Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on democracy and the functioning of the institutions of the Fifth Republic, in Paris on October 6, 2016.

France François Hollande · President of France

6 October 2016 · Statement on democracy and the functioning of the institutions of the Fifth Republic, conference 'Rebuilding democracy' · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed parliamentarians and academics at a Paris conference on rebuilding democracy, reflecting on democratic fragility and institutional reform on October 6, 2016.
Main themes
Crisis of democracy, democratic fragility and distrust, populism and extremism, citizen participation, institutional reform, Fifth Republic institutions, abstention and civic disengagement, globalization and powerlessness, political representation, constitutional reform in France
Duration
~45 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,440
93rd percentile
Sentences
232
92nd percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
12.8
55th percentile
Syntax
3.16
68th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 84%83%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

232 sentences in 97 paragraphs

Mr. President of the National Assembly,

Ladies and gentlemen, parliamentarians,

Ladies and gentlemen, academics,

Ladies and gentlemen,

"Rebuilding democracy," what a program! The very title of your conference, which follows your report, tells us all about the stakes and the urgency.

Democracy, which not so long ago we thought was on an irreversible path of progress, that it was here for generations and generations, who would necessarily seize it, which seemed like an obvious truth, now appears fragile, shaken, disrupted, and in any case contested. It is no longer its progress that is being celebrated, but its trial that is being conducted.

This is true in France. It is true everywhere in Europe. It is true in the United States, where a presidential election is being prepared, the consequences of which we know in advance will not be limited to America.

This crisis arises in the very nations where the modern conception of democracy was invented. This democracy seemed to have triumphed over everything, particularly totalitarianism. It appeared destined, by the force of example, for a deployment as universal as it was irreversible.

But here we are, for several years now, if not several decades, a silent, latent crisis has taken hold. It has been exacerbated by criticisms directed at the very results of democracy and a challenge to its forms of action and exercise.

Mr. President, you have pointed out the symptoms. First, abstention, which has reached high levels and is not silence; it is a deafening noise during every midterm election.

Then, elected officials who are judged to be increasingly distant from citizens, even as they continue to act in proximity. Traditional parties, but I would say all parties, are overwhelmed by new forms of political expression.

Even more seriously, democracies appear powerless; this is where the trial comes in, in the face of globalization, in the face of crises, in the face of everything that creates disorder.

Impatience is growing among an increasing number of citizens, faced with procedures that are too slow, too cumbersome, too opaque.

To this civic indifference, to this impatience, to this powerlessness, violence is also added, which finds its justification in the inability to reach a resolution.

When we take stock of this situation, when we look at this context, it is no surprise that extremist parties, everywhere in Europe and even beyond our continent, are feeding off this distrust. To the point, in fact, of claiming to exercise power seriously, in their turn, with all its attributes.

Extremism, populism are no longer forms of marginal protest, no longer expressions of anger. They are becoming demands for power. With all the appearances of democracy.

I understand that a debate is taking place about our institutions and about democracy. This debate is essential. You were right to open it.

It is, after all, the very essence of democracy to allow for criticism, to revisit it. But let us be careful that from questioning its shortcomings—of which there are many—we do not undermine its foundations. They are less solid than they appear.

It is by wanting another democracy that we risk, in the end, ending up with something other than democracy.

This is one side of the issue, but there is another, more positive side. It is in this movement that has been rising for several years, to contest the functioning of institutions, to denounce practices, usages, those of political life, and also to highlight the inadequacies of our rules in relation to what the world and society are today.

There is, therefore, an aspiration that must be heard and, above all, translated. This aspiration is the citizens' demand for more participation in decision-making, for more control over public policies, and also for more collective elaboration, including in the drafting of laws.

It is to consider that universal suffrage is not the only means of making one's voice heard and that there are others throughout the process of building policies or developing collective rules.

This also applies at the local level, but local democracy, even if it has been revitalized, is not enough to extinguish this irrepressible need to have a say, especially in the context of digitization, where every opinion is worth another.

The questions regarding the functioning of our institutions—I speak before historians—are not new. Almost every presidential term has corresponded to a commission tasked with making proposals, generally at the end of the term. I had preferred to do it at the beginning, but I was unable to implement everything that, in particular, the JOSPIN Commission had proposed.

Nevertheless, I would be unjust, as many reforms have been carried out over the past fifteen years to implement these reflections, these conclusions from working groups or commissions.

I think, for instance, of the five-year term, which also came from a collective reflection, back in 2000. I think of the constitutional revision of 2008, with the sharing of the agenda of the Assemblies, the creation of the Defender of Rights, and the introduction of the QPC, which has indeed changed the very organization of our justice at the highest level, as it involves a review of the conformity of laws that have already been voted on with the Constitution.

Proposals, it is true, abound at the moment. It must be the season, and I do not complain about this creativity. Nevertheless, this creativity is often a repetition.

Some invoke a Sixth Republic with the abolition of the position of Prime Minister or, conversely, the reduction of the President of the Republic's prerogatives. Others include in the Sixth Republic a parliamentary regime. Some focus solely on changing the electoral system, believing it to be the key to everything. It is true that in 1958, the majority voting system had even more effective effects for rationalized parliamentarism than any particular article of the Constitution.

So, you invited me to do so, Mr. President, I will share my experience with you.

I have long been a deputy. I have been a local elected official. But I have been President of the Republic for nearly four and a half years now. I draw several conclusions from this.

First, our institutions are solid and adapted to circumstances. No one knows exactly what the circumstances of a presidential term will be. My predecessors have experienced many situations that have led the one who wanted the Fifth Republic and was its first president to draw a number of conclusions from these conditions.

But these institutions have allowed me to make choices in extremely important moments in the life of our country.

To decide to intervene in Mali within a few hours. Later, in the Central African Republic to prevent massacres. To react overnight to terrorist attacks that have struck our country and continue to threaten it, to speak with authority, as much as possible, at the European Council, when it was necessary, for example, to decide the fate of Greece overnight or, later—in another place, a conference in Paris—to decide on the Paris Agreement on climate, without having any mandate other than that of the French people.

In the face of external dangers, no one will consider that they are not there in the face of internal threats; the Fifth Republic gives the head of state the means to act when the essential is at stake for freedom, for sovereignty, and for security.

I have been aware, in the moments I have experienced, that our country has an institutional asset that it would be very risky to want to deprive itself of in the context I have just described, and which differentiates us from many countries. Not so much because they are parliamentary regimes—some are presidential regimes—but because the Fifth Republic, through its reserved domain undoubtedly, through a number of prerogatives, has given the head of state the means to act quickly. And the whole issue today, I will return to this, is to act quickly.

If I had to give, ultimately, it is my role, a piece of advice to all those who want to be my successors, even if there will only be one, perhaps, but one day, even if there are those who have already held this position, if I have a piece of advice to give, and I do so with the experience that is mine, but without wanting to interfere in choices, it is to understand well that what is seen as a prerogative of the head of state is in fact a guarantee for the French, is in reality a security for all and gives our country, France, a possibility to act when many countries cannot. And not simply because they would not have the power.

When there was this serious, even more inhumane crisis, which was the use of chemical weapons by the regime of Bashar al-ASSAD—it was in August 2013—the British Prime Minister decided to summon his Parliament, namely the House of Commons, to see if it was conceivable to imagine an intervention. He was not allowed to do so.

President OBAMA, who was not obliged to do so, but considering that he had made commitments to his country during the presidential election—particularly by refusing to intervene in Iraq—also thought it possible to consult Congress.

I was the only one, at first, to think that we should intervene. Because a red line, as they say, had been crossed and chemical weapons had been used, in violation of all international laws. I could decide to do it, but if I did not do it, it was because there could not be international action with others. But we can clearly see the consequences that this absence of decision has provoked.

So, it is important to measure that what France's institutions are is, in fact, for the world also a guarantee and a possibility of having a country that can defend international law and the rules of communal life.

So, we have often talked about personal power to qualify precisely the place of the President of the Republic and the role he can have in our institutions. But in reality, I have fully respected the Constitution. I have consulted, made my decisions, with the Prime Minister, in the Defense Council, in the Council of Ministers.

This has not been done to the detriment of Parliament, which has been seized, each time, to confirm or deny the orientations that have been taken. This is true for support for external operations (under Article 35), to ratify European and international agreements, including the European budget treaty—everyone remembers it, sometimes with pain—or to extend the state of emergency.

If a rebalancing is to be done, it is not by introducing prior control of the head of state's decisions by Parliament; it is by strengthening the capacities of our Assemblies to evaluate and, if necessary, to put an end to certain operations. Parliament can do this in our institutions.

Always in the name of this experience and outside of any personal convenience or prejudices, I would like to pause for a moment on a number of proposals that are being put forward in the public debate regarding our institutions.

I tell you straight out, I am not in favor of restoring the seven-year term. Not because I would not want to inflict two more years on those who do not necessarily share the same views as I do, but in any case, I could not. But I want to come to considerations that pertain to institutional logics.

It is true that the seven-year term, whose history is one of a desire for patience, waiting for the decision of a candidate for the throne, who did not want to renounce the white flag. But the seven-year term would give, as it has in the past, a duration that would allow the head of state to carry out his international action, with undoubtedly an advantage over all other heads of government or heads of state who have mandates of only four or five years. Time and stability are an asset in diplomacy.

But it would not confer on the President an additional margin in domestic politics since there would always be a parliamentary majority that would be elected for five years.

As for placing the President "above the parties" and confining him to defining the broad orientations, I also tell you frankly, universal suffrage, the direct election of the President of the Republic means that it is always towards him, regardless of the ministers and Prime Ministers who are supposed to protect him, that the people turn when they have to demand accountability.

He cannot remain in a position that would be that which was conceived, no doubt initially in the Fifth Republic and which owed much to the person of General de GAULLE, a high position, which would look only with relative complacency at what can be decided in the administration. No. Today, everything goes back to the President of the Republic, even what he does not know, even what he has not decided, even a parliamentary amendment, slipped in at night and not necessarily coming from the Government. Everyone thinks they inspired it. He can protest and say he does not know the parliamentarian in question. But then, it is worse! He is supposed not to know what is happening in the National Assembly or the Senate.

So, today there is - because society has changed - because we are in a relationship of immediacy, precisely this demand to hold accountable those who have been elected directly by universal suffrage to lead the country.

Just a point of history. The last seven-year term, outside of periods of cohabitation, was that of Valéry GISCARD d'ESTAING. It was indeed the only one since 1965. This means that, in fact, even before the five-year term was restored, everything reverted to a five-year mandate.

The second topic that comes up is the use of referendums; here too, history should be a good advisor. Its use is not very encouraging, since it was introduced in the year 2000, it generated very little enthusiasm, while the consensus seemed very large - 30% participation - confirming that the French are less passionate about institutions than about democracy.

The 2005 referendum on the European Treaty was more successful, in terms of participation, but it left deep scars in the country. If we think of the uses made by neighboring or more distant countries, in very different contexts, we see the difficulties. Regarding Brexit, those who called for a negative vote withdrew, and those who called for a "yes" vote now bravely decide to go all the way with Brexit, go figure! But we will hold firm, we too!

Should I talk about the Hungarian referendum, where participation can be encouraging, in the sense that it was low, but where the result does not necessarily give us great hope for tolerance?

Should I talk about the referendum in Colombia, where even a peace agreement, although historic, can be contested?

So, unless we use popular consultation as a means to seek out in the crowd the expression of its anger, I am not sure that this is, again, a good mode of governance and law-making.

On the other hand, the formula that may have never been used could be situated in a more peaceful framework if several questions in different areas were submitted to the French people and if it were possible for voters to respond to each of the questions - which could both depassion the relationship and depersonalize the relationship with the one who posed the questions and allow citizens to make choices on a number of subjects in different areas.

The voting system has been a regularly posed question since the introduction of universal suffrage. The Third Republic was charged with numerous debates, the Fourth introduced proportional representation to correct it, and it was not very glorious, and the Fifth restored the majority voting system.

It is true that proportional representation is widely practiced in Europe, and we know its advantages: taking into account the diversity of political currents, promoting parity, forming broader and therefore more sustainable coalitions. We also know its disadvantages: the fragmentation of representation, the risk of instability.

During the 2012 campaign, I spoke in favor of introducing a share of proportional representation in the legislative election for the National Assembly. I remain convinced of this, but it can only be done with a limited number of seats and with a significant reduction in the number of deputies.

I add, because it is often forgotten, that there is a parliamentary assembly that is already largely elected by proportional representation: it is the Senate, even if its electoral body, and this limits the exercise, is made up of elected officials from the territory.

For all these reasons, I believe that the answer does not lie solely in a new institutional arrangement, even if it can evolve, but in a profound change in representation, decision-making procedures, and modalities of participation. This is how our Republic must move forward.

In a democracy worthy of the name, how can we accept that women, working-class categories, young people, and the French in their diversity are so underrepresented? How, in a modern democracy, can we admit that the same people hold the same mandates for decades?

This is the meaning of the reforms I have initiated since 2012 with the support of Parliament - for nothing would have been possible without Parliament - notably the non-cumulative mandates of parliamentarians and members of a local executive. I am sure, first of all, that this reform will necessarily be irreversible. Good luck to those who want to go to the French to defend what will appear as an old order. We are told about proximity? But nothing will prevent the deputy, the senator from maintaining local representation. We are told that we should be sure to find our elected representative. But do not worry, the French find them, even on election day. So, how to justify, except by the desire to please wrongly elected officials who ultimately want, when they are parliamentarians, to be fully representatives of the Nation?

I am sure that this reform will contribute to the renewal and strengthening of our assemblies. But it is your formula, and I take it up: we must now invent the Parliament of non-cumulative mandates, which means giving more means to parliamentarians who must be primarily dedicated to this mission to prepare, deliberate, and control the executive power.

The non-cumulative mandate has been part of the territorial reform that we have built and successfully implemented. Again, a reform that was deemed impossible and which will last, not because the thirteen regional presidents will be eager to remain in the regions that have been drawn - these are personal aspects - but because the French women and men have seen this change take place before their eyes.

Thirteen stronger regions instead of twenty-two, metropolises that can have a size that allows them to compete in territorial competition within Europe itself, a map of intercommunalities that has ultimately been modernized and which has allowed for a 30% reduction in structures. And even if there have been challenges, today, who really questions this new territorial organization? There is this clarification of competencies that has been awaited for a long time and the non-cumulative mandate that will allow for the full exercise of all these functions.

There have also been, since 2012, reforms that have not necessarily been as commented on as the previous ones but that have also changed things: the recognition of blank votes, which came from a parliamentary initiative, but also the reform of voter registration with the creation of a unique electoral directory that will prevent a citizen from being deprived of voting because they did not act in time. Contrary to what is said, there is, of course, a voluntary abstention, but there is also a forced abstention and young people, the vulnerable, the modest, people who move around, who are mobile, who are deprived of the right to vote, not because they do not want to exercise it, but because it is difficult.

And then, since 2012, we have introduced an "institution of integrity": the High Authority for Transparency in Public Life, not so that delinquent behaviors cease - as if a High Authority would shield elected officials from any temptation, as if erecting judges meant that there were no more delinquents - no, the High Authority's objective is precisely to show that elected officials respect the law and to do so transparently. This publicity should not be feared because it helps to avoid conspiracy, suspicion, and rumors that are deliberately maintained and that can lead to a moment of confusion of genres and interests. Let us avoid these processes.

In the same way, it is important that there has been, in the parliamentary debate, an additional penalty of ineligibility for elected officials convicted of breaches of probity. This is also part of the exemplary nature.

In the same bill that is referred to as the "Sapin Law," a directory is also planned, and you are working on it to inform citizens of the relationships that may exist between representatives of interest groups and public authorities. Very well. This will also allow us to know how a legislative text is developed, which is in the public interest and which can sometimes be contradicted by private interests. It is about putting an end to suspicion, distrust, and the supposed or real influence of one group or another.

But what has been done is no longer to be done. This applies to institutions as well as to many other areas, and that is why I allow myself to say what has been done, fearing that it has not yet been sufficiently recalled. But we must go further.

After the non-cumulative mandates, I am in favor of non-cumulative mandates over time, to three consecutive mandates for parliamentarians and local executives. Three mandates is a sufficient duration. It is true that this was not the tradition. It is true that in the history of the Republic, there were parliamentary careers - we still know some that are or were exceptionally long. But we are in another time.

This does not mean that those who have served three parliamentary mandates will not be able to become mayors or presidents of an executive, but they will have to change mandates. Again, this is part of what we must do to promote the back-and-forth between the Assemblies and also between professional life and political life.

This also applies to the senior civil service, whose recruitment methods must change. Thierry MANDON is working on this so that the worlds of research, university, and business can come closer, including to participate in the preparation of the law, in public decision-making, and that it is not always the same categories, the same backgrounds, that can decide in place of those who are the most concerned.

I will share my experience on the making of the law with you, because it is the major issue. More time must be devoted to its preparation and less time to its adoption. In other words, every major legislative reform must now be preceded by an open consultation that can take various forms: digital, citizen jury, participatory debate, Economic, Social and Environmental Council. We have experimented with this for the digital law, and we are also doing it differently for the law on real equality overseas. This consultation must be generalized, made mandatory, and provided with a framework.

Citizens should not simply be consulted on the law being prepared but can also be the initiators of the law. There is, in our Constitution, a procedure that has been so tightly locked that it is, by definition, not used: it is the referendum of popular initiative. The thresholds must be lowered: today, 4.5 million citizens are required, and with an initiative that belongs to parliamentarians. We must maintain systems of control. We can see the abuse that could be made of it. But these thresholds do not truly allow the right to be exercised.

We must also recognize the right of petition, and Parliament could be required to organize a debate as soon as 500,000 signatures have been collected on a proposal.

The two devices are indeed complementary: making citizen legislative initiative possible, under certain conditions, and making citizens' concerns heard in Parliament, including through a citizen amendment right if it is framed.

One of the lessons I draw, and it is yours, is that there is an increasingly glaring gap between the time required by the law-making process and the speed expected by citizens.

We have procedures that date back to the last century at best, sometimes from the 19th century. We have procedures that were designed precisely because time was needed and that it is time that protected against a number of whims that could potentially take over some assembly. This means that we now have projects that are sometimes long awaited and that take months and months. On average, at the shortest, 6 to 7 months, sometimes 9 to 10 months; sometimes we even see proposals for laws that come back every year and are never voted on by the end of the session, even though French women and men are waiting for a number of changes and think that we do not want what we have announced, proclaimed, promised. This explains this gap, this feeling that, ultimately, there is powerlessness, indifference, or worse, even contempt for what we do or what we declare.

This duration is no longer even a guarantee of quality when the same bill comes back seven times in public session, often with the same participants who sometimes repeat the same speeches and most of the same votes, even if there are always one or two originals. This slowness contributes to an exacerbated feeling that a law has been prepared for several months, often without consulting citizens, deliberated in a Council of Ministers after advice from the Council of State. It takes a month before it comes to the Assembly or the Senate, several months before being voted on, and then the implementing decrees, whereas everything should have been anticipated, which do not allow for the application of the law. So, if an alternation occurs on top of that, I am not saying this to prevent it, but if an alternation occurs, you see what the product of public action ultimately is.

So we need to change. Some think that resorting to ordinances can resolve this situation, which would be contradictory to the rights of Parliament. But again, the enabling bill must go through the same procedure, with back-and-forths, with repeated and insufficient readings, to then be ratified by Parliament. I see that it is not simply for reasons of speed that some propose ordinances. They think that by bypassing Parliament to challenge the social model, they could bypass the people. But they will find it around the corner because what interests with information is not necessarily what is debated in Parliament, it is what is done, not done, or undone. One cannot escape this control of the people over what is decided in their name.

I want, I therefore propose that we completely review the legislative procedure. We must take the necessary time to address the major societal questions and perhaps even security issues, bioethical laws, freedoms. We should be able to limit ourselves, however, to a single reading in each Assembly for texts where urgency is declared. Ensure that amendments can be adopted in committee and minimized in session. And I am even in favor of establishing an expedited procedure in Parliament, that is to say, a deadline, as exists for finance laws.

The finance law is undoubtedly the most important law, the one that will govern taxation in our country, that is to say, the redistribution and financing of collective functions. It is what will determine the action of public authorities through the expenditures that are voted on.

No one is shocked that it takes 70 days to vote on a finance law while it is the most important law. Whereas for any other law, we will be looking at six months or eight months. So there are laws that must be voted on within a limited timeframe.

Finally, and it is up to the government and the administration to ensure this, laws must come into force within a timeframe set by the texts; otherwise, the law would become inapplicable.

The last element of this reform is that evaluation must be thorough and left to Parliament with additional resources. I have great respect for the Court of Auditors; I was a member at one point in my life, but the Court of Auditors, which does admirable work to certify public accounts, has become an evaluation body whereas this evaluation must be done by Parliament. This does not mean that the Court of Auditors or other authorities—I am talking about independent authorities—should not also participate in this work, but it is primarily Parliament's role to do so.

I will conclude, Ladies and Gentlemen, with several reflections.

The first is that we are talking about institutions, and in fact, we are returning to democracy. It is democracy that must be revitalized, that must be rethought, that must be, to some extent, revisited in relation to our procedures, our rules, our ways of functioning.

And then, there is a paradoxical relationship that exists in our society regarding power, and Claude BARTOLONE has returned to this because this reflection applies to many countries. Power is the subject of permanent contestation, even desacralization, but at the same time, it remains an irreversible and irrepressible aspiration towards the State, even towards a State that should be strong.

So some have the answer: it is by limiting the intervention of the State that it will be made stronger and that we can thus escape its questioning. Here too, it is an illusion because the horizontality of society, the extent of distrust towards obligations coming from above, and the trial of illegitimacy that authority suffers due to insufficient majority, all this prevents the State from claiming to be able to do everything or that it must be strong to be respected.

So, what conclusions can we draw? What is essential to reconstitute is less an institutional architecture than a moral and civic renovation. It is about giving meaning to the Nation to hold together around the principles that constitute the Republic. This implies promoting—beyond all forms of consultation, participation, and involvement in decision-making—forms of commitment, all possible commitments, and enabling the recognition of the diversity of origins and memories to constitute a common project, so that what is decided in the places of power can be recognized as legitimate and useful and capable of providing hope or a rule.

The role of the President of the Republic is to be the guarantor of the unity of the Nation and the embodiment of France in the world. It is an irreplaceable role in a democracy and particularly in ours, but it is also a major civic challenge to mobilize French men and women regarding this unity and this gathering around the essentials and this awareness that we are part of a whole and that we cannot detach ourselves from it, at the risk of losing ourselves, dividing ourselves, dislocating ourselves.

Finally, my last reflection is that if our democracy must modernize, must expand, must find within itself new forms of expression, participation, and decision-making modes, if Parliament itself must change, if the executive must also have other modes of drafting its texts and implementing its policies, it remains that the foundation of democracy is universal suffrage. The issue is the vote. It is what decides the fate of the country. We would end up forgetting it. Nothing replaces the vote, and when we forget it, it is often too late.

Democracy is always choice, always alternative, and nothing comes that citizens have not wanted or have not prevented. That is why democracy is the subject. Its institutions must evolve, its rules must be perfected, modernized, but the vote, if it is not given meaning, if it is not given that hope that has long ensured that many of our fellow citizens not only fought to seize it but especially committed themselves as they did for change to happen through the vote, that is the essence of the struggle that must be ours, to ensure that the vote does not decide forever and for everything but that the vote can determine the democracy we want.

Thank you.