Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on health policy, in Poitiers on January 26, 2017.

France François Hollande · President of France

26 January 2017 · CHU (university hospital), Poitiers, France

Context
Hollande addressed health professionals and officials in Poitiers on January 26, 2017, outlining five years of health policy achievements and future priorities.
Main themes
Healthcare system reform, access to care, third-party payment, medical deserts, Social Security deficit reduction, health insurance coverage, equal access to care, hospital and health infrastructure, health policy priorities, patient reimbursement
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,335
80th percentile
Sentences
170
85th percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
10.8
30th percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
15th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 71%70%
  • Institutional 10%9%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Technological 6%6%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

170 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Madam Minister,

Mr. Secretary of State,

Mr. Deputy Mayor, dear Alain CLAEYS,

I would like to greet the President of the Departmental Council, the parliamentarians, and even the President of the Centre Region who would have liked to be associated with Poitou-Charentes, as part of a large grouping, but who ultimately remained alone and does not complain about it.

I wanted to thank all of you for your warm welcome. Because I wanted, in responding to the invitation of the Deputy Mayor, to come here to Poitiers, to see the different facets of what our healthcare system is, both a health center, a prestigious hospital, here the CHU, and also to visit centers that provide support. In short, everything that makes up the organization of our healthcare system, but also everything that reflects our desire to humanize and ensure equal access to care.

It is true that the French are very attached to their healthcare system and to Social Security which finances it. They believe that there is excellence and quality. They express great trust in all professionals, doctors, staff, whether in hospitals, in healthcare facilities, or in city medicine.

But at the same time, the French are worried; this is part of their nature. Sometimes for good reasons, sometimes because there is always a fear that what exists could disappear, and also because of the evolution of life, which calls for adaptations and modifications. Will there always be the same level of reimbursement? Given the cost of a number of treatments, of medications that have very high prices. Will everyone be able to access what technology, innovation, and research can provide? Will there always be enough emergency services present in the territory with the necessary means to accommodate, for example, during epidemics? We have experienced one, with the flu.

Then, there is this concern, which at first was probably quite muted, diffuse, and which has now become more intense, the medical deserts, in rural areas, but also in the neighborhoods of our cities.

So, since there is both a great deal of trust in the healthcare system, recognized excellence, generally accepted quality, and at the same time this questioning about the future, we must make and continue to make health a priority for France and for the French.

For nearly five years, we have acted in four main directions. First, to allow access to care for all, while controlling the accounts. This is, as we know, a dilemma. We have to improve the coverage of health expenses for our fellow citizens while also reducing the deficit of health insurance, because we cannot imagine financing current expenses through credit or loans. We do not have the right to do so, even if that is what has been done in the past.

The results are there; it has been possible to reduce the deficit of what is called Social Security: today, it is balanced. Even though there is still a deficit for health insurance of nearly 2 billion, this deficit was nearly 9 billion in 2012. It has also been possible to improve coverage and access to care. For example, excess fees have been stabilized, whereas for twenty years, they had been continuously increasing. There is also continuity of rights through what is called universal health coverage. Finally, there has been a strengthening of complementary health insurance and the development of third-party payment.

Third-party payment is a fairly common practice in many of our neighboring countries. There are always those who take it as an example on many subjects. We had, perhaps, a higher level of reimbursement than elsewhere, but a system that resulted in the patient, the insured, having to advance the costs. Third-party payment, which already exists for pharmacies, is being implemented for the most modest patients, for pregnant women, for chronic patients, totaling 14 million insured individuals. On November 30, third-party payment will be the rule for everyone. Even though it is already accessible to all. I thank Marisol TOURAINE for her persistence in achieving this result.

Persistence does not always mean popularity, but popularity comes afterward, once the measure is applied. We know each other well, we French; we have both an irrepressible desire for reform and at the same time, as soon as it arrives, a certain reluctance to what could be a change in our habits. Then once the reform has passed, we wonder: but what existed before? We are even very attached to what has been introduced; there is no doubt that this will also be the case for third-party payment. I say this for all those who might at some point consider reversing this measure.

In the same way, mandatory health insurance reimburses more and more care: today, it covers nearly 80%. Some tell us: "But why isn't it 100%? We should eliminate complementary health insurance and put everything into Social Security." It is an idea, but it would mean that at that point, contributions would be higher, that structures would disappear, and a form of freedom would also be reduced. Therefore, it is very important that Social Security ensures reimbursement for the greatest number of care.

There has also been, and there is still, the need to improve access to certain care: I am thinking of dental care. A plan has been decided that will cap the price of prosthetics and allow for better reimbursement of these interventions, particularly by health insurance. There is a negotiation currently underway between health insurance and professionals, and I hope it can be carried through to completion. If there is no agreement, the provisions planned will be implemented by decree. But it is always preferable that it be through a contract that partners can find solutions.

So here is what I have been hearing for nearly five years: it is to allow access to care, better reimbursements, while controlling social accounts, and I believe we have achieved this result.

The second priority is research and innovation. France has considerable assets with university hospital centers and with hospital-university institutes that are funded by the future investment program. I have noted this here: the CHU of Poitiers is one of the most modern in France, and unique interventions are performed here in France. I do not say this so that all patients come to the hospital here in Poitiers, but what I have seen is admirable. In the cardiovascular and neurovascular center, several disciplines coexist and work together; there are interventional procedures aided by embedded imaging. In short, everything revolves around the patient, and we are truly in excellence.

This is an important investment that has been made here: 86 million euros, which is considerable. It is financed by Social Security; it is she who allows the hospital to have the means. And it is also thanks to management efforts, and I want to commend the management of the establishment once again.

We must invest; we must have excellence everywhere, and there has been an investment plan of 2 billion euros that was launched last May, which complements what has been done so far: 10 billion in additional resources for public hospitals during the five-year term because we need to have the best equipment, the best research, and the most recent innovations. We must ensure that innovations can be rapidly disseminated in care practices through simplification of procedures. I am also thinking of the revolution called personalized medicine. Again, we will create 12 high-throughput genome sequencing platforms, and two of these platforms will be installed as early as 2017.

Speed, efficiency, personalization, that is what medicine of tomorrow is, and it is a change that will affect all establishments, all practices, since we must move forward with increasingly efficient innovations, with interdisciplinarity and with personalization. I know what this can change in practices, and therefore we must also change a number of habits. The same goes for telemedicine; here too, Poitiers is an example that facilitates consultations, expertise, and remote monitoring. It is another revolution that is coming. But it must never be forgotten that only human intervention can heal, cure, and soothe.

I have mentioned, and it has also been a requirement for me since 2012, the fight against medical deserts. We have created territorial hospital groups. It is not easy because we are all very attached to our municipalities, our departments, our regions, and the same goes for our hospital establishments. Nothing is worse for a territory than to know that its establishment may lose its autonomy. However, it is necessary, essential that there be this cooperation, this coordination. You have succeeded here, first by merging establishments and then by creating this territorial hospital group. Again, I have seen the results: the pooling of technical platforms, the valorization of care teams, the coherence in the organization of hospital care. I understood that this was the case in Châtellerault and Loudun, where, thanks to this organization, it was possible to have medical presence. I think this is yet another great example of what a hospital opening up to others, working as a team can do for the balance of a territory.

Next, there are the Health Houses. I visited the one in Les Couronneries, and this is yet another objective that we set and achieved. We have quadrupled the number of Health Houses in less than five years. There are now nearly 1,200, and I also want to commend the commitment of healthcare professionals and the importance of these centers in local care. The minister told me that today, young doctors primarily choose to settle in Health Houses because they can work together, because they are in teams, and because they also see an important problem in Health Houses that requires particular support to alleviate costs for these structures, so that administrative burdens can be fairly distributed.

We also wanted, always to enable the fight against medical deserts, to have recruitments in hospitals: (31,000 since 2012) that we will favor liberal doctors where they are most needed. In this case, there could have been a method that was obligation. I know that a number of elected officials were in favor of this solution. I have never believed that it was possible to force a doctor to go where he did not want to go. Moreover, what is true for doctors is also true for all other citizens. So it is not about being in coercion; it is about being in encouragement, and that is what has been done: 1,700 public service commitment contracts, 1,000 general medicine practitioner contracts, more training for doctors as SAMU correspondents, and then, because we also need the entire territory to be accessible, strengthening the airlift capabilities of SMUR.

I understood that here, the helicopter was a question that was raised, and the director of the ARS, accompanying me on this visit, had no other choice, was necessarily questioned, and he perfectly answered by saying that the savings that had been made could be used for this equipment. I want to thank him here, even if he had not given his official answer at this stage.

I now want to address the challenges we collectively have to face. First, there is the challenge of prevention and education. It is a common place to say: it is better to prevent than to cure, it is better to provide information, it is better to enable support before there may be the onset of a disease or a tragedy. But we must nevertheless organize this prevention because it is both essential for controlling health expenses and for combating inequalities, because it is often the most vulnerable, the most modest who are not informed and educated about health. It starts in the family, at school, but also throughout life, in workplaces. We have therefore made sure to launch a major movement for prevention that touches all schools, even higher education, and, obviously, the world of work. Even in occupational medicine, a law that has sparked much debate, the Labor Law, has reorganized occupational medicine so that it can be present where the risks are the highest in order to prevent them.

I wanted to launch a mobilization on the well-being of young people with the Regional Health Agencies and the education authorities, in connection with the Houses of Adolescents, to pool all resources to help young people who isolate themselves, who sometimes put themselves in danger, and who express a sense of malaise. This is for prevention, education, and it particularly concerns young people.

The second challenge we face is the challenge of old age. We are aware of the ongoing demographic changes; we know that life expectancy is increasing, and we must take care of more and more aging or dependent individuals. This is the subject of a law, the law of December 28, 2015, relating to the adaptation of society to aging, which allows for better support for loss of autonomy at home and coordination of preventive actions in each department. Much will also depend on what we do with each departmental council. There is also a reduction in the out-of-pocket expenses for families who have to take responsibility for a dependent person.

There was this very heavy, very delicate question regarding the dignity of the person at the end of life. This has been the subject of much reflection that I initiated as early as 2012, many reports, and also the referral to the National Consultative Ethics Committee. We needed to seek, beyond divisions, beyond the multiple philosophies we know, to find consensus. It is not easy to find consensus, even on subjects of such importance.

I therefore asked two parliamentarians, Alain CLAEYS and Jean LEONETTI, to prepare a law that could affirm the right of every person to a dignified and peaceful end of life. This law was able to be voted on in consensus at the beginning of February last year. It organizes the right for people at the end of life to deep and continuous sedation until death. It also introduces what are called "advance directives," meaning the right for any person to express at any time in their life what they wish, particularly the refusal of aggressive medical treatment. These directives can, of course, be amended at any time.

This is a major right of freedom for the citizen, for the patient. It is also a responsibility entrusted to medical teams, but we wanted to allow for an end of life that everyone can manage and for the process to be soothing, through the possibility of deep and continuous sedation.

A law is essential. It provides the framework. Then, it is a matter of application, and I also want to acknowledge all the staff who dedicate themselves to finding the balance point, to providing solutions in connection with the patient and their family.

We have also improved the development of palliative care. Here in Poitiers, you have, once again, found excellence. I want to express my admiration for the staff in these services who accompany, sometimes for a long time, patients at the end of life and who provide them with the relief, care, and humanity that are essential in a civilized, advanced society. There is also the need to support in nursing homes, at home, and we will have to respond to increasing needs and make palliative care a fully-fledged academic discipline.

I wanted, coming to Poitiers, to salute Alain CLAEYS for this remarkable work that has been a great progress for our society. If, at some point, we must always reflect on the legacy we leave, this law will be among the great laws of the Republic.

There are those who would like to go further, and that is quite legitimate! The evolution of a society is necessary! There are all the questions of accompanying the end of life, when one has decided! This is another question, which was not the one that was posed, and which may eventually deserve debates and decisions. But today, this progress has been made.

The last challenge I wanted to mention before you is the organization of care through the relationships between professionals, hospitals - city medicine. We need this coherence, we need this mutual trust, we need an even stronger articulation between hospital establishments, city medicine, and primary care. We will do everything to ensure that there can be, once again, a better understanding for the support of the patient.

A final word on innovative products that can be very expensive but that heal. This is a major issue! Up to what price level can we accept, in a society, to offer patients the solution to their illness for free? There are countries where it depends on life expectancy, "I provide you with the product because you are young. If you are too old, you cannot access it." There are countries where it depends on wealth, "You can pay for the medication, you are entitled to it. You cannot? Well, you will have to live with your illness."

This is a problem that does not arise at the level of a country; it arises at the level of the world! Because in very poor countries, we know that there are innovative products that can heal, we also know that access is impossible. I make this cause of access to medicines for all a French cause. That is to say, here, being capable of living up to what is the moral and ethical responsibility, and also at the global level. France carries this message. I have done so, by the way, with what is called the G7, that is to say, the richest countries in the world, saying that if we do not make the most innovative medicines available to everyone, part of the world will revolt. How can a mother understand that her child will disappear because she cannot access care? How can there not be revolts that occur for life, against inequalities?

Here in France, I had a recent testimony. An elderly person told me, "Here, my partner has a disease, hepatitis C, and I know that the price of the medication is very high. And she is elderly! She was provided with the hepatitis C treatment. She was saved." And he tells me, "I am proud to live in France because in France, I can have access to treatment and save my partner, in this case, my wife, because we have Social Security."

It was expensive, the treatment for hepatitis C, several hundred million euros, for ultimately a limited number of patients, even if there are many! The same could be said for HIV treatment, for cancers. This raises the major question: what kind of society do we want to live in? What are we willing to share together? Are we still determined to contribute, to contribute to solidarity?

This is a subject that can be viewed politically: what falls under private responsibility, what falls under national solidarity? This is a subject that must also be viewed in light of a conception of the Republic: access for all to care, efficiency in the organization of our health system, research and innovation as a condition for raising quality and excellence.

We must respond for the coming years, knowing that, with all the necessary rigor for controlling public accounts, with all the demands we must place on reducing a number of levies, particularly on households, as well as on businesses, if we want to be competitive, we will always need to allocate national spending in favor of health. There is not an obligation based on what an old social model is, Social Security. No! It is an investment in the future because prioritizing health is ensuring national cohesion, opening the promise of equality for all, and making sure we are in a society of kindness and well-being.

That is why I wanted, here in Poitiers, to pay tribute to all health professionals, but also to our health system, to Social Security, to Health Insurance, to what makes us all together in the French Republic. Thank you.