Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the challenges and priorities of the economic and social policy of his five-year term, in Paris on July 9, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

9 July 2012 · Social conference (opening of the social conference, five-year term economic and social policy statement) · Economic, Social and Environmental Council, Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed the inaugural social conference at the Economic, Social and Environmental Council in Paris on July 9, 2012, outlining his presidency's key economic and social priorities.
Main themes
Economic and social policy priorities, public finances and debt reduction, competitiveness and deindustrialization, unemployment and precariousness, social dialogue and consensus-building, sovereignty and market independence, industrial decline, youth and older worker employment, fiscal responsibility, five-year term agenda
Duration
~42 min
91st percentile
Words
4,996
91st percentile
Sentences
240
92nd percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
2.90
34th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 43%43%
  • Institutional 36%36%
  • Social 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

240 sentences in 93 paragraphs

Mr. President of the Economic, Social and Environmental Council,

First, I want to personally thank you for allowing us to be welcomed here for this unprecedented social conference.

As I speak, I am thinking of Jacques DERMAGNE, who passed away on July 3rd, who presided over this great institution for 11 years.

On June 12th, right here, I addressed the Economic, Social and Environmental Council, highlighting its role as a place for exchange and dialogue among all the vital forces of the Nation, and I considered that it could provide a natural framework for the social conference I wanted to open at the beginning of this term.

This conference brings together the government, starting with the Prime Minister, the ministers, elected officials from our territories, but above all the presidents and secretaries-general of the major professional and associative organizations in our country. What we call the intermediary bodies, without which France would not be what it is today. And it is because I wanted to gather them around a great mission, which is to open a perspective for our country, that I wished for this social conference to widely welcome all these participants.

This exceptional meeting engages in a process whose horizon is that of the next five years. It must demonstrate both an awareness of the situation in our country, a sense of responsibility regarding the choices that we will all have to make, and also a willingness to take risks regarding the idea of coming together to determine a common agenda and objectives.

We find ourselves at a particular moment in our public life: that is, in the aftermath of a presidential election that has inevitably divided us, and whose winner must necessarily unite, just a few weeks after the legislative elections that have confirmed the majority choice of the French in favor of political families that have committed to change.

But the time has come to set France in motion, and there is no time to lose.

I do not want to hide anything about the situation in our country. There is no need to exaggerate, to darken the horizon, and at the same time, it would not be worthy of someone in charge of the essentials in our country to deny the realities.

I want everyone to be aware of the three major challenges we must collectively face.

First, the recovery of our public finances.

Debt has increased by 800 billion euros over the past 10 years. It now stands at 90% of national wealth. As for the public deficit, it exceeded 100 billion euros in 2011 and can only be contained around 4.5% of national wealth in 2012 at the cost of a fiscal adjustment for which the government has rightly taken responsibility.

As the Court of Auditors has pointed out, this deterioration is only partially the result of the crisis. It rather reflects the choice that has been made for too long of losing untimely revenues that would now be very precious not only to reduce our deficits but also to act for employment. And a structure of our public spending that is particularly rigid, despite or because of the application of mechanical formulas to control it, which have proven to be as ineffective as they are poorly accepted.

I believe that our country cannot take the risk of dedicating nearly 50 billion euros to paying interest charges, but also the risk of raising funds that can at any moment become more expensive due to a potential vulnerability of our sovereign debt in the markets.

We must regain sovereignty, independence from the markets, and from the need to finance our collective expenditures. This is therefore not a choice for austerity, which would be nothing more than a regression, but a choice for sovereignty and for the future of our country.

The second challenge we face is the deterioration of our competitiveness. France, the figures are now well known, has gone from a trade surplus of 3.5 billion euros in 2002 to a deficit of 70 billion euros in 2011.

We have lost market shares in key export goods.

Our industry, which represented 18% of the value added of production ten years ago, now represents only 13% today. 400,000 jobs in the manufacturing sectors have been lost in the last five years. We know the causes of this situation: poor industrial specialization, too few exporting companies, insufficient innovation, research, and knowledge. But this deterioration of our external accounts is also the product of certain structural rigidities, including our costs, which we must correct.

Deindustrialization is unacceptable. Once again, it harms our independence, weakens our territories, and reduces our capacity to create jobs.

The third challenge is the most demanding: that of unemployment and precariousness. The number of job seekers is now the highest it has been in 12 years. The unemployment rate is approaching 10% of the active population and has been continuously rising for 30 months. It affects young people and older workers: only 45% of those over 55 have a job, and nearly 460,000 people have been unemployed for more than three years, which means a deep exclusion for them.

Four out of five hires today are in fixed-term contracts, and it is primarily women who are victims of job precariousness and part-time work.

And in this context, the announcement of social plans, which may have been conveniently delayed, is even more worrying, especially when considering the silent layoffs experienced in many small businesses. The return to high growth is an obligation if we want to regain a level of employment. However, everyone knows that for the first half of the year, growth will be zero. Therefore, we must mobilize all our forces, all our imagination, all our capacities to build sustainable growth for the coming years. In Europe, there are countries where growth is very low, even countries that are in recession, but there are others that have succeeded, through reforms initiated several years ago, in achieving a level of growth well above ours.

When I look at other regions of the world, not just emerging countries, I also see that by mobilizing supply more, by supporting demand more intelligently, there are potentialities for growth. Until the affirmation of this strategy, we must address the most pressing issues. We need to improve our vocational training system, respond more effectively to job offers, support the unemployed more quickly towards employment, and utilize all mechanisms for integration. But I say this here before you, I will not accept that a country like ours resigns itself to considering unemployment as a fatality.

That is why the period we are going through, if I add all these challenges—competitiveness, unemployment, but also the recovery of our public finances—yes, this period demands strong and new responses.

There are moments in the life of a Nation, we are going through one, when we must collectively take our destiny into our own hands, redefine the collective contract, and ensure our recovery. To achieve this, efforts will be necessary both in terms of our public finances, thus our budgetary and fiscal policy, and in the productive and industrial domain. Everyone is ready to make these efforts.

But under several conditions. First, the French want to understand the meaning of it all. It has been too many years that they have been called to sacrifice without a clearly defined goal, without steps that can be taken, without an evaluation of the policies that have been implemented. What the French want is not redemption; they are guilty of nothing. It is not punishment; they do not deserve it. It is not regression; how can we mobilize a people if it is to ask them to renounce? No, what the French want to understand is whether we are capable of mobilizing our forces to allow for new progress, with the prospect of opening for the new generation, for the youth, a future better than ours. That is the challenge.

The second condition is justice. How can we call for a resurgence, for a transcendence, for a gathering on the essentials, if a favored fraction of the population escapes it, if sacrifices are demanded only from the active, if business and work are penalized compared to speculation and rent? To pose the question is to answer it. Justice will be a condition for recovery. But the most important, if we want to achieve our goals, is trust. Societies that experience the highest performances in terms of growth but also in terms of social progress are those that have managed to forge sustainable compromises. Between the State and other actors, that is to say, social partners, local authorities, and vital forces, a compromise also between employers and unions. A compromise between the demands of the real economy and the preservation of natural resources. A compromise between the financing of the economy and the investment capacity of businesses.

This is the challenge of this conference: to prepare reforms together, to open new spaces for social democracy, thus to develop a roadmap that will offer our country a clear vision of the objectives pursued and a distribution of responsibilities to achieve them.

My will is to evolve our social model to better guarantee it.

I propose a method based on three simple principles.

The first, within the framework of this social conference: to address all subjects, without exclusion. None of the major economic and social questions before us should be ignored. Employment being the top priority. Everything must be discussed to achieve the highest level of employment in our country.

The second principle: to set a coherent, shared agenda that allows us to move forward together, while respecting each other's independence. This requires clearly establishing priorities, distributing what falls under the State, by law or regulation, from negotiation between social partners, and what obeys the rules of consultation. This will be the meaning of the conclusions that the Prime Minister will draw from your work.

The last principle: to inscribe this social conference in the long term. Our goal today is not to hold a one-off social summit; there have been others in the past, our history is rich with a number of events, especially at the beginning of a term. No, our will is to lay the foundations for a process with objectives and steps to achieve them.

The approach I propose to you is new in many respects. France, through its traditions, its history, its organization, and its social movement, has not developed what is called a culture of negotiation.

Everyone has their share of responsibility, and the State above all.

It has often led, and the history is long, with successive majorities, to purely formal consultations with social partners, who consented to live later with frustrations and disillusionments. As an employer, the State has also not set an example, to say the least. That must change.

But let us also agree, in this same spirit of truth, that the social actors themselves have not always taken the initiative to engage, through social negotiation, at the interprofessional level and even at the branch level, the necessary transformations.

We must therefore regain the sense of dialogue. This requires making it a principle of our democratic life and strengthening the representatives who are most qualified to carry out negotiations.

That is why I confirm here that I wish, if Parliament consents and if social partners agree, to enshrine in our Constitution the role of social dialogue and the place of major representative organizations. It will be necessary to more clearly define the obligations of prior consultation before public decision-making. There will be no law in the field of economic and social life that could be voted by Parliament without a phase of dialogue and consultation having taken place. The affirmation of this constitutional principle does not undermine the primacy of the law and thus the role of the legislator, but it allows for engaging with more confidence than in the past in the necessary modes of consultation and negotiation.

For this social democracy to function harmoniously, it is essential that the interlocutors themselves are legitimate. This makes the conclusion of the reform of representativeness, which was initiated by the law of August 20, 2008, all the more necessary, and which must find its conclusion next year.

Other subjects need to be taken into account: the financial means of organizations, the conduct of social dialogue at the territorial level, particularly for employment basins, the evolution of representative institutions for personnel, the place of trade unionism in all companies, as we must ensure that the guarantees offered to employees are the same regardless of the size or location of the companies. More broadly, this conference is an act of trust in social democracy.

Social dialogue is not a constraint; it is a condition for achieving the objective. That is why seven major themes have been selected for this conference.

First, employment.

With two main challenges.

The first is to address the low activity rate of seniors and to reduce youth unemployment, which, I remind you, is double that of adults.

I proposed to the French the generation contract: to bring together ages rather than oppose them, to make more room in our companies for young people who want to enter the workforce and for seniors who want to continue working and passing on their know-how and skills.

The terms of the generation contract must be simple and effective while also being adapted to the situations of companies. This will therefore be the subject of your discussions to determine the framework within which the generation contract will be defined. It will be up to you to indicate whether you want to take up this issue to negotiate an interprofessional agreement, before or after a law that will establish the necessary legal principles. In any case, I wish for the generation contract mechanism to come into effect at the beginning of next year.

Another sensitive issue is precariousness. Permanent contracts, which should be the norm, are increasingly giving way to a multiplication of various formulas: fixed-term contracts, temporary work, and even internships.

The resulting precariousness for the affected workers is harmful not only to the workers themselves but also to companies, as it undermines sustainable investment in employee training. It is therefore up to both the State and social partners to send signals to change these behaviors. Unemployment insurance cannot indefinitely treat companies that extensively use these precarious contracts the same as those that choose stability. More broadly, a reflection on the employment contract must be initiated. You will lead it.

The question of security and collective guarantees also arises in the face of corporate restructuring. The intervention of public authorities can be useful. But again, new forms can be found to prevent social plans or to limit their impact. I invite you to address all these issues in order to better anticipate and prevent these corporate changes, to allow for better information for employees, and even their involvement, and once again, negotiation must take precedence.

The second topic is training and the development of skills throughout life. Here again, we have four obligations:

The first is to give those who have not received sufficient initial training a second or even a third chance.

Next, it is to support employees who want to change sectors so that they can do so, as mobility should be seen as an asset rather than a constraint. This is the idea of securing professional pathways, which is beneficial for employees and companies, allowing for better support of changes and making the needs of companies more aligned with the qualifications of employees.

The third obligation is to help companies navigate periods of reduced activity without resorting to layoffs, drawing inspiration from negotiated arrangements that some regions have successfully experimented with in France and that other countries have long implemented, with lessons we could usefully learn for ourselves.

Finally, we must make our vocational training system more understandable and more accessible to job seekers and employees who are undergoing changes.

The third challenge is remuneration. It must be dignified, fair, established within an intelligible and effective system. I think of the minimum wage; it has been increased. But at the time we made this decision, and the Prime Minister ensured it, we also wanted to open a phase of deliberation on the method of indexing the minimum wage as well as on career developments, as too many employees remain for years at the lowest salary level. The question of branch minima must be addressed, as well as the effects of involuntary part-time work. More generally, we must ensure that exemptions from social contributions are more conditioned on efforts of discussion and negotiation on salary and employment issues.

Regarding the remuneration of company executives, a topic that regularly comes up according to current revelations, we must move forward with more transparency and at the same time more coherence. It is normal for there to be salary disparities within companies. But there have been excesses that have become incomprehensible and unjustifiable, especially when the increases that some benefit from contrast with the extreme moderation applied to others, often by the same individuals. There is a moral issue here that can unite us all, and it will be up to the legislator to decide when the time comes, and I also trust organizations to introduce more moral standards.

Leaders, whether political, social, or economic, have responsibilities. Exemplarity is one of them. They must support the country's recovery by showing the way and making an effort themselves during this very difficult period.

On this issue, as well as more generally on the functioning of our companies, I wish for employees to be more involved in boards of directors, supervisory boards, and also in remuneration committees.

Next, there is the issue of professional equality between women and men; too many delays have been accumulated. Texts have been adopted for a long time, and laws have been added one after another since the ROUDY law to put an end to this unacceptable injustice, which means that in France, for equal skills and equal jobs, a woman earns nearly 25% less than a man.

The right to equality exists; it must be applied. And again, I expect there to be precise proposals, accompanied by a demanding timeline. Thirty years after the law on professional equality, it is time, more than time, to implement it.

In general, the quality of work life has become a concern for many employees but also for many business leaders who are aware of the stakes: health, the prevention of psychosocial risks, the reconciliation of family and professional life are essential issues for improving the relationship with work but also its effectiveness and thus the overall productivity of the French economy. In France in 2012, work cannot be considered a suffering. On these issues, a social deliberation has just concluded. It will pave the way for a very soon negotiation. And I wish again that this Conference can support this approach.

The fifth theme is the future of social protection, particularly pensions.

Justice measures were decided from the very first days of my term, and I had committed to them, aimed at those who started working early and who have contributed for 41 years. We will need to address the issue of complementary pensions. The government has made commitments to define a system that will allow us to finance our pensions sustainably and that responds to the observation, which we also celebrate, of the continuous increase in life expectancy.

I add that it is time, more than time, to define the criteria for hardship, as it is both a condition for social justice and for seeking more sustainable balances for our old-age insurance schemes. Again, discussions and negotiations had been initiated; it is time to conclude them.

For social protection as a whole, we have a goal: to ensure the sustainability of our social systems. We must also recognize that they were conceived in a very different context than today, based on very different needs in terms of health, retirement, or even family policy. The links between the principles of collective insurance based on contributions and the solidarity that calls for taxation must therefore be restructured, particularly from the perspective of equity but also of labor costs and tax justice. Again, none of these issues should be overlooked. Nor should the issue of social deficits. 14 billion euros are currently projected for the year 2012, and we have put things in order in the little time we have been given. How can we accept that every year for more than 10 years and beyond, part of social protection has been financed by credit, that is to say, by borrowing? I mentioned earlier the risks in the markets, vulnerability, financial dependency; how can we accept that part of our pensions and social benefits are financed on bases other than sustainable revenues?

One solution could be to lower the ambitions of protection and to protect fewer French people. They refuse this, and they are right.

That does not mean, however, that nothing should change. We must find new modes of financing, new organizations for our social model. We must also ensure to limit a number of unnecessary, ineffective expenses that are actually a source of profit for some without improving the quality of care for others.

The balance of our accounts must not be based solely on economic or financial imperatives. These are social obligations because our solidarity mechanisms will be threatened if we do not know how to evolve them, to progress them, to finance them.

A major challenge, as I mentioned, is the companies that are exposed to globalization and international competition. We must find a way to help them stay in the race; that is the least we can do, but to put them in the best position through a strengthening of productive supply. I mentioned innovation, research, investment. But at the same time, we must also address issues related to distortions in the financing of our social protection. That is why I believe it is necessary for the social conference to address this issue. Because I do not consider that placing the cost of our social spending solely on labor is a good way to ensure the sustainability of financing.

I wanted, and the Government has implemented this principle, to abandon the social VAT because I considered it a levy on the consumption of the French at a time when growth was slowing and purchasing power was contracting. Imagine if nothing had changed and in October there had been a 1.6% increase in VAT on the consumption of the French! We refused that, and yet we must have this discussion on other means of financing social protection than solely on the labor factor, thus calling for other factors of production, other contributions, and this has been part of the debate you must conduct.

The modernization of public action is also an imperative. It must be conducted with state agents and local authorities; it is ultimately the reform of the State and the new axis of decentralization. The minister is particularly in charge of this file. The two go hand in hand. We must both reflect on the missions of the State, the means to carry them out, and at the same time on the level that must be the most effective to accomplish them. Nothing can be done without the intervention of the agents themselves.

I refuse to consider public employment as a variable for adjusting our financial control. That is why the government has put an end to what was called the "general revision of public policies," which had only been an additional constraint without considerable yield.

Over the next five years, the number of civil servants will remain stable. This means that there will be job creations in priority sectors: education, justice, security.

I have counted; all these ministries represent 60% of public employment in the State. So the priority is broad. There, there will be creations.

In contrast, in other sectors, there will not be a renewal of all the departures of civil servants retiring. But we will maintain stability in staffing levels. These efforts will also concern what are called public operators who rely on state subsidies, and again there will be participation from the agents because it is not simply a matter of reducing here or increasing there; it is about ensuring that the missions of public administrations at all levels can be carried out effectively.

But the major issue is also productive recovery. We are currently being informed of social plans in several major companies (automotive, steel industry, and many others). It seems that they have been contemplated for a long time but not necessarily proclaimed in the early months of the year.

The State cannot remain inactive; it is already acting. It is seeking solutions, mobilizing funding, but we cannot simply be in emergency treatment; we must have a strategy, we must ensure to anticipate, we must mobilize new means, the Public Investment Bank will be one of them.

But also a mobilization, I also wish for us to mobilize savings towards productive investment, particularly for SMEs. I want us to broaden everything related to research and innovation in SMEs. We also have great confidence in companies so that they can export, which requires us to provide them with all the conditions to do so. And it is also the responsibility of large companies to lead SMEs to export markets.

The productive recovery is therefore not a defensive strategy; it is a desire to be among the best in globalization. This requires enabling France, its workers, and its companies to adapt to changes, to orient themselves towards future sectors, to bet on new technologies, to ensure the essential transitions: industrial, energy, ecological. There will be an environmental conference soon in the fall. Social partners will be involved because this is an issue not only for the preservation of the planet but for the emergence of a new economy, to which many here have already prepared and are already engaged, particularly in the construction sector, in the new energy sector, and also in the industry sector that uses new types of materials. Yes, we have the capacity in France to implement. We must fear nothing but stagnation.

Here is a beautiful ambition for this social conference addressing many topics, mobilizing many actors, setting a realistic agenda, allowing for the establishment of a pact of trust and efficiency between the State, employees, companies, social partners, and professional organizations that put France back at the center of the global economic game. We need everyone, from the small artisanal business to the large group. We need the worker who must be involved in the production process, up to the business leader who illuminates the future and prepares for changes.

I do not prejudge what the attitude of each party will be, your respective positions. I do not know what the extent of our convergences will be; I hope they are numerous, but there will necessarily be points of disagreement. I respect them. What we must seek is how to mobilize the forces of our country towards new solutions. How we can organize ourselves over time. I have said that the countries that are best able to ensure their recovery in social justice are those that are ready to forge a contract between the different actors.

The social conference is therefore not an end or a promise that has just been fulfilled. The social conference is a beginning.

I therefore ask the Prime Minister, following your work, to draw all the conclusions from this conference, to then make the decisions that are most in line with the general interest and the social dialogue that must contribute to it with states and responsibilities.

This is the roadmap that will engage the State for the coming years.

I thank each minister for being attentive, in the areas of competence that are theirs, to give this conference all its translation so that, once again, there is follow-up.

The Minister of Social Dialogue will be particularly responsible for this.

So, Ladies and Gentlemen, this is what I came to tell you this morning.

We are launching a new process that already surpasses us. It is an opportunity for our country if we know how to seize it. I already give you an appointment in a year for a first assessment right here if the Economic, Social and Environmental Council still makes us the proposal. But that would be the ideal framework. In the meantime, there will be other meetings with the Prime Minister, with members of the government.

The idea I am putting forward is that of positive compromise. It is the idea that will allow our country to emerge positively from the trials it is going through. This positive compromise is this conference that can tie it together, in any case, organize it, enable it.

This must not be a meeting without a future; it must be a dynamic that will itself be a change in the method that will allow a change in reality.

I do not ask anyone here to abandon their convictions, to renounce their demands, to yield to some pressure. I trust free, independent actors to take their part in the common task. The one that surpasses us: the one that binds us all, the one that mobilizes us deep within ourselves, regardless of our place in society, regardless of our role in relation to those we represent, political democracy, social democracy, we have only one goal: to ensure that the coming generation has a better future than ours, to give our country confidence in itself, to succeed in restoring our country because that is what we have been mandated by the French to do, and it is because we care to give them a beautiful hope for their future.

Thank you.