Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on employment policy, in Paris on October 19, 2015.

France François Hollande · President of France

19 October 2015 · Fourth social conference · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed the fourth Social Conference in Paris on October 19, 2015, to discuss unemployment, job creation, and the future of France's social model.
Main themes
Employment policy, social dialogue, job creation, digital revolution and energy transition, labor market reform, social model reform, trade unionism, parity and social systems, complementary pensions (AGIRC/ARRCO), collective bargaining
Duration
~37 min
88th percentile
Words
4,424
88th percentile
Sentences
165
84th percentile
Readability
36
28th percentile
Grade
14.8
74th percentile
Syntax
3.33
85th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 49%49%
  • Economic 25%25%
  • Social 16%16%
  • Environmental 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

165 sentences in 83 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister,

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Mr. President of the Economic, Social and Environmental Council,

I thank you once again for welcoming us to this venue for this fourth social conference.

I would like to acknowledge all the participants here, the representatives of trade unions, the representatives of employers, but also all those who keep the dialogue alive in our country, as well as the sense of responsibility.

We are gathering for this fourth conference since the beginning of the five-year term. The first was mainly dedicated to preparing the reform of the labor market, particularly concerning social plans.

Let us remember, there were many at that time, and it was necessary to find methods and means to prevent them and, above all, to avoid creating legal insecurity for both employers and employees.

This led to an agreement, a national interprofessional agreement, which became a law: the law on the securing of employment.

The second conference dealt with professional training. And again, after negotiations, a national agreement was reached, and a law was enacted to formalize the outcome of this negotiation.

The third conference was primarily focused on reflecting on social dialogue. A few months later, this resulted in the Rebsamen law. This conference also revitalized apprenticeships, and important decisions were made that have already yielded results for this school year.

So what can we conclude? No conference has been without follow-up. None of these meetings has been without consequence or significance.

All the conferences have opened new avenues, fostered reflections, and concluded with national agreements or laws.

Today, our conference is undoubtedly one of the most important of the five-year term, because it confronts us with the major transformations at work: the digital revolution, the energy transition, ecological changes, the future of work, new production relationships, and this conference is entirely focused on the issue of unemployment and thus the creation of jobs.

This conference compels us to conceive new instruments, new rules for new progress. This conference poses a major question: are we capable of reinventing our social model, while remaining faithful to the values that founded it?

This conference places us all, both those present and those absent, before our responsibilities. Do we want an organized and peaceful democracy with actors ready to compromise when possible, or do we consider that we must put an end to social partners, to intermediary bodies, to parity, or revert to power struggles, confrontation, and conflict on all subjects and in all places?

It is tempting, so easy indeed, to attack social dialogue because it is deemed too slow, too cumbersome, too distant, to question the legitimacy of unions, of employer organizations, and to regard parity as an outdated relic from the post-war era, which we would only have to maintain, even though it is what underpins the management of our main social systems.

It is also to forget that every year, 1,600 branch agreements and 40,000 company agreements are signed, most often by all representative organizations. It is also convenient for others to never commit to signing any agreement, hoping that others will do it for them, while simultaneously denouncing the shortcomings of social dialogue.

I believe in the role of representative organizations. I believe in the necessity of having responsible actors who commit. I believe in social dialogue, and I will never accept that the inexcusable violence that occurred at Air France could be used as an opportunity to attack trade unionism as a whole.

What happened in this large company justifies, on the contrary, the recourse to social dialogue with shared efforts to avoid layoffs and ensure the future of this company. Social dialogue does not erase conflicts, contradictions, or divergent interests; it organizes them, gives them a framework, and promotes compromise in the very interest of those who sustain the company.

What is true for social dialogue in branches, in companies, and at the national level is also true for social systems. Some social systems may fall under the law and thus under the government and Parliament. This was the subject of the pension reform of 2014, and I am already pleased with the results made possible by this evolution, as the general old-age insurance system is already balanced this year.

Then there are social systems that adhere to the rules set by social partners in the name of parity. This is the case for complementary pensions.

In this regard, the principle agreement reached on October 16 between employers and several trade union organizations is, in my eyes, a proof of responsibility. Many anticipated failure, as courageous measures were necessary to safeguard the ARRCO and AGIRC, which had a horizon of only twelve years for employees and even three years for executives.

Failure would have led not only to a financial deadlock but ultimately to the bankruptcy of the systems. This would have resulted either in their nationalization—where the government would have been asked to define, in place of social partners, the future of complementary systems—or in privatization, where insurance companies would have been asked to provide the supplement. This would have created immense insecurity for future retirees, that is, today’s employees.

Thanks to the efforts that have been planned, the pay-as-you-go systems are preserved until 2030—all pay-as-you-go systems, general system, complementary system—and the rights are largely maintained, without the retirement age being pushed back, since that remains the choice offered for future retirees.

Our country needs to move forward, needs to be reformed, but to achieve this, it is necessary to provide guarantees, guarantees to employees for their fundamental rights, guarantees to companies regarding the visibility that must be theirs for making their decisions and choices.

And I want to be clear, the status quo is no longer possible, and the alternative is reform or rupture, the renovation of the social model or its disappearance. Never have the subjects for negotiation been so numerous. I spoke of the relationships to work, linked to new technologies, personal services that blur the boundaries of employment, lifelong training, unemployment compensation, new jobs related to the energy and ecological transition.

On all these issues, France will not advance without a common preparation of decisions, without in-depth consultation on responses, and without negotiation on the consequences. Social dialogue is therefore not a formality, not an obligation, I do not know which one, but a condition for progress.

Employers will not be able to navigate the transformations without the participation of employees, the elevation of their qualifications and their level of training. As for employees, they cannot expect everything from the law and the labor code as it stands. If it is not adapted to the new economic, ecological, and technological conditions, it will only protect them in a virtual manner, and circumventions will multiply, as we are already seeing, to the detriment of employment and social rights.

So, we must move forward. Everyone here understands the gravity of the period; we know the fractures, the tensions, the strains that traverse our country, and no one is fooled by the game of those who advocate retreat behind national borders under the pretext of saving us from everything, when that would lead to the ruin of French work, knowing that a third of our country's production is exported.

I also remind you that our competitiveness is the best guarantee for our future employment. What can we say about those who advocate dismantling the labor code, the duration of work, the employment contract, or even the minimum wage, supposedly to save companies at the expense of workers and social cohesion?

This reminds me of the proponents of the great evening, who, even if they came from a completely different camp and had a completely different vision of society, thought that it was possible to wipe the slate clean all at once. No, there is no more wiping the slate clean than there is radicality; there is the reform that we must undertake.

I know that it is not easy, in such a context, negotiation, consultation, compromise, and yet, these are essential approaches, because we need cohesion, not division. My objective, that of the government, is reform, and my method, that of the government, is social dialogue. Social dialogue does not prevent decision-making at the end of a process, and on no subject will there be any renunciation.

The approach I propose to you is to frankly address the major questions that are posed to us and that are on the agenda of the conference.

First, the personal activity account—this is a major reform that will undoubtedly take more years to come into effect, but which will begin today. Our social model must focus on better anticipating disruptions, providing opportunities for promotion, and closing the various traps of precariousness that have multiplied in recent years.

We must support employees in professional transitions and transform these mobilities, these mutations into opportunities, and for that, we must build legal instruments to ensure the continuity of employees' professional lives. This is the personal activity account.

Every active person will be endowed, from their entry into professional life, with a form of capital, a heritage that will belong to them, and which will be enriched throughout their life by rights that will accumulate, most often expressed in time, and which will allow this employee to have better mobilization of their rights, to make professional choices that will ensure them mobility, a change of profession, a promotion, a return to work if they have lost it.

The personal activity account is therefore primarily a greater capacity for autonomy recognized for each individual, but also new guarantees, fungible rights, portable, easily accessible rights, rights that will aggregate the time savings account, the account for the prevention of hardship, the training account, and even leave rights. And in the discussion that will take place during the UNEDIC convention, this mechanism can also be implemented so that social partners can see it as a solution to a number of transitions.

The principle of the personal activity account has already been provided for by a law, the Rebsamen law of August 17, and it remains to decide on the modalities. France Stratégie has submitted its report to the Prime Minister, and this report constitutes a solid basis for your work so that the reform can quickly move forward. The Minister, Mrs. EL KHOMRI, will present a guidance document to social partners at the end of the month on these various points, so that an agreement or a common position can be reached by mid-December.

This text will specify the key elements of the reform, the possibilities for pooling existing personal accounts, the creation of a rights portal, the strengthening of support, the realization of the right to a second chance for young people who leave without qualifications, and who may also be endowed with a starting capital. Discussions will continue with the regions during the month of November, and the goal is for the draft law to be submitted to Parliament at the beginning of next year. This is the major reform that is the personal activity account.

The second issue of the social conference is the place of collective negotiation. The Rebsamen law has considerably simplified the functioning of representative bodies. But the challenge today is to ensure that social dialogue comes closer to the company, as it is at this level that the necessary adaptations can be negotiated.

The principle of the majority agreement can allow progress in this direction safely for employees and their representatives. Based on the report presented to the Prime Minister by Jean-Denis COMBREXELLE, Mrs. EL-KHOMRI is conducting in-depth consultations that should lead, at the beginning of next year, to legislative provisions.

We must reduce the number of branches—there are 750 in France; I remind you that there are 50 in Germany—ensure that a real service is provided to SMEs and TPEs, and the COMBREXELLE report proposes method agreements to set the rules for negotiation and introduces the idea, which indeed deserves reflection, of fixed-term agreements so that there can be regular evaluations.

It is obviously not a matter of touching the principle of the labor code, the legal duration of work, the minimum wage, or the employment contract. The objective is not to reverse the hierarchy of norms; it is to bet on trust so that employers and employees, through their representatives, can jointly determine the best solutions for their company or their professional sector.

These provisions will therefore be included in the labor law project, which will be presented, as I reminded you at the beginning of the year, by the Minister of Labor, at the same time as the personal activity account. In general, our labor legislation has become unreadable over time, as highlighted by Robert Badinter and Antoine Lyon-Caen.

The problem is not the volume of our labor code, but the fact that it has become increasingly difficult to use for the interested parties themselves, that is to say, for employees, and increasingly difficult to practice for employers, particularly in SMEs and micro-enterprises. Because the labor code is the result of a long history and goes into detail on solutions that are now outdated, hence the complexity.

There will therefore be a clarification of the labor code, which will be launched without delay, and the Prime Minister will specify the method and the timetable.

The third question on the agenda of the conference is digital technology and what it can provoke in terms of work and employment. Again, there has been a report, which I want to acknowledge, that of Bruno Mettling, on digital transformation and life at work.

He reminds us that the great digital adventure impacts all activities and businesses; in the next fifteen years, 50% of current jobs will have evolved, some will have disappeared, or at least been transformed by the digital revolution. But others, even more numerous, will have been created. We must therefore take into account what this will change both in the volume of employment and in the quality of work.

We must ensure that more and more jobs are created by digital technology, and that the quality of work can be improved. Hence the questions, necessarily, to be addressed by social partners: the generalization of remote work, the right to disconnect, the accounting of time, particularly regarding annualized hours, working conditions, and also vocational training related to these new jobs.

I myself launched the Great School of Digital Technology to ensure that we have many more young people embarking on this learning. The Minister of National Education has introduced coding education in schools so that we have future employees who can take hold of this digital issue, not just to make it an element of their personal life or leisure, but to make it an asset to seek and find employment.

And digital technology must not create a divide, either territorially or among the French; it must be an asset made available, which also requires changing the mechanisms of vocational training, and adapting, moreover, all social tools to make them much more accessible to employees.

Digital technology also means the disappearance of certain repetitive or physical tasks, but it can also mean jobs that may be less qualified than in the past, and we must ensure that there is an elevation in the quality and employment content of digital growth. And then, there is also what we must do so that employees or so-called employees, who are hired by large organizations based on the collaborative or sharing economy, can have a status that is recognized for them, and that we avoid exits from social protection.

Forms of individualization that would weaken our solidarity systems. And there are also these blurred boundaries between employees, self-employed workers, service providers, or even individuals, calling into question other activities, which are themselves declared, as we have seen in a number of sectors, whether in transport or tourism.

So, we have to work on these issues, and it is the social partners with the State who will have to make the necessary proposals. We must think about technological progress and social progress together, and also free up a number of initiatives and energies. The law on new economic opportunities, which Minister Macron will present, in connection with the labor law, will allow for adaptation to the new activities of digital technology.

There will also be a framework set for both consumers and producers, so that we can maximize the benefits of the potential for both services and job creation that digital technology can generate. This law must give us all the opportunities to seize the opportunities and modernize our country without undoing rights. This is the entire challenge at stake.

How can we ensure that we can not only adapt but anticipate the movements of digital technology, without erasing essential rights, particularly those of employee protection? Ultimately, this reflection on digital technology is also one that we must engage in regarding ecological and energy transition. France will host the conference at the end of the year; there is currently a negotiation underway in Bonn, and we have a certain confidence in the outcome of this conference, as states have committed, and contributions have been made.

There will be an agreement in Paris. The whole question is at what level the agreement will be, and whether we can regularly revise it; that is the challenge of the negotiation. But I have no doubt, whatever happens in Paris, that this ecological and energy transition is underway; considerable movements will take place, and massive investments will be made.

And the whole question is whether France, which is ahead in a number of technologies, both for energy efficiency and for renewables, will further accentuate its lead or will ultimately be swept away by the movement. So we must, here too, make the energy transition not a constraint, not a sum of regulations, not new taxes; we must ensure that it is an economic asset and also a better way of living, while protecting the planet.

Today, nearly one million people work directly in the green economy; tomorrow, we believe that this will double or even triple, as long as the energy transition is carried out with massive investments and with a growing share of the population being concerned.

All of this can reveal new markets and new models for our industry. The energy and ecological transition is the future of industry in France, this industry, which has lost jobs over the past twenty years, this industry that has fallen behind in terms of competitiveness, particularly in recent years, this industry that has strengths that make us recognized all over the world, this industry must be strengthened, supported, and renewed.

And the energy and ecological transition combined with digital technology represents for us a considerable field of development and exports that can put us in a very favorable position compared to other countries. To prepare for this evolution, there is the law on energy transition and green growth, there are mechanisms that have been introduced, and there is also a strategy that has been defined.

I ask the social partners to take their full part in defining these choices, both in modes of production, in supporting activity, in organizing work, and in training. Because the problem we have in France is not only that it is already considerable to have three and a half million unemployed and many precarious workers; the problem we have is having jobs that are unfilled.

The problem we have is having job opportunities that are not seized, not because of job seekers or the unemployed, but because of a failing training system; initial training, we are working on it; these are the reforms we are undertaking for education. We have supported and stimulated apprenticeships, and there is the entire vocational training system, which requires that every euro collected in the field of professional organizations be directly allocated to preparing for tomorrow's jobs.

This requires that for young people, and even more so for the unemployed, these funds can be directly directed towards training that leads to jobs, which also justifies that Pôle emploi, with the regions, can offer more than today to every job seeker a qualifying training, especially for long-term unemployed individuals who are questioning the possibility of one day reintegrating into the labor market.

This is the major challenge of vocational training posed both by the level of unemployment and by the changes that our economy must face, confront, and seize. If there were no job opportunities, we could consider social measures, but here we have these opportunities that are there; we must train to have the best chances in the transitions that are taking place.

Here too, it goes without saying that a convergent position of all social partners on this vision, on this strategy, on this challenge of qualification and investment, yes, I tell you, a common strategy of all social partners, with the government, would be a precious asset to move forward.

At the confluence of all these challenges is the integration of young people. Much has been done since 2012: future jobs, apprenticeships, youth guarantees, education reform, the right to return to training for those who have been excluded too early from the school system, but we will need to do even more.

First, the right to return to training, which is now operational and welcomes thousands of young people who left school without qualifications, must be further amplified.

I particularly wish that the personal training account, which will therefore become the personal activity account for these young people, be credited with a sufficient number of hours to reach a first level of qualification.

Next, I wish for the renewal for 2016 of the plan related to priority training; this applies to both young people and older individuals. 100,000 were completed in 2015 with great success, as it is believed that 60% of these trainings led to employment.

This potential will be raised next year to 150,000, and even more directed towards long-term unemployed individuals, seniors, and young people.

Finally, as part of its ramp-up, the youth guarantee will offer 100,000 places in 2017 and will be extended to all willing territories starting in March 2016, that is to say, I hope, to the entirety of the territory. Because this is a major issue. We cannot leave a young person without training, without qualifications, and without employment.

Ladies and gentlemen, I have reminded you that our social model must renew itself to remain faithful to the values that constituted it. It cannot be an inexorably fixed construction outside the economic context and the reality experienced by employees.

But if social dialogue comes to a halt, either due to a lack of participation from the actors—they have the right to do so—or due to even questioning its usefulness—which would be false—then it is not social dialogue that will be halted; it is the social model that will be undone. And the first victims will be the employees who will be left to themselves without legitimate representatives capable of defending them; but the companies themselves, and I warn them if some had that idea in mind. The companies themselves, lacking social dialogue, lacking social responsibility, lacking a shared social model, would be confronted with movements they could no longer control, with confrontation, force, brutality, and despair.

Thus, through the social model, its future is at stake, as is the balance of the country and the very conception of social relations. It is the choice between confrontation and appeasement, rupture or reform, retreat or openness. And this question is not posed simply to the President of the Republic or the government; it is posed to each and every one of you, present or absent.

We have a duty to restore confidence in progress, in the future, in a collective project. Economic mutations, energy and ecological transitions, the new technological landscape offer us the view of new conditions to build a solid, new, creative economy.

These opportunities must be seized to serve growth and employment.

The economic recovery that is underway, although still insufficient, the restoration of our public accounts that has been carried out and will continue, and the improvement of our competitiveness that has been fostered by the Responsibility Pact, give us new opportunities to act, margins to invest. And the unemployment that remains at an unbearable level imposes on all of us the obligation to act.

Therefore, I will not slow down the pace of reforms in any way until the end of the five-year term, both in legislative terms with the labor law, with the digital law, and the new opportunities. Also in regulatory terms with simplification and with the improvement of workers' rights. I will not defer any social meeting, the UNEDIC, the evolution of the labor code, and the government will engage in all necessary negotiations on the major themes of the social conference.

The Prime Minister, when preparing the roadmap, will indicate the subjects, the method, and the timetable.

And I have confidence, I say this in this context, I have confidence in the social partners, beyond differences and sensitivities, to engage in this movement. Because this movement is that of a country that wants to face the future head-on; that wants to change a number of procedures without changing its nature; a country that knows it has considerable assets and only wants to implement them; a country that does not resign itself even if there are tensions, even if there are pressures, even if there may always be the ultimate demand for radicalism. A country that cannot accept that the essence of what has made social progress in our country is called into question. A country that also knows what it owes to the social partners.

There has been no major reform since the post-war period without the social partners being involved or taking responsibility themselves.

So I have confidence in social dialogue, in the necessary, indispensable reform, in the social model that we must not only preserve but evolve. I have confidence because I know what the French may feel during this period, a fear, a legitimate fear, what will the future hold? But they will not let themselves be overcome by fear, for no country has been able to be victorious if it has yielded to fear, retreat, and self-doubt. And that is why the social partners will be at the heart of what we have to do until the end to advance our country in reform and in dialogue. Thank you.