Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on future investment programs for the benefit of higher education, research, and the transfer of innovation, in Paris on March 13, 2017.

France François Hollande · President of France

13 March 2017 · Ceremony for the laureates of the future investment programs (Programmes d'investissements d'avenir) prize, at the Élysée Palace · Élysée Palace, Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed laureates and university presidents at the Élysée Palace to celebrate the results of France's Future Investment Program for higher education and research on March 13, 2017.
Main themes
Future Investment Program, higher education excellence, research and innovation, university labeling (IDEX and I-SITE), technology transfer, pedagogical innovation, university governance, economic and societal impact of research, international evaluation, French university landscape
Duration
~16 min
54th percentile
Words
1,868
54th percentile
Sentences
76
50th percentile
Readability
39
35th percentile
Grade
13.9
66th percentile
Syntax
3.11
62nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 37%37%
  • Social 30%30%
  • Ceremonial 16%16%
  • Economic 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

76 sentences in 19 paragraphs

Madam Minister,

Mr. Secretary of State,

Mr. General Commissioner for Investment,

Mr. President of the Jury,

Ladies and Gentlemen Laureates,

Ladies and Gentlemen Presidents of Universities under the friendly supervision of the Rectors of our country,

There is a prize ceremony aspect here at the Elysée, as if ultimately we cannot escape the republican rites that mean we are constantly undergoing examinations under the control of independent juries. I have this desire to express today all our pride in the laureates who have managed to overcome all the steps—I dare not say all the obstacles—to achieve this recognition. So here are the members of the jury and the laureates. As the minister said, it was a long process.

First, there had to be an international jury and that all its decisions be respected. Constituting a jury is not an easy task; finding a president, we can still agree to that, but accepting that the decisions could impose themselves on public authorities, there is only the Constitutional Council in our Republic that can have that privilege, and we accepted it, willingly or by force. We admitted that all your recommendations, that all your choices could be those of the authorities of our country. It was, I believe, a wise choice, because it is the most indisputable one. This does not mean that it is not contested on a number of points—by those, in particular, who were unable to obtain the labeling. But it was surely, on an international level, what needed to be done so that the laureates, that is to say, the universities that have the labels, could justify a rating, an evaluation, or a recognition acknowledged internationally.

I know what this procedure, this process has required in terms of effort and what had to be done in each of the universities to mobilize energies, what patience was needed to understand that if it was not this time, it would be the next, and what pedagogy was also required to explain all these steps, but when success arrives, it is collective. I also know the disappointments. I want to say to all those who are not here today, who were not selected and who must hear me, that their work will not be in vain, that they have worked to create dynamics that will be rewarded at some point or another. There is always the possibility to return before the jury to obtain what was not necessarily the case this time. I also note that of the 83 universities that existed in France at the turn of the year 2000, 37, some of which have merged in the meantime, are part of the 18 IDEX and I-SITE, which shows how considerable an impact this has had on the life of the institutions and on the landscape of higher education in France.

For there to be this recognition, for there to have been this process, there had to be the Future Investment Program, for it is the Future Investment Program that authorized the launch of these competitions and allowed for this labeling. Since 2010, three Future Investment programs have been voted by Parliament for a total amount of—I speak under the supervision of Louis SCHWEITZER—57 billion euros. Higher education and research have received half of this amount, which shows that priority has been given not only to the future—this was, I would say, the founding charter—but also in the so-called future programs at the university, thus to research. These investments have allowed for the emergence of universities that already existed and had this recognition, bringing these universities to a global level.

I wanted, at the end of January 2014, to launch a new wave of IDEX under the second Future Investment program and to complement it with the I-SITE formula. We see the results here. The laureates of the IDEX and I-SITE will benefit not only from the labeling but also from significant financial resources that will accompany their development and transformation in which they were already engaged.

This label rewards scientific excellence, but more than that, the transfer of technologies for the benefit of companies and pedagogical innovations. There are therefore very direct repercussions, in economic and societal terms, from this IDEX and I-SITE formula. Universities are not closed off in the sense of being cut off from economic, social, and even cultural realities—and I would add territorial. Every time our universities progress, rise, and even manage to exceed the objectives set for them, it is to the benefit of our entire country and with direct effects in terms of employment, the creation of activities, and exports. There is also innovation that is encouraged, as has been said before me, because fundamental research also has the virtue of creating an environment that will itself provoke breakthrough innovations and industrial repercussions.

This label also rewards the effort towards a more integrated governance of all components of the landscape of higher education and research in France. This step has not been the easiest to take, but here too we must trust in collective intelligence, especially in the university where there are many individual intelligences, but, according to a theorem I have already established, which has not yet been validated in terms of scientific knowledge, individual intelligences do not make a collective intelligence. The aggregation of individual intelligences does not necessarily form a collective intelligence. There are areas—on which I will not intervene today—that demonstrate this. It is therefore very important, and it was even essential, that all the intelligences present in French universities could federate, come together, unite to become an even more dynamic force, to collectively achieve the results we see today. You have been able to propose adapted, varied solutions according to the situations while always respecting the unique history of the institutions. How to be capable? It is a question that goes well beyond the universities, to always be in lineage with a history, with a rooting, with a territory, and at the same time be able to project oneself to forge solutions for tomorrow? That is what you have done!

We have supported this movement with the Fioraso law of 2013. It is linked to the IDEX, I-SITE labeling, of course, and all this has led to an evolution of the French university landscape and to better visibility internationally. This restructuring has taken many forms: mergers of universities, strengthening of coordination bodies, pooling of resources, scientific cooperation. It is this rapprochement between universities, grandes écoles, and research institutions that has allowed your projects to find their conclusion and to obtain international recognition, a visibility that has allowed for the welcoming of more renowned researchers, to retain a number of French researchers, and to increase exchanges with other universities, because—I often say—it is very important that French universities have links with all universities in the world, and this corresponds to a university diplomacy that, alongside economic diplomacy, I have sought to promote.

Of course, this will be reflected in international rankings—I have heard Thierry MANDON well—and if it is not reflected, it will strengthen our criticisms of international rankings. They are vigilant regarding this ceremony! The success of this policy will be measured over time, because this construction, which has been established over several years, escapes the time of politics, and this is also what must be well understood. The time of democracy sometimes does not align well with that of science. It is therefore necessary to have the capacity to transcend the mandate that has been entrusted to us and to be aware that what we decide today may not necessarily have repercussions for tomorrow, but will have a considerable impact for the day after tomorrow, provided that this effort is continued. This is also the meaning of my message: nothing would be worse than abrupt interruptions of funding or philosophy. This does not mean that there are no reforms to be made—Mr. President of the Jury has given us a few—there are reforms to be accomplished, but this must go in the same direction as what we have initiated. What I would like is for us to be able to support through public policies what you have successfully carried out and which has led to different governance structures.

The PIA3, which has been voted by Parliament, prepared by the government, but especially by Louis SCHWEITZER and his teams, will also be dedicated to higher education and research with the same proportion as PIA1 and PIA2—that is to say, 50%. This is what will allow us to continue the policy that has been initiated. I also want the State to support the economic model that supports structures of excellence. I am thinking in particular of university hospital institutes, but also of research and technology institutes and institutes for energy transition. All this cooperates and collaborates in the same spirit as the one I have just described. It is with this consistency, it is with this determination, that you have shown in your universities, that we will achieve our goals, which is to maintain France's place in the fierce competition that fuels the dynamics of scientific communities, even better, to advance France, to make it more attractive, to welcome the best students and the best researchers, to strengthen our international influence.

This is a pride for our country. Many of our fellow citizens have never attended university; they hope that their children will be able to access it—and we are making sure that they can have this path. Even those who have been deprived, if I may say so, of university know that science, knowledge, and progress are located there. They look at universities not for themselves since they will never go there—even if we do everything to allow employees to return to university. They see these places of excellence, these places of teaching, these places of knowledge dissemination, these places of research as a hope for themselves and for the generations that follow, because they understand well that this is where progress is written. They also have a doubt: will progress generate benefits for all of society and the world? It is this question that is troubling public opinion today here in France, as everywhere in Europe and the world. Can progress be shared? Is progress still possible? Can reason, science, and research nourish not only humanity for good but also spiritually?

This is the battle that must be constantly engaged, not simply against ignorance, but against doubt and suspicion. That is why when there is this policy regarding higher education and research, we pursue the objective of democratization; we ensure that it is beneficial for the economy. We carry a project—you carry a project—that is much higher, which is to instill confidence in the future and to empower the countries that have made this choice of higher education and research to not only be the best in competition but to uphold ideals that are the ideals of reason, freedom, and progress.

That is why the laureates here not only have the satisfaction of having been selected by a jury but must also be aware that they must now give back to society and to the country what the label has given them today. Thank you!