Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the role of Jacques Delors in European construction and on the challenges and priorities of the European Union, in Paris on October 6, 2016.

France François Hollande · President of France

6 October 2016 · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed a gathering at the Notre Europe institute in Paris, paying tribute to Jacques Delors and reflecting on EU challenges and priorities on October 6, 2016.
Main themes
Jacques Delors legacy, European integration, single market, economic and monetary union, social Europe, EU governance, Maastricht Treaty, European Commission leadership, democratic reform, Notre Europe institute, European identity, political cohesion
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,512
89th percentile
Sentences
213
90th percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
11.0
33rd percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 45%45%
  • Institutional 24%24%
  • Economic 14%14%
  • Social 9%8%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

213 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Dear Enrico LETTA, I am happy to see you in this responsibility today, to be at the head of "our Europe." I knew you as the President of the Italian government, coming to Paris for your first trip, recalling that you were raised in a family in Strasbourg - which explains your perfect French, but your English is no less so - but you always had, at the European Council, the delicacy to speak our language, when sometimes French people or Francophones consider it smarter to do so in English, which, by the way, will become an incongruity tomorrow. So, I, President, you, the State, we are together this evening.

I inevitably think of Jacques DELORS, who could not be present today, because he profoundly marked my political commitment, contributed to making it possible for me to be not only a political activist but also a European activist. We are gathered here this evening to both remember what he did for Europe and at the same time what he wanted to engage with the institute. Here, several have presided over its destinies.

"Our Europe" was indeed created once Jacques DELORS had left the presidency of the Commission, a ten-year mandate that he dedicated, in a time that was not as easy as one believes today, to strengthening the Union, to its integration and also to its enlargement. During all the years he was President of the Commission, he gave breath, dynamism to this Institution. He was also surrounded by heads of state and government who wanted to accompany him. Not all, but most were eager to carry a European project at a time when Europe was not yet facing what would be its challenge - reunification - and when Europe thought it was a space of prosperity and democracy.

It is thanks to Jacques DELORS that the single market took place, the extension of regional policy, the launch of the economic and monetary union, and an ambition for social Europe was carried. Jacques DELORS was undoubtedly the first to understand that an integrated economic area had to be accompanied by strengthened political cohesion, and also by a social hope to unite peoples. He wanted the single currency and he worked as early as 1989, with a group of personalities - several of whom are present here - to lay the foundations that led to the Maastricht Treaty.

However, he always had an accurate vision of what this treaty carried and what it had forgotten. What it carried was the creation of a currency that would unite countries and peoples. But what was missing in the Treaty, and what we have suffered from since, was governance, coordination of economic policies, and also a vision of what social harmonization should be. Jacques DELORS also perceived early on that at the pace of integration there were risks of exhaustion and perhaps even rupture.

That is why he wished, between 1985 and 1992, after so many steps had been taken, that the next step could be slowed down so that the achievements of Europe could be preserved and strengthened. Throughout his mandate, Jacques DELORS had the delicacy and care to think that there could not be just an Europe of Institutions and that economic and social actors also needed to be associated. He sometimes secretly brought together business leaders and union leaders in Brussels to discuss what the new advances of social Europe could be.

Jacques DELORS also wanted to bring together intellectuals, great European figures, to reflect on the deepening of Europe. He was aware that cultural, spiritual, and intellectual influence was decisive in making Europeans understand that what united them was not just a market, a currency, exchanges, but values and principles that could not only protect them against the risks of a return to conflict but also forge a European identity.

He was the first to understand that citizen organizations had a role to play in Europe. This justified the birth of this institute, Notre Europe. For 20 years, you have all worked so that Jacques DELORS could continue to spread his thought, propose advances.

One of them changed our European Institutions, with a democratic innovation that made the President of the Commission the product, in the best sense of the term, of the vote of Europeans.

Often what is inscribed in Treaties or what is placed in Institutions has no future. They are put there so that they are never used. It happened, after the last European elections, that the political group that had achieved the best result, which therefore had the largest number of parliamentarians, claimed the presidency of the Commission. This did not necessarily contribute to creating a consensus within the European Council.

It took socialists or social democrats, who had lost the elections, to say: "But no, we accept this principle and Jean-Claude JUNCKER, who had been designated by the parties, the European People's Party, must become the next President of the Commission." It is thus, thanks to the support of socialists and social democrats that Jean-Claude JUNCKER is President of the European Commission. But he is also because he relies on a broad majority in the European Parliament, and it was very important that this Union could be preserved. He ensures to provide everyone with elements to continue to carry the European project, even in this very difficult period.

Jacques DELORS also had the foresight to think that environmental and climate issues would be decisive for the future of Europe. He thought early on about the creation of a European Energy Community, the significance of which we see today. I am speaking here, before you, at a time when the Climate Agreement that was signed in Paris will find its application by the end of the year. Europe has once again been decisive, as the European Parliament and governments have decided to make this joint ratification effective in the name of Europe.

I also want to salute the work of the Institute because for years, under the various presidencies that have been recalled from Pascal LAMY to Enrico LETTA, you have contributed to carrying many proposals on the Schengen area and its strengthening - we should have listened to you earlier - on the collective security of Europeans, on the creation of a eurozone budget which I think is now time to implement, or on an Erasmus for apprentices. Many of your proposals have been retained, often with the necessary time for heads of government to be convinced, but have been retained by the European Council or by the European Parliament.

Jacques DELORS often said that Europe needed firefighters, builders, but also architects, and he was right. The responsibility of heads of state and government, of leaders, is of course to resolve crises. If one thinks about it, Europe has always been in crisis, has always lived with crises, has always been subject to urgencies. This goes back a long way, even to the time when Europe was six. It experienced crises; it is not the number that causes crises, it is the situations. It is also the conflicts between states or between governments. It is of course the divergences regarding the assessment of a number of realities.

Europe has always lived with crises and the role of heads of state and government in the European Council is to overcome them. What is new in the period we are going through is that we are not living through just another crisis; we are living through the crisis of the foundations of Europe with the departure of one country, with deep divisions within the Union, with divergences that have intensified, with the return of nationalisms, with the rise of populisms. This is not just another crisis; it is the crisis of Europe in terms of its foundations and in terms of its project.

From this point of view, we must return - Enrico was right - to the sources and understand what the current situation of Europe is. Since I have been President of the French Republic, I have sat in many European Councils. Each time, we have been seized by urgency. The first European Council I participated in was in June 2012. Italy and Spain were in an extremely difficult situation. Banks were still threatened, and there were serious risks of state challenges and speculation that could have toppled the European Union.

We spent the necessary time there, usually at night, and it required a realization - it was Mario MONTI who represented Italy, Angela MERKEL of course Germany, and Jean-Claude was there as head of government. That night, very important decisions were made for Europe, to maintain the eurozone, to prevent Greece from leaving, to ensure that Italy, Spain, Portugal, and Ireland could be preserved and to set up mechanisms to provide the necessary funding, and the European Central Bank had taken its responsibility. I consider that night to be perhaps the most important of recent years.

Then there were other crises. The crisis with Greece, always Greece. One night, two nights, several nights to find the solution. It was politically, I would say culturally, civilizationally, essential that Greece could remain in the eurozone.

Then we experienced a much deeper crisis because it touches on values, the refugee crisis. This is where the divisions were no longer simply between large and small countries, the South or the North, or surplus countries versus deficit countries. No, the divisions appeared to be much more fundamental in the sense that some countries were ready to welcome and others refused. Some countries were ready to strengthen border control while others thought it was up to each to manage. When it came time to distribute - and here, Jean-Claude remembers - refugees as one would distribute or as one used to distribute budget envelopes or compensatory amounts, when it came time to distribute what were human beings, that is when we understood - that I understood - that Europe was at that moment facing a crisis of meaning and that it was no longer simply a matter of negotiating all night, and that there was perhaps a need to refound the common framework, the spirit that should unite us.

That is why it is no longer a matter of institutional architecture. It is no longer simply a matter of knowing what financial mechanisms we are going to implement to avoid this or that difficulty or bankruptcy. It is about knowing how we are going to redistribute.

Then comes the British question, which is as old as Britain's presence in the European Union. In debates I had with D. CAMERON to facilitate the United Kingdom's continued membership in the European Union, I told him that General de GAULLE had fought for years to prevent Britain from entering the common market. It even required a referendum in France - it was President POMPIDOU - for us to be able to welcome Britain into Europe. "Are you ready today, after so much work together, so many efforts we have made to better understand each other, are you ready to leave? Are you ready to renounce everything that had ultimately been a form of concession or compromise within the European Union?" I think David CAMERON imagined he would win his referendum. We too have had that hope. But beyond the choice of whether or not to hold a referendum, it is the people's response that must be viewed for what it is. What was at stake in the United Kingdom? Essentially immigration, not whether it was beneficial or not for Britain to remain in the Union.

It is clear that this question of immigration, this question of living together, this question of accepting the other - in this case, the other was European, he was Polish, he was Bulgarian, he could be Hungarian - that the acceptance of the other was no longer taken for granted. We are faced with this situation, so how can we overcome it? In Bratislava, we met at 27 to give ourselves an agenda, to set a horizon and to put ourselves in front of our priorities.

The horizon was to set a meeting for next March in Rome, since it is the 60th anniversary. The agenda is to be able to take step by step the most important questions - I will return to this - security, growth and employment, and everything that contributes to our living together, and notably culture, education, university, youth. I believe this approach is the right one. It has not been easy. It does not necessarily gather all our hopes in Europe, but it clearly sets the line we have chosen.

As often, we have reached the end. Some imagined it was possible to separate without a text, and then once there is a text on the table, misfortune strikes. We must take it as it is or change it. After several hours of discussions, wisdom dictates that we change nothing: better to have a text than no text at all. But this text, which was also prepared - and I want to express my full gratitude for the preparation done by Jean-Claude JUNCKER through the speech he delivered before the European Parliament just before the Bratislava summit, is the roadmap.

Does it protect us? Does it give us the assurance that we will regain this common spirit? Does it guarantee that we will be able to get to work on what is essential for the peoples? Or will the centrifugal forces be greater? The nationalist temptations that can sometimes be expressed in a referendum, we had an illustration of that on Sunday, even if we can be satisfied that participation was not high, but when we see those who participated, we can worry about the result.

So are we going to be stronger than all those who at some point think that Europe is no longer a given? Or more precisely, that we could remain there, but only coming to the table to seek what we are entitled to and avoid contributing according to the burdens we may estimate to be those of the future? For my part, I think we need to be clear on several subjects. The first is the question of sovereignty. I am deeply convinced that the solutions to the trials, the challenges that Europe is facing, will not be found in retreat, in closure, in national borders, and in renouncing collective solutions.

But it would also be illusory to think that the European idea can ignore the legitimacy of national sovereignties. It is undoubtedly by having this pretension that populist temptations have awakened and taken hold. Jacques DELORS himself had warned with this formula that raised many questions, sometimes sharp comments of "federations of nation-states." He understood well that it was the relevant formula that respected the States, and therefore the Nations, but at the same time led them to work together on a number of common projects. Hence the need to unite Europeans, but to respect the cohesion of societies, not to rush the peoples, to make them converge towards a common ideal without them having to renounce what makes their uniqueness.

A country like France, which has fully participated in the history and construction of Europe, is a country that is attached to the idea that its exception, its uniqueness - some call it identity, I am not sure that is the right formula - but in any case to the very idea of France, that the idea of France can be found in Europe. The second question arises, which is subsidiarity. What should Europe do? What should the States do? We also debated this in Bratislava, considering that there were several priorities that could be carried by Europe, better than the nations could do separately. It essentially concerns three areas.

First, the protection of borders. We have external borders; it is our responsibility to guarantee them. If we do not do so, countries will want to return to their national borders. Our common good is the external border, and for it to be respected, we must have dedicated means devoted to this obligation. These are the coast guards that have just been strengthened, the border guards. Our security also means ensuring that those who come to us can be registered and that refugees can be directed where they are expected, because that is the right to asylum. But conversely, migrants should be returned, resettled in their country of origin because they cannot assert a right to come onto European territory.

If there are no rules, there is no respect. And if there is no longer cohesion among European countries, there is no longer Europe. Therefore, the first priority that falls under European responsibility is to protect. To protect the borders and also to protect rights, particularly the right to asylum. Security has also become a European common good. France has long prided itself on having a defense that allowed it to project forces abroad, to ensure its independence through nuclear deterrence, and to be perhaps the country with strategic autonomy in Europe, which has allowed us to carry out a number of operations and to do so, even in the name of Europe, recently for Africa.

But I am aware that the greatest service France can render to Europe is to contribute to building common elements of defense and security together. Germany has evolved on this issue, and it is very important that it has been able to do so. It is not because the British have decided to leave that they should not be associated with this process. But all European countries must now coordinate to participate in a defense effort and to know what we can do together and what we can ensure through our own capabilities in each of our countries.

Protection also means forces to fight against terrorism. Terrorism has struck France but has also struck Europe: Belgium, Germany, Denmark, the British. We are aware that terrorism will remain a threat, which should lead us to do together what we cannot succeed in doing alone. To fight against terrorism, we must accept to cooperate, to coordinate our intelligence services, our police, our border controls. Who can do this better than Europe? In this sense, Europe is no longer seen as a risk but rather as a shield against a number of threats. This is the first major priority we must carry so that Europe can be understood by Europeans as an additional guarantee, an extra protection, a security.

The second priority is growth and employment. Of course, economic policies fall under the choices that each government must make for its own country. But we know that we need a boost. It is true that some countries that are in surplus should do more to stimulate. It is true that some countries that are in deficit - current account deficits or budget deficits - must continue the effort of competitiveness and recovery. This is what France is currently doing; we will see. But if there is no impetus coming from Europe, and not just through the central bank's policy, if there is no common will to create growth and employment through major investments, but not just investments for infrastructure, investments for energy, investments for ecological transition, investments for digital, we will not be able to achieve our results. If we want to have European champions that can have a global size, we must invest more, and that is the second priority.

The third is to ensure that culture, education, universities, and research can be carried out on a European scale. Here too, we will always have our own institutions, our tools, but if we do not have this ambition to be the best in the world - and we are in many areas if I judge by the Nobel Prizes awarded today or yesterday - if we do not have this will to be the best in our field, in all fields even, Europe will not be able to carry these values. European culture is not simply the sum of all the cultures of our respective countries. It is what ultimately made the European model that can be associated with a social space, a human space, with values.

I come to European identity. European identity is being able to weigh on the fate of the world. What often bothers me is to see that at the G20, G7 table, Europe is present, present through countries, present through institutions, but does it weigh enough? What we see returning today, for several years now, is the return of empires, of powers. This is undoubtedly a law of history. Empires that we thought were declining, disappeared, are awakening in forms that strangely resemble what existed before the First World War. There are also new powers emerging in economic and demographic terms. Does Europe consider itself a power? Does Europe speak as a power? But Europe is not just a pretension of power. It is a power that seeks only peace, harmony, development, and the resolution of crises.

We have a specificity in the global concert, and that is why, in the face of crises like Syria, where the voice of Europe, if not to say, and it is right, that we must do everything to ensure that humanitarian aid can reach, what is the voice of Europe? Often to provide support to suffering populations, and Europe is exemplary. But can we do more? Yes, not just through our countries but together. When there is a conflict that lasts long enough to allow entire populations to be massacred, as in Aleppo, can we not, as Europeans, contribute more if we decide to address the major questions of the world? This requires having means of force, it is true, diplomacies that we can put in common, and also having this will. But do all countries have this will?

I warn them. There are countries that think that the United States - European countries - that think the United States will always be there to protect them, to the point of even buying weapons only from the United States and not from Europeans. That can happen. There are countries that think there will always be a cover that will keep them safe from all influences. There are those who think they are not concerned by conflicts in the Middle East, that Africa has no link with Europe except for a few migrants who may wash up on the Italian coasts in appalling conditions. Those must be warned. Today, we are in a global world. Conflicts necessarily affect us.

So we must tell these European countries, and I will not cease to do so, that if they do not defend themselves, they will no longer be defended, regardless of who wins the American presidential election. And we hope rather one than the other, without taking sides, but there is not even a choice. But beyond that, whatever the president elected in November, the United States is no longer in the same conception of defense protection, while being our ally within NATO. This question is not posed, but Europeans must realize that, when they are the world's leading economic power - and they are - they must also be a political power with the capacity for defense.

European identity is not simply about defending oneself: it is about defending values and carrying a message to the world. What is the method to achieve this result? It is the one that Jacques DELORS proposed during his first term at the head of the European Commission. A shared objective, a deadline, and a program of measures. This is the spirit that Jean-Claude JUNCKER took up in his speech before the European Parliament, and France fully supports this approach.

Finally, there are the institutions. The European Commission, which must be the guardian of the treaties, it is true, but which must be more than that, which must remain a driving force and must always be concerned with compromises, but first and foremost carry proposals and serve the general interest of Europe. It is the Commission, the European Council. It is the States that must seek at some point the right synthesis, the balance, but which must be stimulated by the Commission and by the European Parliament that represent the peoples. I do not contest the national parliaments, on the contrary, the right and even the duty to be interested in Europe. We should not fear their desire to look at what is being done in Europe in the name of transparency. It would be a mistake to oppose national parliaments to the European Parliament.

I conclude. Jacques DELORS also faced a crisis provoked by the United Kingdom. At that time, Mrs. THATCHER - of whom I see that some have now taken up the economic program - wanted to remain in Europe but receive a check in return. Today, Great Britain wants to leave but would not want to pay anything. That is not possible. I have a lot of friendship for the United Kingdom, and I know what the British have been capable of doing in tragic moments in the history of France and Europe. We are also linked by geographical proximity and by so many economic, cultural ties, and by the population. But at the same time, it is not serving the interest of Europe, nor even the interest of the United Kingdom, to remain in ambiguity.

The United Kingdom has decided to go for Brexit, I even believe a hard Brexit: we must go all the way with the will of the British to leave the European Union. We must have this firmness. If we do not have it, we will call into question the very principles of the European Union. That is to say, it will come to the mind of other countries where other parties may want to leave the European Union to gain the supposed advantages without any disadvantages and without any rules. Firmness is actually the assurance that Europe will be able to preserve its principles, particularly the four freedoms and the freedom of movement.

There must be a threat, there must be a risk, there must be a price. Otherwise, we will be in a negotiation - I know that Michel BARNIER is working on this - that cannot end well, and which will inevitably have economic and human consequences. For all these reasons, what France will do, of course in connection with our partners and allowing the Commission to carry out this negotiation work, is to defend a conception of Europe. This Europe is not simply the defense of a market or financial centers; it is not just about wanting more investments here than there would be elsewhere. Europe is about borders, it is about protections. Protection of a model, of a culture, of values that deserve to be fiercely defended, to be promoted with dignity and everywhere. That is why this Europe must be defended because, as Jacques DELORS said, it is our Europe.