Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on Community Law, in Paris on June 17, 2014.

France François Hollande · President of France

17 June 2014 · General assembly of the Association of the Councils of State and Supreme Administrative Jurisdictions of the European Union · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed supreme administrative court presidents at a Paris general assembly on June 17, 2014, urging reflection on simplifying EU community law.
Main themes
European Union law, simplification of community law, subsidiarity principle, administrative jurisdictions coordination, fundamental freedoms, European construction, economic regulation, environmental law, immigration litigation, EU citizen engagement, climate change and law, judicial cooperation
Duration
~8 min
29th percentile
Words
979
29th percentile
Sentences
59
39th percentile
Readability
42
40th percentile
Grade
11.5
39th percentile
Syntax
2.80
22nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
58th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 66%66%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Economic 10%10%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

59 sentences in 18 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen Presidents,

Ladies and gentlemen judges and magistrates,

I wanted, at the initiative of President SAUVE, to welcome you today. First, to acknowledge your association which brings together the supreme administrative jurisdictions of the member states of the European Union and others from Switzerland, Turkey, Norway, and Montenegro. You are nearly 100 legal professionals gathered for your general assembly.

You are reflecting on these major questions: how can law be a factor of unity? How can law be a guarantee of fundamental freedoms? How can law advance the European Union? It is indeed through law that Europe has been built, through its treaties. But it has also developed through regulations and directives. It is also through law that Europe grants citizens new freedoms and provides economic and social actors with a framework to organize their actions.

The Court of Justice of the European Union, represented here, is the guardian of the fundamental principles of the Union. But it is the national administrative courts that ensure their application. Hence the importance of coordination, hence the necessity of coherence. Your association contributes to this.

Your jurisdictions indeed address all the major legal questions raised by European construction. Your association, for 15 years, has multiplied initiatives that allow for better understanding and therefore better decision-making, better judging.

You have first developed an exchange program that allows magistrates to go to the jurisdiction of other countries, to try to interpret, to better understand what the decisions of administrative courts can be.

You have also established a database that offers all members of the association access to the main decisions of your courts, allowing for evaluation, comparison, and above all, unification.

You organize conferences, beyond the general assemblies, and you address major themes that concern our fellow citizens: food security, environmental law, immigration litigation, and - as the Vice-President mentioned - the role of the administrative judge in economic regulation, namely controlling the regulators. Because no one should be fully independent or, if they are, they must also be responsible.

I want to suggest to you, and this is not the purpose of this invitation, an additional theme for reflection that is indeed at the heart of current European affairs. It is that of simplification. Behind the word simplification, there can be many intentions. They are not all necessarily benevolent. Behind simplification, there is deregulation, there is even the disappearance of competencies. Behind simplification, there can also be the temptation to challenge Europe for its excessive intervention in areas where states have agreed to share a part of their sovereignty.

But there can be in simplification, and this is my approach, a legitimate struggle against burdens, a fight for the application of a founding principle of the European Union, the principle of subsidiarity. It would be detrimental to the very idea of Europe to experience too much centralization or too much complexity that would cause everything, at some point, to revert to the European Union. This was not the intention of those who patiently built Europe.

So I leave you with this task: the simplification of community law. How to lighten a number of procedures that have accumulated? How to reduce delays? The question of time applies to both states and European institutions. How to provide stability and visibility to businesses as well as to citizens? These are objectives we must pursue because they allow, at the same time, to give more competitiveness to our economies and to guarantee equality of citizens before the norm.

There are many other questions that concern Europe and that directly affect you: how to improve the attractiveness of the European economy through law? How to guarantee European citizens better protection against a number of risks - health risks, environmental risks? How to prepare our societies for new challenges, particularly that of aging? How to combat climate change through law, without penalizing our economic dynamism?

I do not expect everything from the law. There are first those who make the law, namely the legislators, in this case, the national parliaments, the European Parliament, but also the European Council and the European Commission as far as it is concerned. It is not my intention to confuse responsibilities. There are those who enact the law and those who enforce it. But we must have the same objectives. They must be both economic (how to give more growth to our continent?) and also political (how to make Europe more loved?).

Is Europe loved through law? I leave you with this subject for reflection. Law can make Europe more lovable, and I advise you to take this direction!

The result of the last European elections, in France and in many other countries, resonates as a warning. We must engage citizens with Europe, not just through states, but through the idea of a Europe that can be, for them, more concrete, more protective. Whenever the law is abstract, complicated, then Europe moves away. We must have European law that is clear, readable, and whose purposes everyone can understand. This justifies what is your task: a unity of jurisprudence, a speed in the delivery of judgments and in their execution, a capacity to better understand the interpretations of your administrative courts.

Law is what Europe wanted to establish through values that we share: justice, equality, freedom, solidarity. We are a space of law and we must be concerned that, everywhere, the law applies, that justice applies, that the rules apply, so that citizens themselves are aware that they are protected. You are the guardians of these fundamental rights. Administrative jurisdictions contribute to building a stronger, more democratic Union that is closer to citizens.

This was the message I wanted to convey to you, at this moment of European construction, in a context that everyone knows, to express all the confidence that France places in the law that you are, you, responsible for enforcing.