does not allow us to be convinced that there is a concentration of strikes, to say the least, concerning Daesh.

The second conclusion is that we must enter into a political transition process and ensure that all components can be gathered in the spirit of Geneva. Bashar al-Assad, as has been recalled, cannot be the future of Syria.

Finally, thirdly, it is very important that bombings on civilian populations, particularly by the Syrian regime, cease. However, the Russian intervention in this regard has changed nothing. There are still these actions of which the Syrians themselves are the victims. This is why the political process must be confirmed. The three countries and the European Union will act in the same direction. There will undoubtedly be contacts with the countries that are most concerned, the countries of the region, the Gulf countries, Iran, none of which should be neglected, but also with all the powers that can also be involved, I am thinking of Russia and the United States.

It is on this basis that the Council also concluded. This is what I can tell you about this Council. Why was it important? Not because there were announcements to be made, but because it was necessary that, after the decisions of September, there be rapid and effective implementations. Because the influx of refugees has not slowed down and cannot slow down as long as there is no comprehensive European policy acting both on the sources, the causes, what is happening in Syria, what is happening in West Africa, what is happening in Libya, but also on aid to the countries that are currently facing the reception, for years now, of refugees. Hence the aid that is now being allocated. There can be no response if there are no external borders that can be respected. If that were not the case, if the distribution mechanism and the mechanism of the "hotspots" were not put in place quickly, we would inevitably have crises that could lead some countries to re-establish borders. This would ultimately be the dismantling of Schengen without being a progress for any country whatsoever.

It was therefore very important for Europe to show that it had not only made decisions but that it was implementing them and that it was capable of doing so in a very short time for the "hotspots," for the border guards, for the aid to Turkey, for the aid to African countries, and for the aid to countries that host refugees.

We will have another European Council in December, and at that time it will be very important to evaluate this policy that will now be implemented quickly.

I can answer your questions.

QUESTIONS/ANSWERS:

Q - Could we be more precise, what is the amount of aid granted? We are talking about one billion euros. Secondly, Turkey also wanted to be recognized as a safe country by the European Union. Would that be the case, and what would the consequences be, possibly, in terms of asylum? These "hotspots" are now operational in Italy, will be operational in Greece. But the question of returns, which you seemed to prioritize again on September 23, is still not addressed. Is there not a risk of congestion in these "hotspots"?

So, first on Turkey. No amount has been set. This will be the subject of ongoing discussions because it is not a matter of giving money. It is about understanding what these funds can have as an effect and what they can represent for Turkey and for the European Union as a means of making life easier for refugees in Turkey. These sums must also be dedicated to the creation of refugee centers, possibly on Turkish territory. These sums must also be allocated to the care of refugee children and also to border controls. So it is on the basis of the actions contained in the plan that the President of the European Commission presented that these transfers will occur. Already, I can communicate that the European Commission has allocated 500 million euros from its own resources to ensure a first action or first actions.

Secondly, what does it mean to recognize Turkey as a safe country? This can have an advantage, which is to say that when you come from a safe country, you cannot be considered a refugee. And, therefore, for individuals who are currently in Turkey, and who are thus in a country that would be recognized as safe, there would be no possibility for these individuals to be welcomed as refugees. We can also see the difficulties of these situations.

As for visa liberalization, which could also be a consequence of being recognized as a safe country - that is why it has been decoupled - there can be no visa liberalization if there are no controls, if there are no conditions that are respected by Turkey. So it is a parallel movement. There will be a gradual liberalization of visas only if actions are undertaken.

Finally, on the very important question of returns. A "hotspot" center - everyone disputes this term because we do not know exactly what it means, even if we know the English language, but it does not reveal what a "hotspot" center is, which is why the definition of the centers given in the conclusions has been specified - what is a center that would be called a "hotspot"? We welcome, we register, we check whether a person qualifies for refugee status or conversely does not qualify and must be returned, and for the refugee, guided to a host country. Therefore, return is inherent to reception and registration centers. And it is very important that we can allocate resources to ensure return. This first requires processing the cases of individuals who come to these centers quickly. If we make them wait for dozens of days, first, it is unbearable for the countries that receive them. Secondly, it is even questionable to detain them, to deprive them of liberty for such a long period. Therefore, it must be stated authoritatively within a very short time, while respecting rights, that a person will be able to enter Europe because they are a refugee, and others must be returned. And then, it is necessary to allocate additional resources to ensure the effectiveness of returns, which also calls for readmission to a number of countries, for example, Turkey. A person coming from Turkey cannot be considered a refugee, must be returned, by means that Europe must propose. And then, the country from which this person comes must accept their return. So it is this process that must be properly established. Because it is this protection of borders and the rights that can be recognized to a number of refugees or migrants that we must provide this clarification to all.

Q - Mr. President, it has been understood that there was a discussion that extended at the initiative of Germany regarding a permanent mechanism for the relocation of refugees that was to be included in the text explicitly. To give a somewhat more permanent character to what had been decided regarding 160,000 asylum seekers. Germany would have somewhat "stirred the pot" in front of Eastern Europe, where there is still a very strong division. That was my first question: what exactly happened during this discussion?

And then, you tell us that in this case, France pushed the idea of this European border guard Frontex, while again Eastern Europe would like to do it on an ad hoc basis. The Visegrad group has already had mechanisms of solidarity precisely at the borders and says that this is enough. Is this French idea really adopted and defended by everyone?

What was the debate? It was to know whether the mechanism, which has already been decided, of distribution, should be recalled in the conclusions. I considered that we needed to have a reference to what we have decided. Germany wanted even more, that we could re-establish the mechanisms as a permanent mechanism. It was therefore agreed that there would be a reminder of what had been decided, namely this distribution mechanism, for 120,000, not more at this stage. And it is ultimately this compromise that was adopted at the end of the Council, that is to say, the reminder of the decision that had already been made regarding distribution.

Then, on the question of border guards, I think not only that the idea has progressed since it has been integrated into the conclusions, thus the agreement on border guards that will gradually be put in place. Because here too, if we want to protect our external borders, we need personnel to do so. I will be told that this will be an additional cost, but it will ultimately be a cost much lower than if we had to, for example, re-establish national borders. I know a number of people who say that we need to re-establish national borders. You see what that could represent as a burden for countries that have large borders - I will not name them but - France for example. It is better to have a system of external borders with a European body, with countries that can and France is ready to add national contingents to this European body if necessary, so that the external borders can be monitored, including in the interest of refugees who could otherwise lose their lives. This is what Frontex has nonetheless allowed, namely to have boats that can save a number of people on boats that were meant to sink, because that is what traffickers do.

So there you go, this proposal is no longer a proposal, it is a decision.

Q - President Juncker and Chancellor Merkel both said upon arrival that there was a lack of effort from a number of countries regarding the promised personnel and the promised money. The Frontex agency, for example, requested 800 experts, and currently has only 48. Do you share this feeling that things are not moving fast enough? We have only 19 people relocated so far out of the 160,000 announced? And what will France do in a more concrete way? You said "we will put people." When? How many? How much money also in the fund for Syria and the fund for Africa?

From a general point of view, before getting to France, yes, the commitments that have been made must be kept. That was indeed the purpose of the European Council, to demonstrate that it is not enough to make decisions, they must be implemented: the "hotspot" centers, the personnel to ensure reception and verification, Frontex which must be strengthened, the financial means that must be released to help countries, the financial means that must also be released to ensure the protection of our borders. That is what the Council should have as an effect.

Then, regarding France: France is already committed to the funds that will need to be made available for Africa. France is also present in the funds for Syria. I am not talking about military operations, I am talking about humanitarian operations. France has increased its participation in the WFP. France has also raised its allocation to UNHCR. We are not doing our duty. It is not just our moral duty. We are doing what we must do in the very interest of refugees, in the very interest of Europe so that there cannot be indeed population displacements.

If we want to prevent people who are in destitution from coming to Europe, we must ensure that they can be in places close to what was once their life, welcomed in the best conditions so that these people can work - This is the problem of Turkey: Turkey must grant work permits to refugees. It is necessary, and it indeed deserves to be supported, that these people can see their children educated, can be fed. That is what we must do. And ensure in particular for African countries developments that prevent them from looking at Europe as a place where it would be necessary to go to live better.

So this is the whole policy that we want to engage in. This requires resources, but ultimately resources that are much lower than those we would have to devote if refugees continued to come in large numbers.

Where do the refugees go? I will return to this question. Today, the refugees who have come over the past several months have mainly gone to Germany, Austria, and Sweden. Germany - these are the figures given by Ms. Merkel - has welcomed more than 500,000 people since the beginning of the year. And the country that, relative to its population, has done the most for refugees is Sweden.

France, which has made commitments and has said that it is ready to ensure the reception of 24,000 (30,000) people over two years in the distribution mechanism, is not, today, in terms of numbers, subject to an influx of refugees. And those who claim that we are being invaded are in reality manipulators, falsifiers, and they do so for purely political reasons, to instill fear.

Do you think that a country like Germany, which welcomes 500,000 refugees and hears political debates, does not apply to France, since there are also other countries that, for reasons that have nothing to do with those of France, refuse to welcome, can continue to have a complacent view towards Europe while it is the one that has made the bulk of the effort?

It is therefore very important that we can find solutions so that refugees can be welcomed as close as possible to their places of origin. That is all we must do. And to welcome only those who are in such distress that their only solution would be to come to Europe.

So it is very important to recall these realities. That is why Ms. Merkel is right. She wants us to be able to work together - to have respected external borders, to have aid mechanisms for countries so that this movement of refugees slows down. And that Germany can integrate these people who have come since the beginning of the year to live in Germany. Germany will be forced to spend very large sums, amounting to several billion, without Germany asking for any compensation whatsoever.

That is what I wanted to say because it helps to have clear ideas in certain minds, not just in Germany.

Q - This evening there was a shooting at the border between Turkey and Bulgaria, and a refugee died. This is why the President of Bulgaria left before the end of the summit. What do you think of this new development?

I did not have this information, so I cannot comment on it. The Prime Minister of Bulgaria stayed almost until the end of the summit. He may have been informed himself of this serious incident, but there was no debate about it at all.

The Bulgarian Prime Minister spoke, and he said that he wanted this plan to be accepted regarding Turkey. He also, since he is not in the Schengen area, said how much he wanted the borders to be protected.

Q - Regarding the trilateral meeting you had with Mr. Cameron and Ms. Merkel, you recalled earlier that it had been stated that Bashar could not be the future of Syria, but have you reached a common solution on the fate to be reserved for President Bashar al-Assad in the context of a political transition that is still debated within the EU?

No, there was no debate about it, because the position is common. It is the one that the Geneva conference had already outlined, namely that the discussion necessarily engages between the opposition and representatives of the regime to form a transitional government where there are representatives of the regime and there are representatives of the different moderate and democratic oppositions. It is stated very clearly that Bashar al-Assad cannot be the future. What does that mean? It means that he will leave. That is what it means. We are all, from this point of view, in agreement. We could say leave right away, leave in the middle, leave at the end. What is important is to say that he is not the future, and therefore from there, we must move as quickly as possible towards this political transition. That is what we will strive to do in the coming weeks. There will be discussions that will continue with the different protagonists I have mentioned so that we can expedite this process.

The Russian intervention in this regard may consolidate the regime but will not save Bashar. It consolidates the regime because today the Russian strikes mainly concern areas controlled by the opposition, and very marginally by Daesh, a little by Al-Nusra. But in any case, beyond this intervention and its effects, the political process must necessarily lead to a unity government in which Bashar al-Assad, in the long term, will no longer have his place.

Q - Regarding France, the CGT announced that it would not participate in the social conference. Are you afraid of a divorce with a certain left since what is now called the Air France affair? A part of the left has expressed solidarity with the dismissed employees. Another reproaches you for not having sufficiently condemned the violence of the layoffs. Do you fear this divorce with a certain part of your electoral base?

I will express myself at the Social Conference on Monday, and you will hear me on this question of dialogue, negotiation, and the social model. I will see you on Monday.

Thank you.